Sual trafficking victims: Where’s justice for us? | Inquirer News

Sual trafficking victims: Where’s justice for us?

Men lured to fish farm express shock at dismissal of case vs Chinese, Taiwanese tormentors
By: - Correspondent / @joeygabietaINQ
/ 05:57 AM August 04, 2018

GOVERNMENT PRESENCE The village government office at Barangay 96 launched an information drive against trafficking. —JOEY GABIETA


There were no easy answers to the questions asked by Eli, 20, a resident of a village here called Barangay 96, when told that the human trafficking case against their tormentors had been dismissed.


Eli was among 27 men and four boys recruited at Barangay 96 here to work at a fish farm in Sual town, Pangasinan.

When someone promised him P5,000 a month just to feed fish, Eli’s eyes lit up.


He was earning barely P150 a day driving a contraption called tricycle.

On July 11, Eli, whose real name was being withheld upon the request of the city’s social welfare office, headed to Sual with his fellow recruits.

Horror stories

Eight days later, on July 19, they were back at Barangay 96 with horror stories about the fish farm where, monitored by armed guards, they were not only deprived of the pay that was promised them but were also made to stay in quarters they had likened to pigsties and given foul-smelling food.

Their rescue on July 19 by the National Bureau of Investigation with the help of city social welfare workers raised hope that the trafficked men and boys would at least get justice, if not the money that was promised them.

But on July 25, the group’s tormentors—Taiwanese Tse-Yu Tai and Chinese nationals Chi Chang Ho and Xi Ping Ho—were ordered freed by the Pangasinan provincial prosecutor’s office, which described the July 19 rescue operations as “unreasonable.”

“Really, it was dismissed? said Eli, told of the release of the foreigners and the junking of the trafficking case against them.


LESSON LEARNED Eli, one of 32 victims of human trafficking at Barangay 96, returns to his old job—driving a tricycle.

Call for justice

“What will happen to us now?” he said. “All we want is for us to be given justice,” said Eli, visibly shocked.

Another victim, Jerome, 20, also expressed dismay at the dismissal of the case.

“All we want is justice,” Jerome said. He wondered aloud if the dismissal would affect the case being readied by Tacloban officials.

In Barangay 96, with a population of less than 7,000, it’s easy to see why residents would fall for scams, like being recruited to work in a fish farm being run by foreigners and be treated worse than the fish.

Most residents are jobless while some operate retail stores with barely any earnings, work as house helpers or sales persons elsewhere with meager pay or, like Eli, drive a tricycle.

Eli fell for glib-tongued recruiters.


The promised P5,000 monthly pay became just P3,500 with a deduction of P200 for every absence.

The recruits were forced out of bed as early as 5 a.m. and made to work until 10 p.m. Work continues under the heat of the sun or rains.

“We were told that we will work in a Boracay-like beach,” Eli said.

“Of course, aside from the promised good pay, the mere mention of Boracay made us excited,” he added.

Eli and Jerome, like the other victims, said they were determined to seek justice for what was done to them.

“By winning our case, these recruiters and these Chinese nationals will be stopped in continuing their unlawful practice against people like us who only dream of good and decent jobs,” Eli said.

Both said they had already executed affidavits detailing their harrowing experience in the Sual fish farm and which the city police would use to file criminal complaints.

Solid evidence

Carmela Bastes, of the City Social and Development Office, had said the affidavits were “solid evidence.”

The recruits left the city on board two vans with markings of one of the country’s leading TV networks and “Red Cross” to avoid suspicion.

When the NBI raided the Sual fish farm on July 19, Eli said the Chinese and Taiwanese bosses were no longer around and hid.

He said the workers knew two of the foreigners only as “Boss Ayong” and “Boss Aris.”

Boss Ayong was the crueler of the two, according to Eli. The Chinese would cuss at the Filipinos for no reason at all.

Information drive

Jocelyn Rosales, Barangay 96 chair, said officials had launched an information campaign as a result of the trafficking case with the help of Plan Philippines, a nongovernment organization.

“Most of our villagers here are really poor and could easily be encouraged to work outside Tacloban City with a promise of good pay,” Rosales said.

“That is why we have now a massive information campaign here in the village against trafficking and they should inform us if there is someone encouraging them to work outside the city,” Rosales said.

Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.

Subscribe to our daily newsletter

By providing an email address. I agree to the Terms of Use and acknowledge that I have read the Privacy Policy.

Read Next
Don't miss out on the latest news and information.

Subscribe to INQUIRER PLUS to get access to The Philippine Daily Inquirer & other 70+ titles, share up to 5 gadgets, listen to the news, download as early as 4am & share articles on social media. Call 896 6000.

TAGS: China, Fishermen, Sual
For feedback, complaints, or inquiries, contact us.
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.

News that matters

By providing an email address. I agree to the Terms of Use and acknowledge that I have read the Privacy Policy.

© Copyright 1997-2023 | All Rights Reserved

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By continuing, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. To find out more, please click this link.