Quantcast

No TRO for Aga Muhlach, Charlene Gonzales-Muhlach

By |


Aga Muhlach. INQUIRER.NET FILE PHOTO

MANILA, Philippines—Show biz couple Aga Muhlach and Charlene Gonzales are left on a cliffhanger after failing to immediately obtain from the Court of Appeals a temporary restraining order (TRO) against their exclusion as voters of San Jose, Camarines Sur.

In a two-page resolution penned by Justice Vicente Veloso, the Court of Appeals 12th Division instead ordered oral arguments to be held on Jan. 15 at 2 p.m.

The other division members, Justices Aurora Jane Lantion and Eduardo Peralta, concurred in the ruling.

“Without necessary giving due course to the petition… respondents are directed to file their comments within 10 days from notice… Let the injunctive relief prayed for be set for hearing on Tuesday,” the resolution said.

Failure to establish residency

Muhlach, who is seeking a congressional seat in Camarines Sur, has to be a qualified voter so his certificate of candidacy would not be cancelled. However, upon the petition of four San Jose residents, two local courts in San Jose ordered the couple’s names stricken from the voters’ list for allegedly failing to establish their residency six moths before the registration period, as required by the Commission on Elections.

Ordered to file their comments are the four residents, regional trial court Judge Noel Paulite, municipal circuit trial court judge Ricky Benigno, the San Jose election registration board and the municipal election officer.

The Court of Appeals also ordered the Office of the Solicitor General to file its comment on the issue.

Last Jan. 3, Muhlach filed a 50-page petition for a TRO through his lawyer Romulo Macalintal, who said his client will “suffer grave and irreparable damage and injury as they will be deprived of their constitutional right of suffrage” if the exclusion order was not stopped.

“The law is very clear in that a voter must be a resident of the place for at least six months before the election and not before registration. Since the courts found that the Muhlachs have been residing in San Jose as of Feb. 17, 2012, then it is as clear as the sunlight that they have more than complied with the six-month residency before the May 13, 2013, elections, or a period of one year and three months from Feb. 17, 2012, to May 13, 2013,” the petition said.

Macalintal said the judges committed grave error by reckoning the six-month residency period before the couple registered on March 19, 2012. The lawyer said the law provides that the period of residency should be counted six months immediately before or preceding the elections or the May 13, 2013, polls.


Follow Us


Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Tags: 2013 midterm elections , Aga Muhlach , Camarines Sur , Charlene Gonzales-Muhlach , San Jose town


  • pcosmachine

    Aga Muhlach will be another addition to the already mostly incompetent and unqualified members of Congress. What is driving these showbiz personalities to politics are the perks (Christmas bonus, MOOE, travel expenses, pork barrel and CUT for every government business transaction) that come with it.

    • Facilitator1

      Ang tindi ng problema ni Juan/Juan dela Cruzes. 

      Mga kandidato natin either NOT job qualified or if job qualified, BIG perception as corrupt. 

      Maganda sana kung problema ng madlang pipol na HINDI nila malaman kung sino ang iboboto dahil puro matitino at mahuhusay ang mga kandidato (kumbaga, the voters can PICK/CHOOSE the BEST among the BEST) pero baliktad ang nangyayari. Kung sa TONGKING ito, puro pantapon ang mga baraha mo…

      Bakit ba wala tayong IDEAL na candidate–BOTH job QUALIFIED and MORALLY upright.

      Ito ba ang KARMA ng mga PINOYs…PEACE…

  • pcosmachine

    Madadagdagan na naman ng WALANG ALAM na taga showbiz sa Kongreso. Mapang akit talaga ang pork barrel.

  • galnxdoor

    have always found Aga to be one of the more sensible, intelligent actors around.

    • http://twitter.com/erncastillo ern

      kaya nga mag actor na lang siya.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/SLIGVU76L2UPOWLUZXLUK2LQSI Roberto

    Bicol politics for Bicolanos only. Can he speak Bicol dialect? Gagamitin lang ang mga taga-San Jose sa ambisyon niya. People of San Jose, CamSur, huwag kayong magpagamit sa artistang ito.

  • brunogiordano

    Dapat walang TRO.

    COMELEC disqualify na iyan.

  • Garo Ungaro

    Case closed…wait next election time. make sure ur a legal resident in a place u want to be a candidate….

