Quantcast
pope ph

Corona wanted to help Arroyo escape–De Lima

By , |


WITNESS FOR THE PROSECUTION Justice Secretary Leila de Lima: If the Supreme Court intended to get a comment from us on Nov. 18 and set oral arguments on Nov. 22, why issue a TRO on Nov. 15? SENATE POOL

Should Chief Justice Renato Corona be removed from office in connection with a “collegial” Supreme Court resolution allowing former President and now Pampanga Representative Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo to seek medical treatment abroad last year?

A day after suffering a significant defeat on the third impeachment article, prosecutors on Wednesday began arguing their case that Corona betrayed the public trust “through his partiality” in granting temporary restraining order (TRO) in favor of Arroyo.

Justice Secretary Leila de Lima took the witness stand and detailed the circumstances surrounding the issuance of the TRO on November 15 last year and why she opted not to follow it and instead prevented the departure of Arroyo and her entourage that day.

“In my own appreciation of what happened, the developments, actions, what I read in the opinions, yes,” De Lima said when questioned by the chief defense counsel, Serafin Cuevas, if Corona wanted to help Arroyo escape.

She said the proof was the court order allowing the government only three days, instead of the standard 10 days, to respond to the November 15 temporary restraining order, and setting the oral arguments in a few days’ time.

“In the issuance of the TRO, it was November 15, and we were given a limited period to file a comment in three days, due on November 18, and then they set the oral arguments on November 22. That’s not common, sir. Normally the respondents are given a period of 10 days to file a comment, and after which, if the court so desires, we set the case for oral argument,” she said.

Irrelevant, impertinent

“If they intended to get a comment from us in three days, and they intended to hear us out in oral arguments, why issue the TRO on November 15?”

In one of his uncharacteristically few objections on Day 22 of the impeachment trial, Cuevas questioned the “relevance” of De Lima’s testimony.

He said it was “practically amending, criticizing the decision” of the high tribunal.

“It has nothing to do with the impeachment complaint against Chief Justice Corona,” he told the court, before reciting the charge contained in Article 7.

“Thus far, nothing has surfaced to this effect. What is being discussed, with due respect to the witness, are matters that are entirely irrelevant and impertinent,” he said.

Cuevas added: “We have been very tolerant in this matter because we were at a loss as to the real purpose of the introduction of the honorable secretary in connection with these matters.”

Senate President Juan Ponce Enrile, the presiding officer in the impeachment trial, noted the objection but allowed De Lima to continue her narration.

He was generally polite and accommodating of both the prosecution and De Lima, after he scolded prosecutors over their faulty articles of impeachment on Tuesday.

Enrile asked if De Lima knew of “any instance in this entire proceeding … when the respondent acted alone in issuing any order, any process or any resolution bearing on this particular instance.”

Dissenting opinion

De Lima said “no” but she asked the court to look into dissenting opinions in connection with the TRO, particularly that of Associate Justice Lourdes Sereno, President Benigno Aquino III’s first appointee to the high tribunal.

De Lima also cited Sereno’s account on how Corona purportedly tried to make it appear that Arroyo had complied with all the conditions set in the TRO.

The order was to take effect only if Arroyo and her husband would post a P2-million cash bond, appoint a legal representative, and report to the Philippine embassy or consulate in the country they were planning to visit.

De Lima referred to Sereno’s opinion revealing that the court, voting 7-6, had ruled that that the Arroyos did not comply with the second condition.

“They didn’t have to say if the TRO was suspended because it was clear, common sense, (to quote) one of the justices, that it was understood that because the TRO was subject to certain conditions pending compliance with those conditions, it cannot be considered as already effective,” said the justice secretary.

Cuevas, who allowed De Lima to talk at length without any interruption from the defense, later told the impeachment court: “There can be no restraining order on any decision that can come out without the majority participating therein, whether it’s an en banc decision or merely a decision in division.”

Enrile asked De Lima if her department would have allowed Arroyo to leave if all the conditions of the TRO were met.

“Maybe or maybe not,” she replied, “because my view is that the TRO was improper in the sense that a TRO… is supposed to preserve the status quo pending the disposition of the merits of the main petition.”

Majority decision

De Lima argued that the November 15 TRO “had the effect of rendering the disposition of the main petition illusory or ineffectual because it is as if you granted already the petition because the main issue really is—should we allow the former President to leave the country despite the pendency of these big cases against her.”

When asked by Cuevas if there was a conspiracy among justices that led to the issuance of the TRO, De Lima said:

“The conspiracy because they issued the questionable TRO? Well, the Chief Justice is only one vote of course when it comes to decisions. But there are other things, there are other duties, functions and powers of the Chief Justice as primus inter pares.”

Cuevas cut her off and said she was not responding to the question.

He then asked her: “This TRO could not have come into effect were it not for a fact that the majority of the court en banc decided to grant the same? It could not have been possible by the mere say so of Chief Justice Corona, is it not?” De Lima replied yes to both.

Cuevas followed up by asking her if the responsibility was shouldered then by all signatories to the TRO.

De Lima said: “If we talk only about voting, and the position with respect to the propriety of the TRO with eight of them concurring that TRO at the time was proper in their view… that’s their position as the majority, then yes.”


Follow Us


Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Tags: Benigno Aquino III , Corona Impeachment , impeachment trial , Judiciary , Leila de Lima , Politics , Renato Corona , Senate , Supreme Court


  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_JQBHSHS22G65Z6V5Z64XBRCIZQ simon

    SC is a passive branch of the government, meaning it does not initiate action, or it will make decision after it hears. In the case of TRO, why the SC issue such TRO without hearing the side of the government? Gusto lang ni CORONA na mag ala Ramona si GLORIA, para walang babagsakan ng subpoena.

    • pangitbudhiko

      a n application of a TRO filed in the supreme court must be acted upon without giving the other party a chance to the respondent.

      • AllaMo

        eeeng?!

      • Mark Suarez

        but the conditions must be fulfilled…

      • http://twitter.com/grandpaber mel bercel

        kaya pala sampu singko ngayon ang TRO. Kung may pambili ka ng TRO, makakakuha ka…paano naman kaming walang pambili ng TRO
        or worst case sa mga walang pambili, paano naman kaming walang connection sa supreme court?

      • marimalo

        you got it right, sapul na sapul mo.

      • scorpio15

        OO nga sampung singko nga ang TRO ngayon sa SC.Meron pang dagdag na posporo. Ang bibilis lumabas ang mga TRO ngayon. Akala mo parating Emergency between Life and Death.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_E5Q5PV6KNYNVSOCHXJVJPYUVFE cion

       Any TRO cannot be issued without the approval (votation) of the majority of the Justices of the Supreme Court . Each of them has only one and for De LIma to single out CJ Corona is purely her own suspicion or allegation along with the sitting president and their cohorts.

      • jurbinsky77

        The question here is: Why is it when Renato Corona became the chief justice, the SC has become lesser in stature. The decisions became very prediictable when it comes to Gloria Arroyo and then like a small chilfd playing head or tails when the question of city or not city. Its chief justice has become so active in gossip and character assssination. The .chief justice also broke so many laws of the land. First time in history, the chief justice became a millionaire in so short period of time.

    • michael_angelo

      Yan mga BAYARAN, Idebate nyo si sir SIMON… asan na kayo,,, ipalabas nyo na ang punto nyo !

  • Philhealth

    Kung pwede lang idaan na lang sa botohan kung may tiwala pa ang taong bayan sa korte suprema. Malamang tapos na ang usapang ito. Ang nagagawa talaga ng pera eh nabubulag ang katotohanan. Paano na kaming mahihirap ng laging naapi dahil walang perang pagsustento sa kasong hinaharap? Korte suprema na lang ang inaasahan para magkaroon ng katarungan, nauuwi na sa paghawak ng armas dahil kung wala ka pera, wala kang hustisya. sana ay bumalik ang ‘delikadesa’ na nawala sa mga hurado. Pera pera na nga lang ba talaga?

    • thunderbolt01

      Hintayin mo ang grand rally at makikita mo ang resulta kung sino ang mas nakakarami.

      • jeff964

        grand rally ng mga magnanakaw? we know for a fact sobrang dami talaga ng magnanakaw sa pilipinas

      • marimalo

        napakarami nila na corrupt at magnanakaw at mga nagbubulagbulagan sa katotohanan.

      • michael_angelo

        grand rally ng INC yan- Iglesia ni Corona… magsama sama kayong mga BOPALS

  • dongvee

    Sec. Delima herself noted that eight (8) of the supreme court justices concurred “that TRO at the time was proper in their view”, (kaya nag-vote sila in favor of its issuance) ang dami pala nila nag-“conspire” to favor a departure of GMA. Ngayon kung impeachable offense nga ito, bakit si CJ Corona lang binanatan? Ganoon na ba ngayon kawalang sariling pag-iisip at panindigan ang mga justices sa Supreme Court na pirma lang ng pirma kung ano yong pinapirma sa kanila ng Chief Justice? Naku naman. Sinong lulukohin nila ngayon?

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_AWGZY3FRXJBAWBZGRFDYD2RTPQ fred fredito alfred

      ang target talaga dito ay si GMA AND CORONA. bakit hindi lahat ng hurado na bumoto sa TRO???? selective ba si de lima???? may isip naman ang mga judges eh.di naman siguro padidikta kay corona. so ite seems, bengansa lang ito. o baka sipsip di si de lima sa amo niya.

    • BeMe_2

      obvious ba na walang sariling paninindigan? of course, they are Corona appointees… they are partisan to him. iyan nga ang issue kaya tarnished ang credibility ng SC. Bear in mind that Corona is the subject of this impeachment – part lang ito ng maraming alleged charges – that’s why sya ang nakasalang. The rest will be dealt with later.

    • jeff964

      mag antay ka lang. arroyo court yun kaya laging magkakasama sa botohan

      • marimalo

        sapul na sapul mo.

    • AllaMo

      Ganuon na nga.

  • http://twitter.com/grandpaber mel bercel

    Magnifico- Sec de Lima  for telling the truth
    Superb — Preosecution team for eliciting the truth
    Bravo —– Defense team for well crafted remarks and dilatory tactics…nice try

  • thunderbolt01

    Talo na naman si de Lima sa mga tanong ni Cuevas. Ang gusto kasi ni de Lima ay mas marunong pa siya sa mga Supreme Court Justices. Leila, isipin mo. Ikaw mag isa laban sa desisyon ng walong justices ibig mong palabasin na mas makatwiran at mas marunong ka kaysa sa kanila? Mahiya ka naman sa sarili mo. 

    • noli_semi07

      ang mga katulad mo na pag iisip pare ang dapat mahiya…

    • marimalo

      mabuhay ang mga corrupt at magnanakaw sa kaban ng bayan, mabuhay ang mga taong nagbubulagbulagan sa katotohanan.napakarami nila, kawawa ang bayan.

    • michael_angelo

      kung sabihin namin OO, maniwala ka kaya BAYARANG COMMENTATOR?

    • Rae_E

      I’d rather go for one person who’s morally discerning & fights in holding accountable those accused of fraud/corruption than 8 justices who only seek to protect their own interests & that of their appoint-er. Those who condone corruption are the bane of this country.

    • dgboy

       judge kaba sa korte? Sino ka para sabihin sino panalo at talo.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2GX7EP6HRDF3YTTQYXAZJ25534 loby

    Nais ng kampo ni CORONA na palabasin na ang kabuuan ng Korte Suprema ang nagpahintulot na bigyan ng TRO si Gloria para makaalis ng Pilipinas kahit na marami itong kinakaharap na mga kaso sa bayan.
    Ang malaking problema dito ngayon ay ang kredibilidad ng Korte Suprema bilang isang malayang institusyon na kumakatawan sa HUSTISYA ng bayan.Kung totoo nga na walang kinikilingan ang Korte Suprema, bakit sila gumawa ng paraan na makaalis ang isang taong may mabigat na kakaharaping kaso kapalit lamang ang salapi at mga kasulatang nangangakong babalik ang may sakdal.

    Ang sampung araw na proseso sa pagbigay ng TRO ay ginawang tatlong araw ng Korte Suprema na siyang dahilan kaya hindi agad nakapagbigay ng komento ang DOJ para tanggihan ito. Hindi ba ito ay lantarang pandaraya sa taong bayan?Sabi ng kampo ni Arroyo, nasa peligro ang buhay ni Gloria pero sinabi na mismo ng Kalihim ng Kagawaran ng Kalusugan na hindi ito totoo at kaya siyang gamutin ng mga doktor sa Pilipinas.

    Wala na ba talagang kredibilidad ang mga pinuno ng ating ahensya ngayon? Kung talaga ngang wala, eh di wag na tayong maglagay ng ahensya kung hindi man lang papaniwalaan ng taumbayan.

    Isa lang ang layon ni Gloria at iyon ay ang makatakas sa batas. Kahit bulag ang ating mata, alam nating ito ay malinaw na panlilinlang.

    Bilang Chief ng Korte Suprema, si CORONA ang dapat sumagot sa mga pangyayaring ito. Hindi maaaring gawing dahilan ang kabuuang desisyon ng lahat ng mga Justices para lang pagtakpan ang panlolokong ginawa sa ating HUSTISYA.

    Ako po ay hindi pumapanig sa depensa o prosekusyon. Nais ko po lamang, bilang isang Pilipino na sabihin ang aking sentimyento.Ayokong mauwi sa wala ang lahat na pagsisinungaling ng dating administrasyong Arroyo para takpan ang kanilang mga kasalanan. Helo Garci ( I am Sorry) at ang lahat ng mga naiwang iskandalo sa ZTE, Fertilizer Scam, Jose Pidal, Palparan at pagpatay sa mga pilipinong mamamahayag sa Ampatuan Massacre.

    Tulungan po nating mapanagot ang mga sumira sa ating bayan.

  • AllaMo

    If the honorable mentions of the supreme court are able to pass a law , making it legal exempting their SALNs from public scrutiny. If the honorable mentions of the supreme court are able to pronounce the, patently, Constitution flouting appointment to the office of chief justice as legal. If the honorable mentions of the supreme court are able to censure members of the bar, that renounce the plagiarism by one of the court’s own; It comes as no surprise that the honorable mentions of the supreme court are able to delude themselves into thinking that they have the right to live beyond accountability. After all, they were appointed. Honorable.

  • Oliver82

    galing.
     

  • Hey_Dudes

    If anyone in the country still do not take it to heart the only reason Renato C. Corona was appointed chief justice of the supreme court by the crook Gloria M. Arroyo  –  was to protect Gloria M. Arroyo, there is still time to trek to Mt. Banahaw to gather yourself.

  • http://www.facebook.com/Taning Tanya Gutang-Solis

    De Lima can’t be blamed.  She was only following the orders of her President.

  • rpjwarrior

    Blame Topacio for bungling Gloria’s last run to freedom. To “receive” pleadings (per SC order) and to “produce” pleadings (as appeared in Topacio’s submitted SPA) are entirely different, hence the  non-compliance of condition #2 of the TRO. No matter how friendly the pro-GMA justices are, they would not like to be accused of deficient English comprehension.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_GM34K3VEVOJ2CKWHOJUHNZAFBY dipakosigurado

    Kala ko magaling itong si De Lima….hehehe, hindi pala puwede kay Cuevas…!
    Forget your being a senator, it will not happen…kung anu-anong mga paratang, eh
    aaminin din palang collegial decision ang lahat ng hindi nila magustuhan,,,,sooo,
    why concentrate only on the CJ…?

    Buking na talaga! The prosecution is crumbling faster than a Goldilock’s polvoron cookie!

    • michael_angelo

      crumbling crumbling ka pa dyan, hay naku… nakaka bobo talaga

  • marimalo

    malinaw pa sa sikat ng araw na planado ang pagtakas ni mother of all buwaya na si former fake president gloria macapagal arroyo.sana hindi na dumami ang lahi nila sanlibo ng mga alipores niya.

  • pepengkabayo

    Corona wanted to help Arroyo escape–De Lima…..

    Bravo,Magnifico Ms. Leila De Lima.
    Ang galing mo talaga, ang galing mong sumagot.
    Kaya lang ang sagot mo PILOSOPO, walang basehan at wala sa libro.
    That is good Barbershop Argument.
    Your still indeed lucky because if your accusations really happened in Barbershop, labaha at gunting ang aabutin mo.
    Gupit militar ang aabutin mo.

    • michael_angelo

      Bat ikaw ano ang nagawa mong magaling sa bayan? kala mo matalino… BOBO

  • Atagalong

    Is there a provision in the criminal or civil procedures that mandates the Supreme Court to give the respondents 10 days for argument? What is a TRO? This is just a temporary restraining order, so it must be acted upon presto! E.g. the Supreme Court could issue a TRO to hold the execution of a criminal due to be “burned” that day. You wait 10 days, that criminal is already in deep 6! De Lima just disobeyed the order of the highest court of the land. In my opinion, she shoud be held in contempt of court.

    • michael_angelo

      In my Opinion, opinion ka pa… bat mahalaga ba ang Opinion mo sa BAYAN?

      Hay ang mga BAYARAN bow

    • Mark Suarez

      but the TRO is conditional and must be fulfiilled…

    • linusmonk

      Ganun nakitang kondisyon ni corona para agaran ilabas ang tro at makalabas ng bansa ang amo nya pero buking na ndi naman pla life threatening ang lagay ng unano puro drama at kasinungalingan

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/I2GCQ5T4QYVCGSRDCHFCVFBKJA Matrix

      You mean patakasin nalang dapat si GMA and the people will be denied of justice. You see, she tried to deceived us by using her physical condition, which is not life threatening according to the independent doctors who assess her, to leave and seek medical assistance abroad. Why leave when her ailments can be taken care of here in the philippines. Even some doctors said that they can do the operation here themselves. In fact until now she is still ok, proving that her condition is not really life threatening. Clearly ,her hidden motive is to escape from her accountability of her unlawful actions.

  • Beguine

    Nothing new.

    Replay,

    Going over hot news some months ago.

    Waste of time.

    De Lima could have summed up her statement in a couple
    of minutes.

    There was a blatant conspiracy in the majority-Gloria-Arroyo-appointed
    Supreme Court to accede to her wish to leave the country and
    flee from justice led by Renato Corona and seconded the motion
    by the rest of the Arroyo or Coronarroyo (coined word which gained
    a lot of currency) Supreme Court.

    It infuriated all walks of life, from the President to the man in the street
    and people began talking of impeaching the entire Corona-led justices for
    conspicupous miscarriage of justice and their duty to safeguard
    the justice system. They subverted it, they flexed their muscle,
    they erred huge, they deserve to be impeached.

    • michael_angelo

      Ang lalim mo tol, pero sa kabuuan ng mga INGLES mo, Bopals pa rin…

      ang mga BAYARAN talaga oo na…

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/JH4R5SKCQUTMZJJYZVOUYXL4L4/ t c

    “In my own appreciation of what happened, the developments, actions,
    what I read in the opinions, yes,” De Lima said when questioned by the
    chief defense counsel, Serafin Cuevas, if Corona wanted to help Arroyo
    escape.  WHAT ABOUT THE LAW? what is your interpretation of the law? Isn’t it your job as DOJ chief to implement the law and not your opinion?

    De Lima want the court and the people to give weight on the “dissenting” opinion only?.  Isn’t it what democracy is all about? to HEAR all dissenting opinion?

    But of course, a communist cannot understand and appreciate dissenting opinions.  They want full control and not objection nor opposition at all and worse, the communist will never accept anything that is not favorable to them.

    • michael_angelo

      Yung LAW mo sinasabi ay lawko lawko, katulad ng mga opinion mong BOPALS talaga…

      Pa appreciate appreciation ka pa, hay naku ang mga BAYARAN talaga oo na

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/JH4R5SKCQUTMZJJYZVOUYXL4L4/ t c

        My 3rd paragraph refers to you – michael_angelo.

      • michael_angelo

        wow pa refer refer ka pa ha… ano yan bagong style..

        Sge nga matanong kita kung matalino ka talaga… bigyan mo ako ng sampung dahilan na bakit karapat dapat si Corona as CJ…

        O sagutin mo yan ha, at wag kang umiwas, kung di mo makaya, irefer mo sa bayarang writer mo, saka copy paste mo ha…

        Naiintindihan mo ba BAYARAN?

      • michael_angelo

        nakalimiutan ko pala, pag nag post ka, pakilike mo na rin ha,,, para naman kapani paniwala….

      • michael_angelo

        bat ngayon 2 hours na ah, wala pang reply…

    • michael_angelo

      Damihan mo pa ang LIKE mo, para naman kapani paniwala… Lalim pa naman ng INGLES mo BAYARAN…

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/JH4R5SKCQUTMZJJYZVOUYXL4L4/ t c

        Why don’t you ask Noynoy to share you some of his medicine so it will calm your psycho attack.  Look at Noynoy, he is able to control his psycho attack because he is taking his medicine religiously so you don’t see the saliva on his mouth anymore.  And since he became President you’re not seeing the saliva on his mouth anymore because he now have people to wipe his mouth before he face the camera. LOL!

      • dnayellowkulayko

        bakit ba porket anti-Peanoy ‘eh bayaran??? nde porket ayaw namin ng diskarte ni Peanoy at lahat ng allies nya eh pro-GMA na .. tsk! kung fair play ang gusto nyo pakinggan dapat ang both side .. lumalabas ang asal nyo at makikita ang bayaran sa dami ng post! pakibilang nga post mo tsk!

    • dgboy

       Democracy is for the people and people wants some answers from Gloria.

  • kabayandinako

    In the first place, why did GMA want to go abroad for medical treatment, wherin she can avail of it in PH with the same expertise. On the other point, look at what happened to Iggy, he was being treated at London, what happened to him? On the other hand again how is the health condition of GMA? Kung pinayagang makaalis yan dahil sa tulong ni Corona, goodbye Philippines na. See you again if the President is no longer Pnoy.

  • thunderbolt01

    Nabubulagan ang karamihan ng mga yellows sa tunay na kuhulugan ng justice dahil bulag silang sumusunod sa bawat sabihin ng kanilang lider .Karapatan ni ginang Arroyo na magpagamot sa mga doktor na makapag papagaling sa kanya at yon ang pinagkaloob ng mga justices. Akusado pa lamang  siya at hindi pa napapatunayan ang kasalanan. A person is considered innocent until  proven guilty. Ang nangyayari ngayon sa Pilipinas ay wala ng hustisya dahil mismong presidente ay hindi hindi na iginagalang ang batas. kapag kapag hindi ka kakampi, ikaw ay makasalanan. Kapag kumampi ka sa kanya automatically malinis ka na. Patunay yan ng mga kakampi niya ngayon na puro may masasamang reputasyon. Kahit anong gawin ninyo ay hindi ma koconvict si corona dahil hindi tayo dapat mgakaroon ng diktador. Bawal sa Pilipinas ang diktador Si Corona lamang ang makakapigil sa kanya..

    • michael_angelo

      buhay na buhay naman ang mga BAYARAN ba…

    • Mark Suarez

      “Karapatan ni ginang Arroyo na magpagamot sa mga doktor na makapag papagaling sa kanya at yon ang pinagkaloob ng mga justices”

      life threatening nga daw kaya magpapagamot abroad..pero ngayon magaling na. muntik na tayo mauto sa life threatening excuses nya .pwede naman sya magpagamot sa pinas dahil hindi naman tlaga  life threatening sakit nya… kung nagktaon nakatakas for sure pinagtatawanan na nila ang mga tangang pilipino.

      • michael_angelo

        Hilot lang katapat dyan, pa ABROAD ABROAD pa… arte nya ah

      • dgboy

         sinong nagsabing life threatening? Abugado niya. Mgadoctor nga niya hindi naglabas ng ganong statment eh. At kung  life threatening, bakit buhay pa siya hanggang ngyon? Malamang kasi masamang damo siya.

      • Mark Suarez

        un nga life threatening na claim ng mga abugado nya para makatakas si pandak.e anong nangyari ngayon magaling na.kung nagkataon nga na nakatakas nauto tayong mga pilipino sa life threatening excuses nya.

  • lambug1

    Hindi lang ako pa English english pa. Nagkinig ako sa sinasabi ni De Lima. Mayroon palang Conspiracy Plot ang Corona at Gloria. Paagi sa cell phone silang dalawa nag-usap usap kung paano o kun kailan “tumakas” ang mga Arroyo. Pahehas din ito sa pag-cell phone ni Maldita kay Hello Garci. “HELLO RENATO! HELLO  RENATO… Nakaempake na kami ni Mr. kasama ang aming mga katabang (14 ka tao) naghahanap na kami ng mga Aeroplano… mukhang may vacant seats yata sa Singapore Airlines. Naka handa na ako magsu-ot ng “brace” para makita ng tao na-talaga maysakit ako… Ikaw ang bahala diyan baka harangin kami. Tutal nan diyan ang boyfriend ninyo (Midas 

    • http://twitter.com/robustgrowth robustgrowth

       hahahahaha nakaka tuwa naman

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_VYVO5BIPX6WO4IGFRGIQE3P6HY Ruben

      Ganoon din naman sina De Lima, SC Justice Sereno at Pnoy.  Three way calling sila.  Si Sereno ang nagbibigay ng balita kay De Lima at si De Lima naman ang nagre-report kay Pnoy.

