Recto to DBM: Restore budget cut on DOH

04:57 AM September 30, 2019

MANILA, Philippines — Senate President Pro Tempore Ralph Recto on Sunday urged the Department of Budget and Management (DBM) to stop treating public spending like an “accounting ledger” and open its eyes to the people’s needs.

The Senate leader issued the call as he moved for the reinstatement of the P10-billion reduction in the infrastructure budget of the Department of Health (DOH) for its Health Facilities Enhancement Program (HFEP) for 2020.


Iloilo Rep. Janette Garin, a House senior deputy minority leader, earlier protested the decision of the executive department to slash the DOH’s proposed outlay next year.

According to Recto, Congress has allocated P15.9 billion for HFEP for 2019, but this is dramatically reduced to P5.9 billion in the latest budget proposal submitted by the DBM.


“The [HFEP] is the cure to the inadequate and dilapidated facilities of public hospitals,” he said in a statement.

“But how much did the DBM recommend for HFEP in 2020? P5.9 billion. It was cut by two-thirds. It is the budgetary equivalent of cutting the calorie intake of a malnourished child,” he added.


Recto earlier disclosed that the DOH and Philippine Health Insurance Corp. were shortchanged in the government’s proposed P4.1-trillion spending program for 2020 by about P28.3 billion in their share of the sin tax collection.

As mandated by Republic Act No. 11346, he said the new tax law specifically allotted for health services 50 percent of all collections from the excise tax on sin and soda products.

Recto said the DBM should not invoke underspending as an excuse to reduce the budget of the DOH for HFEP.

Hospital equipment


He pointed out that many of the items to be purchased under the program were hospital equipment regarded as “off-the-shelf items” that could be procured easily.

Others, he added, were allocated for hospitals managed by local governments, many of which were set to get just P500,000 for new equipment.

“At this level of funding, the usual ‘absorptive capacity’ excuse cannot be invoked. Even doubling the amount will not make procurement work twice as hard,” Recto argued.

He said the government should prepare a budget based on what the people need. “It cannot be reduced to a spreadsheet exercise, lifted from a foreign-funded budgeting manual.”

Ahead of schedule

On Sept. 20, the House passed the 2020 budget bill two weeks ahead of schedule after President Duterte certified it as urgent and did away with the three-day notice rule between second and third reading.

Instead of introducing amendments in plenary session, however, the House formed a “small committee” to accept proposed changes to the budget after it was already approved on third reading, a process questioned by the senators.

The House defended the move, noting that with 300 members, there wouldn’t be enough time to deliberate on all the amendments.

P10B realigned

The small committee, according to House leaders, realigned about P10 billion worth of funding to augment the budgets of national agencies for health, agricultural and educational programs.

The money was to be taken from the allocations for the scheduled 2020 barangay elections, which Congress plans to postpone, as well as unused right-of-way payments.

Rift, pork

In a troubling sign for the 2020 budget, the rift between the Senate and the House of Representatives grew wider over the weekend, as three more deputy speakers entered the fray to lob attacks against two “obstructionist” senators.

Deputy Speakers Henry Oaminal, Pablo John Garcia and Deogracias Victor Savellano issued a statement on Sunday accusing Senators Panfilo Lacson and Franklin Drilon of derailing the President’s reform programs with unfounded accusations of pork insertions in the 2020 general appropriations bill (GAB).

Lacson has taken to task members of the House for their supposed plan to set aside P1.5 billion for each of the 22 deputy speakers and P700 million for every district representative. The senator later claimed that the plan was shelved after he made it public.

Savellano, a representative of Ilocos Sur, laughed off Drilon’s claim of possible irregularities in the House approval of the 2020 budget, recalling that the Senate minority leader had “benefited” from pork funds in the previous administration.

“Senator Drilon, let’s respect one another. Please refrain from prejudging and criticizing us without basis because your statements might boomerang on you,” he said.

As for Lacson, Savellano appealed to the senator not to try to score political points at the expense of the House or to use baseless allegations “in aid of his election.”

Oaminal, of Misamis Occidental, said the GAB was aligned with the administration’s reform initiatives and, thus, is “free of any ‘pork’ or ‘insertions’ and does not allow any ‘parking’ of funds.”

In a radio interview on Sunday, Sen. Juan Edgardo Angara said the Senate would not allow pork items and lump-sum appropriations for legislators in the proposed expenditure program for 2020. —Reports from Marlon Ramos and DJ Yap

Read Next
Don't miss out on the latest news and information.
View comments

Subscribe to INQUIRER PLUS to get access to The Philippine Daily Inquirer & other 70+ titles, share up to 5 gadgets, listen to the news, download as early as 4am & share articles on social media. Call 896 6000.

TAGS: 2020 health budget, 2020 national budget, DBM, DoH, Janette Garin, Ralph Recto
For feedback, complaints, or inquiries, contact us.

© Copyright 1997-2020 INQUIRER.net | All Rights Reserved

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By continuing, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. To find out more, please click this link.