Quantcast
Latest Stories

JBC disqualifies de Lima; 8 names in shortlist

By

Justice Secretary Leila de Lima. INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

MANILA, Philippines – The Judicial and Bar Council disqualified Justice Secretary Leila de Lima for the Chief Justice post due to two pending disbarment cases filed against her, a member of the JBC said on Monday.

Eight names now make up the shortlist by the Judicial and Bar Council for the position of Supreme Court Chief Justice, JBC member Jose Mejia said.

The eight names are:

  1. Acting chief Justice Antonio Carpio
  2. Supreme Court Associate Justice Roberto Abad
  3. Supreme Court Associate Justice Maria Lourdes Sereno
  4. Supreme Court Associate Justice Arthuro Brion
  5. Solicitor General Francis Jardeliza
  6. Former San Juan Representative Ronaldo Zamora
  7. Supreme Court Associate Justice Teresita Leonardo de Castro
  8. Former Ateneo Law Dean Cesar Villanueva

Justice Carpio got seven out of eight votes. Justices Abad, Brion, Sereno, Jardeleza and former Representative Zamora got six votes each while Justice De Castro and Dean Villanueva received five votes each.

The names will be submitted to President Benigno Aquino III, who has until the last week of August to pick who the next Chief Justice will be.

Under Article 8 Section 4 (1), the President has 90 days from the time the vacancy occurred to make the appointment.
The Chief Justice position became vacant after Renato Corona was impeached by the Senate sitting as an impeachment court last May 29.

The JBC rescheduled several times its deliberation for various reasons. Even the group Supreme Court Appointments Watch (SCAW) expressed apprehension over reports that there was pressure to suspend rules on disqualification to accommodate one of the 20 candidates.

After several rescheduling, the JBC has come up with its short list on August 13.

Each JBC member can vote up to eight candidates. Here’s how each member of the JBC voted:

Associate Justice Diosdado Peralta, presiding officer — Abad, Brion, Carpio, De Castro, Supreme Court Associate Justice Presbitero Velasco;

Undersecretary Frederick Musngi — Abad, PCGG Chair Andres Bautista, Carpio, SEC Chair Teresita Herbosa, Jardeleza, Sereno, Villanueva, Zamora;

Senator Francis Escudero — Brion, Diokno, Herbosa, Jardeleza, former UP Law Dean Raul Pangalangan, Sereno, Velasco, Zamora;

Rep. Niel Tupas, Jr. — Abad, Brion, Carpio, Jardeleza, De Castro, Pangalangan, Sereno, Zamora;

Justice Regino Hermosisima, Jr. — Abad, Brion, Carpio, De Castro, Pangalangan, Velasco, Villanueva, Zamora;

Justice Aurora Santiago Lagman — Brion, Carpio, Herbosa, Jardeleza, De Castro, Sereno, Villanueva, Zamora;

Atty. Jose Mejia — Abad, Brion, Carpio, Diokno, Jardeleza, Sereno, Villanueva, Zamora;

Atty. Maria Milagros Fernan-Cayosa — Abad, Bautista, Carpio, Herbosa, Jardeleza, De Castro, Sereno, Villanueva;

Prior to the disqualification of Justice Secretary Leila DeLima, the JBC members had a straw vote where De Lima got four out of eight votes from the JBC members.

Originally posted at 01:29 pm | Monday,  Aug. 13, 2012


Follow Us

Follow us on Facebook Follow on Twitter Follow on Twitter


Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Tags: Government , JBC , Leila de Lima , Supreme Court


  • lee1222

    This is good news. De Lima can now (re)focus on her DOJ job instead of acting like some desperate election candidate.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/6NVJE4NYLGDSCO6KQ4GWP35SVM Macario

    Ayan, hindi ka na kasali ha…matuto ka na…lost opportunity for you…this is a day of reckoning di ba? Ihanda ang calcibloc, baka mahigh blood ang lola nyo…na sa huli ang pag sisisi di ba? Next move, aalisin ka ni P-Noy sa DoJ dahil ang possibility na ma-discipline ka is highly probable, kaya ipi-preempt ka na nya…di pwede ang suspended lawyer or disbarred na humawak ng DoJ….

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_I4KGDZ3GNAKUXPW737YLVJXHWE Zhenda

    Good job

  • TEAM PNOY

    Final nail in the coffin.

  • manresa101

    VERY GOOD JBC! BUT HOW ABOUT HERBOSA AND JARDELEZA? THEY HAVE PENDING CASES AS WELL… 

  • arthur1401

    THis is good news, good not only for the integrity of judiciary in general and for pnoy in particular.
    Had delima been allowed to continue in her quest and JBC subsequently short-listed her, the backlash will be on JBC and the people will point an accusing finger on pnoy. and whether pnoy choose delima or not, the suspicions that he staged managed the shortlisting of the candidates will linger in in the mind of the people forever. That could be fatal and may tarnish the image of pnoy in the long term. 

  • Viktorio Ungasis Coronel

    Mag fi-file ng protest yan si de lima sa supreme court o kaya sa CHR hahaha! I disbar na yan!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_WVJPWHNIZIOGWU2O4Z6PJTXXBM Roberto

      Ungas!

    • http://whywontgodhealamputees.com/ Lucky Luciano

       lol CHR

  • Aryong

    Good.  Hopefully the disbarment (from IBP) will be out soon.

  • Magsasaka

    may kaso ka lang disqualified ka na, hindi ba innocent until proven guilty, eh kung lahat ng nasa list may kaso eh di hindi na magkakaroon ng CJ, si carpio may kaso din , lalo na siguro yong mga natitirang aso ni pandakekak sa supreme court.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_I4KGDZ3GNAKUXPW737YLVJXHWE Zhenda

      if she become a Chief Justice, how do you think she will handle her pending cases? do you think she wont control or influence the court because of her position? think about it

      • Magsasaka

        i am sure she is not like corona, the cheap dog of pandakekak, she was an appointee of pandakekak and yet she defied her, she has balls to defy an illegal TRO.

      • boldyak

        OMG…..Delima has balls?….wahahaha…

      • Magsasaka

        basket balls hehehe

      • VindictivePanot

        joke yun?

      • Magsasaka

        natawa ka?

      • VindictivePanot

        hinde! kasi corny eh.. nakaka-awang trying hard! ugok! hahaha

      • Marlanus

        si Carpio-Morales meron din. . . .

        baka ikaw wala? je je je je

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_HUE7BZXUJ7I5AFIBEPSIBONAHA Alfred A

         Really magaling lang si DeLima sa presscon… if she has balls why until now Lacson is free???

      • Magsasaka

        eh di ba kaya nga ayaw ni lacson na maging CJ si delima

      • VindictivePanot

        ugok!

    • neoxyrel

      Use what’s left inside your skull :) 

      • Magsasaka

        there is nothing inside your head, utak biya

      • neoxyrel

         Read this before you defend your piggy De5 –> Rule 4 of the Rules of the Judicial and Bar Council specifies the
        safeguards necessary to assure the integrity of its short-listed
        candidates. Section 5 of Rule 4 identifies those individuals who “are
        disqualified from being nominated for appointment to any judicial post
        or as Ombudsman or Deputy Ombudsman”

      • Magsasaka

        the case has been elevated to supreme court, while they acted promptly on the case of carpio they seem relucatant to non-justices candidates.

      • VindictivePanot

        puro ka dakdak, kamusta yung walang kwentang rally nyo, ungas? hahahaha

      • Magsasaka

        kumusta na pagbabasura mo?

      • VindictivePanot

        kamusta tulo ng nanay mo?

      • VindictivePanot

        wow, anu kaya laman ng utak ni tonio! hahahaha

      • Magsasaka

        hindi ampaw na katulad ng sa iyo hehehe

      • VindictivePanot

        hindi nga ampaw, kasi walang laman! wahahaha.. tapos ka bang mamulot ng basura? magaling na ba sa tulo nanay mo?

    • JohnDoeGB

      Hey, don’t you know what integrity is? How do pending cases affect integrity and authority of a Chief Justice? Vizconde’s case against Carpio has already been dismissed. He has immunity because he is an SC justice. He needs to be impeached first before a case against him can be heard. Please don’t humiliate yourself. Reading more and learning well will be good for you.

      • Magsasaka

        you humiliate yourself more, Vizcondes case against carpio was dismissed on the ground that a justice can be removed only thru impeachment, being a justice in the supreme court his colleagues acted promptly while with those candidates that are not justices they just sit by and that makes them disqualified, remember you’re just below average, the more you act intelligently the more you look stupid.

      • VindictivePanot

        naks, feeling above average si mokong oh… hahahaha

      • Magsasaka

        naks feeling hindi imburnal ang gunggong hehehe

      • VindictivePanot

        gaya gaya pa ng pang asar! sus, gag0 lang talaga si ugok oh! hahaha

      • Magsasaka

        ano kamo isang kang bugok kaya pala amoy imburnal ka hehehe

      • VindictivePanot

        wahahaha i-edit mo comment mo, gigil na gigil ka na sa pagka pikon hahaha

      • JohnDoeGB

        LoL! Have you reread your reply? Pathetic! It glaringly shows how much you have missed the implications, the rules and the law. Reread your first post also and think very deeply who’s stupid. Awful pride you’re posting here. Get humble my friend, it will be good for you too.

      • Magsasaka

        look who’s posting, feeling genius hehehe, you hardly make it being dumb, you’re worse than that hehehe

    • poltergeist_fuhrer

      akala ko ba, inalis ninyo si corona kasi wala siyang integrity,,,kahit ang mga binato sa kanya ay hindi naman totoo like 45 properties…

      ngaun, ok lang kay de lima???ano ka hilo???

      at, ipagpalagay natin siya ang naging CJ, ano ang mangyayari sa kanya kung napatunayan na guilty siya at na disbar siya? will she cling to her post kahit hindi na siya lawyer???yan ang isipin mo bago ka magputak ng putak dito…

      • Magsasaka

        hindi ako senador, hindi ako nagalis kay corona, hindi rin ako manok hehehe, sa palagay mo may mapapatunayan pa sa kanya kapag naging CJ sya?

      • VindictivePanot

        basurerong ugok! hahaha

      • Magsasaka

        andito na yong imburnal hehehe

      • VindictivePanot

        ugok! hahaha nagmamarunong ka pang basurero ka lang.. nakarecover na ba nanay mong put@?

    • http://www.dafk.net/what/ Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

       ”hindi ba innocent until proven guilty”

      agreed po.

      pero hindi ba ganun din a feeling nung di payagan ni De Lima si GMA from exercising her rights as a free citizen, wanting the right to travel.

      • Magsasaka

        naku eh mabahang paliwanagan pa kapag sinagot ko yan bro hehehe

      • VindictivePanot

        sus, palusot pa ang kumag! wahaha

      • Magsasaka

        naku eh papansin ang hunghang hehehe

      • VindictivePanot

        hahaha kasi nga palusot ka na lang, wala ka nang mahirit! Ugok! wahahaha

    • beatmanny

      ptang ina mo gag0 ka si corona at gma guilty na kaagad sayo impeachment pa lang gag0 ka talaga

      • Magsasaka

        uy lumitaw ang basura na galing sa mabahong baha hehehe, hulaan ko umalis ang nanay mong pokpok kaya ka nagkakaganyan walang nag aalaga sa iyo hehehe

      • VindictivePanot

        hangang ngayon “basura” pa din keyword mo? mag toothbrush ka kasi, kaka-awa mga KSP na tulad mo, quota ka na ba, tagahimod ng pwet ng malakanyang? tsk tsk… hahaha  

      • Magsasaka

        sya basura ikaw balahura hehehe

      • VindictivePanot

        galingan mo naman mga banat mo, walang ka-kwenta kwenta eh.. pikon ka na? hahahaha

      • Magsasaka

        nakakapikon ba ang non entity katulad mo, imburnal na balahura pa hehehe

      • VindictivePanot

        hahaha pikon na nga si ugok!

  • neoxyrel

    Great job JBC!

  • quphal

    o disqualified na daw ha. move on na pls, wag nang mag-apila.

  • kalaban_mo

    Aba, ung mga congressmen, senators, judges, mga government officials, pag aalisin na rin sa pwesto, to be fair with Sec. De Lima. Ung iba nga convicted na e hanggang ngaun nasa payroll parin ng gobyerno. At ang unang una magpakitang gilas para mapatunayang malinis sila, e ang IBP. Maraming Abogado ang masahol pa sa criminal, ngaun nyo subukan mag- disbar.Kilos pakitang gilas kayo!

    • poltergeist_fuhrer

      IBP is composed of lawyers, public and private…it has no connection to the government..it is like a group of accountants or a group of civil engineers called PICE…

      ang gobyerno ni penoy dapat ang magpakita ng gilas, kasi sila ang bayaran ng taong bayan…in fact, yan ang line ng amo mo “kung walang korap walang mahirap”…bakit ngaun, sabi mo, marami pa rin korap sa admin ni penoy???

  • 4kingdaddy

    i guess many doesn’t want a no nonsense cj….i guess they still prefer someone that could be bought……now before you people attack me, let’s see…if de lima allowed the TRO approved by corona and gloria’s appointed associates, the arroyos would have fled the philippines and lived happily ever after….and the people would have been screaming at de lima for allowing them to leave….resign ka na lang kaya, leila….wala kang panalo d’yan… tingnan mo, di mo pinayagang makaaalis, galit sila…kung pinayagan mo…mas lalo sigurong galit sila dahil nakalusot ang mga damuho sa mga kasong isasampa sa kanila…i am not for or against de lima…i’m just trying to see the whole picture of “what if”….. 

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_I4KGDZ3GNAKUXPW737YLVJXHWE Zhenda

      its like this… in the game of basketball, there is a rule called Goal Tending. 
      What De Lima do, is Goal Tending… Not block. But they insist, it is a block.
      So are you saying that we should disregard the rule and do your own rule?

      • 4kingdaddy

        your analogy is like comparing salt and pepper…may i ask you, would you rather let gloria go and live in a country where we have no reciprocity or let her stay here and face the music…..and not that i am better than you, but your sentence “what de lima do, is goal tending”… shoudn’t it be written as “what de lima DID, is goal tending???…just asking….