      • michael_angelo

        bat ka sumali dito? outsider ka ah?

        Eto talagang mga BAYARAN mahilig magsingit, di naman iniinvite..

        Autistic ka ata iho?

      • http://twitter.com/grandpaber mel bercel

        cell pal si nato & glo. nagleak ng info si sereno kay de lima dahil may di magandang mangyayari. tumawag naman si de lima kay PNoy para ipalam sa boss niya ang kanyang hakbang. siempre ang boss ay dapat malaman ang mga gawain ng kanyang tauhan, kung mali sasabihin niya at ko tama ookayhan niya. what is wrong with that?  my question is why is nato & glo cell pal? tawa naman.

      • filipinaskoh

        because they are “soulmate”

      • dgboy

         Ang tanong sinong tatakas at sino ang guardiya?

      • jurbinsky77

        Guni-guni mo lang iyan Ruben.

  • JV Velarde

    This impeachment court should not be compared & should not be ran like a strict criminal trial court. It’s a political process with powers vested on the house & the senate, to remove a public servant immune from the ordinary course of the law. 

    The President, vice-president, senators, congressmen can be removed from office during elections, can even be subjected to impeachment, like the president & the vice president. And we have a chief justice who practically never had the nation’s democratic mandate, that can never be taken out of his position except when impeached. 

    Both congress, the House & the Senate, were never required nor mandated by the Constitution to have Lawyers as its members, so why insist on holding that impeachment court as a criminal trial court?

    The most relevant issue here is public trust & integrity, can this chief justice, after all the revelations, his exhaustive efforts to hide his dollar accounts & ill gotten wealth, can still be trusted? Corona was given due course to explain his side but he insisted on hiding behind the technicalities & circumvent the purpose of the law interpreting it to his selfish interest. 

    This impeachment process was mandated to protect the constitutional office from scalawags like Corona, it should be allowed to ran it’s real course.

  • pepengkabayo

    Corona wanted to help Arroyo escape–De Lima….

    This is the mind of De Lima, Corona wanted to help Arroyo escape that even Madam Auring with her paranormal mind cannot foretell the minds of the Chief Justice.
    On the other hand Arroyo wanted to escape, escape from what.
    She has all the reason, doctors diagnosis, Itinerary, Doctor’s appointment abroad, report on every Phil.Embassy.
    How about Mike, he was erased from travel ban but he stayed in the country. Iggy Arroyo is coming back to face accusers, even the children are in the P.I.
    Nothing will indicate that GMA wanted to escape. There was no motive or intent or run away.
    To accuse somebody must be supported by evidence not mere allegation.

    No arguments will overcome the TRO issued by the Supreme Court. It is a lawful order and should be followed, no matter what.
    And De Lima to accuse the Chief Justice of Conspiracy is a thicken plot in what we call
    Criminal Minds
    De Lima is just in the State of paranoia to disregard the Lawful order of the court.

    • michael_angelo

      Ikaw ata ang na PARANOIA na? bisitahan mo na lang si GMA sa kulungan , mas mabuti pa kesa comment ka ng comment ng walang kwenta iho….

      • pugadlawin21

        Shut up, yan ba ang instruction sa iyo ng handlers mo, basta kumontra ka lang ng kumontra sa lahat basta against Panot may minimum wage ka na. Ikaw siguro ang pinakamababa ang rate sa yellow zombies. Kasi tanga at bobo ka eh, para ka lang parrot na uulitin mo ang sinabi ng iba. Kawawa ka naman. Gusto mo ng kape at biscuit?

      • michael_angelo

        Hay naku eto pa ang isang asungot, nagpapansin…

        Gawin mo na kasi trabaho mo… para naman maka quota…

        post na ng abnoy, panot, yellow zombie sa lahat ng news saka ilike mo ha

      • Maldi2

         The comments is so good – straightforward sapol sa kaibuturan ng mga YELLOW SCUMBAGS!

        Ikaw ang tumahimik BITTER! bwehehehe

      • michael_angelo

        Ang dami nyo talagang account ay oo mga BAYARAN talaga…

      • Maldi2

         Ang manok na pumuputak ay siyang nangingitlog! bwehehehe!

    • dgboy

       No, it is in the minds of the people of Philippines

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_VYVO5BIPX6WO4IGFRGIQE3P6HY Ruben

    Cuevas is always the one saving the day for Corona and Defense as well as making it difficult for the Prosecution.  At 83, wealthy, respected and very successful, what more does Cuevas have to prove by defending Corona?  Tough job for Cuevas but standing for hours and he alone arguing and cross examining the witnesses, everyone would agree that this old man is doing an awesome job.

    • michael_angelo

      yes awesome job, malaki ang BAYARAN dyan, Katulad ng ginagawa mo awesome job din, malaki ang BAYARAN ONLINE…

      • neverneverstop

        E ikaw, bayaran ka ba ni Noynoy dito para maglabas ng pro-Noynoy comments? Tsk tsk.

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3BS4NESVXEFTLMUWQ7LZUJJT5M Agustin

        Your remarks are signifying that you are also an autistic. Just shut up!

    • Jon70

       Cuevas is really good that is why he is a notable lawyer. But he is not a presidential material. We need simple minds but honest and willing to fight against the rapist of our country’s wealth.

    • scorpio15

      Pass para kay San Pedro.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_7IGQYIPU6AFTVRJ742XT2X44M4 Jef

     In the case of TRO, why the SC issue such TRO without hearing the side of the government? to fly to the moon with her husband in order to avoid prosecution….with the help of Corona and his COHORT….even the 3 condition not yet been complied with….imagine early morning on nov 15 2011 in the airport already hoping to fly to moon…. 

  • EdgarEdgar

    What moral lesson can we draw from the life of Leila?

    Leila wasn’t always a pig.  Once upon a time, she was an appointed stalwart of human-rights.  But aiming too high, she sold her soul to the yellow devil and turned into a pig.  But not just any kind of pig.  Mind you, this pig is like no other pig.  Trained to do circus tricks, she will toe the yellow line with hooves and snout.  Standing on one hind leg, she will regale the impeachment circus with tales of hearsay.  Spinning a ball on her snout, she will amuse us with the yellow forces at work that keeps the spinning from falling.  Sniffing around on her snout, she will excite our senses in a fantasy trail of smells and motives.  Attempting to do what no other pig has done before, this pig will put on some lipstick and fly.  Only she’ll come crashing down just as quickly, impressing upon us the risk of flight and the lessons of gravity.  That’s what happens when a formerly decent human being decides to become a yellow pig. 

    • michael_angelo

      That’s what happens also when a formerly decent human being decides to become BAYARAN COMMENTATOR…

      • Maldi2

         hehehe BITTER!

    • dnayellowkulayko

      of course rumor says she was promised a senator slot for next coming election and if this is true then we already know kung cnu ang bayaran :)

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PQW423P3XHY7EAHVTUHEH7U5AI Juan

    in the passing impeachment days, Cuevas ‘respect’ goes down the drain…When it comes to sense of national interest he has none….Cannot give any respect to any man,  who defend another man who obviously betrays public trust….I do believe Cuevas and the rest of the defense team know, they all know, corona is a ‘misfit’…I feel sorry for them…

    • neverneverstop

      I also feel sorry for you because you don’t understand that a defense lawyer needs to defend the accused instead of putting them into danger unlike your insane president who utters nothing but nonsense.

      • michael_angelo

        GMA ka no? Di ba bawal ang internet dyan sa OSPITAL?

  • pugadlawin21

    Dapat magtabi sa kama si Drillon at de Lima, bagay sila. Para sigurong mga baboy na naglulublob sa putikan. Ha ha ha

    • michael_angelo

      Bat di mo nilike ang POST ang ganda ganda naman ng IDEA mo, BRILLIANT mind ka talaga… yan ang kelangan ng Pilipinas, ang mga katulad mo na pag iisip…

      MOre fun in PH talaga

    • dgboy

       ayos din pantasya pati ba naan si drilon at delima hindi mo pinatawad. Mahilig ka sa baboy nga!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_7IGQYIPU6AFTVRJ742XT2X44M4 Jef

    let say on this scenario…nahuli si CJ Corona nagnakaw ng million halaga ng pera tapos doon sa presento sa pag imbistiga sa kanya ng pulis…inisip nya para gagaan yong kaso nya ikinanta nya yong 7 na kasabwat nyang nagnakaw para paghahatian nila yong kaso….meaning gagan hindi impeachable…..bakit ako lang walo kaming nagnakaw….To make the long story short….ikaw lang muna ang ikukulong ngayon….they will follow by and by….

  • Maldi2

    Sample pa lang yan ng mga tanong ng defense.  Maya2 lang ay tingnan natin kung oobra ang DALDALima sa mga tanong ni Mirriam.  So exciting bwehehehehe

    Tingnan natin at mahuhubaran din ang katotohanan na kanyan nya nagawa yon ay dahil sa utos ni Simeon!  Ambisyosa!

    • michael_angelo

      AY naku ang mga LAHI ni MIRRIAM andito na naman…

    • thunderbolt01

      Siguradong mapapanganga sa shock si Daldalima dahil  sa mga kasinungalingan niya at siguradong pagsisigawan siya ni Mirriam.Abnoy bigayaan mo ng tulong si Daldalima.

    • Jon70

       don’t worry about Miriam she is already part of the past history. Damaged na yung  isip.

  • Lapu_lapu

    Conspiracy can be gleaned from the SC issuance of the TRO. All justices voting for the TRO were all appointees of GMA. Is that not a glaring fact Mr. Cuevas? The TRO was issued under extra-ordinary situation skewed in favor of GMA as to allow her to fly out of the country to avoid pending cases. Yes, the SC issued the TRO as collegial body but as a criminally-syndicated gang devoid of reason and the intention is to pander to GMA. De Lima was right and an astute Secretary who knew how to read-in-between lines. Had GMA made it out, de Lima would have been a laughing stock and the dark intentions of SC would have prospered.
    Senator-Judges be more circumvent in your thinking; there’s more than meets the eye here.
    Happily, de Lima was able to thwart the dastardly act of SC.

    • michael_angelo

      O yan mga BAYARAN ni CORONA, ano masasabi nyo aber/…

    • observer1356

      I agree

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/NHR5PHABMUMPBZAEYKP2SROOTQ Jon

      That’s what’s wrong with conspiracy theorist.  They see things that aren’t there and assumes irrelevant information as true facts.

      • Lapu_lapu

        And you are a blabbering idiot for not using your mind and ignoring the facts surrounding. Even circumstantial evidences result to the credulity of an allegation when such point to an incontestible conclusion logically arrived at. ‘If you look like a duck, walk like a duck and you talk like a duck . . . you must be a duck.

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/NHR5PHABMUMPBZAEYKP2SROOTQ Jon

        Fact:
        Supreme Court is the highest court. It has ULTIMATE jurisdiction.
        Fact:
        Prior to the TRO, GMA was not charge with anything.

        If you have only one piece of circumstantial evidence, carrying that evidence to a specific conclusion is prone to significant error and as such, concluding that GMA was a flight risk based solely on who voted for the TRO is erroneous at best.

        Oh, there’s no need for name calling. It just makes you look like a idiot!

      • Lapu_lapu

        The Impeachment Court is the highest court, you don’t even know that, higher than your SC riddled by corrupt officials. Well, de Lima is smarter than your GMA, it shows. “Matalino man ang matsing, napaglalangan din.”I stated “circumstantial evidences” not “evidence”. These evidences connect the dots, so to speak. Your premise is wrong because your assumption is wrong. Because of that you are a double-idiot!

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/NHR5PHABMUMPBZAEYKP2SROOTQ Jon

        The impeachment court is NOT the highest court.
        It has only one function and one function only and that is to try malfeasance of government officials.
        It cannot deliberate or pass laws as mandated by the constitution and it must abide by existing laws. Why do you think Enrile threw out Tupas witness. Why do you think the court was stopped when the Supreme Court issued a TRO concerning the bank accounts?

        Connect all the dots you like, the law is the law.
        There are reason why civilize countries have Laws.
        To paint the whole Supreme Court as corrupt is like saying that all Filipinos are Nurses.
        Simply spouting hearsay and conjecture does not translate into facts no matter how hard you try.
        Name-calling is the last resort of an exhausted and uneducated mind. Have a nice day!

      • Lapu_lapu

        You can have your opinion to yourself and does not hold water. What do you understand about “SOLE” authority to hear impeachment trials? We are in an impeachment trial, what can your SC do to stop it? What can your SC do about the decision it will have? Does your SC have a say? NADA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Can your SC also pass laws?
        Stupid assertion! Remember, it was just a judgment call on the part of Enrile wittingly subjugating the Impeachment Court to the SC to avoid a perceived “constitutional crisis.”
        If I were him, I would not have allowed the SC to interfere in the proceedings of the Impeachment Court. But he lost the brinkmanship. He squinted. Show me a provision in the Constitution which says it can issue a TRO in an impeachment trial!(Remember, it is only a TRO; one way or another the Impeachment Court will finally ask it to be lifted, otherwise, it will see it as it really is: something just to buy time for your beloved Corona). The law when it allowss the crooks to run roughshod of the people’s interest is not a law at all but a tool of repression.Shove your law! You just don’t know your geography! You are lost in your world of make belief!
        One spoiled egg is enough (One BIG ROTTEN EGG at that) to spoil a basket of eggs! You were born yesterday and until now you still have the diapher to show it. You are one guy if let alone will allow his wife to be raped in front of you and you’d still be smiling! You may think you’re intelligent in your way but you just missed the point, man. What we got here is expressing public opinion and that is one arena you people are losing because you support corrupt people and in so doing abet the rise of corruption in government. Corona is hiding his ill-gotten wealth and his irreverent affinity to GMA by mere technicalities! I don’t know you, and you don’t know me. I have BS degree and almost finished my MBA, and you call me uneducated? You are getting thin-skinned. We are in a market of ideas, and the best ideas prevail. If you can’t stand the heat, go get in the shade.

      • AllaMo

        huus, aminin mo na. gusto mo lng makalusot si corona, para ma-absuelto nila, sa coronarroyo court, si gloria.

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/NHR5PHABMUMPBZAEYKP2SROOTQ Jon

        Whether he is found guilty or not is irrelevant to me.
        My concern is that the letter of the law be followed.  That the accused should be judge based on concrete, irrefutable evidence, not mere conjectures and hearsay.

  • Adrienne1225

    Halatang halata na nga ang ginawa ni Corona, itigil nyo na ang impeachment na yan pagalingan na lang sa pagiging pilosopo, wala ng kahihiyan yang mga kaalyado ni GMA dapat diyan patira na lang sa riding in tandem tutal bundat na ang family nila sa dami ng nanakaw ha ! ha !

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/NHR5PHABMUMPBZAEYKP2SROOTQ Jon

    ” De Lima said: “If we talk only about voting, and the position with
    respect to the propriety of the TRO with eight of them concurring that
    TRO at the time was proper in their view… that’s their position as the
    majority, then yes.”

    If De Lima knew that the majority of the Supreme Court justices believe that the TRO was proper, then the procedural in hearing oral arguments a few days later is moot.  The fact that she disregarded the decision of the high court mean she is guilty of contempt of court.  The majority of the Supreme Court voted for the TRO and only Justice Corona was singled out? De Lima had no intention of following any order from the Supreme Court and behave as if she is the one and only authority.  It’s evident that Pnoy and his people were out to get Corona one way or another.

  • thunderbolt01

    Halatang walang laban sa korte ang grupo ng mga sinungaling kaya idinadaan nalang sa paninira.  Kagaya kayo ng lider nyong abnormal na matakaw sa salapi na nagkukunwaring malinis. Kung malinis siya ipamigay ang HACIENDA  sa mga magsasaka. Yumayaman ng walang kapaguran sa pagdurugas sa mga pinagpaguran ng mga magsasaka. Ipokrito.

    • AllaMo

      huus, aminin mo na lang. gusto mo makalusot si corona, para mailusot din nila, sa coronarroyo court, si gloria.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_7IGQYIPU6AFTVRJ742XT2X44M4 Jef

    It obvious naman mga kabayan 8 justices voted the TRO at ang utak sa paglabas ng TRO ay si CJ Corona…spearheaded the immediate released of the TRO kaya nga umuwi agad galing ibang bansa kahit hindi pa tapos yong lakad nya dahil tinawagan ni GMA dahil natunugan na lalabasan sya ng kasong PLUNDERS at SABOTAGE….dba lahat silang bomoto sa TRO are all appointed by the former pres. GMA… wala man isa doon ay appointed by pres. noynoy…di man lang pinayagad yong government para marinig yong side….then how about the 3 condition….effective ba agad…common sense naman….isip isip….

    • thunderbolt01

      Puro tsismis at walang katuturan ang mga post ng mga abnormal. Sino ang maniniwala niyan kungdi kayo kayo lang.

      • AllaMo

        bugok

    • ppr2

      anong klaseng analysis ito?

      “dba lahat silang bomoto sa TRO are all appointed by the former pres. GMA… wala man isa doon ay appointed by pres. noynoy”

      alangan naman, si GMA ang presidente nang nagkaroon ng bakante sa SC eh!!! senator pa si noynoy noon, gusto mo na siya ang mag appoint??

      itong statement na sinabi mo, which is also being peddled by others, defies all logic. sang-ayon sa ating saligang batas, ang presidente ang mag appoint ng SC justice, after being vetted and recommended by the JBC.

      so, noong may nag retire na justice sa panahon ni GMA, hindi dapat palitan para walang appointed justice si GMA, yun ba dapat ang nangyari???

      if the point of your statement is that none of noynoy’s appointee’s voted for the TRO, then think about this: Carpio voted for the TRO. he IS a GMA appointee.

      • AllaMo

        talaga ba’ng di mo alam na in-appoint ni arroyo si corona, within the period proscribed by the Constitution? At, dahil nga pinagbabawal nang Saligang Batas, ginawang ligal itong appointment sa pamamagitan nang desisyon din nang mga mahikero ni arroyo sa korte.

        aminin mo na. gusto mo lng ma-absuelto si corona, para ma-absuelto din nila, sa coronarroyo court, ang panginoon nila na si gloria.

      • ppr2

        alam na alam. si GMA nag appoint kay Corona both as justice and then as CJ. on the second item, it was considered a midnight appointment by quite a number of people, including yourself.

        but that is not the point of my post. what irritated me is the statement of people that is not logical, like that of Jef’s. i already explained why i found his statement illogical.

        mas ma-igi pa yung sinabi mo, kaso hindi yun sagot sa sinabi ko eh. medyo malayo, hindi magka tugma. your point is another debatable item entirely.

        at this point in time, i try to be open minded and not making any judgements yet. wala pa akong aaminin dahil hindi pa tapos ang trial. but i will own to what i think when the time comes and will let you know.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/NHR5PHABMUMPBZAEYKP2SROOTQ Jon

       What??? That’s the most absurd thing I have ever read! What Pnoy followers fail to understand, is that prior to the TRO, GMA was not charged with any alleged crimes
      therefore, the issuing of the TRO is lawful under the law and De Lima should have followed the high court’s decision not make arbitrary decision on her part.

      • AllaMo

        bugok.

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/NHR5PHABMUMPBZAEYKP2SROOTQ Jon

         Thank you for an intelligent rebuttal.  Are you still in grade school?

    • RomyMacalintal

      kanina 7 ngayon 8

      puro kasinungalingan talaga

  • kaipepo

    Simpleng paninipsip lang kay Pnoy. Ganon katindi si De Cinco. Kung hindi niya pinigilan si GMA sigurado wala na siya sa pwesto ngayon. Sabagay mas mataas na posisyon sa DOJ kaysa sa CHR kung saan si GMA ang nag-appoint sa  kanya kaya mas pipiliin na niya si Pnoy para nga naman mas madali siyang maging senador. Pero hinay hinay lang De Cinco. May kasabihan, ang hindi raw lumingon sa pinanggalingan baka madiskarel sa malubak na daan.

    • AllaMo

      huus, gusto molng ma-absuelto si corona. para ma-absuelto din nila, sa korte niya, si gloria. 

  • thunderbolt01

    Gusto kong makita ang sagupaan ni Mirriam at daldalima. Katarungan versus kasinungalingan. Palagay ko ay mapapahiya ng husto si daldalima kagaya ng pagkaka pahiya ni Tupac every now and then. Katawa tawa talaga ang grupo ng prosecution.

    • dgboy

      high blood versus taba. Ngyon alam mo na sino tutumba kung hindi kakalma ang isa.

    • jgl414567

      Isa ka pang walanghiya at hudas sa bayan kasi sa mga tiwali ka pumapanig at sa sira ulo at mayabang na tulad ni Miriam.

  • HUNGKAG

    Hindi TRO ang issue dahil si CJ ay nagtago sa majority ng cgma justices. ang issue ay ang mga ginawa ni cj sa pagpapatupad ng TRO gaya ng:
    1. utusan si midas marquez na sabihin sa press conference na epektibo ang TRO kahit hindi pa natupad ni gama ang kodisyones dito.
    2. utusan si j. velasco na hwag ilabas ang dissenting opinion ni.j.sereno.
    3. utusan ang clerk of court na tanggapin ang bond ni gma kahit lampas na sa oras.

    • ablogman

      kaibigan mukhang  taga SC ka at alam mo lahat inutil ka rin

      • AllaMo

        bugok. lahat nang binanggit ni hungkag ay public knowledge. gusto mo lng makalusot si corona, para ilusot din nya si gloria.

      • scorpio15

        Magbasa ka para hindi ka maging mukhang Inutil. Kasimbilis mo lumabas ang TRO.

      • jgl414567

        kaibigan mas inutil ka kasi pinagtatanggol mo mga corrupt na tulad ni Gloria at Corona! Walanghiya ka!

      • jamesgeorge

        Wag kang manghusga ng inutil! Tama si Hungkag, hindi yung TRO ang issue,kungdi yung mga ginawa ni Corona para makaalis si Gloria! Ikaw ba may alam?

      • HUNGKAG

        kaibigang ablogman, ang inutil ay ang puro kantyaw at buska na lang. magkomento ka sa isyu para maliwanagan ang mga mamamayan.

      • HUNGKAG

        sige na nga. hinto na impeachment trial ni CJ Corona at tigil na kaso ni CGMA. maligaya ka na ablogman?

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/GXROF4RG4OIBU3UYSM4AS657LE Evelyn

    Di dapat e impeach si CJ Corona..may botohan naman sa loob ng korte 8 versus 5 so? ibig sabihin isa lang ang boto ni Corona doon eh bakit si Corona lang ang pinag initan nila. Alam ba nyo? na pumayat na si Pnoy sa kaiisip nya sa Hacienda Luisita..ngayon umpisa na ang gulo na naman sa mga magsasaka sa bintahan noong 2004 doon sa RBC..may putokan na naman..

    • jamesgeorge

      Nagbotohan nga pero ang tutoo talo si Corona duon dahil hindi nag-comply si Gloria sa conditions ng TRO! So, Bakit sabi ni Corona effective ang TRO? Ikaw talaga, mahina umintindi! Ulitin Ko Ha?

    • LandRover628

      It is not hard to see that the “collegial” decision of the SC justices, voting 7-6, was that “….the TRO was subject to certain conditions pending compliance with those conditions, it cannot be considered as already effective.” This was the gist of the majority of the justices’ contention in resolving the issue whether the TRO was already in effect day, Nov 18. CJ Corona’s sin was when he directed the SC Clerk of Court not to promulgate that resolution and instead outed and promulgated a different resolution (drafted no less by the CJ himself, with the connivance of AJ Presbitiro Velasco) that effectively reversed the said “collegial” decision to favor GMA. His action was not only unauthorized, but it was patently illegal and even criminal.

      • 070844

        Condition 2 of the TRO required the Arroyos to appoint an attorney to act on their behalf while out of the country. This would mean executing a Power of Attorney (special or general) which would be in writing and would amount to documentary evidence available to the Justices. For the Justices to vote 7-6 that condition 2 had not been complied with suggests either the Power of Attorney did not exist or that it existed but was flawed. Either way, it seems strange that the Justices would be divided on what appears to be a simple issue. I wonder who the 6 were.

  • lambug1

    Ruben… hindi naman kita aawayin kung kumakampi ka kay Buaya (Corona). Malaking drama ang ginawa ni Gloria pero nabuko siya. Una nagsinungaling siya na ang layunin niya pa gawas ay magpacheck-up… Wala naman hospial na nagpa-appoint KASI pag dito ka sa labas pasunod iyong medical appointment na naka-takda hindi lang kaagad-agqd pasok ka sa hospital right away. Doon siya nabuko! Pangalawa No. 2 … Bakit kung tutuo magpagamot bakit duma-an pa sa around the world  trip… sa New York  upang “mag-attend ng Clinton Conference pagkatapus sa Switzerland raw attend pa rin ng conference (hindi kaya magsito ng pinagnakawan doon bangko.

