Quantcast
pope ph

Supreme Court slams door on coconut farmers

By |


Eduardo “Danding” Cojuangco, current chairman of San Miguel Corp. INQUIRER FILE PHOTO

Coconut farmers can kiss goodbye their hopes of recovering nearly P60 billion worth of shares in San Miguel Corp. (SMC).

The Supreme Court slammed the door to any further judicial action concerning a 20-percent bloc of SMC shares when it issued an “entry of judgment” after declaring on April 12, 2011, that the contested portfolio belonged to Eduardo “Danding” Cojuangco, current chairman of the highly diversified conglomerate and uncle of President Benigno Aquino III.

A six-page entry of judgment notice dated March 16 on Cojuangco’s SMC shares was sent on Tuesday to the Presidential Commission on Good Government (PCGG), which sequestered the package after SMC stock certificates in blank were found in a Malacañang vault on the night the dictator Ferdinand Marcos was ousted during the 1986 People Power Revolution.

Final and executory

The document, signed by Deputy Clerk of Court Ma. Lourdes C. Perfecto, said that the high court’s decision had become “final and executory and is hereby recorded in the Book of Entries of Judgments.”

The action ends three decades of judicial battles over the SMC shares waged by the PCGG and representatives of farmers’ organizations in an effort to recover alleged ill-gotten wealth of Marcos and his cronies.

Lawyers acknowledged that the court’s move meant “everything is closed” to efforts to recover the controversial Cojuangco shares in SMC that farmers said were fruits of the tax on copra imposed for nine years during the Marcos regime and should be used for their benefit and not for private individuals.

Cojuangco, 76, acquired the SMC shares from the late Enrique Zobel in 1983. He was then president of state-owned United Coconut Planters Bank (UCPB), depositary of the levy funds.

The court’s move came amid calls by reformists in the coconut industry on Mr. Aquino to move decisively and use the sequestered assets acquired with the use of a coconut levy collected during the martial law years to ease the plight of a quarter of the country’s population regarded as the poorest of the poor.

Critics have described the levy as the biggest scam perpetrated to enrich a few individuals at the expense of the 3.5 million coconut farmers and their families.

‘Joke of the century’

The petitioners had averred that Cojuangco violated a fiduciary trust and dipped his fingers into the UPCB fund that was created principally to address the farmers’ perennial credit problems that have put them at the mercy of loan sharks and usurers, usually traders who have controlled the industry since the martial law years and kept them impoverished.

Cojuangco allegedly took out loans from UCPB and credit advances from the Coconut Industry Investment Fund (CIIF) Oil Mills Group to acquire the SMC shares.

The court, in a ruling described by a dissenting justice as “the joke of the century,” said that the SMC portfolio “is the exclusive property of Cojuangco.”

An official valuation placed Cojuangco’s 494,881,157 common shares in San Miguel in January at P58,099,047,832 based on a share price of P117.40 per share. The price of an SMC share had reached as high as P180 on the stock exchange.

In January, the Supreme Court ruled that another 24-percent block of SMC shares belonged to the government because it was bought with the levy fund and must now be utilized for the benefit of the farmers.

Faceless, nameless

This portfolio was designated the SMC-CIIF block because it was  acquired under the CIIF in an elaborate scheme that included the formation of 14 holding companies arranged by Cojuangco’s Accra law office.

The Philippine Coconut Producers Federation Inc., or Cocofed, has filed a motion for reconsideration of this decision claiming the package supposedly for its 1 million members, that the court itself said were “nameless and faceless.”

The case is pending. Cocofed has been accused of misusing the fund, which became a wallet that financed profligate projects of the martial law regime.

This SMC-CIIF block comprised 753,848,312 shares. It was converted from common to preferred shares at the behest of the PCGG under the Arroyo administration in a deal approved by the Supreme Court in 2009 at P75 per share at a great loss to the farmers, considering the high price of the SMC stock on the exchange.

The official valuation of this package as of Jan. 20 was P56,538,623,400. SMC has the option to redeem the stocks this year.

Dividends alone on this SMC-CIIF bundle had reached P8.8 billion.

Multiagency task force

Fearing raids on the funds deposited in UCPB, lawmakers have filed bills creating a trust fund for farmers.

Malacañang also has created a multiagency task force to draw up a program to ameliorate the industry with the use of levy-related assets under sequestration.

Farmers groups have urged Mr. Aquino to issue an executive order to free up at least the P8.8 billion in dividends on the SMC-CIIF shares for urgent use in the industry that is reeling from dwindling harvests from aging trees, requiring massive replanting and the impact of climate change.

Motions for recon

Following the April 12, 2011, decision, the PCGG and former Senators Jovito Salonga and Wigberto Tañada filed separate motions for reconsideration, which were denied.

In August, PCGG filed an omnibus motion for leave of court to file a second motion for reconsideration, pointing out an erroneous premise in its original decision—the absence of a definition of ill-gotten wealth and the necessity of treating this issue as “sui generis,” or one of a kind.

Salonga and Tañada likewise filed a second motion for reconsideration.

The court “expunged,” or threw out the petitions.

Lawyers said that the court’s move was unfortunate, pointing out that the high tribunal’s internal rules allow a second motion for reconsideration “in the higher interest of justice” by the court en banc upon a vote of at least two-thirds of its members. They say that in a belated dissenting opinion, Justice Lourdes Sereno raised the possibility that compelling new evidence could prompt the court to revisit the decision.

3rd recon ignored

Salonga and Tañada filed a third motion for reconsideration last November that attached as proof of Cojuangco’s being a Marcos crony pages from the dictator’s diaries which clearly identified Cojuangco as “one of the congressmen close to [Marcos]” to debunk the high tribunal’s claim that the businessman was not a Marcos associate. This was likewise ignored.

Critics say that the coconut levy is the biggest social justice issue to confront the nation, affecting some 25 million Filipinos.


Follow Us


Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Tags: Agriculture , Benigno Aquino III , coco levy funds , Coconut industry , Danding Cojuangco , Government , Judiciary , Justice , Philippine Coconut Authority , Poverty , San Miguel Corp. , Supreme Court , UCPB


  • http://www.facebook.com/oustcorona ILL_HIT_YOUR_FACE

    Not a good sign for the Supreme Court when it stand together with the crook and the rich.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_XDWBHA4RV3DRLMCJTT23LPRM7M eli

    pustahan tayo, NO COMMENT SI CONRADO DE QUIROS DITO!

    • dongvee

      Read carefully conrado de quiros’ column today. There you will see written all over that column in bold letters the message: Obey the powers that be. Or else….

  • RomyLitz

    How much commission again Macho Corona since 1% of 60 billion is cool 600-million pesos? Thats US$15 million to be deposited to your dollar accounts to buy properties for your children?

    • Rhine

       very irrelevant comment,,,

      • RomyLitz

        I strongly agree, that for the hopelessly blind and dumb, it is.

      • Rhine

         thank you bright boy

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_FPVUYCML46QCAJM5N2O4GNID24 tony

    This supposedly “final & executory” decision of the Philippine Supreme Court can still be changed. The coconut farmers need to convince Estelito Mendoza to take their case. Once they have him on their side, all it take would be a letter from Mendoza and viola the decision is reversed and the coconut farmers get to own the SMC shares. They will pay very expensive legal fees but it should be worth it.

    • cliff_castillo

       The farmers cannot afford to pay because it is not merely the legal fees of Mendoza but also the millions they have to give the SC justices thru Mendoza.

    • KapitanBagwis

       That is wishful thinking my friend….Mendoza is one of Marcos cabinet secretary (Justice Secretary??) if I’m not mistaken.

  • RomyLitz

    Add 25 Billion from Banco Filipino, add 3 Billion from FASAP,add 45 Billion from Shell and the total is 133 Billion pesos. If deposited 1% of that to the dollar accounts of 8 Dwarfs Appointees in SC, thats cool US$3 million each for this year. Congrats, Corona Orchestra!!

  • http://twitter.com/Joe_The_Kano Joe Kano

    “Cojuangco allegedly took out loans from UCPB and credit advances from
    the Coconut Industry Investment Fund (CIIF) Oil Mills Group to acquire
    the SMC shares.”

    “Allegedly?” Hasn’t that part of the equation been proven and admitted?

    It’s ridiculous to let the chairman of a state-owned bank use bank deposits for massive personal investments, whether or not he eventually paid back the deposits.

  • http://twitter.com/jayoliver523 jayoliver

    Again another case of flip-flop.  An indirect flip-flop if I may abuse the word. The SC has debunked their own claim that they are “just pro-farmers” while deciding the Hacienda Luisita case.  If indeed they are consistent with their pro-farmers stance they should have ruled in favor of the coco farmers.  But then again consistency is a word alien to the high court. I am awaiting with bated breath the way on how the Corona camp will reconcile this ruling with the Luisita ruling. It surely will be interesting to find out what kind of rhetorics will the Defense use to connect this decision to the much abused Hacienda Luisita justification.
     
    I understand their mindset in deciding this case however.  This was done with the end in view of influencing Enrile and Bongbong Marcos and all the other Marcos cronies in  the Impeachment Court to vote in favor of Corona’s acquittal.  A case of indirect blackmail, if I may again abuse the word, aimed at the Marcos cronies in the IC effectively saying “vote in favor of an acquittal otherwise I (Corona together with his co-thieves in the SC) will again flip-flop and reverse this decision and award the billions to the farmers”!  Indeed they are only after self-preservation instead of the preservation of the interests of the poorest of the poor.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_XYPFIGTBA5LXMX2UBLCQVG5AQE Martin

       This all is related to President Aquino wanting a Supreme Court to vote his way and support him on policy matters.  Now Uncle Danding has his 60 Billion pesos. What more can the President ask?  He is smiling all the way to the bank with his Uncle…

  • AllaMo

    It is become patently clear that Solomonic justice can never be had from the supreme court, as it is constituted. Impeach all these kleptocrat coddling (in)justices now!

  • cliff_castillo

    How could you expect the farmers to win their case with the SC when they don’t have the money (millions) to pay off the SC justices unlike Danding.  Only people power or occupy the SC can reform the present crooks in the SC.

  • JK1000

    What do you expect when the whole justice system of the Country is so corrupt even the Supreme Court led by Thief Justice Corona. Danding Cojuangco should be put in jail with theMarcosses, Enrile, Ongpin, Escudero and other Marcos cronies for raping the Country’s resources.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_W4RTNUSX3BQCWCDQAA562BFC5I Lito G

    ‘Langya kasalanan na naman ni PNOY ‘to kasi uncle nya si Danding!… Hoy PNOY ABNOY ka talaga! LOL

    • indiosbravos2002

      Wtf? Where is the logic in that?

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_W4RTNUSX3BQCWCDQAA562BFC5I Lito G

        Walanghiya kayong apat… haven’t  you heard of “reverse psycho”? Inuunahan ko lang ang mga pro-Coronarroyo hehe

      • Ronilo Yap

        Do not expect them of having logic. There’s no logic in them. they are just plain idiot.

    • KapitanBagwis

       hehehe talaga ikaw oo…basta meron lang masabi kahit walang kwenta

    • JK1000

      Hahahaha…walang hiya ka, lahat sinisisi mo kay Pnoy. Kahit hindi magnanakaw .

    • AttyAAA

      Learn your history first before commenting!!!! There is bad blood between Danding and Cory’s side of the family (ie. Pnoy and his sisters) because Danding was a Marcos crony. 

    • AllaMo

      Ogag! Desisyon ito nang labs mong unaccountably independent coronarroyo court. Ito yung korte na primus inter pares si corona. Ito rin yung korte na nagbigay nang kalingkingan sa mga magsasaka ng HLI. At, ngayon ay kumitil sa kaluluwa at pagasa nang coconut farmers para makamit ang katarungan.

