Maui’s emergency management chief quits amid criticism for not using sirens during fire
Trees charred by the Maui wildfires stand near the shell of a building in Lahaina, Hawaii, United States, August 15, 2023. US Army National Guard/Staff Sgt. Matthew A. Foster/Handout via REUTERS
KIHEI, Hawaii — Maui County Emergency Management administrator Herman Andaya, criticized by local residents and media over the island’s response to the deadly wildfires that killed at least 111 people, resigned on Thursday, officials said.
A statement from Maui County Mayor Richard Bissen cited health reasons.
“Given the gravity of the crisis we are facing, my team and I will be placing someone in this key position as quickly as possible and I look forward to making that announcement soon,” Bissen said.
The resignation takes place one day after Andaya made his first appearance in a press conference, which came more than a week after the catastrophe destroyed or damaged 2,200 buildings and caused some $5.5 billion in damage. Hundreds of people remain unaccounted for.
Some Maui residents said lives could have been saved had emergency sirens sounded, but Andaya’s agency opted against using them, saying they would have been ineffective and confusing.
READ: Maui officials defend decision not to sound sirens during wildfire
“The public is trained to seek higher ground in the event that the siren is sounded,” Andaya said during Wednesday’s press conference, which grew tense at times as reporters questioned the government response during the fire.
“Had we sounded the siren that night, we’re afraid that people would have gone mauka (to the mountainside) and if that was the case then they would have gone into the fire,” Andaya said.
In other developments, President Joe Biden vowed on Thursday that the United States government would remain steadfast in its commitment to help the people of Maui recover, rebuild, and grieve after last week’s deadly wildfires that incinerated the historic resort town of Lahaina.
In a brief video aired on ABC’s “Good Morning America,” Biden said the federal government had already sent hundreds of emergency personnel, thousands of meals, and essential supplies such as cots and blankets to the devastated town.
“We will be with you for as long as it takes, I promise you,” said Biden, who will travel to Hawaii on Monday to survey the devastation and meet with first responders and survivors.
Also on Thursday, August 17, Hawaii Attorney General Anne Lopez said in a written statement that she will appoint a private, third-party agency to investigate and review how state and county officials responded to the deadly wildfire.
READ: ‘Nobody told us jack’: Hawaii fire victims say no warnings
Hawaii Governor Josh Green has tasked Lopez with carrying out a comprehensive review of actions taken before, during, and after the fire, and the third-party investigation will be a part of that effort. The review will likely take months, Lopez wrote.
Hundreds of volunteers have come to the aid of displaced Lahaina residents, many of whom are now sleeping in Maui County-run shelters, at the homes of friends and relatives, and in donated hotel rooms and vacation rentals.
Volunteers are donating supplies, helping distribute food and water, and providing emotional support to many of their fellow Maui residents.
“We’re all one big family in Maui, we call it ‘ohana’,” said Louis Romero, a 55-year-old retired battalion chief for the island’s fire department, who is helping run a crisis-relief hub. “You don’t have to be blood relatives to consider you family. That’s the Hawaiian way. We help each other.”
READ: Tourists are urged to avoid Maui as hotels prepare to take in evacuees, first responders
Meanwhile, Hawaii senior water manager Kaleo Manuel was transferred to a different position, according to a statement by the state’s land and natural resources department, after reports he stalled on requests by a real estate development company to release agricultural water to help fight the Lahaina fire until the blaze was established in a wildland area.
Hawaii’s Department of Land and Natural Resources (DLNR) said in a late Wednesday statement that the agency was “re-deploying” Manuel to “a different DLNR division.” The statement said the move was to allow Maui’s water management agency to focus on wildfire recovery work.
“This deployment does not suggest that First Deputy Manuel did anything wrong,” the statement said.
The Hawaii Alliance for Progressive Action said Hawaii’s government was using Manuel as a scapegoat for the Lahaina fire and an earlier release of the stream water into reservoirs would have made no difference as they are not connected to Lahaina’s hydrant system and it was too windy for helicopters to fly and scoop water out of them.
READ: IN PHOTOS: Nearly a week after Maui wildfire, islanders survey aftermath, look ahead to recovery