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_SSCR6ISSW6MUISWTQASKHQEZKM Roel

        Kung naka alis man si GMA, madaling matrace yan kasi hindi yan maka layo sa mga ospital dahil sa karamdaman nya.  Madali yang ma pa balik sa Pilipinas. 

        Ang di maganda is iyung hindi pag sunod ni De5 sa utos ng court.  Kapal ng mukha! Tingnan mo, marami tuloy ang nag ala De5 na di sumunod sa TRO.  Lalo tayong nag ka gulo.

      • 4kingdaddy

        ma trace mo man si gloria, eh sinabi ko nga na kung wala tayong reciprocity sa bansang kanyang pinuntahan, paano mo maibabalik si gloria dito…si joma, nasa netherlands, wala tayong reciprocity agreement sas bansang ‘yan…nakuha ba natin s’ya?….

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_SSCR6ISSW6MUISWTQASKHQEZKM Roel

        Wala akong pakialam if mamatay mansiya sa ibang bansa. the most important is that the Government have the means and ways to recover her assets.  Yung mga nakaw nya.  Mas mahalaga pa yun na ma balik sa taong bayan kasy sa maka balik siya.

        Hwag mo nang idamay ang puting itlog na joma na yan.

      • 4kingdaddy

        umpisahan mo muna si macoy, tapos si glory be…

      • poltergeist_fuhrer

        may i ask you, would you rather let gloria go and live in a country where we have no reciprocity or let her stay here and face the music..

        ——————

        ayan pa isang katangahan na post…

        hindi pa ginagawa ng tao ang action may judgment ka na agad na hindi na babalik si gma…

        tama nga ang JBC, hindi dapat maisama si delima kasi gagawa ng judgment from fairytale( i remeber a judge na nagtatanong ng verdict sa mga dwende)…

        at si delima hindi lang ang basis ng judgement niya ay fairytale, pati na rin tsismis…

      • beatmanny

        alam na alam mong tatakas talaga si gloria at hindi babalik ha, kahit paulit ulit syang umaalis dati pa man at palaging bumabalik. share ka naman ng nalalaman dyan.. please lang sana yung may ebidensya.

      • 4kingdaddy

        dahil presidente s’ya noon…..’yong ebidensyang hinihingi mo….gayahin ko na lang ang mga matatalinong abogago…at the proper forum….okey ba????

      • http://whywontgodhealamputees.com/ Lucky Luciano

        In the game of basketball, It’s called home-court advantage.

    • poltergeist_fuhrer

      if de lima allowed the TRO approved by corona and gloria’s appointed associates, the arroyos would have fled the philippines and lived happily ever after..

      ———————–

      ang hilig mo sa fairytale tsong…hindi pa nga consummated ang act, un na ang iniisip mo…parehas kayo ni de lima…tsismis lng pinatulan na agad, pinag defy na ang SC,,,hayan tuloy, nakuha niya ang hanap niya…

      tanong mo sa amo mo kung ano ang pakiramdam ng pinag defy

      • indiosbravos2002

        Tsismis daw? Hehehe. So how much do you charge for your trouble? Piso per comment. Either you are truly gullible or voluntarily gullible in exchange for some chqnge. Stop trolling.

      • poltergeist_fuhrer

        who is a troll???haha…sino ang bayaran???sino ang mahilig sa tsismis…sino ang mahilig sa THU BUZZ…walang iba kundi ikaw…kakatawa ikaw…

  • im_not_convinced

    well at least she got media mileage for her Senate run which is their goal in the first place.

  • droccu

    It’s good that Pnoy did not exert his presidential might to get what he wanted. It would have reversed the judicial reform gained with the Corona ouster. So where are the detractors now who were saying that Pnoy would do all he can to push for his choice-ala GMA? Let’s face it…iba na talaga kasi ngayon.  Mag senador ka na lang De Lima…you might still win.

    • tanga_hanga_ni_abnoy

       at sino nman nagsabi na hindi nya ginawa lahat e d b last week lang, inamin na tinutulungan ng palasyo? hindi lang nanaaig kc walang mga drilon dyan sa jbc

      • droccu

        kung ginawa ang lahat eh nakapasok dapat di ba? Iba yung tulong sa ilegal na mane obra ala GMA. Baka nag aantay nang lagay ala GMA eh, di na nagbibigay nagyon…kaya di lumusot.

  • kalaban_mo

    Ok lang na disqualified si Sec. De Lima, as long as applicable na dapat yan sa lahat ng sangay ng gobyerno. Alisin na lahat ng may kasong administratibo at criminal sa gobyerno, sukdulang maubos na kaung lahat na mga kurap at walang hiya. Kung mawala man lahat ng tao sa gobyerno dahil lahat guilty, so be it.Naniniwala ako maraming pang natitirang matinong Pilipino na handang pumalit sa pwesto. Kung di nauubos ang masasama, e lalong di nauubos ang mabubuti.

  • execute

    oh yaN…tama na ang ambisyon…balik kana sa trabaho mo..

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_Q3QGG5QHBLRMZTIYWUFURY6J2E Night

    HAHAHA BUTI NGA!!

  • PH2011

    Solicitor General   Francis Jardeleza  is still  on the running  for the post….

    The Coconut Levy Fund lawyer of San Miguel Corporation and the Philippine Government rolled into one.

    The case ; SMC vs the Government (representing the Poor Pilipino farmers).

    The winner; SMC ofcourse by unanimous, 80 billion pesos plus SC decision.

    Rubbing salt  to “The joke of the Century”.. according to the Ombudsman…Ha,ha,ha…LOL ! Ayawan na pag nagkataon.

    • boldyak

      nawala ang attention sa kay Jardeleza, ginawang diversion……bakit si Jardeleza hindi na disqualify may kaso rin pala….heto na po ang sinasabi ko……akala ko kung disqualified si Delima desqualified din si Jardeleza…wahahahaha…mali pala ako…talagag kapalan ng mukah na ito…

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_HOCSZLQBWVGXXI2NZJ2P7LMPHA Leond Yobar

    Dapat lang ma disqualified siya.

  • mekeni62

    very good. now let the real Pnoy puppet come in. Pnoy for sure won’t take this lightly. It’s still Carpio or Sereno.

    • marionics

      i’m for carpio. sereno next he he. tapos si karen jimeno  yum yum

    • boldyak

      the real puppet will be Jardeleza…mas malakas si UNCLE…wahahaha

  • kalaban_mo

    This JBC rule should be adapted by all government institutions, from president to barangay tanod!!! Pwede naman pala di mag appoint ng my mga pending cases sa Supreme Court e, bakit di na gawin sa Executive at Legistive. Malamang ubos ang government officials!!! Ok lang, My mga next generation of Pilipinos naman tayo!!! Ang mga kabataan!!!

  • ricelander

    Supremely ironic that deLima was disqualified on account of disbarment cases filed against her arising from the very same acts that earned her great praises from the Yellow Forces and the President himself.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/ZBL7MHX5V24AO43YSRZDCAYRWI SJ

      Mmm… I don’t think it’s ironic. What would be ironic is if she becomes the head of the very same court she previously disobeyed.

    • http://www.dafk.net/what/ Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

       That’s what you get when you do not follow the law, but follow someone else interpretation of how to implement ‘justice.’

      Somehow, there is a right method where you can follow the law, and implement justice at the same time. It is hard, but it is fair.

  • kalaban_mo

    Dapat gamitin ng Comelec ang rule ng JBC. E-disqualifed na agad ang may mga pending case bago pa maiboto ng mga bobong botanteng Pilipino na tumatanggap ng lagay at mga walang prinsipyo sa buhay!!!

  • kalaban_mo

    COMELEC, kung nagbabasa kayo ng news, baka may matutunan kayo sa JBC!!! simpleng rule lang un diba. Andali intindihin!!! Kaya nyo ba gawin!!! 

  • kalaban_mo

    Mga kababayan, sige nga kung favor kayo na i-adapt ng COMELEC ang rule ng JBC. i like nyo nga tong comments ko hehehehehe…

  • Belekoy

    This is one small step of a group, but one giant leap for all Filipinos, including the former President.

  • ninewest

    Hats off to JBC for adhering to its own rules otherwise sobrang unfair sa ibang friends ko who were disqualified when they applied for judgeship because of pending administrative cases (whether may merit or harassment lang). At least, ang JBC and IBP di nagpa influence sa Malacanang. 

    • popeyee

      Pero bakit hindi na disqualify yong ibang may pending cases?

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_DCPWG3BR7OTRJ6DCO7HD2LTDX4 benche

    Crab mentality na naman ito, marami kasi naiingit kay de Lima, hay naku buhay Pinoy, puro inggit inggit inggit ang nasa katawan!

    • poltergeist_fuhrer

      loser

    • boldyak

      ay ngengot…wahahaha

  • Sarkasmos

    Judicial independence prevails! Bravo to the principled JBC members who did not succumb to external forces.

  • White24

    It’s Sereno…

    • marionics

      carpio

      • http://www.dafk.net/what/ Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

         Jimeno

      • marionics

        talaga namaaaaaaan! tigas talaga ng pagnanasa mo (hmp sige na nga, ako din he he) kay karen j.

      • http://www.dafk.net/what/ Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

         sayang, kung naging member lang tayo ng JBC, 2 votes na kaagad.

      • marionics

        2 votes at ilang ulos he he

      • http://whywontgodhealamputees.com/ Lucky Luciano

        Jimeno as a CJ? what a waste. FHM is the place to be

      • http://www.dafk.net/what/ Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

        That too.

    • Zamboangueno

       No to Sereno nor to Carpio!

      sana si Sec Kim nalang or si ombudsman ok pa.

      • White24

        :)

  • Fulpol

    the two have pending administrative cases. and still running for the post. what is that?

    • marionics

      good question (but who the heck are you and what have you done to our fulpol? hahaha)

      • Zamboangueno

         baket ikaw ?

      • marionics

        uy gusto makisali. private joke namin ni pol ito di ka kasali chong he he

  • http://www.dafk.net/what/ Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

    Hmmm.

    Did the fat lady sing na ba? Baka may ‘exception’ nanaman. I’d put this to rest when there’s a new CJ na.

    • marionics

      wala na yan. aside from an mr (which i think is malabo na) her only recourse would be the sc and i don’t see her getting anything from there he he

      • http://www.dafk.net/what/ Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

         i hope so.

      • marionics

        actually ka chika ko naman sila leila at sixto at romy kasi we had common clients at a time or two. and i think si leila e magaling na election law practicioner and bilib din naman ako dun sa nakipagtigasan siya na di makaalis si gloria noon pero may nabasa akong doj opinion niya lately lang na talagang nakakawala ng bilib he he. i don’t like her as cj kasi ala siya sa kalibre ng pagkaabugado na kailangan sa level na yan

      • http://www.dafk.net/what/ Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

         Sir, share naman, reference to the opinion.

      • marionics

        dehin na siguro pare. although i don’t like her to be cj i still consider her as a friend and i don’t want to give anyone black pro bala against her. anyway you seem like a very capable researcher. look over the opinions yourself. i’m sure you will find something he he

      • http://www.dafk.net/what/ Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

         I have some inkling (teasers/gist) of the opinions from the DOJ web site, I just can’t get the full text. And there’s plenty enough opinions there, I might focus on which you specifically do not agree with.

        I would appreciate if you can lead me to the full text.

        Incidentally, interesting reading on her “STATEMENT ON IBP GROUNDS FOR DENIAL OF DE LIMA APPEAL”

    • boldyak

      meron exception….si Jardeleza may pending case pero hindi disqualified…exception to the rule pa rin yan di ba?

      • http://www.dafk.net/what/ Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

        I think maybe I should clarify.

        Baka may pakulo nanaman ang palasyo para ma include nanaman si Sec. De Lima. We know for a fact that palace lawyers are looking for loopholes or exceptions. I’ll celebrate when we have a new CJ.

  • poltergeist_fuhrer

    carpio will make it….that will be good for the country

    • marionics

      hmmmm…talaga pol? for once magkasangayon tayo? o sarcastic ka lang? he he

      • JuanTamadachi

        don’t look a gift horse in the mouth lol..

      • poltergeist_fuhrer

        toinks…

      • poltergeist_fuhrer

        of all nominated…he is the lesser evil…he is better than sereno or anyone else…

        he shud be the CJ if not that stupid previous admin made corona as one

      • marionics

        he he okidoki…i concur

      • Zamboangueno

        naks, gusto mo lang makaisa kay pol e :)

        pol, pagbigyan mo na kasi… on-topic, wala ako gusto kahit isa sa mga nominies eh… sana si Atty FG arroyo nalang heheheh …. o mga haters..joke lang.

      • marionics

        nonga kami ni pol di mo ba alam? he he

      • poltergeist_fuhrer

        now u r happy that we have the same thinking on hu shud be the next…

      • marionics

        i am always happy naman but i am glad we agree now he he

      • poltergeist_fuhrer

        on this particular issue man lang…hahaha

        but never ull see me riding in the yellow submarine like you

      • marionics

        In the town where I was born,
        Lived a man who sailed to sea,
        And he told us of his life,
        In the land of submarines, 

        So we sailed on to the sun,
        Till we found the sea green,
        And we lived beneath the waves,
        In our yellow submarine,

        We all live in a yellow submarine,
        yellow submarine, yellow submarine,
        We all live in a yellow submarine,
        yellow submarine, yellow submarine.

        And our friends are all aboard,
        Many more of them live next door,
        And the band begins to play.

        (Trumpets play)

        We all live in a yellow submarine,
        yellow submarine, yellow submarine,
        We all live in a yellow submarine,
        yellow submarine, yellow submarine.

        (Full speed ahead, Mr. Barkley, full speed ahead!
        Full speed over here, sir!
        All together! All together!
        Aye, aye, sir, fire!
        Captain! Captain!)

        As we live a life of ease(life of ease)
        Every one of us(every one of us) has all we need,(has all we need) 
        Sky of blue,(sky of blue) and sea green,(sea of green)
        In our yellow(In our yellow) submarine.(submarine) ( Haha! )

        We all live in a yellow submarine,
        yellow submarine, yellow submarine,
        We all live in a yellow submarine,
        yellow submarine, yellow submarine.

