Turning proof into power: Communities demand clean air after landmark study

Waste burning facilities in the Philippines, Indonesia, and Nigeria. Photos from War on Waste Negros Oriental, Green Knowledge Foundation, and WALHI East Java.
MANILA, Philippines—As air quality monitors finally went silent in Dumaguete, Surabaya, and Ogijo, the communities behind the world’s first cross-regional citizen-led air study were left with more than just numbers—they now held undeniable proof of a public health crisis.
The first part of this series detailed how ordinary residents—storekeepers, waste workers, mothers, and students—exposed dangerously high levels of toxic air pollution in three cities on two continents.
READ: Clearing the air: Ordinary citizens uncover toxic truths near waste incinerators
These findings come from Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives’ (GAIA) Air Quality Monitoring (AQM) initiative, based on the recently released study “Clearing the Air: The Truth Behind Waste Incineration.”
Their efforts revealed that, across these communities, nearly every day brought pollution far above the World Health Organization’s “safe” threshold, and that the health impacts were immediate and far-reaching: children suffering from persistent coughs, families worried about their future, and local leaders demanding answers from silent authorities.
But gathering evidence was only the beginning. Turning this data into real change—policy reform, cleaner air, and justice for the affected—would become the next challenge for these citizen-scientists.
Science by the people, for the people
The volunteers’ work was meticulous. Every reading was logged alongside a daily activity diary—listing where they went, what they did, and what other sources of pollution might have been present.
“We gave them a list of all the known particulate matter sources that you’d find,” Dr. Jorge Emmanuel, chief technical advisor for the project and adjunct professor at Silliman University, explained. That allowed the researchers to filter out spikes from cooking, traffic, or open fires, and pinpoint what came from the plants themselves.

Graphics by Ed Lustan/Inquirer.net
Thanks to the community’s careful monitoring, the study produced hard data that local officials can no longer ignore.
“Often, the burden of proving that industrial pollutants could cause harm are unjustly placed on poor communities, but new technologies such as the one used in our study allow citizens to present incontrovertible evidence of exposures to toxic pollutants and demand greater transparency and accountability,” said Dr. Emmanuel.
A call for justice and real solutions
For all three communities, the message is now impossible to ignore: the right to clean air is not being met, and urgent action is needed—both from local leaders and from those who live with the consequences every day.
In Dumaguete, Aloja Santos, one of the community volunteers in the air monitoring project, called on her neighbors and leaders to face the problem together. “I’m encouraging the citizens of Dumaguete, all residents from the affected communities, to join us in solving the silent problem of the city.”
Santos also called on newly elected officials to “halt the operation of the pyrolysis machine by signing into law an executive order mandating its cessation, because pyrolysis does not benefit the people in any way, nor does it provide value to the community and the environment.”
Mildred Ollena, another volunteer from Dumaguete, echoed the concern for future generations: “My appeal to the people is that we do not burn the future for the generations to come.”
READ: Risks loom as worsening garbage mess pushes deep PH dive into waste-to-energy

Graphics by Ed Lustan/Inquirer.net
In Surabaya, Muhammad Jibril (Jai) of WALHI expressed his concern: “I am just quite worried about the future… I think the government has a big responsibility here because the WTE is also the responsibility of the government in the prevention of air pollution.”
His colleague, Lucky Wahyu Wardhana, urged: “It is important for the government to ensure that the area around the plant does not become a slum and is liveable… especially that the air quality be monitored and maintained.”
And in Ogijo, Nigeria, Collins Azuike of the Green Knowledge Foundation (GKF) reminded everyone: “People are going to stay here. And these factories keep producing and polluting the air. So we wish something could be done so that people can breathe clean air. Clean air is everybody’s right. It’s a human right.”
The fight isn’t over
As the monitors are put away, the haze still lingers over Dumaguete, Surabaya, and Ogijo. But now, the evidence is undeniable. For many, the fight is just beginning.
Despite mounting warnings from scientists and grassroots groups, support for waste-burning continues at the highest levels. In the Philippines, President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. has repeatedly promoted waste-to-energy (WTE) as a “modern” solution and potential income generator for the country.
Just recently, he announced a planned WTE project for Metro Manila in partnership with Japan’s Kanadevia Corporation, emphasizing the government’s interest in large-scale incineration despite local and international concerns.
READ: Marcos discusses plan for waste-to-energy project during Japan visit
Environmental groups, however, have continued to sound the alarm. Advocates such as EcoWaste Coalition have publicly warned President Marcos that waste-to-energy “won’t solve flooding, won’t solve our waste crisis, and will only worsen pollution and threaten community health,” urging the government to pursue real zero waste strategies instead.
READ: EcoWaste tells Marcos: Waste-to-energy won’t solve flooding
The debate is not just theoretical. In Baguio City—long plagued by its own garbage woes—Mayor Benjamin Magalong abandoned all proposed waste-to-energy projects and instead doubled down on recycling, composting, and better waste management. The result? Baguio has shown that it’s possible to control trash and protect public health without resorting to burning.
READ: Baguio’s daily trash drops by 50 tons after shift to reusing waste
But the story doesn’t stop at national borders. Waste-burning projects in the Global South are often presented as sophisticated fixes for mounting plastic waste, much of it produced in the Global North and shipped to developing countries as disposable products or through the waste trade.

Graphics by Ed Lustan/Inquirer.net
Even in countries with tough environmental rules, incineration has proven risky.
Still, major financial institutions like the Asian Development Bank and World Bank continue to recommend and bankroll waste incineration, especially in the Global South, despite a history of controversy and community pushback.
READ: Waste energy: ‘False solution’
As Weyinmi Okotie, GAIA Africa’s Clean Air Program Manager, put it:
“Global climate financing for waste management should avoid funding these false solutions and prioritise solutions at the top of the waste hierarchy, which not only reduce climate emissions but also deliver co-benefits like local job creation, soil restoration, and improved livelihoods.”
For the communities who bravely tracked the air they breathe, the challenge now is to turn hard data into real change, so that the right to clean air, long denied, finally becomes a reality.
A world beyond the smokestack
All across the Global South, communities like Dumaguete, Surabaya, and Ogijo know firsthand what it means to live under the shadow of incinerator pollution. But while the health risks become harder to ignore, real-life examples of a better path forward are emerging, offering hope—and proof—that things can change.
GAIA notes that over 500 cities worldwide are now taking concrete steps to tackle waste before it becomes a crisis. They’re cutting down on single-use products, building up community recycling efforts, and putting public health at the heart of local policies.
In more and more countries, local leaders are refusing shipments of foreign waste, slapping fines on throwaway packaging, and closing incinerators in favor of zero waste programs that are shaped by, and for, the community.
This shift isn’t just about clearing the air. According to GAIA, cities making the move to zero waste are seeing waste management costs drop, new jobs created, and neighborhoods becoming safer, cleaner, and more resilient.
Much of this progress is thanks to the work of GAIA’s network in Asia and Africa, including groups like WAU, GKF, and WALHI—everyday people who are showing what’s possible when citizens are given the tools and support to stand up for their communities.
The story in Dumaguete, Surabaya, and Ogijo is echoed in city after city: ordinary people, equipped with the facts and a sense of purpose, can spark real, lasting change. As GAIA and its partners have shown, accountability starts at the grassroots, and solutions are strongest when they come from those living closest to the problem.
“With tools like air quality monitors, we can shine a light on wrongdoing and fight for our loved ones to breathe clean air. It’s time to stop the smokestack and go for zero waste,” GAIA said.