  • txtman

    THE LAW IS VERY SPECIFIC

    AND VERY CLEAR

    .
    .
    .
    KAILANGAN

    PA BANG PAG-ISIPAN YAN?
    .
    .
    .
    YOU DON’T NEED

    TO BE A LAW GRADUATE

    TO UNDERSTAND THE LAW

    .
    .
    .
    .

    THE MULACHS ARE JUST ANOTHER

    VICTIMS OF THE TRAPOS
    .
    .
    .
    .
     
    ANO PA MAN

    ANG RASON NINA AGA

    .
    .
     
    THE LAW

    MUST BE FOLLOWED.

    PITIFUL

  • http://twitter.com/erncastillo ern

    hoy macalintal… alam ng lahat na hindi sila tagaroon. Masyado mo namang binababoy ang tao. 

    • txtman

      ANO BA SABI NG BATAS?

      AS LONG AS

      YOU MEET

      THE CRITERIA
      .
      .
      .
      .

      ANYBODY CAN RUN FOR ANY SEAT

      AS LONG AS

      THEY MEET THE LAW
      .
      .
      .
       
      MAHIRAP BANG INTINDIHIN YAN?
      .
      .
      .
      KUNG AYAW NINYO SA KNILA

      EH, DI WAG NINYO SILANG IBOTO

      AS SIMPLE

      AS THAT
      .
      .
      .
      .

      HIRAP KASI

      MGA GALAMAY NG TRAPO

      EH, UMABOT NA SA JUSTICE SYSTEM
      .
      .
      .
       SIMPLE LANG

      FOLLOW THE LAW

      .
      .
      KAILANGAN PA BANG PAG-ISIPAN YAN?

      PITIFUL

  • Bayawak

    these people earning not enough in showbiz,now, they saw congress as more profitable than ever.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/H4INAGLB7BOCJ4EVP3ZWJQRQ74 itsumo

    Sa realidad mahirap talaga labanan ang TRAPO o political dynasty. just like in mindanao kahit wala kang intention na pumasok sa politika pagbawalan ka naman mag medical mission sa yung probinsya kung saan ka ipinanganak. gusto nilang mangyari dapat may mukha ni gobernor sa streamer, tama ba naman yun?

    Kung sakaling hindi makatakbo si Aga mahirapan na rin siguro siyang tumulong sa kanyang probinsya dahil lahat ng magandang gawin niya labag sa batas ng nakaupong politiko. ganyan karumi ang politika sa ating bansa.

  • compromise500

    i would vote for muhlach rather than penning for the fuentebellas who have been serving our district for almost a century but has not seen a lot of improvement. 

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/H7P4W37H6UQYUREGWH67MSZSBQ JunPisce

    Please stop your ambition,Aga!Congress is not for you,run 1st as Kagawad,geewiz!!!!Lunatics might vote for you.COMELEC,disqualify him.

  • Fulpol

    ask Padaca why she was qualified to seat as Commissioner in COMELEC..

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/WKY6M3PPFVHG4B3QSYFE4LTQZA jonh

    Im not good with the idea of an artist running and winning even tho theres a word like “anybody can run”. number 1 reason is, that is not thier specialty, second they can always expose themselves on national and intl tvs and promote themselves round year long and in times of elections which is unfair for the rival candidate (you know many artists working of the govt today). are you good with this?

  • boybakal

    Romulo Macalintal, who said his client will “suffer grave and irreparable damage and injury as they will be deprived of their constitutional right of suffrage” if the exclusion order was not
    stopped.

    Ano kayang grave and irreparable damage and injury will Aga suffer ang pinagsasabi nitong si Macalintal.
    Luma na yan tugtugin na yan. Walang mangyayaring injury kay Aga, he will be the same aga.
    Balik lang yan sa tv and movies. Baka ibalik yon Ok Dok.

    Bitter lack neck time na lang Aga…di naman nawawala ang election, nandiyan lang yan.

  • Hey_Dudes

    Pasensiya kana muna Aga.  Talagang pahirapan ngayon kumuha ng TRO.  Tignan mo si Gwen minuta na sa capitolyo hangga ngayon walang TRO?  I think you can forget about your running for politics.  Bakit wala ka bang peliculang ginagawa sa kasalukuyan?