        (fading)

        We all live in a yellow submarine,
        yellow submarine, yellow submarine,
        We all live in a yellow submarine,
        yellow submarine, yellow submarine.

      • http://whywontgodhealamputees.com/ Lucky Luciano

        it’s song about LSD. or Landing Sa Daan.

        jk

      • marionics

        Paul said in an interview, “I wrote that in bed one night, as a kid’s story… I knew it would get [drug] connotations, but it really was a children’s song. I just loved the idea of kids singing it… Kids will understand it easier than adults…”
        Source(s):
        BeatleSongs, William J. Dowlding, 1989.

      • poltergeist_fuhrer

        yellow submarine of yellow fanatics and yellow ribbons…suffering of yellow fever…

      • marionics

        I’m comin’ home, I’ve done my timeNow I’ve got to know what is and isn’t mineIf you received my letter telling you I’d soon be freeThen you’ll know just what to doIf you still want meIf you still want me
        CHORUS
        Whoa, tie a yellow ribbon ’round the ole oak treeIt’s been three long yearsDo ya still want me? (still want me)If I don’t see a ribbon ’round the ole oak treeI’ll stay on the busForget about usPut the blame on meIf I don’t see a yellow ribbon ’round the ole oak treeBus driver, please look for me’cause I couldn’t bear to see what I might seeI’m really still in prisonAnd my love, she holds the keyA simple yellow ribbon’s what I need to set me freeI wrote and told her please
        (CHORUS)
        Now the whole damned bus is cheerin’And I can’t believe I seeA hundred yellow ribbons ’round the ole oak treeI’m comin’ home, mmm, mmm(Tie a ribbon ’round the ole oak tree)(Tie a ribbon ’round the ole oak tree)(Tie a ribbon ’round the ole oak tree)
        FADE
        (Tie a ribbon ’round the ole oak tree)(Tie a ribbon ’round the ole oak tree)(Tie a ribbon ’round the ole oak tree)

      • marionics

        So long boy you can take my place, got my papers I’ve got my pay
        So pack my bags and I’ll be on my way to yellow river
        Put my guns down the war is won
        Fill my glass high the time has come
        I’m going back to the place that I love yellow river

        Yellow river yellow river is in my mind and in my eyes
        Yellow river yellow river is in my blood it’s the place I love
        Got no time for explanation got no time to lose
        Tomorrow night you’ll find me
        Sleeping underneath the moon at yellow river

        Cannon fire lingers in my mind I’m so glad that I’m still alive
        And I’ve been gone for such a long time from yellow river
        I remember the nights were cool I can still see the water pool
        And I remember the girl that I knew from yellow river

        Yellow river yellow river is in my mind and in my eyes
        Yellow river yellow river is in my blood it’s the place I love
        Got no time for explanation got no time to lose
        Tomorrow night you’ll find me
        Sleeping underneath the moon at yellow river

        Yellow river yellow river is in my mind and in my eyes
        Yellow river yellow river is in my blood it’s the place I love

      • marionics

        It was an itsy, bitsy, teenie, weenie,
        Yellow, polka dot bikini,
        That she wore for the first time today.
        An itsy, bitsy, teenie, weenie,
        Yellow, polka dot bikini,
        So, in the locker she wanted to stay.
        (Two, three, four, stick around,)
        (We’ll tell you more.)

      • marionics

        I’m just mad about Saffron
        Saffron’s mad about me
        I’m just mad about Saffron
        She’s just mad about me

        {Refrain}
        They call me mellow yellow
        (Quite rightly)
        They call me mellow yellow
        (Quite rightly)
        They call me mellow yellow

    • http://whywontgodhealamputees.com/ Lucky Luciano

       carpio over de lima kahit walang pulutan.

      • poltergeist_fuhrer

        sereno might be a problem…a big problem in case…de lima might be the pawn…

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_QZZKXPEA67I7HELEIYM35QVYFA Jon

    Justice and fair play still prevail at the end of the day.
    No matter how hard some people may try to manipulate and subvert it to suit their wants.

  • Hey_Dudes

    This group which is pretty much using it’s acronym “J B C” (Jokers Bunch Conspirators) to the hilt should merit the turkey award forever. It went walking across so many miles and yet – when the need to come up with someone the country can depend upon to uphold true interpretation of justice, it hems, hues, deferred and lacking confidence among themselves.  Renato C. Corona also went to this process and the question is, was his selection as the country’s chief justice a wise decision?  Many people including myself wonders, what the purpose and of what good is having this J B C in the selection process of supreme court justices?  This should be the primary role of the president of the country so that if his or her decision turned out bad, he or she is the only one to blame.  In this case, how many are there in this J B C craaap?  Should they not be the entity the country should place the blame if the selection turns out to be just as bad?

    • poltergeist_fuhrer

      bitter!..hahaha

    • acidicboy

      mag kit-kat break ka muna, para di masyadong bitter ang taste mo.

    • spearheads

      Heto basahan. Wipe your behind then your eyes, nose, ears and stop crying loser!

  • http://whywontgodhealamputees.com/ Lucky Luciano

    So be it Corona.
    So be it de Lima

    Stop whining, Move on.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/JKMASTZ6ILTZXOG42337ZESS4I ray

    dapat lang…..nananaig pa rin ang batas after all…. akala ko’y palulusutin uli ni penoy

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_EDXEVEFHW2ZT5VWHDWBNM6XGE4 RyanE

    I guess it will be a contest between senior AJ Carpio and AJ Sereno..

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_AFDQQH2M3OD6ZGBJNJ34UZHIV4 Enrico

    Buti naman at nasunod rin ang existing rules…Sayang din si De Lima kaya lang may masamang motibo kontra GMA kaya ayan di nagtagumpay.

    • popeyee

      Pero bakit hindi nai-apply yong rules sa iba pang may mga pending cases?

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_AFDQQH2M3OD6ZGBJNJ34UZHIV4 Enrico

        Sino dun si Carpio? Wala na syang pending na kaso.

      • popeyee

        Si jardeliza ang isa. Yong isa naman di bale na total di naman naksama sa “long list”, hindi short list..

      • bbguevara

        Si jardeleza walang prime facie case. Si herbosa cleared of the charges Aug.1 pa.

  • 4kingdaddy

    why is almost every comments here are so hateful on de lima?….kung ayaw n’yo kay de lima, ibalik na lang si corona….at least we have a CJ stting on the throne of the supreme court with a crown…..or better yet, why not one of you haters apply for the post…one of you must be better than her!!!!…i am assuming, of course!!!!!!….

    • poltergeist_fuhrer

      toinks…ang layo ng isip mo…kung hindi si de lima, si corona na lang???kayo talaga mga yellow ribbons…walang magawa kundi comparison…comparing aquino with gma, combaring ondoy with last wiks tragedy…now comparing de lima with corona???hahaha

      mas marami magagaling sa mga nominees kaysa kay de lima….

      as if u r implying “we have no choice but delima”…it S-U-C-K-S!!!

      • 4kingdaddy

        you must be a genius!!!!!!!!!!!….hail to pesteng geist, the new cj!!!! 

      • poltergeist_fuhrer

        move on…gising!!!…wala na si corona…move on….

      • 4kingdaddy

        i can’t move….i’m sitting on my cozy chair….a retiree like me need not move on….i wake up when i want to…i’ve done my share….my son is now running our business, pestenggeist….hehehe…sarap ng retiree…..

      • TEAM PNOY

        I Concur!

      • poltergeist_fuhrer

        so what

    • acidicboy

      typical. yellow. kool-aid. drinker’s. reply.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_E3CE56OQVPC4RPYD2NR4VD3SUE Bert

      why hateful? because malacanang’s evil design of putting up a PUPPET CJ, courtesy of Delima is HATEFUL……..

      • Taiko_Kauna

        Pnoy, for all you  know, can still come up with someone out of the 8 that will be sympathetic to his cause,  to hound to the uttermost part of the earth your idol, the tiny but greedy small woman and his cohorts,SO DON’T CELEBRATE yet. Perhaps you people have forgotten that he is still the president!

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_E3CE56OQVPC4RPYD2NR4VD3SUE Bert

        indeed, you want a PUPPET CJ? but at least with de leila out, we are left with a smaller puppet….from a giant st bernard pup to a mini pincher or a tiny poodle…….hehe

        and that tiny lady is now back to the hospital, no she’s much threat to pnoy’s cause no more…so move on….

  • patriotic_act

    I almost liked De Lima, but after she declared that she will NOT SUPPORT and will LOBBY AGAINST the amendments to push back the “Criminal Liability” of Kid Criminals to 12 years old or the “Revised Juvenile Justive Law”.. 

    I would say.. “Good Riddance” 

  • UrHONOR

    SAYANG….tuloy-tuloy na sana ang pagpapalis ng bayan sa mga MMM.  Sayang na sayang na pagkakataon.  Nawala ang isang maganda at mabuting bagay para sa mamamayan sa pamamagitan ng technicality.  KUNG ako ang pangulo ng RP, i-aapoint ko ang kung sino man ang gusto kong makakatulong sa paglilinis ng bayan sa mga cancerous elements na kumakain sa katawan ng bayan na parang kalawang sa bakal. Sayang talaga!

    • acidicboy

      you mean to say “sayang dumadaan sa patakaran at regulasyon ang pagpili ng mahistrado sa korte suprema. technicality lang ito. kung ikaw ang pangulo nag ala-marcos ka na lang at bahala ka na magpili ng kaibigan na pwedeng ilagay sa puwesto, para mawalan ng takot ang mga kakampi at kamag-anak na mahuli at makulong kung may abusong mangyari.”

      ang galing mo, saan ka ba nag-aral?

      • UrHONOR

        DOON sa hindi mo pinag-aralan!

        Gagawa-gawa ka ng sapantaha mo, tapos ikakarga mo sa iba ang ginawa mong pananalamangka sa utak mong sing nipis ng papel de hapon…. at may gana at lakas ka pa ng loob mang-insulto!  Katoliko ka, ano?

        Hetong tip: Mag-aral  ka munang umunawa ng binabasa mo bago ka rumatsada para hindi ka nalalagay sa alanganing nagpapatunay kung gaano kagaan ang taglay mong dekorasyon sa pagitan ng 2 mong balikat.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_E3CE56OQVPC4RPYD2NR4VD3SUE Bert

      better luck next time…….but for now, let’s shed that crocodile tears for de lima….hehe

      • UrHONOR

        TAMA…better luck next time.  

        Hindi ko kilalang personal si Leila De Lima.  Ang pagkakilala ko sa kanya ay yong natutunghayan ko lamang sa mga media.  At ayon sa aking na narinig at nabasa, si Leila ay may taglay na yagbadoodles upang harapin ang kahit na sinong mataas ang ehem.  At yan ay hindi theoretical, kundi actual.That’s how I see it.  If others have different pespectives, so mote it be..  Though not always right and correct, majority rules.

    • spearheads

      Di mo binasa yong editorial kahapon na, “PNoycchio bends, Delima, Tupas, and Musngi sniff.” But the smell was too obnoxious that’s why Delima was short-circuited as in nakuryente. O heto basahan, punasan mo na yang luha, luga, at uhog mo loser.

      • UrHONOR

        OO nga naman.  Huwag kang mabahala at malungkot…..may pag-asa pa ang pagbabalik ninyong mga TNL na mga MMM!

  • JJF724

    sa mga may kaso si DeLima lang ang na disqualified?  And some people whos complaining about JBC is going to break the rules is now okay with that?  Hmmmm

    I just hope that the mafia will not succeeds on claiming back the CJ post.

    • bbguevara

      Jordaleza was cleared due to absence of prima facie. Herbosa was cleared of charges last Aug. 1 pa. No rules were bent after all.

      • JJF724

        all is good then…. capiz

  • Cal_Reznick

    Disqualified?

    Knowing De Lima, she will just ignore and defy that decision and with help from the President…she’ll be back on that shortlist in no time.

    I’m curious to see how this turns out.

  • 4kingdaddy

    o, ‘yong iba d’yan na nasa internet shop, baka maubusan kayo ng pambili ng hapunan…sige, gutom ang aabutin n’yo sa gabing ito….hehehe…..

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_E3CE56OQVPC4RPYD2NR4VD3SUE Bert

      unga no? and how are you doing inside carandang’s malacanang comm group command center? Malamig ba? Sarap waldasin pera ng bayan no?

      • 4kingdaddy

        for your info, dumdum…i am a retiree, living comfortably and spending my own money….my business now is being run by my son, helping those in need of help (by giving them jobs even if it’s considered odd jobs),…and you…what have you done lately for the people suffering from this recent calamity????….pasarap ka lang d’yan sa internet shop…..bili ka naman ng laptap….o baka wala ka ring pambayad sa koryente….may koryente ba ang inuupahan mong bahay…..o baka cpu yan ng pinagtratrabahuhan mo…..baka mahuli ka…ingat lang….hehehe….

      • marionics

        ikaw naman kasi e batu bato sa langit e may tinamaan…so ayun, nagalit hahaha

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_E3CE56OQVPC4RPYD2NR4VD3SUE Bert

        kaya ka rin siguro nag react because you’re hit by the same stone, no?  so how are you doing inside carandang’s malacanang comm group command center? Malamig ba? Sarap waldasin pera ng bayan no?

      • marionics

        oooops sorry sapul na namaaaaan hahaha

      • 4kingdaddy

        itong si berting labrador masyadong maramdamin…este….mainggitin…hehehe…sapul nga….

      • marionics

        e olats ka naman kasi sa kanya at naka modelong ipad nga daw siya habang nageempake ng relief goods hahaha. wala ka naman palang sinabi e. bukod tangi at dalisay ang kalooban ng kausap mo chong. hala sambahin mo na siay he he

      • 4kingdaddy

        oo nga….sana binalot na rin siya ng kanyang “staff” at isinama sa “relief goods” na inimpake…matulungin din pala, eh….hehehe….

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_E3CE56OQVPC4RPYD2NR4VD3SUE Bert

        kuha nyo manongs, matulungin ini…..at mga wala kayong sinabe…hehe

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_E3CE56OQVPC4RPYD2NR4VD3SUE Bert

        ooopppss nag react ulit, sakit mabukulan no?……hehehe

      • marionics

        pareng berting pamana na lang ng modelo mong ipad ha atsaka puede bang pmagpadala sa iyo ng relief goods at napaka dalisay ng kalooban mo hahaha

        Pinasisigla ang sanga, inihahatid sa kasibulan

        Sa mga taong dalisay ang kalooban

        Handog mo ay bulaklak ng kabanalan.

