Arroyo cleared of negligence rap over Maguindanao massacre


Former President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo. AP FILE PHOTO

MANILA, Philippines—The Manila Prosecutors Office has ruled that former President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo is not criminally liable for the Maguindanao massacre that left 58 people dead, according to a statement from Arroyo’s office.

Prosecutors dismissed a criminal negligence case filed against Arroyo by Marconi Abdulaziz Paiso, a candidate for vice governor of the Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (ARMM), the statement issued on Sunday showed.

Paiso had alleged that Arroyo was liable for the massacre for having failed in her duties as president and commander in chief of the Armed Forces of the Philippines.  Paiso contended that her “inaction, ignorance and perhaps tolerance” contributed to the “tense political situation” in Maguindanao that led to the killings.

On Nov. 23, 2009, around 100 armed men reportedly led by Andal Ampatuan Jr. waylaid a convoy comprised of supporters of the clan’s political rival, Esmael Mangudadatu, and killed everyone in the group—including 32 media representatives.

The Ampatuans were known political allies of Arroyo.

But Manila prosecutors found no reason to hold the former president liable for negligence in the massacre, saying the allegations against her consisted of general statements not backed by proof.

The statement from Arroyo’s office, coursed through her spokesperson Elena Bautista Horn, quoted the resolution issued by Assistant City Prosecutor Wilbur Arimboyutan and approved by Senior Assistant City Prosecutor Raymunda Cruz Apolo.

Get Inquirer updates while on the go, add us on these apps:

Inquirer Viber

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.

  • Riz Manas

    What about the firearms that were used to massacre the innocent people as an evidence for negligence of duties on the part of a head of state? As a head of state, it is your responsibility to maintain peace and order; including but not to limited to elimination of private armies, proliferation of firearms and so on. In this case, there was a total failure and breakdown of peace and order, which make the head of state liable.

    • TagaKalos

      Ah ganoon, sa tono ng iyong komento ay para kang isang ABOGAGO! Kung hindi ka kontento bakit hindi ka magsampa ng bago mong kaso para malaman mo kung may katuturan yang iyong komento HUNGHANG!

    • Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

        Wouldn’t that give justification to anyone to sue any  president whence anyone had a misfortune come upon them.

      say a relative of mine died on that bus where that ex police hostaged the tourists.  if pnoy was the president then, could I sue him because he wasnt able to keep criminality checked?

      • FRPSR

        Kilabot ng mga Balahibo :Please check the following post found in Wiki answers . I used this as my response for your excellent point , as my own formulation was less compact . do you sue the U.S. government.
        …Generally, a sovereign government cannot be sued unless it allows itself to be sued. In the United States, Congress has passed the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA) allowing the U.S. government to be sued for the tortious negligence of its employees that causes personal injury or property damage… 
        Your point is a very good one and worth responding to despite perhaps a natural urge to seek vengeance .

  • bogli_anakdami

    syempre ah… santa ate glo had nothing to do with the ampatuanization of the muklos in bangsamoron (silent n) republic…

    santa ate glo’s god and allahu akbar eh nagi-inuman dito sa shangri la makati….

    the backhoe was the main culprit… dapat eh ipakilo kay intsik beho para mapakinabangan ang bakal… at ang toyota na inilibing, dapat eh hugasan at ibenta as used car…

    yun lang, di ba?

    hay naku, flips, puro kayo mga tunggaks y gung gongs…. bwi hi hi hi pwi!

  • Touch_Me_, Nuts!

    This decision will send many fawning mobsters frothing again. This country has become so polarized that any decision on Arroyo, Marcos and even Damaso Celdran will bring people on either side heavily engaged as if there’s no tomorrow. Since Edsa 1, people have been so gullible as to believe that the Aquinos are the messiah of the people, and that they carry a magic wand to solve all problems, failing to realize that the Aquinos have also opened the Pandora’s Box for the continued polarization of this nation. Meanwhile the Aquinos continue to benefit from the shuffle. The gullible and fawning mob makes it possible at their expense.

    • beerhunters

      frothing in the mouth, snarling and snapping at anybody nearby! he he he

    • boybakal

       Remember too that these people are the instigators and agitators of this People Power kuno.
      Why rallies are so scarce….well, they are now in the government.

  • geminimind

    That’s fine but next time don’t be giving them some favor calls,cash allocated for maintenance,ghost projects,cash gifts or allowance etc.

  • joerizal

    Hindi bale, balang araw sa impiyerno naman magkikita-kita sila Arroyo, Ampatuan, Enrile, Lacson, Erap, atbp…sasalubungin sila doon ni Marcos na matagal nang nililitson ni Satanas.

    • carol

      sama mong magsalita

      • joerizal

        Watch out! Arroyo apologist at 12 o’clock.

      • billy gunner

         it’s 11. know your direction! lol

    • Mark

      Arroyo: Isasama kita sa hukay…..

    • billy gunner

       balita ko si cory raw ang appointed na naglilitson doon. totoo kaya?

  • Rogers Nelson Uy

    diba si Cory ang naglagay sa mga ampatuan? Baka lang kasi me nagbubulagbulagan eh, paalala lang

  • Fulpol

    negligence rap against Arroyo?

    BS Aquino III should be the one to be filed with negligence… by Hongkong people whose relatives were killed in Luneta Hostage Massacre..

  • boybakal

    I still believe in our Justice system…especially our men and women whose study of law was put to good use.
    Nobody can be bullied by this malicious fictitious charges.
    Good job….more power to all of you.

  • Cerise David

    Another accusation down the drain.

  • bongarroyo

    hala tanggalin na iyang neck brace na iyan at igarahe na iyong wheelchair…LOL

  • Bigboy I

    wala nga proof  mahirap yung nababalitaan mo sa media dapat maiuugnay mo si ampatuan ke arroyo.