  • joeldcndcn

    HONESTLY, NOBODY TRUST ANYMORE THIS PRESENT SUPREME COURT, ITS VERY CORRUPT, THEREFORE, ONCE THE CORRUPT CORONA IS REMOVE, ANOTHER CASE SHOULD BE FILED REGARDING THE COCOFED CLAIM OF THE FARMERS, JUST HOW MANY “FLIP FLOPPING” THAT THIS CORONA SUPREME COURT HAVE DONE, ANOTHER ONE WILL NOT MAKE ANY DIFFERENCE AT ALL, THE PEOPLE KNEW WHAT KIND OF SC THIS COUNTRY HAS RIGHT NOW, ITS CHIEF JUST IS ACCUSED OF GRAFT & CORRUPTIONS, VERY APPALLING TIME, TSK, TSK, TSK! DISMANTLE THIS SC AND START A NEW ONE, THAT THE PEOPLE CAN TRUST!

    • Rhine

       just sleep and make a wish Philippines…..you may wake up in make believe world of “Straight Path” where people are all happy and has no one to blame anymore!!!!..Yeah????

  • Aris Kalayaan

    Another syndicated anti-people decision of the Supreme Court.  It’s really hard to get social justice unless we have a real judicial reform.   All decisions of the Supreme Court involving high profile cases should be published so the people may know the voting pattern of the justices.  Through their voting pattern we can identify who among them are members of the syndicate.

  • reformist

    This is the reason why in spite of experts analysis that SMC’s stock market price may go up to 500 pesos per share because of their diversification strategies, I never buy SMC share because of its ethical issues that till now is never been cleared to the public. 

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_LLPTRPFUTYJXKI3KJS4B2UO4LI Jim De Garman

    abangan na lang ang flip-flopped wala namang final and executory ang SC maliban lang kung nakatanggap ng P200M each ang mga bumoto.

  • http://twitter.com/yogon Camillo

    If I were the farmers, I’d invoke the FASAP case and ask for a never-ending motion for reconsideration.

  • indiosbravos2002

    Sana ipublish pano botohan ng justices.

  • indiosbravos2002

    Looks like the SC justices are in a mad rush to equal Corona’s loot. Bat ba kasi nabunyag pa secret assets ni Corona. Yan tuloy naguunahan na silang yumaman. To the highest bidder na ini!

  • KapitanBagwis

    Where are the defender of HL farmers? Support these farmers too against the unfairness of the Supreme Court’s decision in this case. 

  • PurpleDaisy13

    So what can coco farmers do to learn from this and avoid this in the future?

    • KapitanBagwis

       Did you think the farmers wanted this in the first place??? During the dictatorship that this was forced to them.

      • PurpleDaisy13

        Thanks for bringing that to my attention.

        In that case, then this judgement is BS.  Something is terribly broken with the Supreme Court.

      • KapitanBagwis

         Your are welcome…we share the same sentiment concerning the Supreme Court.

  • diegogo

    nagdesisyon ang SC pabor sa HL….hoooray! Mabuhay ka CJ Corona! Suportado ka namin laban sa persekusyon ni Penoy!
    nagdesisyon ang SC kontra sa Coco levy….huh?! ano ang nangyari?

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_6O2CBKSLICLJAJW2ITH7FOAIOY Meinsideout Ako

      yan ang nagagawa ng graft & corruption, daming mukha

  • AttyAAA

    Please post the decision. We want to see how the voting went. 

  • e4e5

    Does it mean Corona will be convicted?

  • ushldcallme

    pustahan tayo, complicated din ang accounting for tax purposes nito, hindi ba bureau of internal revenue ? maybe he will bring it to his huling hantungan without being intimidated by the government, hehehe

  • UrHONOR

    ANAK ng PUSA, hindi na ba naawa ang mga TNL na just thesis na yan sa mga naghirap na mga magsasaka?  Mga nagbebenta ng lahat ng mabebenta nila, pati halos na kaluluwa, para lang maka-ahon sa gutom?  Napaka-bulag ng mga taong humatol sa kasong ito na kitang-kita kahit wala ng imbistiga-imibistigasyon na NINAKAW ang perang yon ni Marcos at ng kanyang pulutong na mga kapwa-MAGNANAKAW sa pangunguna ng tiyo ng pangulo ng bayan ngayon.

    Tag-iilang bilyon kaya ang kapalit ng desisyong yon sa mga dumisisyon?  SUBTERRANEAN  lahat ng dumisisyon laban sa mga magsasaka sa bao ng de nueve!

  • romfagen

    everything points to the money was taken from the funds of the coconut farmers.
    that Danding Cojuangco was able to do this because of his position in the bank and his closeness to the dictator ferdinand marcos…

    pero ano ang ginawa ng mga justices na itong linagay ni GMA sa korte suprema?
    sariling pera daw yun ni Danding Conjuangco at walang patunay raw na magkadikit sila ni Macoy!!

    Alam natin na pinalakad ni GMA yung pagka presidente nya sa paraan ng pera-perahan lang. Suhol dito. Suhol doon para makuha nya ang gusto nya at manatili sa kanya ang mga kakampi(kasabwat).

    Ano ang posibilidad na yung mga pinag lalagay ni GMA sa Korte Suprema ay yung mga Bayaran na tao? … MALAKI ANG POSIBILIDAD!

  • UrHONOR

    SA mga MAGSASAKA:  Ang kawikaan ng ating mga ninuno ay……KUNG HINDI MAKUHA SA SANTONG DASALAN, DAANIN SA SANTONG PASPASAN.

    Isang magandang linya sa Godfather na na-aangkop sa usaping ito ay:  If they don’t give, we take!

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/IMVVAVGYORRXVH27G3GOIR5YXE dominguez

    A very sad day for our coco farmers who brought this fight right down the alley. The Supreme Court in its effort to spite Aquino’s administration is suddenly coming out with landmark decisions on decades old cases that are anti-poor. Something has to be done. Where are the so called nationalists, socialists and the leftists? Isnt it time to flex muscles??

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_SHKBBO273I7GMSQTA4ZWLZCG3U Max

      An where is the Roman Catholic Church?  busy opposing RH bill and bashing the P-noy.

  • MNLFoodcritic

    To the young ones na di na kilala si Danding. This is how he got/stole the 20% of San Miguel. Let’s say there are 10 of you siblings and you (as Danding) is the eldest. Each of the siblings are given a daily allowance. You/Danding, forcefully/legally, takes a portion of each of your siblings’ daily allocance, even if they didn’t want to. Say after a month you collected a total of 1000 pesos from your siblings’ allowances, you invest it in various businesses. After a month, the 1000 pesos earned a total of 800 in profit. You now return the 1000 to your siblings (but instead of returning it directly, you just deposited it in a bank though you still have power over it). And the 800 pesos you keep for yourself as a ‘management fee’. Technically, you returned the 1000 pesos, thus, technically did not steal it because you returned it. But was the 800 pesos profit really yours? You can say technically you earned it because you were the one who invested it. But the truth is, majority of that shouldn’t be yours. You may take a portion of it for your ‘management fee’ but not the entirety. This is what happened to the 47% of San Miguel. 27% was the ‘1000 pesos’ and the 20% was the ‘management fee’ of ‘800 pesos’.

    • MarcyPulilan

      To MNLFoodcritic. Tama ka. Ang kadugasan pa, eh inutang daw niya iyong pinang invest niya. Paano kaya kung nalugi ang San Miguel noon at nawala iyong investments niya. Kikilalanin kaya niya na may utang siya sa Farmers? Baka sabihin naman niya eh nalugi iyong pera nila kaya sori na lang. So manalo matalo iyong pera, safe pa rin si Danding Dugas. Tingnan natin kung ano ang sasabihin ng inutile niyang pamangkin na si Noynoy.

    • PurpleDaisy13

      MNLFoodcritic,

      Something is wrong with your logic.

      There’s no such thing as forcefully/legally…..unless someone puts a pistol to their head to fraudulently sign a contract.

      If 9 siblings all agreed to lend their 100 pesos, then you cannot translate that as a transaction they didn’t want to do. That’s considered voluntary despite understanding the element of risk involved. If anyone forces you but you refuse to permit to give anyone your 100 pesos, then you have every right to protect your assets and can disagree to lend your 100 pesos anytime.

      However, if all siblings agreed to lend their 100 pesos to total 1000 pesos without involving a contract agreement to clearly specify how their money shall be returned and whether or not they will be entitled to any profit, it is their fault for the potential result of any misinterpretation. That’s the purpose and the critical importance of having a contract agreement documented on paper….it allows everyone engaged to understand the risks and conditions involved before making a commitment to pursue an investment proposal. And if you don’t understand the conditions written in an agreement, never sign it and get a friend or attorney who can comprehend the terms.

      The lesson is…no one should ever engage in any verbal agreement with regard to financial investment proposals unless there is a written contract that all parties clearly understand which identifies the potential losses and the potential gains that everyone will be subject to or awarded.

      re: “But was the 800 pesos profit really yours?”

      That depends on what the contract agreement specified with respect to who the beneficiary(s) would be upon achieving any profit gain.

      • MNLFoodcritic

        PD 276 <—this is the 'forcefully/legally'. No coconut farmer asked for this. No coconut farmer wanted this! It's called the 'coco levy' young girl.

        Have you ever seen a ciif/cocofed certificate that was given to the poor illiterate coconut farmers in exchange for the coconut levies? If you look at the bottom portion of the back of the certificate, it says, in fine print, the holder/owner of the certificate can not sell the shares without approvel or consent of cocofed/ciif.

        Before you make "i'm so smart" comments: read your history first young woman! Do some research. You seem so smart, stop visiting Facebook or Twitter, study and research instead. Nabobobo na kayo mga kabataan sa kaka FB at jejemon!

      • PurpleDaisy13

        Re: “-this is the ‘forcefully/legally’. No coconut farmer asked for this. No coconut farmer wanted this! It’s called the ‘coco levy’ young girl.”

        No MNLFoodcritic, that’s not forcefully and legally, that’s fraudulently and unlawfully old man.

        Did the Constitution not exist during the implementation of the coco levy? If not, then the country was under a dictatorship that should have abolished the coco levy the day the dictator had been removed while returning the contributions accumulated from the coco levy back to the coconut farmers.

        However, if a Constitution did exist, then the coconut farmers should have had the democratic opportunity to vote out and deny this coco levy from being implemented. If not, then this is fraud and unlawful….not forced by a pistol or legal by the people and the Constitution.

        re: “Before you make “i’m so smart” comments: read your history first young woman! Do some research.”

        After reading a little about the history a few hours ago…I don’t see how you could use your 1000-peso scenario to describe the situation with coco farmers. This is a crime against the people, not a transaction gone bad. Use a better scenario next time old man.

      • MNLFoodcritic

        You said you read a little about the history. I definitely know you only read a little. You know why? I’ll teach you a few things:

        You were wondering about the existence of the constitution. Now student, do you know what constitution you are talking about? Let me give you some useful facts. The 1935 Constitution was abolished by Marcos in 1972 around the same time he declared Martial law. He replaced it with the 1973 Constitution. Now you know why the PD 276 came to be: because the Marcos crafted 1973 allowed for Marcos to create laws just by instituting his presidential decrees. Yes my child, 1973 was already under a dictatorship.

        Going to PD 276, it was not a contract between the coconut farmers and the state. It was a decree by the dictator. So all your pretense of “contractual agreement” never existed between the state and the coconut farmers.

        Yes you are right, it was and still is a crime against the people. Except it was brilliantly executed by President Noynoy Aquino’s uncle Danding Cojuangco by creating so many grey areas. It was forcefully executed.

        I hope you learned a thing or two. Do not “read a little” my student. Read a LOT more! Read about also about the price of copra from the 1970s to the 80s. I hope there’s still material on the internet.

