Palace: ‘Leaked’ DPWH documents remain ‘hearsay without probative value’

MANILA, Philippines — The Palace on Friday maintained that the alleged leaked Department of Public Works and Highways (DPWH) documents remain “hearsay without probative value,” as it rejected insinuations that it is covering up for anyone.
Presidential Communications Office Undersecretary Claire Castro said this in response to Senate president pro tempore Panfilo “Ping” Lacson, who urged Malacañang not to prematurely dismiss allegations in the flood control scandal to avoid any perception of a cover-up.
READ: Lacson to Palace: Avoid ‘premature’ dismissal of flood control allegations
Lacson was specifically referring to when Castro earlier tagged as “hearsay” claims made by Batangas 1st District Rep. Leandro Leviste, citing DPWH documents he allegedly received from the late Public Works Usec. Maria Catalina Cabral supposedly showing that Cabinet secretaries backed the 2025 budget insertions.
“With all due respect to Sen. Lacson, it is the alleged ‘Cabral’s files’ without yet being authenticated by the DPWH that remains hearsay and without probative value. We are only talking about the unverified ‘Leviste list’,” said Castro in a message to reporters.
“There is nothing in our statements that questions the pieces of evidence that had already been discovered through the hearings conducted by the Senate Blue Ribbon Committee which he chairs,” she added.
She then maintained that the Marcos administration and all relevant agencies, including the Independent Commission on Infrastructure, are already working to gather evidence “so that the culprits may be prosecuted for their illegal acts.”
READ: Claire Castro Christmas wish: No more obstructionists, destabilizers
“Rule of law should always be observed, and mere hearsay evidence is generally inadmissible and has no room to be entertained,” Castro said.
She also reiterated President Ferdinand Marcos Jr.’s commitment that all involved in anomalous infrastructure projects will be held accountable, even if they are relatives, friends or allies.
“It is not acceptable to insinuate that the Palace is covering up for someone,” said Castro.
With this, Castro reiterated that the said documents remain questionable, as there is no proof that they really came from the DPWH.
“Unless the documents come from DPWH, we could not give the alleged ‘Cabral files’ or any list from an unknown source any probative value,” said Castro.
“It is nothing but hearsay and can be treated as mere fabricated documents,” she added.
Not the Palace’s job to verify documents’ authenticity
Meanwhile, when asked to respond to Leviste’s call to have Palace verify with Public Works Secretary Vince Dizon if the claims are true that some cabinet officials are proponents of budget insertions, Castro responded that it is not the job of Malacañang to do so.
“He (Leviste) has started bragging about them, so it is his responsibility to prove their authenticity,” said Castro.
“Why should he shift his responsibility to others? We are not even aware if what he is in possession of are mere altered or fabricated documents,” she added.
Castro then stressed that anyone who wishes throw accusations should “substantiate their claims with verified facts and documents.”
“They should not order or obligate others to verify their own allegations,” said Castro.
Leviste previously claimed that high-ranking officials, which allegedly included Cabinet secretaries, were supposedly listed as proponents involved in the controversial 2025 infrastructure budget insertions.
This is based on documents he allegedly received from the late Public Works Usec. Maria Catalina Cabral on September 4.
But Leviste only made the revelation following the death of Cabral, who was likewise implicated in the insertions controversy and reportedly fell from a slope on Kennon Road on December 19. /mr