Latest Stories

Stay neutral on Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo, Vatican told CBCP, says WikiLeaks

By ,

The Vatican “pressured” Filipino bishops to remain neutral and stay away from calls for the ouster of then President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo during the “Hello Garci” scandal in 2005, according to confidential US Embassy cables quoting a “Church contact.”

The papal nuncio at the time, Archbishop Antonio Franco,  made it clear to the bishops during their annual meeting that the Vatican “did not support popular uprisings as a method to remove a government,” according to the US cables recently released by the whistle-blowing website WikiLeaks.

The Vatican appeal was also reported by the Inquirer in its story in 2005 about the meeting of the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of the Philippines (CBCP), which discussed the political crisis confronting Arroyo.

In their pastoral letter after the meeting, the bishops said they were not politicians and that “with Pope Benedict XVI we do not believe in the ‘intrusion’ into politics on the part of the hierarchy.” They made no call for Arroyo to step down.

Interviewed by the Inquirer on Monday, Archbishop Emeritus Oscar Cruz, who attended that meeting, said there was no way the pastoral letter could have been inspired by the Vatican.

“I know this because I am an insider,” Cruz said.

Cruz said the CBCP statement was a plenary decision made after two-thirds of the CBCP members voted not to support calls for Arroyo to step down. Cruz said he was one of the one-third who voted against the majority.

A US Embassy cable (http://www.wikileaks.org/cable/2005/07/05MANILA3202.html) dated July 12, 2005, said that the Church “contact,” Bishop Romulo de la Cruz of Antique, told an embassy political officer that the papal nuncio had advised the bishops to stay clear of political entanglements in line with Vatican policy.

Franco was papal nuncio from 1999 to 2006 and attended Arroyo’s swearing-in as the new President after the ouster of Joseph Estrada following the January 2001 “Edsa People Power II” uprising.

Political activism

According to the cable, Franco urged the CBCP “to be cautious, keeping in mind that it should refrain from political activism.”

Another US Embassy cable said that Msgr. Luis Montemayor, country director for the Philippines under the Vatican Secretariat of State, had confirmed that the Vatican, through Franco, “pressured the (CBCP) to remain neutral in the controversy surrounding Arroyo.”

“(Montemayor) told us that although the Vatican’s preferences on the matter had never been a secret, Franco had for the first time … explained in no uncertain terms to the CBCP that the Vatican did not support popular uprisings as a method to remove a government,” the cable added.

Montemayor, now an archbishop, is currently papal nuncio to the West African states of Senegal, Cape Verde and Guinea-Bissau, while Franco is the current papal nuncio to Israel. De la Cruz is currently the bishop of Kidapawan.

‘Major obstacle’

Montemayor emphasized that he had always opposed the clergy’s involvement in popular uprisings against the government, according to the cable.

“In 2001, with the protests against Estrada, I pressured the bishops to stay neutral. They wouldn’t listen to me,” the cable quoted Montemayor as saying.

Montemayor was further quoted as saying that the late Manila Archbishop Jaime Cardinal Sin, who died in June 2005, had been “a major obstacle” in the Vatican’s policy against political intervention by the clergy.

“We didn’t see eye to eye on the issue,” Montemayor said. “Sin felt it was his moral responsibility toward the people to intervene but we must support democracy and due process. Otherwise we are opening Pandora’s box.”

Montemayor suggested that with Sin’s death, “the current bishops are more amenable to instruction from the Vatican,” according to the cable.

Support from majority

In his account of the CBCP meeting, De la Cruz said the bishops issued the pastoral statement against intruding into politics “in part because of the papal nuncio’s comments” at the meeting, according to the US Embassy cable.

De la Cruz said the vast majority of the bishops supported Franco’s remarks, though several left-leaning bishops—who were urging that the group take an anti-Arroyo stance—believed the papal nuncio had “interfered” in the deliberations, according to the cable.

In a “comment,” the US Embassy cable said: “With the end of the Cardinal Sin era, the Church seems to be moving towards more of a focus on pastoral matters. Sin was very much an activist in the political sphere….

“Although Sin was close to John Paul II, especially on doctrinal matters, the Vatican was not fully comfortable with his political activities, according to contacts. The Church at this point seems to be in a phase of ‘Sin-fatigue’ and …  seems very much open to advice from the Vatican on the need to keep out of politics in a direct way.”

