CHR: Zamboanga City rehabilitation of siege victims not compliant with laws
ZAMBOANGA CITY, Philippines – The Commission on Human Rights has said the city government’s handling of residents displaced by the September 2013 siege here was not compliant with domestic and international laws.
But Mayor Ma. Isabelle Climaco Salazar said the CHR lacked understanding of the “unique situation” here and that it should not have issued a “generic” statement.
“It would have been best for the CHR to look into the unique situation of Zamboanga City rather than come up with a swift advisory,” Salazar said during Wednesday’s public forum on the plight of internally displaced persons, which the CHR has organized.
Human Rights Commissioner Jose Manuel Mamauag said they had no intention of maligning the city government and the assessment was the product of consultations.
“(The city government’s) efforts and actions in addressing the plight of the IDPs are not in compliance with domestic laws as well as international standards and we from the CHR kept on reminding the LGU of its obligations and of actions not in compliance with human rights laws,” Mamauag said,
He cited as an example the city government’s policy of returning the IDPs to their pre-siege condition and not providing them long-term help.
Mamauag added that the city government failed to consult the affected families, especially those displaced with no land titles, and those to be relocated to areas considered new or foreign to them.
Another issue, Mamauag said, has been the city government’s failure to consider the Indigenous People’s Act in the case of the Badjaos.
“The materials and resources provided did not match their habitual way of living and not culturally sensitive,” he added.
Mohammad Taja Arakama, the city local government operations officer, said: “What is the use of having beautiful houses with no livelihood or far from the source of livelihood?”
Mamauag said the CHR did not become reckless in issuing the assessment because the city government had been reminded time and again about its “obligation to address (the problem) in accordance with domestic and international laws.”
But Salazar was furious.
She said the assessment was issued based on the work of “two human rights lawyers who never set foot in Zamboanga.”
Mamauag expressed hope the city government would consider the assessment and work to straighten things up.
As of Wednesday, 22,759 individuals were still in transitional sites and evacuation centers here.
Subscribe to INQUIRER PLUS to get access to The Philippine Daily Inquirer & other 70+ titles, share up to 5 gadgets, listen to the news, download as early as 4am & share articles on social media. Call 896 6000.