  • http://www.facebook.com/melemino Max Elemino

    The appearance of Sec L. de Lima as a witness in yesterday’s hearing is a great help to make fine and very reasonable judgment. More power to  Sec. L de Lima. 

    • RomyMacalintal

      More etits na rin

      • Guest

        Romy tinira sa pwet si CORONA. Threesome sila ni Midas.

  • sigena

    sa sagot ni de lima lagot na sya

    • RomyMacalintal

      Heil PNoy

  • Mattino2011

    Pabagobago stand ni Enrile, nung pinapa sub-poena ng Defense si Speaker Belmonte at iba pang congressman sa Impeachment court sinabi niya di pwede dahil sa Inter parliamentary colurtesy..Now na napag sabihan siya ng prosecutor panel na dapat igalang naman sila at wag sigawgigawan sa court..bigla di pwede inter parliamentary kasi impeachment court daw at di sila kapantay.. ano ba talaga tanda? Be consistent..IF u said inter parliamentary courtesy that time when you ruled out to sub peona the speaker and congressmen,, what is the difference now…? All they are asking is Courtesy,, I believe you have no right to berratle or shout, almost insult the prosecutor congressmen. I guess double standard ka. If you are hot head , you should not be presiding officer,, beside it seems that your memory is failing you aready..Palusot un media interview mo nung sinita ka..bakit nag ala Miriam ka..tandA?

    • scorpio15

      Red ang nirespeto lang ni Go Johnny Go at ang 12 Disepolos ay ang Korte Suprema.

    • jgl414567

      Enrile is a traitor since the time of Marcos to Cory’s time and will be as long as he lives like Judas Iscariot!

  • oracle888

    When come to the judgment day for the Senate Impeachment Court, does each of the Senate-judge has only one vote, including the presiding officer JP Enrile? I believe the answer is yes.

    Yet during the deliberation, and the hearing, accepting of evidences, rejecting of witness as in the case of the PAL vice president of sales, calling the shots, is it not JP Enrile? the presiding officer, even though he has only one vote?

    Using this analogy, and put it on SC Chief Justice Corona, with those of the Associate Justices, then Mr. Cuevas, you can contemplate for the rest of the night.

    And to the Senate-judges, are you not under the influence of JP Enrile? Is he not the one who guide you guys through the whole process?

    primus inter pares? just for fool.

    • jgl414567

      CORONA IS NOT THE PRIMUS INTER PARES OF THE SC BUT ITS DICTATOR AND EVEN HAD THE TEMERITY TO ORDER THE CLERK OF COURT NOT TO PUBLISHTHE DISSENTING OPINIONS OF SERENO AND CARPIO. THAT IS THE HEIGHT OF SUPPRESSION OF THE FREEDOM OF SPEECH!

  • jgl414567

    Sec de Lima is not only very courageous but enlightened and intelligent also unlike Miriam who profess to be intelligent by the book of the law but is unenlightened and uses the law to block justice.SHAME!

    • pugadlawin21

      De Lima can’t hold Santiago’s pantyhose, PERIOD.

    • erick_1972

        Remember that De Lima was an former Pres. Arroyo appointee before CHR , Short minded tend to forget a few years back. This always about the money. De Lima Now chief of the Justice department would someday want to be at Halls of the Justices. Job security. Senator is already primed to be in the International Courts is there something for her to be gained here?Nothing.Senator Santiago already had her fill in the executive and judicial branches why compare Santiago and De Lima.

      • RomyMacalintal

        Masama bang mag aspire maging chief justice?

      • erick_1972

        Wala! Everybody has high aspirations but to what and how to get those aspirations done will be a great question .

  • padrefaura

    sandali, first of all, anong masama sa TRO kay Gloria?
    minadali ba? eh kaya nga TRO yan. remember yung TRO sa watchlist order ni mike arroyo na nag 13-0 ang SC (kasama si justice carpio sa 13)? may hearing before the TRO? wala.  may umalma ba? wala, in fact, tinanggap ni de lima yung order at pinayagan pang pumunta sa germany si FG,

    ang TRO hindi kailangan ng hearing. dapat malaman ng taongbayan yan. hanapin nyo sa lahat ng batas at ituro nyo kung saan kinakailangan ang hearing para sa TRO.

    tandaan nyo rin na noong nag TRO, wala pang kaso na isinasampa ang korte kay GMA. so, walang HDO or warrant of arrest pa laban sa kanya. kaya nga kung maaalala nyo, nung na-deny yung MR nila, minadali nilang dalhin yung kaso sa pasay kay judge mupas na within 4 hours (mas mabilis pa sa SC), may warrant of arrest na.

    eh ano kung si GMA yan? hindi ba sya entitled sa Constitutional right to be presumed innocent? so unless walang court order for her arrest or HDO, hindi ba dapat pwede syang makabyahe?

    dont get me wrong, kung akong tatanungin nyo, gusto kong managot si GMA, pero dapat ilagay sa tamang pamamaraan. walang lokohan at walang susuway sa batas.

    walang masama sa TRO. kung susuriin nyo, kasalanan ni de lima kaya nagka-TRO. 1.5 years na sila sa pwesto, wala pa kahit isang kaso nasasampa sa korte kay GMA. puro investigation pa kuno. kaya nga minadali ng Comelec yung kaso nung nagkaroon ng TRO.

    • jamesgeorge

      May hearing ang TRO lalo na yan DOJ ang involved! Mukang mali yang assumption mo!

      • padrefaura

        please show me the rule on that.

        uulitin ko, sa TRO kay FG on the WLO nya noong august 2011, 13-0 yung botohan. walang hearing doon, walang umalma. nakapunta pa nga sa germany si FG pagkatapos

        kailangan mo siguro ng memory enhancer. try memo-plus gold na binebenta ni kuya kim.

    • RomyMacalintal

       Busy sa kanyang etits kasi

    • antonioluna

      ano ba naman itong asong ito napakamasunurin nga sa kanyang among si pandakekak pero bobo naman palang aso, askal ka ba?

      noong nov. 15, 2011 nagkaroon ng enbanc session ang korte suprema para bigyan ng TRO si pandakekak laban sa HDO at ang resulta nabigyan nga sya ng TRO pero may mga kundisyunes na dapat sundin bago ito magkabisa.

      noong nov. 18, 2011 nagkaroon ulit ng enbanc session para malaman kung nakatupad si pandakekak sa mga kundisyunes, ang resulta 7-6 pitong hukom ang nagsabing hindi nakasunod si pandakekak sa mga kundisyunes pero ano ang ginawa ni cheap dog thief justice ito ay kanyang dinuktor at ginawang 9-4 at pinalabas na siyam na hukom ang bumutong nakatupad si pandakekak sa mga kundisyunes, dyan pa lang kitang kita na ang pagiging aso ni cheap dog at ang amo nya ay si pandakekak.

      hindi rin naman kita masisisi na diehard ka kay cheap dog at pandakekak dahil bagamat mayroong cheap dog ikaw naman ay aso din hindi nga lang ikaw ang pinakamataas na aso dahil askal ka lang hehehe

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PCSQYQZHWBVQ6IK3YNV2DNXM6M Jose

    the act by the SC in itself granting a “hastened” approval, allowing GMA for a medical check up outside the country creates doubts in the minds of the people. if you could remember, Pnoy was not in the country attending ASEAN Summit in Hawaii. of all the issues, events, decisions by the SC, though the decision is collegial and because Corona, an alleged appointee by GMA, you can not blame people’s premonitions that He was doing in favor of GMA.

    • padrefaura

      are you now saying that the SC can no longer decide in favor of GMA in any case at all?

      hindi ba entitled si GMA under our constitution to be presumed innocent until convicted in a court of law? noong time nga nag TRO, sa kahit anong court, walang kaso si GMA. so, anong mali sa TRO doon?

  • brunogiordano

    “De Lima also cited Sereno’s account on how Corona purportedly tried to
    make it appear that Arroyo had complied with all the conditions set in
    the TRO. ”

    “De Lima referred to Sereno’s opinion revealing that the court, voting
    7-6, had ruled that that the Arroyos did not comply with the second
    condition.”

    dito NABISTO at NABUTA ang planong

    “THE GREAT ESCAPE”

    kaya dapat lang ma-impeach at tangalin ang kasalukuyan chief(THIEF) justice.

    • padrefaura

      ano proof na na tatakas si Gloria? yung sinabi ni de lima na kukuha daw ng political asylum sa dominican republic, tapos nag-issue ng statement yung dominican republic na walang political asylum si GMA sa kanila (nahuli tuloy na nagsisinungaling si De Lima).

      • brunogiordano

        bakit nakakulong(detained) ngayon si GLORIA?

      • padrefaura

        kasi naglabas si mupas ng warrant of arrest sa isang non-bailable crime after the TRO. remember that the case was filed AFTER the TRO.

        at kahit nakakulong si Gloria, presumed innocent pa rin until may conviction. convicted na ba si Gloria?

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_BWFXXBJ4RBNOYTNM6UMRCNKRUI Rey

        ha ha ha bakit 14 household help ang gustong sumama kay GMA?  obvious na obvious lalayas siya at magsama 14 katulong.  

      • http://www.facebook.com/lemuel.ballesteros Lemuel Ballesteros

        Proof? Well, di kailangang umalis ni Gloria ng araw na yun papuntang ibang bansa. Medical abstract shows na gumagaling na sya at di nya kailangan magmadaling magpagamot sa ibang bansa at kaya naman gamutin sakit nya dito. In fact one week later ng nagpa interview sya kay Arnold Clavio, voila, wala na syang sakit! Bakit sya nagmamadaling lumayas? Wala naman medical emergency at drama lang pa wheelchair nya. Wala ring importanteng kailangan puntahan sa ibang bansa as a legislator or even for personal reason wala sya sinasabi na kailangang kailangan nya umalis (except ung drama na medical emergency na napatunayan na di naman totoo based on her medical abstract). Again ang tanong, bakit sya nagmamadaling lumayas?

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/2OGCQGFL6ZFWQAB6HMJBGD3NWE Lorelei

         Circumstances show the real intention of GMA in going abroad. Take note of her speaking commitment, kung talagang life threatening ang sakit niya magagawa pa ba niya ito. At saka pag aralan natin ang timeline ng TRO at ng sked niya paalis ng bansa. Parang pelikula, naka set lahat pati ang timing. Planado talaga. Mabuti na lang at may De Lima na may lakas ng loob na pigilan sila. Kung hindi, baka ngayon eh di natin alam kung nasaang bansa na sila.Katuwiran ng iba, di kaselahin ang pasaporte!!! Tsk Tsk Tsk, si Lacson nga di nila ma locate si GMA pa.

      • antonioluna

        naku nuknukan naman pala talaga ng pagkaampaw ang utak mo na kasing laki lang ng sa biya, pero sige bigyan kita ng proof, si pandakekak at mga aso nya ay sumubok na papaniwalain ang mga pinoy na delikado ang sakit nya pero ang proof hindi naman ay ito ay pinatunayan ng mga doktor sa st. lukes na kung naaalala pa ng iyong makitid na kukute na si horn at tupakcio ang parating nagsasabing life threatening ang sakit nya pero hindi naman sila mga doktor.

        ganyan talaga ang mga aso maliit ang utak pero masunurin sa amo kaya nga ikaw eh talaga namang napakamasunurin sa pagtatangol sa kanyang among magnanakaw, sinungaling at hello garci.

        at dahil hindi talaga matino ang takbo ng utak mong supot naisip mo ba kung may bansang aamin na pinayagan nga nilang magkaroon ng political asylum ang isang magnanakaw na katulad ni pandakekak at ang asawa nitong mas buwaya pa kumpara kay lolong.

        sige antayin ko ang sagot ng isang asong katulad mo, meooowwwww.

    • http://twitter.com/JGAbia JABIA

      whats new with this, sympre i quote nya yung dissenting opinion nung 2 eh pareho tao ni PNOY yun eh….. si Carpio want to be the next CJ while Sereno is the first appointee of PNOY…… pero sana lang ha pag d na impeach si Corona dapat mag resign si Carpio at Sereno because i dont think they can work harmoniously with the other SC members.

      Carpio and Serreno are not just TUTA ni PNOY but they are a good illustration of filipino crab mentality…… they will try to pull down those people na nsa taas nila…. Konting hiya rin naman kay Carpio at Serreno

  • LandRover628

    It is not hard to see that the “collegial” decision of the SC justices, voting 7-6, was that “….the TRO was subject to certain conditions pending compliance with those conditions, it cannot be considered as already effective.” This was the gist of the majority of the justices’ contention in resolving the issue whether the TRO was already in effect day, Nov 18. CJ Corona’s sin was when he directed the SC Clerk of Court not to promulgate that resolution and instead outed and promulgated a different resolution (drafted no less by the CJ himself, with the connivance of AJ Presbitiro Velasco) that effectively reversed the said “collegial” decision to favor GMA. His action was not only unauthorized, but it was patently illegal and even criminal. 

    • Bobbie_mae

      This was an amazing disclosure, and it’s documented in a dissenting opinion that none of the other justices has challenged, although corona has attempted to have it suppressed. Corona was probably thinking, none of the other justices will publicly or privately object to  the issuance of  the false resolution on the effectivity of the TRO. So now it is understandable why corona has asked that sereno and carpio be inhibited from hearing the petitions to stop the impeachment trial and other related petitions, because sereno has this habit of documenting what goes on behind closed doors in her dissenting opinion.  If you have nothing to hide, then why not be transparent? While it is true that corona was only one among several signatories in the TRO, this disclosure in sereno’s dissenting opinion exposes behavior unbecoming of a chief justice. 

  • laguar

    Using dissenting opinions as her crystal ball, it seems that the Face of the Filipino  Conscience is also clairvoyant. With a visionary for a president, what else do we need for a circus?

    • Barak_O

      magician like thief midnight. somebody who can make tro’s out of nowhere

  • TinimbangNgunitKulang

    Para namang hindi edukado si Enrile para magtanong kung si Corona acted alone in issuing order..etc. Hindi naman ganoong kabobo si Corona, ano? Siyempre patay malisya yung pagpabor niya ke GMA para desimulado.

    • Reyjohn

      Ganon talaga sa korte kailangan mailagay on record kahit obvious na ang sagot. Enrile is hinting na hindi impeachable yung TRO issue kasi 8 justices voted for it hindi lang si Corona.

      Pero ang sagot ni De Lima, halata parin si Corona na minani-obra kaya impeachable kasi sa mga sumusunod: inutasan nya si Marquez na ilabas sa TV na OK na si GMA lumabas ng bansa kahit di pa nali-lift ni De Lima ang order, inutos sa isang co-judge na wag i-publish ang dissenting opinion ni justice Sereno, inutusan ang Clerk of Court tanggapin ang bond deposit kahit wala na sa oras ng opisina.

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/2OGCQGFL6ZFWQAB6HMJBGD3NWE Lorelei

         For simplicity, kasabwat talaga siya para makatakas si GMA.

      • RomyMacalintal

         Suck LP

    • Paranaque City

      Dude, Enrile had to ask that because that was what the prosecution is trying to insinuate. To put things on record. Everyone knows who De Lima is, pero in ask din for De Lima to state who she is and what office she’s holding. Para ka naming DI nag-aral, dude.

      • RomyMacalintal

        Wag mo ikasigaw baka hindi nga

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/JH4R5SKCQUTMZJJYZVOUYXL4L4/ t c

     Noynoy Aquino should share his medicines to his followers who are now on psycho attack.

  • WAJ

    Huwag na sanang ipagtanggol ni Cuevas si Corona. Sayang lamang ang oras niya dahil wala rin naman silang magagawa. Sino ba ang mga testigo nila? Si GMA, si Miguel, si Marquez, yung secretary/clerk ng SC. E lahat ng mga ito e puro palpak na ang repustasyon sa bayan. At saka, anong testimony nila puro kasinungalingan. Sino ang maniniwala sa kanila, ang taong bayan?   

    • spearheads

      Si noynoy ang testigo ni Corona, hostile witness. Satisfied?

  • JosephNess

    just wondering, why of all the SC magistrates, only CJ was given full privileges of a platinum card by PAL, extending this privilege as well to his wife…primus inter pares ?…what’s really behind these given privileges ? what’s there being a primus inter pares that you should be extended a PAL Platinum card ?….and, what does this implied ?…gee!!! indeed, very suspicious…

    • Paranaque City

      How do you know that CJ is the only person in the GOVERNMENT that has platinum card from PAL? PAL is still the country’s flag carrier, whether you like it or not.

      • JosephNess

        this information was proffered in the impeachment, was it not sir ?…so all who saw and heard it now knew….and, as you implied on government people enjoying same privileges, that’s beside the point, corona was the subject of the impeachment here, not them…now, tell me if this act of accepting this privileges, which included his wife, not a conduct of unbecoming of a government officals, a CJ as he was, the giver having pending case in the SC ?…was it not very suspicious of him being the primus inter pares among the SC justices ?… good if this privileges are freely given to all high ranking government officials, the SC justices included, as an incentives in appreciation being as they are…but no, it was singled out among the SC justices to the CJ and his wife alone, for what purposes and intentions was it given ? well you tell…

  • RJ

    But if De Lima allowed GMA to travel without her official copy of the TRO as DOJ received their official copy the following day and let GMA without complying first with the condition of the TRO (remember the TRO was issued with conditions for GMA to comply), and that indeed as according to De Lima’s opinion really did not come back until now.       Sino naman kaya ang sisisihin nyo pag nagkataon.      The following facts surrounding the TRO and the immediate flight booking of GMA immediately, cast doubt on her intention.1.   Marques announced already the TRO at 2 PM on Nov. 18 while the actual TRO has not yet been officially issued and served.2.   At 5PM was already at the airport with a copy of the TRO while the DOJ has no even been served of the TRO which compelled DOJ to stop GMA from leaving.3.   The TRO was with 3 conditions that GMA has to comply, yet she was in a hurry to leave without even complying with all conditions.4.   After GMA was barred from leaving due to non compliance of the conditions, Marquez made an announcement that the TRO is already enforceable even without complying with the condtions. (Where can you find a paper, contract, writs, orders with conditions executionary without complying first with the condition which is a prerequisite before a document is enforceable. Did Marquez meant that after GMA has landed in another country, she can comply with the conditions after?)5.   Days after the confusion, a discent opinion of 2 justices was barred by Chief Justice from promulgation and tampered a resolution by the enbanc to make it appear that the decision was voted by the majority.     With these facts and confusions, who will take the axe if GMA was allowed to leave and never come back?

    7 hours ag

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/2OGCQGFL6ZFWQAB6HMJBGD3NWE Lorelei

       They will blame the DOJ and question her for honoring a TRO that is not  valid and even without receiving the official copy. Some of the senators are good at that. And the GMA and Corona family will be triumphant in evading the law. Joker and Mirriam are too good in this criticizing De Lima. De Lima is just doing her job. More power to you madam!

      • RomyMacalintal

        Oo she sucks etits for a job

      • BB_Tanggal_Ari_vs_Tabing_Itlog

        Puro ka suck, eh pangalan mo na lang eh maca LINTA, ka ano ano mo si LINTAng Bedol?
        Magkaroon ka ng delikadesa, yan ba natutunan mo sa school o turo ng magulang mo yan???

      • RomyMacalintal

         Ano yon Hijo, Kalesa ba ika mo?  Di na uso ang lintek na kalesa ngayon tingan mo na lang sila sa prosecution walang ka-kale-kalesa.

    • RomyMacalintal

       If she doesn’t come back then even her corpse will never come back.

  • RomyMacalintal

    Leila “Hilig Etits” De Lima

  • http://www.facebook.com/isidro.valencia Isidro Valencia

    The defense strategy is clear: Corona acted alone not by collegial body. It is a an Arroyo Court.
    Why issue TRO to allow a President with pending cases and to allow her to leave the Philippines?

    Ito si Atty Cuevas should be known as Chief Justice of Technicalities. 
    I call upon Filipino patriots to attend the 26th People Power Anniversary on Saturday and
    express our sentiments to what is going in the impeachment. 

    That is People Power 3. Bloodless. Peaceful. Meaningful.

    • RomyMacalintal

       Wala pa pong case nung naglabas ng TRO

      Siguro meron kang short term memory loss

      Biruin mo pagkatapos nyan biglang me kaso agad
      tsk tsk tsk

      Sa labanan ngayon pabilisan lang ang pag suck

      • Winn728

        D ba, ikaw rin mahilig mag Suck kay Kandak. . .

      • Winn728

        Sori, mahilig ka rinn mga Suck kay Pandak. . .d ba. . . .

      • RomyMacalintal

         You suck LP

      • Winn728

        Same to U. . .

      • RomyMacalintal

         Utot mu

        Suck mo si PORK Drillon

      • Winn728

        Huwag kang PIKON. . . PIKON.  .  . PIKON. . .LOL. . . . .hehehehe. . hehehehe.  .  .

        PIKON. . . .

  • http://twitter.com/JGAbia JABIA

    ayos sa headline ha, bayaran ba talaga ang PDI, it seems pag against sa CJ highlighted lagi ang story pero pag mdyo dehado ang PNOY team medyo hindi masyado priority ang reporting.  Is this what you called balance journalism?  Is this what PDI made of?  Saka please be fair, try to highlight its a mere own assessment of De Lima but she also admit that she has no personal knowledge kung yung nga ang intention or with conspiracy with the other judges.  I hate to say this but mukhang government controlled newspaper kayo.

    • RomyMacalintal

      Ikaw ba papalag ke PNoy

      Lacierda:  Takot nyo lang ke PNoy
      Llamas:  Me AK47 ako

      Heil PNoy

    • http://twitter.com/MarLouWang Marlou Wang

      Huwag kang masyadong mag-imagine…. magbigay ka ng proof sa binitawan mong salita.

    • JosephNess

      just because you do not like the news you wanted to read, you accused this broadsheet of being one sided, be fair, not all the time event will favor your liking, be flexible…one time this broadsheet favor the survey for the defense, yet all supporters , maybe including you, hailed this broadsheet because of it…let’s be open minded…read the tribune if all you wanted to find  you  will read them there, that’s the way broadsheets appear, it’s up for the reader to appreciate…

  • jclarendo

    Mr Serfin Cuevas 83 specialty during his time of practice and during this impeachment trial is  objection your honor: The evidence presented are: irrelevant, impertinent, sham, false and redundant. Mr. Cuevas with your age you rather go to the home for the aged than going to court since what you are saying are already unbelievable. Invite your fraternity brother, Sir Johnny Enrile 88 to stay in the same nursing home.

    • RomyMacalintal

      Kesa naman puro false accusation, falsified documents, false witness.

    • Paranaque City

      Jclarendo, being the spring chicken that you are, must be so pleased with your youth that there’s nothing inside your head except hot air. I doubt that you’d be singing the same song about older people when it’s you that’s 88 or 83, because by then, Alzheimer’s has eaten what’s left of your inexperienced brain.

    • JosephNess

      not so sir, please at least have the decency to respect senior citizens like cuevas and enrile, they are worth respecting than other senior citizens who have no chance as these two, they are very senile and very productive in their line of expertise, that’s not the way how to fight your battle, attacking the personal well being of a person, in a fight, if you want to win, you should have respect and don’t under estimate your opponent, do the best you can to outwit them by your own intellectual maneuvering…be sport sir…

    • noypi_07

      so ang tingin mo sa sarili mo you are far more better than them.  seemed like you have to pick up your IQ under your soles. better yet, get out of your mum’s house and get a life.

    • Ulipur

      When Serafin saw his first born he said, I OBJECT.  That face is not admissible

      When the PHIVOCS announced that the condition of Talal Volcano was on Alert Level 2

      he vigorously said I OBJECT.   Statement is vague!

  • JosephNess

    no one really know what’s happening inside an en banc sessions of a supreme court, but one can only imply that the CJ being the primus inter pares, head the en bance session, thus managed the conduct of the session, that may sometimes influence the other justices in the conduct of the deliberation of a certain case, as compared to an ordinary private executive meeting run by the presiding officer  of a company in the decision making of certain company concern…this can be interpreted by the way certain dissenting opinion described the conduct of how the entire collegial body behaved…just my personal opinion… 

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3KDG2U4PB7SDFWXKCF7KJKIXVM Dong

    HINDI BA PARTIAL DIN sina SERENO at CARPIO kasi nag diisent sila dahil pinaboran nila ang kanilang patron na si PNOY ? Di ba si SERENO ay appointed ni PNOY ? Di ba si Carpio ay gustong palitan si Corona ? Kung partial si corona at makulong dapat sina Carpio  at Sereno rin ay bitayin.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_L7PILUDK6IPFGJLJNCM2IROCRY Albin

      korek ka dyan dong. simpleng analysis.

  • RomyMacalintal

    Bagong pangalan ng supreme court would be

    Supreme Court of PNoy

    Heil PNoy

    • Winn728

      I beg your pardon. . .

      Ang new name ng SC is SUPREME CORRUPT. . . . . .

