Quantcast
Latest Stories

Supreme Court junks suits vs Arroyo Maguindanao martial law; Corona dissents

By

former President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo CONTRIBUTED PHOTO

BAGUIO CITY—Voting 9-6, the Supreme Court ruled that seven suits contesting the constitutionality of a martial law proclamation by former President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo in Maguindanao in 2009 had been rendered moot because she lifted the proclamation before Congress could review it.

This time, Chief Justice Renato Corona dissented from the majority decision, which dismissed all constitutional challenges raised against Arroyo for declaring martial law and suspending the writ of habeas corpus in Maguindanao more than two years ago.

Proclamation No. 1959, which took effect for only eight days, was intended to deal with the reported uprising of forces loyal to the Ampatuan family after its members were implicated in the massacre of 57 people in Maguindanao, mostly journalists, on Nov. 23, 2009.

The decision, penned by Associate Justice Roberto Abad, was dated March 20, but it was distributed to reporters here only on Monday. The high court’s justices are holding their annual summer sessions in Baguio City.

In separate dissenting opinions, Associate Justices Antonio Carpio Presbitero Velasco Jr. argued that the court failed to use the opportunity to guide future presidents about the proper way of imposing martial rule.

Carpio said Proclamation No. 1959 was the first case when a Philippine president declared martial law since the administration of former President Ferdinand Marcos.

“[It] provides this court with a rare opportunity… to formulate controlling principles for the guidance of all sectors concerned,” he said.

Corona indicated that he subscribed to the dissenting opinion of Velasco, who believed the court “must take the bull by the horns to guide, explain and elucidate [the parameters of a declaration of martial law] to the executive branch, the legislative branch, the bar and more importantly, the public.”

The majority decision, however, believed that a court-imposed guideline for martial rule would not be effective.

In Zamboanga City, Colonel Randolph Cabangbang, spokesperson of the military’s Western Mindanao Command, said Proclamation No. 1959 made it easier for both the Armed Forces of the Philippines and the Philippine National Police to enforce law and order after the Maguindanao massacre. With a report from Julie S. Alipala, Inquirer Mindanao

Originally posted: 9:50 pm | Monday, April 16th, 2012


Follow Us

Follow us on Facebook Follow on Twitter Follow on Twitter


Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Tags: Commission on Human Rights , courts , Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo , Judiciary , Jurisprudence , litigation , Maguindanao , Maguindanao Martial Law , Maguindanao massacre , Martial law , News , Philippine Government , Politics , Presidency , Renato Corona , Supreme Court , trials


  • Guest

    Nothing wrong with the little girl rattling off her sable eh? Or just a show of consternation to pull her image up during those last few days of bungle.

    • JasminCubacub

      Is it really your name?

      • Guest

        Sure it’s my name. Hows yours? Are you really Jasmin Cubacub?

      • JasminCubacub

        My pen name it is..   but you have nothing to do with SC-CJ!

      • JasminCubacub

        ano’ng trabaho ng nanay mo? bakit nya kilala yng Dad ni CJ?

    • JasminCubacub

      Tell this to PANGANIBAN & DAVIDE!

    • JasminCubacub

      Sino’ng tatay mo? Were you fathered by CJ Corona’s  DAD? It is an honor to CJ so, I hope he won’t get mad at me for asking this from you. But your family must be ashamed if you say that your mother had affair with CJ’s Dad and so you were born! That’s why you have this name. TATAY MO SI ATTY JOSE CORONA? Ang galing ni tatay..  binuntis nya pla maraming babae, pati nanay mo..

    • JasminCubacub

      But  I find something wrong with your mother!! 

  • jurbinsky77

    Too late again..SC.

  • Yahilawod

    With Corona Supreme Court, it’s never over till it’s over.

  • jiroarturo

    Ano ba sa Tagalog ang article na ito?

  • Filipinoflash

    nagpa pogi lang si Corona. Hindi kuno sumabay sa majority na papabor kay Arroyo. Pero kung titingnan mo MOOT AND ACADEMIC na ang lahat. 

    Hindi mo na kami maloloko Corona. 

    • filipinaskoh

      kasi naman 9 na iyong nagvote. ek ek lang nya iyon.

  • marlaw

    Kaya talagang napapanahon na na mareporma ang judiciary. Laging ganito na lang kung kelan “moot & academic” na ang kaso saka lang aaksyunan. Noong kelangang kelangan ang kanilang desisyon ay kanila lang ito inupuan. Kaya dito nawawalan ng tiwala ang taumbayan sa korte dahil na rin sa usad pagong na proseso. Para silang mga pulis sa sine na saka lang dadating sa crime scene kapag nakatakas na ang kriminal.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_U6I5Z47EK5YM3VCD3GXEPJB3CU cutie boy

    hay naku, meron naman talagang dissenting opinion at majority opinion sa mga sc decision. mga idiots kayo pag di nyo alam to……

  • samarutan

    Renato  Corona,  wika  nga ng mga bading,  CHARING!

    • JasminCubacub

      Here is a Renato Corona blogging on this site.. Is he the one that you are talking to?

      • sacrebleau

         Cubacub, eat your vegies!

      • JasminCubacub

        Is it your family culture?

      • sacrebleau

        Cubacub, stop picking your nose!!

      • JasminCubacub

        Just because you do it, you don’t need to assume that I also do it.

      • sacrebleau

        Hey Cubacub! Cubacub backwards is Bucabuc.

      • JasminCubacub

        Hometown mo yan Bucabuc? Bakit ka pala dumalao sa Coconut Palace? Kasi takot na malapit na ikaw  matangal  sa trabahao? 

      • sacrebleau

        Cubacub, where is Bucabuc? In Iraq?

      • JasminCubacub

        di mo pala alam, tapos sinasabi mo yan saken! palagay ko yan ay dating luisita!

      • sacrebleau

        Cubacub, magtinda ka na lang ng kutsinta!

