PNP report: No shootout

11 of 13 victims shot in the head

A+
A
A-

NO RUBOUT Supt. Hansel Marantan, the ground commander in the Jan. 6 shootout in Atimonan, Quezon, insists the operation was not a rubout during an interview at St. Luke’s Medical Center at the Global City in Taguig. MARICAR P. CINCO / INQUIRER SOUTHERN LUZON

There was no shootout. But there was a deliberate effort to make the crime scene look like the site of a gun battle. And the possibility of an ambush cannot be ruled out.

Those are among the findings of the  police investigating team that looked into the supposed shootout between government security forces and alleged criminals that left 13 people dead in Atimonan town, Quezon province, on Jan. 6.

The report by the Philippine National Police  fact-finding committee also found that excessive force was used on the victims, as indicated by their gunshot wounds and the number of bullet holes on their vehicles: Vehicle 1 with 174 entry bullet holes; vehicle 2 with 45 entry bullet holes. Eleven victims were shot in the head.

The PNP submitted the report to the National Bureau of Investigation on Tuesday. President Aquino ordered the NBI to investigate what appear to be gangland-style killings.

Investigators said that one of the victims, Leonardo Marasigan, driver of the first vehicle, “initially had no firearm but later a firearm was placed near his hands and head.”

The investigators identified the firearm as a .45 cal. pistol, which was unfired. But they said Marasigan’s right hand tested positive for gunpowder.

They said one of the slain soldiers, Air Force SSgt. Armando Lescano, “initially had a firearm tucked in his waist, but later a firearm was placed near his hands.”

“An M16 that was initially slung behind the headrest of the seat in front of SPO1 Gruet Mantuano in the lead vehicle was later found between his legs,” the investigators said.

Spent cases of assault rifle ammunition reported by police to have been recovered from the first vehicle were actually recovered from the second vehicle, they said.

Doubts

The investigators said they doubted that all the firearms reportedly recovered from the victims were actually used because of the firearms’ location in relation to the positions of their bodies when they were found.

They said they also doubted that two men whose bodies were reportedly found outside the vehicles were actually found there.

It was also doubtful that the victims actually had guns in their hands when they were shot, the investigators said.

The muzzle of a firearm recovered from one of the vehicles was taped, they said.

They said the M16 found between the legs of Mantuano was pointed “muzzle down,” indicating that the rifle had not been raised during the supposed shootout.

The investigators also said the Quezon provincial police crime scene investigators received “a standby call about the incident at 4:00 in the afternoon from Deputy Police Provincial Office Supt. Renato Alba,” but were not called to the site until 4:25 p.m., 45 minutes after the supposed shootout.

The crime scene investigators arrived at the scene at 5:45 p.m., the investigators said.

But the investigation did not begin at once. The investigators were told to wait for Chief Supt. James Melad, chief of the Calabarzon police.

Three policemen and three soldiers were among the 13 men killed at the joint police-military checkpoint along Maharlika Highway in Barangay (village) Lumutan in Atimonan.

Local police reported that the security forces flagged down three sports utility vehicles at the checkpoint, but the occupants of the SUVs opened fire.

The leader of the police team, Supt. Hansel Marantan, deputy chief of intelligence of the Calabarzon (Cavite, Laguna, Batangas, Rizal and Quezon) police, was hit in the hands and foot, reportedly prompting the policemen and soldiers to return fire, killing all the occupants of the first two vehicles.

Occupants of the third vehicle also fired on the security forces then turned back and fled, local police said.

The Quezon police called the encounter a shootout, but the families of the 13 men charged that the victims were summarily executed.

President Aquino himself observed “inconsistencies” in the early police reports, and ordered the NBI to find out what really happened.

Coplan’s target

The PNP investigation is a separate inquiry into the supposed shootout, in which among those killed was Victor “Vic” Siman, allegedly an operator of the numbers racket “jueteng” in Laguna and Batangas provinces in southern Luzon.

Siman is one of the two targets of “Coplan Armado,” a police operation against jueteng and guns for hire in the Southern Tagalog region.

The other target was Mayor Joven Hidalgo of Balete town, Batangas province. Hidalgo has denied involvement in jueteng and gunrunning in southern Luzon.

Sources in the PNP have told the Philippine Daily Inquirer that the supposed shootout was triggered by a turf war between two jueteng syndicates in Southern Tagalog.

One of the sources told the Inquirer that Siman’s group appeared to have been ambushed by the other group.

In their report, the PNP investigators said the “possibility that an ambush happened cannot be discounted.”

Instant deaths

The PNP probers said “excessive force” was used on the victims, as indicated by 175 bullet entry holes on the first vehicle and 45 on the second vehicle.

“The multiple gunshot wounds in the different parts of the bodies of the victims caused extensive and fatal injuries resulting in instant deaths,” the investigators said.

The trajectories of the bullets that hit the vehicles showed that the shots were fired from different directions and at different angles, including from elevated positions, they said.

But how Marantan was hit could not be ascertained, “since he refused to submit himself for physical examination,” the investigators said.

They said Dr. Arturo de la Peña, director of St. Luke’s Medical Center, refused to turn over to the investigating committee the slugs recovered from Marantan.

Charges recommended

The fact-finding committee recommended the filing of criminal charges against the policemen and Army special forces who took part in the supposed shootout.

They also recommended administrative charges against the policemen involved.

Recommended charged were Melad; Marantan; Senior Supt. Valeriano de Leon, Quezon police director; Supt. Ramon Balauag, chief of intelligence of the Quezon police; Supt. Glenn Dumlao, commander of the Regional Public Safety Battalion of the Calabarzon police; Chief Insp. Grant Gollod, Atimonan police chief; Senior Insp. Ferdinand Aguilar, leader of the police team at first of three  checkpoints in Atimonan at the time of the supposed shootout; and Insp. Evaristo San Juan, team leader at the third checkpoint.

The PNP investigators also said the policemen violated checkpoint rules.

They said that the police used no marked vehicles at the second checkpoint, where the supposed shootout happened.

There were also no signs at the second checkpoint.

The fact-finding report was signed by the chairman of the investigating committee, Chief Supt. Federico Perez Castro, and its members—Senior Superintendents Rene Diaz Ong, Rosvi Cunanan Manulid, Allen Bantolo Bantolo, Reuben Theodore Casenas Sindac and Philip Gil Mallare Philipps.

Inquirer Viber

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of INQUIRER.net. We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.

  • ryan andres

    Huh. This report just confirmed what everyone suspected all along.

  • ryan andres

    The Top Ten Typical Pulpulis Philosophy:
     1. Shoot first, ask questions later
     2. Shoot first, ask no questions
     3. Shoot first, then shoot self and claim self-defense
     4. Shoot first, then call media and make oneself the hero
     5. Shoot first, bahala na si batman pagkatapos
     6. Shoot first, because the police are paid to shoot, not to think
     7. Shoot first, then say, “the SUV shot me first!” (ay, yung nasa loob pala nung SUV)
     8. Shoot first, then cry “I am the collateral damage” upon investigation
     9. Shoot first, then scratch head afterwards
    10. Shoot first, period.

    Palpak na Pulpulis!

    • diamond_digger

      Let’s not be too harsh on Hansel Marantan. If his self-inflicted wounds were not so serious it was because of lack of material time to properly do it. Let’s give him the benefit of the doubt and another chance to do it convincingly by allowing him to point his own gun to his temple and fire it. After all, he and his relatives and cohorts can blame/accuse the ghost of the 7-year old girl he killed in Paranaque as the one who killed him. Besides, he needs to go to find out himself where his victims went.  Do it convingly well enough Hansel. I will be sending a wreath to your wake.

      • justomontevedio

        I agree. Let Manantan do it again, this time by shooting his temple. It will make his case convincing.

      • ryan andres

        You are absolutely 100% right diamond digger!

        Perhaps if we gave him some time to mend his wounds, he can inflict a more lethal one properly? One can hope…

      • 33Sambuang

        barilin nya ulo nya kamo…..hindi yong paa at kamay……reminder of pc days

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/4HFSI7JVVSU3GNKRU72Z2HPWXU Jen

      shoot kurakot ryan andres…

      • ryan andres

        Well hi there, Mrs. Marantan… nag open ka pa talaga ng account to defend Hansel dearest? 

        How about i shoot you in the face? Sanay ka naman siguro napuputukan sa mukha.

    • 33Sambuang

      korek ka brad. marantando kasi ang hayup na yan. mayaman, sa st luke pa nagpahospital. bahag naman ang buntot sa check up. kakutsaba ang isang bayaran na doctor ng st. luke…………….. 

      • ryan andres

        Di ba sakop din dapat ng investigation yung slugs na nakuha kay marantado? Bakit kaya di nila ipasubpoena yun.

        Tama ka, tangna yang bayarang doctor dyan sa st. luke, dapat dyan kasuhan ng obstruction of justice.

    • http://www.dafk.net/what/ Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

       11. Shoot first, then arrange carnage to look like it was the dead person who shot first.
       12. Shoot first, then flee. Never, never ever own up that you were involved.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_VY25ZOHU3FJFFX6CYSH5W4AX3I sugbu

    Ang buhay ng mga biktima ng abusive law enforcements ay hindi na maibabalik….at ang tiwala ng mga mamayan sa mag taong inatasan na tagabantay ng peace and order ay may lamat na….KAYA,dapat lang na magkaroon man lang ng hustisya at sana maparusahan ang may akda sa karumdumal na krimen.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/EA7TIY7PYXEU5UOXG2K5CY5F64 Eric

    Tama na yang acting mo boy. Dapat nagscout ranger ka na Lang. Pang Basilan yang bloodlust mo.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_GVANQHP6VJ2MSGAJB46GUUNISE Jozz

    Were Marantan’s wounds caused by his own bullets ricochet?

    • Carlos_Iho

      ..meaning by his own stupidity?

      • http://www.dafk.net/what/ Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

        ‘self inflicted’ gunshot wounds usually fall in the ‘stupid’ category.

  • chingnarciso

    Dr.Arturo de la Pena should be charge of abstracting  of justice for not turning over the slug that’s  been recovered from Maratrat, [sorry] Marantan wound.

    • boychicharon

      baka ibig mong sabihin e “obstuction” of justice..apology accepted…:)

      • chingnarciso

        na excited lang kaya na itype yong abstracting instead na obstraction. sorry and thanks sa correction mo..

      • mrgracia

        pareho kayong bagsak sa spelling. lagot kayo kay ma’am!… “construction of justin”, hahahahahaha1

    • 33Sambuang

      binayaran ng kapatid ni marantadong jueteng lord yang gagong doctor na yan…. boycott and st luke. …. ang hospital/hotel ng mga gagong kawatan………….

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_ZLG6N3K2NDNGD3JN46EXOIOSEE pogi

    The DOJ “MUST” HAVE A “HOLD DEPARTURE ORDER” should they file a criminal case to this 
    MURDERER.

    It MUST be a NON-BAILABLE OFFENSE.

    The hearing must be a MARATHON HEARING DUE TO THE accused might have the opportunity to retaliate and kill witnesses and the family of the victim’s to silence them.

    Send them to a regular jail in quezon, so that no connections or special privilege be given to this criminals.

    Let the law speaks for itself.

    IGNORANCE OF THE LAW EXCUSES NO ONE. PERIOD.

    • banditpogi

       Ignorance of the law EXECUTES everyone!!!

  • Nunya Effen Biznes

    It is good that President Aquino acknowledges that report has inconsistencies and ordered an investigation. Hopefully, an objective and thorough investigation will be done. From all information given and associated with this incident, it looks like retaliatory action. Quite possibly the injuries suffered by Marantan were either self inflicted or done by associates to appear to be inflicted by the other side.

  • opinyonlangpo

    If the local population can not be safe with this type of police authorities, how much more for the tourists. Maybe it is better if the gun ban applies only to the police.

    • 3_feathers

      I agree with you.. Ban policemen with guns! Hehehe…

    • banditpogi

       Dapat talaga ipatupad Total Gun Ban sa mga bata at bata ang isip!!!

  • diamond_digger

     Let’s not be too harsh on Hansel Marantan. If his self-inflicted wounds
    were not so serious it was because of lack of material time to properly
    do it. Let’s give him the benefit of the doubt and another chance to do
    it convincingly by allowing him to point his own gun to his temple and
    fire it. After all, he and his relatives and cohorts can blame/accuse
    the ghost of the 7-year old girl he killed in Paranaque as the one who
    killed him. Besides, he needs to go to find out himself where his
    victims went.  Do it convingly well enough Hansel. I will be sending a
    wreath to your wake.

    • noyab

      WAG MO NA IPAGTANGOL ANG TRIGGER HAPPY MONG IDOL…DI LANG YAN ANG MGA GINAWA NIYA, MARAMI NA UNEXPLAINED KILLINGS SYANG GINAWA DOCUMENTED PA NG UNTV….PARA KANG TANGA EH

      • LeoSanMig

        marunong ka bang magbasa? 

      • diamond_digger

        Nakakaloko naman ang taong ito, Leo. Biruin, mo, di man lang nahiya sa pagsabing akoy tanga samantalang wala nang mas tanga pa sa kanya. Eh di ngayon, matatauhan na siya.

      • banditpogi

         Sir, baka akala niya medal yung coronang isasabit kay Maratrat :)

      • diamond_digger

         Bwahaha! You are so funny! I thought people participating in this blog do not just know how to write but to understand as well. For the benefit of doubt, before I say you are the most tanga, I would ask you to read and reread what I wrote and try to understand. Better yet, ask help from somebody certain to understand English. You will then realize I wasn’t protecting Marantan. Basahin mong maigi. Para sa iyo pala, pagtatanggol ang pagsabing papadalhan ko siya ng korona ng patay. Baka naintindihan mo na ang korona para sa patay. Sigi nga, sinong tanga sa atin, NOYAB?

  • batangpaslit

    nagkalintikan na
    Col Maratrat is disowned by his own.
    tanong:

    1 paano nagkaroon ng gunpowder burns ang kamay ng isang namatay kung hindi naka paputok ng baril?
    2 paano nalaman na ang baril ng bodyguard ay naka holster pa nang nabaril sia at hinugot lang after he was killed?

    abangan…

    • banditpogi

      1.  Kung binaril daw sila at close range posibleng magkaroon din sila gun powder residue sa katawan kahit hindi sila nagpaputok nang baril.

      2. May una na palang nakuhang letrato sa bodyguard na nakasukbit sa baywang yung baril.  Sa isang letrato naman na huling nakuhanan nasa kamay na niya ata yung baril.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/4HFSI7JVVSU3GNKRU72Z2HPWXU Jen

    maraming reklamador dito… bigyan nyo sila ng commendation and medals mr. president, chief PNP, AFP chief of staff and DILG chief for a job well done… inalis din sa wakas ang mga pinagiinitang jueteng lords ng paring si cruz… bigyan ng wounded medal si manatan.. carry on the good work boy!!! nagpapapogi lang ang mga gustong pumorma sa media bro… walang dapat katakutan kung wala kang ginagawang masama.. wag kang padala sa media harassment contra sa inyong tropa… maraming mga katulad mo na fighter contra syndikato… nasa likod mo sila…

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/GTVNMZR22PGMS55WQPIJTYB4IY Jaime

      No wonder Philippines is a backward country, because of people like you….a walking blind.

      • ryan andres

        Kindly ignore her sir… asawa ni Marantan yan… tignan mo, nag open ng account para idefend si Marantado…

      • 33Sambuang

        ryan, hindi asawa ni marantado yan. kabit siguro. mga hayup sila

      • ryan andres

        Mabibilib ka rin nga naman talaga ser, gumawa pa talaga ng account…

        hehehe kung kabit yan eh pang ilan kaya? Mukhang maraming kabit itong hayop na Marantado na ito eh…

      • mrgracia

        kilala ko yan si jen, syota yan ni leon riego kahit asawa na niya si edward pierro. ngayon naman, kumabit kay malanta (ba?).

    • barako22

      bibigyan ng medal si marantan kung papatayin nya ang kapatid nyang jueting lord

    • ryan andres

      Shut your face.

    • cowboys2

      ugok!

    • $20722540

      anong harassment sa medyo???…siya nga itong drama pa pagmeron medya interview…sa st. luke’s pa nakaconfine meron sigurong insurance or big time

    • 33Sambuang

      jen, ang tanga mo….

    • 33Sambuang

      jen, bakit ayaw ng mentor mo magpacheck up. bakit tinatago ang slugs ng bala na nakuha ke marantando…killer yang bi naback up mo…….white wash. killers, killers, savages, pulis patolang mga tarantado

    • noyab

      GAYA MO NA MEMBER DIN NG POLICE SYDICATE….

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/XJ6M3EEK5LGN77YOMKJHBCXF7Q jeronimo

    Interesting…. let’s see what happens next.

  • tiburara74

    Abangan ang susunod na kabanata – “Da great escape of the trigger happy/bloodthirsty escape artists of the PNP (formerly the dreaded and rotten Phil. Constabulary). God save the Philippines!

  • boybakal

    PNP report: No shootout…

    PNP is showing Impartiality in the investigation of its own.
    Good Job.

  • http://pedestrianobserver.blogspot.com/ Political Jaywalker

    11 out of the 13 massacred este killed were shot in the head. 2 things comes to mind, the ambushers err the checkpoint personnel with unusually large contingent of police and army are composed of sharpshooters or they were deliberately shot in the head gangland style to ensure they are dead.  Which of the two are more likely the scenario? LOL.

    • Loggnat

      Double tap, head shots. Probably shot when they are down so the angle of the head shots should be double checked. They made sure that everybody was dead without doubt if the dead are shot in the head when they are already down. Cold blooded killer whoever did the head shots and my first suspect is Marantan who has experience in brutal multiple deaths including innocent civilians ie. a young girl and his father caught in the crossfire.

