Latest Stories

SC junks doctor’s P100-M lawsuit vs Makati hotel


MANILA, Philippines—A woman-doctor’s 17-year demand for P100 million in damages from a Makati City hotel for a recurring brain injury she allegedly suffered through the years after she hit her head inside the hotel has ended after the Supreme Court (SC) dismissed her claim for lack of merit.

The high court’s Second Division threw out Dr. Genevieve Huang’s appeal on the earlier rulings of the Court of Appeals and the Makati Regional Trial Court which both dismissed her claim for damages for lack of merit in 2006 and 2007, respectively.

“This court examined the records, including the transcripts of stenographic notes, and found no reason to disturb the factual findings of both lower courts. This court, thus, upholds their conclusiveness,” the high tribunal said in the decision penned by Justice Jose Perez.

Justices Arturo Brion, Presbitero Velasco Jr., Martin Villarama Jr. and Estela Perlas-Bernade concurred in the decision.

In August 1996, Huang filed a complaint for damages in the Makati Regional Trial Court against Dusit Thani’s owners, Philippine Hoteliers Inc. and Dusit Thani Public Co. Ltd, as well as the hotel’s insurer, First Lepanto Taisho Insurance Corp.

Court records showed that in June 1995, Huang and a friend had just finished swimming at the hotel pool and were showering when the lights were switched off, plunging the area into darkness. She said they walked carefully to the main door leading out of the pool area but found the door locked.

While looking for a house phone in the dark, Huang spotted one behind the lifeguard’s counter. She said she was walking toward it when she hit her head on a wooden folding countertop, which almost knocked her unconscious.

Huang’s friend called for assistance, and hotel staff brought Huang to the coffee shop.

After arriving home, Huang said she experienced “extraordinary dizziness” and stomach problems for two days, and had headaches for three days. She consulted a neurologist who detected bruising in her head using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and told her she had a very serious brain injury. Two other doctors she consulted came up with similar findings.

After filing the damage suit, Huang went to the United States for further medical treatment. The Mount Sinai Hospital made a similar diagnosis and prescribed her medication for severe pain and made her undergo physical therapy. Her condition, however, did not improve so she went back to the Philippines. She consulted her previous doctors who all advised her to continue her medications and undergo therapy.

In 1996, Huang said the vision in her right eye began to deteriorate and, in 1999, she began experiencing severe fleeting pains in her head, arms and legs; difficulty in concentrating and felt a warm sensation in the legs. The last doctor she consulted concluded that she had a post-traumatic or post-concussion syndrome, an indication of a permanent damage in the brain.

Self-serving testimony

The RTC, however, gave more credence to the defense of the respondents, particularly hotel staff who contradicted Huang’s version of events. The trial court found the petitioner’s testimony “self-serving, thus devoid of credibility,” noting that it was through her own neglect and carelessness that she suffered the injury.

The RTC faulted Huang for failing to present any evidence to substantiate her allegation that the lights in the hotel’s pool area were shut off at the time of the incident. The judge noted that Huang did not present her friend to corroborate her testimony. All the doctors whom Huang consulted, except the last one, also were not presented to the court.

One hotel staffer said he told Huang and her friend to take their showers soon as the pool would be closing by 7 p.m. Another said the pool area was not really dark as Huang claimed, because the lights from a nearby gym overlooking the pool were still on.

The hotel nurse and doctor also testified that Huang told them she was OK and that being a doctor, she knew her condition.

The Supreme Court also agreed with the findings of the RTC and the Court of Appeals that there was no indication that Huang’s head injury was the result of the hotel incident.

The high court noted the RTC’s findings that Huang admitted to suffering different “brain problems” since she was 18 years old and these may have been the cause of her current problems. The court also learned that Huang once fell from a horse, suffered a stroke and had a blood disorder, among other ailments.