‘Be judicious’

In another comment, a cable said:  “The Holy See is hesitant to get out in front of its bishops in opposing local political leaders, but the Vatican is also loath to see clergy take active political roles.

“In fact, the principle of avoiding direct political involvement is enshrined in canon law, even if not always followed. Unlike in matters of ‘faith and morals,’ the Holy See’s control over local bishops on political matters is uneven.”

Archbishop Cruz, who currently chairs the CBCP National Tribunal of Appeals, told the Inquirer that the Vatican was never cited by the bishops in making their collective decision during their 2005 conference.

The CBCP plenary is the highest decision-making body of the Philippine Church hierarchy.

“I don’t think the Vatican will involve itself in such a sociopolitical issue, which is local in significance and implication,” Cruz said. “The Church is universal and global and would not get involved in such an issue.”

The prelate said he also worked closely with the late Sin “so I would know if there was pressure coming from the Vatican.”

While WikiLeaks exposes some cases, “which are realities,” Cruz said, “the public must not take it hook, line and sinker … we should also be judicious.”

Follow Us

Follow us on Facebook Follow on Twitter Follow on Twitter

Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Tags: Archbishop Emeritus Oscar Cruz , Bishop Romulo de la Cruz of Antique , Catholic Bishops’ Conference of the Philippines , CBCP , Filipino bishops , Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo , Hello Garci , Vatican , WikiLeaks

  • Anonymous

    that report could be correct, since vatican don’t want the flow of “dollars” to stop coming into vatican state from anywhere else in teh planet, ha, ha, ha! they didn’t even bother during the dictator marcos time where imelda marcos was one of their top benefactors, at that time, ah, ha, ha!

  • http://twitter.com/hustlergalore hustlergalore

    wow. ang lakas ni mareng gloring sa vatican. o tignan mo ngayon, kinakarma na.

  • http://twitter.com/hustlergalore hustlergalore

    akalain mo. neutral pa pala sila sa lagay na yun.

  • Anonymous

    In their pastoral letter after the meeting, the bishops said they were not politicians and that “with Pope Benedict XVI we do not believe in the ‘intrusion’ into politics on the part of the hierarchy.” So why are they meddling into politics now???? With Gloria, they are not allowed, now with Pnoy, they can dip their fingers whenever they like? Enough of church hypocrisy….

  • Anonymous

    Despite Archbishop Cruz’s denial that the CBCP did not bow to pressure from the Vatican thus its neither here nor there stance on Gloria during the Garci scandal, this leak is believable. But in fairness to Vatican,  the pressure it exerted was not the only consideration that came into play during the CBCP voting  which resulted into the group refusing to call for the resignation of the cheat. There were at least seven bishops who voted against calling for resignation because of very close ties with Gloria. These seven would later be rewarded with vehicles for their support during that crucial time. You think Gloria would give an unsupportive bishop a vehicle? Impossible.

    By the way, I strongly believe  that if Pnoy will get involved in a  scandal of the magnitude of the Garci tapes, the CBCP will call for his resignation immediately even if this is in defiance of the Vatican policy of non-interventino in these situations. Reason: RH Bill.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2BLVKWQR77VJKMEZWS4GIMLGOY Edzel

    They stayed neutral because of the separation of powers between the church and the state.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3RMNEZCQQHXWOQRXJROQ2CORFU Homer Guo

      well the vatican is neutral but i doubt pinas clergymen if neutral sila.

  • Anonymous

    sad to say it sounds like wikileaks has more credibility than the philippine clergy. I wonder why?!?

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_OJPAD5MIDJX6W7NXPNJA4WJYSM JuanMalaya

    Father father, give me a liar..

  • Anonymous

    Even the Vatican is afraid of Gloria Makapal-Arroyo !

    CBCP is afraid of Gloria Makapal-Arroyo !

    Because Gloria Makapal-Arroyo is the SOURCE OF THEIR SUVs!!!!!


