Rape victim having hard time getting case records at DSWD, says lawyer



MANILA, Philippines — A rape victim, who alleged she was sexually abused five years ago by two relatives of a Caloocan City politician, claimed on Thursday that the local court and the Department of Social Welfare Development (DSWD) have been either wittingly or unwittingly preventing the revival of the accusation by denying her access to records of her own case.

The 21-year-old victim “Mila” insisted that no politician had asked her to surface but was stirred into seeking the possible revival of the case after seeing one of her alleged molesters campaigning for public office.

At a press conference on Thursday at the Quezon Memorial Circle, Mila simply told reporters, “I saw him campaigning in front of our house in Bagong Barrio.”

Lawyer Trixie Angeles said that she took on Mila’s case two or three weeks ago and had started looking into it by seeking records from the Caloocan City regional trial court branch 131, which dismissed the rape charge three years ago, and the DSWD National Capital Region (NCR) which handled the litigation for the then 16-year-old victim.

She told reporters that the DSWD-NCR had invoked the confidentiality of the case although she had informed them that Mila was asking for the records. The confidentiality, the lawyer said, extended to the case number.

Angeles also claimed that she fared no better in the Caloocan City regional trial court, which had advised her to file the necessary motions, for entry of appearance and the release of records, although she already presented authorization documents given to her by the rape victim and private complainant.

“That means the court has to resolve after a hearing whether to release the records to the case or not,” the lawyer told the Inquirer after the press conference. She added that while it would be fair for the court to deny indiscriminately all the parties to the suit access to the records of the case, the policy was ridiculous.

According to Angeles, Mila, who only reached grade 2, does not even know why the case was dismissed and at what stage of the proceedings because she was in the custody of the DSWD-NCR for the duration of the trial.

An April 19 response signed by DSWD-NCR director Alicia Bonoan to a letter by the victim, who was admitted to the agency from April, 2008 to November, 2011, seeking records of the case stated that while the receipt of the request was acknowledged, “The purpose on the request of the said documents was not indicated in your letter.”

Bonoan further wrote: “We regret to inform you that as per policy, we cannot provide you the case folder as we observe strict confidentiality on the files of our residents. However, we can assist you on whatever plan/actions you are going to make.”

She then said that Mila’s counsel could coordinate with the social worker to discuss the matter.

Angeles told reporters that they would like to send the DSWD a “letter of concern” over its policy of not releasing records to the actual victim “even if the victim has reached maturity.” The letter she plans to write to the agency would question the policy on confidentiality of records.

“This is not exactly the ideal case. The victim is barely educated and she was out late at night. But she is a rape victim,” she said.

(With additional reports from Bernadette Nicolas, Inquirer intern)

Get Inquirer updates while on the go, add us on these apps:

Inquirer Viber

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of INQUIRER.net. We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.

  • Horst Manure

    When you have a 4th rate judiciary in 3rd world country that is no better than Indonesia there is a long way to go before the legal system can be seen to be open and functional and lift the standing amongst the rest of the world.

  • vaporub123

    rapist nangangampanya para ngayon elksyon?mas lalo delikado kung ganon kung mananalo ang rapist na ito.dapat sinabi ang pangalan ng rapist ng hindi ito maiboto ng mga taong bayan ng Caloocan city.

    • Benigno the Turd

      If you like Karaoke….you sing-Along.

  • http://www.ofwsinhongkong.wordpress.com/ pinoysahongkong2012

    Calling Dinky Soliman and Leila de Lima!!!!!!!!!!

    What say both of you to the apparent moro moro or incompetence or excessively bureaucratic mindset of some of your underlings?

    You have both established credentials and track record for being progressive-minded.

    Simple retrieval of the case record of Mila and having it provided to her lawyer is the least that both of you can do to a purported rape victim.

    And both of you should impose administrative sanctions on your underlings if your office can establish negligence or dereliction of duty.

    • superpilipinas

      I would extremely be disappointed with both if they do not respond to this news. But what can we do if Inquirer does not publish anything from them?

  • panhase

    Confidentiality towards the victim? How much better can it get?
    Can one blame people if some try to take justice into their own hands and not rely on the system?

  • superpilipinas

    I am hoping to read of a decent high profile lawyer or law office to gang up with Atty. Angeles and fight for this girl pro-bono and a rich donor to support her fight and pressure the government to help.

  • superpilipinas

    who is this politician?

  • dexter ngayan

    how ironic to see a rape victim stand up and reported what happen to her again during the election. Wala daw politician na tumutulong? Well ngayon meron na! yung kalaban nyang inakusahan mo ng rape.. kasi nga election time.

  • bayankopdi

    Dapat makasuhan ang rapist na eto or else kung naging opisyal na yan mang rape uli kasi nakalusot na kahit civilian pa lang, paano na kung manalo pa siya? Sigurado lalong maging abusadong opisyal yan.

  • divictes

    And I thought India was the worst country for women to be in… Utak pana rin pala ang korte at DSWD sa Caloocan.

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:

c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City,Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94


editors' picks



latest videos