Judge lets go of Apas case

By: - Senior Reporter / @inquirervisayas
/ 07:26 AM May 09, 2012

As the judge who convicted Ruben Ecleo Jr. of parricide last month, he’s known to be tough and decisive.

But yesterday Regional Trial Court Judge Soliver Peras surprised  parties by  delaring that he  would no longer handle  the eviction case affecting 168 families in barangay Apas.


He cited “personal circumstances” in his order of inhibition and and sent the case records back for reraffling to another judge.

“Considering that portions of the camp, as indicated by the court sheriff (and) based on the sketch attached to the case records are included in this case, the undersigned deemed it necessary to inhibit from this case,” said the judge of Branch 10.


Peras did not elaborate.

His  reference  to a “camp” was clearly  Camp Lapu-Lapu where  the judge  resides.

Peras is an Army reservist or a civilian who belongs to the  military reserve force.

Many occupants in the private lot dispute are retired military and police personnel who settled in the area near the military camp since 1960.

The awkward situation was first pointed out by Benjamin Militar, lawyer of the settlers, who questioned how the judge could rule against neighbors by upholding an earlier court  decision affirming the ownership of Mariano Godinez’ of the  4.7 hectare property.

“We feel he has done a grave injustice,” Militar said.

“He is living in the camp with the help of the people who live there. The residents whom he asked to leave are the same persons who secured him and tried hard so he can live inside the camp,” said the lawyer.


RTC Executive Judge Sylvestre Maamo Jr. still has to decide whether to grant the  inhibition.

Roberto Palmares, lawyer of the land owner,  said this develop ment would  delay the demolition of houses on the property which was earlier set for May 7 then posptoned.

“Sayang kaayo. (It’s very unfortunate.) Judge Peras is an independent, competent and very efficient judge. This won’t be good for us.  I’m sad but what can I do?” he told Cebu Daily News.

Nontheless, he said he would not oppose the judge’s decision.

“Samok na kaayo.  (It would be a hassle)”

“The bottomline is why should the RTC resolve the issues when it has no jurisdiction over the case? It’s now the Court of Appeals that should decide,” he said.

Palmares said the settlers certainly want another judge who would rule in their favor.

“We can’t tell. Maybe the new judge will have another opinion (of the issues),” he said.

Militar said he’s hoping the case will be raffled  to a new judge on Monday.

“We hope the new judge (who shall handle the case) will hear the arguments of the Office of the Solicitor General (OSG),” Militar said.

The OSG wanted to intervene in the case and asked for a 30-day delay of the write of demolition.

However,  its “urgent motion to stay execution of the writ of demolition ” , a last-ditch move on behalf of the settlers, wasn’t acted upon by Peras because only a faxed copy reached him on Monday.

The judge didn’t consider the fax a genuine pleading and decided to”note without action” the faxed document.

The settlers, Militar said, would have intervened in the case filed by Godinez against the Republic of the Philippines when it was still with the lower court.

But the motion for intervention filed by the settlers was denied by the court.

Last April 20, Judge Peras gave the go signal for the court sheriff to demolish structures built in Godinez’ property. In 2002, RTC Judge Benigno Gaviola earlier ruled that Godinez  was the “absolute  and exclusive owner” of the lot.

The lot also housed a regional police training center and part of Camp Lapu-Lapu.

The families through their association, the Archangels Residents Mergence Inc. (ARMI) filed a petition for certiorari before the Court of Appeals (CA). It was dismissed for lack of merit.

Residents said they were not parties to the case or included in the judgment of the civil case.

They said they believed the government had expropriated the land and that the lot was identified as a socialized housing site under Cebu City Council Resolution 99-4771 on June 30, 1999.

The regional police are coordinating with the Central Command on the scheduled demolition.

Chief Supt. Marcelo Garbo, regional police chief, said they are taking every effort to ensure that  no violence would occur if  and when the demolition pushes through.

Cebu Archbishop Jose Palma also shared Garbo’s sentiment, saying the rights of the families should also be respected.

He said he ordered some parish priests to study the situation of the Apas families.

”All works, actinos project or events should be seen in the context of the particular circumstances and with the background of faith,” said Palma.

He said people are free to act “as long as in principle, we say it is according to their consitutional rights and as long as there is no violence.  That’s part of democracy,” he told reporters. /With Correspondents Chito Aragon and Fe Marie D. Dumaboc

Read Next
Don't miss out on the latest news and information.
View comments

Subscribe to INQUIRER PLUS to get access to The Philippine Daily Inquirer & other 70+ titles, share up to 5 gadgets, listen to the news, download as early as 4am & share articles on social media. Call 896 6000.

TAGS: Apas case, parricide, Regional Trial Court Judge Soliver Peras, Ruben Ecleo Jr.
For feedback, complaints, or inquiries, contact us.

© Copyright 1997-2020 INQUIRER.net | All Rights Reserved

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By continuing, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. To find out more, please click this link.