      • JasminCubacub

        You think I am bbo like you? Expert ako sa law

      • sacrebleau

        Cubacub, mapurol ka. Kaya ‘wag kang magyabang. Kitang-kita ang kahinaan mo sa iyong weak reasoning, Cubacub.

      • JasminCubacub

        which is weak reasoning? That I am an expert in Law? Truth for you is weak! I know it already. 

      • sacrebleau

        No Cubacub. Your cognitive and analytical abilities and articulation are below average. Mediocre, Cubacub, mediocre.

      • JasminCubacub

        you are not qualified to demean my capabilities! basta ang alam ko, mas mataas ako sayo!

      • sacrebleau

        Cubacub, shut up. Do you even know my qualifications? Stupid woman. I was educated in the US.

      • JasminCubacub

        Tama’ng hula ko.. kaya wala talaga ikaw natutu.. I have no regard for US education. See who are those in high positions there? Those educated in the third world..

      • sacrebleau

         Cubacub, unlike you, I have high regard for both foreign and local education, but you are an exception. You are a typical example of the low standard of graduates in our education system, you have a mindset of a clerk, not of the Supreme Court, but an office clerk. Can you do filing?

      • JasminCubacub

        can you please tell the inquirer to alter the form of publication of comments..  before I answer you, I have to first understand what you are saying. 

      • sacrebleau

         Never mind Cubacub, you have a limited brain capacity anyway :p

      • JasminCubacub

        i am not surprised by your method of communication.. kasi crook ikaw!

      • JasminCubacub

        TNGGE.. I am a law practitioner.. 

      • sacrebleau

        Well, Cubacub, it seems you are not an asset to your profession.

      • sacrebleau

        Cubacub, wash my underwear! Hahaha!

  • pasaway008ako

    What is the meaning of this? I don’t buy it. More issues to come, dn’t forget!!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Vojie-Dosdos/100000607827922 Vojie Dosdos

    Next time Supreme Court, strike while the iron is hot.

  • NoronJamel

    Eto na nman po ang Supreme Koot, makupad pa sa pison kung mag-decide ng case, malapit na ngang ma-tsugi Andal Ampatuan, Sr. sa Bicutan, saka pa ito lumabas! Cha-cha na lang taumbayan at gawing department na ang Supreme Koot pra wala nang magyaman na abogado, siguro by that time maunlad na tayo dahil wala na halos mga abogagong magnanakaw!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_35DZDJJ4ZHZM7JEDXECWULI2KM eric

      If you do more research, you should know that the case of Ampatuan is not finished yet by the lower court and the DOJ. In fact, the hearing is not doing any progress. It would probably take more than 4 yrs before it is finished.

      The DOJ is breaking a deal with Ampatuan JR for immunity, in exchange of implicating GMA to the massacre and election rigging. Which means that if DE LIMA would have her way, Ampatuan JR will not be prosecuted.

      The SC finished this particular case in about two yrs. It is indeed a long period. WHY? Bec. the martial law lasted only for 6 days and was lifted already, which means the case is not urgent but purely academic.

      Philippine economy is doing well till 2010. When the world was in a double dip recession and thousands of Filipino OFW’s lost their jobs, our economy is growing by 7%, and it went on peak to 9% in 2010. Since Noynoy took over, it goes down to 4%, 3%, 2.9% consistently. This is when all our ASEAN neighbors are growing by 6 to 8% due to the rebound of global economy after the worst ecnomic crisis since the great depression that took place in 2006-2008.

      IT is expected by economists that our economy will get worse by the middle of the year because of the power crisis in Mindanao and mishandling of the Sprately issue.

      By these figures, alam mo ang dahilan kung bakit tumigil ang pagunlad ng bansa natin.

      • hukom2

        Philippine economy is doing well since 2010?   Oh, yes… I almost forgot!  And that includes the ZTE-NBN deal !!!  

      • boypalaban

        pagpasensyahan mo na…may sariling mundo yan…sana sumama na sa panginoon niya doon sa VMMC…o baka takas sa St. Lukes yan.

      • hukom2

        ganun ba? Hindi sya halatang miembro ng KULTO! Hehehehe!

  • http://fables.boxpinoy.com/ Lucky Luciano

    Naks, Talaga lang ha.

  • catmanjohn

    A MAZE ING. One knows that two negatives means a positive, but what does five negatives mean? The court has lost credibility and TRUST, and the sooner the vile pig faced Corona is impeached, Clarity and Trust will return to the Judicial Process. Arroyo’s complicity in rigging the elections in Mindanao and arming the Ampatuans, must be clearly stated before further hogwash is pontificated by this corrupt Supreme Court to make themselves appear like Justice is being carried out.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_35DZDJJ4ZHZM7JEDXECWULI2KM eric

      You should do more reseach.

      It was not Arroyo who armed the Ampatuans. The Aquinos did that, GMA only inherited the problems.

      Cory Aquino fired all the local government officials and appointed OIC. She gave the ampatuans their break in Mindanao politics by giving then prized positions in the local goverment. Prior to Cory, the Ampatuans were poor and powerless clan. They came to power by being Cory’s supporters in 1986. By the end of Cory’s terms, the Ampatuans occupy various positions in Maguindanao, and Mindanao from governor to BOCAL. The Ampatuans were loyal supporters of Cory from 1986 to 1992, then of the LAKAS pary which Cory founded.

      Cory Administration and her party mates used the Ampatuans to rigged elections in Mindanao during 1987, and 1992. Aquilino Pementel an oppositionist to Cory endorsed Lakas party (whom she created to bolt Mitras LDP, after Mitra was loyal to her for 6 yrs) was cheated in the senatorial election in 1995 thru Maguindanao election rigging.

      The first act of Noynoy as a president is to suspend the ARMM election in 2010, fired all elected officials, and appointed his own supporters as OIC in Maguindanao.

