Binays defy Ombudsman
DEFYING OMBUDSMAN ORDER ANEW Vice President Jejomar Binay addresses supporters gathered at Makati City Hall as his son, Makati Mayor Junjun Binay, defies a suspension order from the Office of the Ombudsman for his role in the allegedly overpriced Makati Science High School building. The mayor also refused to heed the suspension order of the Ombudsman early this year for his role in the allegedly overpriced Makati City Hall Building II. RAFFY LERMA
It is just another attack, but Vice President Jejomar Binay is unfazed and says it’s not going to prevent him from running for President next year.
The Vice President’s son, Makati Mayor Junjun Binay, received Monday a second suspension order from the Office of the Ombudsman in connection with its investigation of corruption allegations in the construction of the P1.3-billion Makati City Science High School building.
The mayor’s staff refused to accept the order. The younger Binay said that the directive was an illustration of “selective justice” that his father decried when he resigned from President Aquino’s Cabinet a week ago, saying he was through being the “punching bag” of administration allies seeking higher office in next year’s elections.
The Vice President addressed about 1,000 supporters that had begun to mass on the City Hall grounds in a show of people power to stop the enforcement of the Ombudman’s order on Monday.
“This is just another way for them to attack me and my family,” he said, adding that “no matter what happens” he was pursuing his quest for the presidency in next year’s elections.
The mass gathering on the quadrangle was a repeat of the demonstrations that stymied the enforcement of a similar suspension directive on March 11 in connection with the Ombudsman’s investigation of the alleged overpriced Makati City Hall Building II.
The Court of Appeals issued a temporary restraining order on Ombudsman Conchita Carpio Morales’ move in March on a plea by Binay that whatever administrative offense he had committed had been condoned by his subsequent reelection. The case has been elevated to the Supreme Court by Morales and is pending resolution.
“The Ombudsman’s actions cannot be more obvious. When there are complaints against administration allies, it sleeps on the job. But when a Binay is involved, investigations are rushed even when the charges have no basis at all,” Mayor Binay told reporters.
Interior Secretary Mar Roxas said the suspension was a lawful order of the Ombudsman and urged the mayor to comply.
The potential standard-bearer of the ruling Liberal Party in next year’s elections said that his department, assisted by the Philippine National Police if necessary, was “duty bound” to enforce the order “in the most expeditious and peaceable way.”
Conspiracy
The Vice President’s camp accused Malacañang of harassment and said it would not be “cowed.”
“This precipitate and unduly harsh action demonstrates the undue haste and priority given to investigations against the Vice President and his family, while pussyfooting on the anomalies perpetrated by the Liberal Party and administration allies,” Binay’s political spokesman Rico Quicho said in a statement.
“We expect more retaliatory and oppressive maneuvers against the Vice President and his family,” Quicho said, adding that this was part of the conspiracy of the administration to stop Binay from being elected as president.
Speaker Feliciano Belmonte Jr. dismissed allegations by the Binay camp that the President pressured the Ombudsman into suspending Mayor Binay.
“I don’t see President P-Noy trying to influence anybody. He couldn’t influence (Chief Justice Maria Lourdes) Sereno. He couldn’t influence (Ombudsman) Conchita Carpio Morales,” said Belmonte in an interview with reporters. “Once they are in position, they tend to be their own bosses.”
A special panel of investigators on June 8 recommended the suspension of the mayor while investigations are continuing in the school overprice case, citing as evidence a claim by former Makati City general services head Mario Hechanova that bidding for the building was rigged.
Hechanova’s allegation was based on what he said he had been told by the late city engineer Nelson Morales.
Binay’s lawyer has dismissed the evidence as hearsay.
Monday’s suspension order did not mention the duration, but a spokesperson said it was also for six months. Because Binay’s staff refused to accept the order, a copy was sent to the mayor’s residence.
In press statement, the Ombudsman said the suspension order against Mayor Binay and his fellow City Hall executives stemmed from the seven separate administrative cases for grave misconduct, dishonesty and conduct prejudicial to the best interest of the service filed by the Ombudsman’s Field Investigation Office.
It said there was a “showing that respondents mutually aided one another in rigging and prearranging, in favor of pre-selected contractors, the procurement and award, including the approval and release of payments.”
Evidence strong
“Since their respective positions give them access to public records and influence the possible witnesses, and considering the apparent repeated and similar schematic pattern applied in these transactions, respondents’ continued stay in office may prejudice the cases filed against them,” the Ombudsman said.
It said Republic Act No. 6770, or the Ombudsman Act of 1989, authorized the agency to “preventively suspend” public officials if “the evidence of guilt is strong” and if the charges against them involved dishonesty, oppression, grave misconduct and neglect in the performance of duty.
The suspension is also necessary if the penalty for the charges includes removal from office and if their “continued stay in office may prejudice the case” brought against them.
Of the total project cost, the Ombudsman said P17.3 million went to Infiniti Architectural Works for the design and engineering services for the construction of the school building.
The rest was given in six tranches to Hilmarc’s Construction Corp. from 2007 to 2014, it said.
Aside from Binay, suspended from office were Assistant Department Head II Pio Kenneth Dasal, Department Head II Lorenza Amores, City Accountant III Leonila Querijero, acting City Accountant Cecilio Lim III, Department Head II Nelia Barlis and Engineering Assistant Norman Flores.
Also included in the suspension order were Chief Administrative Officer Giovanni Condes, Administrative Officer V Ralph Liberato, Assistant Department Head II Ulysses Orienza, Bids and Awards Secretariat Head Manolito Uyaco, Department Head II Eleno Mendoza Jr. and Department Head II Mario Badillo.
The Vice President and the respondents were also facing separate criminal charges along with the officials of the two private contractors. But the Vice President has immunity from lawsuits and cannot be removed except by impeachment while sitting in office.–With a report from Gil C. Cabacungan
RELATED STORIES
Junjun Binay defiant over Ombudsman’s second suspension order
Ombudsman issues 2nd suspension order vs Mayor Binay
