Poe: Lone running Dalian train no cause for celebration

ONE AND ONLYOf the 18 trains delivered to the country, only one is in use. —INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

While the Department of Transportation (DOTr) sees as promising the introduction of one of 18 Dalian trains in October to the regular fleet of the Metro Rail Transit (MRT) 3 system, Sen. Grace Poe remains unimpressed and even criticized the Chinese train manufacturer for using Filipinos as “guinea pigs.”

Addressing a road safety forum hosted by Vera Files and the World Health Organization, Poe said, “People have been asking me: What can you say now that one of the Dalian trains is working? Eh ‘di masaya (Well, I’m happy).”


“But remember this: we bought the trains in 2014. It’s 2018 now. Of the 16 trains, 48 coaches, only one train is running. Is this really something to be proud of?” she asked.

As head of the Senate public works committee, Poe led the inquiry into the allegedly anomalous P3.8-billion deal. There were also claims that the delivered trains were overweight and incompatible with the existing railroad tracks but these were disputed by MRT 3 management and experts.


The new trains, bought under the Aquino administration, were meant to expand and augment the rapidly deteriorating overhead light rail system.

Unused for 3 years

However, they sat unused in the MRT 3 depot for three years while the Commission on Audit (COA) found Dalian Corp. owed the DOTr some P1.3 billion in damages.

The COA even recommended that the DOTr, now headed by Transport Secretary Arthur Tugade, revoke the contract.

But Tugade forged a deal where the Chinese firm would fix the trains at no cost to the government.

An independent audit conducted by a third party, TUV Rheinland, also found all 18 trains generally usable despite several deviations from the terms of reference for their purchase.

Asked later at the forum’s sidelines whether such a deal with the same company that failed to deliver in the first place was prudent, Poe could only shrug: “It’s on their [DOTr’s] shoulders now to make sure that the Dalian trains are compatible.”


Depending on the configuration, there could be 18 trains with 3 coaches each or 16 trains, each one pulling 4 coaches.

On Oct. 28, one of the Dalian trains finally hit the tracks after extensive rehabilitation and a battery of tests to ensure its safety.

Its maiden voyage was widely seen by the public and even by the DOTr with cautious optimism that the glitch-marred MRT 3 system could be improved.

Pinoys as guinea pigs 

But for Poe, it is hardly a cause for celebration.

“That’s just one of 16 trains we were supposed to have and it’s still on test run,” she said. “Ordinary Filipinos are being used as guinea pigs when those trains should have been tested by China in the first place.”

“I will be the first to applaud if they deliver next year,” she added. “But let us never forget the incompetent people who entered [into] the deal in the first place.”

Read Next
Don't miss out on the latest news and information.
View comments

Subscribe to INQUIRER PLUS to get access to The Philippine Daily Inquirer & other 70+ titles, share up to 5 gadgets, listen to the news, download as early as 4am & share articles on social media. Call 896 6000.

TAGS: Arthur Tugade, Dalian Corp., Dalian trains, Department of Transportation, DoTr, Grace Poe, MRT 3
For feedback, complaints, or inquiries, contact us.

© Copyright 1997-2019 | All Rights Reserved

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By continuing, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. To find out more, please click this link.