      Let us hope and pray that Noynoy will not create another monster like the Ampatuans, the legacy that is left to us by his mother.

      • catmanjohn

        Your facts are questionable, and only some credible unbiased historian would be able to decipher facts from fiction. You are politicizing the issues here. 

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_35DZDJJ4ZHZM7JEDXECWULI2KM eric

        you already politicized the issue in your post, the issue is political indeed so I do not see why it should be questioned.

        I did ask you to accept my facts, I told you to do more research in Mindanao politics and the rise to power of the Ampatuans.

        If you read other newspapers aside from Inquirer such as Philstar and Manila standard, you will get the facts that I posted.

      • otoling

        Kaga-gohan.

        Bakit afterwards Gloria tolerated it more for the Ampatuan’s?  Why did she put a stop on the Ampatuan’s?

        Dahil si Gloria is lokarit and simply wanted to rule without governing properly. 

      • boypalaban

        paki-cite ang source mo na si cory ang bumuo ng Lakas-NUCD.

        kung di mo ma cite ang source mo na siguradong credible yan…intellectual dishonesty yan…nagmamarunong na peke.

      • billygunn23

        i don’t know what kind of mouse runs in your mind but when someone accuses another of politicizing a certain issue when his very own statements are rife with politics, he is either a fool or a liar. Which are you?

      • catmanjohn

        Another nasty bASS wipe Arroyo lackey coming to her defense. It is clear as MUD that the massacre happened under Arroyos term, and how they were armed with such weapons could only implicate that she allowed them to acquire such weapons, let alone the impunity to kill all their opponents. You’re speaking to a man BOY, and if you really want to do something good for the Nation, go and hunt down that Ecleo Jr., if you got the balls. 

      • boypalaban

        NASOPLAK KO NA PRE….AYAW MAG-RESEARCH E. PURO NOYNOYING ANG ALAM…GAYA NG AMO NIYANG NASA VMMC PASARAP BUHAY….

      • boypalaban

        si cory ang nagbuo ng Lakas CMD? anong source mo? nag-research ka nga ba?
        kung di ka taga maguindanao, puro haka haka lang yang alam mo.
        ako galing ako doon…kaya alam ko sinasabi ko… di kilala yang ampatuan na yan…ang kilala doon sinsuat, ambolodto, biruar, etc.
        yang ampatuan na yan, lalong lumakas nung panahon ni gloriarrovo, na may basbas ni gibo giba teodoro…alam nang halimaw ang mga yan, di pa kinontrol kasi pinapakinabangan.
        Hello garci…

      • dannyflorencio

         boypalabate  binuo ni Cory ang Lakas CMD ng matalo sa LDP convention si Ramos kay Monching Mitra/ Kaya naging presidential standard bearer si Ramos ng Lakas-CMD at Monching Mitra naman sa LDP. Di sukat akalain ni Cory noon na matatalo si Ramos sa LDP Convention pero natalo pa rin ito ni Monching Mitra since walang tiwala si Cory na mananalo si Mitra sa 1992 presidential election binuo nila ang Lakas CMD at si Ramos ang pinatakbong pangulo dito. Wag kang mangmang boy palabate ok ?

      • boypalaban

        boploks ipakita mo ang source mo niyan…isa ka ring haka haka…di porket inindorso ni cory si tabako siya na ang bumuo niyan…saan ang sentido komon mo? ha? nasaaan?
        buti pa yung ginagaya mong pangalan sa pba magaling sa basketball,ikaw walang saysay ang utak mo kung meron ka man boploks!

      • tiopaero

         boypalaban bobo kahit sa goggle at wikipedia mababasa mo yan kaya lang tanga ka kaya di mo alam ang goggle at wikipedia. Saksakan ka kasi ng bobo. tingnan mo posting mo walang may gusto kasi puro basura tulad mo. Mag-aral ka ng di ka asal squatter.

      • boypalaban

        BOPLOKS PAKI-COPY PASTE NGA ANG GALING SA WIKIPEDIA NA SI CORY NAGTATAG NIYAN…BOPLOKS…SIGE BILIS GAYA KA RIN NG ENGOT NA GAYA MONG NAGMAMARUNONG PURO KABOPLOKAN NAMAN ANG ALAM TSUPING…MAGTRABAHO KA…NANG MAY PAMBAYAD KA SA MGA LALAKE! BOPLOKS!

      • boypalaban

        wag magmarunong pag di alam…malaking kasalanan yan
        INTELLECTUAL DISHONESTY YAN kung di mo alam ang term.
        wala ka pa ring mai-cite na credible/reliable na sources…may pantasya kang sarili…ok lang basta wag mo ako pagpantasyahan…ikaw na lang magsariling sikap…wag magnoynoying…trabahuhin mo sarili mo…bilis!

      • boypalaban

        Lakas party founded 1986? ha ha ha
        aminin mo na…..GUILTY KA NG INTELLECTUAL DISHONESTY…FEELING MARUNONG KA, WALA KA NAMANG KREDIBILIDAD…PURO CITE KA NG PEKENG SOURCES KUNG MERON MAN…O KATHANG ISIP MO LANG LAHAT GAYA NG GINAWA NI HORN…HA HA AH HAHAHAH

        ikaw na lang ang magdasal…unahin mo ipagdasal ang panginoon mong si gloriarrovo!

      • catmanjohn

        The Arroyo bASS wipe lackeys are intent on denying the facts that the Arroyos had complicity in arming the Ampatuans, not only rigging the elections in Mindanao. Some two bit pea brained intellectual wants to blame Cory Aquino for the Ampatuans evil deeds. Get real and get out of  your sewers, and face the facts.

      • catmanjohn

        Eric, you two bit bASS wipe Arroyo lackey, seem to wishfully deny the fact that the massacre happened under Arroyo’s watch, and for the Ampatuans to acquire such weapons and act with such impunity, the Arroyos had to have been complicit. Arroyo lackeys are deceptive at every turn, and are a disgrace to truth and humanity. Corona is clear evidence of this and bASS wipes like you will defend these corrupt leeches by blaming everything on the Aquinos, who is finally making a positive change for the Nation.