      • noyab

        BOCHA ANG TAWAG SA GINAWA NG PNP

  • nelsonkamloon

    Transparency calls for allowing the slugs plus physical exam of Supt Marantan,

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/4HFSI7JVVSU3GNKRU72Z2HPWXU Jen

    to give my opinion, the people in the suv’s (all deceased) were armed and dangerous as informants informed the teams of responders, They had guns. precisely, that were the reason why the teams of the PNP and AFP responded. I know they did not go to the place of incident with Murder in their Hearts.. they went there to perform a duty.. they went there to keep peace and enforce the law, but one of the deceased met them with gunfires..the team leader was shot dowm. Under that circumstances, will the police officers just shout at the aggressors to stop shooting at them as they are police officers, soldiers and environmentalist? will the police manning the checkpoint just stand idly and wait for another police or soldiers to be shot, maimed or killed? time was at the moment. they had to defend themselves and their companions. whoever fired shots among them was fulfilling a lawful duty. in every police operations that exchanges of fires occurs, you cannot expect fairness when it comes to news and opinions of “intelligent’ people.. cause they were not the ones who experienced tragic events.. though policemen manning checkpoints or responding in a police assistance were dispatched in good faith.. although it was a legitimate police operations,we likely tends to influence others that it was a well planned operations… to explain to you further, there has never been a well planned operation when it comes to responding to a call for police assistance or manning a checkpoint.. every firefight comes instantly knowing you had accomplish something for the good of the constituents or a job well done..police always act on every information whether it turned out naught or it turned out fruitful.. but what hurts policemen on the field is when they experience miss-encounters knowing later to be their comrades.. I know they were on a legit operation. to require them to be cautious not to hurt the victims when their very lives and limbs are placed in a perilous situation is absolutely illogical and preposterous.. If it is true that they (victims) were alleged members of a criminal elements then why are we to blame them (responders) for a collateral damage when it is a mere repercussion of an instinctive response while in the lawful exercise of their respective duties? .. i’m not to judge, its my opinion.. if all doubt their legitimacy then investigation will take its course but must be fairly, just and God forbids,,WAG MAHALUAN NG MEDIA PAPOGI AT PULITIKA…

    • Guest

      Ang baho ng iyong kuro-kuro. Basahin mo ulit ang pahayag. Kabugukan at sukdulang kawalanghiyaan ang magtanggi sa natuklasang ebidensiya. 13 tao ang tinadtad ng bala. Hibang na bulag ang magkakaila at baluktutin ang pangyayari. 13 pamilya ang masaklap ng nagdurusa. Masamang Hudas lang ang ayaw buksan ang paningin at isipan. Sino ba ang talagang naghahalo ng papogi at pulitika, kung hindi ikaw? 

    • ryan andres

      Tagalugin mo na lang kasi… para kang pulis mag inggles eh

      • vince_bugaboo

        maski siguro tagalugin n’ya, di ko pa rin maiintindihan. sumobra ang dunong nitong jen na ito. siguro and utak nito naging tulok at lumalabas sa kanyang tenga sa dami.

    • payutenyodagimas

      paid hack…

      there are so many ways to get shot..just watch Training Day starring Denzel Washington.

      and where was the 100m? still missing..

    • cowboys2

      Did you read the headline? PNP report: No Shootout, department ni Taranta-do ang nagsabi…engot ka talaga. Siguro pulpulis ka rin….

    • $20722540

      ambushed nga daw!  all things considered…ambushed like pa rin.  you can’t justify killing 13 people in an instant, just because its a legit operations even though they are criminals.  law enforcers are paid to do their job as anybody else doing other job, its as simple as that….that is the risk they have to take but then it doesn’t give them the right to  shoot people when they feel doing it against their own operational procedures.  it was established during the investigation and very clear (as the sun will rise) that they didn’t follow basic operational procedures…doon pa lang nagmali na sila.

    • wehhhhh

      nandun ka ba nung nangyari yon? parang alam na alam mo nangyari a. LOL

    • 33Sambuang

      DUTY KA DYAN. SIGURO KASAMA KA RIN SA NAGPROPROTEKTA NG JUETENG LORDS.ULOL………..

    • bagombong

       ang liwanag na nga ang pagkakasabi ng PNP investigation na did all there best to show that it really a shoot out..inayos nila ang position ng mga namatay…tanga mo rin…si Siman lang ang kilala nila sa grupo…yan maliwanag dahil laking gulat nila na may mga pulis at Supt. pa yung isa pati si Lontok…ii’s dumb of intelligence whoever is the head , it’s there protocol to know all who are in the group before they act…paano kung kakilala mo yun isa doon at nagkataon uuwi ka sa Atimonan sasabihin sa iyo na idadaan ka na nila doon dahil doon ang way nila…o di nayari ka…it’s there obligation to know all who is inside those SUV para maiwasan madamay ang mga civilian…with that no. police and military, do you think you can fight back…

    • JakeR8

      Better to Remain Silent and Be Thought a Fool than to Speak and Remove All Doubt… You  spoke, therefore, no doubt!

    • legnasagra

      talino mo kabayan, san ba pwede matutunan ang style mo ng pag-isisip, lalim niyan ah

    • legnasagra

      isang genius lang ay may ganyan opinion, sana magsulat ka pa at magpa kadalubhasa sa iyong gawain, mabuhay ka (joke lang)

    • ryan andres

      Hoy kabit ni Marantado! Doon ka sa Abante magsulat…kelangan ng kapalit ni Xerex.

    • Istambaysakanto

      Scenario:

      PNP Check Point Sign: Wala

      Ang ibang police personnel ay di naka-uniporme at may mga armas.

      Kung ikaw ay pinapahinto ng mga ito, di ka ba matatakot baka ang mga ito ay bandido?

      • noyab

        that is not a checkpoint but rather massacre comparable to maguindanao massacre…

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/JBEXUO6RODVCZN4NE2ZBLJH3R4 butch p

        sabi ni marantan right after the incident the checkpoint was in preparation for the comelc gunban eh ilang days pa yun meron bang ganun…ginagawang bobo ang mga tao LOL

    • Carlos_Iho

      No experienced soldier or policeman in his right mind will try to outgun with cal 45 well positioned and superior number of enemies having M16 assault rifles…

    • noyab

      then why kill all sana may binuhay to support yung kanilang allegations na member ng gang for hire group…..kaso pinatay nila lahat…how can you prove their innocence or guilt kung patay lahat….sa PNP killings muna bago investigation and built up of evidence. kung talagang under surveillance ang grupo di ilabas nila ang mag evidences like video evidence during the surveillance, bugok lang na gayo mo ang naininiwala sa palusot nila…

  • Guest

    The smiling devil incarnate. Mass Murderer Marantan.

    • ryan andres

      Agree. Lagyan mo ng bigote yan at swastika sa noo eh kamukha na ni Charles Manson.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/JBEXUO6RODVCZN4NE2ZBLJH3R4 butch p

    si dumlao na naman..kelan pa kaya makulong nang totoo tong mga ito isama na si lacson ray aquino, chavit at duterte mga mamatay tao…

    • Loggnat

      Dumlao never learned his lesson and it seems now that he was guilty after all and was saved only after he turned into a snitch against Lacson. He thinks he is above the law now because he got away from the Dacer case and is being protected again by some powerful player. The people has a right to know who is his protector and how he manage to got back to law enforcement. Dumlao and Marantan are made from the same mold, killers without conscience hiding behind the badge.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/JBEXUO6RODVCZN4NE2ZBLJH3R4 butch p

    bobo gumawa nang script na to..si marantan ba or si dumlao hindi na nonood nang CSI NCIS or SOCO man lang…lumang tugtugin na yang planted na yan bro..panahon pa yan sa metrocom ini…

  • yesyesyo

    Mabuti nga magpatayan ang mga masasamang loob.

  • 33Sambuang

    MARANTAN……………….KILLER…………….KILLER………………… WALANG KONSENSYA. AYAW PAG MEDICAL CHECK UP. ME TINATAGO PATI ANG DOCTOR SA ST LUKE’S KASABWAT. MAHIYA NAMAN KAYO…

  • bagombong

    This is what I am talking about..Did they really knows all the people inside those 2 SUV when they got a tip from there informant…alam ba nila na kasama ni Siman sina supt. Casimino at lahat ba sila ay target at kasama sa gun for hire na grupo ni Siman.

  • mamamia

    ST LUKES lungga ng mga criminal dapat dito iniimbistigahan kaya biglang laki ang st lukes dahil sa mga lagay na kurakot na opisyal , nung bata pa ako ang st luke ay ordinaryong ospital lamang ngunit ngayon is asa mga pinakamalaking ospital sa pilipinas bakit? dahiul sa mga buwayang nag tatago at nag lalagay sa mga doktor ng st lukes.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_SIWJUWUPNGG3URJHWGMI5ZCX7Q Aj

      ugok…

      • spider69

        nagsasabi lang lang si mamamia base sa kanyang observation at according to past news na malinaw pa sa sikat ng araw. maybe you are blind. or maybe empleyado ka ng St. Luke’s

      • dani77777

        mas ugok

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_OJWHBJLMWPTRUOZMN6JOMHLO2A Banana Na

    ooooh, in the first place SET-UP naman talaga nitong SHOOTOUT, UNDERWORLD against UNDERWORLD…sino kaya nag-utos kay MARANTAN na mag-checkpoint sila with the back-up ng military…ano kaya magagawa ng government, police at military sa incident nito…abangan….

  • legnasagra

    kung tama an report na ito, pwede ng isali sa olympice competition ang mga miembro ng ambush team, mantakin mo labing isa sa mga biktima ay sa ulo raw ang tama, eh ano ba tawag sa team members, mga sharpshooter lahat

    • banditpogi

       Running gun battle / shootout pa yon at nasa loob pa nang mga sasakyan at sarado pa mga bintana, pero napuruhan pa sa ulo.  Ala e ka galing nitong grupo ni Maratrat.  Kahit Seal Team 6 nang U.S. of A hindi uubra sa barilan sa kanila.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_SIWJUWUPNGG3URJHWGMI5ZCX7Q Aj

    another stupid comment..LOTS of shots were fired….bugok gaya ng “olympice” mo..

    • legnasagra

      kaibigan, ano pa nga ba tawag mo sa ganyan kagaling bumaril, eh di ba sharpshooter, sensya mo na typo error ko, maliban lang kung isa-isa nilapitan at binaril sa ulo para tiyakin talaga, ano say mo

  • MNLFoodcritic

    Ok, you murder people, and all you get are administrative charges? W T F???

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_4R3GZTGML26TV2VGS6RVHP2THM Fred

    This report by the PNP investigation team appears credible. Is Marantan supposed to be transferred to a government hospital? As a police officer in the active service, he should
    be confined at the V. Luna Hospital.

    • legnasagra

      he should have saved enough millions by now to afford himself services of the best lawyers, or maybe you will be surprised that he suddenly disappears

      • doncleo

         Sigurado si Fortun ang abogado nyan.

      • banditpogi

         Malamang.  Kasi may pera gaya ni Kris Aquino itong si Maratrat kaya afford niya service ni Fortun.

  • superpilipinas

    It would be nice if PDI publishes the report.

    Lots of heads need to roll to appease the public. But only serious no-nonsense and believable reform laws are needed to convince all. 

  • farmerpo

    ‘ They said Dr. Arturo de la Peña, director of St. Luke’s Medical Center,
    refused to turn over to the investigating committee the slugs recovered
    from Marantan.’

    Gunshot wounds are supposed to be reported to the authorities immediately. Can this doctor be charged as accomplice after the fact? St Luke Hospital is becoming the hospital of choice of big time ‘alleged lawbreakers’.

    • spider69

      rewind your memory. si Jocjoc Bolante, hindi ba diyan nagtago pagdating galling ng ibang bansa. Si GMA hindi ba diyan din ang taguan at naka wheelchair pa. kaya mas OK pa ang Makati Med dahil naghugas agad sila ng kamay nang mag press conference ang isang doctor sa isang restaurant sa tabi ng Makati Med. to clear that Makati Med has nothing to do with that conference about the condition of GMA. on my fast blog, I always say that why not run after these doctors & hospital na basta nagbabayad ng malaki kahit hinahabol ng batas ay OK sa kanila. kaya tama ang sinabi ni Pnoy na ang tutulin ng mga car nila pero kapag tumakas na ay naka wheelchair na.

      • noyab

        masyado na bolok ang style mo nangangamoy na gaya mo….

      • spider69

        tinamaan ka ba kaya putak ka nang putak

        2013/1/16 Disqus

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_MZOKC6X7Q52Z4E5VLYNB7GF72Y Kaloy

        After your long comment , what do you really want to sa and point out?

    • VeryDisgusted2

      Somebody burn down this evil hospital.

  • vince_bugaboo

    kaya ayaw magpa-eksamen si marantan, kasi superficial ang wounds n’yang “hit” daw from the dead. kung superficial, flesh wounds lang, ibig sabihin self-inflicted, yung walang tama sa mga buto, dahil maski nga naman willing kang kunyari nabaril, papayag ka bang may tatamaang buto sa leg o kamay mo? ang sakit no’n pag tinamaan ka sa buto, durug-durog! 
    malalaman din natin na wlang tama sa buto si marantan kasi nga self-inflicted ang mga ‘yon.

  • mikerocky

    Good job sirs! Here’s hoping that the professionality of the PNP continues even if the case is not so publicized.

  • Chloroform

     “What we’ve got here is (a) failure to communicate”- Cool Hand Luke

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100002207384387 Andrei Mendoza

    the doctor must be slapped with “obstruction of justice” case, and he must also be bitch-slapped too! alisan ng license, ipa-anal rape sa mga criminal sa kulungan, mas maganda, ipa-drive sa kanya ang kotse nya na merong “check-point” para ma-ambush na rin yan.

    • superpilipinas

      paano kung under threat pala pamilya niya kaya hindi niya maibigay?

  • filipinaskoh

    Wow!
    Para bang walang pinag-kaiba sa “Maguindanao massacre” ito.

    Wala din namang silbi ang PAOCC o PAOCTF anuman ang acronym nito pagiba-ibahin man ito, iisa pa rin ang kahihinatnan nito- intended to “eliminate” through killing. Para bang binigyan lang sila ng “license to kill”. 

    Ano ba yan noon pa man ganyan na iyan- magmula sa kuratong baleleng gang- may mga inosenteng biktima na. Walang problema kung ang pinapatay ay iyong mga mamatay tao, kidnappers o mga salot ng lipunan- tulad ng mga jueteng Lord, but  the problem is there are innocent being involved. Worst the reason for the killing is not to eliminate bad people but to eliminate “rivals” and to silence those who “knows something” 

    • lucidlynx

      Advisory lang ang PAOCTF ang pag provide ng logistics. Hindi sila involved sa operations. Besides, hindi aprubado ng PAOCTF ang operation na ito. Magbasa ka muna.

  • https://me.yahoo.com/a/iV0XkkNontlsHWTkG2jcuz.PB64A#6b054 F alonso

    Magawa niyo pang puriin yung leader ng organized crime at gambling lord na may escort na Police Supt.Dapat sa kanila itumba talaga,mga salot sa Lipunan.

    • indiots

      tama. may escort pa ha?yon ang nakasama dun.. kasi sa training , pagtrainee ka at natanong kung kilala mo si ganitong official, buti pa sabihin mong di mo kakilala, dahil lalo ka lang gugulpihin..

    • superpilipinas

      Sino pumuri sa kanila?

    • noyab

      ikaw ang dapa itumba

    • lucidlynx

      Kung may ebidensya, bat hindi kasuhan sa korte? Malay mo kaya itinumba ni Marantan para sila ang mag takeover ng jueteng sa region.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/6DTNBPJJUJCPAJNKUH6PBC7UBE stoneridge

       bakit? hindi ba democratic country tayo. Bawal ang summary execution, dapat patunayan mo muna sa husgado na may kasalanan bago maparusahan at ikulong. Ang isa bang bookies lang ng weteng ay napakalaking kasalanan, pumatay ba sila ng tao? ano sa akala mo, dapat ba sila itumba eh wala naman sila itinumba. Hindi naman sila namimilit na tumaya kung ayaw?

  • filipinaskoh

    “They said Dr. Arturo de la Peña, director of St. Luke’s Medical Center, refused to turn over to the investigating committee the slugs recovered from Marantan.”

    What is this Saint Lukes, are they trying to PAMPER their patients who are notorious- GMA for plunder, etc., now Marantan.

    Kaya sa susunod KAYONG mga “BIGTIME” sa Saint lukes kayo magpa-confine- sigurado lang “SAFE” kayo dun.

    • lucidlynx

      Kasuhan ng obstruction of justice yang Dr. de la Pena na yan.

    • VeryDisgusted2

      That notorious St. Luke should be closed or burned down.

  • superpilipinas

    Major Charges:

    PREMEDITATED MURDER
    OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE
    TAMPERING WITH EVIDENCE

    Buti pa…those who are less at fault turn state witness. That’s the only way out para sa mga sumunod lang sa utos. But they still need to undergo due process.

    • lucidlynx

      Isama ang SOCO sa charges.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/X5TS3UOIZ6COTUWQRBY5ONG5BE Vilma Amon

    ?

  • superpilipinas

    Black eye ito sa PNoy administration. Di umuubra ang reporma na sinasabi nila.

    Mga nakaraang inquiry in aid of legislation ng Senado, walang kwenta. Anong nalegislate nila nung inquiry sa Paranaque incident?

    Sayang taxpayer money natin. Kaya maraming di nagbabayad ng tax. 