      • PurpleDaisy13

        MNLFoodcritic,

        re: “Yes my child, 1973 was already under a dictatorship.”

        then this falls under the condition I described that should have been resolved immediately after the dictator had been removed and the Constitution was restored.

        and if the money ’till this day has not been returned to the people, then you still have a handful of judges that are not immune to bribery and don’t respect the Constitution or recognize justice for the people they were elected as public servants.

        re: “So all your pretense of “contractual agreement” never existed between the state and the coconut farmers.”

        That discussion of contractual agreement did not refer to coconut farmers. It is applicable under the thread and context of what you wanted little kids to learn…your 1000-peso scenario scam.

        re: “I hope you learned a thing or two.”

        i am learning a little bit more…thank you for your insight

      • MNLFoodcritic

        “then this falls under the condition I described that should have been resolved immediately after the dictator had been removed and the Constitution was restored.”

        You really are not too bright. The constitution was NEVER restored. A new constitution was written in 1987 during Noynoy’s mother. And she never resolved it during her time.

        It’s quite hard to discuss with you when you don’t have your facts straight. Read and research first before you make any comments.

      • PurpleDaisy13

        MNLFoodcritic,

        re: “You really are not too bright.”

        On the contrary, you’re stumbling all over yourself just as you had originally used the wrong analogy with Danding as a sibling of 10 regarding the investment of 1000 pesos.  When in fact, Danding is no where near being a sibling with the coconut farmers because brothers and sisters are likely to be honest and trustworthy when it comes to investing finances between siblings as a common goal to bring success and prosperity within family blood lines. Danding is not a relative and moreover is a crooked thief where the word “legal” does not apply.

        re: “The constitution was NEVER restored.”

        When a Constitution is redefined for the wrong reasons, but replaced with a new Constitution for the right reasons, that’s the definition of being “restored”. What kind of game of semantics do you want to waste your time playing?

        re: “A new constitution was written in 1987 during Noynoy’s mother. And she never resolved it during her time”

        Corazon Aquino’s failure to abolish and resolve the illegal implementation of the Coco Levy is not an excuse for a Constitution that has not been restored. This is a case that should be disputed within the Judicial system under the legitimate Constitution.As long as the dictatorship, that forced the Coco Levy upon farmers, have been removed from power, Corazon’s administration or any administration thereafter vs Coco Farmers should have resolved this issue long ago unless corrupt officials were still in power.

        You have a bad habit of insulting the intelligence of others, but you seem to forget that the older you get beyond age 65, the more your own brain shall deteriorate and borderline the chances for dementia, the inability to process thought (intelligence). Soon your self-perception of your own brightness will just be your own imagination.

      • MNLFoodcritic

        By the way, just so you know, my family are copra traders that’s the reason why we know about the certificates of CIIF. We have been waiting for so long. Now, the reason why this robbery by Danding is so hard to fight in the courts and in the legal arena, is because the robbery was crafted in a way that it looked like the “management fee” that I described in an analogy above. I hope this gives you a better picture why I used that analogy.

      • PurpleDaisy13

        re: “the reason why this robbery by Danding is so hard to fight in the courts
        and in the legal arena, is because the robbery was crafted in a way
        that it looked like the management fee”

        No. The reason why this robbery is so hard to fight in the courts is because you have corrupt judges in the Supreme Court like Corona.

        It doesn’t matter if they called it a “management fee” or a “service fee”, judges that have no honor, no integrity, and are easily tempted by wealth over justice can easily be paid off. and unfortunately, they make the final decision…that’s why all these corrupt judges have to be cleaned out by the people if not even an impeachment can get rid of all the filth staining the Supreme Courts.

  • leodegardompruna

    Was it wrong to be a friend of ex President Marcos? I cannot see the reasoning of former Sens. Salonga and Tanada. God bless the Philippines.

    • AllaMo

      Apparently not, if you were danding, lucio tan, henry sy, and, herminio disini.

    • KapitanBagwis

       Nothing wrong to be a friend but being a CRONY is another matter…see the difference?

  • mikerocky

    Sad news for coconut farmers. but this is merely a prelude to more good and better news for them. Just have faith that everything will turn out well in the end.

  • MarcyPulilan

    Kung si Khadaffy natapos din si Danding pa? Hintayin na lang natin malaman ni Danding na iyong 60 Billion pesos na kinita niya ay wala palang kuwenta kung hinihila na isa isa ng mga coconut farmers and buhok niya … sa ilong.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_IHH43FUIDR2OKBRVAB6VTM52GY Nelson

    Danding is the Uncle of President Noynoy.  Maybe the Supreme Court are so afraid of him now?  Hmmmm.

    • Daang_Tuwid2

      Ha ha ha,wala pa impeachment,natatulan na to,check your facts before posting:-)

      • caster1234

        doubt it, KKK parin  :)  

  • MangDolphy

    Ipa sa Diyos na lang ng mga coconut farmers ito. Bahala na si Lord kay Danding at lahat ng mga kasamahan nya (pati na SC) na nakinabang sa pawis at dugo ng mga mahihirap na magsasaka. Sabai naman ni Lord “The revenge is mine”. Kaya dasal na lang tayo. Di naman magbabato sa mundo yang mga iyan. Tignan mo yong may-ari ng Legacy, na timbog na rin. Nagka-kanser pa. May hangganan din naman ang kasakiman ng tao.

  • andoybarrios

    coconut farmers pinagsamantalahan, ninakawan at pinagkaitan ng batas ng gobyerno at ng mayayamang mapagsamantala!

  • UrHONOR

    Supreme Cawatan of the Philippines.  WALANG AWA.  WALANG PAKIKISAMA.  HINDI MAKA-PILIPINO.  MGA ALIPIN ng BAYAN na UMA-ALIPIN sa BAYAN. 

    Swak-na-swak sa eksenang ANIMAL FARM.

    GALISIN sana kayong lahat sa SINGIT!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_AS7ZS3RG454EKLDPVX3UR3MLGE rick

    what would you expect from a supreme court very freindly to estelito mendoza the legal eagle opf danding cojuangco. up to now the legacy(sic) of marcos is still lingering in the philippine society scenery of oppression tsk,tsk,tsk anyway GOD is not sleeping….

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_SHKBBO273I7GMSQTA4ZWLZCG3U Max

    This country is ruled by the elite, the rich and powerful, damned the poor and the ignorant, and we are supposed to be the only Christian country in Asia. 

    • KapitanBagwis

       “Not everyone who says to me, Lord, Lord. will enter into the kingdom of heaven – only the one who does the will of my father” Matt 7:21

      In other words, there are true Christians and pretending to be Christians…or those who believe that they can pay their way to heaven like giving gifts to CBCP and big donations to church (giving away people’s money)

  • KapitanBagwis

    Wala pa yata akong nakikitang mga pro-Corona ngayon dito…saan na sila para makita natin ang comment nila gaya ng pagtatanggol nila sa Hacienda Luisita farmers.

    • Daang_Tuwid2

      Naghahanap pa ng alibi,kasi pro farmer daw corona nila ha ha ha,dyan galing pera ni cj nung 2011

    • boypalaban

      pang isang lugar lang sila….
      di pang nationwide….

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/KXF6KAPFPND7FNPZWPRHMM6RKA Nicholas

     O nasaan na ang ABB. Di ba dapat pag ganitong sitwasyon kayo ang magbigay nang karampatang hustisya. Unahin nyo yong miembro nang supreme court din isunod nyo si Danding…. O ano hindi nyo kaya ano….. Mga pipitsuging pulis lang yata ang kay nyo. Wala ding silbi…. O bayan ko wala ka talagang pag asa…. HU HU HU…… amen.

    • andoybarrios

      mukha ngayon ka lang nagising sa mahabang pagkakatulog dahil tatlong dekada ng wala ang ABB…..sa negros yung sinasabi na mga ABB ay naging mangdarambong at private army di ko nga alam kung bakit hindi ito binuwag ni pnoy ng magsabi siya na unti-unti ng nabubuwag ang mga private armies……

  • UrHONOR

    Walang kinalaman ang kahit na sino pa mang diyos sa usapang pangbayan.  Ang nangyayari at pangyayari sa bayan ay kagagawan ng tao at hindi diyos.  The consequence is true, but do not use gods as the antecedent…UNLESS you have proof within reason to show it.

    SI Angeles namatay sa sakit.  Walang kinalaman ang diyos sa sakit ni Angeles. Si MArcos namatay sa sakit at hindi dahil sa kung sinupamang Lord. May ginawa mang MASAMA o MABUTI ang KAHIT NA SINUPAMAN, tiyak yon na MAMAMATAY din siya balang araw….ke kanser o anupamang dahilan.  LAHAT ng TAO ay MAMAMATAY. May namamatay na bata pa lang at may namamatay na matanda.  Bulag, pipi, pilay, politiko, mangnanakaw, pari, nagpapari-parian, obi$pong mahilig sa SUV, artista, ma-aarte at iba ay lahat mamamatay balang araw.  Hindi sa kung sinupamang pahintulot kundi bahagi ng buhay ang kamatayan. Huwag na haluan pa ng kung ano-anong kaisipan tungkol sa diyos na pinagkikitaan na ng maraming “pres da lurd” na money-making clubs dahil lalong nagiging magulo at ma-aslilamuot ang usapan.  

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_AFDQQH2M3OD6ZGBJNJ34UZHIV4 Enrico

      In short, wala kang alam usapang pang relihiyon. Magbasa ka ng Biblia gayahin mo si Manny.

      • KapitanBagwis

         Kahit siya magbasa hindi niya maiintindihan ang kahulugan ng mga salita ng Diyos

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_AFDQQH2M3OD6ZGBJNJ34UZHIV4 Enrico

        Malay mo hehehe….Lahat naman napag aaralan kahit paunti unti

      • KapitanBagwis

         Totoo yun…pero itong isang ito mukhang sarado isip…money making lang daw yung “pres the lurd”  hehehe

      • UrHONOR

        IN SHORTEST. makitid pa ang utak mo sa eskinita sa Session road!

        May alam man o ako o wala sa kahit na ano ay WALA kang PAKI.  At sino kang nagbibigay ng payo sa kung ano ang dapat gawin ng kahit ninuman…..bakit, bata ka ba ng CBCP?

        Marami ka pang ngangataing nganga bago ka magkaroon ng sapat na kaisipan upang sumali sa usapang matino.  Palakihn mo muna yang tutubing karayom mong utaque saka ka umentra sa bukid ng kaalaman. 

    • KapitanBagwis

       Atheist ka ba?

      • UrHONOR

        La Sallist ako, hindi Atheist.
        IMBISTIGADOR ka ba ni Mike Enriquez?

      • KapitanBagwis

         Imbestigador po ako ni Raissa Robles…ah hindi pala kayo Atheist…ok kung ganun ;o))

      • UrHONOR

        KAYA naman pala MATAYOG ang lipad ng bagwis mo, kapitan.

  • ptoprin

    sa desisyong ito, kahit na ma sipa pa si CORONA at angkinin ng gobyerno lahat ng kanyang ariarian, tiyak nakatawa pa at bukas kamay tatanggapin ni thief justce ang desisyon ng impeachment court. KAYA AYAW MAGBITIW NI CORONA KAHIT KASUKASUKA NA SIYA. ITO NA ANG KANYANG HULING “ALAS”. LAHAT SILA NAKINABANG DITO. SIR CORONA, MAGKANO PO BA AT SAAAN INILAGAK NGAYON ANG HIDDEN DOLLARS?

    • KapitanBagwis

       Pagkatapos ng IC, malamang sumunod ang Ombudsman at Sandigan Bayan…maraming pwedeng ikaso sa kanya kasama na ang perjury (pagsisinungaling)

  • MariusDejess

    How do people get so rich so fast?