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/AND7MQ5FERICDOIAUW56RYT45A tower_of_power

        Hi Eric! GMA inherited the problems? Of course that is your opinion! The real score is that … GMA was only too glad to have the Ampatuans right where they where. She made them devils … look at what happened … GMA and FIRST GUNTLEMAN must be made accessories to the heinous crimes that the Ampatuans perpetrated!!!

  • Pitbulldog

    When P-noy decided to challenge the CJ and drag the SC to all these dirty controveries, I hope he did a lot of thinking before making his moves .  Perhaps he believes his popularity will overcome all hindrances towards  his victory.  What if he fails?  then he should preapare himself for bitter consequences from not so lenient justices that he has offended. Si P-noy kasi, di nag-iisip, arang propesor yan, kapag ininis mo, wag kang umasa ng papasang awa ka kahit di ka magpursige mag-aral.  Nasanay ka kasi sa biyaya. 

    • catmanjohn

      Did you mother teach you, ‘DO THE RIGHT THING’? Until then, you are NOT a man, and if you let the corrupt and evil take that will power away, then you are a lost cause, as the Nation. In your mind, the battle  is lost before the War has begun.

      • Pitbulldog

        What is lost by the way?  Hopeless case na impeachment adventure ni P-noy di ba?.  At kayong mga dilaw na miron na sige pa rin sa kasusulsol kay P-noy, ay dapat mag-isip isp na rin.  Yang idol nyo, parang retarded yan, habang ayon ka ng ayon, lalong sumisige at natutuwa na akala tama ginagawa nya.  Dapat dya latiguhin na dahil sa kapalpakan nya.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/AND7MQ5FERICDOIAUW56RYT45A tower_of_power

    Try again THIEF JUSTICE … hahaha … nakakatawang panloloko!!! Naubos na ang mga tagaMindanao kung nag ka bakbakan doon. Eto talagang SOLDPREME COHORTS …. at nagdissent pa ang THIEF JUSTICE … what a show!!!

  • hukom2

    Spurious document yan a!!! Paki kutusan mo nga Sec. De lima!

  • boypalaban

    sa mga magpo-post ng komento:
    PAKI-SIGURO LANG NA TAMA O TOTOO ANG FACT (fact nga e) NA IPE-PRESENT DITO.
    OK LANG NA IBA IBA OPINION BASTA TAMA ANG DATA.
    DAHIL KUNG HINDI….SIGURADONG SOPLAK LANG ANG AABUTIN…HA HA HA GAYA NG NANGYARI SA ISA DITO…SORRY….

    • dannyflorencio

      boypalabaTE   walang may gusto ng mga comments mo. tingnan mo 0 like ka. kasi mali mali at may reading comprehensopn ka yata eh !

      • boypalaban

        boploks isa ka pa…dami na talagang engot gaya mo…nakikita mo ba sarili mo kay noynoy? masakit ba tanggapin ang katotohanan na boploks ka rin?

      • boypalaban

        reading comprehensopn  AYOS BAGONG TERM! MULA SA ENGOT….

      • boypalaban

        di ako papagamit sa yo, wala kang pera…batehin mo sarili mo

  • dannyflorencio

    GOOD JOB CJ CORONA,  CONGRATULATIONS IN ADVANCE TO YOUR FORTHCOMING ACQUITTAL IN THE IMPEACHMENT TRIAL.

    SAMANATALANG YUNG KALABAN MO NA SI ABNOY PINAGMUMURA NA SA MINDANAO.

    • boypalaban

      halikan mo pwet ni coronababoy….kiss mo ulo ni abnoy…bagay yan sa gaya mong boploks uto uto! ha ah aha h

    • Guest

      Don’t you all worry. If I sense that I’ll be impeached in the senate, I’ll print out a TRO right away to stop and dissolve the senate.

      • JasminCubacub

        You can be charged for usurping powers by falsifying your name.. you admitted to me that you are not the CJ but you are using his name. What if anyone creates an account under Simeon’s ID and issues statements against him? 

      • Guest

        Charge me my dear. I have eleven close friends in higher ..er highest places. Though I wonder what will I be charged with this time? I mean I haven’t used the PAL VIP card yet. Please elaborate.

      • JasminCubacub

        I  DON’T NEED TO CHARGE YOU ANYMORE.. Anyway, you have admitted you have the support of your president and there are so many to save you. The 188 in the HOUSE are also equally confident as you are. At least I am glad that the public is aware of the real mastermind of this drama. It is going to reach its culmination next week.. CONGRATS TO THE TENANTS OF LUISITA! I hope you won’t forget to reward me!

      • Guest

        My president can’t do anything else but languish for time and another chance. Me.. I have my 11 mahjong buddies to throw million-peso chips at or raffle large-paying.. er large-complex cases through games of monopoly, and still function as the leader.

      • Guest

        Oh please you’re comparing a man to boys. I’m old school I play along very well, a fact FVR grew fond of me. I’m still in control, I can still disperse and nullify the impeachment court so what’s to worry? Drop by the GSIS compound one night and let’s play Twister.

      • JasminCubacub

        What is your relation with ARTEMIO PANGANIBAN? He is a bloody rscl..

      • JasminCubacub

        what is the name of your Father? Don’t tell me that CJ’s Father impregnated your Mother [resulting in your conception!].

  • tarikan

    Nagpapa-bilib lang itong si CJ Corona para sabihin “see, I am not always pro-Gloria.” Please acquit me.

  • http://profiles.google.com/forestking19 Ryan Barcelo

    Interesting!