      • RomyMacalintal

         Hindi ako ang presidente kaya hindi kita mabibigyan ng pardon so don’t beg for it.

        PNoy Supreme Court of Justice

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/N3LSGU3UBM7UPONGN5X7QUKDDI Pal

    Kung ikaw ay bomoto sa TRO ikaw ay  PARTIAL kay GMA. Kung ikaw ay bomoto laban sa TRO ikaw ay  PARTIAL kay NOYNOY !    BOW.

    • yatot

      Tumpak!

      Pero nasa prayer sa TRO ang prevention/avoidance of “irreparable damage”. In the case of GMA, health ang main reason kaya binigyan ng TRO. Dapat sinamahan ni Panut si GMA kahit saan man pumunta.

  • spearheads

    If you will read between the lines of Sen. Enrile’s constant overruling of Justice Cuevas objections in the last hearing, he was not exactly going against Cuevas, objections. Enrile made it a point that the senator judges, not only Enrile, understand his position. The truth of the matter is that there is no probative value in anything that de lima testified. Sen. Enrile was only allowing de lima to continue her story in deference to de lima’s position. Insofar as the prosecution’s objective to mislead the public is concerned, they might have aroused some interest in that respect. But as to probative value, de lima’s statements are nothing. That is why before the continuance, Cuevas made it a point first, to read the allergations in article 7 of the impeachment complaint to emphasized the collegial characteristic of the issuance of TRO, second to ask de lima if she subscribed to the allegations which de lima was forced to accept, and finally to emphasized that it is not a usual practice that a lawyer will lean heavily on a dissenting opinion of an SC decision which has no convincing impact as compared to the majority decision. In short, Cuevas was able to show de lima’s biased and partiality taking into consideration her pending disbarment case. Next hearing would be a little bit revealing on de lima’s cross examination. De lima was only testifying as to her own opinions, prejudice, and biases because the issue of TRO was already settled and declared effective upon issuance by the SC. The main question really is, how can you alleged a wrongful act linking it with a lawful evidence such as the TRO? If the TRO is legal then no question can be linked as to the illegality of it’s issuance. This is the bone of the controversy which sadly again, does not favor the Prosecution.

  • tra6Gpeche

    Just like Commissioner Kim Henares, Justice Secretary De Lima should be the pride of the Filipino people. These two government officials are very composed, very intelligent, straight forward and unquestionably honest in serving the Republic of the Philippines. The Filipinos are very lucky to have BIR Commissioner Kim Henares and Justice Secretary Leila de Lima on their side. Kudos to both of them! Their dedication and determination to serve & protect the interest and welfare of the country should be noticed by all Filipinos.

    • RomyMacalintal

       Parehong mahilig sa etits

      • Winn728

        Ganyan ka rin kay PANDAK. . . . .Puro ka ETITS din. . . Flush mo nga ang sarili mo. . . .

      • RomyMacalintal

        Suck LP

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_QZZKXPEA67I7HELEIYM35QVYFA Jon

        Nakakalimutan nyo yata ang reyna ng etit-buffet
        Nympha Kristeta

      • Guest

        Fuc@er

      • yatot

        Panutzky SUCK all theirs… hahahha 

      • yatot

        Leftist at etits

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_L7PILUDK6IPFGJLJNCM2IROCRY Albin

        yung boss nilang panot, mahilig din dun.

      • Guest

        Romy mangtsutsupa

      • tra6Gpeche

        Kaibigan, you are entitled to your “very educational and decent opinion.”

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_L7PILUDK6IPFGJLJNCM2IROCRY Albin

      intelligent kamo? Naman! E puro kasipsipan lang ginawa ng 2 oinl-oink na ito, kasuhan lang mga kalaban ng among panot nila. Pero pag KKK, nakows!!!

      • tra6Gpeche

        You might be partly right about KKK. As for the two women mentioned, I admire their service to the country so far.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_QKIKXLTZATX3UJQM2OE4PED2UE Shinigami

       Your supporting someone who does not honor a Supreme Court decision. Same as Pnoy, he does not care about the law as long at they think they are right.

      • bingdanis12

        yes, dahil bulok ang ibang justices sa supreme court.

      • adam_d_ant

        totoo ka bata … me mga bulok na justices sa korte  …. si carpio at ang mga tuta ni penoy ..

        ang mga nauuto talaga ni budoy… ngeee

      • yatot

        Natalo ka siguro sa SC o nag apply ng TRO at hindi nabigyan.

      • tra6Gpeche

        That’s the way you see it. Honestly, I don’t see it that way.

    • yatot

      Pareho kamong t-bird at leftist!

      • tra6Gpeche

        Kaibigan, you are entitled to your “very educational and decent opinion.”

    • adam_d_ant

      the piripins is beri rocky … sabi ng hapon … they have two t-birds and a president who is a “retard”

      ang mga nauuto nga naman ni budoy … ngeeee

      • tra6Gpeche

        Kaibigan, you are entitled to your “very educational and decent opinion.”

  • JakeReyes

    De Lima is already giving her interpretation of events. Substantially it has no value whatsoever.

    • RomyMacalintal

      Ikaw ba naman makakapagisip ng matino kung me lunok-lunok na etits?

      • adam_d_ant

        mahilig ba si da loudmouth doon?  believe din naman ako sa sikmura ng lalaking ‘yon bro …..

  • spearheads

    Indeed, De Lima’s testimony means nothing because she is testifying as to the circumstances behind of Sereno’s dissenting opinion. The facts alleged by Sereno are matters only Sereno has personal knowledge and of course, De Lima is not privy. So how could De lima’s testimony illicit probative value? The fact is, even if it is Sereno herself who will testify, still her testimony cannot be admitted at face value because it is self serving since Sereno is a dissenter. She or the Prosecution has to support it with actual documents which consist of the Supreme Court deliberations or minutes of the discussion on the matter before her testimony can attain weight and sufficiency to constitute admissible evidence. Unfortunately for the Prosecution, the Supreme Court has already politely denied the Senate Impeachmenbt Court subpoena duces tecum, a development fatal to the Prosecution. 

    • RomyMacalintal

      Hindi pa sila nakakapagnenok ng documents na i fafalsified nila

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/AVTOQDZU5E2P7MZYTFY6L3NBPU Ping

    DELIMA’s LAW :
    pag si Corona ang bomoto …PARTIAL
    pag si Sereno ang bomoto …IMPARTIAL

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_L7PILUDK6IPFGJLJNCM2IROCRY Albin

    Si Carpio at Sereno, nag-uunahan sa pagsipsip kay penoy. Akala nila isa sa kanila magiging CJ.
    Kaya si DeLima, Kim Henares, Tupas, Belmonte, Drilon, Guingona, Osmena, ….para silang Straw. – Plastic na, Sipsip pa.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_YAYZCQ4KSBQRKR2LLGX5XRMXFI pepe

    Madam Communist, that is “ALLEGATION” the court still needs “PROOF” allegation has no weight even in ordinary court.

    • antonioluna

       ang lawak ng utak biya mo kapag human rights advocate communist na hehehe.
      that is not an allegation it came from justice sereno dissenting opinion as required by our constitution.

      • adam_d_ant

        hanep … dissenting opinion as required by our constitution ..

        hey buddy?  how about the majority’s decison?  ooops .. sori kalaban pala ng gusto ni retard.

        ang mga nauuto nga naman ni budoy … ngeee

      • antonioluna

        aba eh mas masahol ka pa kay budoy, akalain mo nga naman ang isang mentally challenged nakakapanguto hehehe.

        tsaka ang majority decision na sinasabi mo ay 7-6 pero ginawang 9-4 hehehe.

        talaga hindi mo alam na required sa salingang batas ang dissenting opinion, mangmang ka pala.

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_YAYZCQ4KSBQRKR2LLGX5XRMXFI pepe

        hey retard antonioluna… una- OPINION is a self-thought and similar to ALLEGATION… next your dissenting opinion is not relevant to the cross-examination of witness…

        pangalawa-UTAK-IPIS ka YELLOW ZOMBIE TROUPER… kasi ang MAKA-KALIWANG kagaya mo ay bias sa mga maka-kaliwa din kaya ang HUMAN RIGHTS na sinasabi mo ay para lang sa inyo.. at once may masaktan o na-ambush na mga pulis o sundalo o na-abduct ng kalaban na mga sundalo o ibang opisyal ng gobyerno o kahit na civilian na inakusahan ninyong may simpatiya sa gobyerno… WALANG HUMAN RIGHTS….

      • antonioluna

        pepeng bugok, isa ka yatang sundalong matapang lang kapag walang armas ang nakaharap o kaya naman ay mga kaugali at kasamahan ng mga pumatay kay pestaño, para sa iyong kaalaman ang human rights ay nakisawsaw din sa kaso ni pestano na pinalalabas ng mga kapwa mo mamamatay sundalo na nagpakamatay daw, bugok ka nga.

        bukod pa sa hindi mo alam na ang commission on human rights ay binuo para bantayan ang mga pangaabuso ng taga gobyerno, lumalabas mas retarded ka pa eh nyaknyaknyak.

  • tamalang

    sana lahat ng witness kasing talino ni DELIMA at HENARES para matulala ang defense. 

    • Winn728

      Tama ka dyan. . .

      • RomyMacalintal

         Suck Drillon

      • Winn728

        Ikaw na lang. . .Gawain mo naman Un. . . PIKON. . .

        Ang PIKON, talo. . .Talo ka ba. . .hehehehehehe

      • RomyMacalintal

         Ikaw nga mahilig sa etits parang boss mo si Leila “Hilig Etits” De Lima

      • Winn728

        GAnun ka rin naman. . .Atty Romy “Etits” Macalintal. . . .Sori, d ak Abugado. .tulad mo. . . hehehe. . . .buti na lang.

        PIKON. . . .PIKON. . .Atty. PIKON

      • RomyMacalintal

         Baka nagkakamali ka hindi po ako attorney

        Jumping to conclusions ka naman agad
        Parang boss mo na mahilig sa etits

    • RomyMacalintal

       Nakakatalino pala ang pagkain ng etits araw-araw?

      • antonioluna

         hahaha garbage

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/AVTOQDZU5E2P7MZYTFY6L3NBPU Ping

    The LAW according to NOYNOY :
    Pag si Genuino CORRUPTION
    Pag si Naguiat  ABSOLUTION.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PN3VRDYP7ZZDTUHWG5R7RJSXWM raul n

      because naguiat has his full trust and confidence and the explanation is valid. It was naguiat terms that the permit was granted. Remember how many millions wort of coffee and the supplier is cornered by their crony. the income of pagcor is all time high compared to previous years. hence there was improvement in its operation.

      • adam_d_ant

        yada, yada, yada ..

        corruption and padulas  .. ‘yon ang sinabi …. he. he. he. tindi talaga ng mga alagad ni retard.

        ang mga nauuto nga naman ni budoy … ngeeee

  • JosephNess

    romy makalintal, ikaw nga ba yan ?…di maiconnect sa pagkatao mo ang mga pinglalagay mo rito…just curious sir…8-).

    • RomyMacalintal

       Me mga bagay na dapat sa tama
      At me mga bagay na hindi pwede sa tama lalo na kung me tama ang nag post

      • JosephNess

        a, okey, di ko lang kasi mapaniwalaan na manggaling itong mga ganitong pagsagot sa isang respetadong tao tulad mo, sir…no offense..8-).

      • RomyMacalintal

         Hindi ako lawyer

      • JosephNess

        o, sorry, just his namesake then…thanks for the info…

      • Guest

        Kupalistic

      • Guest

        As$hole

  • marriondale

    It’s good that De Lima admitted that she is not 100 percent sure that GMA will not come back when she travelled abroad.  The doctor’s testimonies to be presented today will not refute the fact that GMA is travelling abroad for her medical treatment, among others.  that’s GMA’s right if she wanted to seek medical treatment abroad and not here.  The escape reason concocted by DOJ will be watered down when the senator judges began inquiring from the DOJ secretary.  It’s very clear that Malacanang and not De Lima is bent on preventing GMA to travel abroad since De Lima is not convinced that GMA will not come back if De lima allowed her to leave. 

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/OXUONNBVG44QS2LJGCOELUDPXU Gil

    For the Prosecution’s spokesmen, It would be best that Cong. Tanada be the only one to speak for he sounds truthful. Cong.Quimbo appears to be “lying” through his head, and Cong.Angara struggling for his “white lies”.
    Sect. de Lima, with all due respects, appears to be “incompetent” in a witness stand, for the Prosecution at least.

  • yatot

    Delima under oath admitted that she defied the TRO. 

    A JUSTICE SECRETARY, A LAWYER BY PROFESSION DEFIED A LAWFUL ORDER?It can be a precedent. Sooner or later, even an ordinary citizen can break a law just because of presumptions. She is a disgrace to her Alma Mater and the law profession! Her name must be written off from barristers the soonest possible time. 

    • antonioluna

       paanong naging lawful order ang isang TRO na walang pang bisa dahil hindi pa nito nasunod ang mga kundisyon bago ito magkabisa?

      • yatot

        Ang TRO mismo ay lawful order. SC kaba para interpret mo ang TRO?

      • antonioluna

        SC ka rin ba para sabihin na lawful order yon?

    • http://www.crocphotos.com/ Catman John

      When I read the logic of Arroyo lackeys, one gets the feeling that corruption has deprived certain people of their common sense, and must think they are dealing with the stupidest people on earth. At the rate of this corruption, and denial by so many Arroyo Lackeys, you are bound to become the next dodo’s of a failed state. All you need is for Enrile and his little corrupt gang of thieves to set Corona free, thrown in a few more natural calamities, the rise of the rebels, justifiably against the entrenched corrupt, and you will see such a horrific reality. 

      • adam_d_ant

        you failed to mention that number one reason why the phils is going nowhere …

        the 15 million morons elected a retard to become president

        ang mga nauuto nga naman ni budoy …. ngeee

      • yatot

        Where can you find a place on earth that has no corruption? Even in your own homes, there is corruption!

        Corruption is everywhere in varying degrees! We choose leaders of lesser evil because they were all evil! Going to politics means evil! I am not saying that we tolerate corruption, but please, if you point your finger, like Aquino does, he should think that in his five fingers, three were directly pointing back to him.

  • Fakescthiefjustice

    Former Fake Pres. Arroyo , corruption and many 

    1. NBN ZTE Scandal

    2. Millions of bribe money to Congressmen and Governors 

    (October 2007)

    3. Cheating in 2004 Elections (HELLO GARCI)

    4. Joc Joc Bolante Case (Fertilizer Scam, P728 Million)

    5. JOSE PIDAL Bank Account (Unexplained Wealth, P200 

    Million)

    6. NANI PEREZ Power Plant Deal ($2 Million)

    7. Use of Road User’s Tax for Campaigning

    8. Billion Peso Macapagal Boulevard (Overprice of P532 

    Million)

    9. Juetengate? (Illegal Numbers game kickbacks)

    10. Extra Judicial Killings

    11. Arroyo Moneys in Germany (Exposed by Senator Cayetano)

    12. General GARCIA and Other Military Men

    13. Billion Peso Poll Automation contract to(Mega Pacific) 

    (P1.3 Billion)

    14. Northrail Project($503 Million)

    15.  Maguindanao Results of 2007 Elections (ZUBIRI, BEDOL)

    16.  NAIA-3

    17.  Venable Contract (Norberto Gonzales)

    18.  Swine Scam (Exposed by? Atty. Harry Roque

    19. GLORIA Arroyo son hidden assets in united states

    20. EURO GENERAL’S

    21. CALAMITY FUND SCANDAL.

    22.  C-5 road controversy — Senator Manuel Villar

    23.P550-million worth of funds from the Overseas Workers’ 

    Welfare Administration (OWWA).

    24. P780-million LWUA funds-PROSPERO PICHAY

    25. BISHOPS’s SUV-Gloria Birthday gift

    26. Arroyo linked in P325M lotto intelligence fund

    27. Arroyo got P200M in kickbacks from govt projects-Zaldy 

    Ampatuan 

    28. P200.41 billion or $4.6 billion in Malampaya royalties 

    from 2002 to May this year.

    29.LACSON ACCUSED FG MIKE ARROYO OF SELLING 3  REFURBISHED 

    HELICOPTERS TO PNP AT P105 MILLION EACH

    30. 600,000 metric tons of Rotten rice imported from 

    India.Kishore Hemlani, an Indian trader allegedly close to 

    Arroyo, reportedly bagged the P9.5 billion contract for 

    the rice importation. 

    31. DATO ARROYO wife bought the condo unit for $570,000, 

         70-square-meter one-bedroom, one-bathroom unit (Unit 

    No. 533) at the luxury high-rise, full-service Gramercy 

    Towers located at 1177 California St. in upscale downtown 

    San 
    Francisco.

    32.- P50-million bribe to FG for the president’s veto of 

    two franchise bills

    33. The additional funding led to a 41-percent spike in  

    advertising expenses, from P76.129 million in 2008 to 

    P107.420 million in 2009, which went mostly to ads for 

    Arroyo’s achievements.

    34. The report said the PIA received from the Department 

    of Budget and Management a notice of cash allocations 

    amounting to P344.789 million, even though only P222.488 
    million was appropriated for it under the national budget.

    35.- Denial of pork barrel funds to Malacanang’s political 

     enemies

    36.- Praises for Jovito Palparan, alleged mastermind of 

    extra judicial killings of militants

    37.- Removal of govt bodyguards for former pres and Arroyo 

     critic, Cory Aquino

    38.- Appointment of manicurist as a member of the board of 

     Pag-Ibig

    39. Appointment of gardener as deputy of the Luneta Park  

    Administration.

    40. MIDNIGHT APPOINTMENT of Fake President Arroyo,RENATO CORONA, as SC 

    Thief Justice

          200+ other illegal midnight appointments

    41.- MIKEY ARROYO’s undeclared properties in California

    42.- Pardon of controversial convicted criminals like 

    Ninoy’s murderers

    43.- EO 464; requiring Cabinet members to seek 

    presidential clearance before testifying in Congress 

    hearings

    44.- Promise (on Rizal Day) to not run for the presidency 

    in 2004

    45.- “Vote Buying” by giving away Philhealth cards

    46.- Taxpayers’ money for her giant billboards and and 

    PCSO tv campaign ads[/b]

    47- Appointment of Ben Abalos, a staunch GMA ally, as 

    COMELEC chair

    48.- Mikey Arroyo’s importation of 32 thoroughbred horses 

    from Australia worth P384 million.

    49.Former First Gentleman Mike Arroyo used 2 choppers 16 

    times, son Mikey 69

    50.PNoy: PAGCOR spent P1 BILLION on coffee

    51.Jose Miguel Arroyo owned helicopters’
    all Robinson R44 Raven Is with Series Nos. 1370 to 1374
    A total of $1,423,025 was paid to Lionair for the five 

    helicopters.

    52.Pagcor ‘pabaon’ to Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo: P345M

    53.The godmother’s ties to the Pinedas(Jueteng lord)

    54. Glorietta 2 and Batasan bombings

        The Glorietta 2 bombing happened during the height of 

    the bribery case which took place in Malacañang.

    55. Misuse of Balikatan funds Navy Lt. Nancy Gadian 

    revealed an alleged malversation of funds in 2007

    56. Solon: Charge Gloria Arroyo for taking P98-M from 

    PNoy’s social fund

    57. 50 MILLION PABAON GENERALS

        Former Armed Forces chiefs of staff Narciso Abaya, 

    Dionisio Santiago, Generoso Senga, Hermogenes Esperon, and 

    Alexander Yano,chiefs of staff – Angelo Reyes, Diomedio  

    Villanueva, and Roy Cimatu and MANY MORE..

    58.Colmenares: GMA had P488 billion in ‘pork.

    59. P1 BILLION down the drain in Arroyo-era jatropha 

    project—DOST chief 
    60.Fishers push plunder rap vs Arroyo in purchase of ice machines( overpriced at P455 million in 2009.)
    61.$225-million overprice of Metro Rail Transit Corp. (MRTC), 
    62.Ongpin “front” for former First Gentleman Mike Arroyo in a P660-million loan from the Development Bank of the Philippines (DBP)…
    63.sale of the old Iloilo airport for P1.2 billion to Megaworld Corp. in 2007

    • Bobbie_mae

      GMA and FG have sooo much money they are still able to buy so many people in gov’t and thwart justice. 

      • adam_d_ant

        kano ang bilihan?

        nabili na si retard?

        ang mga nauuto nga naman ni budoy … ngeee

  • ukoysakabo

    Hahaha

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_5OC4T6FDZYN5RCVEAFH2YBMNSM Don

    “Many of us believe that wrongs aren’t wrong if it’s done by nice people like ourselves.” – Anon

  • CyberPinoy

    When asked by Cuevas if there was a conspiracy among justices that led to the issuance of the TRO, De Lima said: “The conspiracy because they issued the questionable TRO? Well, the Chief Justice is only one vote of course when it comes to decisions. But there are other things, there are other duties, functions and powers of the Chief Justice as primus inter pares.”Cuevas cut her off and said she was not responding to the question.- Dito palang makikita om na mabagal at palpak ang prosecutors, dapat nag counter sila kay Cuevas para ituloy ni Delima ang statement nya ang kaso pinutol na ni Cuevas bago pa magsabi ng “YES” si Delima. Ang kinalabasan nito sa mata ni Enrile hindi sigurado si De Lima kung may conspiracy nga sa TRO, ang bagal kasi ng Prosecutor na outclass nanaman sila ni Cuevas.Medyo tagilid padin ang prosecutors dito kasi Delima admits its not only Corona who decides and the truth is ang pag issue ng TRO ay isang botohan ng mga Justice. Its not only Corona who voted “YES” to TRO but majoroty of the Justice also voted “YES” to TRO. 

    • indiosbravos2002

      I agree what the prosecutors need is a counsel na maangas rin on technicalities. Papatay patay kasi mga nahire nila na private prosecutors. Why dont they they get the services of the old timers na lawyers like Saguisag or whoever who can play toe to toe with CUEVAS.

  • oracle888

    In supporting JP Enrile’s ousting of PAL vice president of sale as prosecution’s witness, Senator Miriam said, “When I voted against opening the second envelop (during former President Joseph Estrada’s impeachment), unless the prosecution amended their information, my basis was due process of law, that is what is happening now,” she stressed.

    Why did she keep bringing the “second envelop” matter up? Is she regretting that she did not open it? or is she trying to justify what she has done?

    Must have a lot of nightmare having conscience bothering her.

    • adam_d_ant

      hindi mo lang nasakyan ang ibig sabihin ni miriam  ….

      ang mga nauuto nga naman ni budoy ….ngeee

  • CyberPinoy

    When asked by Cuevas if there was a conspiracy among justices that led to the issuance of the TRO, De Lima said: “The conspiracy because they issued the questionable TRO? Well, the Chief Justice is only one vote of course when it comes to decisions. But there are other things, there are other duties, functions and powers of the Chief Justice as primus inter pares.”Cuevas cut her off and said she was not responding to the question.

    – Dito palang makikita om na mabagal at palpak ang prosecutors, dapat nag counter sila kay Cuevas para ituloy ni Delima ang statement nya ang kaso pinutol na ni Cuevas bago pa magsabi ng “YES” si Delima. Ang kinalabasan nito sa mata ni Enrile hindi sigurado si De Lima kung may conspiracy nga sa TRO, ang bagal kasi ng Prosecutor na outclass nanaman sila ni Cuevas.

    Medyo tagilid padin ang prosecutors dito kasi Delima admits its not only Corona who decides and the truth is ang pag issue ng TRO ay isang botohan ng mga Justice. Its not only Corona who voted “YES” to TRO but majoroty of the Justice also voted “YES” to TRO.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/OXUONNBVG44QS2LJGCOELUDPXU Gil

    News reports nowadays, are subjected to “profiling”. But no matter what, the truth always come out.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/CWFTC6N7TLQGE3J4CQCRTZESPQ handsomeb

    1. Surging Gas Prices
    2. Increasing Prices of Basic Commodities
    3. Stupid Prosecution Team
    4. An Impeachment Court wasting Money on what could have been placed in Negros
    5. Sendong Victims still with no home and Food
    6. Negros Victims with No Food to eat
    7. Mining and logging Companies still Operating in Mindanao
    … I can go on and on kaso wala na ako pera pang Internet. 
    Ung nanay at Tatay ko wala na mabigay pati pamasahe ko.

    • sonic91

       at hanggang hindi nawawal sa puwesto yang mga ka-alyado ni Gloria, wala ni-isa sa mga hiling mo ang matutupad..

      • jaygibi

        hanggang nasa pwesto si Abnoy, lalong masasadlak sa kahirapan ang pinas.. Grace Lee at CJ Corona lang ang inaasikaso.

