Showdown on Poe DQ case shifts to SC | Inquirer News

Showdown on Poe DQ case shifts to SC

By: - Reporter / @TarraINQ
/ 03:15 AM December 04, 2015
WRITING ON THE WALL    The words “risks” and “miracle,” projected on the face of presidential candidate Sen. Grace Poe during a PowerPoint presentation at a presscon on Thursday, may well be the keywords to her quest for the presidency,  under siege by a string of DQ cases. RAFFY LERMA

WRITING ON THE WALL The words “risks” and “miracle,” projected on the face of presidential candidate Sen. Grace Poe during a PowerPoint presentation at a presscon on Thursday, may well be the keywords to her quest for the presidency, under siege by a string of DQ cases. RAFFY LERMA

The battle for the elimination of Sen. Grace Poe from next year’s presidential election moves to the Supreme Court next week, after the Senate Electoral Tribunal (SET) on Thursday affirmed its Nov. 17 ruling that Poe is a natural-born Filipino.

The nine-member SET maintained its 5-4 vote and junked the motion for reconsideration brought by petitioner Rizalito David, who had sought the ouster of Poe from the Senate on the grounds that she was not a natural-born citizen of the Philippines.


“Motion denied. Same voting,” Sen. Vicente Sotto, one of the senators on the SET, told reporters in a text message after the tribunal’s meeting at a hotel in Pasay City.

Sen. Loren Legarda, a member of the SET, said the decision came in just one minute, with the members keeping their Nov. 17 votes to reject David’s contention that Poe should be considered stateless because she was a foundling.


Poe was abandoned in a church in Jaro, Iloilo province, shortly after birth in 1968.  She was later adopted by the late movie actor Fernando Poe Jr. and his wife, movie actress Susan Roces.

 ‘It only took a minute’

She is now the favorite candidate for President in next year’s presidential election, leading Vice President Jejomar Binay, administration candidate Mar Roxas, Davao City Mayor Rodrigo Duterte and Sen. Miriam Defensor-Santiago in the polls.

“There was no change. We almost did not talk about it. There was no more voting. It took a minute,” Legarda said.

She said the members of the tribunal had a longer discussion about the United Nations arbitral tribunal’s recently concluded proceedings on the Philippines’ petition to invalidate China’s claim to almost the entire South China Sea.

“Our discussions were exciting because we talked about international law,” Legarda said.

On Nov. 17, Senators Sotto, Legarda, Cynthia Villar, Pia Cayetano and Paolo Benigno “Bam” Aquino voted to throw out David’s petition to oust Poe from the Senate.


Sen. Nancy Binay, a daughter of the Vice President, joined the three Supreme Court associate justices on the tribunal—Teresita Leonardo-de Castro, Arturo Brion and Antonio Carpio—in the vote against Poe.

The case decided by the SET is separate from the four cases in the Commission on Elections (Comelec) seeking to disqualify Poe from the race for Malacañang.

Poe’s camp thanked the SET for the favorable ruling.

“Senator Poe is grateful to the SET members for continuing to uphold the rights of foundlings, Valenzuela City Mayor Rex Gatchalian, a spokesperson for Poe, said in a statement.

Gatchalian said the SET ruling was “a clear indication that Senator Poe is a natural-born Filipino.”

“In the coming days, we hope the Comelec does the same and upholds the rights of foundlings,” he said.

Long legal battle

Poe’s running mate, Sen. Francis Escudero, also welcomed the SET ruling, but said the camp expected a long legal battle over the legality of Poe’s candidacy.

“There’s no Plan B, C, D or E. There’s only one plan,” Escudero told reporters in Iloilo City.

He said only the Supreme Court could rule with finality on a disqualification case against a candidate.

The filing of cases against Poe is meant to weaken her candidacy, he added.

“Even if they (the petitioners) lose, at least they have made it difficult for [her] or at least they have made voters doubt if she is qualified or not,” he said.

Poe’s supporters planned to hold a rally in front of the Comelec office in Iloilo today to protest the Comelec Second Division’s decision on Tuesday to disqualify her from next year’s elections on grounds that she did not meet the 10-year residency requirement for presidential candidates.

Bayan Muna Rep. Neri Colmenares, a senatorial candidate on Poe’s ticket, said the protest would be joined by groups and individuals supporting Poe’s fight for the rights of abandoned children.

No new issues raised

In a brief interview, Carpio said David’s motion for reconsideration carried no new issues for deliberation.

“No new issues were raised. We just affirmed our own votes,” said Carpio, the SET chair who held that Poe “failed to prove that she is a natural-born Filipino citizen.”

Carpio said the justices who voted against Poe would inhibit themselves from the case once it reached the Supreme Court.

“We cannot take part in the review of our own decision. So we will have to inhibit (ourselves), the three of us, when this goes to the Supreme Court, if this is brought to the Supreme Court,” Carpio said.


Not political decision

Thursday’s ruling rejected David’s claim that the majority vote was a political decision.

“Indeed, aside from ascribing unfounded and baseless ill and improper motives to the senator-members who composed the majority and citing some opinion columns and tabloid reports that carry no evidentiary weight whatsoever, petitioner utterly failed to present any new issue or arguments that would warrant a reversal of

Nov. 17, 2015 decision of the tribunal,” the SET said in its resolution.

On the minute resolution, Carpio wrote over his signature: “I reiterate my dissenting opinion.”

De Castro wrote the same over her signature.

Brion and Binay both wrote over their signatures: “I reiterate my dissenting vote.”

David’s lawyer Manuelito Luna said the petitioner would raise the case to the Supreme Court early next week.

In a statement, Luna expressed confidence that the senators who voted in Poe’s favor would be “shamed” when the Supreme Court ruled on the case.

“We’re expecting it since the majority doesn’t know how to read the Constitution. On Monday or Tuesday, [we will file a petition for] certiorari in the Supreme Court, where they will be reversed and shamed for grave abuse of discretion,” he said.

Lerias doctrine

He asserted David’s position that the ruling was in violation of the Supreme Court’s ruling in a 1991 case, in which the court warned lawmakers who served on electoral tribunals against making political decisions in electoral challenges brought before them.

“They (senators) violated the Lerias doctrine,” Luna said.

The doctrine stemmed from the Supreme Court’s ruling in a case that Rosette Lerias filed against the House of Representatives Electoral Tribunal and Roger Mercado, her rival for the Southern Leyte congressional seat at the time.

In that decision, the Supreme Court warned politicans against making political decisions on electoral protests, saying “they must resolve election controversies with judicial, not political, integrity.” With reports from Marlon Ramos in Manila; and Nestor P. Burgos Jr. and Carla P. Gomez, Inquirer Visayas


Comelec disqualifies Grace Poe

Grace Poe all smiles after SET junks disqualification case

Poe on disqualification cases: ‘DQ pa more’

Read Next
Don't miss out on the latest news and information.

Subscribe to INQUIRER PLUS to get access to The Philippine Daily Inquirer & other 70+ titles, share up to 5 gadgets, listen to the news, download as early as 4am & share articles on social media. Call 896 6000.

TAGS: citizenship, disqualification case, Elections 2016, foundling, Grace Poe, natural-born citizen, Poe, Presidential Election, Rizalito David, Senate Electoral Tribunal, SET
For feedback, complaints, or inquiries, contact us.

News that matters

By providing an email address. I agree to the Terms of Use and
acknowledge that I have read the Privacy Policy.

© Copyright 1997-2021 | All Rights Reserved

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By continuing, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. To find out more, please click this link.