  • TuwadNaDaan

    hahahaha….congratz GMA ….walang kahit isang kaso na mapapatunayan na nagkasala ka….lahat bokya….!!!

    • I Love This game

      WALA?(!)   Bakit kaya nagbigti si Angelo Reyes Kong wala?

      • carol

        Dahil sa insulto ni Trillanes, na mas mababa sa kanya.

      • kolambogan

        Napaka babaw na dahilan kung yun lang ang dahilan at kung iba ang nasa kalagayan ni Angelo Reyes malamang si Trillanes ang binaril niya at hindi ang kaniyang sarili, total suicidal na rin lang siya, hmmm, sa palagay ko may mas malalim na dahilan, ano sa palagay mo?

      • Mark

        Kasi may mga taong katulad mo na hindi ma bura-bura sa mundo!

      • Febien

        Sigurado ka ba na nagbigti o nagpakamatay si Angelo Reyes? Isang sundalo na sanay sa labanan, dahil lang sa insulto ng ibang senador e magpapakamatay? Karma ang tatama sa mga sinungaling!

  • rodben

    Hindi ako maka Gloria at hindi maka-Noy2 maginhawa kasi buhay kay Diosdado at Macoy, payo lang PO kay expres.GMA wag na kyong mag comment ng di maganda sa kasalukoyang gobyerno maraming galamay na grupo ito kung hindi man maganda para syo palakad sabihin nyo EXCELLENT kawawa naman kyo.

  • scconcern

    Ay! walang mangyayari sa kaso ni Pnadak sa systema ng hidukatura na eletismo. Magkakaayosan sa loob ang mga abugago (ng taong bayan). Dapat gawin democrasiya, taong bayan kasali sa proseso ng paghusga. Ang (grupo) taong bayan ang maghusga, di isang bias/weak abugado. Ang abugado ay magiging consultant ng akusado/nag-akusado, administrador, moderator at taga hatol. Ang paghusga kailagan lahat sang ayon para tunay na “beyond reasonable doubt” na laging binibigkas ng isang bias na huwes/judge.

    • Mark

      hahatulan kita na maging palaka! kachiiinng… KOOOKAAK!

  • imongredneck

    Ampatuan dynasty is a monster created and nursed by the power that be, starting with Cory. To hold GMA liable for their heinous acts was the biggest Injustice; even tyrannical.I’m neither a GMA nor a yellow fanboy.

    • Mamerto

      It was during the term of GMA that these ‘animals’ became the monsters that they are today..! NO IF’s or BUT’s about it.

      • imongredneck

        A .monster of that magnitude cannot develop without being nurtured for a while. Just about every winning national election candidates has benefited from this monsters, again since Cory. That has emboldened them to do anything as they wish, including massacre.No ifs or buts.

      • carol

        panahon ni Marcos, binigyan sila ng mga armas, hindi GMA. 

  • kalikasanipagtanggol

    Yung optimism ko na magbabago ang kalakaran sa pilipinas tuluyan ng naglaho matagal na! kaya hindi ko inaasahan na magkakaroon ng hustisya si juan de la cruz simula pa kay marcos, mendiola, hacienda luisita, maguindanao massacres at lahat ng mga desaparacidos politically motivated man ito o hindi!  Madaling magbago ang pilipino kung ito ay nasa labas ng bansa pero hanggat nasa loob ng bansa ito ay mananatiling alipin ng katiwalian!

  • boybakal

    Arroyo cleared of negligence rap over Maguindanao massacre
    Witness: No proof on use of PCSO funds by Arroyo…Ministerial

    Slowly but surely.
    Konting tiis na lang po Mahal na GMA.
    Bukod pa diyan….tumatakbo ang panahon.

  • Mamerto

    Why did the Court take so long to arrive at this VERY CONTROVERSIAL Decision…?

    Has an arrangement &/or an understanding been made among the parties, including the Judge..?

  • josefe38



    • richard ortega

       Epal sa maguindanao maari wala syang alam pero sa mga pagnanakaw sa kaban ng bayan lahat silang pamilya o pati ikaw ay kasama. magnanakaw kayo tulad ng inaasahan niniyong magliligtas sa kaso na si thief justice.

      • carol

        Siya ay corrupt according sa mga kalaban niya noong siya ay presidente. Ni wala nga maski isang mansion si GMA, kaparis ng Erap, sangkatutak ang mga mansion.

      • josefe38


  • kontra_boohaya

    Talaga namang walang maidadawit na “padrino” ni Amputawan kahit pa mga opisyales na nagsupply ng mga baril at bala e wala. Pero dami na yumaman jan.  That’s just the way it is, pinoy style!

  • ztefertilizerscam10

    P101 billion lost during Fake President  Arroyo rule – COA

    1. NBN ZTE Scandal

    2. Millions of bribe money to Congressmen and Governors

    (October 2007)

    3. Cheating in 2004 Elections (HELLO GARCI)

    4. Joc Joc Bolante Case (Fertilizer Scam, P728 Million)

    5. JOSE PIDAL Bank Account (Unexplained Wealth, P200


    6. NANI PEREZ Power Plant Deal ($2 Million)

    7. Use of Road User’s Tax for Campaigning

    8. Billion Peso Macapagal Boulevard (Overprice of P532


    9. Juetengate? (Illegal Numbers game kickbacks)

    10. Extra Judicial Killings

    11. Arroyo Moneys in Germany (Exposed by Senator Cayetano)

    12. General GARCIA and Other Military Men

    13. Billion Peso Poll Automation contract to(Mega Pacific)

    (P1.3 Billion)

    14. Northrail Project($503 Million)

    15. Maguindanao Results of 2007 Elections (ZUBIRI, BEDOL)

    16. NAIA-3

    17. Venable Contract (Norberto Gonzales)

    18. Swine Scam (Exposed by? Atty. Harry Roque

    19. GLORIA Arroyo son hidden assets in united states



    22. C-5 road controversy — Senator Manuel Villar

    23.P550-million worth of funds from the Overseas Workers’

    Welfare Administration (OWWA).

