Quantcast
Latest Stories

Cardinal asks ‘blasphemous’ artist: Can you do that to your own father?

By

MANILA, Philippines—Manila Archbishop Gaudencio Cardinal Rosales condemned on Monday the art exhibit at the Cultural Center of the Philippines (CCP) depicting a crucifix with a wooden penis and a picture of Jesus Christ with the ears of a rabbit.

Speaking on Church-run Radio Veritas, Rosales said the exhibit of Mideo Cruz “abused” freedom of expression and urged the faithful to “rise up” in protest against it.

“It’s an abuse of freedom because the use of freedom must respect responsibilities. There’s a responsibility not to destroy culture, civilization or the good conduct of persons,” Rosales said.

“Those who are like that, I don’t know what he learned from his parents, from his school, from his friends. It’s a complete betrayal of what is right and the knowledge of what is wrong,” Rosales said.

The cardinal said the exhibit, which the CCP has defended, was a “big insult, disrespect” to “right-thinking persons.”

“Let me just ask, can he (Cruz) do that to his own father (or) to (national hero Jose) Rizal? …you will never do that to somebody you respect (like) your parents or to a hero like Jose Rizal. Why did you do that to the Son of God?” Rosales said.

The Manila archbishop urged the laity to rise up and correct the perceived blasphemous exhibit at the CCP.

“The lay persons should rise up, especially the parents, teachers and institutions. I hope you don’t allow this to be done to your children. I leave it to you to act,” Rosales said.

“This is highly offensive and not the act of a good man. It’s a shame that a Filipino did this. There are good works of artists but this is offensive and is disrespectful to God. There’s punishment for that. That is not artistic freedom,” Rosales added.

Manila Auxiliary Bishop Broderick Pabillo said it was wrong for a person to “play” with objects considered holy by a religion.

“Art should enhance life…Freedom of expression has a limit because that freedom involves our duty to respect the stand, the opinion and the culture of others,” Pabillo said.

“Who will be happy if an artist plays and desecrates the culture and holiness of faith of a religion? I don’t know but if they do that to Muslims, will our Muslim brothers be happy? Freedom of expression has a corresponding responsibility. It should not be abused,” Pabillo added.

Pro-life Philippines president Eric Manalang said that they would file criminal charges against Cruz and the leadership of the CCP.

“It’s going to be a criminal case at the Ombudsman because members of the CCP board are government officials so they are liable for public trust. We will file a case (against) both of them,” said Manalang.

He said that if the CCP exhibit was not stopped, others might follow and also degrade other religions, not just Christianity.

Tagbilaran bishop Leonardo Medroso said CCP officials and Cruz should be charged if they did not relent.

“What we’ll do is have a dialogue with the CCP. Talk with CCP. Again, if nothing is being done, then we go to a higher office or a higher court. We will charge them,” said Medroso.


Follow Us

Follow us on Facebook Follow on Twitter Follow on Twitter


Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Tags: Arts , Catholic Church , Controversy , Cultural Center of the Philippines , Culture , Freedom of expression , Gaudencio Cardinal Rosales , Jesus Christ , Mideo Cruz , Politics , religion and faith , visual arts

  • Anonymous

    sorry nes…what you’re asking from me is impossible..i’m not an artist, so there you go…i am not defending cruz, per se…let me say it again, for your benefit..I ABHOR CRUZ ON WHAT HE DID TO CHRISTIANITY, BUT I ALSO RESPECT HIS PERSPECTIVE…since his art is against the catholic faith (which is my faith too), many catholics were insulted including the”papogi” senators..but you neglected to reply on what i quoted cardinal rosales’…. so, the magnificent bishops that got SUVs, AND THOSE THAT ACCEPTED CASH FROM PAGCOR,  ARE THEY EXCLUDED FROM YOUR COMMENTS?? 

