Quantcast
Latest Stories

CBCP wants anti-discrimination bill cleansed of provisions on gay rights

By

MANILA, Philippines—The Catholic Bishops’ Conference of the Philippines (CBCP) is now training its guns on the anti-discrimination bill, saying the possible enactment of the bill into law would open the door for the legalization of same sex marriages.

Speaking at a weekly forum in Greenhills, San Juan City, on Wednesday, lawyers of the CBCP and a Catholic bishop hit the Senate for amending the previous version of the anti-discrimination bill or the Senate Bill 2814.

The Senate has recently passed on third reading the bill which is after penalizing all forms of discrimination.

The SB 2814, known as Anti-Ethnic, Racial or Religious Discrimination and Profiling Act of 2011, will be discussed by a bicameral conference committee tasked to harmonize the Senate bill with similar bills passed by the House.

Ronald Reyes, a lawyer of the CBCP, said they had no qualms about the bill before but became concerned when the bill was amended and “sex, gender, sexual orientation, gender identity” were included.

“It’s opening the door for same sex marriages, which our country doesn’t allow,” Reyes told reporters.

He said the Catholic church, which would not officiate same sex marriages, might be punished if the bill became law.

“This is alarming and it might change our society,” Reyes said.

Another CBCP lawyer Jo Imbong said the LGBT (lesbians, gays, bisexuals, transgender) should not be considered the same as the elderly, the handicapped, and the poor.

“These people are disadvantaged not by their own choice. But the third sex, they choose this. How can you give protection to a choice like that?” Imbong said.

Imbong said the bill violated religious freedom and the “no prior restraint” accorded by the law to freedom of speech.

“The government may not penalize a religious organization for … excluding a person from Church responsibilities, for example, based upon that person’s moral behavior which could include the practice or promotion of homosexuality,” she said.

The bill would hinder the Church from teaching what it believed to be right or wrong, Imbong said.

The lawyer noted that under the bill, the priest who refused to officiate same sex marriages may be fined with P500,000 and jailed for 25 years.

Antipolo Bishop Gabriel Reyes said the Episcopal Commission on Family and Life of the CBCP has been appealing to the Senate and the House of Representatives to exclude the LGBT from the bill.


Follow Us

Follow us on Facebook Follow on Twitter Follow on Twitter


Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Tags: anti-discrimination bill , Catholic Bishops’ Conference of the Philippines , CBCP , Gay rights , same-sex marriages

  • Caleb_A

    This discussion is not about the RH Bill, it is about the anti-discrimination bill.  I fully agree that we should seek the truth, which is why we are compelled to hear what science has to say on the matter and then draw our own informed conclusions from there. 

    Giving citizens protection against discrimination is not an imposition of “immorality,” it is a defense of the civil rights of all Filipinos. You will not be forced to become gay, have gay sex against your will, or even start approving of homosexuality if this bill passes. Come on, surely you’re smarter than that.

    • antonioluna

      irregardless of what science has to say about homosexuality RCC should leave this matter to our government and civil society, my opinion on homosexuality may differ from the rests but discrimination and racism don’t have a place in a civilized world, let the government pass laws needed in our times without undue influence from any fanatics institution.

      • Anonymous

        antonioluna…are you flipfloping or what? Now if I understand you correctly, are you now approving that this bill be passed! Am I correct?

      • antonioluna

        huh?did you read my first post in this thread?while you were emotionally busy reading my post about how i see homosexuality as a disease you miserably miss the other side,only gay flip flops.

      • Anonymous

        Why don’t you just say your ideas in Tagalog maybe people won’t misunderstand you! You’re trying so hard speaking in english..but the grammar is so bad the jest of whatever you’re trying to convey is completely lost! It’s convoluted and always comes out sounding ridiculous!

      • antonioluna

        i told you already, its same format whether in english or tagalog hehehe

      • Caleb_A

        Dude, you just agreed with me.  That’s my point as well:  keep religion out of the equation (including the meddling CBCP) and allow the secular government to protect and defend the rights of ALL Filipinos…not just the straight Catholic ones.  I’m glad you’ve seen the light, antonioluna!

      • antonioluna

        dude, you should read my first post in this thread, i did not agree with you because it is my stand from the very beginning, anyway we are on the same side regarding civil rights, whether third sex or not it should be equal.