Follow Us

Follow us on Facebook Follow on Twitter Follow on Twitter

Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Tags: concussion , Dr. Genevieve Huang , Dusit Thani Hotel , Makati City , Makati Regional Trial Court , Supreme Court

Copyright © 2014, .
To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.
Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:
c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94
  1. Kim Henares needs a reprimand, says Cayetano
  2. ‘No real progress in PH if dynasties not dismantled’
  3. More legal woes for Cedric Lee
  4. Massive infra spending set
  5. OFW brings MERS virus to Philippines
  6. DOJ to NBI: Arrest Cedric Lee, 4 others
  7. Cardinal Tagle to faithful: Join politics to clean it
  8. Estrada, Gigi Reyes denied access to evidence from other respondents
  9. Lacson’s wife loses diamond earring to thieves but recovers jewelry quickly with police arrest
  10. DOJ orders arrest of Cedric Lee
  1. Suspect in Vhong Navarro mauling tries to leave PH
  2. MH370 co-pilot made mid-flight phone call – report
  3. Netizens cry: 6/55 Lotto was rigged
  4. I’ll follow my conscience on Estrada, says JV Ejercito
  5. ‘Wife of Jesus’ theory papyrus not fake – Harvard study
  6. Fr. Suarez says last Mass on Easter before returning donated land to San Miguel
  7. Gay college instructor arrested for oral sex with student
  8. ‘King’ Yabut and I: Driver bares Makati dad ‘abuses’
  9. It was difficult having Japanese blood
  10. Palace: We can’t blame increase in population on Vitangcol
  1. KL confirms Malaysian Airlines Flight MH370 ended in Indian Ocean
  2. MRT passengers pass the hat for 6-year-old Ashley
  3. Pork payoffs to newscasters Erwin Tulfo, Del Prado, others bared
  4. UP back on top as ‘average’ student aces bar
  5. Rookie, lady cops lauded for quick response to MOA heist
  6. Model Helena Belmonte wished ‘to slash her wrist and hope to die’
  7. Malaysia averts another air tragedy; pilot lands troubled plane safely
  8. Revilla says he was joking; Lacson stands by his story
  9. Revilla ‘consulted’ Lacson on how he evaded arrest
  10. Police rule out foul play in Helena Belmonte’s death as boyfriend is ‘traumatized’


  • Henares on Pacquiao bashing: I did not start this
  • Drilon, Nancy Binay urge Filipinos to strengthen faith
  • ‘Yolanda’ toll now at 6,300 – NDRRMC
  • ‘Mom, I love you,’ says text from student on sinking ferry
  • Moderate earthquake jolts southern Iran
  • Sports

  • Power Pinays smash India in Asian Women’s Club volleyball opener
  • PH youth boxers off to stumbling start in AIBA World tilt
  • Durant has 42, Thunder beat Pistons 112-111
  • Walker leads Bobcats over Bulls in OT, 91-86
  • Man City slips further out of title contention
  • Lifestyle

  • Pro visual artists, lensmen to judge Pagcor’s photo contest
  • ‘Labahita a la bacalao’
  • This is not just a farm
  • Clams and garlic, softshell crab risotto–not your usual seafood fare for Holy Week
  • Moist, extra-tender blueberry muffins
  • Entertainment

  • Will Arnett files for divorce from Amy Poehler
  • American rapper cuts own penis, jumps off building
  • Jay Z to bring Made in America music fest to LA
  • Why Lucky has not bought an engagement ring for Angel
  • Derek more private with new girlfriend
  • Business

  • World stocks subdued, Nikkei flat on profit taking
  • Asia stocks fail to match Wall Street gains
  • Fired Yahoo exec gets $58M for 15 months of work
  • PH presses bid to keep rice import controls
  • PSEi continues to gain
  • Technology

  • Netizens seething in anger over Aquino ‘sacrifice’ message
  • Filipinos #PrayForSouthKorea
  • Taylor Swift tries video blogging, crashes into fan’s bridal shower
  • DOF: Tagaytay, QC best at handling funds
  • Smart phone apps and sites perfect for the Holy Week
  • Opinion

  • Editorial cartoon, April 17, 2014
  • A humbler Church
  • Deepest darkness
  • ‘Agnihotra’ for Earth’s health
  • It’s the Holy Week, time to think of others
  • Global Nation

  • Syria most dangerous country for journalists, PH 3rd—watchdog
  • Japan says visa-free entry still a plan
  • First Fil-Am elected to Sierra Madre, Calif. city council
  • UC Irvine cultural night to dramatize clash of values in immigrant family
  • Filipino sweets and info served at UC Berkeley Spring Fest
  • Marketplace