  • http://joboni96.myopenid.com/ joboni96

    ‘Corona dissented from the majority decision’

    kailangan niyang pampa pogi
    lalo na sa kongreso

    wala na rin sa poder amo niyang aroyo

  • sacrebleau

    Because Corona’s supposed CJ term is up to 2018 if acquitted, it behooves the thieving philanderer to seem neutral and impartial until Pnoy steps down in 2016. After which he will start to exact revenge against the filipino people and free the little monster – let her loose to become PM. 

    There seems to be an upsurge in finalizing big cases before the Senate resumes the impeachment and renders judgment.

    • tiopaero

      sacrebleau TUMIRA KA NAMAN BAKLA. MAG-PARLOR KA DUN PUNTA NA !!!

      NAGHIHINTAY ANG MGA CUSTOMERS MO BAYOT ! BALIK SA PARLOR ALIS DYAN !

      • sacrebleau

        Hehehe, pag nag-react ng ganyan si choopaero, ibig sabihin sapul na naman ang Corona federacion. Tsug!

      • tiopaero

        sacrebleau bakla bakit mo nilagay ung litrato mong bading pati pangalan mo badap ang dating. Kamusta na pick-up mo sa DOJ gym ok pa ba ? grabe iniisip mo ba makakadale ka dito online ng magiging jowa mo ? kaya bading na bading ang parating mo sa pangalan at picture ? hahahahahahaha  desperado na itong siyoke na ito pati sa internet nambibiktima     hahahahahahahaha

        DI KA NA TALAGA NAHIHIYA LANTARAN NA ANG PAGIGING BAKLA MO HA ? heheheheeheheheeheheheheh

      • boypalaban

        STALKER KA NIYAN…SENSYA KA DI KA PINAPANSIN…BOPLOKS KA KASI E…WALA KA PANG PERA….KAWAWA KA NAMAN…TSUPING…KAMAG-ANAK MO BA SI TSUPING LACSON? HAHAHHAHAHH

      • sacrebleau

        Uy, tactic number 2 ng Corona federacion: Reduce my brilliant argument to nonsense by talking about choopa. Nyuk, nyuk, nyuk, Choopaero, alam naman namin na kaya wala kang pic e dahil mukha kang driftwood. Baklang driftwood. O e di pano, fcuk you very much na lang ha.

      • boypalaban

        nakita niyang si tiopadbreath pic mo…type niya…pero kahit sino di papatol diyan…may tagas sa utak…may tulo bandang ibaba…daming STD clinic bandang Caloocan at Cubao…di pa rin nagpapagamot yan…dapat diyan ibartolina na e…tsupinggot…tsupingping badingding.

      • sacrebleau

        Ha ha! Tsaka mana sa tatay nya yan bro, pareho silang supot.

      • boypalaban

        hoy boploks walang papagamit sa yo, wala kang pera BOPLOKS KA PA! HAHAH AHA AH

      • boypalaban

        O MAGALING NA TSUPING BADINGDING, NASAAN NA YUNG COPY PASTE NA SINASABI MONG SI CORY NAGTATAG NG LAKAS-NUCD? MASYADO KANG NAGMAMAGALING,PATI PANLALALAKE GINAGAWA MO PARA LANG MAY PUMANSIN SA YO…HA TSUPING BADING?!

      • tiopaero

        boypalaban tanga mo talaga !!! tanungin mo na lang tatay mo !! mahirap magsayang ng oras sa isang mangmang at tangang tulad mo.

      • boypalaban

        DI MO MAIPAKITA O MAI REFER ANG LINK…HALATANG SINUNGALING KA…MAHIYA KA NAMAN SA IBANG PANATIKO NI CORONABABOY…IKINAHIHIYA KA NILA…SABLAY KA…MADADAMAY PA SILA SA KAENGOTAN MO…NAGMAMARUNONG.WALA NAMANG ALAM…

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_ZKPNHSPBMK74VZ3GBIPNTJA7KE Edwin

    o anu ngayon, mga YELLOWTARDS…kahit nga di bumoto si Corona..

    • boypalaban

      E YUNG MGA CORONATURD KUMUSTA NAMAN?

  • SG0609

    hahaha…malay ko ba sayo KORONA…padissent dissent ka pa…lokohin mo mga lelang mo…MOROMORO yanpwe

  • tiopaero

    Mga senators na huhusga kay CJ Corona ayun nagsamahan at nag-uunahan na lahat sa Una at kay Binay at itong gungong na pangulong sira ulo umaasa pa din na di titiwalag si Binay sa kanya. hahahahahahahahahaha  tulad ng ibang mga supporters ni Baklang Carandang umaasa pa silang magiging guilty ang hatol ng Impeachment court. Ano na ba naman nangyari sa IQ ninyo ?

    • boypalaban

      nagaya sa IQ mong pang engot…boploks…uso na talaga…o nasaan na yung pinagmamalaki mong alam mo na si cory nagtatag ng Lakas-NUCD? nagmamagaling ka, exposed ka naman na boploks ka…gaya ng panginoon mong baboycorrovo…haha ah aha ah

      • tiopaero

        boypalabate mahiya ka sa nakakabasa ng post mo kitang kita nila na ignorante ka sa mga sinasabi mo. Tanungin mo tatay mo mukang di ka pa ipinapanganak ng mangyari to kaya di mo alam. bobo

        Kakahiya ka wikipedia at goggle di ka marunong gumamit hahahahahahaha

      • boypalaban

        DI MO MAIPAKITA ANG LINK…BOPLOKS NOON KO PA BINASA YANG SA GOOGLE AT WIKIPEDIA…NASAAN ANG PANGALAN NI CORY? HA? SA PANTASYA MO YATA… ANDUN SI GLORIARROVO KASAMA SI BABOY(CORONAMPATUAN)

      • boypalaban

        HANGGAT DI MO MAIPAKITA ANG LINK NA SI CORY NAGTATAG NIYAN, WALA KANG KREDIBILIDAD..MATULOG KA NA LANG…SAYANG LANG ESPASYO DITO…TANUNGIN MO KAYA SI BABOYCORONA NG OPINION NIYA…BAKA IKAHIYA KA NIYA…TONTO KA KASI…HA AH AH