    • Anonymous

      Those are solved issues. Why do you bring them out? I agree with you I may respect Mideo Cruz if he expressed himself in virtue of decency and respect but what he did is crossing the line and you on the other hand is using the past issues to implicate others. You are giving in to your biases. Please be aware of that. You may have a point but this is not the rightful place for that because it does not hit the issue at hand. There might be a separate page for that. 

      Wont you agree with me?

  • Anonymous

    HERE’S THE QUOTE FROM CARDINAL ROSALES “Those who are like that, I don’t know what he learned from his parents, from his school, from his friends. It’s a complete betrayal of what is right and the knowledge of what is wrong,” Rosales said. 
    your analogy is a little off, but let’s leave it at that…so the bishops are not included on cardinal rosales’ condemnation of Cruz? SO THE COMPLETE BETRAYAL OF WHAT IS RIGHT AND WRONGS FALLS ONLY WITH CRUZ?  NAMIMILI LANG?… READ AGAIN…I ABHOR WHATCRUZ DID TO CHRISTIANITY, BUT I ALSO RERSPECT HIS PERSPECTIVE…THAT’S WHY WE ARE GOING NOWHERE BECAUSE WE ARE SO FANATICAL WHEN IT COMES TO SOMETHING, IN THIS CASE, OUR FAITH…NOT ONLY ARE YOU NARROW MINDED,BUT SHORT MINDED TOO.,,BASAHIN MO KUNG ANO ANG LAMAN NG MGA BALITA, SA PRINT O TV,..PINATAY ANG KAIBIGAN DAHIL NAPIKON…SEE???..YOU HAVE TO FACE REALITY…GETS MO, BISHOP FBPKSA??????????? 

    • Anonymous

      You are stupid.  Respecting God is NOT fanatical.

      • Guest

        well, i may be stupid, but you are a moron….you probably didn’t go to school, so you know nothing about science….and i never said fanatic…you’re putting words in my mouth… 

      • Anonymous

        okay…don’t be selective..i also want you to tell me what you think of cardinal rosales’ comments: here, READ IT!!!  “It’s a complete betrayal of what is right and the knowledge of what is wrong,” Rosales said.  SO, HIS BISHOPS WHO WERE IMPLICATED ABOUT A MONTH AGO ON SOME “MONKEY BUSINESS” ARE EXEMPTED?  THEY DID NOT BETRAY ON WHAT WERE RIGHT AND NO KNOWLEDGE OF WHAT WERE WRONG??????….THE GALLLLLLLLL……..

      • Anonymous

        I am sorry but it seems that your comment does not belong here. You are out of the topic.

  • http://twitter.com/ReyrexA reyrex arcilla

    Si Director Millado ng CCP dapat mag resing ka dyan sa positon mo,tama si sneator Enrile mag resign kayo,hindi nyo nakita na ang tono ng exibit ay blasphemous.OUTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT MILLADO

  • http://twitter.com/ReyrexA reyrex arcilla

    Ano klase utak meron ka MIllado para sabihin mo na hindi para gawin katatawanan ang exibit ni medio cruz?

  • Chua Bee

    Some posts here are coming from too narrrow of a mind. The issue here is the desecration of Christs and not the so called SUVs corruption etc (which by the way, the cars will depreciate in value over time, in 20 years the worth nothing–so gets ninyo?) That means the damage is not long term. But desecrating Christ does not only create short but also long term consequences. Young people will not think that it is okay to do that in the name of Art? What a jerk.

  • Anonymous

         I think there is such thing as move for non-violence. We must avoid hate comments toward this artist. We can criticize him but not to the point of having comments of hate and violence. At the end we who depend our faith, promotes decency, respect and all would have to eat our words because we have become bigots who in turn do not respect other beliefs and principle. 
         However, I say to  the artists who would in one way or the other follow Mideo Cruz’ example that freedom of any form with respect to its gravity demands as well the same gravity of responsibility. They are very much interrelated. That is balance. If you shout louder for freedom you must be prepared for its forthcoming responsibility. 
         Now, when you demanded that what the artist did was right did you really gave second thought to what you were saying? How come we ended up having these arguments here and as you noticed people who turned to hate comments? 