        Diwa mo’t kaluluwa’y amin nawang makapiling

        Liwanag ng kamalaya’y pagdaup-daupin

        At nang mabanaag bukang-liwayway sa panginorin

        Yakapin ang kalayaang inihahatid ng hangin.

        Matining ang loob mo sa harap ng kamatayan

        Talim ng kaaway nilupig ng katatagan

        Mula sa pira-pirasong bahagi

        Ng katawan mong nilapastangan

        Pananalig ay umagos sa bawat kaparangan.

        Tadhana mo’y sa Tayabas magbuwis ng buhay

        Burol ng pasakit sa ami’y nakatunghay

        Nagparikit sa simulain,

        Lumaganap ang kapatiran

        Nagningas ang kasaysayan

        Naging apoy ang kaliwanagan.

        Umiikid ang buhay,

        Nagbabago ang kaanyuan

        May pagdadalisay sa dambana ng sambayanan

        Nakadarang sa init ang aming pananagutan

        Maghahari ang araw, mapaparam ang karimlan.

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_E3CE56OQVPC4RPYD2NR4VD3SUE Bert

        poetic non-sense…hehe

      • marionics

        he he medyo nung lunes pa ito pareng bert a. pero sige. ika nga ni john keating sa dea poets society e – ”
        We don’t read and write poetry because it’s cute. We read and write poetry because we are members of the human race. And the human race is filled with passion. And medicine, law, business, engineering, these are noble pursuits and necessary to sustain life. But poetry, beauty, romance, love, these are what we stay alive for. To quote from Whitman, “O me! O life!… of the questions of these recurring; of the endless trains of the faithless… of cities filled with the foolish; what good amid these, O me, O life?” Answer. That you are here – that life exists, and identity; that the powerful play goes on and you may contribute a verse. That the powerful play *goes on* and you may contribute a verse. What will your verse be? ”

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_E3CE56OQVPC4RPYD2NR4VD3SUE Bert

        aba manong, pareho lang pala tayo, “living comfortably and spending our own money”….except that im no retiree yet….hehe

        and fyi, while keying this post on my latest ipad model, am just having a break packing those relief goods for our typhoon victims, with my staff op cors….kuryente? no probs, have lots of them….

        btw, how’s electricity inside carandang’s, este, YOUR office? hehe

      • 4kingdaddy

        my electricity is fine…if you see a house with a 25kw standby generator with two 3,000 k lpg tanks that powers it, that’s my house…no problem with brown outs……and you’re welcome to have a drink with me by the pool…see you soooooon!!!!! 

      • billy gunner

         i’ve heard your excuse form another blogger here not long ago. seems like all your excuse for blogging to defend the president is that you’re all retirees! LOL

      • 4kingdaddy

        defend???.are you hallucinating???…i never liked this mama’s boy since he was a congressman….i did not vote for him and i cross parties when i vote…i choose the lesser of the evils…..aren’t they all evils??…i praise anyone when they did something good for our country and lambast anyone who takes advantage of the oppressed……check my blogs…..

  • billy gunner

    pigs deserve the pigsty. they’re even banned in some countries. what will the other countries say if they hear we have one in the supreme court??? good job jbc!

  • neverneverstop

    YOU’RE THE WEAKEST LINK DE LIMA.. GOODBYE!

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/AMG5EDI2JBQRL4Z5H2L7ED4OQA yahoo-AMG5EDI2JBQRL4Z5H2L7ED4OQA

       hahaha…..mga alipores ni gma itong mga ito….
      sugod magnakaw tayo sa kaban ng bayan
      magbenta tayo ng second hand na helicopter sa brand new na presyo
      hahaha….ang sarap yata ng buhay sa panahon ni gma
      libre ang magnakaw walang huli
      lahat may presyo pati mga obispo
      hahaha

  • neverneverstop

    BEH BUTI NGA!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_4C2SFYIH52Y2KR7QPZPHJO2XQQ sl1

    Sayang na disqualify si De Lima….but if it is done without bias then okay lang!  Whoever is choicen sana maging simula na ng mabilis na pag bibigay ng hustiya sa ating bansa.

  • $20733759

    The people’s clamor now is to know …who among the JBC members voted in favor of whom! It is JBC’s obligation to supply the details in response to this query! Furthermore, who voted for De Lima’s disqualification and the individual members’ reason are also the public’s concern. Transparency anyone?

    • spearheads

      Sa kakaiyak mo sa nabalahura mong alaga di mo na nabasa yong balita, Siguro title lang ang binasa mo at umatungal ka na dyan. Basahin mo ulit at intindihin ang balita, hane?

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/TGSMKB6ZWYHH3GYXFHISXVSBHU Modesto

    to my mind delima is one of the best preforming,delivering results with no holds barred: justice secretary,the philippines ever had,and is not corrupt,period

    • http://whywontgodhealamputees.com/ Lucky Luciano

      She’s perfect for DOJ.

    • acidicboy

      really? aside from gma’s and abalos’ case, what has she actually done?  the cj case isn’t hers- its the actions of the legislative.  has she brought to justice any big time smuggler? how about leaders of drug syndicates?  how about professional squatter syndicates?  other corrupt government officials past and present?  has she invested/hired more government prosecutors?  when you said she is the “best performing” what exactly are you pointing at?  

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_E3CE56OQVPC4RPYD2NR4VD3SUE Bert

      owwsss, really, so what has she done so far with Lacson’s Dacer-Corbito double murder case? Didn’t she chicken out? No holds barred pala ha……

      • drew_casta

        She stood her ground. It was the CA which held that Lacson can surface pending the resolution of the case against him.

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_E3CE56OQVPC4RPYD2NR4VD3SUE Bert

        nope, lacson, Pnoy’s political ally, was welcomed IN RED CARPET inside malacanang by Pnoy himself. That showed strong signal to De Leila that Lacson is untouchable, hence, the chickening…..hehe

      • drew_casta

        I thought we are talking about the case. haha. My bad. Well, in fairness to her, she pursued Lacson when the warrant issued by the RTC was still effective. Chickening out? I don’t think so. Her silence as to the merits of the case can be explained by the subjudice rule. Hope you have come across that concept. If not, you can always google it up. :)

  • marciano3rd

    It’s time for Laila de Lima to move on. She should accept the verdict.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_MZOKC6X7Q52Z4E5VLYNB7GF72Y Kaloy

    Doj Secretaey De Lima should accept the JBC ruling. She should stay with DOJ where she can be most effective.

    In the meantime,  the President can appoint Carpio or Sereno. Delima may be qualified for Associate Justice after clearing her case.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/KISP4XFWDO7PMCBCIAG5XEYQ7M Peregrino Natividad

    De Lima’s loyalty to P-noy is 100 Percent. The rest CAN BE BOUGHT BY GLORIA! Why can’t Pinoy appoint the Chief Justice he wanted like what Gloria had done!

    • rising_phoenix40

      Peregrino, Corona’s appointment was based on the JBC shortlist submitted to Arroyo, and not from out of nowhere.  Magbasa ka muna.  Stop parading your ignorance.

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_E3CE56OQVPC4RPYD2NR4VD3SUE Bert

        oouuucchhhh….

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/2ORSHXEGITQDUG3EBH6GYXUVKA Mr. Suave

        Aray! Utak lamok kasi kung sumagot. Ayan tuloy parang taeng natapakan.

    • indiosbravos2002

      Because the JBC who appointed Corona was lutong lugao. Even the objections set by the Basa’s was not considered. Railroaded ba.

  • Jun Go

    I guess based on this Carpio could get the post soon.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2VLO53PRSSY76BZOWLOHJDM33M jeray

    hahaha…..

  • ARRANCAR

    poor woman she prostituted herself in front of media and TV what a shame how she salivated that position almost to the point of baring all herself just to be the next CJ of the SC. now what face can she show to the people how she begged and crawl onto her knees in exchange of including in the nomination WHAT TOTAL SHAME!! oh well, it shows her character a person will do everything including her soul a position and soiled her name, reputation for the SC seat tsk…tsk… RESIGN IRREVOCABLE SAVE YOUR REPUTATION IF THEIRS LEFT IN IT MS. LEILA DE LIMA!!!!! 

    • amelius23

      TO DOJ secretary, there is no reason to be ashamed of if you were not on the shortlist, the nomination to the JBC was an honor enough for a practicing  lawyer like you madam. There is another day to tarry.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/NEYEA2ISXCNDUUYAOVODRLA5BQ Timothy

      she thinks she can twist anything in her favor. sino ba sya??? she’s dangerous to hold a powerful position, she will abuse.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/AMG5EDI2JBQRL4Z5H2L7ED4OQA yahoo-AMG5EDI2JBQRL4Z5H2L7ED4OQA

       poor ARROYO she prostituted herself in front of media and TV what a shame
      how ARROYO salivated that presidency almost to the point of baring all
      herself just to be the next president of the phils. now what face can she show to
      the people how she begged and crawl onto her knees in exchange of
      including in the nomination WHAT TOTAL SHAME!! oh well, it shows ARROYO’S
      character a person will do everything including her soul a position and
      soiled her name, reputation for the PRESIDENT’S seat tsk…tsk…

  • im_not_convinced

    I bet Pnoy Chooses Sereno who was his choice in the 1st place. the provoked negative publicity on De Lima was just to hide Sereno from the scrutinizing eye of the public. As the youngest Associate Justice, Sereno will be in power for more than 20 years as Chief Justice.

    KKK all the way. kaklase sereno will be there to watch over the interest of the Cojuangco Aquino clan long after Pnoy steps down. Luisita Hascienda will go back to Pnoy’s family.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_EDXEVEFHW2ZT5VWHDWBNM6XGE4 RyanE

      I think there’s a big chance for acting CJ Carpio to get the post. PNoy might consider SC tradition where the most senior usually becomes CJ.

      • tootsie_roll

        I hope so, sir.

    • poltergeist_fuhrer

      if that is the case…penoy will be protected from the lawsuits after his term…

      • http://whywontgodhealamputees.com/ Lucky Luciano

        If that is the case…The guy they labeled as mongoloid turned out to be the smarter one because he secured his exit points first instead of racing to the airport’s check-ins against the DOJ Sec.

      • poltergeist_fuhrer

        it doesnt need to be smart for one to think of it…

    • Liquor Depot

      Noynoy and Sereno do not know each other personally and were never classmates.  Check your “facts”.

      • im_not_convinced

        you check your facts. It is common, undenied knowledge that Noynoy and Sereno were classmates in college. PDI itself ran a story on it when she was appointed Associate Justice. the youngest in Philippine History and bi-passed many more senior than her.

      • http://whywontgodhealamputees.com/ Lucky Luciano

         Ignore. He’s drunk.

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_E3CE56OQVPC4RPYD2NR4VD3SUE Bert

        are you sure, is that what carandang told you?

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/JKMASTZ6ILTZXOG42337ZESS4I ray

        paanong di magkakilala eh si penoy ang nag appoint kay sereno sa sc

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/6NVJE4NYLGDSCO6KQ4GWP35SVM Macario

    and that’s all she wrote…

  • mad_as_Hamlet

    A rather long shortlist.  But short enough by one  that could have otherwise spoiled the menu, and even the cook himself.

  • http://twitter.com/reignclark reign clark

    hindi man lang nakasama si atty. katrina legarda! wtf!

    • marionics

      o si raul p man lang

  • ARRANCAR

    now pnoy will surely appoint sereno the woman who wants the taxpayer money’s pay the cojuangco family BILLIONS be the next CJ for sure since she was appointed by pnoy as AJ of the SC and with her as CJ at the helm the cases against pnoy after his term ends on 2016 he will be shielded from any cases filed against pnoy. all this brouhaha about de lima we are all duped by pnoy silently keeping sereno out of limelight the issues against sereno was not publicly discuss or mentioned. 

  • Fulpol

    Carpio is 62 or 63(?). while Abad is 68, 2 years more to serve from the compulsory retirement age for Justice in Supreme Court.

    If Abad will get the nod, he will retire on 2014. Noynoying is still the President. Then Noynoying can appoint Carpio as Chief Justice. Carpio still have 5-6 years to serve as Chief Justice. 2 years left to accomplished the desire of Noynoying, the problem on Hacienda Luisita just compensation.

    Abad, the interim Chief Justice, who will just sit, do nothing in favor to Noynoying, and wait until Carpio replace him.

    Gap filler… 2 years, enough time to forget the circus in Corona’s impeachment.
     

  • eltee mulawin

    >>> My guess is … Villanueva or Abad. Pero the “Judicial Is Mine” episode of Noy2′s teleserye still not yet in finale. Wait, see and read soon …and “SURPRISE.! ! ! ending of episode “Judicial Is Mine”.

  • rising_phoenix40

    Bye, girl. You are equally talented and beautiful, but we must select the eight finalists.  Please don’t call us. We’ll call you. : )

    • boldyak

      BEAUTIFUL????????? Oh my goodness…wahahaha

    • spearheads

      Instead of “beautiful” try Botikol. In case you don’t know what it means, ask anyone who speaks visayan language.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_GUZISWUMVDD5QJUC7GBJKEM7XA prangka

    Hey de Lima, you need handkerchief? 

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/AMG5EDI2JBQRL4Z5H2L7ED4OQA yahoo-AMG5EDI2JBQRL4Z5H2L7ED4OQA

       si arroyo ang bigyan mo
      pati na si corona…..hahahahaha

  • ARRANCAR

    we are all being played dumb by pnoy SERENO will get the SC seat since she will protect the cojuangco and aquino from any cases after 2016, the issues against corona will be played again SERENO as CJ she will shield pnoy from any litigation and cases once the immunity of pnoy is finally remove. SERENO will be his praetorian guard at the SC protecting pnoy!!