    • lucidlynx

      PNP personnel yan. Ang layo naman sa presidente yan. Hindi mo naman malilinis ng scalawags ang police force overnight. Buti kung involved ang DILG or some other office from the Office of the President. Hindi nga aprubado ng PAOCTC ang operation.

    • doncleo

       magiging black eye lang kung iwhite-wash nila…pero mukhang iniipit na nga si Marantan e…dineklara na ng PNP na walang shootout.. baka lang makialam na naman si Lacson kasi bata nya si Dumlao. Abangan na lang mukhang hindi na nila maloloko nga tao.

      • banditpogi

         Nagsalita nga si Lacson noon una pa lang lumabas balitas.  Sabi niya shootout daw talaga.  Ngayon tumahimik siya, siguro alam niya masyado garapal pagka EXECUTE nung plano.

  • superpilipinas

    Si Doc, dapat kasuhan ng obstruction of justice.

    Property ng gubyerno yung mga bala.

    Pero tignan din nila, baka naman under threat si Doc. Dapat bigyan ng proteksyon ang pamilya bago nila hingin yung mga bala.

    • lucidlynx

      Yung bala is evidence and part of the investigation. Hindi dapat ni refuse kung hinihingi ito ng investigators. Ang bobo naman ng investigators at nagpa-uto sila. The doctor should also be charged with obstruction of justice.

      Even yung examination kay Marantan can be taken from the doctors. Pag wounds inflicted by gunshots, hindi ito kasama sa doctor-patient privilege.

      • http://www.dafk.net/what/ Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

        “Pag wounds inflicted by gunshots, hindi ito kasama sa doctor-patient privilege.”

        pag self inflicted, kasama.  joke joke joke!

    • okabato

       Palagay ko walang bala kung self inflicted lusot lusotan yon daplis lang o baka naman walang sugat pang camera lang ang mga bandage. Malaking bagay kay Marantan na ipakita ang mga tinamong sugat sa mga imbestigador para mawala ang pagdududa.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_4C2SFYIH52Y2KR7QPZPHJO2XQQ sl1

    It is very clear that Marantan is hiding something “why would he refuse to submit himself for physical examination”? The wounds must be self inflected and no shootout happened but an ambush. 

  • Keeper242

    Police Supt. Hansel “Friendly Fire” Marantan, PNP

    • banditpogi

      To the Senate ala Ping Lacson or Gringo Honasan??? H’wag naman sana.  Magiging katatawanan na naman justice system sa bansa natin sa buong mundo.

  • BoySugb0

    In this modern times, why our police couldn’t use video camera to record something like this? We can even use our cellphone to captures video. Police can use this as their protection for themselves in case someone inquire what really happen.

    • legnasagra

      and incriminate themselves to their nefarious activities??

    • superpilipinas

      yes survilla. they should use surveillance cameras.

      i just looked at ebay, wow, the law enforcement cameras are cheap. they are HD quality too. Tamper proof na, kevlar covered pa. Ang galing, video is transmitted via wireless broadband live. The HQ can actually see the blow by blow event as it happens and are able to hear the live audio and the communication between the field operatives. $5,000 only. Team leads should be able to borrow cameras like this  and it should be required for planned operations. There’s also body worn video that costs only $500.

      see them in www,policeone,com (change commas to periods)

    • Balot Pinoy

      Yes roland and using these video devices would like shooting their own feet.  We both know the reason why.

      • superpilipinas

        if boss PNoy orders them to use it, then they need to use it. 

    • lucidlynx

      Be realistic. A news team should do the video coverage. The police force won’t waste time in covering their operations with video and put the cameraman at risk.

      • superpilipinas

        you should see this www,watchguardvideo,com/4re/overview 

        no need for camera man! easy to install plug and play.

        or use www,vievue,com or www,taser,com body worn video.

      • http://www.facebook.com/andy.mendoza.1044 Andy Mendoza

        shallow!

  • lucidlynx

    What about the SOCO? They tried to cover up the incident.

    • superpilipinas

      guilty…..your honor.

    • http://www.dafk.net/what/ Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

       ummmmm.

      the article reports about the PNP report. I believe they include SOCO findings.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/NXV3F6YUQWDOA4HPYOFN5F2N3U Danyel

    palpak ang plano…masyado halata…may mga pulis at sundalo among the victims pero hindi nakaputok…..bopol ang direktor……

    • banditpogi

      Pang drama at action lang kasi si Maratrat.  Parang kulang pang experience yung 27 na liquidate niya sa mga ambush at check point para mag setup siya nang realistic shootout scene.

      Sabi siguro niya sa sarili, “sino ba naman mag question sa version ko nang kwentong barbero, eh sinabitan pa nga ako nang medalya dahil sa mga previous exploits ko”.

  • doncleo

    Ayaw magpa-physical exam ni Marantan ayaw din isurrender yung slug na tumama sa kanya sa imbestigador kasi malalaman sariling bala nya yun..sabi ng PNP walang shootout… e di rub-out nga..papaano maipaliwanag na sa labingtatlo.ay labing-isa ang may tama sa ulo?.execution style ito para masiguro na walang mabuhay na makapagkwento kung ano talaga nangyari..ang kaso MURDER!!!

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/6DTNBPJJUJCPAJNKUH6PBC7UBE stoneridge

    It must be passed into a law that 360 degree cameras be included into rules of operation in a check point or any operation, or invite a media representative to avoid any speculation and cover up. Any violation would be considered as illegitimate operation.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_UYCOAGIL35OAIRH2T6QH3IZUMY Ike

      all police car should have a dashboard mounted camera. And if not all, at least the team leader should have a helmet mounted camera. This is a very cheap and realiable technology, They would not spend millions and millions of taxpayers money on this. This is a lot cheaper than a Senate inquiry on thesame incident, using thesame taxpayers money while not acheiving nor resolving nor convicting  nor stablishing anything.

      • http://twitter.com/whipnsaddle Bastonero

        Ok yun, pro ang problema, walang police car na pag lalagyan ng camera…

    • superpilipinas

      each povincial command should be provided with a few sets of mobile video cameras and body worn video cameras. at least 5 of each. then the lead operative should be able to borrow for authorized operations. long planned operations should not be allowed to be carried out without them. but when there is no planned operation, the video cameras should be shared by rotation among the patrol cars/motorcycles and police officers so that there is a good chance to use them for unplanned encounters. 

    • Loggnat

      Police cars in the US are equipped with dashboard cameras and are mandated that it be used when making any traffic stops. Also during checkpoints which are strictly used when police are in hot pursuit situation of a suspect who had just committed a crime. The reason for the cameras used is to protect the police officer from being charged of irregularity in performing his duty and also to protect the suspect from any irregularity of the arresting officer. It benefits and protects both sides and it is also an important teaching tool for the law enforcement officers on how to perform their duties properly.  

  • superpilipinas

    The big question…

    why did Marantan want all to be dead?

    But of course he will never reveal that. Not even if he is sent to the gallows.

  • parengtony

    This news article was written, for lack of a better term, objectively. Much unlike…

    • James McTangay

      It should not have been published as the contents are just parts chosen from the PNP report. It may not even be official and could be interpreted as a mere hearsay.

      • D_BystandeR

        Anong gusto mo, “news censorship?” Maybe you sympathize with the killers dahil may interes ka sa kanilang grupo o kayo ay kasanib nila? Masabi mo lang ‘yon dahil you are not among the relatives of the victims…

      • James McTangay

        You are the one who mentioned “news censorship”. Why quote something that serves only the purpose of story? Where is balance in the news writing? What about the other part of the PNP report? There is an official body that investigates this event and reports such as this should not be brought out until the official investigation report is made public. And yes I am not a relative of any of the victims but my comment has nothing to do with them.

  • w4d

    LOL…si Marantan, naghihintay ng medalyang isasabit sa leeg niya. Posas ang bagay sa mga duwag na kagaya niya.

  • Loggnat

    That incident just proves that it is not safe to travel in certain areas at night. The danger not only comes from the insurgents but also from the rogue law enforcement officers. These police officers assumed the they are the judge, jury and executioners of the people suspected of being criminals.  

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_UYCOAGIL35OAIRH2T6QH3IZUMY Ike

      Loggnat, the incident happen at 3:30 in the afternoon, in broad daylight. And police officers are not supposed to execute people for just being a suspect in a crime, It is simply againts the law that they are trying to uphold. We are in a modern civilized soceity. But the act of this rogue law enforcement officers shows  that we are still far from it.

      • http://www.dafk.net/what/ Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

        Perhaps it has become personal for Marantan.

        Perhaps it goes against Marantan’s interests.

        Interest in either when Marantan heard that Siman was actively trying to assassinate him. OR Marantan’s interest in other gambling group is threatened by Siman.

      • D_BystandeR

        Isipin mo lang si Marantan ang “kumander” sa blocking force doon sa checkpoint at 16 pulis na pinamunoan ni Marantan silang lahat at naka-damit sibilyan, walang uniporme ng niratrat nila ang nasa loob ng sasakyan. At alam mo ba ang dami nang itinumba ‘yang si Marantan sa nabasa ko umabut na ng 40 at hanggang ngayon buhay pa ang hayup. May nagtanong bakit binigyan pa ng “outside” assignment dapat sana sa mga ganung klaseng tao ay paupuin na lang sa loob ng opisina para wala na siyang mapatay pa. Pero palagay ko malakas magbigay ng “regalo” sa kanyang “superior officer” sa bawat lakad niya na makakuha siya ng limpaklimpak na pera sa mga taong pinatay n’ya.

  • Atawid

    Pati yung Doctor sa St. Luke’s Criminal Hangout I charge ng obstruction of justice because of his refusal to turn over the slugs. What if later the doctor turns over a fake slug. Maybe those in cohoots ar still looking for slugs from any of the firearms from the victims to support marantan’s allegation that he was shot by the victims. Better still, all the victims firearms should be properly tagged.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/SPDAZIXLRDOGCON42ETFG4AG3A TonTon

    i wonder why Marantan, went to St Lukes instead of going to hospitals run by the goverment, he could have saved money for confinement since he is a goverment employee – an officer wounded in action. hmm.. a private room in St Lukes costs 3500 perday (thats the cheapest). 

    why did he not submit himself for physical examination? and the slugs taken from his hand and leg, that is needed for the investigation, why did the doctor refuse to submit for investigation – is it because those slugs came from his own gun? – a self inflicted wound? hmm… that is something that we need to know..

    • http://www.dafk.net/what/ Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

      Kasi pag government funded, baka padaanin ang order thru government channels na i submit yung mga slugs na self inflicted thru proper channels.

      This way, thru private, if the government tries to get the slugs, he may use in court a technicality where it may be unusable as evidence against him.

  • Atawid

    Palagay ko meron someone influential ang nag back up ni Marantan. Bakit Di kaya ni purisisima na I enforce ang kanyang authority on Marantan. At si Pnoy Di rin nag utos na strict compliance k Marantan to undergo investigation. Insubordination din ang I kaso k Marantan. Ano nangyari sa pinas, d kayang ipa tupad ang Batas. Si Marantan, Di kayang inbestigahan, si Gwen Garcia nagmatigas. Tungkol kay Gwen, meron kc siyang Magi (3 kings). Sa kalaunan, wala ng Batas na mapa tupad

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/JBEXUO6RODVCZN4NE2ZBLJH3R4 butch p

      si lacson ang pasimuno nyan

  • http://twitter.com/whipnsaddle Bastonero

    Sabi may third vehicle pero nakapuslit, papaano nakalusot ang third vehicle sa una o pangatlong checkpoint?

    • D_BystandeR

      That 3rd car is a “fiction.” They just want to muddle the issue. Kung totoo pa bakit walang nakakuha ng Plate Number? At paano makalusot, sa likuran andyan ang checkpoint #1, at kung tumuloy man sila at hindi nahagip sa high powered firearms ng army special forces dahil may “bullet proof” sila eh nandun naman ang checkpoint #3. Talagang walang lusot. Kaya ayan nagmukha silang “baliw” sa kanilang allegation. Talagang gawa-gawa lang nila ang 3rd car para isipin ng tao na totoo ang sinabi nilang
      “encounter.”

    • banditpogi

       Yun din ang tanong ko sir, at bakit hindi naitanong yon sa pinalabas na report.

  • Ommm

    Firing from elevated positions, no marked cars, no signs…  “rubout” is too mild, this was a planned massacre.

    In the civilized world the police “serve and protect”….

  • padrefaura

    im at a lost here. are we now saying that the jueteng lord and his henchmen are now victims and we feel sorry for them? 

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_UYCOAGIL35OAIRH2T6QH3IZUMY Ike

      NO padrefaura, What is under question and scrutiny is how they conducted and finished the coplan. The Police or so called coplan is legit. They got their objective, but at the cost of unnecessary civilian lives, because they use unnecessary excesive force. Its like you burn the house down just to kill a rat.
        Since last year, inteligence report is already gathered on Siman. According to Marantan himself they had real solid evidence. They know where he lives, they know his Security office. He is not in hiding and he is doing his bussiness openly. Then why not bring him to precint for questioning or why not issue an arrest warrant and pick him up in his house. Why do you have to put up a checkpoint just to get him when you can easily drop by to his office to pick him up. He is not on the run nor a fugitive. Why do you have to raked the convoy with bullets and kill evryone inside including your superior officer, when you can simply apprehend him while he is having his lunch or watching tv.

      • http://www.dafk.net/what/ Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

         Ike is right. If you can legitimately pick him up on the streets based on what Marantan said is solid evidence, why do it in a check point?

        Perhaps its really a gambling turf war disguised as a legitimate operation.

        Certainly the higher-ups of the PAOCC didn’t give their blessings for a checkpoint style ambush. And yet it happened.

      • VeryDisgusted2

        Why the jueteng operator sister of Marantan excluded from these bullshit Oplan? Is she the milkcow of Roxas, Lacson, or any protecting godfather. I wish they would have been the victims of Marantan’s murderous rampage. These godfathers are more evil than Siman or Marantan. They made us Filipinos sick and vomit.

      • banditpogi

         Ang galing nang explanation!!!  Thumbs up to you sir.

    • D_BystandeR

      Nand’yan ka na naman. Di mo ba alam na kapag wala ka sa medication mo ay para kang isip-bata. Go right away take your pills. Kung hindi na pwede ay lumipat ka na lang sa impiyerno para mag-usap kayo ng sarilinan ni Taning.

  • Vertumnus

    “Dr. Arturo de la Peña, director of St. Luke’s Medical Center, refused to turn over to the investigating committee the slugs recovered from Marantan.”

    In a commision of a crime, those slug are considered evidence.  What exactly is  Dr. Peña’s reasons for not turning those slugs to the NBI?  Forensic examination of those slugs will tell more truthful facts than what Marantan’s and the PNP has been saying.

    • http://www.dafk.net/what/ Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

      hmmmm. proper turnover comes to mind.

      I wouldn’t just turn over evidence to anyone dressed as a cop and nothing else, asking for something important.

      • Vertumnus

        Right you are! But then again maybe he’s afraid some of Marantan’s goons might come after him. But then again, that’s a good reason to give it to the NBI.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/DC6NG5LRTD3HOCQPAYFQ53NWIY Crisanto

    If I’m the attending physician of Marantan, I will refer him to surgery to castrate and amputate both of his arms…

    • http://www.dafk.net/what/ Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

      and amputate his neck too. i believe, from this moment on, he’s going to be in hot water.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/DC6NG5LRTD3HOCQPAYFQ53NWIY Crisanto

    Here its obstruction of justice. They can subpoena the slug from the MD. At the same time arrest the MD.

    • VeryDisgusted2

      Why Marantan and that doctor not immediately arrested for obstruction of justice? Why the investigator seemed to beg? Is Roxas or Lacson behind?

  • speaksoftlylove

    To reveal who is the protector of Marantan and who is the brains of this massacre, the investigative journalists (not the chismoso journalist) should focus on When was the intial funding was given and When it was stopped. Remember that Roxas warned the jueteng lords right after he assumed the DILG post, Therefore, it follows that Coplan Operation has the blessings of either PNoy or Roxas. This is why Ochoa immediately revealed that Coplan Operation was disapproved. His purpose was to wash his hands on this issue which of course, is true. Ochoa deemed it proper because PAOCC which he heads can no longer control these scalawags in uniform. It is out of his hands.

    Kaya ganyan na lang yan ang lakas loob ni Marantan na di makisama sa imbestigasyon at ayaw magpa physical check up dahil mas malakas pa sa pader ang protector at yang protector niya mismo ang nagutos sa kanya na wag makisama. Bakit puro pakiusap na lang ang ginawa ng PNP kay Marantan na makisama? Yang PNP mismo ay alam kung sino ang “Godfather” ni Marantan. Sino sa tingin ninyo ang super lakas na politiko sa Pilipinas na takot pati PNP Fact Finding Investigating Team?

    O sige mga yellowvultures, delete na ulit kaagad.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/JBEXUO6RODVCZN4NE2ZBLJH3R4 butch p

      ang godfather nyan pweding si lacson,binay,enrile,erap….anong say mo….

      • batangsulpok

        Siguradong si Lacson ang godfather dahil si Melad at Dumlao ay dating mga bataan niya at si Marantan ang hitman nila.

    • droccu

      “To reveal who is the protector of Marantan …..should focus on When was the intial funding was given and When it was stopped. Remember that Roxas warned the jueteng lords right after he assumed the DILG post, Therefore, it follows that Coplan Operation has the blessings of either PNoy or Roxas.”
      Spitfire, you are really earning your keep very early today to come up with your quick analysis above. Though the logic of your narrative is very much suspect (especially above), I sure commend you for quickly and directly getting to your assigned target that Roxas and Pnoy are the protectors and the brains of this massacre and jueteng in general. (?!) Did I get it right? 