      • adam_d_ant

        at hanggang walang nagagawa si retard, si gloria ang ready excuse.

        ang mga nauuto nga naman ni budoy … ngeee

    • JosephNess

      kawawa ka naman pre, kasama mo ako riyan, kaya lang, magkaiba tayong pananaw sa buhay, payong kapatid pare, wag ka kasing umasa ng husto sa gobyerno, siguro naman may nalalaman kang puwedeng gawin mo na makakatulong sa magulang mo para di ka na makadagdag pa sa pasanin nila ano, gamitin mo pre ang iyong mga kaalaman kung gusto mong makatulong sa magulang mo at magkaroon tuloy ng sapat na pera na pang internet mo, maraming puwedeng gawin pre, gamitin mo lamang sa tama ang laman ng nasa ulo mo…8-)).

      • BB_Tanggal_Ari_vs_Tabing_Itlog

        Tama ka Josephness, dapat isipin ni Handsomeb (Handsome nga ba??) kung ano ang maitutulong nya sa bayan (Pinas) at hindi kung ano ang itutulong ng bayan sa kanya (Quote from former US Pres.).
        Sabi nga kay ..~ John kaya ikaw magsumikap ka! wag ka palamunin o puro asa sa gobyerno tulongan natin ang gobyerno!!
        Sama-sama nating ayusin, baguhin at alisin ang mga masasamang ugali natin… para sa pag-asenso ng Pinas. Alisin ang mga taong di karapat dapat sa gobyerno. Tanggalin ang mga magnanakaw at makasariling tao.

      • adam_d_ant

        at alisin din ang mga namumuno na me sayad sa ulo …

        ang mga nauuto nga naman ni budoy …. ngeee

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/3KZZAMTXYDWX3DIBTSP4FECOOA Yengg

        sorry kana lang budoy, engot lang ang susunod sau, hahahahahahahahh….

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/3KZZAMTXYDWX3DIBTSP4FECOOA Yengg

        I agree with you, na inspired lalo ako sa cinabi mo…

      • NoronJamel

        I agree with you, si PNoy ba dapat maghanap ng isusubo mo? Ganda p naman name nia Hansomeb, baka meaning e “Handsome Batugan”!hi!hi!hi! Dapat araw-araw ito siyang kantahan ng “Kaya ikaw Handsomeb, magsumikap ka”, same don drama nila Dolphy na “John & Marsha” before!

      • adam_d_ant

        sis retard maghahanp ng “isusubo”?  excuse me … hina ng type ni retard ..

        ang mga nauuto nga naman ni budoy … ngeeee

      • adam_d_ant

        pero dapat hindi s’ya gumaya sa ‘yo “PRE” .. kung nagtanim ka ng kamote rather na nakikitsismis ka dito, me mauula ang mga magulang mo

        ang mga nauuto nga naman ni budoy … ngeee

      • JosephNess

        hahahaha…ayan ka na naman langgam as in tanga sa bikol…yan gayahin mo ko, pre, nageenjoy na ako ng buhay, wala na rin akong mga magulang, at wala na rin akong pinapag-aral, tapus na sila, dahil yan sa mga tinanim kong kamote, sabi mo, kaw nga, di mo inaatupag trabaho mo, andito ka nakikipagtsismis lang, baka mahuli ka ng boss mo masisante ka pa…gayahin mo ako, sa mga paghihirap kong pagtatanim ng kamote, sabi mo yan ha, ito na ako, reaping the harvest of my labor…kaya, payo sayo brother, magsipag ka lalo, nang meron namang mapala sayo itong lupa mong tinubuan…ha !!!, sige na, trabaho ka muna…

      • adam_d_ant

        he. he. he… nag-eenjoy ka sa buhay … parang si budoy … para din si retard  … wala ka ng magulang … suwerte ng magulang mo .. hindi nilanakitang nagpaloko ka sa retard  ..

        he. he. he… hindi ko din kailangan magtanim … me nagtatanim para sa akin … hindi ko din kailangan maging uto-uto  … ni hindi ko nga kailangan ngumuya  .. me ngumunguya para sa akin … meron ka n’yan? 

        aaliwin ko na lang ang mga kampon ng retard  … kawawa ka naman …. pag nanakit ka pa kawawanaman  mga neighbors mo …. …

        ang mga nauuto talaga ni budoy …. ngeee

      • JosephNess

        paano magiging kawawa pre, eh, eto nga eni-enjoy ko na yong pinagtrabahuhan ko…wala na nga akong pinag-aaral tapus na lahat anak ko, kaya eto, masarap na lang nagliliwaliw kung saan saan…siguro, kamag anak mo si budoy no,  pre…sa ginagawa mo nga dahil nga langgam ka, tanga sng tawaag sa bikol non,  uto-uto ka nga…hahahahahaha…

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/3KZZAMTXYDWX3DIBTSP4FECOOA Yengg

        cino nauto mo ngayon budoy?, hahahahaha pweehhh…
        sarili mo lang uncle o mag trabaho ka daw di yung kong ano ano cinusulat mong walang ka logic logic, heheheeheheh….

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/3KZZAMTXYDWX3DIBTSP4FECOOA Yengg

      tamad ka naman pala ang dami momg reklamo, mahiya ka sa sarili mo. gumawa ka ng magandang paraan para may pamasahe ng makapag net at baka matauhan kapa iba ang sasabihin mo sa comment, hay sus…

  • Fakescthiefjustice

    Midnight appointment of a Fake President Arroyo,Renato Corona, as Fake SC Chief Justice- 200+ other illegal midnight appointments

    • jaygibi

      including you, fake human being.. taga ibang planeta…

  • Ulipur

    Travels of Renato/Cristina

    Manila-Guam (April 20, 2011), Guam-Manila (April 24, 2011)

    • Manila-Singapore (April 15, 2011), Singapore-Manila (April 19, 2011)

    • Manila-Honolulu, Hawaii (Dec. 25, 2010), Honolulu, Hawaii-Manila (Dec. 30, 2010)

    • Manila-Hong Kong (December 20, 2010,) Hong Kong-Manila (Dec. 21, 2010).

    Mrs. Tina Corona’s foreign and domestic PAL trips

    • Manila-Jakarta, Indonesia (July 10, 2011), Jakarta, Indonesia-Manila (July 15 2011)

    • Manila-Guam (April 20, 2011), Guam-Manila (April 24, 2011)

    • Manila-Singapore (April 15, 2011), Singapore-Manila (April 19, 2011)

    • Manila-Bangkok, Thailand (March 4, 2011), Manila-Bangkok, Thailand (March 7, 2011)

    • Manila-Honolulu, Hawaii (Dec. 25, 2010), Manila-Honolulu, Hawaii (Dec. 30, 2010)

    • Manila-Hong Kong (Dec. 18, 2010) Hong Kong-Manila (Dec. 21, 2010)

    • Manila-Bacolod (July 28, 2011), Bacolod-Manila (July 28, 2011)

    • Manila-General Santos City (June 3, 2011), General Santos City- Manila (June 4, 2011)

    • Manila-Cebu (March 18, 2011), Cebu-Manila (March 19, 2011)

    • Manila-Tagbiliran (March 22 and 24, 2011), Tagbiliran-Manila (March 24, 2011)

    • Manila-General Santos City (March 2, 2011), Manila-General Santos City (March 3, 2011)

    • Manila-Cebu (Feb. 15 and 16, 2011), Cebu-Manila (Feb. 16, 2011).

    Other than free tickets in First or Business Class, at any day or
    time they wish to board a PAL flight, the Coronas enjoyed unlimited
    baggage allowance that came with being a PAL Platinum Card holder.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_STBRRMGDSSWIJEPGUZMV7CLC4Y Marcial

      di daw yan bribery sabi ni ENRILE, as this is not alleged in the ARTICLES of IMPEACHMENT, it is unethical for a THIEF JUSTICE to accept this kind of perks, wittingly or unwittingly, wla sya delicadeza, considering that PAL has case at PASAF, this is indirect GIFTS of BRIBERY….malinaw sa sikat ng araw…Companies offered and give this kind of privileged na me purpose at me kapalit siempre in return.wlang private company na me vested interest na manlilibre kung wlang kapalit ito for sure.. IN SHORT CORONA has no DELICADEZA…in short CORRUPT sya in ROBES… 

      • indiosbravos2002

        Its true the prosecution fu@ked up the writing of the complaint, but if the evidense is already right in front of your face what would a responsible judge/senator do in our country? Berate the prosecutor and ask the witness to go home.

      • adam_d_ant

        no  .. berate the prosecutors because they are dumb …. by the way, alam mo ba kung saan ang barberya ni “tsupa”?

        ang mga nauuto nga naman ni budoy … ngeee

      • Bobbie_mae

        If this were the US — Corona would have been asked to resign simply for accepting free tickets from PAL given that there was an on-going case in the supreme court between PAL and FASAP. I wonder when we will learn to demand that standard of integrity from our judges? 

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PN3VRDYP7ZZDTUHWG5R7RJSXWM raul n

        pakapalan lang yan kasi wala sa mga lawyers ang ethics, morality, probity because these are subjective. ang objectivity lang ang gusto ng mga lawyers. kasi yan ang technicality ng law

      • adam_d_ant

        if this were the u.s., aquino will never be elected president .. kahit na nga siguro trustee  …. nahahalta kaagad ang tamad doon

        ang mga nauuto nga naman ni budoy … ngeee

      • adam_d_ant

        kayang galit sa kanya si retard  .. aba si corona naka bestida  … samantala ang bruha hindi puwedeng magladlad .. type pa naman ang terno .

        ang mga nauuto talga ni budoy … ngeeee

    • Pablo Juan

       who else is a “platinum” card holder? maybe some senators even? protect the perks and trappings of the rich, powerful and infamous!

    • jaygibi

      inggit ka lang!

    • alexfrommactan

      Ulipur, the question is which comes first? The issuance of platinum card or these travels? Looking at these travels, I would not be surprised that Corona will be issued with platinum card.

      Due to some company travels, I was issued with platinum hotel card also due to months of stays in the hotel. And it normal to get some perk out of it. I had both free flights within Asia and free hotel stays.I was even once upgraded to business class international flight with the price of an economy.  It a normal company policy for customer loyalty. But you have to earn it with prior travels or hotel stays, and then you can use it on your next travels.

      If platinum card was first issued prior to Coronas travel that allows for Platinum card issuance, then that is something not usual and needs to be checked or investigated. But until that is established, nothing unusual there.

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PN3VRDYP7ZZDTUHWG5R7RJSXWM raul n

        yes but you have to earn a lot of mileage first to avail such perks. with what was presented as his itinerary by the pal officer  he could have gone around the world for 5 times first just to earn this perks including that of his wife  let alone the bigger baggage allowance because that platinum card of yours are actually loyalty points that have accrued with frequent travel.

      • adam_d_ant

        sus me  .. subokan mong kuning ang travel ng mga government officials natin … try mo lang   … baka ka matauhan ..

        ang mga nauuto talaga ni budoy … ngeee

      • alexfrommactan

         That is precisely my question. To paint that Corona is doing something bad because he has a platinum card is a bias or jumping to the corruption bandwagon without knowing the  entire facts.
        The proper question is did he qualified to received platinum cards based on his previous travels? If an ordinary professional like me got a platinum card, how much more a CJ?

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PN3VRDYP7ZZDTUHWG5R7RJSXWM raul n

        i am jumping to conclusion because with such distances travelled he must have been travelling most of the time. I should know because the mileage points can be computed before you can avail the free perks. As I have said he must have gone around the world five times already and paid for his stay in most hotels with pay that has an alliance with PAL to earn points. But with such itinerary? can you earn points and accumulate that much every year? you must have been a jet setter already.

      • alexfrommactan

        You are indeed jumping to conclusion.That is convenient especially if we dont like Corona or if we are Pinoys supporters. Again, do we know if the platinum membership was given before or after these travels?

        By the way in my knowledge, in PAL there is NO so called Platinum Membership for rewards as mentioned by the prosecution. The membership are only base, elite, premier elite and million miler. So is is the platinum award a new one or something made up again?

    • noeltabaz2

      Can these be related to the SC decision reversing its own decision with finality involving the PAL employees.

  • scank

    AKO SI RENATO CORONA- ANG BUWAYANG NILIKHA NI GLORIA AT MIKE BUWAYA ARROYO SA KORTE SUPREMA.

    AKO SI RENATO CORONA- ANG BUWAYANG NILIKHA NI GLORIA AT MIKE BUWAYA ARROYO PARA PROTEKTAHAN  ANG MAGASAWA LABAN SA KURAKUTAN AT NAKAWAN GINAWA NOONG NASA NINAKAW NG TRONO.

    AKO SI RENATO CORONA- ANG BUWAYANG NILIKHA NI GLORIA AT MIKE BUWAYA ARROYO PARA MAGNAKAW AT MANGURAKOT NG BILYONG PERAN NG BAYAN. 

    AKO SI RENATO CORONA- ANG BUWAYANG NILIKHA NI GLORIA AT MIKE BUWAYA ARROYO PARA PALABASIN WALANG PAGKAKASALA SI GLORIA AT MIKE SA TAUMBAYAN.

      

    • adam_d_ant

      ako si ninay ..ang dalaga sa palasyo ….

      ang mga kakampi ko kapareho ko =me mga sayad.

      ang mga nauuto nga naman ni budoy …. ngeee

  • alexfrommactan

    One of the reason the supreme court issued a TRO is because no case was filed yet during that time. But when the case was filed, even SC’s spokeman mentioned that might render TRO moot. It is not SC’s or Coronas fault that Pnoy’s men are slow.

    SC’s TRO was mainly based on the facts that no case filed against GMA and that GMA left 8 times already  for medical check and had consistently come back.

    • NoronJamel

      You are wrong Mr. Alexfrommactan, if you had read well the conditions set by the SC, the 3rd condition was impossible to accomplished for such short period that would never enable the Arroyos to comply with, but then even before the announcement of Pinkie Marques about the TRO, the Arroyos were already at the airport ready to depart! Sec. de Lima was and still right in not allowing the boss of Thief Justice Coronarroyo to leave the country.

    • Ulipur

      Pero nitong tangkang huling pag-alis may kasama silang taga-peke ng passport.

      kaya kahit hindi nga bumalik at kanselahin ng DFA  passports nila ay magagawan pa rin ng paraan

      na makagawa ng passports at iba pang travel documents.

  • scank

    AKO SI RENATO CORONA- ANG BUWAYANG NILIKHA NI GLORIA AT MIKE BUWAYA ARROYO PARA MAGING THIEF JUSTICE NG KORTE SUPREMA AT MAGING HARI SA LAHAT NG KALOKOHAN SA KORTE.

    AKO SI RENATO CORONA- ANG BUWAYANG NILIKHA NI GLORIA AT MIKE BUWAYA ARROYO PARA MAGNAKAW NG MARAMING ARI-ARIAN BAHAY SA MANILA.

    AKO SI RENATO CORONA- ANG BUWAYANG NILIKHA NI GLORIA AT MIKE BUWAYA ARROYO PARA MAGING MACHO SA BABAE . SAMPU LANG NAMAN ASAWA KO.

    • jaygibi

      buwaya ka nga katulad ng 188 crocodiles sa lower house..

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PN3VRDYP7ZZDTUHWG5R7RJSXWM raul n

        mas grabe na buwaya na mas malaki pa kang lolong ang mga arroyo. matok mo 9years na president bumalik sa congress kasama dalawang anak. LOL

    • adam_d_ant

      ako si ninay aquino . .. nilikha ni kristeta para maging “dalaga”  /// ang dami ko atang mga lalakwe  ..

      ang mga nauuto nga naman ni budoy … ngeee

  • AbangPinoy

    Nagtataka lang ako????? bakit kaya daming nagagalit ki PNOY ngayon, samantalang sa administration lang nya maraming nabubulgar na corrupt officials, abusadong militar, illegal na transactions…… siguro yun tira-ng-tira kay PNOY ay yun tinatamaan ng kanyang plataporma “against corrupt gov’t officials”….. nasanay na siguro ang mga pinoy na kinukorakot lang ng mga politiko at gov’t officials yun pinaghirapang buwis ng mamamayan Filipino…… to tell you honestly, di ako bumoto ki PNOY pero sa pananaw ko tama yun diskarte nya na i-convict yun mga matataas na officials na corrupt, kc feeling ng mga iyan na “untouchables sila” atleast me ma-example sa panahon n PNOY para matakot naman yung mga “Kurakot” na yan. Saka yun mga nangyayaring kamalasan k PNOY ay namana lang nya….. kapabayaan to ng nakaraan administration…… walang mangyayari ng kadadakdak at kapupuna nating sa Gobyerno….. tumulong tayo at makipagtulungan….. kung sabagay me mga tao na walang alam kundi pumuna at mamintas lang kesa gumawa ng paraan, marami dyan!!!!

    • jaygibi

      nagtataka lang kung hanggang ngayon ay wala pang accomplishment si Pnoy.. 2 bagay lang ang pnagtutuunan niya ng panahon.. si Grace Lee at CJ Corona.. Ano na nangyari sa hacienda luisita? sa mga biktima ng mendiola massacre nung panahon ni cory? sa ekonomiyang 3%GDP pabagsak? (minana niya sa nagdaang admin ay 7% GDP). kay Llamas na bumili ng pirated DVD? sa pagbigay niya ng 5million s mga MILF? (na kalaban ng AFP n siya ang commander-in-chief), kay Gaudencio Pangilinan, BuCor Director, na kinasuhan ng Graft? sa reccomendation ni delima sa Luneta hostage drama, may nakasuhan b? nagtatanong lang…..

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PN3VRDYP7ZZDTUHWG5R7RJSXWM raul n

        mas grabe ang second hand helicopter ni FG na halata na syang may ari. of course what can you expect from an inherited bankrupt economy of gloria na artificial growth driven by too much spending of govt money resulting to an all time high of deficit in govt. budget.

      • jimiji

        lilinawin ko lang ang tungkol kay grace lee….itinatanggi na niya na may relasyon sila o nanliligaw ba…..kathang-isip

      • noeltabaz2

        Also, people must respect the President’s privacy.  He is entitled to that.

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/3KZZAMTXYDWX3DIBTSP4FECOOA Yengg

        alam mo kaibigan ito ang mga taong manhid o mga kaalyado din ciguro to ng mga magnanakaw din kaya takot din to na mahuli ang pinaka mag nanakaw at baka cila naman ang susunod na mahuli.

        ang mga utak nito hindi matuwid, ang matuwid pilit na binabaloktot makalusot lang cila ng ibig sabihin nila kahit mali
        pweeeehhh.. here only in the phils. we have so many idiots and stupid, huhuhuhuhuhuhhu….

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/3KZZAMTXYDWX3DIBTSP4FECOOA Yengg

        may pagkakataon ka nang ligawan ci grace lee… heheheheheh…

      • AngNagmamasid

        ssshhhh.huwag kayong maingay at baka malaman ni grace na girlfriend na siya ni pnoy.

    • jimiji

      anong mga binulgar niya? mga corrupt officials nung nakaraang administrasyon. tandaan mo na ang kanyang mga kaalyado ay di niya binubulgar ang katiwalian at korapsyon. at hanggang ngayon wala pa rin siyang malinaw na nagawang kabutihan sa ating bayan

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_WRTZ6LHZGZH4SASHWEDVMYF5MI Edward

         hindi mo naman kasi maiaalis ang mga corrup officials palaging nandyan yan pero tandaan mo din sa panahon ni gloria sobrang lantaraan ang pag nanakaw. ano bang nagawa ni gloria sa modernization ng armed forces? kahit nga yata bangkang papel hindi sya bumili .

  • scank

    AKO SI RENATO CORONA- ANG BUWAYANG NILIKHA NI GLORIA AT MIKE BUWAYA ARROYO PARA MAGHARI SA KORTE SUPREMA  AT MALIBRE ANG MAGASAWANG BUWAYA SA PAQGKAKASALA SA TAUMBAYAN.

    AKO SI RENATO CORONA- ANG BUWAYANG NILIKHA NI GLORIA AT MIKE BUWAYA ARROYO PARA MAGNAKAW NG BILYONG DOLYAR AT ITAGO SA IBANG BANSA. MARAMI KAMING NAKATAGONG DOLYAR SA AMERICA KASI NARRON ANG KABIT KONG SI EVA.  

    • AngNagmamasid

      BUHAY PA PALA ANG MABAHONG SKUNK NA ITO.

  • Yahilawod

     I don’t know what’s in Enrile’s mind. He sure knows that’s the best way to conduct this trial. He’s a lawyer but he’s more of a politician now. I think he had that ambition before to become a chief justice, the ultimate aspiration of a lawyer. Now, by accident or by destiny, he suddenly is in that position, or perhaps one more powerful than a CJ. I think it is the suddenness that put him in this awkward position – a political animal acting like a judge of a court of law. My 2 cents advise to Manong Johnny: get over with that childhood ambition to become the alpha dog of his law profession, be true to his duty as a true statesman, fire Corona from his usurped position, and redeem himself, at least for posterity’s sake. That is, and i pray, that it’s not really that hard to teach an old dog new tricks. 

    • JosephNess

      that’s acting liberal…just like saying, those who hear…decide according to your intelligence…that’s the way he showed himself, the way I see this…

  • DinngMae

    The testimony of DOJ Sec. Leila de Lima was irrelevant as far as the impeachment court is concerned but what was relevant and significant are the contents of what she said and these could have some ramification on the decision-making of the Senator-judges in the tribunal.

    De Lima’s narration, even if inadmissible in the court as oral evidence, provided a clear picture of what transpired before the suspected plunderer tried to escape into another country. Her detailed account mesmerized the tribunal that she was provided leeway to complete the whole picture of how the chief magistrate was connected to such highly irregular actions made by the Supreme Court.

    The onus of contention is not about the majority vote in the granting of TRO but the question of how it could be applied when the petitioner failed to comply with its requirements. The omission of Chief Justice Corona was he made it appear that there was conformity so that the TRO could be made executory when there was none. Thus, it is very clear of the partiality of the respondent.

    The motive to let the suspected ravager escape is well defined and what made matters worse was the Supreme Court, thru its spokesman, delivered and tried to shovel up the TRO by means of press conference so that the suspected pillager of the country’s wealth who was waiting at the airport could remain scot-free.

    If the suspected great depredator, who is not yet dead contrary to her petition of right to life was allowed to let go, the Filipino people would be crying in shame while she basks under the sun with a margarita in hand somewhere in Central America.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PN3VRDYP7ZZDTUHWG5R7RJSXWM raul n

      ang sakit lang pala ay simpleng rayuma sa leeg..search mo sa google..and try to talk with medical expert..it is not very life threatening na pinapalabas ng artistang arroyo na peke na presidente

    • noeltabaz2

      Well said.  It was good that the DOJ Secretary stood firm regarding the hold departure order.  Not only she would be basking under the sun with a margarita in hand but also with an ear to ear smile.  Laughing loud, too, that she was again able to pull one over the Filipino people.

    • yatot

      Pwede pala sa yo ang BAKA at DAW!

      Thang Inha nyo!

  • sonic91

    nakaka-lungkot ang desisyon ng senado patungkol sa article 3 at article 7. Bilang isang karaniwang filipino citizen, hindi ko mapaniwalaan na hindi mapapanagot ang mga justices sa kanilang mga boto sa supreme court.

    Hindi naman ang kapangyarihan at ang pangkalahatang desisyon ng Supreme court ang kinukuwestiyon dito eh, kundi ang mga kanahina-hinalang motibo ng isang justice na nag-udyok sa kanya na bumoto ng ganon.

    Hindi naman dahil isa kang justice ay kahit ano na lang iboboto mo. Kailangang may accountability ang isang justice sa kanyang boto, kaya dapat imbestigahan kung may masama siyang motibo na magpapa-tunay na siya ay nagkasala ng “betrayal of public trust”.

    Tandaan po natin na ito ay isang impeachment case, at hindi criminal case. Hindi kailangang patunayan na may naganap na bribery o anumang kriminal activity, ang kailangan lang patunayan ay kung may “betrayal of public trust” ba talaga. Kaya kailangan tingnan ang bawat anggolo kung may nag-udyok ba talaga sa isang justice para magkaroon ng masamang motibo sa kanyang desisyon.

    • yatot

      Kalokohan yang iniisip mo!

      Impeachment man o criminal case, pareho dapat ang process/procedures/presentation sa hearing at sa treatment of witnesses and evidences.

      Otherwise gagawa tayo ng Bachelor of Laws major in Impeachment.

      Hahahahahahaha

  • adoremus

    Yung iba rito ay tulog pa pala hanggang ngayon. Ngayon lang daw nabubulgar ang mga corrupt eh habang buhay ng puro corrupt ang mga tao sa gobyerno. Walang mabuti diyan kung hindi pagbutihin na lang ang economy nga bansa dahil aminin man o hindi, yang corruption ay pasalin-salin lang. Kung hindi aasikasuhin ang economy, lalaong masakit ang epekto nito sa mga mahihirap. Ang problema pa, yung mga corrupt lang na hindi kakampi ang tinutugis, at yung mga kaalyado, “standard” lang daw yon. Funny talaga itong mga clown na ito, kakahiya na tuloy makilalang Filipino sa ibang bansa dahil sa nagyayari sa bansa at sa gobyerno. Showbiz na showbiz!