    24. P780-million LWUA funds-PROSPERO PICHAY

    25. BISHOPS’s SUV-Gloria Birthday gift

    26. Arroyo linked in P325M lotto intelligence fund

    27. Arroyo got P200M in kickbacks from govt projects-Zaldy


    28. P200.41 billion or $4.6 billion in Malampaya royalties

    from 2002 to May this year.



    30. 600,Thousand metric tons of Rotten rice imported from

    India.Kishore Hemlani, an Indian trader allegedly close to

    Arroyo, reportedly bagged the P9.5 billion contract for

    the rice importation.

    31. DATO ARROYO wife bought the condo unit for $570,000,

    70-square-meter one-bedroom, one-bathroom unit (Unit

    No. 533) at the luxury high-rise, full-service Gramercy

    Towers located at 1177 California St. in upscale downtown


    32.- P50-million bribe to FG for the president’s veto of

    two franchise bills

    33. The additional funding led to a 41-percent spike in

    advertising expenses, from P76.129 million in 2008 to

    P107.420 million in 2009, which went mostly to ads for

    Arroyo’s achievements.

    34. The report said the PIA received from the Department

    of Budget and Management a notice of cash allocations

    amounting to P344.789 million, even though only P222.488 
    million was appropriated for it under the national budget.

    35.- Denial of pork barrel funds to Malacanang’s political


    36.- Praises for Jovito Palparan, alleged mastermind of

    extra judicial killings of militants

    37.- Removal of govt bodyguards for former pres and Arroyo

    critic, Cory Aquino

    38.- Appointment of manicurist as a member of the board of


    39. Appointment of gardener as deputy of the Luneta Park



    Chief Justice

    200+ other illegal midnight appointments

    41.- MIKEY ARROYO’s undeclared properties in California

    42.- Pardon of controversial convicted criminals like

    Ninoy’s murderers

    43.- EO 464; requiring Cabinet members to seek

    presidential clearance before testifying in Congress


    44.- Promise (on Rizal Day) to not run for the presidency

    in 2004

    45.- “Vote Buying” by giving away Philhealth cards

    46.- Taxpayers’ money for her giant billboards and and

    PCSO tv campaign ads

    47- Appointment of Ben Abalos, a staunch GMA ally, as

    COMELEC chair

    48.- Mikey Arroyo’s importation of 32 thoroughbred horses

    from Australia worth P384 million.

    49.Former First Gentleman Mike Arroyo used 2 choppers 16

    times, son Mikey 69

    50.PNoy: PAGCOR spent P1 BILLION on coffee

    51.Jose Miguel Arroyo owned helicopters’
    all Robinson R44 Raven Is with Series Nos. 1370 to 1374
    A total of $1,423,025 was paid to Lionair for the five


    52.Pagcor ‘pabaon’ to Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo: P345M

    53.The godmother’s ties to the Pinedas(Jueteng lord)

    54. Glorietta 2 and Batasan bombings

    The Glorietta 2 bombing happened during the height of

    the bribery case which took place in Malacañang.

    55. Misuse of Balikatan funds Navy Lt. Nancy Gadian

    revealed an alleged malversation of funds in 2007

    56. Solon: Charge Gloria Arroyo for taking P98-M from

    PNoy’s social fund


    Former Armed Forces chiefs of staff Narciso Abaya,

    Dionisio Santiago, Generoso Senga, Hermogenes Esperon, and

    Alexander Yano,chiefs of staff – Angelo Reyes, Diomedio

    Villanueva, and Roy Cimatu and MANY MORE..

    58.Colmenares: GMA had P488 billion in ‘pork.

    59. P1 BILLION down the drain in Arroyo-era jatropha

    project—DOST chief 
    60.Fishers push plunder rap vs Arroyo in purchase of ice machines( overpriced at P455 million in 2009.)
    61.$225-million overprice of Metro Rail Transit Corp. (MRTC), 
    62.Successor sues Pichay over P2.3-B fund mess
    63.Noli De Castro P6.6 billion pesos Pag-ibig Fund scam.
    64.Arroyo execs pocket P15-B from bridge scam…..

    • TuwadNaDaan

      case junk for lack of proof….

      • Mark

        Huwag mo nang patulan c zte kasi robot yan at programmed blogger kaya copy-paste ang comment

    • $20722540

      coooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooopy pastttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttteeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

    • ben

      This guy (ZTE) is crazy. Why you have to enumerate lot of staff just to malign someone. One or two or three or four is enough but to mention many things will make a great possibility of mistake. Dont use your emotion…use your brain.

      • Albin

        6 months na ganyan si zte. Hindi siguro na-increase bayad sa kanya, kaya copy-paste lang alam.

  • ztefertilizerscam10


    Jose Miguel Arroyo owned helicopters 

    five helicopters—all Robinson R44 Raven 
    with Series Nos. 1370 to 1374
    A total of $1,423,025 was paid to Lionair 

    GlorIa bribed to Mitsubishop and Safari
     Butuan City Bishop Juan de Dios Pueblos, who received a Mitsubishi Montero, Bontoc-Lagawe Bishop Rodolfo Beltran (Nissan Pathfinder), Abra Bishop Leopoldo Jaucian (Mitsubishi Strada), Cotabato Archbishop Orlando Quevedo (Toyota Grandia Hi-Ace), Basilan Bishop Martin Jumoad (Mitsubishi Strada), Zamboanga Archbishop Romulo Valles (Toyota Grandia Hi-Ace); and Nueva Segovia Archbishop Ernesto Salgado (Isuzu Crosswind).