    • D_BystandeR

      Talagang it’s mind-boggling to speculate that the “padrino” of Marantan is that powerful and influential that the “investigating team” is powerless to force him to submit to their “official questioning.” Pati na “physical examination” sa kanyang alleged “gunshot wounds” ay umayaw siya when in fact the investigating team is supposed to be “clothed with special police powers” to force anybody to ferret out the truth. At ‘yung doktor ng St. Luke Medical Center na si Arturo de la Pena na director daw sa ospital ay ayaw isurender ang mga “slugs” na allegedly taken from Marantan. Baka maghanap pa ‘yan ng ibang source para “palitan” ‘yung mga slugs na ‘yon to  suit whatever evil motives they want para lang makuha nila ang gusto nilang palabasin sa mga ebidensya. Kung talagang “self-inflicted” ang mga tama ni Marantan ay tiyak na ang sariling baril niya ang ginamit kaya ayaw ibigay ng doktor ang mga “slugs” dahil balak niyang pagtakpan si Marantan sa ginawa niyang mga kabalbalan. At isa pa, bakit nand’yan siya na-confine sa isang mamahaling ospital na balita ko ay P3,500 ang lowest daily rate, dahil ba kayangkayang pagbayaran sa nakuha nilang “red bag” na may lamang P100 million at idagdag pa ‘yung sinabi sa anak ni Supt. Boy Consemino
      na may dalang P5 million para sa isang transaksyon ng kanilang lakad di ba total ay
      P105 million. Kahit pa matalsik sa trabaho niya si Marantan ay sigurado na ang kanyang kinabukasan sa laking perang nakulimbat nila sa mga patay.

  • speaksoftlylove

    Remember also that during Mar Roxas’ press conference with Gen. Purisima he criticized the tv channel, without mentioning abs cbn, for releasing the PNP Fact Finding Team Report which was “returned for reformatting” by Gen. Purisima to the investigating team. Roxas said “it is not right, it is not right.” It is not right because they can no longer doctor the report anymore because it contains damning evidence that the guns were planted near the dead bodies to fake a scenario that the victims fired shots or it was a shootout. Glaring on those picture is one dead body who wears an orange t-shirt. In the first picture the gun was still clearly inside his holster but in the second picture the gun was drawn already and laid beside the person. Meron pang mga ibang biktima na may tigalawang pictures din na kitangkitang magkaiba, walang baril sa una pero may baril na sa pangalawa. It’s ironic that Roxas wife, Corina is an abs cbn reporter. Maybe she can explain why they release the video of those pictures preempotively. My hunch is that abs cbn is not willing to participate in the sarsuela. Roxas magpakatoo ka!

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/JBEXUO6RODVCZN4NE2ZBLJH3R4 butch p

      hooo si lacson ang godfather kung sinosino pa tinutoky mo

    • D_BystandeR

      Kung gusto ni Roxas na manalo siya sa 2016 ay ito na ang pagkakataon na magpakitang gilas siya at huwag takpan ang katotohanan. Sabi pa nga, “Truth will lead the way.” 

  • Cavitekid

    Another example of a case that will go unsolved and will float away to oblivion and out of sight.

    • juansanmateo

      and eventually into an action movie…or not.

  • http://www.dafk.net/what/ Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

    Not surprised about the findings.

    I’m just surprised the PNP would ‘bear all,’ which they have not done in the past esp when high ranking personnel are involved.

  • acer

    i can’t understand the mentality we pinoys have… vic siman is a criminial and he has protection from these militayr men….. why defend him? ANG TATANGA NYO CRIMINAL NA NGA I DEDEFEND NYO PA…… PARA KAYONG SI PRESIDENTE ABNOY!!…. MGA SHOW LNG ITO NI ROXAS PARA SIKAT XIA

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_AR3F3RNQX4U3PKBI526NJI6BYM Jose

      Mukhang mas malaking criminal kasi itong tumira.  Turf war nga daw, ang nadadale yung mas maliit. Di ka ba kinikilabutan na mas brutal ang maghari-harian at komo patay na kumpetensiya eh di wala nang pangingilagan, pulis pa naman, di nakuntento sa lagay, gusto kopoin na pati operation ng illegal.

      Ngayon, sino ang tanga?

    • torch_po

      TANGA KA DYAN!!! walang kinakampihan dito, ini imbistagahan lang yung nangyaring shootout/rubout/ambush.. at wag mo kaming isama sa mentalidad mo

    • D_BystandeR

      Sana kayo na lang ang niratrat, ogag ka pala. Huwag kang magsabi ng ganun, maawa ka sa mga relatives na still in the state of mourning. Buhay ka pa pero ang kaluluwa mo ay kinuha na ni Taning para sa impiyerno!

    • Concade

      Ikaw ang TANGA, hindi nman pwede na basta na lamang magpaulan ng bala ang mga pulis basta makakita ng Wanted. Paano kung may mga kasamang sibilyan, ok lang ba sa iyo na maraming madamay at mamatay na inosente basta mapatay lang ang Gambling Lord?

    • Paitan

       sir,,may ebidensiya po ba kayo na kriminal si Mr. Vic Siman? at kung sakali  na siya nga ay ganun ayon sa inyong sinabi, tama po ba ang ginawang proseso sa pagtatalaga ng isang check point na ginawa ni Col Marantan at kanyang mga grupo kung ibabase natin sa guidelines at operating procedures na nakapaloob dito? kahit pusakal na kriminal sir e dapat pa rin yatang dumaan sa tamang proseso ang lahat ng kasong kinasasakgkutan?
      siguro naman katulad nyo ako na sumusubaybay sa pangyayaring ito at tulad nyo ay hindi ako magtatanggol ng isang taong may masamang loob at hangarin pero sa punto ng argumento, sa ganang akin ay di lang iisang panig ang titignan ko..

    • banditpogi

       Okay lang sa akin patayin lahat nang criminal kung criminal nga talaga.  Pero kung ang papatay kapwa criminal din na siya naman ang papalit sa mga pinatay, maghahari at maghahasik nang lagim, parang wala naman ata hustisya kung ganoon.

  • juancrossofthe

    how could saint luke hospital cannot comply to surrender the slug taken in Maratnan body?….the philippine laws and justice is full of bullshit..  it’s part of the investigation of a murder/rubout/shootout??… 

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/ZNYPDBVE2OVC723Y36LT6CC2ZE wakai_duvatan

      sir, its been the SOP for medical officers to keep those, slugs, x-rays or any evidences we collect from patients involved in any medicolegal cases for when we are being called to court, there we could surrender those things when so ordered… 

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_44QGTQXFYHNVPNMX453LWBPMXM Opel

    NBI:    Bakit ninyo pinalabas na shootout?
    Pulis:  Wais to!, Alangan naman na palabasin namin na suicide, masmahirap yon! 

  • edvival

    Instead of belaboring questions  about CoPlan Armado, PNoy should simply declassify it to assist the NBI Investigating Team. In that way, discussions will be open and not subject to speculation. IMO, wala naman yata concern tungkol sa national security dun, puro lang law enforcement issues lang.

  • speaksoftlylove

    Butch Panot, yong bata mong si Lacson ayun, inaaway yong kapwa corrupt niyang si Santiago. sa kabila. Gumagawa ng diversionary tactic dahil umuusok masyado itong Atimonan Massacre.

    • banditpogi

      Kawawa naman si Brenda.  Baka bigla na lang mawala yan na parang bula ala Bubby Dacer. 

  • kimkim1226

    Baka another whitewash naman ito pag merung malaking baboy sa goberno na involved o protector sa grupo ni marantan. if government of pinoy is truly serious of cleansing the pnp and so as the pnp chief then all personnel involved should have to answer, and leave no dirt on the table. They filipino people already have no more trust with the pnp. kanya2ng sabwatan basta pera, they do not think it’s the civilians who feed their family.The civilians paid tax so as to be protected by the police or soldiers. This people do not follow operation procedures so delikado ang mga mamayan sa mga pulis na ito. so its better to armed ourself with high powered guns to protect this kind of policemen. kung pwde nga lang missiles na ang bibilhin ko kung ganito ang operating procedures ng ibang police.

    • banditpogi

       Yung mga tipo nitong si Maratrat ang nakakatakot maka gitgitan sa traffic.  Babarilin ka na walang kalaban laban at lahat kasama mo sa sasakyan para walang testigo, papalabasin pa na gun for hire kayo o drug pusher with matching evidence pa sa glove compartment para realistic sa SOCO!!!

      Mahilig siguro manood nang hollywood gangster film itong si Maratrat.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/KAAEZZZL7OMMZ5K4KCFETADLSM jerome

    If the doctor refuse to give the bullet slug recovered he should be charge with obstruction of justice and be treated as an accomplice of Marantan. Base also on the reports if some of the trajectories of the bullet is coming from above the it only shows that the whole scenario has already been planned. And if Marantan claimed that he was a collateral damage who shot him the driver do does not have a gun but later found out lying outside with a gun near him and as they said was positive for gun powder burn and why did the incident was only reported 25min or 45min after the shootout happen. Clearly this is no case of a shoot out but a clear rub out and why would Marantan be hospitalized in St. Lukes should he be in V. Luna where every active officer should be treated don’t tell us that the tax payers money will be used in his treatment in that hospital? And why will he not let himself be physically examined is it because the wounds he has were all self inflicted to make it look real. Kudos to PNP for their imparial stance and report. This are atrocities committed by Police officers who thinks they are above and beyond the law. This is one reason why the people are losing their confidence and trust with the Police and Military.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/ZNYPDBVE2OVC723Y36LT6CC2ZE wakai_duvatan

      sir, medical officers usually keep those slugs, even x-ray films, etc to prove their findings for their defense. its only given out on court order., 

      • TEAM PNOY

        bakit, criminal ba yong doctor or na charge ba ng malpractice? Anong defense? Hindi naman ma charge ang doctor kung hindi cya kasama sa patayan. 

  • regd

    And why is this guy smiling and resting comfortably at the hospital treated humanely? HE WASN’T TO HIS VICTIMS!

    • justjarred

       ikaw na ang madyaryo! god or bad publicity is still a publicity

    • James Wise

      …………….in a hospital suite

    • banditpogi

       Mangiyak-ngiyak na nga siya noong isang araw na ini interview siya nang malaman niyan ipinaubaya sa NBI ang investigastyon.  Multi-talented pala itong si Maratrat.  Manang mana kay Ping. 

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/CAWLT6SE3IC36RTDVRUIDWO364 Dag Erickson

    When doctor Arturo de la Pena refuses to turn over the slug to SOCO, he becomes  an accessory to the crime.  Gross obstruction of justice.  So, what did they do when doctor de la Pena refused to turn over the slugs, its ok with the SOCO? They should put him under arrest on the spot. He got no right to refure to turn over the slug !!!!!!!!!!   It is police matter.  Our police system in the Philippines is a BIG JOKE !!!!!!!!!!  

    • jpmd88

       dude, there is no obstruction of justice yet here as there is no case filed against the person involved yet.  It only becomes a case of obstruction when there is a pending case already and the court has ordered the turnover of the slugs to the police.  Until then it becomes the property of the hospital and they are under no pressure to turn it over unless there is a “continuing crime” that is happening or to prevent the commission of a crime.

  • edleon

    The brighter side is that the suspected criminals were eliminated and the accusing criminals will be prosecuted. although meron din mga inosente na nadamay just because they were at the wrong place with the wrong companion at the wrong time.

  • speaksoftlylove

    droccu cement, I already posted before that the PNP has morphed, but I am not saying all of them. But the brains of these massacre are no longer contented of the usual jueteng payola. They want to operate it themselves thanks to Marantan and his sister. That is why there is a need to eliminate their nearest business competitor. Kung di lang ito nagkabulgaran ay marami pa sanang titimbuwang the jueteng lords at tuwang tuwa naman ang mga tao pero nungka sila rin ang ng papalit.

    As to Mar Roxas, I am not pointing my dirty fingers to him directly. What I am saying is that he should tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth kahit si PNoy pa ang tatamaan o mga kamaganak niya. If you just read my post between the lines, you must have noticed that I inserted Corina’s name. And, if you want a direct answer, I have a hunch that it is Mar Roxas himself who allowed the PNP Fact Finding Investigation Team to leak their report prematurely to abs cbn. Kung totoo si Mar, he is fighting a very dangerous crusade. He does not know who is his enemy or foe in this jueteng curse. Kaya sabi ko, :magpakatotoo siya, call a spade a spade once and for all!

    • speaksoftlylove

       correction:

      friend or foe in lieu of “enemy or foe.”

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/CAWLT6SE3IC36RTDVRUIDWO364 Dag Erickson

    i ALSO NOTICED nobody wants to talk about that ambushed Montero with a sticker — Office of the President of the Philippines. Here are the names just connect them… Marantan, Glen Dumlao, Ping Lacson.    Then the Siman Group- P100-million in different red bags, gold bars,    precious stones as his business. Siman dead, money, gold bars missind.
       By the way, how did Glen Dumlao got re-instated ???????????  Who’s behind it ???  Is this the deal given to him by Ping Lacson in exchange for his silence?   Let us not forget that when in hiding, Ping Lacson is always in a secret phone conversation with President Pnoy almost everyday.
            MGA SINDICATO NOW ARE BOTH ON THE CRIMINAL AND THE GOVERNMENT SIDE. TSK, TSK, TSK, TSK !!!!!!!!!!

    • jpmd88

       really? you actually have evidence of this? or are you just making this all up?

      • basyong

        siguradong sigurado angat!!!!!

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/4HFSI7JVVSU3GNKRU72Z2HPWXU Jen

        less evil prevails pa rin yan.. God all planned for this.. 

    • novaliches

       Sabi ko na nga ba kasama na naman si Ping dito e.

    • banditpogi

       Kaya nga noong una pa lang lumabas ang news sa shootout kuno nagsalita na si Lacson na hindi daw rubout at legitimate operation daw.  Ngayon lang siya nanahimik kasi masyado nang maraming matang nakamasid.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_GYYFBINDMTZHM6TDHPB667452M agustin

    Jueteng money and drug money are needed to advance political funding for the coming election.this is a rivalry between syndicates.

  • tra6Gpeche

    The fact-finding report was signed by the PNP investigator,
    Chief Supt Federico Perez Castro. That there was no shootout! Based on this, the
    officers of the Coplan Armado and their members should be sent to prison and be
    dismissed immediately. I consider said report to be unbiased, truthful and
    brave. Victor Siman might be a jueteng lord but the group of Supt Hansel
    Marantan did not have to massacre Siman and his men. There is a law to make
    them answerable to their illegal activities. Supt Marantan, his men and Chief
    Supt James Melad should be considered lawless, dangerous and a pest in the PNP
    organization!

  • http://www.facebook.com/nasa.pinas Nasa Pinas

    there suppose to have a backhoe on a stand by near the checkpoint but ampatuan called Marantan and said “Bro ,be original dont try to copy ” . so Col. Dumlap prevail and told Marantan ,lets just do a Kuratong Balleleng syle and we will get away with it .and so they did.

    • banditpogi

      Dumalao and Maratrat’s next career move would probably lead to the senate!!!

  • omg11

     Why can’t someone make a law requiring police operations to use cameras
    that can record what actually happened? Make it a law that it is illegal
    without properly videotaping the operation. With the current
    technology, it is very easy to do this. This will erase all doubts when something like this happen.

    Calling all congressmen and senators…

    • Rovingmoron

      Make it a law that media coverage of the incident should be captured in video like a correspondent covering a fighting war. Or a chopper above should record whatever is happening on the ground.

    • banditpogi

       Magaling na suggestion.  Ewan  ko ba ilang beses na nangyari yung ganoong insidente hindi pa rin naiisip maging official policy yung pag video tape sa mga ganoong operation. 

    • billy gunner

       problem is, the same congressmen and senators are masterminding this kind of operations.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_UJFIHEYFTMFPXK4XXCOCGNHJS4 Jeni

      Nice suggestion, but who will take the video if that person is with the group?  He should be independent so there will be no doubts as to the veracity of the film.

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_UYCOAGIL35OAIRH2T6QH3IZUMY Ike

        Jeni in all develop countries, camera recording technology is used in all Police and Military operation.  US, Canada, Australia, & all Europe just to name a few had a dashboard mounted camera on their police cars. It automatically recorded every events in an operation, No one has to hold the camera. This would protect both the suspect and the police from any counter accusation. On the other hand every U.S. foot soldier in Afganishtan & Iraq has a helmet mounted camera that also record their operation. Both miltary helmet mounted and police dashboard mounted camera can feed livescreen video of the actual accounts in their Headquaters as it happens. Nowadays this technology cost less than a Senate inquiry on thesame incident that would not establish nor resolve anything other than spending taxpayers money to gain publicity,

      • Guest

        When I watch videos on US commandos, their helmet are equipped with cameras. It may not be as sophisticated as that but if it will become a requirement, police will be forced to do it. It is also a deterrent for rogue elements to do something stupid such as this Atimonan encounter.

      • omg11

        When I watch videos on US commandos, their helmet are equipped with cameras. It may not be as sophisticated as that but if it will become a requirement, police will be forced to do it. It is also a deterrent for rogue elements from doing something stupid such as this Atimonan encounter.

  • PH2011

    They said Dr. Arturo de la Peña,
    director of St. Luke’s Medical Center, refused to turn over to the
    investigating committee the slugs recovered from Marantan.

    NOW, THAT JUSTIFIES WHY THE ENEMY
    OF THE STATE PROCEED TO ST. LUKE HOSPITAL.   A FIRST CLASS, CERTIFIED  SANCTUARY OF THE UNDERGROUND WORLD WHO CAN PAY
    THE PRICE.