    • spider69

      ayaw kasing tumanggap ng role na TATAY akala niya he is still matinee idol. hindi matanggap na matanda na siya.

  • amapangarap

    style ng mga laos na artista. wala na sila pang sustento sa lifestyle nila kaya sa pinaka-malapit sa propesyon nila naman ang papasukin.

    • tilamsik

      “pinakamalapit sa propesyon”… tama dahil ang mga politiko mga artista din, karamihan ang role ay magnanakaw  

      • ano ikaw

         mga bu-aya pati

      • spider69

        at mas matinding magsinungaling ang mga artista kaysa sa politico. ang mga niloko ng politico ay ang mga constituent nya lang. pero ang mga artista buong mundo ang niloloko at pinagsisinungalingan.

    • zoom_lens

      Nadale mo. Tumpak na tumpak ang iyong tinuran.

  • boybakal

    Bat ba nagpakalayo layo pa si Aga sa pagkandidato.
    Gayong pwedeng pwede siya sa Quezon City. Nandiyan si Herbert tutulong sa kanya.
    Pati na rin si Roderick, si Aiko at kung sino sino pang artistang pangit.
    Gaya ni Lou Veloso sa Maynila o Isko sa Manila.

  • wilson

    tagarito ako sa san jose  pero hindi naman talaga yan tumira dito si lray  villafuerte lang naman may kagustuhan niyan ang tutuo sa lahat nang lakad ni aga ang pera ng kapitolyo ang ginagamit simula sa sasakyan red plate, bigas galing sa kapitolyo ang sankaterbang security nagpapasahod gobtyerno pero pribadong tao iyan. Lulubog at lilitaw ang ginagawa yan paano yan mananalo ni walang organization..Ang bahay na inupahan niya ay kay cesar chavez at bihira nga siya doon kaya tama lang siguro na alisin na  siya ng comelec.

  • ano ikaw

    Laos na mga artista ngayon ngama-pulitika? kasi naman laos at wala ng pera…so pork barrel ang ina-ambisyon ng mga ito.

    Kasama na diyan ang LAHAT na media at artista.

  • Albert Einstien

    COMELEC & CA should allow AGA to run… WiILL of the PEOPLE is sovereignty…this cant be overcome by a mere technical absurdity of late or early registration…for ALL his LIFE aga is a FILIPINO CITIZEN …..LET the PEOPLE decide it is an ELECTION CONTEST…not a UNILATERAL & WHIMSICAL appointment by executive…but a COMMANDING VOICE of the PEOPLE…the sovereign..!

    in fact the MORE STRINGENT AGE REQUIREMENT supreme court held should be BASED on the DAY of the ELECTION what more to mere choice of domicile or residence whch is based on INTENTion a PURELY PERSONAL MATTER…..SC held: as in the case of candidates for elective provincial and national offices, a candidate for an elective municipal office must have, in order to be eligible, at least twenty three years of age at the TIME OF ELECTION is held. [ G. R. No. L-10201, September 23, 1957 ].

    While the Court ordinarily respects the factual findings of administrative bodies like the COMELEC, this does not prevent it from exercising its review powers to correct palpable misappreciation of evidence or wrong or irrelevant considerations……There is NO HARD & FAST RULE to determine a candidate’s compliance with residency requirement since the question of residence is a question of intention. Still, jurisprudence has laid down the following guidelines: (a) every person has a domicile or residence somewhere; (b) where once established, that domicile remains until he acquires a new one; and (c) a person can have but one domicile at a time.( SUPREME COURT G.R. No. 191970 April 24, 2012 )

    residency or domicile requirement REALLY boils down to DOMICILE by CHOICE…INTENTION is the sole basis & INTENTION is PERSONAL…what is greater PROOF of INTENTION than to SERVE your PEOPLE… : > )

    • anton kinuton

      ayan ka na naman ka romy.

  • Maboot

    Going to Partido area, you will be welcomed by large tarpaulins greeting you, “Marhayna AGA” (literally Good Morning) with the picture of Aga Muhlach on them, too. It takes no Einstein to know what these posters mean. 