    • TuwadNaDaan

      case dismissed for lack of evidence…

      • Mark

        tauhan kasi yan ni Boy Abunda si robotic ZTE kaya mahilig sa chismax! aww! hahaha

    • $20722540

      copy copy copy paste paste paste

    • boldyak

      ganito ang style, palagi mong ipaste para sa bandang huli akalain ng karamihan totoo…bwahahaha..yan ang strategy…brainwashing

  • ztefertilizerscam10

    Gloria Macapal-Arroyo spent a whopping P2.85 billion for foreign trips she made during her nine years in office.

    Ex Fake President Gloria Arroyo’s $20,000 worth of dinner @ Le Cirque, New York, USA


    FG in $20, 000 hotel suite!
    During Manny Pacquiao’s match with Erick Morales in Las Vegas, the First Gentleman LOLONG ARROYO allegedly stayed in a $20, 000-a-night suite at the MGM Grand Hotel in Las Vegas, Nevada

    • TuwadNaDaan

      All cases were dismissed…jejeje

    • carol

      aquino spends 50 M pesos every trip, panay ang trip  niya for only 3 years, so baka sobra pa for only 6 years.

      • Augusto de Vera

        tama alng yun mag trip sya ..presendente isa pa maganda pamamalakad nya sa bansa at ekonomiya,,

      • boldyak

        thanks to OFW’s no thanks to Pnoy…bwahahaha

    • Mark

      Abangan ang susunod: ” Plunder against Arroyo et al dismissed! hahahahaha

      • boldyak

        siguradong madismiss ang sa PCSO…bwahahaha…

    • boybakal

       Hallucinating talaga tong si ZTE.
      Para malaman ko na di ka baliw…i post mo ang mga pinaggagawa ni Pnoy.
      Ilang beses na yan nagtravel ng walang resulta.
      Ilista mo kung magkano ang gastos…
      Yon binigay niya sa mga NPA sa Negros, sa MILF na nagbiyahe sa Japan, Donation sa Japan tsunami victims na $1 million dollars.
      Yan last biyahe sa Dagos P49 million ang gastos.

      Tutal magaling kang mag itemized…isa isahin mo rin simula ng maupo si Pnoy.
      Diyan mo lang na mapapatunayan na ikaw ay Normal at di Abnormal o isang baliw.

      • etomacq

        Abnoy din malamang itong si Mr. ZTEFERTILIZERSCAM10… Sa username pa lang halatang scammer na talaga.. No. 1 LINTA ni Noynoy dito.

    • $20722540

       copy paste nanaman??? from last week, if not the other week

      • batangpaslit

        eh, fertilizer nga eh, kaya mabunga ang halaman

      • Templar Society

        Pero hindi lang yun ang kaso. :)) yung sa ZTE NBN, 2004 Election cheating, compared lang sa kaso ng mga ampatuan – wala naman siyang direct hand diyan. pero sa ibang kaso may direct hand siya at may ebidensiya kaya wag niyo sasabhihn na one by one siya maabsuwelto. :p

      • boldyak

        ito pa isa, nakasave na ang post, paste na lang ng paste…bwahaha

      • Albin

        6 months na ganyan lagi post ni ztefertilizerscam10. Binabayadn naman, pero ayaw mag post ng bago. Puro copy-paste.

      • Febien

        Impeach ztefertilizer scam binabayaran e puro copy paste lang. Mabuti nga ngayon maikli na ang listahan ng mga bintang nya kay GMA. Noon medyo isang kilometro ang listahan nya. Konti pa lang ang dismissed na kaso pero malaki nabawas sa listahan ni ztefertilizerscam.

    • etomacq

      Bumanat na naman si Boy Abunda….Hoy  wala na naniniwala sayo! Sayang na lang binabayad sayo ng amo mo.. Dapat sayo tineterminate na. Hanap ka na ibang trabaho.

    • TuwadNaDaan

      Case Dismissed…jejeje

  • catmanjohn

    The prosecutors office should be investigated for bribes and graft. This is Justice Philippines style, that makes it the laughingstock of the world. The Ampatuans had 50 calibre guns they used on the victims, that could only have come from the army. Someone must be made accountable, but the fight is not over, and the truth will be revealed. This kind of justice is what makes the Philippines the last on the list, whether it be in economic development, Olympics, education rating, etc, but first when it comes to winning transgender beauty contests. What a joke…

    • Mark


    • Touch_Me_, Nuts!

      Catmanjohn has the option to make himself look asinine on his reaction to this matter, but he’s too smart enough for him to realize that he can’t prevent it from happening. lulz

    • boldyak

      kung ang hatol kay GMA guolity, hindi joke…bwahahahaha

  • Padre Damaso

    To be fair to GMA, there is nothing to blame her for in this case. Even though she is allied with them, the Ampatuans where monsters of their own class. She allied herself with these people merely for political gains. However, she could have brought down the hammer of justice upon this people during her last days as President. For what ever the reason why she did not, – only her and God knows. Or the Ampatuans confesses a version of their own.

    • carol

      We have the court who is in charge, unlike aquino, he decides whether one is guilty or not.

    • catmanjohn

      That is called ‘negligence’, befitting to her ineptitude.

    • etomacq

      Now the Ampatuans are allied with LP.. Kaya wag magtaka kung bakit mabagal ang hustisya sa mga Maguindaano massacre victims. Myembro na sila ng KKK.

      • Bert

        The Ampatuans are indebted to the Aquinos more than the Arroyos. The Ampatuans were monsters which have its origins from Tita Cory, they were after-all Aquino’s APPOINTEES as governors and mayors in Maguindanao after martial law.

  • dodong1

    Arroyo cleared of negligence rap over Maguindanao massacre.. Cleared nga PERO KONSENSIYA NYA CLEAR KAYA??