  • boypalaban

    SORRY NA LANG SA MGA LIBAG NI CORONABABOY…LAGI KAYONG SOPLAK SA MGA ARGUMENTO…PASENSIYA NA GANYAN LANG TALAGA…DAMI KO NANG NAKABANGGA NA MGA PANATIKO NI BABOY DITO,WALANG TUMAGAL…LAHAT SOPLAK…TSK TSK…UUUUYY MALAPIT NA NGA PALA ANG RESUMPTION….PAPAPUTOK NA NAMAN SI ATTY ROY SA SENADO…ANG LAKAAAASS….AAAHHH DI KO NA KAYA…..AAHHH

  • boypalaban

    PARA PO SA MGA NAGBABASA DITO AT NAGKOKOMENTO NA MGA PRO AT ANTI CORONA: SABI NI TIOPAERO SI CORY AQUINO DAW ANG NAGTATAG NG LAKAS-NUCD-UMDP-CMD….KAYO NA PO ANG HUMUSGA KUNG MAY KREDIBILIDAD YAN…

    • sacrebleau

       Talaga palang bobo yang si tiopaero, siguro ‘yung syphillis na nakuha nya sa gay a n a l  s3x e kumalat na sa utak nyang sinlake ng buto ng santol.

      • tiopaero

        sacrebleau  BAKLA AKALA KO BUMALIK NA KA NA SA PARLOR MO ANDITO KA PA PALA. APEKTADO BA ANG PARLOR MO SA POWER CRISIS NG MINDANANO AT NANDITO KA ? hahahahahahahaha

        DIYOS KO NAMAN PATI SA PARLOR MO BROWNOUT DIN ?

      • sacrebleau

        Wala, ta3 ka! Di ka nakakatawa! Pak yu! ha ha ha!

  • hukom2

    Dissenting Opinion? Paki salang nga sa “Lie Ditector” yang Cheap Justice na yan, kung totoo ang sinasabi!!! O, kitam… sinungaling!!! E di spurious documents nga ang pinagkakalat nyan… Naku!!! Paki batukan mo nga, Sec. Ochoa!!!

    • Pitbulldog

      Hirap sa die hard P-noy yellow fanatics talaga, parang inispalto na talaga ni P-noy ang mga utak na ayaw nang gamitin lalo na’t di makakabuti kay idol nila.  Ang linaw ng headline na yan.  Yan ang ipanamumukha nyo na si Corona ay tuta daw ni GMA katulad ng pagiging tunay na tuta ng mga tuta ni P-noy.  Ano ba ibig ng “dissenting opinion” na yan?  Common sense na lang.  May pahabol pa, huli na daw lahat para dyan. Tama, huli na lahat ng pamamaraan nyo para ma-convict si CJ.

      • hukom2

        Me, fanatic? Here, doggie tsu,tsu here doggie! Mahirap talaga turuan ang aso pagmatanda na! Matigas na ulo para pasunurin pa. Here doggie pitbulldog  tsu,tsu, tsu…   

  • tiopaero

    Noynoy abnoy nagmalaki tagumpay daw ang mga hakbangin niya ! mga government corporation officials na may malalaking sweldo inalis na, BIR  mas mataas pa sa target ang collection pati na ang custom ganun din ang laki ng budget surplus ng gobierno ! pero ng magka-aberya sa power supply sa Mindanao -wala daw budget !!!  hahahaha ! asan na ang mga pinagyayabang mo ha ?  hahahahahahahaha  Noynoy Abnoy !!!   GRABE NA KAABNOYAN MO 

    • boypalaban

      OO ABNOY YAN.. YAN LANG BA ALAM MO?
      PERO DI MO PA RIN MAIPAKITA ANG CLAIM MO NA SI CORY NAGTATAG NG LAKAS NUCD.

      • tiopaero

        boypalaban  hahaha kawawa di marunong gumamit ng goggle at wikipedia bobo hahahahahahahaha

        hoy tanga sulatan mo si Fidel Valdez Ramos sasagutin ka non.

      • boypalaban

        tangengot ikaw ang sumulat para masoplak ka rin ni tabako…may sarili kang kwento…gayang gaya mo si horn sungay…o may bago ka pang kwento? may affair nga ba si federacion mong midas kay baboycorovo? pwede ko ba i-google yon? mas ok yata galing sa yo…galing sa tsismis ng kinukulutan mo….ahahaay…

        DI TALAGA MAIPAKITA….SORRY PERO WALA KA NANG KREDIBILIDAD…PANSININ MO WALANG NAGTATANGGOL SA YO…KASI PATI MGA PANATIKO NI CORONA NA ALAM ANG TOTOO DI MANINIWALA SA CLAIM MO NA SI CORY NAGTATAG NG LAKAS NUCD…tsk tsk sorrrry…

      • tiopaero

        boypalaban  ganyan talaga pag kahapon lang pinanganak walang alam sa kahapon.  Tanong mo sa mga magulang mo boy ! alam nila yon o kaya sa kapitbahay mo kasi ikaw lang ang tanga na DI NAKAKAALAM NITO. nGAYON KUNG IBABATO MO KAY GMA ANG LAKAS NUCD NAGKAKAMALI KA KASI KAMPI ANG PARTIDO NIYA NG VP PA SIYA NI ERAP. AYAN MAY NATUTUNAN KA NA BOY AY SANGOL PALA.

      • boypalaban

        sinabi ko ba na si gloria ang nagtatag ng Lakas?talagang KUMSINSIDO KANG SI CORY ANG NAGTATAG NG LAKAS NUCD…TSK TSK….kanina medyo naiinis ako sa yo…ngayon naaawa na…sige na nga, nakakaawa ka talaga…baka nanggigigil na sa yo mga fans ni corona dito…nilalagay mo ang fans club niyo sa alanganin.