    THE OFFICER INJURED SHOULD HAD
    BEEN CONFINED TO A GOVERNMENT HOSPITAL ( i.e. V. LUNA, VETERANS, PGH ETC.) AS A
    MATTER OF STANDARD PROCEDURE. BUT THE FAVORITE CHOICE IS THE PRIVATE AND COSTLY ST. LUKE.

    SO, WHO WILL PAY THE BILL?  A GAMBLING LORD? A POLTITCIAN? OR CHARGE TO GOVERNMENT
    INTEL FUND….THE REPORT MENTIONED THE GUNS, BUT DID NOT MENTIONED ANYTHING ABOUT
    THE MONEY BAG, THE CELPHONES/LAPTOPS OF THE VICTIMS  WHICH  ARE
    VITAL AND WILL SURELY ADD RELEVANT INFORMATION IN THIS INCIDENT.

    • Atawid

      Kaya lakas loob ni lang manratrat lalo kng alam ni lang may dalang Marami pera like kuratong baleleng kc admin charges lang ang case at dismissal lang. Kng ma dismiss, no worry kc in the bag na ung pera na Hindi kasama sa inventory

    • ever green

      the doctor should have criminal liabilities for obstruction, Di ba ang tamang procedure ay pag may gunshot wound, irereport sa police at i-turn over ang marerecover na bullet slug????

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/4HFSI7JVVSU3GNKRU72Z2HPWXU Jen

      he has the right to choose where to be confine.. nakalimutan yata ninyo yan.. mamatay ka lang sa government hospital dahil wala ng mas magagaling na doctor dun, nagliparan sa tate at europa.. mga equiptment, facilities ay nung wala pang cellphone yan.. ikaw  lang ba ang me kakayahang magpahospital dun.. kaya din ni pobreng juan dela cruz. ang isip ng tao nga naman..  

  • novaliches

    Kung hindi maayos ni mar ito, dapat umalis siya sa dilg at ipalit si ping. maraming galit kay ping pero siya lang ang nagpatino sa mga criminal noong panahon ni erap.

    • joshmale2004

      Well said.Lacson is very much qualified for the position of DILG Chief.

      • Atawid

        At pag si ping na, abswelto na c marantan

      • joshmale2004

        You said that. I don’t want to speculate.As far as i know, during the time of Ping, kidnapping and drug syndicates were at all time low at nawala din ang mga pulis na malalaki ang tiyan.

      • banditpogi

        Papaano nga malinis gumawa grupo ni Ping.  Mga drug lords nawawala na lang parang bula at kasama din nawawala pera nila.

        Yung pagpapaliit tiyan nang mga polis PR campaign lang yon.

      • joshmale2004

        That’s purely speculation which can not be proven.

      • banditpogi

        Sa tuso ni Ping talagang wala makikitang evidencia para ma link siya sa mga anomalya.  Buong resource nga gobyerno ni Pandak ginamit wala pa rin napatunayan.

        Ang naiipit lang yung kanyang mga subordinate palagi.

      • joshmale2004

        Ibig sabihin wala talaga siyang kinalaman sa anomalya. Yung mga ibang tauhan niya binayaran ng gobyerno para isabit siya pero bandang huli binawi din nila pagsabit sa kanya at ginawa lang nila dahil inipit sila ng gobyerno.Imposible namang sa dami ng bintang sa kanya eh wala kahit isa mang napatunayan. There is nothing such as perfect crime lalo kung maraming crime ang ginawa. As I said, panay speculation at media propaganda lang ang ginawa kay Ping kahit walang evidence to prove. 

      • banditpogi

        Coincidence lang kaya na mga bata niya sina Dumlao at Melad na naman ang nasangkot sa kasong ito?  At bakit nagpahayag siya kaagad nang support noong una pa man na “shootout” nga daw ang nangyari.

      • joshmale2004

        I believe it is. Also, not only Lacson but many commenters and politicians initially made their comments that it seem legitimate with a clarification that it is personal view and we need to wait the official report. Besides, Marantan as far as I can recall was reinstated back in 2007 while Dumlao in 2005 so I don’t think Lacson had a hand in their coming back to service as during that time, Lacson was also the number 1 enemy of the Arroyos.

      • banditpogi

         Tama ka diyan kabayan.  Birds of the same feather mga yan!!!

      • banditpogi

        Malamang ma promote pa nga si Maratrat at Dumlao kapag si Ping ang nasa puwesto.

    • banditpogi

       Oo, ibalik si Ping at ipalit si Maratrat sa pwesto niya sa senado.  Kawawang familya Dacer.

    • ever green

      yup…maraming criminal ang nawala nun panahon ni lacson kasi maraming pinatumba  ang grupo niya……
      in a sense, okay si lacson, but that’s just like weeding out the weaker criminals at ang natira ay ang mga mas walanghiyang mga pusakal.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/SUZF4IVEV6CG4KRCTDIPNAGGAI liloy

    kawawa talaga tong grupo n marantan…. nilalaglag na cla ng kapwa nila kasama….pasensya ka na sir bigtime n criminal kc ung nabanga mo…. daming konection nyan….maraming matataas na opisyal ng gobyerna na naka payrol dyan…… kung grupo kaya n marantan ang namatay….cgurado d na yan lalabas sa media…kung marami lng trabaho dyan wala ng mag pupulis…. 

    • Magsasaka

      sinong kawawa?si maratrat o yong mga namatay?nagkataon lang na hindi na uubra ang mga PAPUTOK at PAMUMUGO nila ngayon, sundan mo ang mga ginawa nila para malaman mo kung paanong puro walang laban ang mga pinapatay ng mga sindikato ni marantan, ganyan na gawain nya noong nasa task force limbas pa iyan.

      • speaksoftlylove

         Yong task force Limbas at task force Lambat ay nagmerge na kaya ang tawag ngayon ay Task Force Kulimbat, in charge sa Cupalan Operation.

      • Magsasaka

        tumpak

      • ever green

        wahahaha…….nice one.

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/4HFSI7JVVSU3GNKRU72Z2HPWXU Jen

        sabi mo yan dahil kurakot ka..less evil prevails pa rin yan… ang Diyos ang me alam dyan…

      • Kairosphil

        nayari mo spitfire! hahahha.. TFKulimbat, Cupala Operation! 
        less evil daw si manratrat? evil pa rin kahit less.. 2 lang klase lang Good or Evil!
        parang lies or white lies.. lies pa rin yun. no such thing as less evil!

      • Kairosphil

        liquidation squad! soon to be liquidated?

  • anu12345

    Kung government ang nagbabayad ng hospital bill nito, ‘yung soldiers natin sa Mindanao eh saang hospital?

    • ever green

      albularyo lang tol…..

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3UAABFPUE5ZKBXOAGLWL6POGWU joel genese

    Nagkakalaglagan na! Baka magsasalita na rin si Marantan kung sino ang protektor nya at kung sino sino ang mga boss nya na konektado sa jueteng. 

    • ever green

      abangan ang susunod na kabanata…..marantan ambushed……

    • Kairosphil

      …tingin ko susunod na siya.. kung ano ginawa niya ganun din gagawin sa kanya ng mga amo niya… Marantan check mo mga gamot mo. wag ka magtiwala kahit kanino..

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/JLZJHQHV7WVOJ4XZW4QKRDYSUA Gerry Randel

    If the investigation of the PNP showed that this incident was an ambush and excessive force were used by Marantan and his men, then a case of MURDER should be filed against them. And to avoid intimidating and coercing the witnesses to this heinous crime, all involved PNP and members of the Philippine Army, should be immediately suspended and not only “confined to barracks” and their issued firearms should be confiscated.  Administrative proceedings against them should be initiated without delay and if they will be found liable, they should be terminated in the service ASAP. 

    • billy gunner

       and jailed.

      • Kairosphil

        for Life!

      • banditpogi

         For good!!! No pardon!!! No amnesty!!!

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/4HFSI7JVVSU3GNKRU72Z2HPWXU Jen

      tama ka….and fair investigation should be.. ganyan ang gusto kong comment.. confined to baraks lang dahil pending investigation pa.. not suspended immediately dahil wala pa yung final verdict.. nasa hearing officer kung ang findings nya ay removal from the service..at pwede pa silang mag appeal.. dapat masunod ang due process…

  • Mel

    I find it disturbing that all suspects die every time the PNP steps in.

    • ever green

      That’s why its PNP — Patay Ng Patay!!!!!

      • Kairosphil

        Generalization! Marantan lang po… 40 people na daw un nadale everytime he steps in.. PNP is not Marantan!

    • Kairosphil

      Generalization! Marantan lang po… 40 people na daw un nadale everytime he steps in.. PNP is not Marantan!

  • Rovingmoron

    That’s right. No mistah, mistah dito sa problemang ito. The PNP should be fair and square in this investigation.

  • Atawid

    Ma check kaya ang mga clientele (patients) ni Dr. Dela Pena, bka mostly shady backgrounds or mga tinamaan ng bala. Maraming pera kc pag shady lives ang patients

  • XY ZEE

    A classic rubout worthy as successor to the Kuratong Baleleng Massacre.
    Great job Marantan, you a now a worthy understudy of Dumlao’s criminal ways. 

  • julieboy

    Complete disregard of the law,what money and power can do to a person.No regard for life and completely embarrassing the whole government,the PNP and the military.It seems the PNP and military organization including the government has lost control of its people.That is really scary wherein they can just kill you and come up with all kinds of bullshit. Pres.Noy do something drastic,you dont deserve having people like this with guns in your organization.A complete overhaul is in order on all personnel that have to do with our nations security.I hope it happens soon before more people are killed.

  • noynoyingalways

    Hansel Marantan YARI ka na! sige sa mga kalokohan nyo huli!

  • JV Velarde

    “I can swear to my God that it was not a rubout,” Marantan said.
    Did your God agree when you had an OFW father together with her daughter killed in Paranaque?
    Which Lord are you referring? Drug Lord or Jueteng Lord?Sarap ba diyan sa St. Lukes? Sinong Lord ang may sagot syo diyan?

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/4HFSI7JVVSU3GNKRU72Z2HPWXU Jen

      it was the OFWs time… God called him and his daughter, unfortunately naging collateral damage sila… God continue to save the policeman for a purpose.. kahit itapon pa yan sa buwan kung talagang gagamitin ng Diyos.. wala tayong magagawa.. sino bang tao ang walang kasalanan..less evil prevails.

      • Kairosphil

        Sinong diyos sinasabi mo Jen?

      • banditpogi

        God??? What God???

      • JV Velarde

        Madaling sabihin kasi hinde naman tayo yun namatayan at naulila ng ama at kapatid… Napakahirap kaya para sa mga naulila yun isipin na sa matagal na panahon mong hinde nakasama yun taong nag-sasakrupisyo at hahanapbuhay sa ibang bansa para mabigyan ng magandang kinabukasan ang pamilya ninyo at nag-babakasyon sa Pinas dahil sa pangungulila at muling mayakap ang pamilyang minsan lang sa isang taon niya makakasama.

        Tapos dahil sa kalabisan ng dahas ng isang pulis para pumatay ng taong nagkakasala sa lipunan, tatanggapin na lang natin na normal ang laging may madadamay na inosenteng tao.

        Wala sanang nadadamay na inosenteng tao kung ang kapulisan ay laging nag-iisip ng tama at marunong mag-ingat ng buhay lalung-lalu na yun mga taong walang kinalaman sa mga krimen.

        Ang masakit pa kasi nito, ang madalas na nakakapatay ng mga inosente sa mga ganitong sitwasyon o barilan sa pagitan ng pulis at mga kriminal ay yun pang pulis na dapat magpro-protekta sana sa kanila.

  • JV Velarde

    “I can swear to my God that it was not a rubout,” Marantan said.

    Did your God agree when you had an OFW father together with her daughter killed in Paranaque?

    Which Lord are you referring? Drug Lord or Jueteng Lord? Sarap ba diyan sa St. Lukes?

    Sinong Lord ang may sagot syo diyan?

    • speaksoftlylove

      I don’t know why the newspapers headline this issue whether rubout or shootout. The meaning of rubout is the elimination of a “rival gang,” The group of Sicam is not a rival gang, they were not even criminals like the dreaded Kuratong Baleleng robbery group. They were Sicam, drivers, police officers, military escorts, and civilians. So, to this extent, Marantan is correct that it was not a rubout. It was not also a shootout proven by the result of PNP fact finding report team. So what is it? It is simply multiple murders or massacre, that’s all it is.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/4HFSI7JVVSU3GNKRU72Z2HPWXU Jen

      God save him.. for a purpose, marami pang katulad ni siman ang nagkalat dyan.. 

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/P4PIU2AIGVXJNQ4UBH5X64MSFE mr

        sino ang isisave ng lord nya, si marantan at dumlao, eh parehong tropa ng demonyo?

      • batangpaslit

        paano mo nalaman na tropa ng demonyo sina Dumlao at Col Maratrat?
        are they engaged in Jueteng too? in kidnapping for ransom? in bank robberies? in gun-for-hire activities?

      • batangpaslit

        am inclined to believe you, Jen

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/P4PIU2AIGVXJNQ4UBH5X64MSFE mr

      Tatlo lord nyan at kasama na si Satanas sa drug at jueteng lord ni Marantan. Sanay na sanay na pala sa pagambush ng mga kalaban at pati mga civilian talagang pinapatay para walang testigo. Sino kaya nagbabayad ng kanyang hospital bill sa St. Luke at sa exclusive na room pa sya? Bat di sa V Luna dalhin o PGH na government hospital? Saka sino kaya backer nito sa Senado at kada tira nya sa shoot out eh napropromote lagi? Baka maging heneral na to pagkatapos ng imbestigasyon ng huling kaso, kasama si Dumlao.

  • glg_ph

    “mayor joven hidalgo…denied involvement in jueteng and gunrunning” ito ung rason bakit kailangan extra judicial na lang sa mga sindikato, sobrang yaman na nila they can hire the best lawyers and pay the police and military to escort them. they can corrupt journalist to twist the news. on the other hand, dapat di si marantan ang gumawa nito, sobrang katangahan naman ung nagyari,

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/SRZX4KS3LXYDDQZNLW464YQG3I Rodel

      tapos pag malapit nang ma convict tatakas sa nearby countries na di kailangan ang visa. Oo nga naman ang pera sobrang gamit sa kasamaan dito sa Pinas at garapal ang palitan among politicians, military at kasama ang mga corrupt journalists, tama ka diyan.

    • batangpaslit

      agree ako sa extra judicial acts against the confirmed economic saboteurs

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/2DG3R2AAQZDON2KH45T3YC5DOA del pillar

    WHAT EVER THE RESULTS OF THIS INCIDENT, LIKE ANY OTHER INCIDENTS THAT UNTIL NOW REMAIN UNSOLVED, THIS ADAGE SHOULD BE A GREAT REMINDER, IT RUNS THUS: “CRIME DOES NOT PAY”!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • pinoypower

      Maybe crime does not pay but Jueteng Lord Pays!!!

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/ME73SJ2KNVTMNU4JMRMRLRYPVQ zom

    ang eengot dn ng mga investigators e. e di kasuhan niyo ng obstruction of justice yung duktor na ayaw ibigay yung slug! zzzzzzzzzz

    • http://www.facebook.com/gerry.mendez.923 Gerry Mendez

       hindi nila kasohan yan. Mayaman yan.  Yung mahihirap lang ang may kaso nito.  Hindi sila engot, wise sila

    • stilettoL2

       wala pa po kasing kasong isinasampa kundi recommendation pa lang kaya di mo mapipilt yong doktor, kung may kaso na pwede ng i subpoena yan. kung ibigay nya yong bala at mapunta sa di mabubuting kamay di may pananagutan din sya, kaya di tayo segurado kung mabuti ba o masama ang intensyon nya.

  • Mel

    It obviously is a rub out/ambush made to look legit in order to cater to personal interests. 

  • Rovingmoron

    Just surprised that the director of the St. Luke’s Medical Center has refused to turn over the slugs taken from Marantan’s wounds. I’m not so sure if he’s aware that the court will seek the turn over of those slugs once the appropriate criminal charges against those involved in the alleged Atinoman shootout are filed before the court. Whether St. Luke’s Hospital like it or not, it has to surrender the slugs just the same.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/4HFSI7JVVSU3GNKRU72Z2HPWXU Jen

      he will submit in the proper time..sigurista yan..baka palitan yan ng ibang bullet at maging bullet ng kanyon… alisin muna ang anesthesia sa katawan para walang makalimutan na sasabihin sa investigation.. iba ang statement ng traumatic pare coy…

      • batangpaslit

        doctor ka, Jen?

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/4HFSI7JVVSU3GNKRU72Z2HPWXU Jen

        ha ha… doctor lang ba ang me pagiisip ng ganyan… i’m not a doctor, i’m not a lawyer, i’m not the way you think.. im just an ordinary person who obey the laws of the land…

    • batangpaslit

      paano kung lumusot ang bala? tumagos ba? di, walang slugs

  • Janch

    “They said Dr. Arturo de la Peña, director of St. Luke’s Medical Center, refused to turn over to the investigating committee the slugs recovered from Marantan.”
    Charge this doctor too.  He has no right to withhold those pieces of evidence.  Why is he obstructing the investigation?

    • batangpaslit

      merong court order ba to collect the slug

      • Janch

        Hindi na kailangan. May imbestigasyon ang mga pulis sa barilan. Kailangan ng doktor i-surrender yung ebidensya kapag hiningi sa kanya ng mga pulis kahit pa walang pahintulot ni Marantan. Kung hindi pwede siyang kasuhan ng obstruction of justice.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/4HFSI7JVVSU3GNKRU72Z2HPWXU Jen

    less evil prevails… kanya kanya tayong pag iisip pare coy.. 