    • josefe38


      • Templar Society

        Pero hindi lang yun ang kaso. :)) yung sa ZTE NBN, 2004 Election cheating, compared lang sa kaso ng mga ampatuan – wala naman siyang direct hand diyan. pero sa ibang kaso may direct hand siya at may ebidensiya kaya wag niyo sasabhihn na one by one siya maabsuwelto. :p

      • boldyak

        Bring it on…!!!!…bwahahahaha

      • Febien

        May palagay ako na madi dismiss din yang election sabotage na yan. Wala ring ebidensya at puro hearsay lang.

      • adscity_info

        Oo nga ang tanga naman ng dodong1 na to.

      • dodong1

        kaya ba nilaglag nya yung mga ampatuans…

    • Febien

      Congrats Dodong may apat na nag like sa OPINYON mo! Nice one! Dodong, paano mo isisisi ang massacre na nangyari sa Maguindanao sa Presidente na nasa Manila. Kung bawat krimen ay isisisi sa Presidente baka puro one month lang makapaglingkod yang mga yan!

      • dodong1

        did you mean to say FAKE PRESIDENT?? you do not have to be physically present sa scene ng crime to be guilty..

      • Adam_d_langgam

        Parang si budoy. Hindi kailangan nakakulong sa mental para sabihin na matino.

  • kolambogan

    Praise the decision for seeing the “butas but not the karayom” The way some people in authorities easily dispatch small time crooks in plain view of witnesses while release under pretense and legal mumbo-jumbo/or “suhulan to make “iwas from the kaso”  big time drug dealers, crooks in government, high profile killers belonging to rich families (they support secretly being their benefactors for their positions in the past or their real bosses in real life) and what have you in the books of thievery and crookedness, adherents in the Philippines tops the world over for having the temerity and presence of mind not to leave evidence for nincompoops in government service to use and enjoy gratis. It is really easy life for criminals, swindlers and crooks in Philippines’ politics, judiciary, justice, military and police even in business, maybe, that’s the reason why the Chinese can easily annex any part of the Philippines with the cowards, gluttons, greedy and Mafioso minded people at the helm of government from top down displayed nothing of the sort of any strong opposition or pronouncements from the unhonorable leeches of society themselves with all the power and authorities they wanted for themselves from the people that they just acted “patay mali” gladly and let the Chinese takeover whatever they wanted to without resistance all rights and justice to the dogs, the way they do with all the cases from Marcos, Estrada, Ampatuan and Gloria Macapagal Arroyo, etc., etc., etc. As it happened and still happening, that’s the way it is in the Philippines, poor Filipinos for they will forever be pawns and instruments to be transgressed and trampled upon by the shrewed members of the evil families in the political clans and dynasties among them. Their only salvation from the evils that smile with and among them (to the good and decent ones) are to open their eyes and mind, be educated in the ways of the wicked that profess to be their friends but only and naturally prey on their being gullible or needy. Nice words and patronage doesn’t make a nice man or woman, it’s the easiest strategy to employ, even the highly educated use it the way the Mafioso hitmen and assasins do to lure victims to their fate or death. So beware of the UNA candidates this coming elections for they are the very people and candidates who will make life for the Filipinos back to misery and perdition. Avoid them like plagues and vote wisely if you want something good for yourself and your country. Make a change and be different from the past. Start people in service and their cohorts still working for the evildoers be accountable with their principals and don’t let them all be off the hook with legal finesse, expertise and gobble degook while laughing all the way to their banks.

    • catmanjohn

      If the Prosecutors Office had real credibility and value to their decision, they would release the all the transcripts and logs of their investigation. This is why the FOI must be passed asap.

      • Adam_d_langgam

        Tell your idiot president to certify the bill as urgent.

        But before opening your stinky mouth, go have your two-inch dick circumcised as well ….. He he he …

      • catmanjohn

        Its about time this pin head worm dropped out of Mike Arroyo’s a$$, to spread your virus. We know a sicko pervert scum like you, fixated on uncircumcised two inch dick needs one up your a$$, but your buddy Bong Revilla would probably be glad to give you his. Mine is too big for your A hole and its already circumcised. You are proof that losers like you are a big disgrace to the Filipinos… your wife having left you, your tiny Ant dick is as lame as your brains, and with a pet dog and lots of Viagra, your breathe smells like dog schit.  Hmmmm I wonder why?  what a low life sewer rat. 

      • Adam_d_langgam

        Ooops .. The two-inch uncircumcised wonder can no longer think straight. He he he. .. That was the same crap you posted a few weeks back and will for sure be your reply.

        I got news for you. Due to my “cis manila” connection, we found out the reason why your dick’s so tiny. When your mom gang-raped 12 mexicans (not mexicans gang-raping your mom), they found out she was so “big” …. They all got swallowed except for a tiny chihuahua which was observing the action. He joined the fray …. You were the result. Ha ha ha. … Dork

      • catmanjohn

        I’ve got hides as tough as a crocodile, and jumping into the sewer after a scum rat like you is fun.. this exercise reveals how low the depraved minds of Arroyo lackeys are, sitting in their stinking  mud hole, a$$ wiping with your hands and wondering why you have diarrhea  coming out of both ends of your orifices. Why don’t you just go suk on your dork friend Bong Revilla’s tiny pacifier he’s got between his legs, you faggott creep.

    • etomacq

      Very biased ka… LP candidates will only prolong our agonies. Ipagpapatuloy lang nila ang KKK system. Sila sila lang din makikinabang sa kapangyarihan. 

      UNA at LP candidates mga basura. Puro magkakamag anak at mga TRAPO!

      Iboboto ko mga independent canditates.. kahit matalo man, atleast malinis konsyensa ko.