    • marlaw

      Ang galing naman ng analysis mo. Kaya proud ako sayo dahil sa pagiging matalino mo. Dapat ang kagaya ng intregerong pag iisip mo ang siyang namumuno sa Pilipinas.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/AMG5EDI2JBQRL4Z5H2L7ED4OQA yahoo-AMG5EDI2JBQRL4Z5H2L7ED4OQA

        hahaha…..mga alipores ni gma itong mga ito….
      sugod magnakaw tayo sa kaban ng bayan
      magbenta tayo ng second hand na helicopter sa brand new na presyo
      hahaha….ang sarap yata ng buhay sa panahon ni gma
      libre ang magnakaw walang huli
      lahat may presyo pati mga obispo
      hahaha

  • twitgurl

    ang kapal kasi ng taba hahaha.. 

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/AMG5EDI2JBQRL4Z5H2L7ED4OQA yahoo-AMG5EDI2JBQRL4Z5H2L7ED4OQA

        hahaha…..mga alipores ni gma itong mga ito….
      sugod magnakaw tayo sa kaban ng bayan
      magbenta tayo ng second hand na helicopter sa brand new na presyo
      hahaha….ang sarap yata ng buhay sa panahon ni gma
      libre ang magnakaw walang huli
      lahat may presyo pati mga obispo
      hahaha

  • CaseBlue

    I thought Jardaleza had a pending case … 

    • boldyak

      Utos ni Uncle isama sa short list..wahahaha

  • 12JEM

     Sobrang nagalit ang IBP (particularly si Libarios) sa di pag-enforce ng defective TRO…para

    makatakas si GMA puntang Germany or Dominican Republic…..

    Kaya kinasuhan ng disbarment si deLima….

    Pero salamat Madame de Lima…kundi dahil sa iyo……wala na si Gloria….nasa Germany or DR na.

    Mabuhay ang matapang na babaye ng IRIGA.  Mabuhay ka.

    • billy gunner

      hanep ang conspiracy theory mo pare daig mo pang taga hollywood!

      in case you’re still not getting it, IBP (where de lima is a member) got enraged due to de lima’s disobedience to a lawful order which is the TRO and not because arroyo could not leave the country, tonto!

  • Fulpol

    shortlist? or still a long list? 

    out from 22 nominees, down to eight. it’s still a long list. is this a guessing game? guessing made by JBC to satisfy the taste of Noynoying.. but one was dumped.. a bad taste. 

    I guessed… Carpio because Carpio and his cousin Conchita worked together for the conviction of Corona

    I guessed… Sereno… billions computation on Hacienda Luisita just compensation

    I guessed… Abad.. interim CHief Justice.. just have 2 years left to sit

    others have pending administrative cases, ally of Corona, others ‘pandagdag lang sa listahan”..

  • 4kingdaddy

    ‘yong mga miyembro ng JBC, lahat ng pangalan, may kasamang hon…..honorable nga kaya ang mga ito?…o, baka may magalit na naman sa inyo….napapansin ko lang na napakahilig ng nasa pwesto na tawaging honorable, your honor (hindi naman huwes), your excellency atbp…..hehehe…..hindi….magalang lang tayong mga pinoy, ‘di ba????…

  • speedstream2

    The shortlist does not come as a surprise really, What I’m looking forward to is the President’s choice.

  • JohnDoeGB

    Excluding De Lima is the best decision of the JBC. Else it would have created much issue and would have questioned the integrity and independence of the body. Therefore, let us be happy and be supportive of the move. Let us pray that PNoy will appoint a Chief Justice that has the highest moral ascendance among the nominees. 

  • bongbong39

    Sabi ng cebuano naming abugado dito sa ofis “Gaba nimo De Lima, amaw”..Well, the cebuanos can understand this..Bwehehehe 

    • KpTUL

      That is what we call good riddance. If she is appointed there, it is stupidity ! How can you appoint someone to the top post when this person does not obey orders from the SC ? She can be NBI director or senator or even president but de lima is not an SC material. Kelangan natin yung may breed, hindi yung asal askal.

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/LM2SPIWUAR2U6G3CJX7NVT7ETY ANDRES

        Wow..wala palang ASKAL sa Supreme Court? Bakit ASO-SHIT tawag sa mga justices?

  • TEAM PNOY

    ABAD is a bad choice. 

  • tarikan

    There is a number nine person in the list, Ma. Lourdes Sereno Arthuro Brion. This person is half female half male courtesy of the half-half vote of the House and Senate representatives. Good list but why Jardeliza is on it? I thought he has a pending case? Mr. JBC, not following the rules strictly  or applying it selectively is no good. Male members, if you had played basketball….iyan ang inuumpisahan ng rumble.

    • boldyak

      nagtataka ka pa, tanong mo sa amo ni Chiz at Uncle ng presidente

  • Barak_O

    de singko should stay in her post as doj secretary

    she’s done a great job in there

    more power madam secretary!

  • 12JEM

    My choices were Sereno, Pangalangan, Herbosa, Villanueva and Diokno.

    I hope the choice of the president will be limited to Sereno and Villanueva.

    Para naman mgakroon ng tunay na pagbabago sa Justice System natin.

    .

    • KpTUL

       O yeah ? How bobo can you be ? The appointing authority will always dictate the judiciary. Hulog IQ ko sa ‘yo !

    • marionics

      ay hindi pala kasama si raul p ah. dati perennial shortlister yan. di na sinama this time. siguro tingin nila wala namang pagasang maappoint

  • TEAM PNOY

    Dont cry Leila over spilled milk, even if you will not be chief justice, you are the chief prosecutor naman.

  • athenapallas

    kung hindi dahil kay De Lima e di nakatakas sana si Glorya all the way to Caiman Island at nakahiga sa pearang ninakaw nilang mag-asawa na almost bilyones from the caban ng bayan. Bakit sya idi-disbar? Against the law ba ang pumigil at magpakulong sa isang presidenteng abusado, mandaraya at magnanakaw? More power, Sec. De Lima! Be strong and have faith, what you did was correct at yung mga gustong i-disbar ka sila yung mga directly affected by Glorya’s fall – mga hindi na makapagnakaw sa kaban ng bayan kaya mamatay sila sa gigil at sama ng loob ngayon.

    Ranaldo Zamora candidate for CJ?? God have mercy on us and save our poor miserable country form another Erap alipores na namamaga sa pagiging ganid at self-serving interest lang ang hangad. The Zamoras are the mining industry mafias of the country kaya sobrang yaman nila while they deplore and suck dry our natural resources that truly belongs to us all Filipinos. Sinosolo nila and pay their workers peanuts.

  • KpTUL

    I have seen the CV of SC justice Roberts of the US SC. Sobra ! De lima go back to law school !

    • marlaw

      Eh dapat ireklamo mo ang San Beda dahil pinagraduate nila si De Lima. Pati ang SC dapat din ireklamo mo dahil ipinasa nila sa bar kaya naging abogada. Sino pa ang dapat sisihin mo?

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/LM2SPIWUAR2U6G3CJX7NVT7ETY ANDRES

        Si CORONA..sisihin mo rin..kung hindi siya natanggal..Di sana eh hindi nag-hangad maging CJ si Delima.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/2ORSHXEGITQDUG3EBH6GYXUVKA Mr. Suave

    Pipiliin ni PNOY yung pinakamatanda, tapos in 2 years kapag magretire na, pwede na ulit isali si dilemna este de lima pala.

    • marlaw

      Ang galing ng analysis mo kabayan. Ang mga kagaya mong pag-iisip ang dapat namumuno sa ating bansa dahil may kakakayahang makapag-iisip ng mga bagay na hindi pa nangyayari. Pag ang lider ng bansa ay alam ang hindi pa nangyayari seguradong  maaayos ang mga problema ng bansa. Halimbawa na lang kung magtutuloy-tuloy ang pag ulan o bagyo man at siyempre alam mo in adavance na ganon ang mangyayari, maiiwasan ang mabiktima sa mga baha at kalamidad dahil bago pa man mangyari ay nakalikas na ang mga tao. 

      • marionics

        ikaw naman. theory lang naman yung sa kanya e he he

    • boldyak

      pipiliin ang gusto ni Uncle….wahahaha

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2WTTL6FMGU4D7YZQNHAXBVO2DU Betz Chui

    The lawyers and the IBP mafia…through their massive machinations and their patronage, old, and corrupt view of dispensing justice WON…. change, massive change and reforms which our courts and supreme court needs would in peril….hindi mababago ni Pinoy ang kalakaran sa pagpapatupad ng hustisya, malalim ang ugat ang sistema, – tagumpay sila. Parang hindi rin nagbago at nawalan ng saysay ang pagtangal kay Korona! SISTEMA PA RIN NI CUEVAS ANG UMIRAL!

  • justyouraveragechinoy

    ahahahaha sabi nga you can’t have it all!

  • indiosbravos2002

    Abad, de Castro and Brion belong to Corona’s posse and possibly GMAs sleeper cell. Zamora is a close ally of Erap. Jardeliza is dandings’s boy. Ateneo law was pretty supportive of Cornona so Villanueva is a no-no.

    Carpio or Sereno will do. Although, Im sure the president’s favor is already leaning on the lady.

    • sanjuan683

      Gumawa ka na lang ng isang ROBOT puro ka hinala walang mangyayari din. O kaya pumunta ka sa jungle ng Africa kumuha ka ng isang Chipanzee yun ang gawin mo chief. hehehe lahat ng gawin ng kapwa mo wala ka tiwala. hehehehehehe

      • indiosbravos2002

        Pre, Nagdrugs ka na naman ba? Ano kinalaman ng ROBOT at AFrica dito. Hehehe. Pakatino ka nga. Pangkatapos bumatak, tulog ka muna at wag mag-internet. Busssetttt!

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/LM2SPIWUAR2U6G3CJX7NVT7ETY ANDRES

        Between Carpio & Sereno..Kay Sereno na lang…may paninindigan…may kinikilingan..eh si Carpio? wala…sariling interest lang..biruin mong maging hudas sa kaibigan n’yang si Corona….anong tawag mo don?

      • wyl5326

        while I share same support on Sereno, I won’t cast aspersion on Carpio.

  • AbdullahZahir

    nothing to fret for de lima, she’s still the DOJ sec for the next 3 years… :P

    • marionics

      kung hindi niya biglang isipin na tumakbong senadora. if she runs she will have to resign. so win or loses alis siya sa doj

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_27PPDGBKQ7LTIPGINBCF7556UQ GeorgeR

      Without confirmation from CA..

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/AMG5EDI2JBQRL4Z5H2L7ED4OQA yahoo-AMG5EDI2JBQRL4Z5H2L7ED4OQA

    asan ang mga doom-sayers na galit na galit kay mrs de lima??????
    ano kayo ngayon??? itlog kayo!!!!
    sabi ninyo pupuwersahin ni presidente ang jbc…
    ano kayo ngayon???
    mga utak talangka !!!!!

    • boldyak

      wahahaha, hanggang ngayon hindi mo pa alam na cover lang si De Lima sa totoong gusto ni Uncle na maluklok sa pwesto….

  • indiosbravos2002

    I was hoping De Lima will get a shot. Too bad she gained a lot of enemies and became a real threat. She could have cleaned up the tainted SC image and possibly provided reform to the IBP syndicate. With the shortlist, looks like the Sc and IBP mafia were able to hold a strong grip on the shortlist. Many names are corrupt friendly. So, how will the clwan up in the judiciary proceed? Your guess is just as good as mine.

    • sanjuan683

      hehehehe tanga kasi siya hindi siya marunong sumusunod sa TRO, papaano susundin yun TRO ipapalabas niya kung siya na ang SC chief, malamang gagayahin din siya hindi susundin ang TRO. hehehehehehe yan ang napala ng isang mayabang.

      • indiosbravos2002

        Sobrang bilib mo naman kay Corona at SC posse nya. Siguro kung nagpaTRO sila dati na BAWAL HUMINGA mga tao. Susundin mo? Hehehehe.

        Oist! Bawal huminga sabi. Ang huminga mayabang.

      • AbdullahZahir

        lame analogy… lame argument… 

      • Guest

        K. Whatever you say. Where is the bomb, m brother? Peace to allah. Hehehe.

      • Guest

        K. Whatever you say. Where is the bomb, m brother? Peace to allah. Hehehe.

      • indiosbravos2002

        Astig GMA forces, may foreign correspondent na. Are you paid in Iraqi currency? Or with pita and some kebab only?

      • indiosbravos2002

        Sanjuan, dont be a Troll and stop fooling people here. Everyone knows the TRO was defective. Only Corona and his gay sidekick Midas believed in its effectivity. In essence, there was no TRO in effect.

      • AbdullahZahir

        everyone as in “me included” everyone? speak for your self kid. 

        trust me, it was that single miscalculated political MISTAKE de lima took that dimmed all her chances to being a justice.

      • Guest

        Alright, peace man. Where can we eat shawarmah?

    • spearheads

      Stop crying, robots don’t.

      • indiosbravos2002

        Stop trolling culubut este culubus

  • Andres_Bagumbayan

    Suriin natin mabuti ang mga nakalinya sa pagka punong mahistrado…mapapansin natin na maliban kay Ginoong Cesar Villanueva,lahat ay nanunkulan o nanununkulan sa kasalukuyang pamahalaan ni BS aquino…

    Sa aking pananaw,mas mainam na taga-labas ng gobyerno ang mamumuno sa korte suprema. Kahit ito ay walang kasiguraduhan na hindi ito magpapailalim sa utos ng Palasyo ng Malacanang!!! Sa tutoo lang,kailangan natin ng bagong mukha at pamamalakad sa korte suprema at kung ang mga galamay na naman ni BS aquino ang siyang mauupo ay wala din magandang kinahinatnan ang pagpapatalsik kay ginoong corona!!!!

    • sanjuan683

      hehehehehe wala rin yan masama ang motibo nila kaya bagyo ang aanihin nila. hehehehehe

  • walaKA

    Ms. De Lima should stop acting as if her failure to be included in that shortlist is the end of her world..Don’t be too obsessed for a more powerful position..You’ve got a lot of work to do in DOJ..

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_HUE7BZXUJ7I5AFIBEPSIBONAHA Alfred A

    KARMA…. nakabawe si Corona…

    • marionics

      lugi pa rin yata si corona. si leila di man nasali sa shortlist e doj secretary pa din siya. e si corona tanggal e

      • beatmanny

        hindi naman noytard. panalo pa rin.