    • noeltabaz2

      It is true that there are people in the government that are corrupt.  But it is incorrect to issue a sweeping statement that all government servants are corrupt. 

      The manner you have written your comment, you seem to know people in the government (not allied with the President) that are corrupt and not being charged or just being tolerated by the administration.

      Maybe to test the sincerity of the President in going after the corrupt people in the government you can name names so proper charges can be made against those corrupt government officials or personnel.  Just a word of caution, you have to come out with solid evidence and not just base your accusation on mere hearsay or personal perception.  Any accusation must stand in court.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_NXU2XGAHFDYLAQULE3TMTR6SWU Brando

    A country ran by laws not by men. We must live in this kind of environment. Otherwise, we become a lawless nation. Remember this always. 

    • parefrank

       Tell this to Noy and look what he would say: “True, but I am the law”

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_KZEBAUGBBXOSZBPR5HUZGZXV5U andy bonifacio

    The issue is the impropriety of the act to allow an accused to escape. While it may have been done in connivance  with the others appointed by the accused, it is clear he is also part of the impropriety and is therefore guilty as charged.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_NXU2XGAHFDYLAQULE3TMTR6SWU Brando

    Defiance to the SC’s TRO on this particular case by no less than the DOJ Secretary was in every sense contemptous.  She should get punished so that no one would follow what she did in the future.

    • pugadlawin21

      Here in the US contempt of court is a guaranteed jail time whoever you are.

      • yatot

        Here in the Philippines, TRO is defied by a lawyer and the Secretary of Justice herself.

        Only in the Philippines!

  • eli_mejia

    At this point in time, it is no longer the legal issue that matters. It is now more on INTEGRITY, CHARACTER, and MORAL FITNESS. Siyanga pala fellow citizens, do you realize the consequence ng pagsawsaw ng INC sa kasong ito? It will certainly sway the Senators decisions on this issue. Malapit na ang midterm election and they certainly, want the INC vote. If they voted to convict Corona, they will lose it.

    • thunderbolt01

      INC are against Aquino not Corona. So all of aquino’ s allies should watch out next election.

      • noeltabaz2

        INC are not against any politician.  They are friends to everyone who is able to pay the price.  Members have no right to vote.  They are required/dictated who to vote to by their spiritual leader, who of course, received the pay off.   

      • AbangPinoy

        Sir igalang naman nating ang karapatan ng ibang religion, like you, Christian din ako pero iginagalang ko ang bawat relihiyon na may takot sa Amang Lumikha!!!! alalahanin mo lahat ng religion ay puro pagpuri sa Amang Lumikha ang itinuturo, kapag saliwa dito at di na tama ang itinuturo ay ito ay itinuturing ng “kulto”

      • noeltabaz2

        I am sorry, but I don’t get you. Where did I write that I showed disrespect to other religion?

    • BoyWaray

      Indeed, it is the INTEGRITY, CHARACTER, and MORAL FITNESS of PeNoy and his minions in Congress that is the real issue here.

      PeNoy’s LACK OF INTEGRITY by bribing Congressmen with pork barrel to sign the impeachment (when these same Congressmen are equally corrupt, even more so).

      PeNoy’s DICTATORIAL CHARACTER to control the Supreme Court with a tainted Justice  Carpio to pursue his personal goals (including the Hacienda Luisita) and abuse the power of BSP/AMLAC in seeking vengeance to his critics.

      PeNoy’s LACK of MORAL ASCENDANCY to accuse Corona of “betrayal of public trust” for using free flights when his family and cabinet members also enjoy the same privilege.

    • Trollollolloll

      Another BOBO! Next!

      • AngNagmamasid

        SUSTAIN ULIT.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_NXU2XGAHFDYLAQULE3TMTR6SWU Brando

    I am posting here this part of a news item in the Philstar because I can’t find it here.

    “My God, it is the entire system that is an issue here. I am not against the examining if they comply with the law, but if they can look into the accounts of anybody in this country, then what (for) are the Republic Acts (RA) that impose secrecies on certain matters in this country?” Senate President Juan Ponce Enrile asked his colleagues during the morning session of the Senate yesterday.

    Enrile was referring to RA 6426 and RA 1465, the laws which cover foreign and local deposits, respectively.

    “Is this not a violation of our laws? Is this not an intrusion into the Bill of Rights? Is this not a violation of the rule of law in this country? Have we become lawless? I posit this question and address it to the members of this Senate,” the Senate President said. Enrile made the manifestation after Sen. Teofisto Guingona III read the explanation of the BSP of its 2010 audit of some accounts with Philippine Savings Bank (PSBank) Katipunan branch.

  • BoyWaray

    When PeNoy, his family, and his cabinet officials get free trips and accommodations… it’s “cost-saving”

    When CJ Corona avails of free trips… it’s “betrayal of public trust”

    What kind of twisted double standard is this?!

    • noeltabaz2

      Correct.  It is double standard.  Maybe I missed the news when Pres. Aquino, his family and cabinet officials got free trips and accommodations.  Can you enlighten us (those who like me missed the news) by citing the specific instance you are referring to?

      • BoyWaray

        PAGCOR Chairman Naguiat (best friend of PeNoy) received free overnight stays in a $6,000/night villa in Macau.

      • noeltabaz2

        You failed to mention who sponsored the overnight stay of Chairman Naguiat and for how long and where did he stay.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_SOKSHNG3FM3OSHVHNPQXS5WIOE yahoo-SOKSHNG3FM3OSHVHNPQXS5WIOE

      not to mention free security for a would be gf at people’s expense???

    • ramser

      The real double standard is in having to reduce one’s intellect when discussing matters of importance with retards.

  • virgoyap

    Action speaks louder than words. AMEN!!

  • jeproks2002

    The argument that a justice of the supreme court should not be singled out because the decision was made by a collegial body is specious.  It submits that the decision was made by the court en banc and not by one person only and thus should not be singled out and held liable.  
    Does this mean then that if there was a grave abuse of discretion by one, ALL of the justices who participated in making the decision – including those who dissented, be made liable too?  It is not essential that the act itself (i.e. the decision) was erroneous or irregular.  What needs to be shown only is that one participant tried or attempted to do something not in accordance with regular procedure or even influenced the promulgation of an erroneous/incomplete decision such act amounting to betrayal of public trust.

    • anoba123

      yes collegial with the thief opss chief justice looking all over and demanding for a favorable outcome  hahaha. you all can’t all Filipinos about collegial decisions as long CJ Corona is the Chief. CJ can’t be trusted!!

  • http://twitter.com/pangittalagaako pangittalagaako

    plain and simple…suntok sa buwan planning!  Clearly a manifestation that those who signed the articles of impeachment did not find time to verify the complaint…an indication that they heed to the orders of Pnoy simply because of Pork Barrel!!!!

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/24U2S3PZY4X2B2GO3YBYO226QM Sol

    Sonic91, simple logic lang, kung may naganap na irregularity, bribery, criminal act or whatchamacallit surrounding the TRO issuance, that’s already a betrayal of public trust, kase as government officials they’re supposed to demonstrate integrity! So for me, one can’t say De Lima’s testimony is immaterial or irrelevant. Hindi naman katakataka sabihin ni Atty. Cuevas na irrelevant kase Defense Counsel sya eh! Yan ang trabaho ng mga abugado, ang tulungan ang kliyente nilang mkalusot sa batas or gamitin ang batas upang makalusot! In fact, I would say, things would have been simpler if people are just outright honest and accountable. We don’t need to pay for lawyers! Sorry mga panyero, but it’s hard not to lie in this profession! But in the end, we go to our grave and be judged by what we do in this lifetime. There is the ultimate justice system at work!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_NXU2XGAHFDYLAQULE3TMTR6SWU Brando

    If the rights of the Chief Justice can so easily be violated by those entrusted with political power, if he can be so vehemently vilified by state-sponsored propaganda, how can ordinary citizens be secure in the framework of law? – Alex Magno, Philippine Star

    • Bert Bert

       Alex Magno? lols.. the lapdog of Arroyo. hahaha.

      no way!!!

      wag mong gamitin basis yan kasi BULAG yan sa mga corruption ni Arroyo!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_DYXSBRILSDYIRWUSCWGYADFH5I Bubbles

      that’s exactly my fear, too, being an ordinary citizen at that. I still believe in Sec. De Lima’s credibility though.  I just hope and pray that this fishing expedition by the administration is just limited to getting even to the CJ because at least CJ have the capability, capacity and the resources to defend himself in court, while an ordinary citizen like me, don’t.

    • Handiong

      Faulty logic, as usual, from Alex Magno. I have not heard of any instance when the government had “vilified” an ordinary citizen. And I don’t see any reason why a government would “vilify” an ordinary citizen. What for?

      This tactic employed by Magno is devious. It tries to identify the personal interest of Corona with the interest of ordinary citizens. It tries to portray that Corona and the ordinary citizens have a common stake in the impeachment case.

      No, the ordinary citizens have nothing in common with Corona in the impeachment case. The case is all about Corona’s official acts as a Chief Justice. There is nothing that Corona can do acting as a Chief Justice that an ordinary citizen can do. Nothing.

      This is reminiscent of the argument that preventing GMA from travelling abroad endangered the right of ordinary citizens to travel. Absolutely non-sequitur. I never felt, not for a moment, that my right to travel was put at risk when GMA was barred from leaving the country. In fact, I was able to travel freely last December.

      And what right of Corona has been violated? He is having his day in the impeachment court. He is given all the opportunities to present his side. He has the best legal advice that he can get.

      If Corona is doing badly in the court of public opinion, it is because the pieces of evidence being brought out in the impeachment court are damning. But, he still has the opportunity to controvert those pieces of evidence. He still has the opportunity to reverse public opinion.

      In short, Corona is getting a fair trial.

  • parefrank

    to any bonifacio
    Very wrong, sorry. But when the TRO was issued, there have been accusations against GMA but no case filed. Therefore she was rightful to travel. Why the DoJ talked of “mountains of evidence” against GMA but did not file a single case during 15 months with Noy? Even the running case filed by the Cheatelec and railroaded by the court will hardly stand at any unbiased court since it is just based on the suspicious hearsay of a criminal, connected to the Ampatuan murder case.
    So, De Lima was defying an SC order just to please Noy and should be punisheed and fired from her post for giving such a bad example, even it is exactly what Noy wants: an SC which follows him and not laws and constitution.

    • Bert Bert

        I will ask you, If you allowed Arroyo to travel and never come back,
      WHAT will happen to all CASES? Mas mabuti pang maagapan kaysa makatakas
      pa! Kanino kasalanan yan kung makatakas? di ba sa DOJ? eh wala ka pala eh! di ka nag-iisip sa mga possible gawin ni Arroyo!

      Isa pa, may mga KASO na nasampa sa DOJ and it is not EASY to file cases immediately WITHOUT proper evidences!

      Parang hindi ka sumusunod sa timeline sa kaso ni GMA! Basa ka ulet ha kung ano talaga ang TUNAY na pakay ni GMA…

      Ipapa-alala ko sayo… Saan ka magpapagamot kung life threatening na ang sakit mo? Sa Clinton convention sa states, sa isang meeting sa Geneva etc. etc… kung life threatening na yang sakit mo?

      eh bakit BUHAY pa ang kumag na yan hanggang ngayon? Sana PATAY na yan kung life threatening ang sakit nya… nakikita mo ba ang TRUE logic kung bakit sya aalis?

      • lolong reklamador

        correction lang po… walang kaso before magkaroon ng TRO ang DOJ.

      • SignTheWaiverNow

        Irrelevant ito sa usaping impeachment!

      • Trollollolloll

        Another BOBO. Next!

      • AngNagmamasid

        SUSTAIN.

    • RomyMacalintal

       Mahirap mag nenok ng maraming ebidensya tapos i-fa-falsify pa nila yung mga nenok na ebidensya

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_OHOD5EA75DBBUH53UKLRXRK764 Mang Teban

    The article is about the testimony of the DOJ Secretary about the undue haste that the Supreme Court acted to issue a TRO on the Hold-Departure-Order and Watch-List-Order by the DOJ.

    But, some readers comment about something else that only muddles the real issue. Thus, the issue must be commented by readers either if they agree or disagree…chop suey na tuloy itong forum na buhol-buhol na “threads”. Ang saya-saya sa Pilipinas…it is more fun to make IMPERTINENT, IRRELEVANT COMMENTS in the Philippine Daily Inquirer!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    I can almost hear Retired Justice Serafin Cuevas to say “I object, your honor,…your honors, please” ringing in my ears like a mantra for he never fails to cut in for his client’s sake…hehe

     

    • hakudaten

      I can almost hear Retired Justice Serafin Cuevas to say “I object, your
      honor,…your honors, please” ringing in my ears like a mantra for he
      never fails to cut in for his client’s sake.

      Ganun talaga Mang Teban… hintayin natin mag-prisinta naman ng witness ang defense… at sa tingin ko ang magri-ring naman sa iyong mga tenga ay “I object” from the prosecution team. ;-)

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_DI3QGCJEEFK52CT4DTQ7I5SRUE Neil

    Malaki ang utang na loob ni Corona (Arroyo’s midnight appointee) sa pamilyang Arroyo.  Mauunawaan natin ito sa ating kulturang Pinoy,   ito’y tinutumbasan at sinusuklian ng kapalit.

    Kaya’t  tama lang na mag-issue ito ng TRO at i-rationalized ito sa batas na “isang karapatan ng bawat Pilipino ang bumiyahe papalabas.”   Litaw ang batas at karapatan,  NAKATAGO at ISANG INVISIBLE sa mata ng tao ang UTANG NA LOOB. 

    Si GMA na halos 9 taon nasa kapangyarihan ay siya ring tumayong REYNA ng PATRON ng mga naghaharing political elite sa ating bansa.    

    Ang PATRONAGE POLITICS na itinuturing UGAT ng KATIWALIAN at PANGUNGURAKOT  ay makalumang kalakarang at tradisyon na BUMAON sa mga Pilipino,  di lang sa hanay ng ELITE  manging sa ordinaryong mamamayan..

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_NXU2XGAHFDYLAQULE3TMTR6SWU Brando

      Hindi rin. Di ba si De Lima appointee rin ni GMA sa pagiging Chair, Commission on Human Rights? Doon ipinamalas niya ang galing niyang dumepensa sa mga taga kaliwa.

  • 200214994

    Putangina nyong lahat! Andami nyong dada! Lahat kayo abogago! Tangina nyo!

    • BoyWaray

      Hahaha

  • SignTheWaiverNow

    When asked by Enrile if she has personal knowledge about it, she said she based her statement on the dissenting opinion of Sereno.

    HEARSAY! LOL

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/FXCIZ3GD4CSNVVIUIVYX6VC4KI Apolinario

      I was not able to see the telecast yesterday ng impeachment. Kung totoo ang statement ni DOJ de Lima, based lang sa dissenting opinion e di kathang isip nya lang yun. Hindi matibay na ebidencya yun to convict.

      Ang masama kasi nung panahon na yon e panay pa-presscon nya pati ni Pinoy na pakukulong si GMA. Kung nanahimik lang sila at ska sinampa yung dimanda di sana nagkaganito. Feel ko naman kung bakit eh. Eleksyon na ulit next year. Mlamang si Tupas din.

      • SignTheWaiverNow

        That is what the DOJ secretary said yesterday. She based it on the dissenting opinion of the honorable Justice Sereno.

        Hearsay talaga! it is now very clear that the evidences presented are weak!

    • RomyMacalintal

       Chismax lang

  • SignTheWaiverNow

    Mukhang Acquit talaga ito! Nakakaawa naman mga yellow zombies, nagiging desperado na! LOL

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Billy-Mosende/100002425968724 Billy Mosende

      acquit?… o? talaga?  kaya mong ipusta yagbols mo?  baka tulad ka ni badingirlshe Berdugo – di pa nahihipo a-titi, a-tulin a-takbo na! NYAHAHAHA!!!!

      • SignTheWaiverNow

        ACQUIT! ACQUIT! ACQUIT! LOL

        Another desperate act of a yellow zombie! LOL

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/3KZZAMTXYDWX3DIBTSP4FECOOA Yengg

        hahahahahaahah….

  • PeteJrfern

    Yan and DOJ secretary, palpak talaga ang SC sa TRO.  Immediately effective daw pero defective, so walang TRO.  Dahil sa gusto nilang lumusot si GMA ayon, buhol buhol ang napalabas na TRO.

  • parefrank

    Hello DinngMae
    Looks like you are a typical YELLOW. Accusations and imaginations but no view of
    reality. Nowhere accusing is a proof and it was De Lima’s job to file cases to hold GMA
    back. She did not for 15 months, is that GMA’s fault? But without a case, the TRO was
    correct and De Lima has to follow SC orders, like it or not. Nobody would blame her if
    GMA really would have decided not to come back.
    Besides, nowhere she could hide with an international warrant.  Except senator-judge
    Lacson whose first way back in RP was to Noy for “thank you”, De Lima vowed to check
    his travel papers but let the deadline pass at Noy’s order, even the DFA declared the
    paper as fake because the same=numbered original was still in Manila at DFA.
    Good work, secretary, at least it pleased Noynoy who wanted this Arroyo enemy here
    when there are cases against the Arroyos

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Billy-Mosende/100002425968724 Billy Mosende

      weather, weather lang yan! …nung panahon ni Pandak + Berdugo, dusa yang mga dilawan at pulahan. …o, sila naman ngayon ang sikat…eh, di kayo naman ang magdusa!  NYAHAHAHA!!!!  

      hoy!  9 na taon kay Pandak…dapat 9 na taon din kayong magdusa! NYAHAHAHA!!!! 

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/AVTOQDZU5E2P7MZYTFY6L3NBPU Ping

    The LAW according to PNYO :

    Pag bomoto si Corona PARTIAL
    Pag bomoto si Sereno IMPARTIAL
    Pag si Genuino MALPRACTICE
    Pag si Naguiat  INDUSTRY PRACTICE
    Pag si Genuino CORRUPTION
    Pag si Naguiat ABSOLUTION !

  • thunderbolt01

    pahayagan upang maeducate kayo.

  • dead_pixel

    Nagmamaktol si LIE LA at ang amo niyang retarded dahil hindi nila nakukuha ang gusto nilang kapritso!
    HINDI LAHAT NG BAGAY AY NAKUKUHA NINYO MGA LINTIK!

    • thunderbolt01

      Huwag mong isnabin kinumbida si Jeremy Renner sa palasyo.

      • dnayellowkulayko

        hahar! jan magaling sa pa-showbiz at pa-cute mas importante daw ang love life nya at ni Kris hahar! … this is happening while the economy is in deep sh*t

      • AngNagmamasid

        noong ma-meet ni j.renner si pnoy,nagulat daw at mukhang retarded daw.pati ibang lahi ay alam ang mental status ni pnoy.

    • CheapJ

      Kung alam mo lang, mas matindi ang pagmamaktol ni GMA nang hindi siya payagan ni de Lima na umalis ng bansa. Hindi umubra ang TRO ni Corona, nauwi lang sa TROtot. Ngayon, nakakulong ang diyosa ng kasamaan. Better luck next time. 
      Why don’t you pay her a visit sometime? She needs badly your moral supot este support.

      • dead_pixel

        @CheapJ
        Ang amo mong bakla ang supot!

      • dead_pixel

        @CheapJ
        Ang amo mong bakla ang supot!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_5GRTCH676OFEK7ELOJBBA6EMCE Bonifacio Aquino

    IT’S HIGH TIME TO CREATE A “PEOPLES’ IMPEACHMENT COURT” THAT WILL TRY FROM THE SIDELINES THE “HIGH CRIMES” OF THIS PENOY ADMINISTRATION WHICH INCLUDE AMONG OTHERS HIS ACTS OF TREASON AND BETRAYAL OF PUBLIC TRUST BY ALLOWING LEFTISTS IN HIS CABINET OR GOVERNMENT; CULPABLE VIOLATION OF THE CONSTITUTION ON THE “SEPARATION OF POWERS, BILL OF RIGHTS, DUE PROCESS, PROPER PROTOCOL, ETC.; INFLUENCE-PEDDLING AND MEDDLING; UN-PRESIDENTIAL ACTS AND RHETORIC; “TANTRUM AND HEARSAY” POLITICS; INTELLECTUAL AND EMOTIONAL INCAPACITY TO GOVERN EFFECTIVELY; AMONG OTHER ACTS OF  MALFEASANCE, MISFEASANCE AND NONFEASANCE  IN NATIONAL GOVERNANCE. 

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Billy-Mosende/100002425968724 Billy Mosende

      Then why didn’t you do that during the time of Pandak + Berdugo, et. al?

    • Handiong

      May nakawala ata sa mental hospital.

      • CheapJ

        Pakibalik nga sa Mental si Mang Boni, nagwawala na naman.

      • sc53300

        yes, ang presidente mo DAW

  • djangotom

    Corona wanted to help Arroyo escape–De Lima
    masyadong seryoso ang mga bintang, sana nagpresent na siya ng evidence na totoo ang sinasabi niya.

  • pepengkabayo

    Corona wanted to help Arroyo escape–De Lima…..

    Masyadong Brutal itong si De Lima, parang mga notorious criminal kung akusan si Chief Justice and former President Gloria Arroyo.
    Parang mga Abu Sayaff bandit na tinulungan tatakas.

    Itong si De Lima, magaakala ,Maling Akala pa.
    Sinong ungas na Presidente ang tatakas gayong ang Pilipinas ay tinatawag na cradle of democracy.
    Lahat may Due Process aywan ko lang dito kay Pnoy na mukha atang wala.

    Tingnan ninyo si Marcos, pinatatakas, ayaw tumakas noong People Power, kundi pa nilinlang na pupunta ng Paoay hindi aalis papuntang Hawaii.
    Si President Erap, pinaaalis din ng bansa pero di umalis at hinarap ang problema at nagpakulong.
    Ngayon naman si GMA pagbibintangan tatakas at tinutulungan ni Corona, mahiya naman kayo.
    Walang gustong umalis ng sariling bansa dahil dito tayo ipinanganak at lumaki, tumanda.

    Si Pnoy at De Lima ang tiyak tatakas pag nagbago ang administration sa mga kapalpakan na kanilang pinaggagawa..

    • Handiong

      Si GMA ayaw umalis ng bansa? Meron pa nga siyang tickets sa lahat ng airlines na lilipad ng hapon ng Nov. 15, eh. At nagkakang-darapa siyang pumunta sa NAIA.

      Si PNoy tatakas? Mga kapalpakan? Ano yon?

    • CheapJ

      May sayad ba ang utak mo? Eto ngang nagkandarapa na sa airport ang kampo ni GMA, may kasama pang acting, hindi lang pang-FAMAS, pang-Oscar pa. Sasabihin mong hindi siya tatakas? May sayad ka nga dong.

    • AngNagmamasid

      i believed that 5x pang lumabas ng bansa si gloria bago pa ang mga moro-morong iyan.if she really has an intention to abscond or escape,she could easily did that.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_EDXEVEFHW2ZT5VWHDWBNM6XGE4 RyanE

    Impeachment trial is not a criminal trial where you need proof beyond reasonable doubt to convict. On the contrary, all it needs is a shadow of doubt because he is the Chief Justice who should be possessing a character beyond reproach.

    His non-disclosure of his condos and cash in banks including dollar accounts is not what we expect from the person leading the highest court of the land.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_NXU2XGAHFDYLAQULE3TMTR6SWU Brando

      Isang santo ang sinasabi mo. Wala kang mahanap na ganyan sa buong mundo.

      • CheapJ

        Hindi santo ang hinahanap dito, ito yung taong may prinsipyo. 

      • edwin525

        Brando, 6 likes na si RyanE!! Hehehe. Out-voted ka bro. Sana lang taasan natin standard natin, nobody is perfect sabi nga.. pero that’s not an excuse to allow imperfections. We Filipino’s should always aim for the best governance.

    • Trollollolloll


      Impeachment trial is not a criminal trial where you need proof beyond reasonable doubt to convict. On the contrary, all it needs is a shadow of doubt because he is the Chief Justice who should be possessing a character beyond reproach.”

      TANGA! STAPLE HAND TO FOREHEAD!

  • skyrockettt

    She said the proof was the court order allowing the government only three days, instead of the standard 10 days, to respond to the November 15 temporary restraining order, and setting the oral arguments in a few days’ time.
    SUS! MARUNONG KA DIN PALANG MAG_ANALYZE NG GANYAN, HOW ABOUT THE RECORD-BREAKING SPEED OF SIGNING THE ARTICLES OF IMPEACHMENT BY 188 CONGRESSMEN IN JUST SEVERAL HOURS??? WEH…

    • CheapJ

      Kung pinatagal nila ulit ito, di biglang nag-isyu na naman ang SC ng TRO kagaya sa kaso ni Gutierrez. 

      • skyrockettt

        o cge, sana ginawa namang 2 days yung preparation ng impeachment diba, para mas kapani-paniwala LOL

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/U2J4DJQPQ4PON73N3KBZYXCNCM Francis

    kamukha ni lay lay bil bil de lima yung atty ni gma..si atty. topakcio…ang mga tagapag sinungaling ng magkabilang panig..

