In this March 26, 2015 file photo drawings of some of 43 missing students are surrounded by flower petals, formimg the shape of a heart, during a protest marking the six-month anniversary of their disappearance, in Mexico City. An independent report released Sunday Sept. 6, 2015 dismantles the Mexican government”s investigation into last year’s disappearance of 43 teachers’ college students, starting with the assertion that the giant funeral pyre in which the attorney general said they were burned to ash beyond identification simply never happened. AP FILE PHOTO
MEXICO CITY, Mexico—Almost a year since the disappearance of 43 students tainted his administration’s international image, the case has come back to haunt Mexican President Enrique Pena Nieto.
Pena Nieto’s approval rating began to plunge after his government’s handling of the case was criticized last year, and now an independent probe has raised questions about the credibility of the official investigation.
READ: Mexican government affirms that missing students burned at dump
Experts from the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights rejected the government’s conclusion—that the students were incinerated by a drug gang in a garbage dump—as scientifically impossible.
The panel also put the army on the spot, calling for an investigation into whether soldiers failed in their duty to protect the young men while corrupt police attacked and detained them in the southern city of Iguala.
“It’s another element that adds up to the lack of credibility of the official narrative in many areas,” Hector Zamitiz Gamboa, political science professor at the National Autonomous University of Mexico, told AFP.
‘Tunnel of impunity’
Pena Nieto’s popularity had already taken a battering in recent weeks following the prison escape of Mexico’s most powerful drug lord, Joaquin “El Chapo” Guzman in July.
He and his wife have also come under scrutiny over the purchase of a mansion from a government contractor, although a government investigation said they did nothing wrong.
The independent probe into the Iguala case found that some detainees in the case claimed they were tortured and that some evidence, including video footage, was destroyed.
The experts urged the government to open a new line of investigation into their own theory: that the students may have been viciously attacked because they inadvertently snatched a bus used to transport drugs.
“Mexico needs to resolve the case as soon as possible, not only to solve this crime, but also to prove to the world that there is a light at the end of the tunnel of impunity in Mexico,” El Universal newspaper said in an editorial.
While the government said it would investigate the garbage dump again, the director of investigations at the attorney general’s office insisted that at least a large group of students were burned there.
“Rather than doing new tests to prove a theory that has already been discarded, the Mexican government should work to restructure the investigation and pursue all of the proposed lines of investigation,” said Maureen Meyer, a Mexico expert at the Washington Office on Latin America, an advocacy group.
‘Massive stain’ on government
The former attorney general, Jesus Murilla Karam called the official account of the fire last year the “historic truth.”
Denise Dresser, a renowned political analyst, wrote in the daily Reforma that the case was a “historic lie” that was fabricated by prosecutors to “turn the page, close the book.”
The case never went away and Pena Nieto has faced criticism for only meeting with parents of the victims once and never going to visit them in their impoverished home state of Guerrero.
Pena Nieto, however, said on Monday that he was willing to meet with them again “and support them in a permanent way” because he shared their desire to know the truth.
A day before, relatives of the students had demanded a meeting with him this week along with the experts of the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights.
The human rights group Amnesty International said the commission’s findings are “a massive stain on the Mexican government’s reputation, which they can only begin to reverse if they find those responsible.”
RELATED STORIES
Thousands protest in Mexico City over missing students
Clashes as Mexicans hold rally for 43 missing students