‘Motivated by desire to serve’: Guanzon didn’t commit crime in leaking vote vs Marcos, says law dean

Guanzon Marcos comelec

Comelec Commissioner Rowena Guanzon, who is also retiring in February. PHOTO COURTESY OF COMELEC

MANILA, Philippines — Commission on Elections (Comelec) commissioner Rowena Guanzon did not commit a crime in leaking her decision in favor of disqualifying Ferdinand “Bongbong” Marcos Jr., a lawyer said on Saturday.

Professor and dean of Far Eastern University-Institute of Law Mel Sta. Maria said Guanzon did not violate the Article 154 of the Revised Penal Code (RPC) which stated that any person who maliciously publish or cause to be published any official resolution or document without proper authority, or before they have been published officially shall be punished by arresto mayor.

“Commissioner Guanzon surely is a very daring public officer.  Some may criticize her for what she did in her revelation BUT I believe she did not commit any crime,” Sta. Maria said in a Facebook post.

Guanzon, who serves as the presiding commissioner of the Comelec’s First Division that handles the three consolidated cases to stop Marcos Jr.’s presidential bid, revealed in a television interview on Thursday that she voted to disqualify the son and namesake of the late dictator.

READ: Guanzon leaks her vote disqualifying Bongbong Marcos

Sta. Maria noted that Guanzon’s revealing of her vote via television or radio will not count as publishing as contemplated by RPC, adding that a “dissenting opinion” is not a document and a resolution to be released by proper authority.

The lawyer also pointed out that there is no law prohibiting the release of a dissenting opinion if a majority opinion has not yet been published.

“IF at all, it is only a long-followed tradition, but not a law,” Sta. Maria noted.

Sta. Maria also said that while some would say that Guanzon’s move may be “imprudent”, it could not be equated to malice.

“She was motivated by a desire to serve the public as far as she is concerned, a matter of national interest,” the lawyer added.

Sta Maria’s legal opinion differs from that of veteran election lawyer Romulo Macalintal, who said that Guanzon could be liable for prematurely revealing her vote to disqualify Marcos Jr.

READ: Macalintal says Guanzon liable for revealing vote to disqualify Bongbong Marcos


Guanzon to Bongbong Marcos camp: How do you know I had ‘minority opinion’ on DQ cases?


Subscribe to our daily newsletter

Success! You have been subscribed!
Oops! Something went wrong and you could not be subscribed

By providing an email address. I agree to the Terms of Use and acknowledge that I have read the Privacy Policy.