      • joel genese

        Ganyan dapat. Mga presidentiables ko, alam kong walang panalo pero hindi ako nakikisali sa uso na kung sino daw ang may “WINNABILTIY” ang dapat na iboto.

      • kolambogan

        Biased ako dahil sa mga kawalanghiyaang nakikita ko, at kung tutuusin ang aking  pagkabias kung ikukumpara sa  mga walanghiyang politico ay wala sa kanilang kalingkingan na walang inatupag kundi mga sariling bulsa at kapakanan ng pamilya, kung ang mga salita ko ang pagbabasehan. Ang kanilang mga garapal na pangungurakot sa kaban ng bayan ay mga indirect na dahilan ng paghihirap at madaliang kamatayan ng maraming Pilipino ng walang maasahan. Iboto mo kung sino ang iyong gusto, karapatan mo iyan na iyung dapat ingatan at ingat sa iyong pipiliin, nawa’y di ka magkamali. Kung iyong papansinin wala akong iniindorso, kundi pawang batikos sa mga alam kong walanghiya sa tungkulin na hindi na dapat iboto sa aking pananaw, mga taong mayayaman na at nagpayaman pa sa tungkulin at mga nagtatamasa ng sarap sa buhay sa kahirapan ng mga mamamayan, kasaganaan ng iilang mga duhapang at kanilang mga kampon na dalahin ng bansang Pilipinas. Sa ganang akin maski LP o sino pa man kapag walang hiya dapat isumpa ng hindi pamarisan, pero dapat ay may matibay na basehan hindi katulad ng mga naturan na balak pang patuloy pahirapan ang bayan, mga mandarambong na naka damit disente pero burak ang mga kalooban, na ang mga buhay at track record sa pag-angat sa buhay ng pamilya ay mga bukas na aklat na puno ng mga katiwalian, malalakas nga lang, una na ang mga apog at kapal ng pagmumukha.

    • boldyak

      bwahahahaha…ang daming sinabi, kampanya lang pala…bwahahaha

      • kolambogan

        kung ngayon ka lang sumusunod sa mga postings sa disqus, magbasa kang pabalik baka maubos ang tawa mo sa haba ng aking mga komento sa loob ng mahigit kong dalawang taong pakikipagtalastasan dito. Alam ko ang ugat ng kahirapan at kasalaulaan ng buhay ng mga Filipino ay gawa ng mga tiwali at walanghiyang politico na sumisiil sa buhay ng kanilang kapuwa marahil isa ka na, kaya pag butihan mo at maaring bilang na rin ang maliligaya mong araw sa pagtawa at mahalinhan ng iyak at himutok dahil unti-unti ng nagigising ang mga tao sa kahayupan at kawalang pakundangan ng mga ganid sa serbisyo. At saka nga pala wala akong iniindorso ang sa akin ay ipaalam sa maliit kong kakayanan ang mga taong nagwawalanghiya sa sambayanang Filipino gawa ng kanilang pagkasalat sa kaalaman sa mga tunay na pagkatao na nakatawa sa kanilang harapan at mukhang mga santo pero ang totoo ay mga ngiting aso at demonyo, siyanga pala kuha mo ang kanilang tawa at istilo.

  • Guest

    I agree that Arroyo was partly responsible for why the Ampatuans got to be so powerful in Maguindanao. But blaming Arroyo for the Maguindanao Massacre is simply preposterous.

    If Arroyo is criminally negligent on the case of Maguindanao Massacre, so should PNoy be on the case of the Luneta Hostage Massacre. To think PNoy even let Mayor Lim off the hook despite DOJ’s findings.

    Let’s stop wasting government resources on PNoy’s vendetta politics. Sayang ang binbabayad ng mga taxpayers.

    • batangpaslit

      Bro, ang alam ko, ginamit ng gobyerno ang mga Ampatuan kontra Moslem Seccesionist Movement noong Marcos time pa
      In place na ang mga Ampatuan when PGMA was esconded to power.
      I concur with your view about vendetta politics.

      • Templar Society

        Pero hindi lang yun ang kaso. :)) yung sa ZTE NBN, 2004 Election cheating, compared lang sa kaso ng mga ampatuan – wala naman siyang direct hand diyan. pero sa ibang kaso may direct hand siya at may ebidensiya kaya wag niyo sasabhihn na one by one siya maabsuwelto. :p

      • boldyak

        the purpose of filing cases should not be due to revenge and to make one popular, the main purpose should be to punish the guilty…kaya nagkakabulilyaso dahil nauuna ang paghinganti at pasikat…bwahahahaha

    • etomacq

      Dapat liable din si Noynoy sa mga sundalong na-amdush ng ASG at MILF… ang atimonan ambush, isama na pati mga kidnappings ngayon sa Mindanao..

      Liable dapat si Noynoy sa mga incident na yan kasi nga sya ang Commander-in-Chief.

  • Maldi2

    That’s the RULE of LAW.  One by one all these (harassment) cases will fall one by one.  They don’t have an iota of logic and pieces of evidence to pin GMA.  Magigising din ang sambayanan sa mga katotohanan na ginagamit lang itong puhunan ni Panot sa kanyang dismal na pamamalakad sa pamahalaan!

  • Augusto de Vera

    tama lang yan idiin si glorya..mga kalahi na lng nya ang maniniwala sa kanya,,,

    • etomacq

      Solidong ebidensya ang kailangan sa korte hindi tsismis.. Alam ni ztefertilizerscam10  yan..

      Huwag masyado makinig sa mga sabi sabi ng mga pulitiko lalo na sa mga tsismosa at tsismoso.

    • Ralph L

      at kalahi mo ang bobo at wlaang isip tulad ng presidente mo

  • etomacq

    Puro cleared ang mga kaso against GMA. Napaghahalataan tuloy na puro tsismis lang talaga ang mga truck loads of evidence daw.  Naiisip ngayon ng mga Pilipino na purely harassment at demolition job lang talaga ang mga binabato sa kanya. Ganyan talaga kadumi pulitika.

