Ramming of PH vessel intentional or accident? Boat captain now unsure

/ 09:18 PM June 19, 2019
Ramming of PH vessel intentional or accident? Boat captain now unsure

AFLOAT AGAIN Fishermen inspect the damage to the FB Gem-Vir 1, which was salvaged by Philippine Navy divers after it sank on June 9 in the West Philippine Sea. —PHILIPPINE COAST GUARD PHOTO

MANILA, Philippines — Far from a fishing boat captain who was so certain that their boat was deliberately rammed by a Chinese vessel in the West Philippine Sea, Junel Insigne, after meeting Agriculture Secretary Emmanuel “Manny” Piñol on Wednesday, seemed to now doubt his own account of what happened to them last June 9.

Piñol arrived in Occidental Mindoro to meet with the 22 fishermen, who were abandoned by the Chinese vessel in the open sea after the ramming incident.


During the subsequent press briefing, Insigne was asked if he still believes the ramming of their boat at Recto (Reed) Bank was intentional.

“Naguguluhan po ako eh,” Insigne replied after a long pause while he bowed his head. “Parang binangga, parang sinadya, parang hindi rin eh.”


“‘Yun po talaga ang sinadya nila, ‘yung pag-iwan nila sa amin,” Insigne added. 

READ: Captain of sunken PH boat: ‘The Chinese did it’

READ: China fishing vessel sinks Filipino boat after ‘collision’ in West Philippine Sea

READ: Piñol: Filipino crewman says Recto Bank incident ‘could be unintentional’

According to Piñol, the fishermen could also not agree whether or not their boat, Gem-Vir 1, was deliberately rammed.

“Kanina sa pag-uusap namin, they came up with a position. Number one, hindi nila matukoy ‘yung intentional o accidental ang pangyayari sapagkat ayon kay Richard Blaza, posibleng hindi sila nakita nung barko ng Intsik. Ayon naman sa bang tripulante, posible intentional,” Piñol said. 

Piñol added the Filipino fishermen also “agreed” that Blaza offers the most credible story since he was the only one awake before the impact. 


“The Recto Bank 22 agree that Richard Blaza offers the most reliable and credible testimony on what actually transpired moments before the impact, being the only crew member who was awake,” he noted.

Asked if the testimony of the other fishermen, aside from Blaza, would still be used in the investigation, Piñol said: “The statements of other fishermen as to what transpired after the impact would be of material importance to the inquiry.”

“But as to the events prior to the impact, because isa lang ang gising, si Richard Blaza lang, sa kanya ang pinaka-credible na statement,” he added. 

Presidential Spokesperson Salvador Panelo earlier took note of the conflicting statements of Insigne and Blaza. 

“Kaya kailangan imbestigahan na talaga natin. Formal inquiry na kailangan dito,” Panelo said in a Palace briefing on Tuesday. 

“Kasi parang may conflict ‘yung kapitan at ‘yung cook. Kasi tingin ng kapitan, sinadya. Tingin ng cook, mukhang hindi [sila] nakita,” Panelo also said. 

READ: Conflicting accounts of boat sinking will cast doubt on PH fishermen — Palace

The 22 fishermen were left afloat for hours in the open sea after the incident. A Vietnamese vessel was able to rescue them on June 10.

Apology to Duterte

Insigne likewise apologized to President Rodrigo Duterte for mistakenly believing that he was invited to the Palace for a meeting.

Insigne said he learned it was Piñol who wanted to meet with them in Manila.

“Humihingi po ako ng pahumanhin sa ating mahal na Presidente, na hindi po pala ako pinatawag, si Secretary Piñol po ang nagpatawag sa amin. Hindi po ako nakatuloy, umatras po ako dahil masama po ‘yung pakiramdam ko,” Insigne said. (Editor: Katherine G. Adraneda)

Read Next
Don't miss out on the latest news and information.
View comments

Subscribe to INQUIRER PLUS to get access to The Philippine Daily Inquirer & other 70+ titles, share up to 5 gadgets, listen to the news, download as early as 4am & share articles on social media. Call 896 6000.

TAGS: China, Conflict, Diplomacy, EEZ, Foreign relations, Gem-Vir 1, Junel Insigne, Local news, Manny Piñol, maritime dispute, Nation, national news, news, Philippine news updates, Philippines, Recto Bank, Reed Bank, Richard Blaza, West Philippine Sea
For feedback, complaints, or inquiries, contact us.

© Copyright 1997-2020 INQUIRER.net | All Rights Reserved

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By continuing, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. To find out more, please click this link.