    You have got to maneuver things so that others are defrauded to your advantage, that is how; then you get wickedly sharp lawyers and judges to side with you on legality.

  • Mattino2011

    Farmers…wala na un inaasahan pa ninyo…nabigyan si coro at sc asso ng mga condo kasi..Ayan…rally kayo sa SC dali

  • Mario_Garcia

    That’s the way it is with Philippine justice.  Supreme Corruption scores again.

  • boypalaban

    hello sa mga corona fans:
    musta na kayo?
    musta na hacienda luisita?
    musta na ang coconut farmers?
    di ba tagapagtanggol kayo ng inaapi ng mga panginoong may lupa?
    di ba bilib na bilib kayo sa SC na siyang nagtatanggol sa mga magsasaka?
    PANG HACIENDA LUISITA LANG BA KAYO?

  • caster1234

    scores ung mga conjuangco d2 ahh, they get the money + help pnoy’s so called daan matuwid campaign. hehehe 

  • boypalaban

    mga corona fans: wag magnoynoying…sugod na sa malacanang…kalampagin nyo….isumbong nyo ang SC…niloko kayo na kunwari maka-magsasaka sila…..pang isang lugar lang pala….HACIENDA LUISITA….hahaha!
    TAWA TAWA NGAYON SI ATTY ROY…..
    PARA DAW SA INYO…ISANG NAKAKAKILABOT NA PUTOK……BOOOOOOOOOM!

  • Taiko_Kauna

    you cannot expect justice from a corrupt court, as Jesus said ” bad trees cannot bear good fruit, only good trees can bring forth good fruits”, especially with a corrupt trunk of that tree. Cut the trunk and plant again would be the best option

  • GKid

    President Aquino must be happy that the Supreme Court sided with his Uncle Danding, who helped him during the election.

    • boypalaban

      SI DANDING AY KAY GIBA…ANG DAKILANG TUTA NI GLORIA…TAGAPAG-PATUPAD NG CURFEW AT MILITARISASYON NG REHIMENG ARROVO-CORONA.

  • boypalaban

    CORONA: ANG SHARES NG MGA MAGNINIYOG AY PARA LANG KAY DANDING…NA CRONY MI MARCOS…NA PANGINOON NAMAN NI AMO GLORIA…. ANG HACIENDA LUISITA AY PARA SA MAGSASAKA (HUWAG KAYO MAINGAY HA…JOKE LANG)…MUSTA NA KAYA ANG MGA CONDO KO?WALA NA BANG BUTAS? MIDAS!!!! HALIKA DITO…BAKIT MAY TULO DITO?

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_H225J62UZJRMG2PMZ6BB6UOYCI tipay

    we’re talking of billions of pesos again. WOW pula na naman ang mga hasang ng mga taga SC.

    sige dalian mo cj ang pagdesisyon sa mga malalaking kaso at magipon ka bago matapos ang trial mo hehehe. 

  • False_Prophet

    This complicated legal issue is another sign of how the judges of the Supreme Court can be bought by the highest bidder. Transparency is paramount in trusting the decisions, however complex. It is a disappointing sign that all things are corrupt in the PH, and truth and justice for the People is sacrificed for personal gains of the rich and corrupt. This will ultimately lead to a weaker Nation, and not a stronger one.

  • http://www.facebook.com/isidro.valencia Isidro Valencia

    Di ba ang Supreme Court is well known for rendering flip flopping decisions. On this premise, baka may pag asa pa.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_RFG6UCNQ56C4BLXE67YMGP7REI henry

      SC is no different fom other Government agencies. The policy is “Name your price” or “highest bidder.” Imagine, CJ Corona has only 100 million pesos, while the favorite candidate of PNoy has more than 250 million pesos. The question then is how does thee “salamagan” able to accumulate so much money in their life-time. He hehe. They must be moonlighting as security guard, and “bote-garapa” in their day offs.

      In the Municipal Trial Court, I WAS EXTORT OF 10,000 PESOS BYan Acting Prosecutor here in Q.C. What more in the SC?

  • Mattino2011

    Danding;   Luke 9:25
    “For what is a man profited if he gains the whole world, and loses or forfeits himself?

    • MNLFoodcritic

      I don’t think he cares. A really big, bad thief wouldn’t care about any bible verses.

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_RFG6UCNQ56C4BLXE67YMGP7REI henry

        Don’t speak about wealth and the bible. It is said that it is easier for a horse to enter the eye of a needle than a rich man to enter the gates of heaven. Besides, you are speaking of a Chinese. Chinese are known predator, cheater, and opportunist. You do not talk sense with these race. They will always put one over you. Not only Cojuangco after the Coco Levy funds, now they also want to consolidate their hold on the Hacienda Luisita which was in the first place agreed that they will only operate it on 10 years lease. That was dacades ago.

        This is the major reason why CJ Corona is being impeach. And Corona said it so. Our country is no longer democratic. We have an Oligarchy government in which only rich and powerful people rules our government. This is disadvantageous to the entire Filipinos because these our Chinese Dominated Government is in to dominate us Filpinos whether we like it or not. The Chinese controls almost everything the Filipinos have, and even our government. Think again.

  • edleon

    Pasok na naman yan sa mga $ accounts ni TJ CORONA and gang…  tsk..tsk..tsk..

  • 1VeritasAequitas

    @GKid : Kung babalikan mo ang mas recent history ng PIlipinas, malalaman mo na si Eduardo Cojuangco at  ang mga magulang ni Presidente Aquino ay magkalaban  sa pulitika. Si Danding ay  napakalapit na Crony ni Marcos samantalang si Ninoy na ama ng Presidente at ang ina niyang si Cory ay nasa Oposisyon. Nakulong nang matagal si Ninoy hanggang palayain siya ni Marcos for health reasons dahil na din sa calls and  demands locally and internationally for his release. Buong pamilya nila Ninoy ay pumunta sa America at  maraming taon silang na-exile hanggang mag-desisyon si Ninoy na bumalik ng Pilipinas para matulungang mahango at mailigtas ang ating bansa mula sa  malawakan at walang habas na corruption at kasamaan ng rehimeng Marcos.

    Kabi-kabila ang kahambal-hambal at karumal-dumal na mga krimen. Ang mga taong sumasalungat sa katiwalian at kawalan ng katarungan at iba pang mga paninikil at  pagpapahirap sa sambayanan ay hinuhuli,kinukulong at binabansagang mga Komunista. LIbu-libo sa kanila ang nangangawala at .sila ay itinorture ng kalunus-lunos at napakatagal bago pinatay. Doon nagsimula ang Desparecidos. Hanggang ngayon, liibu-libo sa kanila ang hindi pa natatagpuan. Sa panahon ni Marcos nagsimula ang walang kapantay na pag-abuso sa karapatang pang-tao at pagpatay ng masasamang miyembro ng militar at pulisya sa mga mamamayan.. Bilyung-bilyong dolyar ang ninakaw at idineposito ng mga Marcos sa ibang mga bansa at bilyun-bilyon din ang pesos na ninakaw nila. Sa pag-takas ng mga Marcos sa Pilipinas sa tulong o mediation ng Amerika , daang-daang milyung piso ang nakumpiska ng U.S. Customs officials sa pagdating nila sa airport sa Honolulu, Hawaii na nakalagay sa mga maletang pag-aari ng mga Marcos.

    Doon din nag-simula ang malawakang pagbagsak ng moralidad at decency ng mga Pilipino. Isa sa ginamit ng rehimeng Marcos para libangin ang mga tao lalo na ang mga kalalakihan ay ang pagpapalabas ng ponograpiya sa pelikula at malalaswng diyaryo at magasin. Noon nagsimula ang  mga pelikula na tinatawag na “bomba”. Nakakalungkot na hanggang ngayon, marami pa rin na mga tabloids at magazines na naglalaman ng napakalalaswang artikulo , litrato, at imahe na isa sa mga sanhi ng krimen at rape sa mga kababaihan na kadalasan ay humahantong pa sa pagpatay sa kanila. Ang mga pelikula ay totoo ding malalaswa. Dapat ay tutukan ito ng gobyerno. May right and duty ang state or government na protektahan ang moralidad ng sosyedad lalo na kung ito ay nagiging sanhi ng erosion ng moralidad ng citizenry at ng mga heinous crimes.

    Si Ninoy na ama ni Presidente Aquino ay pinatay sa tarmac ng Manila International Airport na ngayon ay NAIA na ang pangalan. Noon ay hinihinala ng marami na alam ni Danding Cojuangco ang planong assassination kay Ninoy at kasama dito si General Fabian Ver, Imelda Marcos at iba pa. Ngayon, paano mo sasabihin na si Danding Cojuangco at Presidente Aquino ay magkakampi at nagtutulungan? Napakalaki ng pag-kakaiba ng kanilang mga panuntunan sa buhay at tunay na magkalayo ang tinatahak na landas ng bawat isa sa kanila.

    Ang mga justices ng Supreme Court na nag-promulgate ng napakawalang-katarungang ruling na ito ay isa sa kasuklam-suklam na miyembro ng ating lipunan. Wala silang awa sa mga mahihirap na magsasaka ng niyog. Hindi kay Danding ang bilyung-bilyong pera ng Coconut Levy. He should be compelled to return the money to the real and rightful owners.

  • ardong

    A barrage of sneer and protest must be done to these SC’s expunging of petitioners. Circumventing real issues favoring highest bidder, it’s a mockery of our judicial system favoring the rich (as usual!)  and subsequently furthering oppression of  coconut farmers.

    Simple question: what is UCPB before Martial Law? Where did Cojuangco’s get his fund in acquiring SMC?Mr. Cojuangco knows in heart his follies and madness – in connivance with the late dictator in siphoning hard-earned and meager profits of these small farmers, they  both (Mr. C and Marcos) pocketed millions of pesos under the guise of “taxation” and now enjoy the full luxury of the biggest food conglomerates in SE Asia.He could maintain his present stature to the fullest, consequently, gain all the blessing of his god, but in the end, he surely is going to lose his soul to One true God.

  • tuldok

    This is the greatest sin and injustice ever against the Filipino people.   What we got after my parents died was a mere P10,000 insurance, but for 9 long years – we paid levies on our harvest.  Cocofed never improved the way we cultivate our farms, never helped subsidize fertilizers and the like, never helped us against the traders and other entities that controlled and monopolized the whole coconut industry.

    This is undoubtedly the worst offense this country has ever done to its citizens. Blood, sweat and tears from farmers like us, billions and billions of pesos to the pockets of the powerful and the greedy.

    We’re all mortals and we’re all gonna die.  I just wish those big crocodiles die first and soon!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_RFG6UCNQ56C4BLXE67YMGP7REI henry

      People power is the solution. If a government does not obey the wish of the people, it becomes illegitmate government. We have been treated by our Chinese Domnated Government as serf, slaves, and our role is just to feed their greed. Look at the eyes of Cabinet Secretary of the past and present administration. They are all Filipino Chinese. And they do not care what happens to the millions of Coconut farmers. What our government delivers are all lip service. Now, they are in the last stage of Chinese takeover of our country. PNoy will privatize ALL the properties, the shares, the government owned corporation and give it to his co-Chinese. In the end, the Filipinos is merely holding an empty bag. He heehhe. We are a nation of slaves for a long time because we do not react to the abuses our government is doing to us. 

      Billions of pesos just like the Jetropa sponsored by the former Senator of Maguindanao, Migz Zubiri, worth 4 billion pesos has gone to the drain. Who is the victim, we, the tax payer. Was he jailed for engaging on spurious project, NO!

      The project was bankrupt but Migz became a mulimillionaire. He hehe. Suckers!