    Iisipin ngayon ng mga foreign investors na puro JOKE lang pala ang pinagsasabi ni Noynoy na corrupt si GMA.. May pa-wheelchair joke pa sya.. Now nagbackfire sa kanya mga jokes nya. 

    Sige ang JOKE ni Noynoy kay GMA, yun pala sya ang big JOKE! lol!


    • Albin

      Puro based sa vengeance ang understanding ni penoy sa justice.

  • Albin

    Tabingi na naman siguro kilay ni Valte, kapag naubusan ng paliwanag.

  • billy gunner

    magagalit na naman si el presidente nito! lol

  • Boy

    let’s see with her other cases. Eto medyo clear naman na wala tlga siyang kinalaman. But the other cases such as fertilizer scam yun sigurado siya dun.

    • Arnel

      Segurado??? Paano mo nasabi saksi ka ba?? nandoon ka ba nang kinuha ni GMA ang pera???  lahat na alegasyon mo ay walng kabuluhan at nadagdagan pa ang kasalanan mo sa harap ng Maykapal

  • Tommy

    More persecution in the offing abangan pa! all by more hearsay obvious naman eh.   Ampatuan clan nandyan na estudyante pa lang si GMA.   7thousand islands ang composition ng Pilipinas mahirap ang complete monitoring.   Sa MM na lang, susmaryosep kabi-kabila ang mga karumal-dumal na krimen sa kabila ng umiiral na gun ban.

    Grabe naman kasi mga taong ito baldado na sa katatrabaho si GMA sabihin pa nagsasakitsakitan pa kuwari naka-wheelchair pa.

    Nadale lang kasi si CJ Corona nacorner lang sya ng Aquino Allied Forces pero kung tutuusin hindi impeachable offense ang nangyari sa kanya.   Sa dami ng trabaho nya hindi na nya namalayan ang mga trabaho ng mga accountant nya kaya ganun ang declaration ng kanyang SALN purely persecution lang ang nangyari sa kanya

    Kawawang CJ Corona ginawang punching bag, pampaganda ng image ng bagong administrasyon saka na lang sya bumawi malakas sila nasa kanila ang makinarya wala syang magawa dyan sa ibang araw na lang.

    • etomacq

      Napolitika lang din si Corona.. Ano ba verdict ng Senado sa kanya? Dinuktor daw ang SALN nya? Wala nga sila maibato na kaso kung may nalabag na batas si Corona. Ang pinipilit nila “lack of public trust” daw.. E samantalang very obvious na si Noynoy lang naman ang may gusto syang sibakin para ipalit si Sereno na kaalyado nya. 

      Syempre tatablahin ng Congress at Senado si Corona kasi wala na naman PORK BARREL na panapal yun tao sa mga senatong at Tongressmen!.Someday si Noynoy naman ang uupo sa hot chair.. Guilty or not guilty? Abangan natin.

      • Febien

        Kayanga noong sinasabi na magresign na lang si Corona kesa litisin sa senado, pinili ni Corona ang lumaban dahil walang maikakaso sa kanya. Pero ayun nga dinoktor daw yungmSALN. Di lalaban yon kung may anomaly sya. Ang tagal ngang naghanap ng maikakaso kay Corona ayun nagkasya na lang sila sa dinoktor na SALN. Kaya nga sa senado ginawa angmlitis kasi kung sa korte gagawin ,matatagalan at tiyak na abswelto si Corona. Kaya impeachment ang ginawa!

      • kolambogan

        Old issue, pure rehash that will not even get a consideration from even the courts, the senate and the people. Get on, get a life and pick on new and better issues to discuss if you want to be of help. Corona is history, he was already sentenced, whether right or wrong doesn’t matter anymore, it’s called  “Res Judicata” no amount of bringing up a dead matter can resurrect his tarnished image and by your bringing it up helps to crucify him more, leave the man to his miseries, there are so many crucial things to ponder with in the Philippines, unless you’re one of them and hurt very badly by the decision I cannot fault you, but then better luck. you need it like your man Corona.

      • kolambogan


  • damiranda126

    This decision should be lauded.  At the very start these noise are brougth about by hearsay and allegations, vengeance and pa-pogi points by the Aquino administration.  Those who persecuted this woman will someday reap the revenge of the Almighty.  What you did to this woman is not a joke. After setting this country to economic prosperity hoping that someday each of us will live a better life, you maltreated her.  Now Karma is after to those wrong this woman.

    • tunderlulo

      Magkano ba at ng isali mo ako sa pagdepensa sa kawatan ng bayan para magkapera rin. Madatong si maam kaya siguradong malaki ang bayad niyo?

      • boldyak

        unti unting mawawalang sala si GMA…deal with it….na brainwash kasi kayo…bwahahaha…naglulumpasay ako ng tawa sa inyo…bwahahahahaha

      • Arnel

        hahahaha yellow mobs…. kawatan?? bakit ninakwan ka ba ni GMA??? hahahaha 

      • Musta Na Mo

         malinaw na sa kasalukuyan c Pnoy ang makapangyarihan pro paano nya maidiin c Gloria sa salang di naman talaga nya ginawa?ginawa na lahat ng paraan ni Pnoy para kawawain c Gloria itinalaga c Conchita Carpio para usigin c Glo pro wala ring panama kesi pro guniguni lang pala ni Pnoy ang kaso lang ebidensya…nakaligtaan lang palang inumin ang gamot nya.

  • kwapong654

    Hoy Mister prosecutor, how much did the queen of thieves gave? Arroyo must be held responsible for the AFP arms that were dug in place owned by the Ampatuans due to command responsibility as the commander in chief of the AFP hut since payoff was proffered to the fixcal so the case was thrown to the bin.