  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Steven-Zahl/1670371040 Steven Zahl

    Pera-Pera lang yan

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3RMNEZCQQHXWOQRXJROQ2CORFU Homer Guo

    ang pari me vow of POVERTY CHASTITY and OBEDIENCE,. lahat yan hindi nila ginagawa. masaya maging pari. me pera na galing sa abuloy ng tao nakaka enjoy pa sila ng luho

Copyright © 2014, .
To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.
Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:
c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94
  1. Kim Henares needs a reprimand, says Cayetano
  2. ‘No real progress in PH if dynasties not dismantled’
  3. More legal woes for Cedric Lee
  4. Massive infra spending set
  5. OFW brings MERS virus to Philippines
  6. DOJ to NBI: Arrest Cedric Lee, 4 others
  7. Cardinal Tagle to faithful: Join politics to clean it
  8. Estrada, Gigi Reyes denied access to evidence from other respondents
  9. Lacson’s wife loses diamond earring to thieves but recovers jewelry quickly with police arrest
  10. DOJ orders arrest of Cedric Lee
  1. Suspect in Vhong Navarro mauling tries to leave PH
  2. MH370 co-pilot made mid-flight phone call – report
  3. Netizens cry: 6/55 Lotto was rigged
  4. I’ll follow my conscience on Estrada, says JV Ejercito
  5. ‘Wife of Jesus’ theory papyrus not fake – Harvard study
  6. Fr. Suarez says last Mass on Easter before returning donated land to San Miguel
  7. Gay college instructor arrested for oral sex with student
  8. ‘King’ Yabut and I: Driver bares Makati dad ‘abuses’
  9. It was difficult having Japanese blood
  10. Palace: We can’t blame increase in population on Vitangcol
  1. KL confirms Malaysian Airlines Flight MH370 ended in Indian Ocean
  2. MRT passengers pass the hat for 6-year-old Ashley
  3. Pork payoffs to newscasters Erwin Tulfo, Del Prado, others bared
  4. UP back on top as ‘average’ student aces bar
  5. Rookie, lady cops lauded for quick response to MOA heist
  6. Model Helena Belmonte wished ‘to slash her wrist and hope to die’
  7. Malaysia averts another air tragedy; pilot lands troubled plane safely
  8. Revilla says he was joking; Lacson stands by his story
  9. Revilla ‘consulted’ Lacson on how he evaded arrest
  10. Police rule out foul play in Helena Belmonte’s death as boyfriend is ‘traumatized’


  • Henares on Pacquiao bashing: I did not start this
  • Drilon, Nancy Binay urge Filipinos to strengthen faith
  • ‘Yolanda’ toll now at 6,300 – NDRRMC
  • ‘Mom, I love you,’ says text from student on sinking ferry
  • Moderate earthquake jolts southern Iran
  • Sports

  • Power Pinays smash India in Asian Women’s Club volleyball opener
  • PH youth boxers off to stumbling start in AIBA World tilt
  • Durant has 42, Thunder beat Pistons 112-111
  • Walker leads Bobcats over Bulls in OT, 91-86
  • Man City slips further out of title contention
  • Lifestyle

  • Pro visual artists, lensmen to judge Pagcor’s photo contest
  • ‘Labahita a la bacalao’
  • This is not just a farm
  • Clams and garlic, softshell crab risotto–not your usual seafood fare for Holy Week
  • Moist, extra-tender blueberry muffins
  • Entertainment

  • Will Arnett files for divorce from Amy Poehler
  • American rapper cuts own penis, jumps off building
  • Jay Z to bring Made in America music fest to LA
  • Why Lucky has not bought an engagement ring for Angel
  • Derek more private with new girlfriend
  • Business

  • Asia stocks fail to match Wall Street gains
  • Fired Yahoo exec gets $58M for 15 months of work
  • PH presses bid to keep rice import controls
  • PSEi continues to gain
  • Number of retrenched workers rose by 42% in ’13
  • Technology

  • Filipinos #PrayForSouthKorea
  • Taylor Swift tries video blogging, crashes into fan’s bridal shower
  • DOF: Tagaytay, QC best at handling funds
  • Smart phone apps and sites perfect for the Holy Week
  • Tech company: Change passwords or suffer ‘Heartbleed’
  • Opinion

  • Editorial cartoon, April 17, 2014
  • A humbler Church
  • Deepest darkness
  • ‘Agnihotra’ for Earth’s health
  • It’s the Holy Week, time to think of others
  • Global Nation

  • Syria most dangerous country for journalists, PH 3rd—watchdog
  • Japan says visa-free entry still a plan
  • First Fil-Am elected to Sierra Madre, Calif. city council
  • UC Irvine cultural night to dramatize clash of values in immigrant family
  • Filipino sweets and info served at UC Berkeley Spring Fest
  • Marketplace