  • Anonymous

    ‎”You do not have the right to force your religion on others. You do not have the right to discriminate against those who do not practice your religion. To discriminate against someone for not practicing your religion is religious discrimination.” (http://www.huffingtonpost.com/erica-keppler/religious-discrimination-macys-transgender-woman_b_1137472.html)

  • Anonymous

    Hahahahaha..debating with antonioluna..is like pulling your teeth!!!! LOL

    • antonioluna

      that’s how it is when you lack common sense, you seem to have difficulties in understanding simple postings.

      • Anonymous

        Only your posting! I don’t have problem understanding just_anotherperson! He speaks clearly! He even outlines his points! So just you..i am having hard time following it!

  • http://twitter.com/ygrrec dr. mieber/mememon

    being homosexual/transgendered isn’t a choice. why would anyone choose to be discriminated against? 
    besides, we are, first and foremost, FILIPINOS, not just Christians. this bill would benefit all Filipinos, Christian or not. 

  • Anonymous

    We are all born with weaknesses, a direct result of our fallen natures.

    We can deal with these weaknesses in one of two ways. We can accept them as crosses given to us by God, and we can glorify His Name by struggling to overcome them with the aid of His grace. Or we can simply give in and use the “born that way” excuse, the weak and cowardly road that is a vote of no confidence in God’s grace and its ability to save us.

    A person can have a genetic predisposition towards alcoholism. Yet our spouses do not accept the “born that way” excuse if we arrive home drunk every night. Kleptomania may indeed also be genetic, yet no court in the world has ever accepted the “born that way” excuse as a defense against shoplifting charges.

    Alcoholics and those tempted to steal can be good and holy priests — just so long as they recognize their weaknesses, avoid near occasions of sin, and fight to overcome them on a daily basis with the help of God’s grace. Men who are sexually attracted to women or to other men can also become saintly priests — but only if they do not give in to temptation and act out their desires.

    • Anonymous

      Again, you keep looking at this issue in your own religious context! I hope you realize by now that not everyone shares in that belief. Not everyone even believe in a god. So you cannot expect that people see those issues the way you see them.

      Interestingly, I’m amazed that you equate alcoholism and kleptomania to homosexuality. Both of those are included in the current DSM-IV TR as mental disorders that have known psychopathology with specific treatments. Homosexuality is NOT. Alcoholism is an addictive disorder that has both genetic and environmental causes, whereas kleptomania belongs to the obsessive-compulsive disorders. So you cannot lump homosexuality with these other 2 because you said so! That will be ignorance on your part. You might wanna use prayers and denial as treatment but it’s a deservice and unethical to a person to deny him/her that option because you think it can be suppressed by just believing in a god. That’s like tantamount to withholding a much needed blood transfusion to a severely anemic or hemorrhaging child of a Jehova’s witness because Jehova said so and his/her parent agree. And by the way that’s a crime! That’s endangering a child. The child can be taken from their custody and parents be put in jail!

    • Anonymous

      //A person can have a genetic predisposition towards alcoholism. Yet
      our spouses do not accept the “born that way” excuse if we arrive home
      drunk every night. Kleptomania may indeed also be genetic, yet no court
      in the world has ever accepted the “born that way” excuse as a defense
      against shoplifting charges.

      Alcoholics and those tempted to
      steal can be good and holy priests — just so long as they recognize
      their weaknesses, avoid near occasions of sin, and fight to overcome
      them on a daily basis with the help of God’s grace. Men who are sexually
      attracted to women or to other men can also become saintly priests —
      but only if they do not give in to temptation and act out their desires.//

      And once again, you’re trying to equate homosexuality with mental illness. Can you cite how being gay is somehow disruptive to society?

      • Anonymous

        You are putting your own ideas in what I wrote by saying that I am equating same sex attraction with mental illness. Nowhere did I allude to anyone having mental sickness.

        The mentally ill are in bondage of sickness, not in bondage to sin.

      • Caleb_A

        And you’re in bondage to ignorance and fear.

      • Vince B

        actually bondage to stupidity and ignorance

      • AntonioPeYangIII

        //The mentally ill are in bondage of sickness, not in bondage to sin.//

        And who gives a flying buck what you think is sinful or not?

  • Vince B

    wow this thread has been going on over the weekend. you guys must enjoy this too much.

    now justanother_moron is a vaccine denialist. i love it where they can never post how vaccines failed badly.

    @tamumd its useless arguing with that guy. the best you can do is make fun of him or show the rest of the world how moronical he is. welcome to be PDI!

    be sure to get to know mang teban, bgcorg and ianpatrick. resident katolibans and 100% detached from reality.