    • batangpaslit

      yup…buti nga mabawasan ang mga economic saboteurs

  • $41083759

    Hanggang sa Chief Superintendent (Melad) at Superintendednt (Marantan) level lang kaya yan? Sa lakas ng loob nila sure ako at si Ate Vi na may mataas na ranking militar pa ang involved. Abangan pa ang mga kakanta…handa awit…
    Baka maunahan ng salvage.

    • boldyak

      marantan is an intelligence agent of PAOCC…they are not under the PNP, guess who directly supervise them?…hmmmm…research if you still don’t know…

  • kawatancila

    kung d nag paputok ang grupo ng mga 13 na napatay, e sino kaya ang naka baril kay marantan, so kapwa nya police o kasamahan na army ang naka tama sa kanya, e presinta mo mr marantan ang slugs at e kumpara sa mga baril na nakuha sa mga napatay, ballistic exam will be done, 
         malas naman ng team leader siya pa itong na tamaan sa crossfire ,ng mga bala ng mga kasama nya… mag basa kayo ng mga crime scene investigations, bihira ang makikita na may hawak pang baril bago malagutan ng hininga, d na uso yung papahawak sa mga napatay ang baril para mag mukhang siya ay humawak at nag paputok ng baril, 
        bakit kaya d agad dumating ang crime scene investigator, tapos d pa sila agad nag imbestiga inantay pa ata ang hepe nila… cguro d nila alam procedure ng pag imbestiga.?.. 
        masarap maging tanga minsan… mahirap ayusin ang scene ng krimen, tiyak me makalimutan kang ayusin, cguro , walang perfect crime… maaring sa una perfect pero sa huli may makikitang butas… subukan mong gawin star witness ang isa sa mga involved at isa sa witness protection program.. pero d na ata kailangan ang witness … evidence will surely tell .. what actually happen…hindi mo pwedeng pag tugmain ang statements ng mga nag sisinungaling … pero pag totoo ang sasabihn mong nangyari d na kailangan pang mag usap usap kau para sabihin kung alin talaga ang nangyari… 
         lalabas na ang mga abogado de kampanilya ngayon… ng mga akusado… dami naman nilang pera eh,,,, kawawa yung mga alalay lang.. na sumama sa operation na ang alam ay lihitimong operation ang gagawin… sabit sabit na lahat… 
       kawawang mga alagad… na walang pang piyansa o pang abogado…

  • virgoyap

    There’s something suspicious when the doctor of St Luke’s hospital refused to hand over the bullet slug taken from Marantan to the investigators.

    • http://www.facebook.com/gerry.mendez.923 Gerry Mendez

       Ano ba mayroon diyan sa St. Lukes na halos lahat ng mga suspect sa high profile crimes nandiyan

      • Magsasaka

         nandon ang mga doctor politician

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/SRZX4KS3LXYDDQZNLW464YQG3I Rodel

         siempre yang hospital na yan ay mahal at yung lang mga ma influential at mayayaman na leader nang mga syndikato ang makakaafford. parang isang empleyado yang nang mga malaking corporation na may medical benefits din. Sa Batangas at Quezon pa na pugad nang mga sasari saring kasamaan like smuggling, jueteng, guns for hire group, bank holduppers etc. Ala eh isang lambanog na pandak lang ang buhay nang tao diyan tulad sa San Juan Batangas hehehe…..

      • Garo Ungaro

        St.Lukes Hospital is accredited Medical Hospital,  recognized by International medical standards…cases like bullet wounds/trauma is automatically reported to the police…and documented as crime evidence. This should not happen.As this will be grounds for litigations…later on. True, it’s expensive because of the high medical standard.

      • http://Yahoo.com/ Ragdeleafar

        In St. Lukes the have the best Doctors of all trade!!!!

    • $14141131

      That is obstruction of justice. The doctor must be made to explain why the refusal. Threat or coercion could be behind the uncooperative doctor. 

    • Jesuit13

      Old story  .. The doctor was bought ..Plain and simple …   Marantan controls jueteng in the Southern tagalog area. Money is no object ..

  • Michael

    thats right, dapat merong cctv cam at handy cam pag may checkpoint, ma luzon visayas or mindanao na pnp dapat every operation specially raid and checkpointss, dapat mag dala ng camera for auditing, no camera means illegal ang operation.. calling alll lawmakers pls. provide a law for this para malinisan na ang pnp .  kawawa naman yong ibang toto-ong PULIS!!!! 

  • katabay1106

    This was an ambush and the excessive force used is evidence that the killers intention was to kill everyone in the vehicles. In other words, the victims were murdered in cold blood.

  • Jesuit13

    At least this story seems to come from a reporter who is reporting from facts. The other reporter .. named Maricar Cinco has somewhat slanted tocover up for  Marantan and the massacre.

  • TEAM PNOY

    Let us put it this way, both groups – siman and marantan groups – are all involved in a gang war. Both are gun-for-hire groups. The atimonan 13 got killed because marantan is one step ahead of siman. Marantan was able to get the army special forces with them. Marantan is able to hide his activities under the cover of a legitimate government operation. utakan lang yan.

    Marantan was a target of 6 assassins hired by siman in laguna, but being marantan, his group was able to kill the 6 assassins instead. He had to finish siman.

    Somebody sold the siman group out – the informer/s. They give actual and real time wherabouts of the siman group to marantan. The one peso question here is “Could the informer/s be riding on the third vehicle that easily got away?” The gold dealer in cam sur has a lot of explaining to do.

    CELLPHONE forensics can do the trick here. I do not need to elaborate on this one.

    Una unahan lang yan. Matira ang matibay. Pareho pareho silang mga criminal. If you think that with the fall of the siman group, jeuteng will stop. NO! up to this date jeuteng is very much alive. Go and bet for yourself in CALBARZON. kaliwa’t kanan ang mga bookies dyan now.

    On thing is for sure, malacanang, dilg, pnp top are not in control. TUWID NA DAAN with CHECKPOINT is deadly!

    • m1600

      good point pareparehas lang sila pero ang problema jan kung may madadamay na hindi naman kasama sa grupo other thing use of excessive force  in not necessary unless na mga salot na NPA yan.

      • batangpaslit

        pag dating sa barilan Bro hindi issue ang “excessive force”
        when U.S.A. invaded Iraq, was excessive force a question?
        in war or even in small scale firefight handa ka na makipagratratan
        ubosan ng lahi

        madamay talaga ang mga police at sundalo na nag moonlight as bodyguards sa Jueteng Lord, pati ang gustong makipag negosyo sa kanila

    • batangpaslit

      galing ni Gurl
      very intelligent
      out of the loop na kasi ako eh…walang nang mahagilap masyado na tsismis
      spill more beans Gurl.
      parang action movie ikaw mag narrate eh
      fast, intriguing, and informative
      suerte ng maging bf mo or employer dahil you are an excellent resource woman
      hehehe…

  • banditpogi

    Ilang beses na nga naman niyang ginawa yung ganoon nakakalusot naman.  May matching medal pa ibinigay sa effort niya.  Sino ba naman ang magaakalang mabubuking at ilalaglag siya sa latest exploit niya.

    Baka nga nagpantasya na siya pumirma nang movie contract sa Viva.  Sino kaya mag portray sa true-to-life story niya???  Si Rudy F patay na at hindi bagay.  Si Redford White siguro bagay kasi tragic-comedy latest exploit ni Maratrat.

    • stilettoL2

       Ang alam ko patay na rin po si Redford White.

    • http://Yahoo.com/ Ragdeleafar

      Lito Lapid o kaya Bong Revilla o kay Tito Sotto buhay pa pwede???

      • banditpogi

        Oo brod swak na swak si Bobong Revilla, Dinggoy Estrada, Nalilitong Lapid at Sotto sa true-to-life story ni Maratrat. 

        Pero sana di na rin magtagal buhay nila at kunin na ni Lord ASAP.  Kawawa naman bansa natin kung matagal pa mamamayagpag sa kakapalan mukha ang mga ito. Isama mo na rin Lord si Enrile, Lacson at Honasan.

  • lostsoul808

    pag magmamatigas yang director ng hospital St. Lukes sabit sya…

    • TEAM PNOY

      Nah, they have the best lawyers that money can buy!

      • kismaytami

        No need to pay expensive lawyers if you can have judges a dime a dozen.

    • batangpaslit

      Bro, kamag-anak mo si General? the new CoS, AFP?

  • Albert Einstien

    panahon ng pnoy admin…Wala na GANGNAM REPUBLIC na tayo ngayon……ky nga milyones na MIGRANTE at OFW  ang tumatakas sa kahirapan, kriminalidad  at  walang hiyaan ng mga opisyal dito e …grabe!

    • stilettoL2

       Naman! Matagal ng panahon na ganyan ang Pilipinas. Kelan ka ba ipinanganak ngayon lang sa panahon ni Pnoy?

      • Jeff Clint

        Baka nga kapapanganak lang kay Albert, kasi mali nga ang spelling ng apelyedo. 
        Genius ka rin ba? Just curious. 

      • Albert Einstien

        ·        my lonely friend…before you JUDGE a person..sir..please try to EDUCATE yourself first…
        RULES: Usernames or pseudonyms based on another person’s identity, publicly known or otherwise, living or dead..are PROHIBITED!
        SOLUTION: IDEM SONANS….sound like or mis-spelling is ALLOWED…besides there is already a user account einstein…
        hope that i contributed a lot to your EDUCATION…. : > )

    • Nagagalitna

      Sobrang galit mo kay Pinoy ah…apo ka ba ni Glorya kaya now mo lng alam na madami ang umaalis na pinoy sa bansa natin?

      • Albert Einstien

        nge…..je je… galit ba pag sasabihin yun katotohanan…nasa news ….lagi na kasi bad news…..di kb naaawa sa bansa……REALIDAD po yan e…yellow zombie lang ky ang walang sariling isip……lol

    • sk3tk

       HAHA. mas may GRAGRABE pa ba sa PANDAK mong PRESIDENTE??? haha.

  • TEAM PNOY

    According to a reliable source from St. Crooks: Dr. Arturo Dela pena is cooking the evidence right now. Once the evidence is cooked, he will present the bullets. That is one hell of a world class HOSPITAL.

    • Kairosphil

      moneyyyyyy!

    • batangpaslit

      paano ma “cooked”
      naka kuha ba sila ng baril na galing sa mga patay sa SUV?
      ang grooved ng slug, paano ma pa match?

      • boldyak

        sigradong matched yon sa baril ni marantan…lol…hanggang ngayon di mo pa kuha ang scenario….lol

      • batangpaslit

        Bro, the theory advanced kasi, ay:
        Col Maratrat shot himself
        or, perhaps one of the troops did it.

        assuming that the theory is right that the gunshot wound is self-inflicted, to make it credible that his bullet wound was caused by his adversary, the bullet must be coming from one of the six guns found from SUV.

        madali gawin ang documents to look old, dahil papel lang. pero the matching of the groove of the expelled bullet and the mark of the firing pin of the spent shell is no easy matter—if it is a self inflicted wound
        maliban na lamang kung ang baril na ginamit sa pagbaril sa kanya ay na plant sa mga napatay.

        pero kung hindi drama ang tama ng bala sa kanya, two gunshot wounds pa, his case is defensible that his troops was compelled to open fire again to finish them off

      • banditpogi

        One way to literally cook the evidence is to microwave the bullet until the slug melts and, presto, wala na markings para wala nang match sa mga baril na ginamit.

        At least hindi na mapatunayan sa baril ni Maratrat nanggaling yung slug.

  • PepingCo

    How can Marantan afford to be confined at St. Luke’s Global City? Can’t PGH or VMMC handle his wounds? At saka mahirap ba kumuha ng subpoena para sa medical records and gun slugs niya so the whole nation can know the truth? Someone is deliberately buying time to get the truth out.

    • batangpaslit

      merong financier eh….ikaw, Bro, may tama ka nang baril and you can afford naman to get the best treatment, papasok ka ba sa free ward ng PGH o sa Veteran’s Hospital?

    • http://Yahoo.com/ Ragdeleafar

      Sa St. Luke’s ang Doctor pwedeng magdoctor ‘ITPIR’. Reject to  submit the slug recovered from the wound(s) of Marantan, waiting for the right time for switching of slug(s)? The longer the delay the better…same principle  ” Justice delayed justice denied” just-tiis na lang muna!

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/74DX67S5U6H557SPUXS5XZ6QJI Alisto Juan

      Maraming pera Bro at mababayaran ang mga doctor. . pueding gumawa ng sakit ang walang sakit

  • circe anice salazar

    heto ang unsolicited scenario ko: nagkainitan sa checkpoint. si Marantan, ang dakilang ground commander ay bumunot ng baril. trigger finger in. nabaril ang sariling paa. ang mga PO1 na nerbyoso, dahil nakarinig ng putok ay nag-open fire. ambango ng amoy ng pulbura. (weeh, di nga!)

    • batangpaslit

      hehehe…sine na madrama, eh

  • DannyGane

    Supt. Marantan hit in arm and foot. Bakit di sa ulo o sa katawan??? hehehe. Director of St. Luke should be held in contempt…

  • wakats

    It’s official: PNP fact-finding investigation report says NO SHOOTOUT, possibly rubout.

    Sources in the PNP have told the PDI that the Atimonan massacre was triggered by a turf war between two rival jueteng operators – similar to the 1929 Chicago St. Valentine’s day massacre where 7 mobsters were lined up and machine gunned by a rival group led by Al Capone (no relation to hansel marantan).

    Criminal and administrative charges were recommended to be filed against the PNP and army personnel who participated in the ambush-slaying, including many top PNP officials in the region.

    TO PNOY AND DAANG-MATUWID = NO WHITEWASH PLEASE… 

  • FernandoBusi

    Jueteng money on the move … ang tanong kaninong bulsa to na punta. Malabo nman cgurong si Mike Arroyo pa pagbibintangan this time around. 

    • Jeff Clint

      Nai-deliver na yun kay Rico Puno.

  • sk3tk

    St. Luke sets a new standard in nurturing CROOKS.. (“,)

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/74DX67S5U6H557SPUXS5XZ6QJI Alisto Juan

      St Crooks Hospital na. . bwa. .  ….

  • batangpaslit

    ganun ba?
    close range eh, sinugurong matodas talaga

    dapat di na nila ginalaw pagka baril
    eh ano kung nakasabit pa sa holster ang baril ng gun for hire na bodyguard ng Jueteng Lord?
    bakit pag sila ba ay nakipag enkuentro, are they going to wait for the adversary to draw their gun before firing?
    ang masabi ko, the policemen and the soldiers who were moonlighting as bodyguards were never trained as bodyguards
    otherwise,, naka patas sila kahit isang patay sa grupo ni Col Maratrat kung bodyguards sila

  • batangpaslit

    magaling umilag ng bala eh
    paano maka baril ng husto ang sa loob ng sasakyan parang sardinas

    • banditpogi

       Isang blunder pa ni Maratrat yon.  Sana pinalabas muna niya sa sasakyan, dinis-armahan, saka niratrat para mas madaling gawan nang kapanipaniwalang kwentong kutsero.

  • calixto909

    Withholding of the slug by de la pena is obstruction of justice or it isn’t? What’s missing in the PNP report is the paraffin test on the victims to ascertain if they had fired their guns or not? 3 days is the expiry date of a paraffin test and the investigating team was at the crime scene barely 4 hours after the gun battle so the test is absolutely in schedule. Without the result of the paraffin test, a very vital evidence, this PNP report is half baked, inconclusive.

    • wakats

      The PNP has conducted the paraffin tests, etc., almost immediately, as reported.  The NBI got involved in earnest on Wednesday, Janaury 9, or 4 days after the rubout, per order of Sec. de Lima. 

    • banditpogi

       Malamang may nakapagpaputok din sa mga nakasakay sa SUV dahil instinct na nga naman na kapag pinaputukan ka mag return fire ka rin. 

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_VY25ZOHU3FJFFX6CYSH5W4AX3I sugbu

    Sana iyong hard copy ng PNP fact finding report ay isaksak sa baga nitong Maratrat na ito….busalan.

  • Jeff Clint

    Maratrat.tatatatatat. Magpagaling kang mabuti dahil ang sunod mong misyon ay sina Espino at Pineda kabilang ang kanilang mga protector. Kailangan planohin mong mabuti, mas malalaking isda ang mga ito in comparison to Siman. Good luck boy!!!

    • wakats

      Dapat ang next mission nya ay “Oplan Ecleo.”  Tingnan natin kung makakalabas sya ng buhay sa Dinagat Island. 

  • batangpaslit

    tama….if Col Maratrat is disowned, eh di, survival of the fittest na

  • NoWorryBHappy

    If this was a TURF WAR between 2 rival Jueteng Lords, who is the other
    Jueteng Lord that Marantan’s group is PROTECTING ?

  • mari suli

    tingnan mo si dumlao,dati ng may kaso kinupkop pa ng pamahalaan.kaya tuloy balik sa dating gawi.hay pinas talaga.

    • banditpogi

       Naka pwesto pa kasi yung amo niyang si Ping. 

  • pinoypower

    St. Luke’s is fast gaining the reputation as the hospital for the rich and famous and notorious. Marantan would have gain more sympathy if he was in a PNP, AFP or other government hospital.
    He is now a hot potato that no one wants to handle or be associated with. With due process, the truth will come out over the Atimonan shootout and other pending cases where he was involved because his mask of impunity has been unveiled.

  • noli chu

    Kaya ayaw ipakita ng st lukes…kasi wala atang bala at walang tama ng baril… Benda lang ,,,, hahahhaha..Alam nyo ba kung anong susunod na eksena….

