Luistro: Defense now dragging impeachment, validates article withdrawal

SUBSTANTIALAND COMPELLING Lead prosecutor Gerville Luistro tells the impeachment court the evidence they have presented were sufficient to warrant Vice President Sara Duterte’s removal for culpable violation of the Constitution and betrayal of public trust. —NIÑO JESUS ORBETA
Lead prosecutor Gerville Luistro —NIÑO JESUS ORBETA

MANILA, Philippines — The slow pace of Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial once the defense started presenting witnesses — and their request to defer trial dates — only validates the need to expedite the proceedings and withdraw several articles, Batangas Rep. Gerville Luistro said on Friday.

In a press briefing after Day 45 of Duterte’s trial, Luistro said that with the way the defense is dragging the trial, they would have consumed more time if three of four Articles of Impeachment were not withdrawn by the prosecution.

Last October 13, Luistro — the lead public prosecutor — manifested before open court that they will no longer present three articles, and would move forward with Article II only, or the allegation that Duterte amassed unexplained wealth and failed to declare it in her Statement of Assets, Liabilities, and Net Worth (SALN).

“We are now witnessing how the defense has been dragging the presentation of their evidence.  And take note, there is only one remaining article, so try to imagine if there are four articles of impeachment.  I think I would be correct when I said ‘baka 2028 na hindi pa tapos ang presentation ng defense,’” Luistro said.

(We are now witnessing how the defense has been dragging the presentation of their evidence.  And take note, there is only one remaining article, so try to imagine if there are four articles of impeachment.  I think I would be correct when I said ‘it might be 2028 already and the defense hasn’t finished presenting.)

“As a matter of fact, based on my observation on how the defense is presenting its witness, it only validates the decision of the prosecution to let go of the three, let the Ombudsman and the Regional Trial Court of Quezon City take care of the confidential fund, the bribery, and the grave threat, and we focus on the most-appreciated article by the public,” she added.

READ: From 4 to 1: Impeachment court OKs reduced raps vs Sara Duterte

Article I deals with the alleged confidential fund misuse within Duterte’s offices, while Article III contains allegations that the vice president bribed Department of Education officials, and Article IV her supposed grave threats against President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. and his relatives.

The prosecution started presenting its case last July with Article IV, before moving to Article I by the end of the same month.  By mid-September, the prosecution shifted to Article II.Article III was no longer presented by the panel.

Luistro also reiterated that the prosecution did not waste the Senate Impeachment Court’s time when it withdrew the Articles of Impeachment, contrary to the statements of lead defense counsel Sheila Sison.

Sison, during the latter part of Friday’s trial, said that the defense remains committed to moving forward and would not like a “protracted trial,” adding that they have not “wasted three months of time for presenting witnesses that will eventually be withdrawn.”

Luistro countered that the withdrawal of the articles saves the impeachment court’s time, and allows it to focus on other functions like passing the 2027 national budget.

“The prosecution maintains its position that we did not waste the time of the impeachment court when we withdrew the three other Articles of Impeachment.  Please take note, we merely considered number one, the interest of the public — they have the right to witness the conclusion of this long impeachment process,” Luistro said.

“Second, we considered also the equally important legislative functions, other legislative functions of the Senate, that includes the hearing of one of the most important pieces of legislation, and that is of course the budget for 2027.  And ultimately, it is indeed a favor for the defense because they needed to present only on the last remaining article that is unexplained wealth,” she added.

Earlier, impeachment court Presiding Officer Francis Escudero said that the court will adjourn to give way to the budget deliberations, and will resume on November 26 and 27, following the original schedule where the trial will be held in the morning and session will be conducted afterwards.

READ: Escudero unveils VP trial schedule for December

However, Sison informed the court that none of their listed witnesses would be available on those days, requesting that the trial scheduled on November 26 and 27 be cancelled.  Escudero granted this request.

Eventually, Escudero said that the next trial days would be on December 1 to 4, 7, 9 to 11 and 14 to 16, as necessary. /ms

Read more...