French court to have final say on pensions reform
Protesters clash with police officers during a demonstration on the 12th day of action after the government pushed a pensions reform through parliament without a vote, using the article 49.3 of the constitution, in Nantes, western France on April 13, 2023. (Photo by LOIC VENANCE / AFP)
Paris, France — France’s top constitutional court is to rule Friday on whether to approve President Emmanuel Macron’s deeply unpopular pensions overhaul after months of protests.
The 45-year-old centrist leader is facing a major domestic crisis over his flagship pensions reform, whose headline measure is to raise the legal retirement age to 64 from 62.
Some demonstrations have turned violent since Macron’s government forced the bill through parliament last month without a vote, using an executive power that is legal but has sparked accusations of undemocratic behaviour from opponents.
The Constitutional Council’s green light is the final hurdle before Macron can sign the changes into law and ensure they are implemented by year-end.
But labor unions and opposition lawmakers hope for a rejection of a reform that Macron put at the heart of his re-election campaign last year for a second term in office.
Article continues after this advertisementSome 380,000 people took to the streets nationwide on Thursday in the latest day of union-led action against the bill since January, according to the interior ministry.
Article continues after this advertisementBut that was far fewer that the nearly 1.3 million it said demonstrated at the height of the protests in March.
Momentum has petered out in recent weeks as people appear to become increasingly weary of sacrificing a day’s pay to strike or march.
A woman writes “resistance, the voice of the people is legitimate” on pavement during a demonstration on the 12th day of action after the government pushed a pensions reform through parliament without a vote, using the article 49.3 of the constitution, in Combourg, western France on April 13, 2023. – France faced nationwide protests and strikes on April 13, 2023, to denounce the French government’s pension reform on the eve of a ruling from France’s Constitutional Council on the reform. (Photo by Damien MEYER / AFP)
Partial approval?
Paris police have banned any demonstration around the Constitutional Council in Paris until Saturday morning.
The court is to issue two decisions by the end of the day.
First, the nine-member council is to rule on whether the pensions overhaul, which has been formulated as a social security budget law, is in line with the constitution.
Experts think the most likely scenario is that it will partially approve the bill.
That means it may scrap some details of the law as inappropriate for that kind of legislation, but it will probably throw its weight behind its core elements, including pushing back the minimum legal age for retirement.
Second, the court is to look into two separate requests from the left-wing opposition to launch a possible referendum on an alternative law to limit the retirement age to 62.
It is not yet clear whether it will give its go-ahead, but the path towards any actual referendum would be very long.
For any vote, the opposition would need to collect some 4.8 million signatures from members of the electorate backing their proposal within nine months.
And a referendum would take place only if both chambers of parliament refused to examine the bill in the next six months — something regarded as unlikely.
Flames rise from a Mercedes car set on fire during a demonstration on the 12th day of action after the government pushed a pensions reform through parliament without a vote, using the article 49.3 of the constitution, in Rennes, northwestern France on April 13, 2023. – France faced nationwide protests and strikes on April 13, 2023, to denounce the French government’s pension reform on the eve of a ruling from France’s Constitutional Council on the reform. (Photo by Damien MEYER / AFP)
‘End to procedures’
Having repeatedly dismissed calls for talks with union leaders in recent weeks, Macron has said he will invite labor representatives for discussions once the court decision is published.
“The decision from the Constitutional Council on Friday will bring an end to the democratic and constitutional procedures,” Macron told reporters on a trip to the Netherlands on Wednesday.
He added however that public debate “will continue, for sure”.
CFDT union leader Laurent Berger has said that if the bill is only partially approved, it should be re-examined in parliament.
Surveys show that about two in three French people are against the pension changes, with critics arguing they are unfair for women and unskilled workers who started working early in life.
But the government argues that they are essential to stop the system from falling into heavy deficits in coming decades, and bring France in line with the rest of Europe where people typically retire later.