    Mayong malinaw na kaAGAhan an distritokanPartido. The electorate is torn between two choices: (1) continue the Fuentebella dynasty that is in existence for over 100 years now or (2) give chance to actor Aga Muhlach who suddenly came to his senses that he is from the town of San Jose and dreams to win a seat in Congress. The first gives the evil of dynasty; the second parades of the “good” of the actor who found enlightenment and aims to rule carrying nothing (not even political experience)but the desire to help the people. Is it a battle between good and evil or a choice for a lesser evil? 

    No matter what the battle may be, just like in the national politics, the drought in good and able leaders in Partido is a tragedy that has been going on and will soon be full blown if the prayers for rains will not come soon. 

    • Loggnat

      They should go for the unknown newbie, cross their finger and hope that he is legit in trying to bring progress to his future constituents. :))

  • lolo_Jose

    Tapos ba ng high school ang Aga na ito? Ala na bang pelikula at laos na talaga kaya
    pagka politiko naman ang naisip? Sabagay, kaway dito ngiti doon at halik sa mga bata
    panalo na sa mga botante si Aga. Haysss mga apo sana isipin ninyong mabuti kung 
    sino iboboto ninyo para hindi mapariwara ang bansa natin..

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/AMG5EDI2JBQRL4Z5H2L7ED4OQA yahoo-AMG5EDI2JBQRL4Z5H2L7ED4OQA

    NO TO ACTORS IN THE NEXT ELECTION !!! NO TO BINAY,NO TO ENRILE,NO TO ERAP..

  • poltergeist_fuhrer

    NO TO BAM AQUINO. NO TO HONTIVEROS. NO TO LIBERAL PARTY!!!!!!!!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PN3VRDYP7ZZDTUHWG5R7RJSXWM raul n

       and NO TO UNA CANDIDATES UNA SA MGA KABULASTUGAN. LOL

      • poltergeist_fuhrer

        ganun ba…tingnan mo nga kung sino nakinabang sa mga bonuses sa senado at congreso????

        MAJORITY OF THEM MGA TUTA NI PENOY…MGA LIBERAL PARTY…

        akala mo kung sino malinis…mas masahol pa kay GMA…

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_T42Q37DX5BRWJ5NRYTBC2DXUAU Jols – batman Robin

    gusto pala ni aga na maging kasapi ng mga tong gressman….. heheeh 

  • wilson

    hindi nga siya taga rito sa san jose may batas tayo na dapat sundin.Kung hindi natin igagalang ang batas bakit pa ito ginawa, alam mo itong c macalintal alam naman niya ang tutuo pero pera ang pinaguusapan dito. Halimbawa ako taga rito bigla akong lilipat sa lugar niyo para magkandidato sa wari niyo tama ba yan.

  • bugoybanggers

    Iyan na nga ang mahirap sa mga Pilipino, alam na nga nilang ginagamit lang ng ibang ambisyosong tao ang kanilang kasikatan. Samakatuwid, bakit kailangan pang dumayo sa Bikol si nonoy aga?  Ano palan ang laog sa payo mo noy! Taga Quezon City ka eversince, bakit hindi ka tumakbo bilang Congresista sa lugar mo at dadayo ka pa sa Bikol para kumandidato? Ibig sabihin alam mo na maraming mga BOBO ang taga San Jose, Cam Sur kaya doon ka at hindi mo kaya ang taga QC? Tama ka na nga! Matulog ka na lang sa bahay mong tunay, wag mong pilitin ang sarili mo sa isang lugar na ni anino mo hindi man lang tumatagal. Kayo namang taga Cam SUR, lalo na ang mga BAKLA, hayaan ninyo na mapigil na ang mapag samantalang laos na artistang itong manahimik. Pinag lalaruan lang nila ang kabobohan ng mga taga diyan.

  • tarikan

    Politicians (not only Aga & Charlene, there are many, many more)) make a travesty of the Comelec Law on residency. Usually trapos are doing that…spreading their kin’s residences (actually only vacation houses) in the province to capture all possible positions. Bakit hindi ayusin ang batas na yan to avoid loopholes?

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_U62PHGMKO4RK7BLMC4ACA4EG5A EREC

      Intensiyon talaga ng ating mga GONGGONG na mambabatas na magulo ang batas dahil sila naman ang makikinabang lalo na pag nasa puwesto na. Ang batas patungkol sa politiko ay batas para sa kanila hindi naman para sa mamayan. Its only a law for the elite politicians.