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Robert-Cruz/100002281792575 Robert Cruz

        Alam mo Henry, bakit chinese ang sinisisi mo? E samantalang ang argument mo ay si Zubiri at mga corrupt ng justices ng Supreme Court? E sino ba dyan sa mga yan ang Chinese? Napaka-racist mo at may pagka-t a n g a. kasing t a n g a mo nanay mo!

      • tuldok

        Robert, with due respect, let’s all try to argue with civility.   I responded to Henry in the best argument I could present.  There is no need for name calling here, my friend.

        We can all disagree without being disagreeable.

        Peace.

      • noeltabaz2

        Exactly.  I wonder what satisfaction does it give to those people who post their comments with nothing but calling names and throwing invectives to people whom they don’t even know.  For all they know those people they call stupid are brighter than them.  To me, what they are doing is just a sign of poor breeding.

      • tuldok

        I know that pards,  that’s why i know of many young guns who went to the hills at the height of martial law… i was so close to doing so too myself, thanks i did not, as i do not need any purist ideologies to butress my own personal view of a government that really is for the people and its citizens –  a view that i am sure you and i share….

        i am all for people power of whatever shape, way or form.   but the BIG problem is still rooted from the OLD MONEY (chinese, spanish elite/hacienderos etc) and the OLIGARCHY, Political Dynasties, and may I add, a lack of cultural/moral revolution that will benefit the next generations when our generation leave this world.

        Still too many big tasks ahead…A step in the right direction would be unity of urpose and sharing of common goals for all Filipinos. People power through education (specially in election years) , networking, facebooking, emailing, eblogging…… cyberpower perhaps?

  • kismaytami

    Pera-pera lang yan sa SC.

  • marriondale

    Can you say that the SC is anti-Pnoy and his relatives.  Definitely not with this ruling.  For all bloggers here that insinuates that the SC can be paid by the highest bidder.  Read the whole ruling first and see its merits before jumping to that conclusion. In every decision, one will be a winner and the other a loser.  In this case, Danding cojuangco wins and the farmer claimants lose.

    • anak_mahirap50

      …and some SC justices as winners?

  • jamesgeorge

    It’s totally expected from a bunch of SC justices who caters to the highest bidder! Kilala ninyo yang mga yan, they’re just being consistent, wait yung Boss nila kamukha ni Macoy, tumaba lang ng konti!

  • gener ver

    They favored the Cojuangcos to tell the people they are not bias against PNoy. Very good move by Corona and allies. PNoy will now be blamed by the people for the failure to support the coconut farmers in this case. 

    • marriondale

      What more can I say? I cannot force you to change your impression of the SC.

    • Mattino2011

      Till this day Danding and Cory’ siblings are still not in good terms….Danding supported Gibo not Pnoy.Iam anti-corona s well but  I think otherwise

    • Mattino2011

      SAbi nga the enemy of my enemy is my friend..Ninoy’s children still have not forgotten the crony that was Danding during Macoy’s time..At one time he was suspected to have masterminded his assasination 

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1173108837 Manuel C. Diaz

    The coconut farmers using their numbers should organize a mob and occupy the Supreme Court.

  • boypalaban

    MARCOS=DANDING=GLORIA=CORONA
    May pagkakaiba ba?…..IBA ANG MAY PINAGSAMAHAN….

    HI CORONA BLOGGERS, MUSTA NA KAYO…MGA TAGAPAGPANGGOL KUNO NG MGA INAAPI NG MGA HACIENDERO?

    • NOYNOYING

      bkit hnd mo isama si noynoy tanga ampota hacinedero rin yon bobo!!

      MARCOS=DANDING=GLORIA=CORONA=NOYNOY GANYAN DAPAT BOBO!!

      Puro pag amoy kasi kay roy inaatupag mo mga kabaklaan mo kasi boybeki boyhimod boybakla

      • boypalaban

        BOPLOKS BAKLA BOOOOOM!
        MUSTA GABI NYO NI TROPA MIDAS
        TANGA KA PA RIN HANGGANG NGAYON, PANSAYANG SPACE KA LANG DITO! BOPLOKS ….BOOOOOOOOOM!

      • NOYNOYING

        bwahaha.. tignan mo nga post mo hahah sino mas tanga sa atin? haha.. puro baklaan lang ang alm mo dito.. lagi ka nakahimod sa noo ni panot boyhimod.. pati kilikili ni atty roy pnapasok mo pa.. eh lagi mo nmn hinihimod kilikila ni att roy.. tapos ngayon maya pa BOOOM BOOM kapa.. baklang bakla ampoto baklang salot boybakla

  • boypalaban

    O MGA TAGAPAGTANGGOL NG MGA MAGSASAKA SA HACIENDA LUISITA…LABAS! LABAS KAYO NGAYON! IPAGTANGGOL NYO ANG PINAKAMAMAHAL NINYONG COROKOT….SIGE,PUNTA SA SC,MAGBARIKADA AT BAKA SUGURIN NG MGA MAGSASAKA…

    ETO SABIHIN NYO HA:

    “LUPA PARA SA MAGSASAKA!
    WAG MAGNOYNOYING!
    IBIGAY ANG PARA KAY DANDING!”

    REGARDS FROM ATTY ROY:   BOOOOOOOOOM!

    YAN HA KUMPLETO PA, MAY FIREWORKS PA ANG RALLY NYO, HA HA HAPPY NEW YEAR…PUTUKAN NA…..SINGHUTIN ANG MASANGSANG NA HANGIN! BOOOOM!

  • Guest

    the supreme court machinery is oiled by money and its justices are lapdogs of the chinese and the oligarchy. the only solution to this is to shed blood. we have been oppressed for too long as a people. no one really cares about us from among these people high up. our children must be taught assassination, demolition, and other internecine techniques, for the only way to free ourselves is to annihilate those who oppress us. ALL OF THEM.

    these people in government and business view us as mere commodities, money factories from whom to take hard-earned wages, in exchange for the lousy services and substandard and poisonous products they offer. they will only pay us enough not to die of hunger, then take the money away and back to themselves. this cannot go on. and the only way to change everything is to assassinate these people and their seed. every vestige of their existence that will continue the oppression must be erased. if the farmers want change, there is no other way but to make the ultimate sacrifice.

    • Dyndin

      blame penoy !

      • resgestae

        Ang kulit mo wala kang sense.

  • TinimbangNgunitKulang

    Kunwari pa na sila daw eh para sa mahirap ng ibigay nila ang Hacienda Luisita sa mga tenants. Pero ngayon lumitaw talaga ang tunay na kulay ng mga hunyangong justices kuno. Sino ngayon ang talagang naghihiganti ng gawin nila ang Luisita ruling?

  • muddygoose

    Akala ko ba ang supreme court ang protector ng mga farmers? Hmmmmm…

  • muddygoose

    Please ilabas ang voting record at ipublish lahat ng opinions, kasama na ang dissents.

  • Yanong_OFW

    sorry guys billionaryo ang katapat nyo..mag imagine nalang kayo na natanggap nyo..

    • MNLFoodcritic

      di na kelangan kasi kalahati nung mga farmers na yun patay na…

  • http://profiles.yahoo.com/u/JQI7ACPTNS65URDEQ3KRYKCPDY Henry

    It is indeed the “joke of the century,” the biggest highway robbery, the most gross injustice and the ultimate example of the richest thief in Phil. history getting away with the crime courtesy of the most corrupt supreme court led by CJ Corona whose ally associate justices compose the majority. May the karmic forces get back at them.

    • Dyndin

      why blame corona? blames your president, this is his uncle, danding cojuangco.

      • resgestae

        Ang labo naman ng logic mo. Si Noynoy ba ang nagdesisyon? Hindi ba ang SC, na majority ay hawak ni Corona?

  • MNLFoodcritic

    Danding Cojuangco manipulated the coconut industry in the 70s, and using a series of Marcos presidential decrees starting with PD 276, forced a monopoly on the industry as well as manipulated the price of copra. This made him a billionaire at the expense of the coconut farmers becoming poorer. Now, because of supporting his nephew Noynoy to the presidency, he is back with a vengeance and dominating the oil, energy and other utilities industries via his ownership of Petron, Meralco, SLEX, etc, etc. Given his power to manipulate whole industries back in the 70s, is he possibly behind the present so-called “energy crisis in Mindanao” and the wholesale price increases of electricity throughout the country? Hmmm…

  • http://twitter.com/top_sandy Desan

    The president and his families succeeded in HARASSING the judiciary……….They are now afraid to go against the President because they might be impeached………Poor Republic of the Philippines and the Filipino People in believing with this kind of President……… A PRESIDENT FOR THE ELITE AND PROTECTOR OF FAMILY HOLDINGS LIKE HER MOTHER CORY AQUINO BUT NOT FOR THE POOR…..Shame on you dear president and your leaders……..

    • Dyndin

      Matagal nang pinaglalaban ni GMA ni COCO Levy.
      Kagagawan ni Penoy lahat ito. 

      • boypalaban

        OO NGA PINAGLALABAN NI GLORIARROVO ITO PARA SA SARILI NIYA,…PARA RIN KAY CORONA, ABALOS,MENDOZA, AMPATUAN, DELA PAZ, LIGOT., HORN,…ETC.

    • antonioluna

      ang tanga naman ng kumentong ito, isang tanong isang sagot, kailan sa kasaysayan ng pinas nakinabang ang mga mahihirap sa mga desisyon ng korte suprema?
      sagutin mo para hindi ka na magmukhang tanga ay nagmumukhang napakabobo mo pa.
      kung lalaliman mo pa ng kaunti ang iyong payak na pag iisip malalaman mo na kailanman hindi pa nagkaroon ng tinatawag na social justice dito sa pinas, nagkalat ang mga tangang katulad mo na sa halip na tingnan ang tunay na problema ay isisi sa iba.

    • AttyAAA

      Shame on you for not knowing your history! Alam mo bang magkagalit si Pnoy at Danding dahil Marcos crony si Danding at may balita pa na siya ang nagpa-patay kay Ninoy? Banat ng banat eh di naman alam ang buong storya.

      • MNLFoodcritic

        Sir Atty, my guess is the last time you read the newspapers was when FVR was still the president. Let me give you lang po a quick review of history after FVR’s administration when you were still away (mahabang bakasyon po ata kinuha niyo). Yes, Cory and Danding (and maybe Pnoy) during the 80s and most part of the 90s were enemies, but towards the late 90s and early 2000s, there was reconciliation. Kris started talking about her “Tito Ed” na, at mabi na daw sila ng “Mom” niya. 2010, kumalas po si Gibo (pamangkin din ni Danding) from the Nacionalista party. Nagalit si Tito Ed. Ngayon nakita niya, mas-winnerable si pamangking Noynoy, sinuportahan niya. Money and machinery. Even loaned Noynoy his white, bullet proof Lexus SUV (remember the inauguration in 2010?). Ayan po Tatang Atty.

      • http://profiles.google.com/odredd Dredd Ofalexandria

        Just my personal opinion. Danding is a power-broker. He might have orchestrated the Ninoy assasination kasi sure yun na yung political nemesis nya na si Ferdinand Marcos ang seguradong sisisihin.

        So what happened? People power to overthrow the regime. Installing Cory as new president.Well, who could have blamed him when after all he is a Cojuanco.So now he is enjoying the “fruits” of his labor.

    • NOYNOYING

      db sabi nga magiging miserable buhay mo pag kinalaban mo ang administrasyon.. tignan mo si pakyaw.. hnd lang pumirma sa impeachement eto pa ginawa.. dapat si panot ang harassin ng mga pilipino.. buti pa si pakyaw may naambag na karangalan sa pilipinas i panot NOYNOYING ang binibgay na karangalan sa pilipinas..

      • boypalaban

        BOOOOOOOM!
        BAKLENGTOT!
        ANG LAKAS NG PUTOK NG UTAK MO! BOOOOOOM!