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_YAU43R25CAHGNYPHE6HLAM3V6Y Benjamin

        grabe paghimod mo mo sa kuyukot ni coronakot..nawawala ka na sa sarile….

      • boypalaban

        google hindi goggle ….may swimming ba?

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_S2UQGGNN35EUOBNX4N5OBIBDUM Kromuel

      NAsan na yung naipong budget?… hmmm nakaplano na ibayad sa overpriced private electric companies na pagmamayari ng mga supporters nya nung election at kama-ganak na businessmen.

  • tiopaero

    Asa pa kayo na magi-guilty si Corona hahahahahahahahahaha not even in Carandang’s wildest wet dreams !!!!  hahahahahahahahahah

    • boypalaban

      di guilty si Corona…ayon sa ilang senador…pero ikaw GUILTY ng INTELLECTUAL DISHONESTY…mas malala yan….

  • mad_as_Hamlet

    “By the pricking of my thumbs, something wicked this way comes.”
     
    Is not Mr. Corona’s dissent from the majority opinion a clear sign of how he will actually take a stand and vote in a far more important case?  That he will surely still act as GMA’s Grand Protector where it most matters? Actually, both in his and GMA’s interest?
     
    Based on the above report the majority of the Justices declined to pass upon the constitutionality of GMA’s declaration placing Maguindanao under Martial Law because the issue had become moot.  Mr Corona dissented as he wanted the Court to “take the bull by the horns to guide, explain and elucidate [the parameters of a declaration of martial law .”

    That would arguably mean that Mr. Corona will also not consider moot and academic the case which GMA filed assailing the DOJ’s WLO against her as well as the constitutionality of the DOJ’s power to issue WLOs.  That is, despite  such an issue having been mooted by GMA’s arrest via a court-issued warrant for a “non-bailable” offense, and/or a court-issued Hold Departure Order.  Mr.Corona will most probably also say that the Court should “”take the bull by the horns to guide, explain and elucidate the parameters of the right to travel.”  He will definitely not want to lose the grand opportunity to “you-know-what” those whom he consider as his demonizers, to borrow Mr. Fr. Bernas’ favorite word nowadays. 

    • magsasakasanayon

      so you’re a ray bradbury fan. i like that. :) 

  • Amboypinoy1

    Lets burn those 9 judges alive and stab gloria in the eye with a screwdriver. Get a knife and carve out their hearts and throats.

  • Amboypinoy1

    Lets burn down the supreme court. Kill those judges and stab their hearts with a spear. tapos ipakain kay lolong.

  • gwenbalili

    another condo unit change hands

  • aldhins

    Kung pwedi  pala mag declare ng martial Law ang Pres. na di dumaan sa congreso walang pinag kaiba noong kay Pres. Marcos wag natin shortcut ang batas para di magkaroon ng  di pag kakaunawaan ang congress at Judiciary.

  • White24

    hahahaha,,,, ay naku buhay nga namn,,, :)

  • Atagalong

    Moot! Period.

  • -XO-

    What a bunch of avoiders, running the other way when the opportunity comes to establish a erudite precedent. What’s a Supreme Court for? Are they still afraid of pronouncing yea or nay on their masters’ conduct? 

  • Pedro_Gil

    Supreme Court of the Philippines.  A group you can’t trust.  Its owned by Arroyo.

    • Guest

      You don’t have to say the obvious, okay? Just zip it and I’ll give you autographed copies of my president’s memoirs.

  • JasminCubacub

    I have supported GMA on many of her actions/acts while in the Palace.. including proclamation of   1959..  So, I am happy about the majority opinion in this case. However, I can’t understand the basis of the dissenting opinions written by Carpio and Velasco that the Court failed to give guidance for future presidents regarding declaration/administration of martial law.  Is it theoretically impossible for Carpio and Velasco, or is it prohibited,   to give such guideline in a separate opinion  [which is missing in Abad's decision]  than to write a dissenting opinion pointing out such deficiency in the majority opinion? I STILL HAVE TO READ THE MAJORITY DECISION  OF ABAD AND SEPARATE DISSENTING OPINIONS OF CARPIO AND VELASCO. 

  • j1u2a3n

    Nakakatawa talaga ‘tong si Corona. 

    • Guest

       Thanks. I can use a little laugh  you know.

  • Taiko_Kauna

    So the crown is now making amends or he’s just fooling around to make it appear he has? “Pare i abswelto ninyo ha at kunwari sa dissenting side ako”, making fools out of us? 

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_BHWDD6ANTKA7M5M3NIEI33SHMQ Che Koms

    lutong macau!

  • http://twitter.com/Anton0613 anton

    May naniniwala pa ba sa mga desisyon ng SC?

    • pinoy4evermore

      I unequivocally disgree with you,  Mr. Anton I still believe in the rule of law, and the SC still have my trust.  Could we agree to disagree? I expect you to be a gentleman, not a communist.  Mabuhay ang Plilipinas!.

  • aSwedishguy

    Mr Corona,,woww  9-6 or 10-5 what´s the difference ?

  • barangayboso

    I just hope this decision was accurate and not biased.

  • antonioluna

    kahit na ano pang gawing pagkukunwari ng aso lalabas at lalabas pa rin kung kanino sya loyal, di ba cheap dog?hehehe

  • Andoy51

    As long as Corona remains Chief Justice, the decisions of the Supreme Court will always be suspect. This shameless magistrate has so damaged the image of the judiciary, the only way to restore that image is his removal through his impeachment trial, an extreme and unprecedented event in the high court.

    From his grades in school to his sham law doctorate, from his understated SALN to his unreported luxury condos, to the ways he manipulated the money of his wife’s family (Basa Quidote Enterprises) — Corona has been exposed for the brazen liar he really is.