    “THE WHEELCHAIR STRATEGY”

    • kismaytami

      Hindi pa naman nakaupo sa wheelchair eh, so “the st. lukes” strategy muna.

    • banditpogi

       Pwede din “emergency triple hurt bypass”.  Kasi masyado daw na HURT si Maratrat sa mga napapanood at nababasa sa news!!!

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/X2U4X42BZTUHPWMP2UKFP5QWMU LucasPacascas

    Bingo ka na Kernel Marantan. Kung nakalusot ka dun sa tatlong checkpoint encounter na story-telling-a-lie mo, dito swak ka sa balde. Ang dami mong idinamay. Yung mga Hepe mo, yung mga sundalong nananahimik sa Candelaria, Quezon masisira ang career dahil sa katarantaduhan mo.
    Magpagaling ka Kernel. Maraming asunto ang naghihintay sa iyo.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/G2UFL7BAIFFUU6TIW4FFAPTVV4 Ghost

    Labing tatlo ang napatay ng marahas, at ang major suspect refused to submit himself for physical examination.

    Pwede pala yun. Lokohan na to.
    .

    • Magsasaka

      wala na kasi syang lusot kapag nasalang sya pati bala na tumama sa kanya ayaw ibigay ng doctor na mukhang perang kakutsaba nya, dapat tangalan din ng lisensya ang doctor kwak kwak na yon

    • banditpogi

       Ngayon ko nga lang nalaman na pwede pala yon.  Only in da Philippines, ika nga.

  • kismaytami

    Huwag na tayong magtaka kung ma-promote pa itong mokong na ito, marami pa yang papatayin, yung mga tipong walang kalaban-laban.

    • batangpaslit

      Bro, not exactly walang kalaban-laban
      the bodyguards are elements from the military establishment and from the police command
      naunahan lang sila

      • banditpogi

        13 katao nakasiksik sa loob nang dalawang sasakyan.  40+ yung mga assailant naka porma at nakatutok mga baril sa kanila.  Palagay ko nga pwede sabihin wala sila kalaban laban sa situwasyon na yon.

      • kismaytami

        LOL! Paano yung mag-amang nadamay sa isa sa mga ‘shootout’ kuno nitong mokong na ito?

        And guess what, may latest na revelation yung mga testigo, hands-up na pala yung environmentalist pero binistay pa rin ng bala.

  • $16638896

     The trajectories of the bullets that hit the vehicles showed that the
    shots were fired from different directions and at different angles,
    including from elevated positions, they said.-AMBUSH!

  • Edward Castro

    di talaga pwedeng i whitewash dahil sa preponderance of inconsistencies sa mga sinasabi nila at crime scene.  legitimate daw ang operation kaso illegitimate ang “execution”.

  • koolkid_inthehouse

    A bigger fish is behind the massacre. 
    Marantan shoots himself, look at the wounds its on a left arm and on his knees. 
    He’s trying to fool his superiors or the superiors already expected it to happen.

    Imagine shooting yourself intentionally, to justify a massacre into a shoot out.  There must be a big lord/protector for Marantan.  This is not an ordinary massacre.  This is big time turf war.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/74DX67S5U6H557SPUXS5XZ6QJI Alisto Juan

      Siguro, malapit sa kanya dahil tinaya n’ya ang buhay at career. Kapatid, kabit, kaibigang matalik. . KKK rin. . . bwa. .  ..

    • batangpaslit

      how big do you think is the “big lord/protector”?
      a government official with a rank of a Cabinet Secretary?
      or
      a Kamag-anak?

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/7FDDNRT65UQX2MA463JWDZZRMA drifter

         puede!

  • disqusted0fu

    How will the administration twist this horrible incident involving dirty money, illegal gambling, mass murders with the participation of law enforcers, and unauthorized operations happening out right in their supposed straight path government?

    • muddygoose

      If this were the previous administration or any other admin before that, you would not be reading the investigation results above.

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/7FDDNRT65UQX2MA463JWDZZRMA drifter

        Of course, kung previous admin ito .. mas maayos yung cover up and no one will suspect much. Ngayon kase, ang mga nagcocover-up nde alam ang gagawin lol. Pathetic!

      • muddygoose

        So you appreciate leaders for their craftiness in committing crimes? I prefer a government that investigates and solves them.

      • disqusted0fu

        But we are in the present aren’t we? Bringing up the past doesn’t have anything to do with this. This is a current issue that at present have to be resolved, regardless of who the current administration is.

      • muddygoose

        Let’s be honest to ourselves, you’re the one who wanted to politicize the discussion. Just lay it down and tell us how you still m-bate to the thought of Gibo or Mikey running this country.

  • INQ415

    he shot himself to get a medal and a promotion. the higher up he goes the more blunder he makes. he’ll get his ladder pulled out from under him soon enough and he’ll be in the same situation.

    its already doubtful as to what happened and shooting yourself makes you look like a complete idiot. why the arm and foot? why not the body? its an easier target for “stray” bullets.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/74DX67S5U6H557SPUXS5XZ6QJI Alisto Juan

    Walang bagong report? Nag re-enactment na si Sec. De Lima sa site at ang sagot sa mga reporters ay rub-out, nakaputok pa nga yung sa loob ng SUV pero walang ng silbe dahil may tama na at instinct reaction na lang yun sa namamatay dahil mga sundalo yun, may training. Yun mga tama sa ulo, sinegurado na wala ng magsalita pa. . Kawawa yung mga Army dahil damay sa kabalastugan ng mga opisyals. .

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_VY25ZOHU3FJFFX6CYSH5W4AX3I sugbu

    Hindi naman kasing lalim ang bulsa ni Maratrat kaysa doon kay Little Girl ? Malamang ililipat ito sa V.Luna either with posas or wheelchair…or both blingblings.
    Tandaan mo Maratrat,hindi pa sapat iyan sa mga buhay na inutang mo !!!

  • Martin Rademakers

    219 bullets for 13 guys…..what do you say to the wife’s and kids of those murdered. All shot in the head after the fact to make sure no witness.    Marantan was most likely shot by one of his own men or even shot himself during the ambush.

  • Cerise David

    Papano na yan, eh nakalagay sa sworn affidavits ng mga AFP, legitimate encounter daw at justified use of force kasi nagkaroon daw ng shootout?

    • batangpaslit

      di, four way shootout
      NBI versus PNP versus Malacanang versus Army

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3TWVIBNBHJIBKXLUC5IT2JYM5E Harry

    Is the government spending so much for an injured superintendent in a top private hospital when PGH should be able to handle injured soldiers?

    If he is spending personally for such costly medical attention then a background check maybe necessary.

  • noelpogi

    Maski ano shoot-out, rub-out, ambush o overkill, iisa ang pinagaawayan. JUETENG. wala ng iba.

    • batangpaslit

      tumpak

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_AUHY7NAKYRSA2T24MJ5P7EAA6U junteddy m

    tsk, tsk..Maguindanao Massacre in the making, I hope Maratrat faces the same fate the Ampatuans are facing now..

  • caloyski65

    yan ST. LUKES hospital na yan eh sikat na hospital dahil yun mga taong gaya ni GMA at yan si MARANTAN at iba pang mga sikat na personalidad na may kaso eh dyan nag sa hospital na yan nag papa confine at dahil “hospital friendly” ang ST. LUKES….palalabasin nila na kesyo grabe ang sakit nun tao para di maka attend ng mga hearing…..o yun bala na tumama kuno kay MARANTAN eh ayaw i bigay sa mga imbestigador para masuri….mukhang wala naman yatang bala talaga…..kaya sa mga kriminal o corrupt na govt official….eh welcome na welcome sa ST. LUKES. 

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/YYEV67ZUX5B75YGHM7CZUWGSAY renea

    Before the first picture of Marantan left leg(tibfib) shows leg brace when according to x-ray the upper leg(femur) shows fracture from the bullet. Now look no more support on either lower or upper leg only in the knee. Femur fracture should be taken seriously because of major arteries and veins underlying it, seems that nothing happen to this guy thigh, ?????.

    • batangpaslit

      himala eh…gumaling agad
      hahaha…

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_WYX4ZTAV4BUGW2RIMT45CPYBGA Pio Gante

    that has been my conclusion from the very beginning when the news came out and this incident brings to spotlight which makes it equally doubtful all the encounters between lawmen and suspected criminals in deserted areas in the middle of the night.

    in all fake encounters there’s always someone who got away but they are not criminals but cops themselves who are called ‘tagabuhos’ and ‘taga-ayos’ or they might be the ones who fired the first shots to lure the roadblock people to use  ‘calibrated force’, that’s why there’s a possibility that the story about the 3rd suv is true. whoever are those in that vehicle i’m sure, are just lurking around r2.

    • batangpaslit

      baka sila ang may bitbit ng one-half of half billion pesos na baon ng three car convoy. sila din ang nag bigay ng lead kung sino ang sakay sa dalawang naunang SUV

  • kawatancila

    hanggat d pa bayad ang hospital bills d pwede e release ang slugs, saka me presyo ang bala,, kc silver bullets ito…pwede din yan gawin pabigat sa bingwit pag tingga . 
         atsaka ang alam ko.. me batas na obligado ang mga hospital na e report ang mga wounds na sanhi ng tama ng baril… kc nga baka mga pugante yan, tapos ginamot mo… ok lang kc propesyun mo yan na manggamot pero me record .

        bayadan na ang hospital bills para ma kuha na ang slugs…kanino kayang baril ang tumama kay super intended marantan . e ballistic exam agad.. baka ma swap pa ng ibang slugs.. saan kaya sila makakahanap ng slugs na galing sa baril ng mga napatay … para ma swap sa inalis ni dr dela pinya.. dr ingatan mo ang slugs… baka madamay ka sa asunto.. ikaw ang nag alis nyan kaya dapat itabi mo yan…174 na tama ng bala sa unang sasakyan.. wow , divide mo sa 6 na pasajero.. mahina ako sa math..  halos tag 30 ang bawat isa … pag equal ang tama nila… say. tag bente sila ang iba tumama sa hangin.. himala na lang na mabuhay ka pa nyan… kahit d mo pa oras mamatay pag kanyan kadami ang tama mo ng bala… tiyak,, mapiplitan si san pedro na kunin kana… no choice ,,, kc sabog ang bunbunan mo eh… hati ang bewang mo pa… 
         parang galit na galit sila sa mga napatay, d talaga sila hahayaan na mabuhay…
        napakahirap ng may threat sa buhay mo… lagi kang naka tingin sa likod mo… dapat me mata ka pa sa likod… baka gantihan ka ng mga kamag anak ng napatay mo..
      e yung ngang walang kaaway e napapatay din e.. kc napagkamalan lang… 
       sakin lang naman .. kuro kuro..d naman gaano masama ang jueteng eh.. d naman pilitan ang pag taya.. madami kc mananaya.. na nag babakasakali na ang pambili ng sansalop e baka maka bili ng isang cavan pag sila ay naka tama…d sa pag maliit, ang mananaya ng jueteng ay karamihan ay mga  mahihirap … ang iba naman nataya ay pag me kursunada laang,, o me pananginip na numero.. 
       ITO ANG SOLUSYUN SA JUETENG..  KC D KAYA NG MGA POLICE HULIHIN ANG ME ARI NG PA JUETENG, E D ANG HULIHIN NA LANG ANG MGA KUBRADOR… PATI ANG MANANAYA… BAWAT MAHULI E PWEDENG MAKULONG O MAG MULTA .. 
       KC NGA D NGA KAYA HULIHIN ANG JUETENG LORD… KC NGA MINSAN … D LANG NAMAN ANG JUETENG LORD ANG ME ARII ME KASOSYO DIN SIYA… NA PARTNER NYA… 
       BAKIT NGA PA D MAPATIGIL ANG JUETENG SA ATING BAYAN.. WHY WHY WHY…
        BASTA ME ILLEGAL .. ME PERA… GAWIN NA KAYANG LEGAL… KC PAG LEGAL NA ..WALA NG PROTECTOR,,, ME INCOME PA SA BUWIS… PERO WAG PONG GAWIN LEGAL ANG DROGA… KC D PO DIN ITO MASUGPO D PO BA… IBA NAMAN ANG DROGA… ANG TAONG NAKA DROGA PUMAPATAY NG ISA O MADAMING TAO.. ANG JUETENG NAMAN AY  PUMAPATAY NG JUETENG LORD… AMEN… WAG PO KAYO MAG REPLY SA COMMENTS KO .. GUMAWA NA LANG KAYO NG COMMENTS NYO.. AT AKING BABASAHIN…  D NA PO USO ANG BATO BATO SA LANGIT… KC PO ANG USO PO AY BALA BALA SA LANGIT… ANG TAMAAN AY MGA PASLIT… GUMAWA PO KAYO NG BATAS NA ANG SINUMAN MAG PAPUTOK NG BARIL SA NEW YEAR AY .. MA BILANGGO NG HABAMBUHAY … SOBRA ATA ANG PARUSA… SUGGEST KO LANG …

    • batangpaslit

      hangga’t di bayad ang hospital at doctor’s fees, no slugs
      ayos ah
      brilliant bargaining move
      hahaha…

  • tukmoldinako

    hindi nyo ba napansin na mapusyaw ang klase ng imbestigasyon na ginawa, ha ha ha ha

    Totoo na walang shoot out na nangyari batay sa tama ng bala sa mga biktima.

    Pero excessive force was not the right word.

    Grupo ni marantan na pulis dagdag mo 20 sundalo ilan sila lahat sa check point 30?

    Kung ganon, anong kalibre ang ginamit dapat binanggit din,
    Sa isang sasakyan 147 ang tama ng sasakyan divided by 30 kataong sundalo, put it at five bullet each was used? that was funny , maybe they uses a caliber 45 at single shots fired. kaya importante na lahat ng slugs ay kinolekta at pina ballistic , para malaman kung ilang baril ang nagamit? Ano ang hawak ng isang sundalo, high powered ba ito, isang clip ilan ang laman?
    Kung 147 di ilan lang ang bumaril kaya napaka halaga ng slugs. 

    Yung report ay nililito na naman ang lahat, sa tama ng mga biktima sa gitna ng mata, ibig sabihin ang mga sasakyan ay kusang tumigil, lumabas yung pinaka mataas para makiusap, pinababa si siman, pinaputukan silang dalawa patay, binalik sa sasakyan sabay pinaputukan lahat lalo na yung driver, ganun lang kasimple.

    kaya ipa ballistic lahat ng slug, at alamin kung ilan ang baril na ginamit.

    kawawa naman yung mga mabababang sundalo na sumusunod lang sa namumuno. pakiwari ko nga dyan me sundalo na di man lang nagamit ang kanyang baril?

    O ayan mag isip kayo at ganda gandahan nyo ang sistema ng imbestigasyon ninyo para naman kapanipaniwala sa lahat

    excessive force, eh kung yung isang clip na bala ay inubos ng lahat na bumaril, LOL

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/4HFSI7JVVSU3GNKRU72Z2HPWXU Jen

    If they did not give any provocation at all for the gunman to fire at
    them then they have to stand their ground to accomplish their mandated task of enforcing the law. A police
    officer however is not required to afford a person attacking him the
    opportunity for a fair or equal struggle; his duty requires him to overcome his
    opponent. The use of weapon is also justified under the Doctrine of Self-Defense
    if the suspect poses imminent danger of causing death or injury to the police officers. There was this justifying circumstance(self-defense)
    because there was an unlawful aggression on the part of the occupants of the suv’s. Thus, the use of force
    was reasonable. they acted in accordance with the Rules Set by the PNP on the Use of Force pursuant to the POP, Rule 8, Section 1, 2, & 3;

     

    • sk3tk

       I suppose you can back up your claims with HARD EVIDENCE!!! You talk about SELF-DEFENSE while all the EVIDENCE speaks OTHERWISE… get your FACTS straight.

      “there is none so BLIND as those who REFUSE to see”…

      • batangpaslit

        good rebuttal

    • RIGGS1220

      Jen, isa lang masasabi ko sayo…ang BOBO mo!

      • banditpogi

        Palagay ko po matalino itong si Jen at hindi bobo.  Yung mga tao na ganoon ang sentiment at reasoning most likely ginagawa lang yung trabaho nila.  Professional itong (as in bayaran) si Jen.

        Hindi kaya siya naka payroll kay Ping Lacson?

      • batangpaslit

        pahingi ng balato ha from Ping’s funds

      • banditpogi

        Saka na daw sir yung balato natin galing sa xmas bonus ni Ping.  Sa ngayon squid tactic mode muna siya para di siya ma link sa gusot ni Dumlao, Melad at Maratrat kaya siya nakisawsaw sa alitan ni Enrile at Santiago.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_AUHY7NAKYRSA2T24MJ5P7EAA6U junteddy m

      there is no unlawful aggression on the part of the victims thus it was a plain and premeditated COLD BLOOD MURDER! tanga!!!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_4R2ECT66ZXHR5BHKGO36OF2XQA Emperador

       Ahahaha.. bilib na ako sa ka tangahan nintong Jen!! idol.. pinoy most stupid person ever.. ahahaha .. may pa english2x pa wala naman laman ang utak.. wag kasi COPY PASTE

    • kawawang_bansa

      there was no shootout, according to the police investigation report…what provocation are you talking about? your statements don’t make sense

    • INQ415

      [insert rubout procedures here]

    • banditpogi

      Sigurado po kayo hindi kayo speechwriter ni Sotto of Tito, Vic and Joey fame???