      • marionics

        oo nga naman. sabi nga sa pelikulang da vinci code e “what matters is what you believe” he he

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/65LK654T3MX6URQNGIP62W5FWE Red Knight

    In the end, it’s still AJ Carpio.  Sec De Lima was a willing participant in a well-crafted script.  They made her appear Malacanang’s favorite to take the heat out of AJ Carpio who was being accused (fairly or unfairly) of having a hand in the removal of CJ Corona.  Now that the emotion over CJ Corona’s removal has subsided, hindi na magiging masyadong halata that AJ Carpio is really PNoy’s choice from the very start.  Besides, he got the highest number of votes, and this makes him a very strong contender for the top SC post.  

    I have nothing against AJ Carpio.  In fact, I believe he should be the next CJ.  Mukha lang nasobrahan ng drama itong selectionn process, with some candidates willingly playing their part in the script concocted by the very mischievous spin doctors of Malacanang.

    Kudos to the spin doctors, and to the drama kings/queens!

    • yatot

      10billion likes!!!!

      You hit the nail in the head! Wheeewww!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PPUPSBWP2WEBCCPGHRY54UCTOM Anne Torre

    Carpio has a disbarment case filed by Vizconde yet he is on the list. Why? Of course, de Lima should have disqualified herself because she has a clear political bias in favor of BS Aquino.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/LM2SPIWUAR2U6G3CJX7NVT7ETY ANDRES

      Why? because Aso-Shit Justice like Carpio is under the immunity from suit except thru impeachment…Ganon kagaling ang mga abogado..they will exempt their selves from suit and share the fruit of powers among themselves.

  • sprint_netms

    I don’t think that Budoy is really rooting for de Lima.The brouhaha about de Lima’s appointment is just a smoke screen to distract the people’s attention from the sinister plot of appointing the very ambitious Sereno to ensure that all adverse decisions in connection with the Hacienda Luisita will be overturned and allow the 10 billion payment to Budoy’s clan. The long-shot strategy is to tire us on this de Lima ek ek and surreptitiously appoint Sereno. This was my fearless forecast during the impeachment trial.   

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/65LK654T3MX6URQNGIP62W5FWE Red Knight

      Sec De Lima seems to be enjoying her newfound fame as the new drama queen.  I don’t hate her though. :)  Mukha lang overdid ang execution ng script ni PNoy. :)

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/LM2SPIWUAR2U6G3CJX7NVT7ETY ANDRES

    Katulad ng inaasahan..sila-sila pa rin ang pagpipilian..Kasi daw..hindi pwedeng i-disqualify si Carpio not unless ma-impeach..Huh! Where’s the equality there between insider and outsider? Kung outsider ka, it’s that simple para i-disqualify…but for those Aso-Shit Justices..they have the immunity. Change n’yo n lang name JBC into Judiciary Barred Common

    • yatot

      Aso-Shit! ahahahahahaha

  • eltee mulawin

    >>> My guess is … Villanueva or Abad. Pero the “Judicial Is Mine” episode of Noy2′s teleserye still not yet in finale. Wait, see and read soon …and “SURPRISE.! ! ! ending of episode “Judicial Is Mine”.

    • spearheads

      Wait a minute, is this Villanueva related to Tesda’s Villanueva the JIL’s founder’s son? If he is then malakas nga ang kapit.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_QZZKXPEA67I7HELEIYM35QVYFA Jon

    Naku, tiyak hagulgol ang buwayang Tupas sa balitang ito.
    Kinakabahan lang ako kapag tumulo na ang uhog sa mala-kwebang butas ng ilong niya.
    Baka i-angat ang alert level sa Marikina river kung ganoon.
    So, please have mercy on us and don’t cry Cong. Tupas.  

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_OJWHBJLMWPTRUOZMN6JOMHLO2A Banana Na

    na-shortlist si DE LIMA….gamit yata nag-sulat ng names ay short bond papers, wala na kasi ang long bondpapers sa office nila…heee

  • Rathbumo

    Sec. Dilema, talagang ganyan, kung hindi ukol, hindi bubukol. Hindi pa tapos ang problema mo. Kapag napatunayan ng JBC na guilty ka, tapos na ang career mo. Hindi ka na liar, este, lawyer, samantalang si exSC CJ Renato Corona ay abogado pa. What goes around, comes around. Karma?

    • titod

      you mean IBP, pero best case scenario pa rin.

      • Rathbumo

        Oh yes. I mean IBP not JBC. I stand corrected. Baka nga gumanti yung mga ka-Bro ni Corona na nasa IBP ngayon, kay Sec. Dilema dahil nagtestify siya sa impeachment.

      • titod

        Lawyers have been disbarred for lesser offenses. What she did was make a mockery of our system, defying the highest court in the land, setting a dangerous precedent that will outlive her. She should be punished and excluded from the profession she does not belong to. 

      • Rathbumo

        Yup. Sec. Dilema aspired to serve an institution she once defied. Tatlo ang disbarment cases niya. Mahihirapan siyang lusutan yan. You’re right. She should be punished just to restore the people’s faith in our justice system.

  • malek_abdul

    The JBC won’t let/allow De Lima be in the shortlist because if chosen by Pnoy, she will be the CJ for next 18 years. Too long. Paano naman ang iba na gusto o nag-aambisyong maging CJ? Mga naka-line up sa shortlist medyo may mga edad na. Iyan din siguro ang dahilan kung bakit hindi napasama sa shortlist si Bautista (PCGG Chairman) kasi masyado siyang bata for the CJ post. He’s only 48 y.o. Am not saying that younger aspirants are not qualified…its just that they are too young and will take so many years for them to retire. Pagbigyan naman ang iba para everybody happy…hehe

  • Arcsolo

    it would be best if Sec. Delima be excluded from the short list. as a SC Chief Justice, she is seen as someone who’s willing to break a law just to serve justice in an infamous manner. that is not becoming of a chief justice. her actions would reflect with the one who was impeached.

  • marlaw

    Dati bago ang pilian marami ang angal na baka makasali si De Lima sa shortlist. Ngayong meron ng shortlist at hindi kasama si De Lima marami pa ring umaangal. Walang ipinagkaiba ito sa mga nahahalal na pangulo. Noong si Marcos ang nakaupo umaangal ang tao dahil diktador. Noong si Cory naman umangal din dahil walang alam at makakomunista. Noong si Ramos angal pa rin kasi ipinagbebenta ang mga properties ng gobyerno at maraming natanggal sa trabaho. Pag upo ni Erap angalan din kasi di raw marunong mag-ingles, isang artista at jueteng ang inatupag. Nang agawin ni Gloria ang trono angal din uli ang tao dahil illegal na pangulo, sinungaling, mandaraya at kurakot ito. Naupos si Noynoy tuloy pa rin ang angal dahil tamad daw ito, walang ginagawa, abnoy, etc. Lahat ng maupo may angal ang Pinoy. Sa puntong ito talagang hindi uunlad ang Pilipinas dahil hindi alam ng mga Pinoy ang gustong mangyari sa Pilipinas. Kahit pa sino ang maupo tiyak may angal at hindi maayos ang problema. Walang ibang makakapagpabago sa Pilipinas kundi ang pagbabago mismo ng ugali ng bawat Pilipino.

    • spearheads

      Pasensya ka na loser, disqualified ang alaga mo. Heto basahan, punasan mo na yang luha, luga, at uhog mo and move on.

      • http://www.facebook.com/dave.panganiban.1 Dave Panganiban

        Here’s for u….

        Read !…

        “DOnt FInd a Fault,  Find a REmedy ”

        will help ur never ending LOVE to this current ADMIn !  :)

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_MZOKC6X7Q52Z4E5VLYNB7GF72Y Kaloy

    De Lima can go back to work as Sec. of Doj. This is where she can help to the max.

    Carpio should be the man for CJ. Matured tested and with conviction.

    Sorry Mr. Lauro Vizconde. Next time you should base your disbarment complaint on evidence and not what a man with zero as in 0 credibility told you..

    Otherwise it is no better than hearsay.

    • $25214711

      I can live with that. Why not?

    • spearheads

      Just as I repeatedly posted before, “Anybody but Delima!”

      As regards your comment on Vizconde’s disbarment complaint, even if Vizconde has tons of material and credible evidence the same cannot prosper and susceptible to outright dismissal. You have to remove a sitting associate justice through impeachment first before you can initiate disbarment proceedings.

  • spearheads

    To PNoy: “You can not fool all of the people all of the time.”

    To Delima: “The most heroic thing to do now is resign as soon as possible and retreat to oblivion.

    To the yellows: Better luck next time.

    To the People: All I can say is that this happened because we are vigilant. The Rule of Law and Justice has prevailed but this could not have been achieved if the people are not vigilant. Continue the crusade to righteousness for we have an irresponsible, incompetent, and vindictive leader.

    • http://www.facebook.com/dave.panganiban.1 Dave Panganiban

      Ru out of ur Mind ?

      wot ru Talkin bout ?

      love ur President ..Lol !………..

    • Rolly257

      Ibalik si Gloria

  • sprint_netms

    All went according to Budoy’s script. Though de Lima is not the real bet for SCCJ, she now enjoys the name recall needed for her senate ambition. Naisahan na naman nila tayo but let us be vigilant.

    • Rolly257

      Naisahan na naman nila tayo but let us be vigilant, sabi mo.

      Hindi basta-basta maiisahan si Gloria, Marcos, Binay at Enrile…matatalino sila.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/FWD5IDZT7SXOEHKLE3O7CGFOAE Bright

    The Filipino people is hoping that the next Chief Justice will work for the masses, especially in the hastening of cases to be unclog in the courts. 

    Whoever it may be, let them work for the Filipino nation. 

    • Atagalong

      Amen!

  • rising_phoenix40

    Kawawa naman si Delima, huhuhuh. Ginawang pamato ng malakanyang, tapos ngayon di man lang maipagtanggol. sob sob sob. Di bale, after two years na lang ulit pag retire na si Carpio. Pero siguraduhin ni Delima na di siya disbarred by that time, or suspended. : (

  • Bato’ng Bantilis

    ‘hanggang wish ko lang’ tayo dito. Gusto natin na outsider sa admin ang maging hepe sa sc. E paano? Ang presidente ang may kapangyarihan na pumili sa cj. We have given that prerogative power to him through the constitution.

  • sprint_netms

    Yes, all went well according to Budoy’s script. Though the drama queen is not the real bet for SCCJ, she now enjoys tremendous name recall for her senate ambition. But I guess Sereno’s advantage is her usefulness in connection with the HL case. As SCCJ for more than 20 years, the Aquino-Conjanco clan and their interests are fully protected. 

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_HPGUIIJ44DMCSONOPI4JAEMUZM lex

    let us celebrate hacienda luisita will be back to aquino clan! yan ang tuwid na daan! 

  • http://www.facebook.com/dave.panganiban.1 Dave Panganiban

    Hey guys..I told .yah…DE lima wont be ur PROBS….see now

    She’s out of d Short List ……….all ur non sense bickering in VAIN…..

    Now wot ?……still not Happy Huh!  LMao

    Cmon..try another non sense arguments…….just to please ur Love to NOYnoy!  :)

  • wyl5326

    Considering the vote of notorious Hermosisima, I would throw my support for Sereno to avoid his future influence and debt of gratitude he might try to exploit later ! While Zamora is brilliant, he did nothing during our darkest days and the Zamora brothers are notoriously influential ! In addition, he was considered the protege of Macoy and was considered as behind Macoy’s legal mind too ! For that, I’ll bat now for Sereno as she was clearly not the choice of SC Tyrants and Insiders ! It is interesting to note that Insiders and notorious Hermosisima eventually supported Carpio, because that is their way of trying to continue their influence as they have no better alternative candidate and was propositioning for future influence with their votes for Carpio whom they think as maneuverable for them ! I would consider their support for Carpio as belated and desperation move to extend their power/influence .

  • spearheads

    “Don’t cry for me yellows, I still have a chance to be Chief Justice of the SC – Showbiz Central. It’s still vacant.” – Delima

    One thing is clear, except for Tupas and Musngi, the JBC does not want to preempt the disbarment cases of Delima. By the way, I am waiting for the praise release of the blabbering spokespersons in the person of either Valte or Lacierda which says, “The disqualification of Delima only proves that PNoycchio has no hand in the JBC vetting process.” Tiyak yang spin story nila, mark my word.

    • pinoychinese

      You said it! Tama ka.

  • Mattino2011

    Let me guess, si Carpio na yan,,,,Delima, tama lang di ikaw isama.

  • pinoychinese

    Let’s leave the JBC first. Anyway, just like any script, the Filipino-Chinese will still win. There is no kayumanggi selected on the list. All are Filipino-Chinese, including De Lima, and more so with Carpio. 

    Anyway, in Olympic Final result, America with 48 golds with over all medals of 104 while China has 38 golds (hehe he he!) with 67 over all medals. Eat my dust, “sabi nga ni ‘Clint Eastwood.” In spite of Cradel training, China ended second best. My bote pa sa bibig ang potential Chinese athlete, nag te-train na siya. Buawhhhhhh!

  • aramco92

    i think carpio na kunwari lng yang selected process na yan niloloko lng ng jbc sarili nila eh carpio eh carpio nman talaga pipiliin nila kasi yng senior sa lahat

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/573GKVTQMBD62PQ6XOEPMI7LXA Yugi

    naku! iyak siguro si PNoy nito. wala si De Lima.

  • Atagalong

    I hope that Justice Carpio will finally get selected as a replacement of the former Chief Justice Ranato Corona. Experience and legal savvy make him more suitable to become the head of the highest court of the land. Besides, it gives a glimmer of hope to those people from Mindanao and the Visayas, that they too has a place in the Supreme Court. I hope too, that the new justice will come from the Visayas. It’s only fair that there will also be a person representing the Visayas in our national government.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/MMZ4ZMFTI6XAN5UB3WKVANCPVE theo

    just by reading the blogs here you can pretty much make a sound judgement just what kind of brains these people have, no wonder this country made erap president and elected bongbong as senator just to mention a few among other deplorable…….. you finish the blank. This nation is largely populated by moronic citizens, the evidence is in the pudding, so to speak!!!