      • NOYNOYING

        hahaha.. kabaklaann mo n nmn BOYHIMOD hahaha… puros kabaklaan lang alm mo dito boybakla hahaha.. BOYBEKI BOYBAKLA hahaha.. BOYPALABADING HAHAHA..

      • boypalaban

        HOY TAGAHILOD NG PWET NI CORONARROVO: KILIKILI NAMAN NI PUTOK ROY ISUNOD MO! BOOOOM!

      • NOYNOYING

        BOYHIMOD tigil mo na yang kabaklaan mo dito.. may pa BOOM BOOM kapa haha.. pang skwater pa banat mo haha… pang skwater lang yan BOOM hahah.. BOYSWATER hahaha..

      • boypalaban

        SIGE ITAWAG MO NA KAHIT ANONG GUSTO MONG ITAWAG….BASTA BADINGER KA PA RIN…KUNG MAY PERA KA OK SA AKIN, KASO WALA E…DI AKO KIKITA SA YO…NANAKAWIN MO LANG LAKAS KO….BOOOOOOOOOM! MAS BAGAY SA YO PUTOK NG DIOS MONG SI ATTY ROY.

      • boypalaban

        IKAW BINIBIGYAN MO SI PANOT NG LIBRENG AD…BOBO KA TALAGA! BOOOOOM!

      • NOYNOYING

        uuuy nkiki-panot rin hahaha.. kakahimod mo sa noo ni panot.. kaya ka nagkakalat dito.. resulta yan ng kabaklaan mo.. boybakla, boyhimod boybeki boyswakter.. noynoying everyday hahaha..

      • boypalaban

        PURO KA TAWAG NG KUNG ANO ANO WALA KA KASING ARGUMENTO…BOPLOKS KASI UTAK MONG MAY PUTOK!
        BOOOOM!
        KAHIT ANONG SABIHIN MO DITO, BAKLA KA PA RIN….NANGANGAMOY KA…MALANSA…HUGAS KA MUNA…BOPLOKS…BOOOOM!

      • NOYNOYING

        hahaha.. tignan mo nga mga post mo dito kung may argumento ba? hahaha.. puro lang pambabara lang ang gingwa mo dito brad.. pag inaway ang syota mong si panot binbara mo.. baklang bakla ka kasi.. syota mo si panot.. gawain lang yan ng mga bakla.. mga kabaklaan mo wag mo ikalat dito.. ang lansa mo.. BOY SKWATER

      • boypalaban

        THANK YOU, ANDAMI MONG TAWAG SA AKIN…THANKS HA…BASTA IKAW BADINGER PA RIN…AT MAY MALAKAS NA PUTOOOOOK! BOOOOOM!

      • NOYNOYING

        ampota baklang bakla talga mga banat mo brad hahaha.. nkakatawa lang ang banat mo.. puro noynoying at kabaklaan hahaha.. mahiya ka nmn sa among panot.. ganyan ka dito.. ugaling skwater.. hahaha..  BOYBAKLA haha.. BOYHIMOD.. hahaha.. BAKLANG BAKLA KA HAHA..

      • boypalaban

        IKAW KAHIT DI MO KALABANIN ADMINISTRASYON ,WALANG KWENTA BUHAY MO…BOPLOKS KA KASI….BOOOOM!

  • AttyAAA

    FYI. Danding and Pnoy are not on good terms. Magkaaway si Danding at Cory nung buhay pa si Cory. Danding supported Gibo during the 2020 elections.

    • AttyAAA

      Sorry typo 2010 elections po yun.

    • boypalaban

      DI ALAM NI NOYNOYING(BLOGGER) YAN. ENGOT YUN E.
      PANATIKO PA NI GIBO,BAKLANG BAKLA DAW SIYA KAY GIBA.
      PARA SA MGA CORONA FANS: BOOOOOOOOM! SINGHUTIN NYO ANG MASANGSANG NA AMOY NG PUTOK NI ATTY ROY BOOOM BOOOOM!

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/GGGD5HDR6JLY5J7LRTMCHWRY7U Barbara

      Correction: Danding supported Noynoy.  Please review news reports dealing with the 2010 presidential elections.

    • MNLFoodcritic

      Yes, Cory and Danding were not in good terms, way, way before but towards the end of the 90s dahan dahan nagkabati (remember Kris started calling “Tito Ed” na at this time). Danding supported Pnoy in the 2010 elections (even provided his own white, bulletproof Lexus SUV). Atty: might I ask, kelan pa ho kayo last nagbasa ng dyaryo? hehehe no offense meant hahaha

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/GGGD5HDR6JLY5J7LRTMCHWRY7U Barbara

    Tragedy of the Century!  Very hard to go into details. Despite the recent SC ruling, the issue on real ownership will remain hanging.

  • http://profiles.yahoo.com/u/FRU7DTSTOE257GCYTMLLHV5HMI Coty

    really, since when did the supreme court ever sided with the tired, the poor, huddled masses yearning to breathe free”!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_TAAQ77M6BSRXSRGFXJETQHOUMI Tagailog

    another anti poor, anti worker & pro martial law supreme court final ruling. if another dictator comes again, it is not bad to be at the side of the oppressor & join robbing this nation blind.  

  • Fulpol

    masaya ba si Noynoying sa decision ng Supreme Court???

    siguro kasi Tito Danding niya yun.. pero may kinalaman ba si Corona sa desisyon na yan?? sabi ng mga yellow supporters, wala kasi collegial ang decision..

    ahahha
    ahhaha
    haahah
    ahhha

    • damatannapo

      isang kang failure sa lipunan natin

  • Fulpol

    may 24 percent share pa na hinahabol… papayag ba si danding cojuangco??

    siguro kasi si Noynoying ang naghahabol… tit-for-tat lang naman ang labanan…

    pero yung 24 percent, diretso sa gobyerno… duda na naman kung makakarating sa mga coconut farmers ang anumang kita mula sa share na yan..

    hahaha
    hahha
    haahha

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/NOGYYDXDPEIEO6UAWDBVRDK3NU sarcasm jose

    i don’t know which is worse marcos or pnoy. they are the same.

  • 1VeritasAequitas

    @henry, huwag mo sanang lahatin ang mga Chinese-Filipinos. Hindi lahat sa kanila ay masasama.  Si Jose Rizal ay Filipino-Chinese subali’t ini-alay niya ang buhay niya para sa bayan. Isang Chinese ang ama niya.  Ikaw, kaya mo bang mamatay para sa bayan mo?  Si San Lorenzo Ruiz na kinikilalang Santo ng Simbahang Katoliko at si Mother Ignacia del Espiritu Santo  na  kandidata sa pagiging Santa sa Roma ay Chinese-Filipino din.  Ang mga ama nila ay parehong Chinese.  Pilipina ang mga ina nila. Wala sa pagiging purong Pilipino ang pagmamahal sa bayan o sa kabutihan at katarungan. Napakaraming purong Pilipino  ang masasama at bumibiktima sa kapwa nila mga Pilipino.  Ang  pag-papalaki ng mga  magulang at ang kinamulatang moral values ng pamilya ang humuhubog sa character, moral values , at  mga prinsipyo ng isang tao.

    Huwag ka sanang mag-pasimula ng hatred laban sa mga Pilipino na may dugong Chinese. Milyung-milyong  mga Pilipino ang may dugong Chinese. Maging may dugong banyaga man sila , ang Pilipinas ang kanilang bayang sinilangan kaya’t ito lamang ang bansang itinuturing nilang kanila. Wala sa pagiging Pilipino o dayuhan ang batayan sa pagiging mabuti o masama ng isang tao. Bawa’t lahi ay may mabuti at masama. Ang isang tao ay dapat may compassion para sa kapwa at sa iba pang mga nilikha ng Diyos. Dapat ay sikapin nating mabuhay nang nagtutulungan at hindi niyuyurakan ang karapatan ng kapwa lalo ng karamihan. Ito ang dapat matutuhan ni Danding Cojuangco para maisipan niyang ibalik ang bilyung-bilyong pera ng mga coconut farmers. Dapat nating baguhin ang masamang kalakaran sa gobyerno,  Supreme Court, at  sosyedad sa pamamagitan ng mapayapang paraan. Kung magmamahalan lamang at magtutulungan ang mga Pilipino, liligaya at matatahimik ang ating bansa.

  • PH2011

    Good Work Solgen Jardeleza …Good Work Estelito Mendoza… Good Work Cojuangco… ( ALL SMC Shareholders)

    Good Work President for Appointing Jardeliza as Solicitor General.

    Good Work Supreme Court Justices.

    Case close with dispatched.

    All of the above can now have their share for the Billions….at the expense of poor Pilipino farmers.

    GOD BLESS PHILIPPINES…

    GOD BLESS THE PILIPINO FARMERS….

     

  • http://profiles.yahoo.com/u/FRU7DTSTOE257GCYTMLLHV5HMI Coty

    he wouldn’t have earned the monicker “Pacman” (the original) is he’s not!

    • boypalaban

      DANDING “PACMAN” COJUANGCO….ISA SA MGA NAGPLANO NG MARTIAL LAW.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_FVBPRR4NKZ2DFURBCD5I4Q5GN4 Leg

    ONE SOLUTION: PALAYASIN ANG MGA CHINESE CITIZENS!

    ” Tens of thousands of Chinese, along with other Asians (Malaysians,
    Philippines) have illegally entered the country, but have quickly
    established themselves through cash and corruption.  Now they control
    the Papuan fishing industry and the fishermen are exploited working long
    hours.  Swathes of rain forest have been decimated for their precious
    woods, with no regard for the ecological consequences.  Corruption and
    racketeering are widespread…”

    “..the Chinese do not integrate with the other Asians or the local
    population; rather they aim to take advantage of the resources with
    colonial methods.  Only a few groups of Philippines, Catholics, are just
    in their payments.” ~ Rebellions against Chinese “colonialism” in Papua-New Guinea

    Noynoying:

    * no plans for education — they never wanted the filipino population to have better education, para madaling ma-uto.

    * chinese, don’t like filipinos to be out of poverty. period.

    * they are loyal to china..so why would they obey and respect the rules and laws of the Pinas? :p

    * they supported the NPAs/MILFs..manipulate the peace and order for their own business benefit..FUND rallies.

    * power problems in Mindanao? …oh well, its part of the plan…the
    Cojuanco’s are planning on building COAL-fueled power plants in
    Mindanao.

    * the chinese controls the Pinas’ telecoms, agriculture, fishery, mining, power, oil, banking…all for the GLORY of china!

    Ang umangal ay yellow retard…at pwede na ring umuwi sa china.

    • damatannapo

      lousy comment

    • boypalaban

      PUNTA KA CHINATOWN SA BINONDO…DOON KA MAGLUPASAY….SABIHIN MO:.HU HU HU…..BAKIT HACIENDA LUISITA LANG ANG ALAM KO…MERON PA PALANG TINATAGO ANG CORONAMPATUAN NA ‘TO….HU HU HU…BAKIT ANG MGA GAMIT KO MADE IN CHINA…PATI PANTY KO MADE IN CHINA…HU HU HU….

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_FVBPRR4NKZ2DFURBCD5I4Q5GN4 Leg

        waah! luma na yan.
        hahah..panty pala suot mo tsong. waah!

        PINAS CORRUPTION made in china.
        POWER OUTAGE in Mindanao made in china.