         The freedom of expression that you might be longing has gone astray. 

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_5CUXT5SSBD2YTJLTGHHCHOMQMY Alfonso V

    hindi porke maraming gnwang mali anga bishops expempted na ang mga ibang tao sa pggwa ngmga offensive na bagay na 2lad n2. ano 2 prang bata na dahil my gnwa ang iba na pgkakamali pwd ka na rng gumwa nun? grow up nmn puro kc hanapan ng pgkkmali ang tintngnan nyo.simple lng nmn ang issue d2 ung gnwa ng artist hnd kung anu2x sinusumbat nyo pra maexempt kau sa pgkakamali ng gnwa ng iba.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_RJCHUTIWOUCA6624R75ORYVWLU Just Me

    geez… i dont understand what the fuzz is all about… do they really know the history of the face they call Jesus… can the catholic church guarantee that it is how Christ looked while he was walking the earth… pardon me if im wrong but if i recall the current image of Christ was based the painting made by leonardo da vinci who used live models during his time as basis for how Jesus and his apostoles would look like… so basically the face they call jesus was simply da vinci’s interprepation of the face of a male model who lived during his time and not the face of the true Christ who lived long before that… now who’s commiting blasphemy by  labeling a man’s face as Christ… just my two cents on the matter



Copyright © 2013, .
To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.
Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:
c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94
Advertisement

News

  • Ex-Antipolo barangay leader killed
  • Baby girl born on LRT train
  • Maynilad to MPD: What P2.5M?
  • Did you know: NCR index crimes
  • HEARD ON RADYO INQUIRER 990AM
  • Sports

  • Sadorra sustains Asian chess romp
  • SMB battles Sports Rev
  • UE’s Mammie working extra to overcome freethrow shooting weakness
  • Happi’s double-double powers EAC to its first FilOil win
  • UE comes back to beat Lyceum, but coach wary of slow starts
  • Lifestyle

  • The biggest, brightest at Resorts World Manila’s Musikat Jam
  • On goose, gold, eggs, and the stock market
  • Should we parents keep secrets from our kids?
  • Creative sisters concoct a Pinoy-themed treat for Mother’s Day
  • Has the helmet law been forgotten so soon?
  • Entertainment

  • Ryan Gosling’s violent new crime movie booed at Cannes
  • Soaked, sleepless on Croisette
  • Easier for viewers to relate to
  • Luke Evans: There’s more talent in PH
  • Girl power deftly plays ‘Game of Thrones’
  • Business

  • Hotels’ bid for tax perks rejected
  • US company eyes coco products from PH
  • Q1 GDP growth seen at 6%
  • PH, Brazil forge air agreement to mount flights
  • Petron builds depots in 3 provinces
  • Technology

  • Risky behavior starts young on web—survey
  • Office bullying video sparks outcry in Singapore
  • Poll: Teens migrating to Twitter
  • Microsoft readies new Xbox as entertainment hub
  • Yahoo! vows not to ruin Tumblr after $1.1B takeover
  • Opinion

  • Editorial cartoon, May 23, 2013
  • False god
  • When neighbors fight
  • Becoming the world’s most bullied
  • Have a heart
  • Global Nation

  • PH thanks Taiwan for call to citizens not to harm Filipino workers
  • Taiwan OKs visit by NBI team
  • OFW claims to be Indonesian, skips night-outs to avoid attacks in Taiwan
  • PNP assures safety of Taiwanese visitors in PH
  • PH continues to monitor Chinese ships in Ayungin Shoal
  • Marketplace
    Advertisement
    Azure Skin Ad
    Azure Skin Ad
    © Copyright 1997-2013 INQUIRER.net | All Rights Reserved