    • boybakal

       I agree and you are one of them.

    • walaeh

      you are the biggest moron!!!!

    • Aryong

      Same here… Puzzled how 12 million could vote a cong turn sen turn pres without his own legit achievement…

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/PRDGZHO73F5SCBMJO3BGCPXR6E Nilo C

      Ganon talaga Igan. Pagmakapagsalita rine ay akala mo sila na ang magagaling sa bu-ong Mundo.

    • boybakal

       i cannot even understand your blog…what kind of brain you have.
      just be straight to the point, no going around the bush.
      You Einstein, genius.

  • boybakal

    After Disqualification, Disbarment na ang kasunod.
    Ika nga eh, De Lima is like a shooting star, biglang sumulpot at kumikinang at bigla rin naglahong bula.
    Once in a pedestal, keep on the pedal.
    Ang buhay ay parang Life….Lulubog lilitaw.

  • yatot

    Ahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha.

    Kakahiya ka Delimna. Sa estero ka pupulutin! KARMA at its best!

  • yatot

    Delimna is just net to his noynoying amo – moronic as you said.

  • yatot

    ek ek lang ni Panot si Delimna. Nililinlang lang nila nag mga tao para hindi tamaan si Carpio. Sa totoo lang si Carpio ang tuta ng Panot!

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/PRDGZHO73F5SCBMJO3BGCPXR6E Nilo C

      Ano ba ang problema mo pag si Carpio ang magiging Chief ng Supreme Court??? Apektadong apektado ka ata ah. Hind ba iikot ang mundo mo pag si Carpio ang Chief ng SC???

      • Luthmar

        Baka relative ito ni Corona kaya sya ganyan ka bastos.

  • yatot

    Anjan din pala si Sereno.. Ang hiyas ni Panot! Ehek

  • yatot

    copy paste

    In the end, it’s still AJ Carpio.  Sec De Lima was a willing participant in a well-crafted script.  They made her appear Malacanang’s favorite to take the heat out of AJ Carpio who was being accused (fairly or unfairly) of having a hand in the removal of CJ Corona.  Now that the emotion over CJ Corona’s removal has subsided, hindi na magiging masyadong halata that AJ Carpio is really PNoy’s choice from the very start.  Besides, he got the highest number of votes, and this makes him a very strong contender for the top SC post.   

  • PepingCo

    The end of the road for Daldalima. How can a DoJ secretary covet so much the CJ position of the institution who’s TRO she willingly defied? How can a DoJ ask for leniency of the JBC rule that she herself vehemently defended last Sept 2011 as cast in stone? Such blind hypocrisy. May God have mercy on you Daldalima.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/DKFL6JWEYJETV36OUSJPYHJFQM May

    This is the victory of justice because those who voted are lawyers and I believe in their wisdom. This is different from impeachment that the rule of law could be circumvented. Fair enough.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/DKFL6JWEYJETV36OUSJPYHJFQM May

    okay na lang si sereno kaysa kay delima.

  • boybakal

    JBC disqualifies de Lima; 8 names in shortlist…

    10 ang pinapilian, 8 in shortlist.
    Dapat sinabi nyo na lang Long List or Elite Eight.

  • pepengkabayo

    JBC disqualifies de Lima; 8 names in SHORT LIST.

    Malas naman ni De Lima, naubusan ng space yon papel.
    Kung  cocon bond na long form ang ginamit baka naisulat ang pangalan niya.
    Di naman pwede sa likod ng papel.
    As they say….Beter lak nek taym.

  • reydomingo

    bakit madami galit kay delima? why is she being singled out by the jbc?

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/JKMASTZ6ILTZXOG42337ZESS4I ray

      delimna=hearsy…how come

  • jinx

    Carpio is the man!

    • RomyLitz

      If Roxas has the leverage in influencing Pnoy, then Carpio is the man.

  • TimeTraveller123

    Pinagloloko lang ng mga ito ang mga Pilipino. Ginamit lang nila na pang divert ng attention si Delima para sa ganoon ay makalimutan ng lahat ang tungkol kay Carpio. Maigi pa si Abad na lang ang italaga as SC CJ. Gunggong talaga ang mga officials ng gobyerno, pinagloloko ang tao. Iyong mga hindi naman nakakaintini ay hindi na maintindihan ang nangyayari. In the end, malamang si Carpio rin ang maging CJ kaya si Ombudsgirl Carpio ay parang baboy ramo na hindi makastahan noong nagtestify siya sa impeachment…Poor philippines talaga puros panloloko at interest ng mga makapangyarihan ang nananaig….

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/JKMASTZ6ILTZXOG42337ZESS4I ray

      tama ka bigan….

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_GUDXSLGDJSVES3MAZKXXMXJXXM Ratzkey

      this is just your opinion and you are entitled to it.

    • Luthmar

      Eh bakit ang gobyerno ang pinanggigigilan mo.  Ang JBC ang nag-interview at magsu-submit ng short list sa presidente.  At saka wala pa namang napipili, ano ba ang problema doon.

      • TimeTraveller123

        Because the Government is in cahoots with the JBC! That is why! Delima’s case was a decoy to divert the people’s attention from Carpio.

      • Luthmar

        What do you know of the govt.’s plan to chose the next CJ.  Do you have a first hand knowledge that the govt. is in cahoots with the JBC.  Even if the govt. select Acting CJ Carpio to replace Corona, I think it is only fair because Acting CJ Carpio is the most senior and experienced among the
        current SC justices.  

        Frankly, De Lima did a good job stopping GMA to get out of the
        country.  If she didn’t, GMA and her family and a whole bunch of her
        friends would now be laughing at us.  They would already be enjoying their loots.

  • bbguevara

    Some observations on the voting results:
    1. Obviously Justice Peralta did not want an outsider (including Sereno) to be the next CJ
    2. Why did Escudero not vote for Carpio ????Could it be , because he feels Carpio is with Roxas camp, while Escudero is with the Binay camp???

    • 12JEM

      Peralta: Di niya ibinoto si Sereno.  Lahat na ibinoto niya mga GMA appointees katulad niya.

    • pidalcopter2

       Tama po kayo sir! Escudero didnt vote for Carpio kasi basag ang kaldero niya kay Carpio! heheh. Si Binay na lang ang naniniwala sa kayabangan niya!

    • spearheads

      Sereno is not an outsider.

      As to Chiz Escudero, he is only maintaining his position that those who are close to PNoy and those who were embroiled in Corona’s ouster should not be appointed as Chief Justice. Aside from Carpio, he also did not vote for Abad and Sereno who are both PNoy’s appointees.

  • eltee mulawin

    >>> My guess is … Villanueva or Abad. PERO the “Judicial Is Mine” episode of Noy2′s teleserye still not yet in finale. Wait, see and read soon …and “SURPRISE.! ! ! ending of episode “Judicial Is Mine”.

  • pidalcopter2

     Either Carpio or Sereno are sure winners and best for the country. The rest are lemons!

  • smartestofall

    no to justices who freed murderers

  • dead_pixel

    At nag boomerang rin ang double-standard ng dambuhalang LIE LA!!!

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/OGLUX4BU6VIQZUDLMTLUIQDAM4 Ramon JR.

    PINAKA CREDIBLE SA SHORTLIST SI VILLANUEVA WALANG BAHID NG POLITIKA ANG PAGKATAO, MATULUNGIN, MAY TAKOT SA DIYOS AT MATALINO.

    • http://blogusvox.blogspot.com/ ApoNiLolo

      They’re selecting nominees for the next Chief Justice hindi political candidate for the next election.

  • lemon88

     KAHIT 1 WALANG QUALIFIED. KAHIT NA SI VILLANUEVA NA GALING SA ACADEME WALA RIN SINABI COZ TUTA RIN SYA NG MGA OLIGARCH. eXCEPT FOR SERENO, ALL THE 6 NOMINEES AY TUTA LAHAT NI GMA.

    THE BEST WEApon nating mga pilipino ay panalangin ngayon. Panalangin na kung sino man mapiling sususond na CJ ay maging maka-Diyos, makatao at makabansa at hindi maging tuta ng appointing authority kahit si P-Noy pa.

  • guest1500

    It is another UP-Ateneo rivalry. It seems other law schools could not keep up with the standards of these two law schools.

  • drew_casta

    IRONIES.  If the JBC Rules provide for disqualification without distinction as to the nature of the case filed, why was Jardeleza included in the list? Whether there was a prima facie case or not, the Rules did not qualify. Too, why was the case against Carpio decided swiftly and was the first in the order of priorities? The case barely touched the docket of the Supreme Court. That of De Lima’s on the other hand were pending with the court for 6 months only to be referred to the IBP (headed by Libarios, a known ally of Corona) on the last minute. The court could have decided the matter outrightly or referred the matter to the IBP earlier on so as to remove doubts whether De Lima is qualified or not for nomination. The court might have realized the repercussions of a “pending case” against a candidate. Thus, Carpio was cleared in no time. Since De Lima is the apparent favorite of Malacanang, she was booted out of the race. All told, the clique in the SC does not want to be led by an outsider.

  • superbok

    Sabi nga ni Ted Failon – trust, believe, surrender. :)

    Tama na negatibismo, di ba tayo napapagod? Sa panahon ngayon, dapat inisip natin ang mga taong nasalanta ng habagat. Kesa kung anu-ano isulat natin dito na hindi naman makakatulong, kesa puro batikos, tumulong nalang tayo sa mga nasalanta. Ang magandang batikos ay hindi paninirang puri o pangalan ng kahit sino man. Tama na po, tulong tulong na lang tayo!

    • Luthmar

      Tama ka brother.  You are the most sensible commentator here.  Most of them, typical Filipino character, sala sa lamig, sala sa init.  Haaaaaaaaay bakit kaya ganoon.

    • poltergeist_fuhrer

      paano naman kami tutulong kung ang leader ay napaka noynoying…tell your boss. to LEAD THE COUNTRY…HAVE SoME LEADERSHIP!

      • superbok

        Polter- I am not even defending our President.  I am simply reacting to how some of the commentors react.  Masaydo tayong talangka.  Please read my comment again.

        Paano tayo tutulong?  Hindi natin kelangan ng leader para tulungan ang sarili natin.  Wag natin iasa lahat sa gubyerno.  Tayo na mismo dapat ang magsimula.  Simulan natin sa sarili natin.

        Our country is who we are, not by one person, not even the President, and all of us have to do something.

        Think positive lang, brad!  Wag masyadong negatibismo.  Walang mapapala. 

      • poltergeist_fuhrer

        negatibismo…tema yan ni penoy sa SONA a…so u r saying na u r not defending him???

        the truth is…sinimulan na ng tao…kayod kalabaw na ho ang tao ngaun…tingnan mo diya sa roxas blvd…mga basurero, kayod kalabaw na sila, tapos sasabihin mo, simulan natin…SINIMULAN NA…ang problema, ang leader natin na napaka noynoying…simple lang para umasenso naman ang mga taong bayan…control the prices of commodities and oil…police visibility…waga alisan or kaltasan ng sahod ang mangagawa kagaya ng pag asa at lahat ng govt agencies…YAN HO ANG TRABAHO ng gobyerno…HINDI HO YAN TRABAHO NG bawat pilipino kaso BUGBOG NA SILA NG TRABAHO, mahirap pa rin…tapos ngaun, sisisihin mo pa sila…maawa ka naman pare!!!for heaven sake, maawaka sa mga ordinaryong tao, wag mong depensahan pa itong noynoying

      • superbok

        Eh ano gagawin mo kung hindi kaya nang gobyerno? Magrereklamo ka lang ng magrereklamo dito sa forum? ANO NA BA NAGAWA MO PARA TUGUNAN ANG MGA SULIRANING NABANGGIT MO? Eh baka naman pati ikaw “noynoying” rin?

        Kaya nga, sinasabi ko, at kung naintindihan mo, tayo mismo na ang gumawa. Kung hindi matupad ng gobyerno ang dapat nilang gampanan, eh di wag sila iboto sa susunod na eleksyon. Pero hangga’t wala pa ang eleksyon, patuloy lang tayo. Hangga’t puro tayo reklamo at walang aksyon, tingin mo may mapapala tayo? May maitutulong ba?

      • poltergeist_fuhrer

        ANO NA BA NAGAWA MO PARA TUGUNAN ANG MGA SULIRANING NABANGGIT MO?

        ——-

        nakita ko na naman ang statement na ito….mahiya naman kayong mga taga gobyerno…TRABAHO ninyo, ipapasa sa mga tao….HOY magtrabaho kayo…sinasahudan kayo ng taong bayan para serbisyuhan ang taong bayan, tapos sasabihin mo, ANO NA BA ANG NAGAWA NAMIN????kapal ng pagmumukha ninyo….gusto lang talaga ninyo mag noynoying at hihintay ng sweldo

      • superbok

        At oo nga po pala, gaya na nang nabanggit ko nang nakaraan, wag naman rin po sana kayo manghusga, at di niyo naman po ako kakilala. Marahil kagaya mo, isa rin po akong private citizen, naghahanap buhay at empleyado ng isang pribadong kumpanya. Marahil kagaya mo, nangangarap rin, na balang araw, maging mabuti ang buhay ng bawat Pilipino. Hindi po ako nagtatrabaho sa gobyerno, at walang balak magtrabaho sa gobyerno. Bahagi ako sa “namin” na binabanggit mo. Mas magandang sabihin, ano ba ang nagawa na natin? Wag niyo po ipasan ang problema ng lipunan, damay rin po kami diyan.

        Kayo po ba, sa gubyerno kayo nagtatrabaho? Relax lang, Polter.

      • superbok

        Relax lang, Polter? Puro ka galit 

        The question I posted is a rhetorical. It doesn’t need to be answered, but would need self-examination and reflection.
        Alam kong matalino kayo at di niyo na po kailangan ilathala dito ang mga nagawa o di niyo nagawa.

  • spearheads

    My observation on how the JBC members voted:

    AJ Peralta = voted for only five nominees, all insiders. Are the rest not qualified?;

    Usec Musngi = voted for 2 insiders and 5 outsiders, loyalist vote of course;

    Sen. Escudero = Voted 4 insiders and 4 outsiders. Fair vote but why did he not vote for Abad when Abad is PNoy’s appointee? To many Abad’s already?