      • boypalaban

        tsong…tsonggo!
        tingnan mo yang suot mong panty…galing China
        pati yang peke mong sapin sa paa, galing China
        pati yang mga pirata mong DVD, galing China
        kahit maglupasay ka pa, di mo kaya gibain ang impluwensiya ng mga chekwa dito….
        sabihan mo man yang si sy, ty, gokongwei, etc na lumayas, di na lalayas ang mga yan…negosyante mga yan….
        in fairness sa mga intsik…daming pang-aabuso na ginawa ng iba sa mga yan..pero nga may kakutsabang mga pinoy na gahaman kaya hayan…

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_FVBPRR4NKZ2DFURBCD5I4Q5GN4 Leg

    hi fans! kumusta na kayo?

    hell-o yellow zombies! …na-miss nyo ko ano? …how’s he funding going? ..balato naman jan! WAAH!
    pasensya na kung ngayon lang nakabalik….you know nah..
    ..sa mga nagdaang araw….para kasing…para kasing…
    nahawaan ako ng NOYNOYING SYNDROME!

    …waah!

    • damatannapo

      disappoinment ka sa bayan natin

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_FVBPRR4NKZ2DFURBCD5I4Q5GN4 Leg

        ur referring to china for sure. :p

    • boypalaban

      UTO-UTO NG MAGNANAKAW ETO PARA SA YO:BOOOOOOM!
      PARA SA UTAK MONG MAY PUTOK GALING KAY ATTY ROY!
      BAGUHAN KA LANG DITO BOPLOKS…ASTANG MAGALING KA NA..
      O NAGPALIT KA LANG NG USERNAME KASI NOON KA PA SOPLAK…
      BOOOOM! ANG LAKAS NG PUTOK MO…GALING SA LUSAW MONG UTAK NA NASA KILIKILI!

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_FVBPRR4NKZ2DFURBCD5I4Q5GN4 Leg

        chinese loyalist ka nga…pati “boom” sa Boy Pickup…kinopya at pinirata mo tsong. waah!

      • boypalaban

        sa yo na yang boy pick up mo
        basta ang alam ko galing sa putok ni atty roy yan…di pa raw tapos ang fireworks sa MOA, may pahabol pa…happy new year!

    • boypalaban

      KUMUSTA RAW MGA PAMAYPAY…BOBO KA TALAGA!
      YELLOW BA NG KULAY NG NABUBULOK? ENGS TALAGA
      SORRY HA, PA-ENGLISH ENGLISH KA PA, MALI MALI NAMAN GRAMMAR MO….TAGALUGIN MO NA LANG…O KAYA MAGNOYNOYING KA NA LANG…SAYANG SPACE DITO SA WALANG KWENTA MONG KOMENTO.

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_FVBPRR4NKZ2DFURBCD5I4Q5GN4 Leg

        wala na..wala na talagang ibang masabi ang yellow chinese retard.. waah!  kumita na yang style mo. waah!

      • boypalaban

        gusto mo balato?
        boooooom…para sa pang engs mong argumento
        pasalamat ka kay atty roy, galing sa putok niya yan…
        saka nga pala may bagong bukas na hair salon si cuevas diyan sa commonwealth baka gusto mo bagong hairdo…libre daw sa kagaya mong walang isip…di daw talo…

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_TAAQ77M6BSRXSRGFXJETQHOUMI Tagailog

    the supreme court final ruling have just cleanse the dirty money of martial law regime.

    • Loggnat

       Does that mean Sen. Marcos is definitely obligated to vote for no on impeachment of CJ Corona? Scratch my back and I’ll scratch yours? Only in the Philippines. Garapal! Out in the open and showing no shame it seems. More fun in the Philippines…..

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_5X6PEYZIGEAVM6QCZDWANAPQC4 Cyrus

    Mga justices hindi man lang kayo naawa sa mga mamamayan na dapat makinabang nyan.  Lalo na ang mga coconut farmers.  Sobrang ganid at corrupt talaga ang ating judicatura.  Mula sa chief justice hangang sa mga associates, bulsa lang nila ang kanilang pinapataba.

    God bless the dead coconut industry in the philippines.  The nail in our coffin is complete.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_FVBPRR4NKZ2DFURBCD5I4Q5GN4 Leg

      natakot kasi sa impeachment na pakulo ni chinese pwesedent Noynoying…kaya ayon.

  • reyAragon

    This SC decision on the coco-levy fund reeks of sabotage. Pnoy would surely earn the ire of these farmers. It is easy to connect him to Danding. They are kins.

  • RomyLitz

    Cojuangco is not stingy and may offer 10% of 60-Billion Peso to the Corona Orchestra that would translate to US$37.5 Million each. Thus, their dollar accounts must be opened!!

  • WeAry_Bat

    Philippine justice is dumb.  One of the biggest thieves is scooting free.

    • Rhine

       or you can also say all Filipinos are thieves! if the biggest thieves is scooting free!!!

      • WeAry_Bat

         Nope, it’s obvious you know you have a flawed argument; just for argument’s sake?

      • Rhine

        really? you yourself said that the biggest thieves is scooting free…..

  • themayflower

    to the Conjuangco Clan,

    Maawa naman kayo sa sambayang Filipino. Ipaubaya na ninyo sa iba ang Hacienda Luisita!!!!!

    • boypalaban

      oo nga…supreme court maawa na kayo sa mga magni-niyog…
      ninakawan na dati…nanakawan pa ulit

    • pakita_ko_sayo

       Eh ikaw kung meron ganitong hacienda, sa iyong matinong pag iisip, ipamimigay mo? Eh baka kung madukutan ka lang ng cellphone, baka magngangawa ka ng husto sa kalye hahahaha. Madaling magsalita!

    • cliff_castillo

       Puro ka HL pero di mo nakikita ang billion na kinuha ng SC sa magsasaka ng niyog at ibinigay kay Danding.

  • RomyLitz

    The multi-billion pesos pending cases like the 3 billion FASAP vs PAL, Banco Filipino’s 25 Billion, and Shell’s 45 Billion peso misdeclaration are the real reason Corona and his orchestra cannot afford to resign. Maintaining the thick face is their immunized integrity.

  • Ilonggated

    Congrats Uncle Danding. Tahimik ang mga anti-Corona na pro-PNoy. Pabor sila dito sa decision na ito. Hahahaha!

    • boypalaban

      gulong gulo ka na ba?
      kasi akala mo hacienda luisita lang ang issue?di ba tagapagtanggol ka ng mga magsasaka sa hacienda?
      bakit di mo pasinungalingan na pro-magsasaka nga si Corokot….na meron pa palang kasakiman ang supreme court sa pangunguna ni coronampatuan?

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_E7SFPQFWHHEAJ4IZKPD7OYJXVM Jabba

    dapat judge dredd style na lang dito sa pilipinas. walang ka kwenta kwenta dito ang judiciary. ako panalo sa kaso ng lupa pero yung ganid na sheriff naghihintay pa ng lagay bago i-execute yung hatol ng hukom.

    • pakita_ko_sayo

       May pa judge dredd judge dredd ka pa, di mo lang gusto yung nakahinatnan ng desisyon. Labag lang sa loob mo. Kung puro ka reklamo sa Pinas, libre kang lumayas

  • ofwme2807

    akala ko ba si thief ay ipinaglalaban ang mga farmers, sa HLI ipinagmamalaki nyang single handedly nyang hinaharangan ang mga Cojuangco – Aquinos sa valuation tapos dito sa mga coconut farmers na syang binuwisan ng coco levy fund ni Marcos at tunay na mga may-ari ng fund ay ibinagsak ng SC na ksama pa rin si thief…Another case of flip-flop, inconsistent social justice ng SC…Hay buhay paano hindi nya magamit na excuse laban sa mga Cojuangco-Aquino pero bakit di ba uncle din ni Pnoy si Danding????ewan ko ba ang justice system, itong SC ni corona ang daming pinakialamang mga cases na matagal na nkapending paano nga naman malaki ang bigayan sa mga kasong ito, never mind real justice for the sake of peso and dollar accounts????

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2VLO53PRSSY76BZOWLOHJDM33M jeray

      lumabas na namn ang katangahan mo. IIsa lang ang boto ni Corona…Ung galit mo sa cojuangco tanung mo kay noy mo. dahil si danding ang nag fund sa kanyang candidacy.

      • ofwme2807

        ikaw ang mas tanga kung nagpapaniwala ka sa sinungaling na manipulator na si evil corona….it runs in his blood again i repeat ikaw ang tanga ok????gets mo???

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_I4KGDZ3GNAKUXPW737YLVJXHWE Zhenda

      Pinakialamn ni Corona? teka…. sino ba dapat makaialam? retired na yun mga justices na naglilitis nuon. Napasa lang sa current justice and case. and one more… why do you blame 1 person when this case is being voted by justices? 

      • ofwme2807

        di ba nga sabi ni thief single handedly nyang nilalabanan ang mga Cojuangcos sa HLI…singlehanded with matching kumpas sa mga jackals na sunud-sunuran sa thief…at ang tanong sapat na ba ang kaalaman nila sa buong kaso at history ng HLI….wag mong sabihing ang SC justices at CJ’s noon hindi kayang magrender ng fair @ equal justice????ibig mong sabihin sa mga past na humawak sa kaso ng HLI noon sa SC ay walang alam at incompetent para magrender ng decision dito????

  • ofwme2807

    final na daw iyan for the third time may MR din tingnan natin kung talagang final na iyan baka may 4th, 5th at 6th etc etc MR pa ring mangyari dito remember billions of pesos ang halaga ng decision dito by the stroke of the pen ni thief at ng kanyang mga jackals….we’ll see…bye bye farmers daw akala ko ba si thief ay for the farmers….walang pera ang mga farmers daw ksi….yan ang social justice na ipinaiiral nitong SC ni thief….

  • Rey Baltazar C. Tolentino

    I hope inquirer will do a complete report on this issue –
    from the time of Marcos up to present.

  • ofwme2807

    ang ating magiting na impeached na thief wala talagang delicadeza kapal muks to the max nagpaparticipate pa rin sa deliberations ng SC kahit nakasalang sa impeachment may time pa ba syang magparticipate di ba dapat lang mg-inhibit ang thief sa mga kaso na may connection at links sa impeachment nya….sya na ang nagsabing dahil sa HLI kaya sya naimpeach, eh di ba may connection at interest din ang case ng coco levy fund kasi si Danding ay Cojuangco din na kamg-anak ni Pnoy…..baka naman talagang irresistible din ang offer dito kayat naipanalo ni Danging ang kaso to the detriment ng coconut farmers natin…..hay buhay ginisa sa sariling mantika mula sa langis ng niyog ang mga farmers natin…..

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_ZKPNHSPBMK74VZ3GBIPNTJA7KE Edwin

      at bakit si CJ ang pinagbubuntungan mo ng galit? sino ba ang nanduon sa SC?

      • ofwme2807

        his 8 jackals are there dont you remember their names???

      • boypalaban

        sino ba ang nagmamalaking ipinaglalaban niya ang mga magsasaka ng hacienda luisita kaya siya na-impeached?

    • boypalaban

      mas matindi ang kaso ng sa coco levy, nationwide yan!
      ganyan si coronarrovo, double standard…pa awa pa….

  • TinimbangNgunitKulang

    Cojuangco may gain billions of pesos that does not belong to him but will surely suffer the lost of his soul. Matanda na, ganid pa rin.

    • http://profiles.google.com/odredd Dredd Ofalexandria

      He sure is a power broker.

  • ofwme2807

    im sure 101% after this SC decision by the thief and his jackals, the corona family will again do buying spree of real estate properties maybe elsewhere not in Metro Manila maybe not in the US where he was electric shocked by his flip-flop admission of not owning any property in the US….and maybe the dollar accounts at PSB again received new deposits you know from whom…..remember atty estelito mendoza is one of the trusted lawyers of Danding the godfather…..hay sarap buhay talaga….

    • http://twitter.com/jhaydom Jherald Doing

       sino naman kaya ang pamangkin ni danding? layo naman sa topic ng comment mo,halatang galit ka ke corona..

