Past Forward

Will Cardinal Tagle make Pope?


It is a bit of a sad reality that when the conclave to elect the next Pope opens at the Vatican sometime between March 10 and March 20, only one elector will come from the Philippines. That voter is himself a papabile, the term used in Rome for a potential candidate as the next pope. Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle, the 55-year-old Archbishop of Manila will be the lone voice representing 80 million Filipino Roman Catholics when the elections for the next pope will ensue.

Is Cardinal Tagle really in the running to be the next pope? I am here in Manila on a book project (which keeps me mostly inside the air conditioned confines of the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas Money Museum) and therefore I cannot feel the pulse of the people, as it were, unlike what I felt in Rome among Filipino expatriates and pilgrims when Pope Benedict XVI announced that Bishop Tagle was to receive the Cardinal’s hat shortly. Back then, everyone was agog over the fact that he was inching ever closer to the papacy with the pope himself seemingly showing the right signal that he was a worthy contender by giving him the cardinalate after barely a year on the throne of the Manila archdiocese.

Yesterday, I read a spoiler in the person of a former employee of Malacañang who questioned the Cardinal’s management skills. I wonder whether that nasty opinion had any objective basis, given the very brief period that Tagle has been archbishop of the largest archdiocese in the country. Be that as it may, it will not be his management skills that will come into question when the voting comes. Vatican has a bureaucracy that has been tested for nearly two millennia now. Any pope can come in and perhaps even turn insane inside but the whole bureaucracy there will continue to grind nonetheless. In other words, management skill is not the most important factor that will come into play when the conclave unveils in March.

For Cardinal Tagle, what will work in his favor is the perception of an imprimatur, an endorsement, from Pope Benedict XVI himself in the body language that is often talked about whenever the two meet in gatherings at the Vatican. The pope has been known to spend more time conversing with Tagle than with any other cardinal during these meetings. It was this same pope, in fact, when he was still Josef Cardinal Ratzinger, who introduced the young Fr. Tagle to Pope John Paul II at the Vatican’s International Theological Commission, where Tagle was to sit. Cardinal Ratzinger was allegedly heard to have jokingly said to the pope, “Don’t worry, he has already received his first communion.”

That joke, made over a decade ago, also serves as an important footnote to the cardinal electors who will most probably see the boyish-looking Cardinal Tagle as too young to be pope who, if elected, will be at the Vatican for three decades, much like Pope John Paul II did—far too long for other cardinals to feel comfortable. The election of 78-year-old Josef Cardinal Ratzinger after Pope John Paul II’s death in 2005 was in fact interpreted as a forceful point made of ushering in a leader that would not last too long and leave too much of an impact. Indeed, Pope Benedict XVI, in this sudden and unexpected resignation to take effect on February 28, has not failed those who saw to it that his papacy would be brief.

Given a strong anti-Eurocentric undertone reverberating all over the Roman Catholic world—something that one really feels also as one gets nearer and nearer to the Vatican—it will not be so much of a surprise if the next pope will come from outside Europe. Already some are saying that the next pope will most likely come from the Latin American countries (with about 11 cardinal electors) which now count about 1.2 billion Catholics or from Africa where the Catholic mission is ever-expanding.

As a Filipino, however, I do hope that the age factor will be overcome by the cardinal-electors who will then see in Cardinal Tagle the person who will bring Roman Catholicism out of its Eurocentricism and who will appreciate the vibrant expressions of faith that one can only see most especially here in the Philippines.

Let us hope then that come election time in March, the Holy Spirit will see to this.

Get Inquirer updates while on the go, add us on these apps:

Inquirer Viber

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.

  • isellnuts

    Just leave it to the conclave, thats their job.

  • gilbs72

    Going through various Catholic forums, there is indeed a push for non-European papacy.  However, I estimate that preference for an Asian and Latin-American Pope seems to take second place in favor of an African Pope.  This is what I read from the laity – the conclave is a different story.

  • Albin

    Maybe it is time to have another Asian as Pope. Italians have long dominated the papacy until Karol Wojtyla and Joseph Ratzinger. Afterall, Jesus and St. Peter are Asians. The guiding light in Asia is the Philippines.

    • Tamarindwalk

       The Philippines is the guiding light alright!  The guiding light to the pits!  What a mess the Philippines is!!!

      • christian tacocong


  • Lord_patawad

    dapat bang tingnan ang lahi para maging papa? di ba dapat yung kakayanan niya upang mai angat ang pananampalataya ng mga katoliko sa buong mundo  at yung dinadala niyang prinsipyo ang dapat na tingnan? regardless kung itim, puti, dilaw o, kayumanggi. kung pantay pantay sila sa ganitong katangian, ang susunod na batayan ay ang accomplishments. hindi dapat pinag-uusapan ang kulay. 

  • pioanonuevo

    Cardinal Tagle, the only one from the Philippines, has a good chance of getting the title. You know crab mentality of the Filipinos may just influence the thinking of the cardinals from other countries who are in big numbers and decide to vote for him so jealousy in their ranks could be avoided. Not far-fetched.

  • GreenStallion

    As the official church often says to the media, it doesn’t matter what colors, personality will the Pope be elected but what’s important is the next Pope has the exemplary qualities to govern the Billion Catholics around the globe. Let’s not sensationalize & overly confident that Cardinal Tagle should be our next Pope but instead let’s wait & see how the Holy Spirit will run its course. Or we will just be dismayed & frustrated if things will not result the way expect it.     

  • doublecross

    pray for him…..

  • Dieserweg

    For discussion’s sake either or may make sense both sides of the spectrum.  But, in the most subtle way, it’s the Spirit that determines who will finally become the next pope.  And it has always come as a surprise.  John XXIII believed to be a transition pope, convened Vatican II.  Paul VI wrote Humanae Vitae.  John Paul I ruled for barely a month.  Pope John Paul II was the first non-Italian pope in over two hundreds years, and now Blessed.  Cardinal Ratzinger proved to be a great theologian and a great inspiration. 

  • Estrella Segarra Navera

    Why do we as faithful Catholics discuss endlessly things we cannot do about?  Instead why don’t we pray hard for the wisdom of our Cardinals under the guidance of the Holy Spirit.  He will choose whom He chooses.  Let us have faith in God especially because this year had been declared “year of  the faith”. Be happy there is no vote buying nor the use of guns, goons and gold in the elections conducted inside the Vatican.  For that alone we should be joyful and thankful.  Best wishes to you.  

  • PasswordFlame

    for me YES maging POPE sya.

  • sidamarille

    We are very proud being a Filipino that we have a cardinal being nominated for papacy. What the Roman Catholic hierarchy is looking is a communicator not an administrator We will pray for the success of our very own Luis Antonio Cardinal Tagle.

  • Drawoh Yacab

    If Cardinal Tagle became a pope… He will defeat the longest term pope, the founder of the church… Saint Peter, who is also the first pope. So the cardinals will prevent electing Cardinal Tagle, because he will break the traditional norm.

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:

c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City,Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94


editors' picks



latest videos