      • Komen To

        Correct. That’s why the anti dynasty provision in the constitution is never implemented because the law is vague from the start

  • Yobhtron

    Let the people of San Jose, CamSur decide.  Sabi naman ng taga doon ay mas gugustuhin nila iboto si Aga keysa sa political dynasty na andun na wala naman ginawa kundi magpayaman.

    • bugoybanggers

      Sila rin ang nag paabuso sa kasakiman ng kanilang mga pinuno. Bakit wala bang ibang taga San Jose Cam Sur ang pwede? Ibig sabihin ang mga taga diyan pala mga mang-mang at kailangan pa si AGATON na taga QC ang patatakbuhin laban sa dati nila? Nakakahiya naman kayo.. o baka mahilig lang talaga kayo sa mga gwapong laos! Naku mga kababayan, tumindig naman kayo sa sarili.. maraming magagaling at may karapatang mamuno sa lugar ninyo. ilabas na ninyo sila at Larga na.

      • Komen To

        Obviously you know little about politics. Try running against a political dynasty. Do you think an ordinary new comer can unseat political big names in Makati, Cagayan, Ilocos, Tarlac, Angeles, Pampanga, Cebu, Mindanao…etc

      • bugoybanggers

        Kaya iyan kung lahat kikilos. Bakit napatalsik si MACOY aber? Nasa tao iyan.

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/H4INAGLB7BOCJ4EVP3ZWJQRQ74 itsumo

        madaling sabihin mahirap gawin. bilangin mo lang kung ilang tao ang namatay noong panahon nga martial law.

  • aldhins

    Bakit ba natin pipigilan ang taong gustong mag silbi ?  ilang congressman na  di naman naka tira doon sa destrito kung saan sya ang congressman  sa manila ang  boung familya nila tuwing election lang sya nakikita ng mga kababayan nya :)

    • Komen To

      Take Pacquiao for example, where does he stay most of the time? Tama ka aldhins

    • bugoybanggers

      Kaya nga dapat sunugin ang mga bahay nila sa probinsya para wala na silang babalikan tuwing eleksyon.

  • regd

    Hehehe limot na ni aga na totoong buhay na ng maraming tao ang nakataya. Dati porma porma, shooting shooting, nagpapangap na mahirap, inaapi, tinutulungan mga mahihirap. Pagkatapos gawa ng pelikula pangiti-ngiti sabay sabi ” bukas na po ang palabas, wag po nyong kalimutan panoorin ho, kita kita po tayo bukas”. 

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/6N45VTMWG44CSNC2G5WS33ZAHI MS. F3

    Gaya ng nasabi ko na dati pa tungkol sa residency ng mga Muhlach sa Camarines Sur, madali lang naman makumpirma kung talagang residents sila dun (kaya nga residency tawag e). School ages na yung mga anak nila. So saang school sa CamSur nagaaral? Alangan naman silang magasawa lang nakatira sa CamSur tapos yung mga anak nila sa De Lasalle Zobel sa Alabang Village ang school o baka hatid sundo nila from CamSur to Alabang and back. Hindi porke bumili ka ng residence certificate sa isang lugar e residente ka na dun.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_44QGTQXFYHNVPNMX453LWBPMXM Opel

    the muhlachs are getting an early taste of political bite from the trad pols. if you plan to run for govt office you should try to be visible even before the campaign period prar hindi maquestion residency 

    • Loggnat

      Mullach should have established residency a full year to deny any politicians in the opposition to have an excuse to derail his candidacy. Do not give any future opponent any excuse so dot all the i’s and crossed all the t’s. Lesson learned, hope for the best and meticulously prepare for the worst.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_U62PHGMKO4RK7BLMC4ACA4EG5A EREC

    Election is nearly coming May 2013…. better push judisciary to put this in finality. Then lets the people speak through clean and orderly election. Its clear that Aga is not a resident of San Jose, Cam. Sur and the group of people opposing the candidacy of Aga is the group of Fuentibella.

  • Komen To

    “The law is very clear in that a voter must be a resident of the place for at least six months before the election and not before registration” – If this is the law, why would the judges, per Macalintal reckon it to registration time? I hope that if the judges were proven wrong, they will be sanctioned for grave abuse of authority. Otherwise, if they are correct, I hope the correction be publish so that the public will know the law on filing candidacy

  • boybakal

     Ordered to file their comments are:

    1.four residents,
    2.Regional Trial Court Judge Noel Paulite,
    3Municipal Circuit Trial Court Judge Ricky
    Benigno,
    4.San Jose Election Registration Board and
    5.Municipal Election Officer.

