Chua: SALN, AMLC, SEC, COA data support probable cause vs Sara Duterte

Manila Rep. Joel Chua on Saturday night cited government records as strong bases for proving the alleged misuse of confidential funds and unexplained wealth of Vice President Sara Duterte.
These include Statements of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth (SALN), Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) reports, Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) filings, and Commission on Audit (COA) notices of disallowance, the lawmaker said.
While the House committee on justice’s unanimous finding of probable cause does not amount to a declaration of guilt, Chua said Duterte would still need to present counterevidence to rebut the allegations if these are untrue.
“We are not saying that she is already guilty. Our basis here is only probable cause. This means it is likely that it happened. But of course, she needs to present evidence to rebut all the allegations,” Chua said in Filipino in an interview on ONE News’ “Politika All The Way.”
Chua explained that one of the main concerns raised in the impeachment complaints involves alleged discrepancies in Duterte’s SALN declarations when compared with her and her husband’s bank transactions over the past two decades.
He noted that from 2007 to 2018, Duterte’s SALN reflected declared millions in cash on hand and bank deposits per year.
However, from 2019 to 2024, he said these entries were reported as zero, with the defense explaining that these were allegedly consolidated under “others.”
READ: PDP: Lawmakers backing Sara Duterte impeach bid may lose 2028 support
Chua questioned this explanation, saying the figures declared under “others” only amounted to P5.8 million for one year. However, AMLC data showed that about P6.7 billion in covered and suspicious bank transactions were recorded over several years, consisting of both inflows and outflows.
Of this amount, he said, approximately P4 billion represented inflows, while about P1.8 billion represented outflows, leaving a remaining balance that raised further questions when compared with declared income levels.
“Now, how do you reconcile the two? What mathematical computation would you apply?” he said in Filipino.
Chua also argued that even when computed against a long-term public salary trajectory, the figures did not align with the declared financial capacity of a government official.
“Let’s say a government official earns P300,000 a month. Multiply that by a month. So in a year, that is only P3.6 million. In ten years, that is P36 million,” he said in Filipino.
“The figures do not match,” he added.
The Manila House leader also cited SEC records showing that businesses linked to Duterte and her husband posted either minimal earnings or losses, further raising questions on their source of funds.
“The SEC records showed that all businesses they opened were at a loss. All were declared losses. If there were earnings, they were not that large. The income was around P1 point something million, P400,000,” Chua said.
“So now, what defense will you make? How will you say that this is politics? Or that this is ill-gotten wealth?” he added.
READ: Lawmakers backing VP impeach raps know the risks – Puno
Meanwhile, on the use of confidential funds, Chua cited a Philippine Statistics Authority (PSA) certification showing that many of the beneficiaries listed in acknowledgment receipts had no corresponding records in the civil registry, raising serious doubts about their identities and the legitimacy of the reported recipients.
“It came out that the names Mary Grace Piatos and Kokoy Villamin, right? When we requested them from the PSA, there were no such living persons with those names. They do not exist,” he said in Filipino.
Even if the recipients were assumed to be real, he said the Office of the Vice President would still have to explain how and why it spent P1 million on a “safe house” rental in just four days, according to the receipts it submitted to COA.
Chua further cited audit findings, including notices of disallowance covering P73 million in confidential funds in the last quarter of 2022 and another P375 million for the first three quarters of 2023. He said the first notice of disallowance had already become final at the Commission Proper after the OVP’s appeal was denied, with the en banc ruling finding that the expenses were not sufficiently justified.
He also mentioned findings from the Committee on Good Government and Public Accountability involving the Department of Education’s “Youth Leadership Summits,” noting that the Philippine Army itself stated it did not receive any confidential fund support for the conduct of the trainings and instead used its own funds, along with allocations from local government units.
“He admitted it. It is on record. The Marine who issued the certification said that four did not receive anything,” he added.
The records that Chua mentioned are among the documentary pieces of evidence presented during the committee on justice’s clarificatory hearings on the impeachment complaints filed against Duterte. The same records were cited in the articles of impeachment prepared by the committee, which will be put to a plenary vote on May 11 on whether to transmit the case to the Senate for trial.