    • TuwadNaDaan

      Sabi ni Simeon nasa Tuwid Na Daan na daw tayo eh nakatuwad pa pala hehehe…

    • Musta Na Mo

      kung gayun dapat pala nakakulong na din c Pnoy for being the Commander in Chief of the AFP na nag-ambush sa mga jueteng lords sa Atimonan na kalaunan ay binigyan ng military honor…

  • doublecross

    panakip butaas lang niyan, kc kapartido nniya ang nagkasala.

  • boldyak

    bwahahahahaha….isa na namang kaso ang palpak…bwahahahaha

  • disqusted0fu

    One at a time, the cases against GMA are fading away. The cases against her are all politically motivated anyway. The only question is how long can her accusers delay the dismissal of each and every case filed against her for them to continue their persecution against the former president.

  • JaePablo

    Ano kaya ang masasabi nanaman ni PNoy dito? Or let me say, Ano ang gagawin niya dito?

  • disqusted0fu

    Next up, the plunder case. After revealing that the first resolution of investigators dismissed plunder against GMA, then the main witness admitting that she has no evidence, not even information that GMA and her co-accused actually acquired money from PCSO funds, GMA persecutors have no more excuses in continuing the plunder case.

  • Albert

    Deliberate delays on the “non bailable” offenses just so to keep her locked up.
    Lets hear the cases on those, if guilty lock her up, if dismissed then let her go. But at least stop the delay tactics and let her have her day in court.

  • disqusted0fu

    It would be too obvious if they held GMA liable for this case. And if they did, that means that Pnoy could also be held liable for the Atimonan killings?

    Out of all the cases filed against GMA, there’s not one that could point her criminally liable, which is why the Aquino administration is doing everything they can to delay the cases and keep her in detention so they will always have a scapegoat for their shortcomings. 

    • Wdalicante

      Your analysis of the situation/events covering the cases filed against FPGMA is very correct. Actually there would have been no cases against her if the present president is not so eager to pin her down for reasons we just don’t know about.

      • disqusted0fu

        It is not hard to figure out the tactics of Pnoy since he has been doing it for three years now. It has become nauseating. I agree that there would have been no cases against GMA but since Pnoy has very little accomplishments, she needs GMA to be detained for him to have a go-to ‘achievement’. I wonder if Pnoy’s predecessor was a KKK, would he do the same?

  • Beguine

    The Ampatuans were emboldened by the fact that Gloria Arroyo 
    was their sure ally in Malacanang, but it so happened she was on 
    her way out and all she could do for the Ampatuans was to let
    their arrest and imprisonment seem like no longer her responsibility
    for she was almost finished and waiting to turn over the presidency 
    to the newly elected President, PNoy. 

    Well now it’s been more than three years since PNoy took over, and would
    you say he’s an ally of the Ampatuans, if only because the Ampatuans 
    have yet to be punished for the horrendous massacre? 

    Only one thing remains clear. If you have enormous ill gotten wealth like
    the Ampatuans and Gloria and Mike Arroyo, your chances of being 
    quickly and summarily punished for your crimes diminishes and recedes
    into an ambiguous future when the punishment will be meted out. 
    And here we are waiting for that punishment to come to these people
    and it’s gonna be a long long wait, that much we know and have come
    to realize is the way our justice system works. So easy to indict and
    jail till they rot the poor but the rich are ever as slippery as eels. 


  • disqusted0fu

    @yahoo-ELGS2BPKJKG5PDWJAOOCF7K5KI:disqus :The delaying tactics are also delaying developments in the PH. As long as there are cases filed against GMA, the administration will continue to put the spotlight on her and not on them and Pnoy’s KKKs. If majority eyes are on GMA, only few will notice the anomalies and the inaction of the current administration, causing the hold up of the nation’s developments.

    • beerhunters

      in military parlance,”diversionary tactic”!

    • etomacq

      Kasi nga kailangan ni Noy ng kontrabida para sya maging bida.

  • tilamsik


  • phantomofhope

    at least si GMA pinakulong nya si Ampatuan…eh yung presidente nyo ngayon napakulong na ba ang adik na si Ecleo at ex-gov ng palawan na si reyes? hindi pa naman ah…alaws!

  • Pio Gante

    this is exactly the kind of news that simeon would love to read,

    kaya dapat walang hahara-hara dyan sa dadaanan niya dahil siguradong may tatamaan pag nabasa nya ito.

  • Rogers Nelson Uy

    lahat ng bintang ke GMA lahat puro haka haka lang, maniwala ka bang dinaya nya si FPJ e mismo sa barangay ni FPJ Talo si FPJ! naku ba naman! mag research nga kayo!

  • JasonBieber

    I’m sure Aquino is disappointed. Btw what has Aquino done to expedite the Maguindanao massacre case? Seriously, it’s been 4 years since the tragic event but still the case has yet to even begin. Aquino was able to speed up the impeaching of a CJ faster than he can get justice for the 58 victims and their families…that doesn’t seem right.

  • Ralph L


  • lostRunes

    Ah ok. Gusto ni Noynoy kasuhan si GMA dahil sa nangyari sa Maguindanao. Pero yung mismo nagplano na si Unas, right hand man ni Ampatuan, gagawing STATE WITNESS para makulong si GMA dahil sa dayaan ng election daw.

    Magaling. Yan yung tuwid na daan. Ang mundo mo Noynoy nakatutok kay GMA.

     Puntahan mo kaya sa selda niya. Magkantahan kayo, tapos kasuhan mo ng RAPE.

    O ayan. Sigurado nang kulong si GMA at wala ka nang excuse para hindi magtrabaho

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:

c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City,Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94


editors' picks



latest videos