      • batangpaslit

        hehehe…ganun ba

    • patukar

      Maaring tama ka sa isang banda pero sa isang scenario na ambush ang pangyayari anong justification ng Doctrine of self-defense pwede rin defense pag dating sa korte wag lang sa victoria court baka mangyari nyan maging kangaroo court.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/6DTNBPJJUJCPAJNKUH6PBC7UBE stoneridge

       bakit hindi sila naglagay ng camera para ma justfy ang mga pinagsasabi mo?

    • ryan andres

      shut your face already. wala ka nang naloloko. Lahat ng tao alam na ikaw yung kabit ni Marantado na nagbukas pa ng account para idefend sya.

      • batangpaslit

        hehehe….pahingi ng balato

      • ryan andres

        wala…luki nekosyo… tinangay ng mamang pulpulis yung jueteng money na bitbit nila Siman eh…

      • batangpaslit

        chuckles…
        levity aside, Ryan, hindi mapigil ang jueteng by sheer police work
        ang mga tao mismo ang may gusto eh
        ang compromised solution dian is to legalize it para ang lahat makinabang, hindi lang ang Jueteng Lord at ang kanilang protectors–police, and politicians seating in power.
        problema, marami sa congress at sa law enforcement ang ayaw gawing legal.
        wala nang makunan eh pag legal ang activities.
        sa lugar kong tinitirhan ngaon, lahat ng pasugal ay controlled ng gobyerno.
        forty percent (40%) of the proceeds goes to Medicare.
        kaya pag ako ay nagkasakit, hindi problema ang hospitalization ko dahil covered ako ng Medicare.
        tubong lugaw talaga ang Jueteng.
        every collector gets 10% for every bet. tapos kung may nanalo, sasabihn ng operator, “eh, bossing sampu kayo ang tumaya sa number na ‘yan. so, ang parti mo one-tenth lang”.
        hehehe…
        kung one million ang pot money, the operator makes PhP900,000.00
        bakit alam ko ito?
        kasi
        bago ako lumisan, tumulong ako sa pag organize ng Task Force kontra Jueteng
        when our operatives found out na ang suholan ay lagpas pa sa Chief, PC, sabi ko “Let us disband the Task Force. There is no point to continue this kaungasan”
        kaya when i am reading news about the abolition of Jueteng, i am extremely amused.
        to conclude, i am impressed of your nimble mind, Ryan.
        pero ‘yan ang katotohanan.
        malungkot.
        hindi malipol ang Jueteng kung ang aasahan natin ay ang law enforcement lamang.
        there is a need for social transformation of every Filipinos who are hooked in gambling.
        to my mind, economic sabotage ang illegal gambling.
        nagbabayad ba yan ng tax ang mga Jueteng Lords at ang kanilang respective protectors?
        the old homeland, Philippines, is no longer a place to live in; but, a paradise to be robbed.

      • ryan andres

        tama ka dyan ser. matatanggal ang “middle man” kapag nalegalize eto.

        Ang tanong dyan eh, hanggang saan level ng gobyerno umaabot ang galamay ng mga “middle men” and who stands to lose the most kapag nalegalize nga…?

        Parang ayoko na malaman pa…

    • batangpaslit

      naks ha….well read ikaw ah, Jen

    • $20722540

      kong ikaw nasa isang checkpoint (kuno) at nakita mo na meron 50 police at army na lahat nakatutuk sa iyo ng armalite rifles…iproprovoke mo paba sila ng isang putok, ano ka hilo?  hey, kong anong mag set of rules sinasabi mo…eh yong very basic checkpoint signage and uniform ni hindi nga nasunod, ano pa kaya yong ibang mga rules, duh!!!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_WN5TKEXEJ2VHQVNGP2CJEDLJH4 Jess

    WALANG BINUHAY SA 13 BIKTIMA UPANG WALANG TESTIGO. AYON SA ILAN INFORMANT AY 300 MILYONG PISO ANG DALA NG MGA BIKTIMA. KAYA NGA SIGURO MAY MGA POLICE AT MILITARY ESCORTS. NOW, SAAN ITO GALING AT ASAN NA NGAYON ANG 300 MILYONG PISO NA DALA NILA? PAG GANYANG NAPAAKARAMING PINATAY AY MAHIRAP ITAGO ANG KRIMEN KAHT PA WALANG BINUHAY.KAYA LAHAT NG SANGKOT DYAN DAPAT AY IKULONG NG HABANG BUHAY. KAWAWA DYABN YUNG MGA SUNDALONG ANG RANGGO AY PRIVATE AT YUNG MGA PO1 NA PULIS, SILA MAN AY BIKTIMA RIN NG KANILANG MGA PINUNO. PERO KUNG NAGAHAMAN SILA SA MAKAKAPARTE NILA, DAPAT DIN SILANG IKULONG NG HABANG BUHAY. 

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/6DTNBPJJUJCPAJNKUH6PBC7UBE stoneridge

       at pagkatapos ikulong, ratratin!!!

  • edleon

    Who will pay the bill of this Supt. Marantan sa St. Luke in Global City?  Kung government eh sana naman ilipat sa medyo mura at ngunit maayos din naman na ospital!

    • batangpaslit

      hehehe…
      may pera ang PAOCC
      baka doon kunin ang pambayad sa half-billion pesos na bitbit ng Jueteng Lord

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_AUHY7NAKYRSA2T24MJ5P7EAA6U junteddy m

    mARANTAN ET AL SACRFICED EVERYTHING FOR 3OO MILLION PESOS..WHAT A SHAME..KARMA WILL STRIKE YOU COLONEL MARATRAT, MARK MY WORDS!!! YOU WILL SUFFER WORST THAN YOUR VICTIMS FAMILIES SUFFER!!!

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/VS5EYSP4FPOTVQCJZ24NRE6Z2M Edgardo Mendoza

    nakakawalang tiwala sa atin ang mga kapulisan nakakatakot mga mukang PERA!! mga criminal mga utak pulbura

    • ARIKUTIK

      Ang kapulisan ay under the command of Commander in cheif Boy AB of Malacanang. Nakapag tataka ba kung naging parang mga Abnoy na din sila, shooting at each other ? Dis unity, showbizz and corruption is the mark of Abnoy era. Hidden through persecution of political enemies.

  • uugodugod

    ang atin pang aantayin ay ang ending nito kung anong whitewash ang gagawin

    • batangpaslit

      abangan…

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2RVERYUPGBL4EHNMB2QNIQTFS4 Boying

    Marantan kurakot. BITAYIN!!

  • Your_King

    This is such an embarrassment to the Aquino administration and all their efforts to stop corruption because this is as bad as it gets for corruption and crookedness. This was under the President’s commission and this operation was known by the President and for it to take this tragic turn is horrible. The mistake’s list is a long one for everyone involved. We can just hope the President finally gets a wake up call to wake up and start fixing the problems of the Philippines instead of riding on the wave of his popularity which was generated from his national hero father and mother.

  • alex_diaz2014

    Another circumstantial evidence that Marantan is a crook – he is being treated at St. Luke’s Hospital!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_Q2OTHRY3DREIMJMK4VXT6UIPSA salvation phils

    It is similar to the style of Al Capone as seen on movies. Bad guys against each other for control.
    Money, money, money, and more money.

    • batangpaslit

      pang sine material nga ang nangyari sa Atimonan
      pero sa twist of events, baka mapabalita na si Jueteng Lord ay buhay pala
      hahaha..

  • ARIKUTIK

    Ang driver daw ay may hawak na baril. Akala ko ba ang driver ay in charge sa manibela ? It’s impossible to drive in escape mode while holding a gun. Planted ….planted ….planted guns ….

    • bogli_anakdami

      kc ang drayber eh di naka-seatbelt… against da law yun, di ba?…kaya tinadtad ng tingga…

      • batangpaslit

        ganyan na katindi ang traffic enforcement sa Pilipinas. pag di naka seat belt, natadtad ng bala
        o, diba, effective law?

    • batangpaslit

      Tsong, apat ang kamay ng driver
      hahaha…

  • boldyak

    marantan is an intelligence agent of PAOCC…ano ba meaning ng PAOCC?…who controls them?

    • ARIKUTIK

      PAOCC = P stands for Presidential or in othert words under the control of Penoy. Maratatat insist that the killing operation was Approved by PAOCC. Penoy is the head killer of this fiasco. Impeach Penoy for being a murderous president.  

    • batangpaslit

      sabi ng news item ang Little President, the current Executive Secretary

  • Damaso

    Tama lang maubos ang mga hinayupak na yan.., lahat ng sangkot sa jueteng mamatay na kayo!

    • patukar

      Walang matitira sa kanayonan baka iba dun pinsan mo!

    • Pedro_Gil

      oo isama mo mga protektor gaya ni maratrat at mga kasama niya.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/6DTNBPJJUJCPAJNKUH6PBC7UBE stoneridge

    sino pa kayang maniniwala sa mga kuwento kwento nila ngayong wala ng kredibilidad. me naglagay ng basyo sa loob ng SUV, naglagay ng baril sa mga victim, nawawalang bag na puno ng pera, kinaladkad na biktima palabas, ipinutok na baril ng biktima, ginamit ang mga baril ng biktima sa kamay ng biktima para iputok at magka powder burns, gamitin ang slug ng biktima para kay Manratrat, barilin ng malapitan sa ulo ng biktima, etc., etc. Dapat kasi naglagay na lang ng camera sa pinangyarihan, eh di tapos ang kwento

    • batangpaslit

      drama nga daw, Tsong
      dahil sa mga pa ibang-ibang version ng news account, sa palagay ko buhay si Jueteng Lord
      pinalabas lang na patay na sia para dina habulin ng authorities
      mag palastic surgery and assumed a new identity enjoying the luxuries in life out of his jueteng proceeds
      hehehe…

  • bogli_anakdami

    bwi hi hi hi hi pwi!… hoy mga kabayang flips, sa totoo lang ang mga litrato dito sa PDI tungkol sa atimonan eh lahat eh “photoshoot”…

    sa susunod eh si prez akin’o eh lilitaw doon sa tabi ng butas-butas na SUV na kunyari eh nag-iimbistiga din…

    • batangpaslit

      photoshop?
      hahaha…
      you mean, pati ang balitang ratraratan drama lang?
      buhay si Siman?
      galing nang plot ano? talo ang sine
      hahaha…

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_BL2GYU35SO6HTJUEAUTXS3QFYM George Lapulapu

      nahawa ka yata sa mga paranoid dyan sa america na lahat conspiracy theory…paranoia is sick in the mind….

      • Pedro_Gil

        gunggong ka rin. tahimik ka na lang wala ka kasing tamang edukasyon. 

  • Pluma Mana

    “They said Dr. Arturo de la Peña, director of St. Luke’s Medical Center,
    refused to turn over to the investigating committee the slugs recovered
    from Marantan….”

    ang layo naman ng hospital na pinagdalhan sa kanya…. itong st. luke hospital ay takbuhan ng mga  nagtatago sa batas talaga.

    • bogli_anakdami

      kc, ang st luke’s medical eh considered sanctuary ng mga dimonyo… pag labas sa st lukes’s eh para ka na ring nangumpisal kay padre damaso… your sins are all forgiven… kaya pwede ulit magnakaws, pumatay ng tao, mang-iyot ng kapwa, etchastera, etc… 

      • Pedro_Gil

        Tama ka diyan. diyan lang may bayad ang pangungumpisal kasama din ang proteksiyon. talagang malayo ang st lukes taguig sa pinangyarihan ng massacre. LOL. akala ni gungong gunggong din ang masang Pinoy. hangal kang talaga Maratrat!

    • rouelcalzita

      You are correct…but you forgot to identify among them whom fugitive seek at St. Luke.

    • $20722540

      takbuhan yan ng mga pasyente na mayaman, si maratrat ba mayaman ba?  saan galing ang kanayang kayamanan o baka naman maganda ang kanyang health insurance???  

  • batangpaslit

    i see…
    am no longer familiar kasi sa local laws eh
    dito sa lugar na tinitirhan ko ngaon, automatic kasi na mag report ang medical doctors sa police authorities kung ang na admit sa facilities nila ay gunshot wound, blade, or blunt weapons
    interesting case, extremely interesting story

  • http://www.yellowmythbusters.gov.ph/ Weder-Weder Lang

    Marantan is a rightee. His self-inflicted injuries are on the left arm and left leg. In the GMA7 interview conducted by Sandra Aguinaldo, Marantan kept gesticulating with his right arm. Nicotine stains can be seen between his right index and middle finger.

  • Paliwaweng

    Kung kay Gloria to, para na namang Ampatuan massacre. Itatago pa nya si maratrat.

    • batangpaslit

      Abe, bawa’t administration, may “tirador”

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_BL2GYU35SO6HTJUEAUTXS3QFYM George Lapulapu

    Marantan–accuser, judge, exectioner!!!!

  • Pedro_Gil

    Paglabas ng gunggong na yan galing sa ospital ng st lukes, dalhin agad yan sa muntinglupa.  ilapit yan sa mga kamaganak ng mga inambush at pinatay niya. tingnan ko lang kung tatagal yan doon. isama na si melad  at dumlao. Tingnan ko lang ang tapang ng mga kumag na ito.  Mga hangal!!!

  • beerhunters

    “I already warned them a number of times to never ever mess with me, my business or encroach into my turf. There, that’s what they get for not listening to me!”

    • batangpaslit

      Bro, sino nagsabi nian? Grupo ng karibal na Jueteng Lord?

      • beerhunters

        that’s just a fictional statement by a fictional character in this mad world of politics, business, influence and turf 

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/FXNIN7XJ52H6BOQLS7NRMO3GEA Lorelei

    kahit ilang beses siya mamatay, hindi maiibsan pagkawala ni tisoy. napakalaking dagok pagkawala ni jun. magbalik loob siya, tapatan niya ang serbisyo ni jun sa sambayanan, sa bundok, mula ngayon ialay niya ang hiram niyang buhay, para sa kahit napakaliit na bagay na ito, ang pagtuwid sa kanyang sarili, pagbayad sa lipunan ng kanyang mga sala, at higit sa lahat ay paghingi ng kapatawaran, ay may bahagi siya sa pagpunan ng pagkawala ni dignum

    • batangpaslit

      Lorelei, bakit naman kasi sumama sia sa lakad ng Jueteng Lord? Alam naman nia na sobra ang inggitan sa illegal na negosyo.
      Kung inosente si Jun, liable ang Philippine Government na bayaran ang pamilya nia for life dahil ang naka disgrasya sa kanya ay government functionary.

      Sino si Dignum?

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/4XVVCOAZXYTPN2X3IPFCFDSKFM Melvin

    Sorry na lang si Marantan siya ang naging scapegoat o fall guy… Paano na yung nag-utos, yung chain of commands walang kasalanan? Kanya-kanya na silang paghuhugas ng kamay. Kapag bulilyaso iwas-pusoy na sila…

    • $20722540

      siempre kasama si melad, dumlao, etc.  legit daw yong operation, it could be legit kasi meron silang mga documents to support their the claim.  however, how credible the oplan is? is another story and how it was executed…like a gangster way of doing it, in the godfather movie

    • Edward Castro

      e di kung gusto nya kumant na sya para malaman sino malaman punot dulo nyan.

    • batangpaslit

      you said it

  • Rovingmoron

    Lumang style na yan. Walang dalang baril tapos biglang nagkaroon ng baril, ano ba yan? Planting rice is never fun. But it’s more fun in the Philippines!

  • Rovingmoron

    When a higher official says he approves of the plan, it must be covered in black and white. When something negative crops up, you can always have something to show and prove that the plan was approved. Nodding one’s head as a mean to aporove a plan is not enough in a dangerous project such as the Atimonan rubout.

  • justomontevedio

    Marantan, kawawa ka naman pala.
    Iwas pusoy na yong amo mo na nag-utos sa rub-out na ito, at kung di ka makakalabos sa  kaso na ito ay malamang na ipatumba ka na rin ng amo mo.

    • batangpaslit

      may alam ka rin…

  • http://twitter.com/simplyGracelyn Gracelyn Feliciano

    Wow very well said.. nice presentation of facts and investigations. God job PDI! It is just heart breaking that the real suspects are trying to divert what’s the truth into lies. At the end, I hope that justice will really prevail.. at sana know what is the real intentions why such crimes has been commited :)

  • batangpaslit

    Kung inosente ang mga namatay, the Philippine Government has to compensate the family for life, since the operatives that undid them are government functionaries.
    The point am trying to convey, is:
    This acivity of economic sabotage—Jueteng—killing the rivals comes with the territory.
    So, if you are involved in this illegal acts, you have to be prepared to kill and be killed.
    Naunahan lang ang grupo ni Siman ng grupo ng karibal nia.
    Otherwise, ang grupo ng karibal ni Siman ang naratrat, kung pabaya ang karibal nia.
    The long and short of it, Tsong, I have no tears to elements who are engaged in economic sabotage
    I don’t mind how they lost their lives, after all, all of them—-the illegal operators, are of criminal mind.
    If you think the court of law is the remedy, let me ask you this question:
    Was there a Jueteng Lord that was convicted?
    Si Erap paano nasipa? ‘Diba sa Jueteng din? Sino ang nagpasipa, diba ang ka probinsiya ni Bong Pineda, a Jueteng Lord.
    Sino ang naging principal na accuser, diba, another Jueteng Lord, si Governor Sabit?
    Filipinos should not be naive on this matter.

  • Chihuahua

    Take a seat on your cushy armchair and enjoy the movie…now showing ..starring Maratan as Wyatt Earp in the The Shootout at O.K. Corral! Don on your 3D glasses for a more stunning realistic on the scene experience. 

  • YanoSantos

    Nice case analysis! Bring it on PDI!

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:

c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City,Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94


editors' picks

advertisement

popular

advertisement

videos