    Congressman Tupas = Voted for 5 insiders and 3 outsiders. Seems leaning to insiders;

    Former AJ Hermosisima = Same as Tupas;

    Former AJ Lagman = also fair vote – 4 insiders and 4 outsiders;

    Atty. Mejia = also fair vote – 4 insiders and 4 outsiders;

    Atty. Fernan-Cayosa = also fair vote – 4 insiders and 4 outsiders.

    Note: If we base the selection of the future Chief Justice of the Supreme Court on the JBC members votes, Carpio has it. It’s only Escudero who did not vote for Carpio. AJ Peralta, Sen. Escudero, Former AJ Hermosisima, and Atty. Fernan-Cayosa did not vote for Sereno. In fact, it’s Abad who runs second to Carpio based on the JBC members votes. A wise choice for PNoy is between Carpio and Abad only, Sereno is the worst choice.

    • spearheads

      Correction: Musngi voted for three insiders.

    • observer18

       what’s wrong with sereno?

      • poltergeist_fuhrer

        what’s wrong?

        all her decisions are on the side of penoy…

        and worst of all…HER DISSENTING OPINION ON HACIENDA LUISITA CASE IS…THE GOVERNMENT SHOULD PAY THE COJUANCOS-AQUINOS NOT LESS THAN 10 BILLION PESOS AS PAYMENT…which is too far from the real value that the SC decided, which is 180 MILLION pesos..that is worst…VERY MUCH WORST!!!..

        in case she will be next CJ, dont you think she will not flipflop the decision on Luisita as Corona did for many instances???think of it!!!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_AJVFGREFB2WJ5ORE6CHJXLMOTE Jimmy

       sereno is a good choice if pnoy does not like carpio or abad…

  • spearheads

    If the JBC comes up with the usual 3 nominees shortlist then Brion should be the third choice and not Sereno based on the JBC voting.

    • spearheads

      Addendum:

      This must be the reason why the JBC came up with an 8 nominee voting instead of a shortlist of three nominees, ostensibly to include Sereno. I am not really sure if this voting is already the official shortlist but if they will come up with the usual official shortlist of three names then Sereno is definitely out.

  • spearheads

    I might have been too judgmental on Sen. Escudero in my previous posts. My apology sir, I am terribly sorry. The way Sen. Escudero voted proved me wrong. He did not vote for Abad and Sereno who are both appointees of PNoy.

    • observer18

      He voted for Sereno. Look at the news item closely.

      “Senator Francis Escudero — Brion, Diokno, Herbosa, Jardeleza, former UP Law Dean Raul Pangalangan, Sereno, Velasco, Zamora;”

      But in fairness, Sereno showed competence and intellect during the interview.

      • spearheads

        Ok, I stand corrected, yet I maintain my position that this is only the result of JBC voting and not the official shortlist. The usual shortlist contains only three names of nominees from which the president makes his choice. Based on the voting result, the contenders should be Carpio, Abad, and Brion. Sereno is definitely out whether or not her interview is outstanding.

  • jimiji

    long “short list”

  • jimiji

    de lima a smoke-screen…..carpio is really pnoy’s choice

    • http://blogusvox.blogspot.com/ ApoNiLolo

      Is this a fact or just a speculation?

      • jimiji

        ano sa tingin mo?

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_AJVFGREFB2WJ5ORE6CHJXLMOTE Jimmy

         speculation coz no pronouncement, fact if it is mentioned by Pnoy…

  • RomyLitz

    So let Justice Carpio be chosen to replace Corona.

  • Cal_Reznick

    People wishing for De Lima to be the next CJ need not worry. They need not even listen to the ruling decision of the candidates included in the short-list

    De Lima and President has a knack for defying and ignoring decisions and orders and rulings (ala TRO last November 2011) so don’t be surprised if she gets back on the short-list.

    • http://www.dafk.net/what/ Kilabot ng mga Balahibo

      Agreed.

      Surest way to know is when there is new CJ that is not De Lima. Only then you will know with exact certainty.

      I wouldn’t put it past this government to bend or relax or suspend laws or what ever they want to call it, all in the name of ‘matuwid na daad’. That’s a contradiction, isn’t it?

      “knack for defying and ignoring decisions and orders and rulings”

      She does, doesn’t she?

    • wawa2172

      The TRO was painful to swallow by De Lima and Noy but its highest court of the land that orders with legal basis: No case still filed in court against The Pandak. De Lima is a lawyer of lesser legal mind and she was caught sleeping on her job thus defying the TRO then filing a weak case of election sabotage with just one not credible witness against The Pandak whose now on bail.  De Lima does not even deserved to be nominated as CJ as she is only banking on her closeness to Noy as her ace. What a credential, she is banking on “palakasan” to be a CJ and its “nakakasuka”. De Lima should have concentrated on her job as DOJ secretary, focus on it and win cases for the government. She is losing her cases and have not won yet so it is not an excellent performance. Noy trust her because she follows her marching order even if it against the law. She is supposed to be the guardian of the rules and orders as set by the constitution and not to defy it. Granting that The Pandak “might ” escape when allowed to travel, it is all hearsay as she may just be seeking medical treatment. The Pandak is now a bionic woman and no longer a threat to national security, unlike Erap and Ferdie then. The Pandak should face the music no question about ir, but the government should have act fast then to make it happen. With De Lima focusing on her nomination and be included in the shortlist, tiyak marami siyang naiwang kaso na dapat niyang atupagin. Good that she was not included on the short list  dahil mas marami pang magaling sa kanya. Tama ka, defiance is the key to everything at baka makuha pa iyan ni De Lima.

      • Cal_Reznick

        I could not have set it better myself.

        I may have chosen a different term than Pandak though I did find it a bit humorous but nonetheless unfortunately for the Philippines, your observations are on point.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/5TENDBNOVQRJEKFPV76D2N4XUM Socorro

    De Lima is not really fit to be the next CJ even included in the shortlist.  How will she make pepole follow the rules , eh sya mismo hindi marunong sumunod sa SC di ba? Bakit sya or sila ni Pinoy nagpipilit na maging CJ? We have to  remember the 3 branches are independent of each other and equal in power. Pag si de Lima eh di ayos na ang LP at si Pinoy. PLS.WE FILIPINOS ARE NOT DUMD OR TANGA AS YOU THINK WE ARE. NAG IISIP ANG MGA FILIPINO. STOP ALL THOSE PAMBOBOLA. 

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/UZF4OTGY4BREFE42RXP7FZJKFY Ding

      Filipino ka ba? Bakit parang hindi ka kasama sa mga binabanggit mo?

  • http://twitter.com/superjudge32 super judge

    De Lima…naKARMA!

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/UZF4OTGY4BREFE42RXP7FZJKFY Ding

      isa ka rin sa magdurusa kapag hindi ayos ang napuwesto !

      • http://www.facebook.com/julian.lennon.31 Julian Lennon

        fortunately for us, de lima is out, one candidate na di maayos sa puwesto

  • poltergeist_fuhrer

    SERENO IS THE WORST…

    SHE WAS THE ONE WHO VALUED THE HACIENDA LUISITA TO 10 BILLION IN HER DISSENTING OPINION…

    IF SHE BECOMES A CJ, SHE MIGHT FLIPFLOP THE DECISION OF THE SC…SHE IS LIKE DELIMA WHO BOWS AT PENOY…HAS NO INDEPENDENT THINKING BASTA BA MAY PERA, cos she was one of the lawyers who got 2 billion pesos for winning the PIATCO case, unfortunately, it is not reflected in her SALN…

  • nakatutok

    ..Sec Dilemma can always comfort herself in the loving arms of ALEX…

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_AJVFGREFB2WJ5ORE6CHJXLMOTE Jimmy

    regrettable. i wish that Pnoy can appoint a de lime like candidate for SC chief justice.

  • dongvee

    Are not all these hollaballo intended to put the big S to be next CJ? Since as anyone who dares to know is bound to find out, all these elaborate shows that had happened and those that are to happen are all about the money, money, money……Kaya Jessie J ibahin mo na yong kanta mo. Dito sa Pinas lahat na milagro mangyari dahil sa It’s all about money, money, money…..

  • http://pinoypenoy.livejournal.com/ pinoypenoy

    Zamora is a corrupt nincompoop!  He was Erap’s right hand man at the height of the latter’s presidency and was as giddy as a schoolgirl whenever he is called “the little president”…putsa…kiligin ba?  It’s obvious by that action that he loves power…

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/UZF4OTGY4BREFE42RXP7FZJKFY Ding

    Tsk…tsk…tsk…we really have lots of people who cannot use their own conscience kung labas sa pagkakaprogram sa kanila…parang mga computers, na magaling lang according to the system they have been programmed…ni hindi na gumagana ang human kukote…palagay ko may nabanggit si Dean Valdez  na , kailangan din ang morarlity, not only laws sa decision making…eh, yan lang ang ginamit ni De Lima, ang ipaglaban ang gusto ng bayan, kaya tinibag niya ang nakaharang na pader, against all odd-making legal robots, exploiting the law for their selfish motives…kung walang katatagan si De Lima, maaaring nasa mataas na position pa ang isang hindi marunong ng simple arithmetic..so, that’s how they got their names ‘bar council’ and ‘integrated bar’ , robots out to bar anyone who prefers JUSTICE to prevail…hence, barring all barriers created by these barring councils, in the spirit of democracy, where the people are the true and supreme judges, the people see you fit for even higher positions, even the highest office of the land.  God bless you.

    • http://www.facebook.com/julian.lennon.31 Julian Lennon

      when JBC included de lima in the list, we never heard anything from people like you.. Infact you were probably all praises for them, but since they’ve found irregularity in her nomination, they had to disqualify her and for obvious constitutional reason… and now youre blaming JBC for the legal problems of delima that disqualified her?  what if she got voted as CJ and her legal cases are decided against her, we end up asking her to resign and then we choose another CJ?  isnt this the reason why there is a JBC? to filter out candidates with possible flaws? delima was only in in the first place because of Pnoy.. the dictator.



Copyright © 2014, .
To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.
Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:
c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94
Advertisement
  1. Enrile chief aide back in PH ‘to face charges’
  2. Gigi Reyes back to face charges
  3. SC suspends proctor in 2011 bar exams
  4. What Went Before: Enrile denies Gigi Reyes was ‘other woman’
  5. In the know: Gigi Reyes
  6. Henares on Pacquiao bashing: I did not start this
  7. At 77, Erap has Easter treat for Manila cops but keeps City Hall folk in agony
  8. Solons seek ample protection for bank depositors
  9. ‘No real progress in PH if dynasties not dismantled’
  10. More legal woes for Cedric Lee
  1. Kim Henares needs a reprimand, says Cayetano
  2. Suspect in Vhong Navarro mauling tries to leave PH
  3. More legal woes for Cedric Lee
  4. ‘No real progress in PH if dynasties not dismantled’
  5. ‘Mom, I love you,’ says text from student on sinking ferry
  6. Fr. Suarez says last Mass on Easter before returning donated land to San Miguel
  7. Enrile chief aide back in PH ‘to face charges’
  8. Massive infra spending set
  9. Henares on Pacquiao bashing: I did not start this
  10. I’ll follow my conscience on Estrada, says JV Ejercito
  1. KL confirms Malaysian Airlines Flight MH370 ended in Indian Ocean
  2. MRT passengers pass the hat for 6-year-old Ashley
  3. Rookie, lady cops lauded for quick response to MOA heist
  4. Malaysia averts another air tragedy; pilot lands troubled plane safely
  5. Revilla says he was joking; Lacson stands by his story
  6. Revilla ‘consulted’ Lacson on how he evaded arrest
  7. Police rule out foul play in Helena Belmonte’s death as boyfriend is ‘traumatized’
  8. Cudia, dismissed for lying, got 99% in conduct
  9. Model Helena Belmonte wished ‘to slash her wrist and hope to die’
  10. Hammer-wielding robbers cause chaos at Philippines’ Mall of Asia
Advertisement

News

  • ‘I’ll make it,’ says young ferry passenger to family
  • Bad weather halts rescue after deadliest Everest disaster
  • Gigi Reyes has no other option but to turn state witness — Santiago
  • US weighing military exercises in Eastern Europe
  • Rains loom in Surigao as LPA nears
  • Sports

  • Nick Calathes suspension a reminder of supplement risk
  • Teague scores 28 as Hawks soar past Pacers in Game 1
  • Warriors beat Clippers in playoff opener
  • Pacquiao top Mayweather contender
  • Rain or Shine, Ginebra clash for No. 6 spot
  • Lifestyle

  • Noli Yamsuan, Cardinal Sin’s ‘official’ photographer: ‘I could smell the aftershave lotion of the Pope’
  • Simplifying and lightening life
  • Where to go for Easter night-out
  • Joe de Venecia visits the Queen Mother of Cambodia
  • Fashionistas flock to designer’s wedding
  • Entertainment

  • Show-biz celebrities’ other choices of summer getaway
  • Why ‘Noah’ can’t dock his ark at Philippine theaters
  • Acclaimed artist goes wild while on holiday
  • Believing in this mermaid
  • Missing Xian
  • Business

  • Top-selling insurance agent opens her dream café
  • Connecting and transacting with one another
  • Building wealth for health
  • Why Mandaue Foam buys, rather than rents, space
  • A workplace of new possibilities
  • Technology

  • Nasa’s moon-orbiting robot crashes down
  • Netizens pay respects to Gabriel Garcia Marquez
  • Nokia recalls 30,000 chargers for Lumia 2520 tablet
  • Facebook rolls out ‘nearby friends’ feature
  • Netizens seethe over Aquino’s ‘sacrifice’ message
  • Opinion

  • Epiphany
  • Unpaid creditor vs distressed debtor
  • Moving on
  • From culinary desert to paradise
  • Response to China: ‘Usjaphil’
  • Global Nation

  • Asia seeks Obama’s assurance in territorial spats
  • Cesar Chavez movie sparks memories of Fil-Am labor leaders
  • Filipinos in US poised for success
  • Visas for priests and other faith leaders
  • DOH to continue tracking co-passengers of OFW infected with MERS virus
  • Marketplace
    Advertisement