    Who can trust a man like this. He’s not even fit to become a barangay tanod. But he became chief justice because he was illegally appointed (as a midnight appointee) to that powerful position precisely to defend his equally corrupt patron, Gloria Macapagal Arroyo, from prosecution.

  • JasminCubacub

    Moderator, please check on the usernames of your bloggers.. It is very unethical to allow the bloggers to use the names of prominent persons, with the motive of demoralizing those very persons. See here is a RENATO CORONA who is demeaning CJ Corona. PLEASE CHECK & THANKS FOR THE ATTENTION.

    • Guest

       Duly noted. Thanks for the heads up.

      • JasminCubacub

        You said you have your president’s support.. I am sure your head was down when you said this.

      • Guest

        My president have no other choice but to yield that support for me, for I would be dismissing and expunging all charges against .. hrrmm.. my beloved president. Well of course, that would be after I dissolve the impeachment court with a simple TRO and clean my slate myself. Oh I’m so good.

  • Guest

    Birthday party tonight. Its gonna be grand. My president personally asked me to attain. Who can say no to such attention? Hohohooo!!

    • Guest

      I shouldn’t have attended. I was tasked to rub my president gallons of anti-bacterial lotion everytime the curtains fall off. Yaiikkss!

  • JasminCubacub

    @RENATO_CORONA:disqus WON’T RETURN ANYMORE HERE.. Kasi alam nya kilala ko kung sino’ng TATAY NYA!

  • JasminCubacub

    wala na talaga si @Renato_corona..  napahiya na siya.. okay! it was a very simple strategy to make him disappear from here or using that name here. I just asked him if he was fathered by CJ Corona’s father..  He stopped but now using another name, @Guest 



Copyright © 2014, .
To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.
Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:
c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94
Advertisement
  1. Gigi Reyes back to face charges
  2. Enrile chief aide back in PH ‘to face charges’
  3. In the know: Gigi Reyes
  4. SC suspends proctor in 2011 bar exams
  5. Senator Pimentel backs German think tank’s stand vs dynasties
  6. Bar proctor suspended for photographing test papers
  7. Collector Danny Garcia says Inquirer worth more than news
  8. Meteor shower to light up PH skies
  9. What Went Before: Enrile denies Gigi Reyes was ‘other woman’
  10. Henares on Pacquiao bashing: I did not start this
  1. Kim Henares needs a reprimand, says Cayetano
  2. Suspect in Vhong Navarro mauling tries to leave PH
  3. More legal woes for Cedric Lee
  4. ‘No real progress in PH if dynasties not dismantled’
  5. ‘Mom, I love you,’ says text from student on sinking ferry
  6. Fr. Suarez says last Mass on Easter before returning donated land to San Miguel
  7. Enrile chief aide back in PH ‘to face charges’
  8. Massive infra spending set
  9. Henares on Pacquiao bashing: I did not start this
  10. I’ll follow my conscience on Estrada, says JV Ejercito
  1. KL confirms Malaysian Airlines Flight MH370 ended in Indian Ocean
  2. MRT passengers pass the hat for 6-year-old Ashley
  3. Rookie, lady cops lauded for quick response to MOA heist
  4. Malaysia averts another air tragedy; pilot lands troubled plane safely
  5. Revilla says he was joking; Lacson stands by his story
  6. Revilla ‘consulted’ Lacson on how he evaded arrest
  7. Police rule out foul play in Helena Belmonte’s death as boyfriend is ‘traumatized’
  8. Cudia, dismissed for lying, got 99% in conduct
  9. Model Helena Belmonte wished ‘to slash her wrist and hope to die’
  10. Hammer-wielding robbers cause chaos at Philippines’ Mall of Asia
Advertisement

News

  • Militants kill 14 Algerian soldiers in ambush
  • Pope Francis, huge crowd joyously celebrate Easter
  • 4 French journalists freed from Syria captors home
  • Thousands celebrate Easter in Holy Land
  • Transcript reveals confusion over ferry evacuation
  • Sports

  • Red-hot Alaska rips injury-depleted San Mig Coffee
  • Pacquiao courtesy call to Aquino set for Monday
  • Nick Calathes suspension a reminder of supplement risk
  • Teague scores 28 as Hawks soar past Pacers in Game 1
  • Warriors beat Clippers in playoff opener
  • Lifestyle

  • Angono petroglyphs in danger of disappearing
  • Britain’s baby Prince George visits Australian zoo
  • Noli Yamsuan, Cardinal Sin’s ‘official’ photographer: ‘I could smell the aftershave lotion of the Pope’
  • Simplifying and lightening life
  • Where to go for Easter night-out
  • Entertainment

  • Show-biz celebrities’ other choices of summer getaway
  • Why ‘Noah’ can’t dock his ark at Philippine theaters
  • Acclaimed artist goes wild while on holiday
  • Believing in this mermaid
  • Missing Xian
  • Business

  • Top-selling insurance agent opens her dream café
  • Connecting and transacting with one another
  • Building wealth for health
  • Why Mandaue Foam buys, rather than rents, space
  • A workplace of new possibilities
  • Technology

  • Nasa’s moon-orbiting robot crashes down
  • Netizens pay respects to Gabriel Garcia Marquez
  • Nokia recalls 30,000 chargers for Lumia 2520 tablet
  • Facebook rolls out ‘nearby friends’ feature
  • Netizens seethe over Aquino’s ‘sacrifice’ message
  • Opinion

  • Epiphany
  • Unpaid creditor vs distressed debtor
  • Moving on
  • From culinary desert to paradise
  • Response to China: ‘Usjaphil’
  • Global Nation

  • Tim Tebow’s charity hospital in Davao seen to open in 7 months
  • OFW died of Mers-CoV in Saudi Arabia, says family
  • Aquino, Obama to tackle US pivot to Asia during state visit
  • Asia seeks Obama’s assurance in territorial spats
  • Cesar Chavez movie sparks memories of Fil-Am labor leaders
  • Marketplace
    Advertisement