  • yousef

    but of course being a lackey it’s but natural to do what he is told! 

  • SignTheWaiverNow

    Mahina ang Kaso! period. Better luck next time!

  • Handiong

    To Brando:

    Faulty logic, as usual, from Alex Magno. I have not heard of any instance when the government had “vilified” an ordinary citizen. And I don’t see any reason why a government would “vilify” an ordinary citizen. What for?

    This tactic employed by Magno is devious. It tries to identify the personal interest of Corona with the interest of ordinary citizens. It tries to portray that Corona and the ordinary citizens have a common stake in the impeachment case.

    No, the ordinary citizens have nothing in common with Corona in the impeachment case. The case is all about Corona’s official acts as a Chief Justice. There is nothing that Corona can do acting as a Chief Justice that an ordinary citizen can do. Nothing.

    This is reminiscent of the argument that preventing GMA from travelling abroad endangered the right of ordinary citizens to travel. Absolutely non-sequitur. I never felt, not for a moment, that my right to travel was put at risk when GMA was barred from leaving the country. In fact, I was able to travel freely last December.

    And what right of Corona has been violated? He is having his day in the impeachment court. He is given all the opportunities to present his side. He has the best legal advice that he can get.

    If Corona is doing badly in the court of public opinion, it is because the pieces of evidence being brought out in the impeachment court are damning. But, he still has the opportunity to controvert those pieces of evidence. He still has the opportunity to reverse public opinion.

    In short, Corona is getting a fair trial.

    • TeabagDeluxe

      An impeachment complaint railroaded through the Lower House without the signatories even bothering to go through its contents is not a violation of rights? Trial by publicity using unverified and possibly illegally obtained evidence, teetering on defamation and slander are also not violating basic rights?

      I want to live in your world.

      • el_latigo

         @TEABUG: Perception mo lang iyan. What defanation are u talking about? May pinagmumura ba sa panig ni Corona? What slander?

      • TeabagDeluxe

        From Wikipedia:
        Defamation—also called calumny, vilification, traducement, slander (for transitory statements), and libel (for written, broadcast, or otherwise published words)—is the communication of a statement that makes a claim, expressly stated or implied to be factual, that may give an individual, business, product, group, government, or nation a negative image.

        From thefreedictionary:
        defamatory – (used of statements) harmful and often untrue; tending to discredit or malign
        defamatory adj
        (Law) injurious to someone’s name or reputation

        Did you see anything about “pinagmumura” in those definitions?

        I suggest you learn the definitions of words first before trying to use them in your arguments. Though I think it would be too much for you, since you resort to corrupting my online handle in order to take a jab at me, instead of focusing on my arguments.

      • Handiong

        If Corona is being defamed, it is not by anybody but by evidence. The pieces of evidence so far exposed are damning him, unless his defense team can controvert them.

      • TeabagDeluxe

        The prosecution violated the impeachment process by releasing their purported evidence to the media before the trial even started. Whatever they have, they should’ve just kept it to themselves until the time to present it before the senator-judges came. Furthermore, a lot of the claims they released to the media have been shown to be half-truths or flimsy evidence.

      • Handiong

        1.  Only two or three congressmen said that they did not read the complaint. They did not sign it anyway. What’s the problem? 

        2. Trial by publicity? The impeachment trial is real, you can even watch it live.

        3. Unverified evidence? The bank peso accounts are unverified? The properties Corona bought but did not declare in his SALNs are unverified? All these have been testified on by witnesses. You must be the one living in another planet.

        4. Illegally obtained? The signature cards are not evidence. The evidence are the bank accounts.

        Get real!

      • TeabagDeluxe

        My oh my.

        1. Do you think all of the 188 signatories read the complaint? If they did, there should be quite a number among them that find the complaint to be weak and should’ve spoken out. Unless, you know, threat of pork barrel etc etc.

        2. Impeachment trial is real, yes – but the trial by publicity the admin is running is far worse than what the Senate is doing.

        3. What the prosecution is arguing is that the wealth contained in said bank accounts are ill-gotten. No proof about ill-gotten wealth yet.

        4. The signature cards were used as evidence by the prosecution to subpoena the bank records, which is against the law.

  • andrew lim

    SERAFIN CUEVAS IS A MARCOS LOYALIST WHO ADVOCATED REBELLION AGAINST CORY AQUINO

    I found out that sometime in July 1986, a few months after the EDSA revolt, a pathetic attempt by some Marcos loyalists, together with some military officers to install Arturo Tolentino as President was made at Manila Hotel. (Source: Schenectady Gazzette July 7, 1986, but im sure it was covered by major dailies at the time)

    Who swore in Arturo Tolentino, the running mate of Ferdinand Marcos as the “duly elected president of the philippines”?  None other than Serafin Cuevas! Using a bullhorn at the Manila Hotel, together with some Marcos loyalists (Gen Zumel among them) he administered the oath to Arturo Tolentino!

    He lectures us on rule of law when he advocated rebellion against the newly installed government of Cory Aquino!

    • SignTheWaiverNow

      Nice try! What is the purpose of your statement? LOL

      • andrew lim

        well, for starters, it’s the anniv of Edsa, and this puts perspective on the man of the defense. he portrays himself to be a man of the law, invoking it like your moniker, but he actually advocated rebellion himself.

        Go back to the archives of the major dailies of that week of July 1986.

      • TeabagDeluxe

        Cory Aquino was a crappy president.

        1. Multiple coup d’etats
        2. Nationwide brownouts/blackouts during her entire admin
        3. Economy didn’t improve much
        4. Exempted Hacienda Luisita from land reform that requires the owners to distribute the land from the farmers
        5. Coddled cronies and relatives 
        6. Mendiola massacre

        And it looks like her son is following her footsteps.

      • SignTheWaiverNow

        I believe you are in a wrong section. Maybe you can try entertainment section. LOL

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_XOLTIFWSG3REDCYVFRPVWYN25U Jay

      boooooh!!! nonsense

      • andrew lim

        then go back to the archives of the major dailies of that week in July 1986. Cuevas is described there as “an ousted Associate Justice of the SC” and a Marcos loyalist.

      • AngNagmamasid

        hehehe…ang kulit mo at sabi ng walang bearing iyan mga pinagkakakana mo.pag hindi ka tumigil ay ipapa-contempt na kita or ipalalabas namin ang psychological record mo.hahaha…

    • Simon Ybarramendia

      So were Sens. Trillanes and Honasan. So was Danny Lim. So was allegedly JPE. So were so many at a given time.

      Bumenta na approach mo. Character assassination tawag dyan. Not only Cuevas but almost all personalities who have been in the center of a particular cause or historical event have a record or two, but their involvement does not invalidate the validity and sharpness of their argument and reason on another issue. Just stick to the current issue and event at hand.

    • AngNagmamasid

      wala ng nakakaalala niyan.walang bearing iyan sa impeachment trial.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_QXRY5FFJHVBW2THD226CSOAXVA JanB

      It has been a Known Fact that ” A Good Lawyer is A Good Lier “. the more these lawyer learned about the Law of the Land the more expensive they are on their fees and more sought by Criminals!!!! These lawyers worst enemy is the TRUTH!!!! take for example Sen Miriam Santiago caught in an interview years back!!! After the truth catch-up with her, SHE JUST ADMIT BLANTLY ! I LIED with a big smile!!! That is how easy these people LIE without remorse or shame!!! They are learned people yet the more they learned, the more they hide from the TRUTH as they knew that is the only weapon that they can’t face once it catches them especially LAWYERS!!! So Don’t be surprise with CUEVAS!!! He is an INC together CJ Corona who believed they are the only one saved under the Church of INC and not with their actions. IKAw ba naman pag sabihan buong taon or buhay mo na ikaw lang ang maliligtas! Ewan ko lang kung di LALAKI ULO MO!!! Make Sense????

    • http://www.facebook.com/domzki Dominic Melu Godornes

      But do you know that if NAMFREL had finished their quick count of all the ballots it will show Marcos winning the elections? The Complete Unofficial NAMFREL Quick Count back in 1986 shows: 
      Ferdinand E. Marcos KBL: 10,635,458; Corazon C. Aquino UNIDO – PDP-LABAN: 9,853,456. We are all familiar with this figure: 
      Ferdinand E. Marcos KBL: 
      7,053,068; Corazon C. Aquino UNIDO – PDP-LABAN: 
      7,835,070 — This is the Partial Unofficial NAMFREL Quick Count that was shown when the COMELEC walked out and sparked the EDSA 1. Still there are few who finished the quick count and it showed that Marcos still won. Very few people know this. If the people had already known that still Marcos won, then EDSA 1 could have not have had happened. Technically, CUEVAS did nothing wrong when he sworn in Tolentino.

  • kismaytami

    Akala siguro ni Tandang Cuevas, mapapaikot niya si De Lima. Nice try Cuevas, but De Lima is a witty girl.

    • AngNagmamasid

      you just don’t know how a veteran lawyer works.he is just testing the water.you will see and admire cuevas how he will make minions of delima.

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/RCTO3OYGGPIL7LEULWKQZFB45Q Nazariel

        Correct.. that would spell the difference between a lawyer who practiced and is practicing his profession and a lawyer who never practiced the same and merely engaged in “the business of politics”..

  • andrew lim

    @teabag de luxe

    that’s your opinion, but at least you stuck to issues and avoided curse words like your cohorts.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_NXU2XGAHFDYLAQULE3TMTR6SWU Brando

      There was nothing wrong in Cueva’s action in supporting Tolentino or Marcos, as you said he was a Marcos Loyalist. The EDSA revolution was by itself illegal. Hence, the government of Cory was a revolutionary government that did not have the mandate of the people.

  • andrew lim

    i agree with you, but how come serafin cuevas advocated rebellion in July 1986, swearing in Arturo Tolentino at the Manila Hotel together with some Marcos loyalists , a few months after EDSA?

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_NXU2XGAHFDYLAQULE3TMTR6SWU Brando

      So was there illegal in Cueva’s action?

    • arnold reyes

      Walang Rebellion sa ginawa ni CUEVAS, dahil ang administrasyong CORY ay isang ilegal na PAMUMUNO na tinawag na REVOLUTIONARY GOVERNMENT.  Kung talagang gustong patunayan ni CORY na siya talaga ang nanalo, bakit noong umalis si MARCOS di sya nagpatawag ng SNAP ELECTION para matawag na legal ang kanyang panunungkulan.  Lahat ng mga nangungurakot ngayon ay bunga ng EDSA UNO, na lahat ng mga politikong naupo buhat ng panahon ni CORY sila na ang masisiba ngayon.

  • Hey_Dudes

    Renato C. Corona is no different from ordinary individuals who take advantage of anything free .  Surely, with his stature let alone his millions and dollars, he should have been one individual who cares more for his reputation and less on what he can take from anyone without paying for it.

    Such is the case of freebees he enjoys compliments of Philippine Airlines.  Free trips, first/business class anytime, any where and any place his heart desire.  For some of our countrymen specially those lumped with the description of “mapagsamantala”, naturally, even for a chief justice of the country’s highest court – Normal at OK lang ito.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/ECIE67KHVMUBODFZH6ED7Z4HLU sedfrey

      aah talaga, bakit pag KKK tulad ni naguit na tumanggap ng 278,000.00 per day na room at chanel bag e, industry practice lang at di mapagsamantala.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_7T2BPPGLG457K5BUPQBPOKDPA4 Marlon

    “Corona wanted to help Arroyo to escape – De Lima”

    really???

    De Lima proves to be all mouth no brains. what is the causal connection of the TRO to the alleged “escape try”???

    did Corona tell De Lima that he wanted Arroyo to escape??? and can Corona do it alone??? there were 7 other SC Justices who concurred with the TRO resolution.  

    why did De Lima think that Arroyo wanted to escape??? escape from what???

    there were no cases filed against Arroyo and before her November 2011 planned trip, Arroyo had travelled 6 times abroad during the Pnoy Abnoy administration, so why escape when the worst thing that could happen to Arroyo would be an Erap style incarceration and, even if convicted, she will be pardoned by the next President if not by Pnoy Abnoy himself.

    puro kathang isip lang ang laman ng utak nitong publicity-hungry na si De Lima. parehong pareho talaga sila ni Pnoy Abnoy.
     

    • THELITTLEGIRL

      Pssssst, baka madamay ang 7 other justices. baka ma impeach. Keep you tone low.

    • negicbk

      you can’t blame her as too many of our countrymen believes in her.
      pay may nagpapaloko e laging nandyan ang manloloko.

  • negicbk

    this government break laws and get away with it.
    just can’t understand that “tuwid na daan” still works with people.
    the course of which the impeachment started, from rail roading proceeding to illegal production of evidence just shows that even “congress” which are supposed to protect laws are the one’s breaking it. hindi ko makita kung nasan yung “tuwid”
    anyway, history wil decide the fate of this government.

  • DondonSantosJr

    Daldalima, bakit mo sinabi na Corona wanted to help Arroyo escape? Nakakulong na ba si Arroyo?

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_TV7UX6Z5F4W3QJNODUMA6UTB2U Pinoydin

    Noynoy’s Legacy to Filipino People:  Impeach mo yun… impeach mo yan huh…. (to the tume of bil mo ko)

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3UZOAQ6YXZ7LV4AEKHDH6HDDCA Jeamergs

    Corona wanted to help Arroyo escape–De Lima but
    De Lima do not want Corona to help Arroyo escape.

    • gayweathersucks

      Don’t forget – DAW !!!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_RQTDK4CQFIH7OE6THRPVTOQE4Q Ness

    De lima said DAW, NILA- the heresay DOJ secretary. Yung ambush sa NBI -DAW, NILA ang favorite words nya. Dapat maingat cya sa kanyang mga sinasabi na walng batayan or same PNOY kahit na ano sasabihin nila even nilalabag na ang karapatan pang tao.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/K53BA7BJQX5YTHCNTZU73TQN6A May

    The LIE LIMA….= EPIC FAIL

  • SignTheWaiverNow

    Sa totoo lang, binabasa ko mga comments ng mga PNOY fans dito at isa lang ang aking conclusion.

    Puro haka haka ang kanilang pinagsasabi at puro tanong “bakit may milyon si corona, bakit naghain ng TRO ang korte suprema sa HDO, bakit? bakit? bakit?”

    hindi po ba dapat sila ang magbigay sa atin ng mga kasagutan na ito kasi sila ang nag-akusa sa chief justice? obviously, wala silang ebidensya kasi kahit sila nagtatanong at wala silang sagot! LOL

    diba yellow zombies? aminin nyo na kasing nag-sampa kayo ng kaso na walang ebidensya! ay diyosko!

  • SignTheWaiverNow

    Pati Lead Defense Lawyer tinitira! Hayyy….. such a lowly life form! LOL

    • gayweathersucks

      Lahat ng sumusporta kay PaNOT ay mga STUPIDONG BOBO gaya niya.

      • manks

         Owww…. Basta kayo mga mag nanakaw..

  • lambug1

    Hoy ayaw maghasa-hasa pagtangol kay Buaya Corona. Siguro binayan ka ng kampo nila katulad ng nagdemonstrate na kasamahan niny sa Supreme Court… hindi ba 300 pesos kada tao? Magkano ang bayad sa inyo?l

    • SignTheWaiverNow

      sabi ko na sa inyo e! another lowly life form! LOL

  • SignTheWaiverNow

    Pag si CJ Corona MaAcquit! (Na mukhang sigurado na dahil walang ebidensya) Si PNOY naman ang maiimpeach! Si Corona naman magsasampa ng kaso laban kay PNOY. Believe me!

    Lalo na kapag mapatunayan na ginamit nya ang AMLC para makakuha ng illegal na bank documents. Nakow po PNOY! Nanganganib ka na!

    • paul_and_david

      Dahil hawak nya ang kongreso hindi pa maiimpeach yan. Pero pagkatapos ng kanyang termino, Isa na yan sa kanyang kaso, pangalawa ang pag-protekta kay Llamas.

    • Felix Evangelista

      The minority will not file an impeachment until after the next 2013 election. With the lowsy leadership of Pnoy, cgurado magiging minority nalang sila after that. At that time, cguradong ma iimpeach si Pnoy. Ngayon palang marami nang impeachable offense si Pnoy, ano pa kaya pag katapos nang 2013. Imagine comes election with INC, and the bishops, plus faction of military & police, all of them enemies of Pnoy now, and all of their votes goes to whoever is not within the line of Pnoy or LDP.

    • FernandoBusi

      Much as I don’t like Pnoy I hope the next admin will not be vindictive and we have a real statesman otherwise wala talaga patutunguhan ang bansa … hayaan nyo ng mag retiro yan is noynoy sa paglalaro ng playstation nya … 

  • tabitabi

    Kawawang Dilemma kahit alam nyang walang bigat ang testimony nya ay tuloy parin
    para lang makatulong sa persecution.

  • gisingpinas

    Some people dont understand about TRO.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_BMSQUIOZUHN6ZR2B3KA7Y7RC6Y Alex Leonidas

    The main issue here is, can the government prevent anybody from traveling abroad? The answer is no since the right to travel is a constitutional right.  The government can only prevent a person from doing so if he or she poses a threat to national security, public safety, or public health or if he or she is under the jurisdiction of the court.

    Since the right to travel is a constitutional right, its free exercise and constraint is applicable to everybody. Thus, the issue here is actually the right of every Filipino. It only happens that it is being tested in the case of Former President Gloria Arroyo.

    After being in office for more than a year, President Aquino failed to file a single case against Former President Arroyo in court. Thus, Former President Arroyo was not under the jurisdiction of the court; she wasn’t also declared a threat to national security, public safety, or public health. Whether she needed to be medically treated here or not then was immaterial; nobody had the right to set other conditions on her right to travel.

    The status quo then was that there was no constraint against Former President Arroyo’s right to travel.  The hold order of President Aquino, through Justice Secretary de Lima, against Former President Arroyo was irregular.  If the TRO of the Supreme Court was meant to preserve the status quo, it should preserve the right of Former President Arroyo’s right to travel against any constraint.

    The constraint in this instance is the hold order against Former President Arroyo.  Curiously, Secretary de Lima’s understanding is that the status quo is the hold order.  Thus, in her questionable version, the Supreme Court then should not issue a TRO!

    Thus, in reverse logic, Secretary de Lima sees the TRO now as irregular. She particularly blames Chief Justice Corona as the architect of the TRO and wants him convicted for it.  In her testimony, however, she confirms that the issuance of the TRO is the responsibility of the Supreme Court as a collegial undertaking and not of Corona alone.

  • neoxyrel

    De 5 favorite words are “Daw” “I heard reports” “Maybe” and so on and so forth…is this lady a lawyer? Bakit lahat ng lumalabas sa bibig niya eh mga hearsay. I heard this ultimate penoy lap dog said yesterday regarding the ambush of esmeralda that she heard somewhere that there was an animosity between Gatdula and Esmeralda “daw”… why would she utter those hearsays/chismis in national TV without the benefit of investigation? this pig-faced lady should be remove as justice secretary….

    • gayweathersucks

      This government is full of incompetent fools – no. 1 is PaNOT.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_5CUS4WBMW2EKUIIKF2ES25VUNQ julius

      padagdag… NABASA KO sa….LOL

  • SignTheWaiverNow

    The HEARSAY QUEEN is back at the Senate!!!! LOL Abangan ang susunod na Hearsay! LOL

    Sasabihin nya, sabi ng tatay ng driver ng kapatid ng lolo ko, narinig daw nya na si CJ Corona ang nagimpluwensya sa SC para maglabas ng TRO! LOL

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_AYITA5V33GYZSLC3G37UCVNTKA Ben

    Precog De Lima strikes again….just like in the movie precognition. They were arresting people for something that never happened yet.

  • dilimon

    .. i tot 8-5 yung nasa records na ginawa ni sereno.. 

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_7T2BPPGLG457K5BUPQBPOKDPA4 Marlon

    “Corona wanted to help Arroyo to escape – De Lima”

    really???

    De Lima proves to be all mouth no brains. what is the causal connection of the TRO to the alleged “escape try”???

    did Corona tell De Lima that he wanted Arroyo to escape??? and can Corona do it alone??? there were 7 other SC Justices who concurred with the TRO resolution. 

    why did De Lima think that Arroyo wanted to escape??? escape from what???

    there were no cases filed against Arroyo and before her November 2011 planned trip, Arroyo had travelled 6 times abroad during the Pnoy Abnoy administration, so why escape when the worst thing that could happen to Arroyo would be an Erap style incarceration and, even if convicted, she will be pardoned by the next President if not by Pnoy Abnoy himself.

    puro kathang isip lang ang laman ng utak nitong publicity-hungry na si De Lima. parehong pareho talaga sila ni Pnoy Abnoy.  

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_ZWTTKJTI57YO7TZBJC66GA2OLU dennis

    In one of the articles here,it was said that “Arroyo not guilty” in electoral sabotage.This article will  make the Defense more stronger.My question here is “What was the use of detaining or putting someone under Hospital arrest kung not guilty na?…Now,TRO will become reasonable,di ba?

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2LMFLBTHSLUNJTYZYHSIYHGBNM Kyle

      Plea pa lang yan dre. Parang kung ikaw sinabihan na “sinungaling” e sinagot mo ng “di a?”. Yung hospital arrest e special treatment nga yun dapat nga sa kulungan sya na regular. Yung TRO ay ibang kaso naman yun. Medyo mixed na ata mga information mo…

  • Smoke_screen30

    Sa mga suportang ibinibigay naman ni Arroyo kay Corona ito ang theme song nila “That’s what friends are for”. Ang sweet nila noh.

  • Jay_Esplana

    Tama lang isyuhan ni De Lima ng hold departure order sina Gloria and Mike Arroyo. Biruin mo kung hinayaan lang natin, eh di tiluyan na nilang tinakasan ang mga kaso nila. Tama lang yun.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_7T2BPPGLG457K5BUPQBPOKDPA4 Marlon

      anim na beses nag-abroad si GMA noong President si Abnoy.

      bakit naman sya tatakas???

      wala syang kaso noon at kung makasuhan man sya, makukulong lang sya katuld ni Erap (hospital/resthouse arrest).

      kung ma-convict man sya, ipa-pardon lang sya ng sunod na Presidente o ni Abnoy mismo.

  • Uyere

    Hindi nga desisyon iyon ni Corona, ang TRO pero naimpluwnsiyahan niya ang 7 pang mga justice na pwang mga appointees, siya ang pasimuno niya, siya ang nagkukumpas.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_7T2BPPGLG457K5BUPQBPOKDPA4 Marlon

      weeh, hinde nga???  para ka namang De Lima eh. puro tsismis.  

      sinabi ba ni Corona yan sayo??? andun ka ba noong ginawa nila ang “conspiracy” na yan???

      • FernandoBusi

        hindi naman pwede mag labas ang CJ ng TRO kung sabi ng enbanc eh ibang bagay …

    • http://twitter.com/FlorenceDoit Florence Marie Doit

      Uyere– facts. Present the facts please.

  • markx2012

    the whole country knew that!
    but enrile acted like he’s been sleeping unaware of what’s going on with corona and his glory.
    ang hirap pa namang gisingin ang taong tulog lalo na kung busog.
    ang mamayan naman ay gising kasi gutom sa hustisya.

  • Over_drive99

    Pag na-acquit si Corona,lalaya si Gloria Arroyo. Ano sila sinuswerte.Sa kulungan sila magbonding!

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/NC6QZTK7YTJTP2ZGAMUGHXUFOI ate glue

      kulong ba ang hatol pag natanggal si Corona?did both of you were on your own deep? tanggal lang po sa pwesto…ay anong klaseng isip kayo?

  • Gugwipe

    Ayaw talagang magresign ni Corona,gusto muna subaybayan ang impeachment trial niya bago makulong!

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/NC6QZTK7YTJTP2ZGAMUGHXUFOI ate glue

    Gugwipe and Over_drive99…. alam niyo ang galing galing niyo na dalawa…bwahahahahahah! Impeachment na mapupunta sa kulungan upon conviction? Oh my God! would you something now? Tatanggalin lamang po siya sa pwesto oy… di po makukulong… tulog ata tong dalawa na to eh. maliban nalang if kakasuhan siya De Lilah wahahahahhaha De Luma pala ang palda.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/3KZZAMTXYDWX3DIBTSP4FECOOA Yengg

      yun na nga yun ate paste ang sususnod na hakbang ay yun na yun makukulong engot. nyahahahahahahahha….

  • islapshaq

    Hindi naman kasi life threatening ang condition noon ni Gloria. Nag aarte lang. pwede naming gamutin siya dito, dadayo pa sa ibang bansa. Style niya bulok.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_VY25ZOHU3FJFFX6CYSH5W4AX3I sugbu

    What a funny day at Impeachment court today ! Mr.Enrile showed his supremacy which very deserving as the Presiding Judge.

  • Hyperion999

    Sina Miat and Mike Defensor ang nag oorganize ng rally ng INC. Ang budget dapat P1000 per head perso P300 lang ibinibigay ng mag-amang Defensor. Bukulero sila!