    • Anonymous

      :-) Thanks for the heads up! I think I’ve met a couple of them already!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_IJYMFWI5A74TKZEOGM5OZ66YZU persistence

    ignorance is the root cause of this discrimination. most people in the world particularly in religious sector refuse to be aware that homosexuality is a natural phenomena. research, educate yourself, and see how homosexuality abounds in the animal kingdom. humans are the only creature with brain capable of inventing their ‘standards’ according to their time-culture preferences..

  • Jeremy Jones

    Interesting… so they want to be discriminated against! Isn’t that the largest bastion of pedophilies and closeted homosexuals in the world!?! The Church is becoming one of the most un-Christian institutions in existence. They care about laws and dogma more than humanity. How different are they from the Pharisees that Jesus lashed out against?

  • exterminator1

    gusto ng cbcp na lahat ng bading eh sumapi sa kanila kaya ayaw nila yan bill na yan. bwisit na mga bading pati sa simbahan naglipana

  • Hfxwst

    There is a group forming in the Philippines whose mission is to have all legislation cleansed of Catholic dogma, discrimination, hate and general mean spiritedness.  There are more than 20 million Filipinos being forced to live under Catholic rule – so it is a human rights issue. Religious extremism. Separation of State and Catholic Church Please – perhaps the Catholic Bishops could learn from other religious leaders in the Philippines and show respect for the Filipino people and their constitution.

    Also,  an investigation is underway to identify all Catholic Priests who arrived in the Philippines within the past 20 years.  It is suspected that this country has been a dumping ground for Priests who have sexually molested children in 1st world countries.  A code of silence, supported by the media, is protecting these priests – or at least that is suspected –  I guess the investigation will tell.

    In a country that cannot feed itself, the RH Bill is a priority – failing passage, would mean we would have to cash in the billions of investments and properties owned by religious groups here in order to feed hungry children – maybe not a bad idea anyway as Christ taught humility, something very needed by this bunch of Bishops.



Copyright © 2013, .
To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.
Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:
c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94
Advertisement

News

  • It’s Furlough Friday for federal workers
  • Church revenge: Buhay says Catholic vote was key
  • It’s looking like NP’s for Drilon, says Alan Cayetano
  • Substandard maritime schools warned anew
  • 78 massacre suspects face charges over 58th victim
  • Sports

  • Vengeful Beermen destroy Slammers
  • Ateneo goes for sweep
  • Que fires career-low 62, rules Orchard by four
  • Warriors foil Archers; Lions, Chiefs triumph
  • Paragua still leads
  • Lifestyle

  • Read-Along at 6 picks celebs as ambassadors
  • Mt. Pulag revisited: Quo vadis?
  • Healthy gorilla born to 1st time parents at US zoo
  • US teen takes Danish supermodel to prom
  • Ninoy Aquino’s birthday is ‘Day of Reading’
  • Entertainment

  • Julie Delpy on life at 40
  • It takes two to do the show biz breakup cha-cha
  • Juday: Violence against women unacceptable
  • PH cineastes celebrate in the French Riviera
  • Stone Temple Pilots sue ex-frontman Scott Weiland
  • Business

  • Coco sugar sweetens small town’s finances
  • Along Mt. Bulusan’s foothills: A balmy ‘agricultural resort’
  • For Mona Serrano, there is no ‘escape’ from entrepreneurship
  • Buildings designed with unique character finding market
  • 18 Avon top sellers get a car each in ‘lipstick red’ shade
  • Technology

  • A new way for Filipinos to connect on social media launched
  • Statement of Smart Communications
  • Yahoo takes big leap with $1.1B deal for Tumblr
  • Poll: More US teens turn to Twitter; Facebook old
  • Tips to avoid becoming an identity theft victim
  • Opinion

  • Deep impact
  • The return of traditional politics in Pampanga
  • Most important investment incentive
  • Making (and keeping) friends
  • The Trinity and us
  • Global Nation

  • Sky lanterns light up Iloilo sky, set world record
  • Filipino WWII veterans used to cover up for senators’ inaction on family unification
  • Warship from US here next month
  • Taiwan has new terms
  • Taipei welcomes start of fisheries talks with PH
  • Marketplace
    Advertisement
    Azure Skin Ad
    Azure Skin Ad
    © Copyright 1997-2013 INQUIRER.net | All Rights Reserved