    Judges, Election Officials concur that Aga did not fulfill the residency requirement.
    All the four have the same thinking, is that not enough for Aga to respect the decision.

    AGA is a good man and has good intention in running for public office.
    But good intention should also abide with the law, this time Aga should abide and concede.
    Just like the saying….Huling Biyaheng Bicol, humahabol si Aga sa Bicol Express.

    • Komen To

      Review your comments. Kaya nga they were asked to file their comments because the CA judge finds probable reason for not respecting their decision. Until we know their specific reasons for the disqualification can we understand fully whether or not to respect their decision. Let the CA render its decision

  • Albert Einstien

    COMELEC & CA should allow AGA to run… WiILL of the PEOPLE is sovereignty…this cant be overcome by a mere technical absurdity of late or early registration…for ALL his LIFE aga is a FILIPINO CITIZEN …..LET the PEOPLE decide it is an ELECTION CONTEST…not a UNILATERAL & WHIMSICAL appointment by executive…but a COMMANDING VOICE of the PEOPLE…the sovereign..!

    in fact the MORE STRINGENT AGE REQUIREMENT supreme court held should be BASED on the DAY of the ELECTION what more to mere choice of domicile or residence whch is based on INTENTion a PURELY PERSONAL MATTER…..SC held: as in the case of candidates for elective provincial and national offices, a candidate for an elective municipal office must have, in order to be eligible, at least twenty three years of age at the TIME OF ELECTION is held. [ G. R. No. L-10201, September 23, 1957 ].

    While the Court ordinarily respects the factual findings of administrative bodies like the COMELEC, this does not prevent it from exercising its review powers to correct palpable misappreciation of evidence or wrong or irrelevant considerations……There is NO HARD & FAST RULE to determine a candidate’s compliance with residency requirement since the question of residence is a question of intention. Still, jurisprudence has laid down the following guidelines: (a) every person has a domicile or residence somewhere; (b) where once established, that domicile remains until he acquires a new one; and (c) a person can have but one domicile at a time.( SUPREME COURT G.R. No. 191970 April 24, 2012 )

    residency or domicile requirement REALLY boils down to DOMICILE by CHOICE…INTENTION is the sole basis & INTENTION is PERSONAL…what is greater PROOF of INTENTION than to SERVE your PEOPLE… : > )

    • anton kinuton

      si makalintal ka ano?

      • Albert Einstien

        that’s a great honor to be in league of top caliber lawyers… pero tingnan nyo po pleadings nya kung parehas kami….lol

  • 123_pampanggo_farmer

    ARTISTA NA NAMAN YAN! DAPAT BUSISIING MABUTI NG MGA BOTANTE ANG KWALIPIKASYON NG MGA ITO BAGO IBOTO.
    SANA HUWAG MAINGGANYO ANG MGA BOTANTE NANG DAHIL LANG SA KASIKATAN NG MGA ARTISTA.
    GAMITIN NATIN NANG MAAYOS ANG ATING KARAPATAN AT KAPANGYARIHAN NA MAG LUKLUK SA PWESTO NG MGA OPISYAL NG BAYAN UPANG HUWAG MAGISISI SA BANDANG HULI.
    MAG-ISIP MABUTI BAGO ISULAT ANG PANGALAN NG IBOBOTO, ISIPIN MABUTI ANG KAPAKANAN NG MGA ANAK NATIN AT ANG PARA SA KABUTIHAN NG BAYAN.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_H47CPJUE4QYKFUCKSUXK3LNBGI Allan

      ano ba tinapos ni aga? baka pareho lang sila ni pacquiao, puro kaklase ni joseph estrada?