  • HUNGKAG

    Art.7, the testimony of sec de lima and the dissenting opinions of j.carpio and j. sereno and the concurring opinions of j. abad, velasco and reyes piece the story as follows:
    1. On part 1, the collegial decision of the SC is not assailed but the concurring opinion only of CJCorona on the TRO and related resolutions.
    2. On Part 2, the individual acts of CJCorona as the highest administrative officer or Chief Executive of the SC is the main basis of the charge of partiality as enumerated below:
    a. ordering  midas arquez twice to anounce that the tro is suspended whereas the actual decision is that the tro is suspended for non complaince to the conditions of tro
    b. ordering j. velasco to adapt his draft resolution that the tro is suspended although the ponente appointed are j.velasco and j.carpio
    c. ordering j. velasco not to release the dissenting opinion of j,sereno

    everybody agreed that sec de lima’s testimony is hearsay but together with the documents presented is not stricken out.
    Big Win for the prosecution  at this point because the court can rule that Sec de lima’s testimony is an exception to the hearsay rule and may be admissible. Bigger win if the subject justices volunteers the answer to the questions on statement of facts and testify accordingly. Good performance of Sec de lima and cong. daza. they received positive responses from some senators and receive no hostility from any senator.

    • pinklace88

      thanks for sharing HUNGKAG, this is what these Corona defenders here should read who keep on insisting on collegial decision reasoning not to blame the Corona on his act on the TRO. yes, it could be a collegial decision but as in the words of Sec De Lima, the CJ has exceptional powers in the supreme court, which is true and he did abused it!

  • Syund

    Last card ni Corona ang INC rally, idea ni Gloria and Mike Arroyo. Magaling-magaling ang mga plunderer.

  • Mumfumble

    Si Corona ng lider gang sa Supreme Court, ang mga appointed justices ni GMA, mga disipulo lang niya, mga tagasunod. Kung ano kumpas ni Corona, sunod-sunuran lang sila.

  • wonder_twins

    San ka nakakaita ng magpapagamot sa ibang bansa na 14 ang kasama sa kanyang travel advisory. Obvious na may planong tumakas. Buti na lang napigilan, kundi matatakasan tayo ng mga plunderers.

  • RmarcialR

    Magkano ang nilabas na pera ni Gloria Arroyo para sa rally ng INC sa Feb 28? Ganun kalakas si Corona sa kanya!

    • FernandoBusi

      Mag isip ka nga sino so far ang nag labas ng pera … 188 tongressman x 20% of their pork barrel … ilang bilyon yun aber.

  • Bondying

    Todo ang paglalabas ng pera ni Gloria Arroyo para sa tuta nyang si Corona!Sya ang nagbayad sa INC para sa magrally!

    • Green_Latern

      another hearsay :)

    • Paranaque City

      Bakit, ano ba ang rally ng INC? About Corona ba? Sure ka?

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_DI3QGCJEEFK52CT4DTQ7I5SRUE Neil

    Mukhang UNFAIR kung ibabasura lamang at di kikilalanin (hearsay) ni Enrile at ni Cuevas ang testimonya ni Sec de Lima..patungkol sa suporta at alalay ni CJ Corona na makalabas ng bansa si CGMA.
    Facts siya at halos napanood ito sa buong Pilipinas kung paano nagkumahog si Midas Marquez at SC na obligahing PASAKAYIN si CGMA sa eroplano (5 bookings sa plane tickets) tungong Europa..kahit hindi nito naiproseso ang requirements na itinakda mismo ng SC…

    Hindi ito HEARSAY….

    • skyrockettt

      the supreme court was acting mainly to protect the right of the petitioner(GMA), it was their obligation to render justice, liberty, and promote equality among citizens. To say that they were only favoring GMA in issuing the TRO is, back to square one, a mere hearsay.

    • Norodin

      The SC had to. Their rulings set precedents that can be used again in any court in the Philippines. It’s the legal principle of Stare Decisis. If they ruled otherwise, then the government can deny anybody their right to travel and the courts can do nothing about it… Like legally justifying dictatorial powers of the government.

    • stingray357

      Takot lang c cuevas sa mga sinabi ni de lima.

    • passingthru2u

      what do you understand by hearsay?

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/3KZZAMTXYDWX3DIBTSP4FECOOA Yengg

    wag kang mag alala marami kami…

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_AO5QFUXGQ6B22K5G2AEXSJOHCU Lelet Puno

    GMA and husband knew that a TRO was forthcoming courtesy of Corona that is why they were able to book for plane tickets for 14 people, arranged appointment with a singapore hospital, etc.

    hope the prosecution would also look into this.  GMA has an insider in the SC…and yes, it is the chief justice himself.

    and why were they able to post bail at 6pm when the Supreme Court office is closed at 5p.m.

    • hustlergalore

      and wag kalimutan ang tactical error na ginawa nina GMA at SC co-horts para tumakas.

      dahil dyan hindi nila kayang macontempt si delima e.

      bwahahahahahahaha

      tapos yung secretary inutusan na agad magannounce na may tro kahit hindi pa natutupad ang lahat ng mga conditiones. sino kaya nag-utos sa kanya?

      LOL

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/3KZZAMTXYDWX3DIBTSP4FECOOA Yengg

    TO: Romy Macalintal
    para mo na ring dinadown ang pagkatao mo ibig mong sabihin poydi kang mag comment nang kung ano ano kaci di ka lawyer ang ibig mo pang sabihin sa behavior mo na wala kang pinag aralan kaci di ka lawyer na poydi kang intindihin kaci wala kang pinag aralan “mal edukado”

  • skyrockettt

    Pinipilit kase nitong si Noynoy na magmukhang SAINT of all the Presidents elected in the Philippines, that’s why desperado syang makapag-convict ng corrupt na official, otherwise yung platform nyang Daang Matuwid mawawalan ng substance. Madami ding nakiki-ride on sa campaign nya, gaya nitong all-mouth puppet nyang De lima, subalit in their desperate attempt to show to the public that they’re doing their best job in eradicating graft and corruption, kung sino sino na lang ang napagbabalingan nila ng pansin without careful preparations or scrutiny first. Sana lang Noynoy magpalit ka nalang ng campaign slogan mo baka sakaling maituwid mo pa mga pagkakamaling nasimulan mo.

  • BAKIT2011

    HAAY!

    DELIMA IS OVER AND ABOVE THE LAW -THAT IS MY ASSESSMENT OF
    HER STORY AND SHE TOOK THE LAW INTO HER OWN HANDS BY ADMITTING YESTERDAY TO
    SEN. ENRILE THAT EVEN IF THE TRO IS PERFECTLY DONE still according TO HER, she
    WILL NOT FOLLOW THE TRO OF THE SC! WHATTA BRAT! I THINK THIS IS A CRIME MORE
    THAN PLUNDER OR CORRUPT PRACTICE OF A FAT LADY THAT SHOULD NOT BE TOLERATED!
    SHE IS NOT “CUTE” AS WHAT SHE IS TRYING TO PORTRAY BEC. THIS IS A
    MURDER AND MOCKERY OF OUR LAW!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_CKBW2BZX34JXQUSVAMZVKCLNAU TagaDumantay

      Basahin mo uli, ang sabi ay may be yes, may be no.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/24U2S3PZY4X2B2GO3YBYO226QM Sol

    Hearsay! Kahit totoo, basta’t wala kang personal knowledge, hearsay yon! Kaya madaling lumusot dito sa bansa natin. One can easily stage an ambush to justify Martial Law, and somebody could just be killed in broad daylight with the killer and mastermind remain scot free!

  • emma_ele

    Tahimik na ngayon ang kampo ng prosecution..  Parang  medyo  hindi na masyado ang kahambugan..  nanibago kasi sila noon  akala nila porke kanila ang administrasyon,  kanila na rin ang senado…

    Sa article 2,  nagsinungaling at nagnakaw sila ng dokumento,  sa  article 3 hindi tinanggap ang witness..  Ngayon sa article 7,  hearsay naman..  

    Ang mga sitwasyong ganito ay talagang nangyayari.  Kung nagsimula ka sa mali,  matatpos din yan sa mali..   Ginawa ng 188 tongressman  na pumirma para sa milyones na Pork.

    Sa kagustuhan ni Peenoy na ma-monopolya ang SC,  lahat ng paraan,  malinis man o marumi, gagawin  dahil  desperado na…   Mabuti na lang may matatalino sa senado na hindi nadadala sa maling panghuhusga..  wag lang isama dyan si Drilon  na  marumi maglaro.

    Wag nila sisihin si Cuevas..  hindi nya kasalanan kung niregaluhan sya ng talino..  katulad nating lahat,  may karapatan syang pumili ng mga taong gusto nyang tulungan..   pasensya si Peenoy kasi hindi sya kasali doon…

    Kawawa ang mga taong masagasaan ng galit ni Peenoy.. lahat gagawin para makapanakit ng kalaban..  kung lahat ng pilipino  magiging katulad nya,  sasabog ang pilipinas  sa tindi ng paghihiganti…

    If  LUCK  will be on the side of the CJ and he will be acquitted,  maybe it will be the turn of Peenoy to resign  if he cannot tolerate working harmoniously with the SC…It will be for the betterment of all the people…

    Acceptance of defeat is easy if you are a person with a normal mind..  It will be  destruction  of oneself if you are abnormal…

    • BeMe_2

      emma gurl olat olat ka na agad, hija! wake up.

    • FernandoBusi

      Too true

  • Nic Legaspi

    “If they intended to get a comment from us in three days, and they intended to hear us out in oral arguments, why issue the TRO on November 15?”

    Kaya nga po temporary.

    • hustlergalore

      you just dont give TRO whimsically

      • JasminCubacub

        But palace wanted GMA to leave even without a TRO..

        Malacañang: GMA free to seek treatment abroad
        By Delon Porcalla (The Philippine Star) Updated October 14, 2011 12:00 AM Comments (0)

        MANILA, Philippines – Malacañang gave assurance yesterday that former President and now Pampanga Rep. Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo – who it wants to face trial for large-scale corruption – can travel to any place she wants, in the absence of any hold-departure order.

        Even the Department of Justice (DOJ) is considering allowing Arroyo to travel abroad and seek medication for her rare disease.

        “She’s free to travel. Right now, to my knowledge, no case has been filed against Rep. Arroyo (in court). Having no case against her, there’s no hold departure order, she is free to travel,” presidential spokesman Edwin Lacierda said.

        “It’s her prerogative, I cannot speak for Rep. Arroyo what is the best course of action that she will take. But we will take her word for it that she is going to Germany to seek medical treatment. We assumed that it was a statement made in good faith,” he added.

    • http://www.facebook.com/paulino.belga Paulino Belga

      Sana po alam ninyo kung kailan dapat i-issue ang TRO.  

      • Nic Legaspi

        Yes po. Paki-search sa wikipedia ang Temporary Restraining Order. You’ll see how it can be used to stop a party from committing an action. Thanks. ;)

  • pepengkabayo

    Corona wanted to help Arroyo escape–De Lima….

    Dapat ang tanong kay De Lima, bakit mo sinuway ang TRO?
    Para ipakulong si GMA, minadali ang pagpafile ng kaso sa loob ng isang linggo.
    Kasi nga may Ulterior Motive itong si DE LIMA na Ikulong agad si GMA bago makalabas.

    On the other hand, no explanation whatsoever is necessary when TRO is issued by the Court much more the SUPREME COURT because that is only TEMPORARY.

    • aristeosj

      bakit sinuway ang TRO?kung sinunod ang TRO,malamang hindi na alam ng pamahalaang ito at ng mga tao kung saan hahabulin si gloria.

      • emma_ele

        Praning ka rin tulad ni deLima…  kaya dumadami kayo eh,  nagpapa-uto kayo..  Pareho kayong ipinanganak ng makalumang panahon.. Hi-tech na po.. kaya pls upgrade yourself.   ok?

      • aristeosj

        well;ako hindi ako nagpapa-uto.gusto kong managot ang mga nagkasala.anong kinalaman ng high tech dito?sa paghuli kay gloria?ang alam ko ang pupuntahan nya sanang mga bansa ay walang extradtition treaty ang Pilipinas.

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_ZBDO77APDA7IB25W6R44QR6GHI Ajoeroooo

        Boba!!! E ano kung magpunta sia don edi ikaw maghanap sa kania!!! Tanga!!!

      • http://www.facebook.com/paulino.belga Paulino Belga

        Tingin po muna kayo sa salamin bago tawagin ang tao ng boba or tanga.  

      • aristeosj

        hahaha!!!yung idol mo na lang kaya ang maghanap sa kanya kasi sya naman ang nag-maniobra sa TRO para makalabas sa bansa ang patron nyong si gloria!!!bwahahaha!!!

      • http://www.facebook.com/paulino.belga Paulino Belga

        Sana humarap ka muna sa salamin bago mo tawagin ang ibang tao na praning.

    • hustlergalore

      Wala kasing bisa ang TRO. hindi nga siya macontempt ng supreme court dahil sa pagsuway niya e. meron kasing nakalimutan tuparin na kondisyon si gloring para sa TRO na yan dahil sa kakamadali nyang tumakas. it was a tactical failure on their part. LOL

  • isalexus

    AY AY AY- here is a case where a narrative is being presented by someone who was not even present during an event. This is like having someone  telling “how big was the fish that got away!!!” — and  she expect us to to accept it as the gospel truth ?As Enrile sez– hearsay!!

  • leo paras

    Nakabawi ang Prosec mula sa “pagbulusok” ng Art 3 makalipas maisalang sa witness stand si Justice Sec Leila de Lima na tumestigo sa Art 7.

    Pumailanglang hanggang alapaap ang posisyon ngayon ng Prosec vs Corona para tuluyang ma-impeach ang chief justice.

    Idiniin ni De Lima si Corona bilang “kapural” sa pag-isyu ng “ersatz” TRO noong Nov 15, 2011 para patakasin si GMA abroad at iwasan ang plunder case na isasampa ng Phl Gov’t vs GMA.

    Good riddance, senator-apparent De Lima, madam!

  • Thadeo Thadeo

    The people have matured. It won’t happen again.  

    The first EDSA was a spontaneous response of the people, after a long sleep and tolerance build up, to the suppression of their cherished freedom.  I remember fondly how passionate and electrically charged I was for its cause.  I tied yellow ribbons in my house, in my cars.  I wore yellow shirts with the face of Ninoy, or yellow polo shirts, or pinned yellow ribbons on the lapel of my coat – as my shout to the world .

      Down with dictatorship.  Down with authoritarianism.  Down with abuses.  Dahil sa iyo (Ninoy), nagising ang tao.  Those were some of the slogans I waved prominently everytime I joined the protests on the streets following Ninoy’s assasination, on through the snap elections, and culminated with the three day event at EDSA.

    This time, I might go back to the streets but I won’t be wearing yellow shirt, nor would I be tying yellow ribbons in my car.  I might be waving placards again with slogans like – DOWN WITH AUTHORITARIANISM, DOWN WITH ABUSES, and DAHIL SA IYO, NABOBO ANG MGA TAO.

    I NEVER THOUGHT THAT THE SON WOULD BE THE ANTI-THESIS OF THE FATHER, and that I would rise up against him passionately, just like what I did, with same fervor, of support   for NINOY and CORY.

    • JasminCubacub

      Can any miracle happen tomorrow? Like PNoy announcing ceasefire with his political enemies?

  • Thadeo Thadeo

    De Lima is hiding some vital information that  will reveal that Malacanang is privy to confidential matters among justices of the Supreme Court.  Pressed for a reply from Sen Cayetano,  the feisty DOJ Secretary hesitated, asked for a pause, and invoked the executive privilege, meaning there were matters that the president (or some members of the cabinet) intimated to her that cannot be divulged, even in the court.  De Lima is hiding some truths coming from the president, or other sources within the cabinet that has something to do with leaks from the Supreme Court and relayed to the Executive Departtment.  We will remember that even before he got hold of the TRO physically,  De Lima started firing orders to her subalterns at the Immigration to disallow GMA from leaving from the Palace.  They had a meeting starting late morning that day, Nov. 15, 2011, anticipating the decision of the SC’s TRO.  They must have learned from an insider, presumably from SC justices, that a TRO is forthcoming and agreed to defy the TRO, even before it was announced by the SC spokesman.  Judging from her testimony, she knew more than what  Sereno’s dissenting opinion says, details which can come only from moles inside the SC or from the justices themselves, and made known to the Palace.

    Now how do you like that.  First, the president denied he was influencing the congressmen to impeach Corona.  Then he declares he was staying away or will not intervene in the process.  When the trial got going, he made statements (disguised as his views) on the merits of the the case.  Now, it is becoming apparent that he is using all the powers and resources of the executive branch to ensure the conviction of the chief justice.  This time, all doubts are erased the the whole thing is the brainchild of the president, and there is no let up in the efforts.  And to think that this man took an oath on the bible before his preferred justice of the SC, Justice Sereno, to uphold and protect the constitution and the laws of the land.  This constitution is the highest law of the land and is based on the proposition that there is separation of powers between the executive, the legislative, and the judiciary, designed for checks and balance within each other.

    This president is trying to dissolve the the three institutions into one which he is heading.  He has the Lower house in his palms already, he has four partymates performing prosecutorial functions disguised as judges, to convict the chief justice – what else is he trying to achieve?

    • http://www.facebook.com/paulino.belga Paulino Belga

      The only question that should be answered is whether Corona is still fit to hold the position of chief justice.  As an ordinary citizen, I will not deal with all those technicalities.  If in our honest and sincere opinion Corona is fit to hold that position, so be it.

      • SignTheWaiverNow

        Nice try! Dapat laging may election araw araw kapag ganito ka mag isip! LOL

    • TGM_ERICK

      all the more we should be cautious of the justice appointees of p-noy. never have i read or learned leaks from the previous sets of SC justices.leakage is destroying the credibility of the supreme court.

    • yatot

      I agree!

      Panut must be called to testify? 

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_JQBHSHS22G65Z6V5Z64XBRCIZQ simon

       why worry for tomorrow? todays problem on CORONA is enough.

      • Thadeo Thadeo

        Who’s worried?  You have a hate problem, and that’s not good for a holy man like you.  Hate is like murder, the bible says so.  I wonder how you could miss it.Are you being selective because you’re guilty of it?

  • randyaltarejos

    This could be the primordial reason why majority members of the collegial body, through the dictates of CJ Corona, speedily approved the issuance of the TRO that would allow Arroyo to flee the country despite the lack of the necessary requirements for its approval.

    • SignTheWaiverNow

      Using your argument, this could be a primordial reason why 188 tongressman signed the impeachment complaint in just a matter of hours! LOL

  • SignTheWaiverNow

    TALO NA ANG KASO KAHIT DI MAGPRESINTA NG EBIDENSYA ANG DEPENSA! WALA NAMAN NAPATUNAYAN ANG PROSECUTORS E! TSK TSK….

    PORK BARREL PA!!!! SIGE PAKALASING TAYO SA TABA!!!! LOL

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/3ZVFIE272VCYKITRNNYFB3VSPI chris

    Corona wanted to help Arroyo escape–De Lima….
    if she just followed the sc ruling and respected the TRO….. corona would have been convicted already by article 7

  • randyaltarejos

    CJ Corona is in this kind of mess is because he undermined the rule of partiality as CJ of the SC. In fact, he only got into the spotlight after this TRO thing cropped up. That’s the reason why there is an impeachment complaint against him. Had Corona known in advance that his name and career would turn abnormal as a consequence of his actions that seemed to have favored the negative wishes of the former president, I’m sure he wouldn’t dip his hands into this mess.

    • yatot

      Do you know what is EN BANC?

      What is COLLEGIAL BODY?

      Murun!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_KF2TCBJ2AUC7VIPR3TACWUGITE Rednaxela VD

    Sec de Lima, you have reached a low of lows…  you now resort to public conviction and bias in an ongoing trial just like penoy? how can we still call you justice secretary when you dont weigh justice fair and break the law?

    sayang ka and you know ginagamit ka lang ni Penoy and LP for Senate seat come 2013..

    sayang ka maam

    • pinklace88

      mas sayang ka, binigyan ka ng mata, ipinipikit mo.

  • henry21

    because of despite the pendency of cases against GMA…. the justices who voted for the issuance and implementation of TRO wants GMA to escape….

    thats the logic of Atty. De Lima… sayang naman…dahil sa sobrang sipsip mo… ganyan ka na kababa….  kawawa naman ang mga bata….

    • Adrienne1225

      Parang ikaw !!! Sipsip kay GMA. Kahit sa dami ng mga ninakaw, kasama na si CJ Corona. Magkano ba ang mga pinagpartihan ninyo?

  • henry21

    Justice Sereno, being the appointee of PNoy will surely say  the confidential matters inside the SC to Pnoy…  ganyan din yan kasipsip… which is definitely alam din ni De Lima kaya nga muntik na siyang madulas… 

    Sereno should come forward and say her piece sa senate impeachment court… para malaman natin kung anong klaseng Justice yan….

    • Adrienne1225

      Tama yan para malaman kung gaano ka corrupt si Corona at ganon kadikit kay Gloria Magnanakw Arroyo (GMA). Confidentiality for  being a rude  supreme court justice? This is the reason why Philippines is so poor, more corruptions more bias to protect criminals in our  justice system. Tax is wasted from these corrupt officials for acquiring ill-gotten wealth and undeclared SALN.

    • pinklace88

      at para malaman din anung klaseng corrupt ang amo mong si Corona, servant ni GMA, fake president appoints fake Chief Justice.

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/BRXF6L5ROQPSXXZQKXDM7QSVU4 Nognog

        tama ka dyan ….fake president….fake chief justice…..fake religion aka Iglesia ni Manalo….

  • http://twitter.com/TUBAGBOHOLcom TUBAGBOHOL.com

    No doubt about it. Master-servant relationship applies here.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_JQBHSHS22G65Z6V5Z64XBRCIZQ simon

    the purpose of the TRO is to let GLORIA  escape…. in the airport, Gloria wants to escape,, and flight according to the bible is a sign of guilt. and the bible say so,, not me but the bible written 3000 years ago and nobody can refutes until today, “flight is a sign of guilt”.

    • Thadeo Thadeo

      Bible ka na naman diyan.  Nangangaral na naman

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/EOEV4LZFRNEA74FB4SPY25NQWQ salvador

      i agree with you. Corona was a midnight appointed CJ by Gloria Arroyo to protect her from incoming civil,criminal cases .Corona advised gloria how to rule out the existing law against midnight appointment{SC interpreted the law in favor corona/gloria by excepting the justices,corana.}they voilated the constitutions by making a law thru their rulings.Justices are only to interpret the law NOT to make a law.They should be also impeached.what the SC rules out becomes law of the land.This should not be because they are subject to abuse and corruptions. Let us amend our justices system with jury system like USA to get rid of bribery ,corruption in justices.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_JQBHSHS22G65Z6V5Z64XBRCIZQ simon

    CORONA and the group of seven,,,agreed or concurred or consented or act in one accord to let GLORIA escape… how much or what favor GLORIA give to them in return,,, i do not want to know,,, and i am not interested to know,,, because the bible is telling us,,, secret things belongs to the Lord,,, 

  • JakeReyes

    Whatever happened to the investigation you are suppose to conduct regarding Lacson’s evading arrest? Hypocrite!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100001372442772 Enchong Millari

    laylay na delima. abugadang wlang prinsipyo. kahit mali-mali, paninidigan. para sa ambisyon. 2013!!!

  • Malitbog1975

    Prove if it’s hearsay, let Sereno be in the witness stand, if she says it’s true or false then we will know and it will be proven or not, SIMPLE!

    • http://profiles.yahoo.com/u/X7QN5BSAGBRDLTLW4644BTJVFU showUmyDICK

       no need to prove it. Sec DeLima admitted herself, that her statements are just hearsays.

  • http://profiles.yahoo.com/u/X7QN5BSAGBRDLTLW4644BTJVFU showUmyDICK

    000

  • nice_boy

    At the time the TRO was issued, there was no case filed against GMA.  She had all the right to travel as guaranteed by our constitution.  De Lima was curtailing her right to travel hence she went to the SC for relief.  The SC in granting the TRO ensured that the right of citizen GMA is not violated. 

    De Lima, in defying the TRO violated not only the right of GMA but also violated the constitution.  She now declares that she will review all orders of the SC and obey only those that she thinks is in conformity to her interpretation of the law.  If everybody follows her example, we will have chaos. 

    It’s ok for the president to control congress.  We can have a unilateral form of government for all I care.  But the Supreme Court must remain independent and must be obeyed and respected. 

  • Francis81

    Maraming salamat po Madame Delilah sa pahayag mong ito kasi sa wakas may kapalit na si Madame Auring! 

  • Malik62

    Is she really a Liar este I mean a Lawyer?   I can’t believe that a lawyer and DOJ Secretary as that, would present a “speculation” as her testimony.



Copyright © 2014, .
To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.
Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:
c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94
Advertisement
Advertisement
Marketplace
Advertisement