Inside Baguio public market, calls vs ‘mallification’ ring loud

Even before sunrise breaks over the pine-lined skyline, the Baguio City Public Market is already awake—the clang of metal shades, the sound of slippers, and the voice of vendors convincing people to buy create a rhythm as familiar to the city’s everyday chill.
However, since 2020, when most Filipinos were struggling with the COVID-19 crisis that killed thousands and triggered an economic standstill, a louder, more exigent sound has started to fill the market’s aisles—one that comes from local vendors fearing a future they do not want—the “mallification” of the central market.
READ: Baguio vendors want to lead market upgrade
Sonny Benedicto, president of one market section, told INQUIRER.net that they oppose a “corporate takeover” because “it is still better for the local government to redevelop this in a way that it is still a public market, not something that is centered on having a mall close to it.”

“That will create competition,” he said, pointing out that if this will be the case, they would certainly lose. “The products sold in the mall would compete with what we sell here in the market. There’s already a mall at Luneta Hill, and it is already a big one,” he stressed.
For him, who has been a vendor at the public market for 30 years already, there is no need to build a mall at the heart of the city, which draws steady crowds of locals and tourists who weave through its aisles for fresh farm products, low-priced commodities, and native specialties.
Christian Dave Ruz, an activist based in Baguio City and local coordinator for Koalisyong Makabayan, had explained that the market rehabilitation has been a discussion for years and that back in 2019, the local government reignited the proposal and created a TWG, or Technical Working Group.
READ: Market on the brink: Can Baguio folk save a vibrant legacy?
Eventually, the TWG presented in a public consultation a redevelopment proposal that was initially set to be financed through loans, with the Baguio City Council stating that the rehabilitation of the public market will not be through PPP, or Public-Private Partnership.
As pointed out by the Tongtongan ti Umili, a local network of CSOs in Baguio City, the PPP option entered the discussion in 2020, when both Robinsons Land Corporation and SM Prime Holdings (SMPH) sent their unsolicited proposals to redevelop the over 100-year-old market.
Soon enough, SMPH was given the Original Proponent Status.
But as Ruz said, market vendors and the people of Baguio City remained consistent from day one—“Yes to development! No to mallification,” with the Tongtongan ti Umili stressing that the local government, “by fixating on the need for a one-shot, large-scale redevelopment,” missed a chance to scale down the project to a more feasible and sustainable one.
READ: Baguio Market isn’t your usual ‘palengke’
“This lack of strategic foresight has pushed the government into a corner, where it now leans heavily towards the PPP model as the only viable option, primarily banking on the claim that ‘the city cannot afford it’,” considering that the rehabilitation is expected to cost P4.5 billion.
The proposal, through a lease agreement, will have SMPH finance and construct a mall and a new public market at no cost to the local government, with the public market comprising 70 percent of the area, while the rest, 30 percent, will be occupied by the mall with a parking lot.
Baguio City Mayor Benjamin Magalong previously addressed concerns, saying that the public market will not be privatized because it will be “exclusively managed and operated by the city” and that “all the revenues from the market operation will go to the city.”
However, Baguio City Budget Officer Leticia Clemente stated that based on the latest design and estimates, 48 percent of the land area is allocated for commercial and parking managed by SMPH, and 52 percent is designated for the public market area which will continue to be owned and managed by the local government.
As she explained, it will only be after 50 years that the rest of the redevelopment—the commercial and parking areas—will be turned over to the LGU, which is expecting the redevelopment of the public market to be completed by 2032 because the construction, it said, would take two to two and a half years.

For 57-year-old Benedicto, the market should be rehabilitated by the local government so that there will no longer be a need for a private corporation to construct and manage a mall at the heart of the city, saying that “people might even get tired of malls because down in the lowlands, they already have a lot of malls.”
“So when they come here in Baguio City, what will they see? Mall again?” he said.
“What will they even sell? There will really be competition,” Benedicto stressed, pointing out that if they end up being attached to a mall, they will certainly lose. “Here in the public market, people can buy inexpensive goods. They can buy in small quantities, and those budgeting their money can stretch it here—they can haggle.”
Last Sept. 12, Magalong’s office sent a proposal, approved by the City Development Council, to the Baguio City Council for deliberations. They have 120 days to decide whether to agree or not to the proposal, or probably, negotiate again on the rehabilitation of the public market./tsb