  • anton kinuton

    ikaw naman makalintal, ano ba talaga ang “resident” in a true sense of the word? dadating ka sa isang lugar, magrenta ka ng kwarto o bahay o apartment o sabihin natin na bumili ka ng bahay at nagpalista bilang botante at pagkatapos nun, umalis ka at bumalik sa mnila, wla kang kilala sa lugar, ni isang kapitbahay, except ang yung isang barkada mo na tag-ruon na siyang nagsuyo sa iyo na kakandidato. di alam kung saan ang palengke, di alam ang mga pangalan ng barangay, dikilala mga local goveernment at religious at dept of education personalities. siguro naman dapat titira dun ng ilang buwan para makilala at makipagkilala, di kaya galit kay aga yung nagsulsul sa kanya na kakandidato?

    • okabato

       Tama si makalintal febrero pa nanirahan sila aga doon kaya lampas na sa anim na buwan na kailangang paninirahan sa isang lugar para kumandidato. Nasa mga botante na yon kung gusto silang iboto o hindi, wala tayong pakialam doon nasa demokrasya tayo.

      • LEANDRO BALDEMOR JR.

        FAN…

  • dequis

    kung masabi mo aga muhlach ng diretsahan na ang hangad mo ay maglingkod at wala kang interesado 70m taon taon na pork barrel, baka pumayag ang court of appeals na residente ka nga ng camarines sur at kasama ka naming mga bicolano. kaya lang mahihirapan kang ikaila iyon.

  • boybakal

    Kung talagang Bicolano nga si Aga at resident siya dapat magsalita siya ng Bicolano, dapat fluent.
    Pangalawa dapat kumain siya ng sampung siling labuyo na di iinom ng tubig.
    Pag nagawa niya yon, for sure He is a Bonafide Bicolano at walang halong Ilocano.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_4R3GZTGML26TV2VGS6RVHP2THM Fred

    kapag hindi ka lehitimong tagaroon, mahihirapan kang makalusot.
    itanong ninyo kay Cesar at Goma.

  • RiverHorse

    residency is different from owning a property. residency means you actually live there and your livelihood is also based there. semantics!

  • Balot Pinoy

    Show your almoranas aga, that’s the solid proof that you are bicol.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_5TBFLMGYQ6VOQOSMUUFHOML5VE Archie B

    i don’t think hindi magiging election lawyer expert si Macalintal kung mali ang tinugon niya. the issue here is kung pasok ba siya sa itinatakda ng batas o hindi. e pinatunayan naman nila na pasok siya so why not let him run?

    don’t get me wrong. i’m not Aga’s fan. hindi rin ako pabor na tumakbo siya as Congressman. ang akin laang ay yung rights nung tao. yun lang.

  • boybakal

    Aga and Charlene cannot be residents of Bicol….why?
     Charlene is always in the Buzz with Boy Abunda and Toni Gonzaga.
    Every Sunday on the Buzz Charlene is making chismis on latest gossip news about actors and actresses.

    Per rule, 6 months residency should be continuous and any absences should be deducted from 6 months.
    For sure, time travel back and forth means five days in a week Aga was not in Bicol but in Manila.
    To sum it up, Aga stayed more in Manila than Bicol during the probation 6 months
    residency requirement.
    In short, Aga is short in residency.

    Bitter lack neck time Aga.

  • chitetskoy

    yan kasi laos na sa artista kaya sa pulitika na lang trying hard

  • GustoKoHappyKa

    Mamili nalang kayo kung sino ang iboboto… yung Traditional Politician coming from the same Family lording the province since time ni kopong kopong or si Aga?

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_4C2SFYIH52Y2KR7QPZPHJO2XQQ sl1

    If you did not meet the residency requirement then you just have to postpone your running for congressman next time and don’t try to circumvent the election law.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/BKDTKLW6CJNOHFFH3LY3YTPNHY Noshairalawever

    He and his idiot wife don’t deserve to be in politics. ESPECIALLY when they have Mr. “Your mother should have aborted you” ANTI-RH bill lawyer (LIAR) Romulo Macalintal.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_H47CPJUE4QYKFUCKSUXK3LNBGI Allan

    before you get your american citizenship, you must stay in the us of a for 5 years. absences are deducted. remember, a fraction of a day you are absent means you are absent the whole day. now, has aga or charlene completed six months of stay in the province? tanungin lang ang mga residente kung nakita nila either one or aga or charlene could show documentary proof of their stay. simple, hindi ba? you don’t need 50 pages of petition for that.



Copyright © 2014, .
To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.
Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:
c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94
Advertisement
Advertisement
Marketplace
Advertisement