De Lima ordered to explain why she should not be held in contempt
Sen. Leila de Lima. INQUIRER FILE PHOTO/LYN RILLON
The House of Representatives justice committee has approved a show-cause order to have Senator Leila de Lima explain why she should not be cited in contempt for supposedly preventing her driver and former lover Ronnie Dayan from testifying in the Bilibid drug probe.
During the reopening of the inquiry in aid of legislation on Thursday, committee chairman Oriental Mindoro Rep. Reynaldo Umali approved the seconded motion to have De Lima explain why she should not be cited in contempt.
The committee issued the show-cause order against De Lima despite the interparliamentary courtesy rule between the two chambers of Congress to respect each other.
READ: House probe of De Lima to violate congressional courtesy—solons
“The continuing snub of Senator De Lima, to my appreciation, is an affront to a coequal chamber which is the House of Representatives,” Umali said.
Umali approved the motion even though De Lima is his sister in the fraternity.
Article continues after this advertisementREAD: Umali slams sorority sister De Lima for Bilibid probe snub
The committee issued the show-cause order following calls from lawmakers to have De Lima cited in contempt for allegedly obstructing justice after Dayan’s daughter Hannah Mae claimed the senator ordered his father to hide from authorities and snub the hearings.
Article continues after this advertisementREAD: Solons hit De Lima for preventing Dayan from testifying | Dayan: De Lima asked me to hide after House subpoena
Dayan’s 23-year-old daughter said De Lima had blamed Speaker Pantaleon Alvarez for orchestrating the smear campaign in the guise of a congressional hearing on the whims of President Rodrigo Duterte.
De Lima’s ally, Magdalo Rep. Gary Alejano, said holding the senator in contempt may violate the interparliamentary courtesy between the two Houses of Congress.
“We cannot prevent the Senate to also do this thing. Ang mangyayari diyan pwede i-detain yung isang senador, madidetain din ang isang congressman. Masisira yung interparliamentary courtesy (What would happen in that situation is, we could detain a senator, and the Senate could detain a congressman. This would violate interparliamentary courtesy),” Alejano said.
Leyte Rep. Vicente Veloso, a former Court of Appeals justice, said whether or not Congress can hold a senator in contempt, the issue would definitely reach the Supreme Court.
ABS Rep. Eugene De Vera, the congressman who moved for the motion to issue a show-cause order, said there is a need for De Lima to explain why she prevented Dayan from testifying in the House probe.
“We’d just like to protect the integrity of the House of Representatives, at the same time, give the Honorable Senator to also have the chance to explain if there is truth to the matter that she prevented in any way the witness to testify before this Honorable committee,” De Vera said.
Justice Secretary Vitaliano Aguirre II said aside from contempt, De Lima may also be liable for immorality and concubinage for having an affair with a married man, which may result in her disbarment.
READ: Aguirre: De Lima may be liable for concubinage, immorality
Dayan has admitted delivering money from alleged Eastern Visayas drug lord Kerwin Espinosa to De Lima. He said he gave drug money from Espinosa to De Lima at least five times in 2014. Espinosa, however, said he gave De Lima at least P8 million in 2015 for the justice secretary’s senatorial campaign.
READ: ‘She even thanked me’: Kerwin claims De Lima aware of delivered money | Dayan admits delivering Kerwin’s money to De Lima
Dayan was arrested in La Union around 11:30 a.m. last Tuesday after he was cited in contempt for snubbing the House of Representatives inquiry on the proliferation of drugs at the New Bilibid Prison implicating De Lima.
READ: Ronnie Dayan arrested in La Union
During the turnover by the police to the House of Representatives Tuesday night, Dayan admitted receiving drug kickbacks from Espinosa for De Lima, an allegation the senator said was a lie.
READ: Dayan admits delivering Kerwin’s money to De Lima | Dayan tells De Lima: Stay strong
Bilibid inmates who testified in the House inquiry tagged Dayan as the one who allegedly collected millions of kickbacks for De Lima from the drug trade for her senatorial campaign.
READ: House cites Ronnie Dayan in contempt; arrest order out
De Lima has vehemently denied the allegation, pointing out that allies of President have an ax to grind against her since she has crossed swords with Duterte. De Lima as human rights chair investigated the alleged links of Duterte to the Davao Death Squad when the latter was mayor.
De Lima has admitted having an affair with Dayan but said both of them were separated from their spouses at the time. De Lima has also expressed fear Dayan might be forced to testify against her. RAM/rga
RELATED STORIES