      • ofwme2807

        excuse me mas malayo ang comment mo basahin mo ang mga comments ko lahat ng comments ko at malalaman mo ang sagot ok???anyway thanks nice try corona loyalist

  • Lou333

    NOISE BARRAGE 5 PM TO 7 PM ON MARCH 30, 2012. PLEASE HELP SPREAD…

    • boypalaban

      ano po ang pinaka-cause?
      pwede ko po i-spread….

  • ofwme2807

    with this latest decision of the SC with the thief as the head it showed the true colors of these current hoodlum in robes sitting in the bench……thepresent SC under the thief is anti-people, anti-social justice, anti-fair and equal justice and again betrayed the public and the lowly coconut farmers so dapat lang na tuluyan ng patalsikin itong mga ginagamit ng mga in power at mga greedy businessmen…..the present SC deserve to be condemned in the strongest possible terms especially the thief due to this decision….

  • AntiAko

    HAHAHAHA… Niluluto lang talaga tayo sa ating sariling mantika ng mga ganid na elitista sa ating lipunan.

    WHY CAN’T THE PRESIDENT LEAD HIS RELATIVE TO WALK THE STRAIGHT PATH? Ano kaya, gustuhin ba kaya ni PNoy na tanggalan ng kayamanan ang kanyang kamag-anak just for the sake of the matuwid na daan?

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_NZD4E4C6WQD7S4QNMNTIPAAAC4 Mark ferry john Lamsen

      Danding has long been treated himself separated from the Aquino family..

      So, just to be very impartial, it’s not logical and proper to directly blame PNoy for the affairs of his uncle; doing so means we’re stupid…

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_KBG3CSDWJH7MZ273WQV37H6DIA mario

       hinala nga nila isa sa mga nagplano ng pag patay ke Ninoy yang si danding

  • coladu

    Ang number one na pangalan sa ACCRA Law Office ay Angara.  Isa sa Senadores si Angara na siya ang kasama ng nag-forma ng ACCRA Law Office.  Ang isa sa pinaka-actibo sa prosecution panel spokesperson ay ang ANAK ni Edgardo Angara.  Ngayon sasabihin natin na si Corona ang may pakana nito.  Ang isa dito sa ACCRA ay si Cruz, at ang isa ay Regala at ang isa ay si Concepcion.  Tingnan ninyo ang mga ito at si Danding. Tingnan din natin kung sino yong mga bumoto.  Huwag agad maghusga.  Kung pagkatapos ninyong tingnan ay ganun pa rin ang nasa isip ninyo, ok lang.  At least, tumingin kayo bago humusga.

    • boypalaban

      ganon?
      si Angara tatay ay pro-FPJ at pro-Erap na naging tuta ni Gloria…mas matindi ang rabies ng ama….bow wow wow

  • coladu

    By the way, the voting was a 7-7 tie that is why, the former decision cannot be reversed.  So, with a 7-7 voting, can we say that there were eight including Corona? Arithmetic?

  • MonMayuga

    FLIP FLOP MOST WELCOME HERE

    This is that one case where we would most welcome a flip flopping act of this Supreme Court.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_XYPFIGTBA5LXMX2UBLCQVG5AQE Martin

       Flip-flopping happens much more than you think…and its really an indicator a Supreme  Court is continuing to evaluate a judgement.  Happened 68 times in US Supreme court system.   But Pinoy has “impeached” Corona on flip flopping procedures, so i guess everyone will not expect that to ever happen again.   Pinoy has “trained” the Supreme Court that flip flopping a decision is very bad…and that all the media and public agreed with him.  Remember it was an article of impeachment..

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/66IS3CYAAZYSRMPVINWJBJ7VRY pedro

    kawawa naman ang mga coco planters ….. isa na dyan ang lolo ko ….. si Danding Cojuangco front lang ni Marcos ….. kung talagang susundan iyan ang dulo niyan ay kay Imelda Romualdez Marcos ganyan lang kasimple iyan ….. Whoooping 60 billion pesos binigay kay danding in silver platter nang SC ….. sana sinabi rin sa balita kung ilan sa SC justices ang pabor at iyung hinde …..

  • http://twitter.com/jhaydom Jherald Doing

    yan ang tunay na mga ganid sa pera…sobra na ang yaman ayaw pang ipamigay ang lupa sa tunay na me ari..pinagkakitaan na nila ng limpak limpak na pera, gusto pa nilang pabayaran ng 10 bilyon..

    • sanjuan683

      Ganun talaga kapalaran niya yun maging mayaman. Hintayin mo mamatay ka at sa susunod na buhay ano malay ikaw naman ang pinakamayaman sa balat ng lupa at yun mga Cojuangco naman sa ilalim ng tulay natutulog. Huag ka mainggit kanyang-kanya kapalaran yan. heheheheheh wha!!!!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_KBG3CSDWJH7MZ273WQV37H6DIA mario

    talaga papabor ang mga justices na yan kina danding at lucio tan pera lang ang katapat ng mga yan

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_OHOD5EA75DBBUH53UKLRXRK764 Mang Teban

    From the very beginning, Eduardo “Danding the Pacman” Cojuangco stole the money from the 3.5 million coconut farmers and their children and grandchildren. The conflict of interest is so obvious that businessman Cojuangco suddenly got interested to set up a bank, UPCB, in an utterly shameful move to make it the depositary bank from the coco levy funds.

    There is more than meets the eye in the takeover of SMC shares by Danding, (also called Bossing before Vic Sotto appropriated the nickname for himself). We wonder how the mastermind of Ninoy’s assassination was never brought out in the open and how the original owner of those SMC shares, Enrique Zobel (EnZo), had bothered to travel to Hawaii to be at the bedside of the dictator Ferdinand Marcos to watch him die. What EnZo’s actual purpose was only he knew.

    Bossing Danding hoodwinked the coconut farmers to sign proxies to make him sole “representative” for them as a single block so that he could buy San Miguel Corp. shares from the late Enrique Zobel who had an axe to grind  against his cousins, the Soriano brothers. Danding not only got SMC. He also caused the downfall of the Soriano business empire in the Philippines.

    In such a mysterious haste and repeated victories by Danding the Pacman, one could really wonder if justice really exists in this country. I am no longer surprised if there were backroom deals with the Supreme Court justices. it is not farfetched to think that the Marcoses are involved in this mess. We can now look with more scorn at how the Supreme Court has decided in favor of the criminal organization of rich tycoons.

    If P-Noy remains inactive like a dead volcano about this matter, he should not be surprised if in later months, he will face an angry nation for his complacency to look seriously at this web of deception his uncle Bossing Danding had done to the detriment of millions of Filipinos. I will also support any move to impeach the present president if he does not use all means to re-open the case. I am sure that there is a way to override Supreme Court if it has blatantly abused its power to render decisions to the favored few.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_XYPFIGTBA5LXMX2UBLCQVG5AQE Martin

       So what else is new…dirty politics as usual in the Philippines.   Nothing ever really changes because Filipinos always vote for the “name”  and not take time to do deep research on a political candidate.   Pinoy may say he is for anti corruption, what he is really saying it ok JUST for my friends and my family.  The only way to overrule the Supreme Court decision is a 2/3 vote in the Senate.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_HUSGK7WZIX3G5OXOZJ7RWF52II Cypher

    this might be an offset to CJ Corona’s acquittal

    • francoalminolibre

      certainly because the impeachment was meant to destroy the independence of the judiciary so the president can get what his biggest supporter, mr. danding cojuanco,  can want. daang tuwid? this is a great hoax.

      • boypalaban

        bilib na bilib ka sa sinasabi mo ah….parang totoong totoo….anong mundo ka nga pala?

      • francoalminolibre

        i don’t belong to the world of ignoramuses like you.

      • boypalaban

        world of herp derps pwede ka doon…wag mo akong gamitan ng kung ano anong terminologies…di lang ikaw ang nakapag-aral….yung idol mong si Lady Gaga Santiago…gustong laging 1 ang grade sa graduate school namin….buti nga di pinagbigyan….ha ha ha

  • PHtaxpayer

    SC justices should be investigated for receiving bribes for this decision.  It is an obvious injustice to the farmers.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_RWPOD4ER5LJPDQU3N32NAC74X4 johnnie r

    Kala ko ba ARROYO court ang Supreme Court? Bakit nanalo si DADING COJUANGCO!!!

    • boypalaban

      si coronarrovo na ang amo ay si gloria…na malapit naman kay danding…

  • francoalminolibre

    p-noy would be very happy with this development. to the yellow supporters, you were all taken for a ride. and i mightily call it “gaba”. nag pautouto kasi kayo sa presidente. this decision is really prelude to cj’s acquittal.

    • francoalminolibre

      if you you are wondering why the sc is now favoring p-noy’s clan it is because the institution is scared to the bones. this impeachment trial was meant to compromise the independence of the court. 

      • ofwme2807

        bulag ka ba itong decision ni thief at ng 8 jackals nya ay dahil sa pera pera lang….im sure 101% nglalaway na naman ng mag-asawang thief sa bagong properties na bibilhin nila ks may dumating na namang biyaya ng diyos kay nato… 

      • francoalminolibre

        your logic is so short that i need binoculars to see it. if cj and danding are friends why would the latter allow the impeachment trial to be initiated when he is calling the shots in the malacanang palace as the the president’s biggest campaign contributor? maybe you have not acquired good education which very well explain your bereft manners and right conduct aside from being an “uto-uto nang presidente”.

      • ofwme2807

        ikaw din sayang mga pina-aral sa inyo ng mga magulang nyo puro ksi bulakbol inatupag nyo kaya ayan ang nangyari sa inyo…

      • francoalminolibre

        i did not become a lawyer for a song. so i know what’s a foul, odious, or rumor evidence and what is genuine. the next time around don’t cross-path with me or i will massacre your reputation with utmost embarrassment.

      • ofwme2807

        so inamin mong alipores ka ni corona good luck…by the way saan ba pwesto mo sa recto un ngnonotaryo ng pekeng documentos???lakas ba kita ngaun o mahina kasi bakasyon n ng mga estudyante ok….

      • boypalaban

        wala sigurong kaso yan…kaya hayan…attorney, may isasampa sana akong kaso laban kay Coronampatuan, pwede ka bang abogado ko? ha hah hah

      • boypalaban

        abogado ka pala e…atty, ginagamit mo ba utak mo? di ko yata ma-sense na may sense ka…parang ikaw lang ang may alam kung ano ang totoo ah…monopoly of truth.. baka si Genuino kilala mo, hindi ang pagiging genuine….pasensya na attorney….

      • boypalaban

        best example…..how a loyal and rabid Coronaligot fan reacts… tsk tsk…don’t worry, i understand….tsu tsu…sit….stand….get that bone…..cry….post comment……BOOOOOOOM! ( courtesy of atty roy)

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_I4KGDZ3GNAKUXPW737YLVJXHWE Zhenda

        Really? how sure you are? 

      • ofwme2807

        oh ano marunong ka na bang mag-isip at mag-analyze???

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_XYPFIGTBA5LXMX2UBLCQVG5AQE Martin

         I agree it was all a long term strategy by the Cojuangco family to render the Supreme Court so scared they can now get away with this 60 Billion Peso decision.   If this court case was decided against anyone else…you would hear screams and protests. But no one dares challenge Aquino and Cojuangco family now.

    • boypalaban

      di ba ikaw ang nauto ni coronakot?
      akala mo pro-magsasaka siya…para lang pala sa isang hacienda….para lang may mai-banat kay pnoy.
      di mo alam na mas malala ang ginawa ni corokot sa mga magni-niyog….
      grabe ang pagka uto uto mo…patingin ka na, malala na yan….

      • francoalminolibre

        you are really grossly ignorant of the impeachment case. there is no witness who came forward and testified that corona was engaged in corruption. .there is a medicine for treating a mental patient, but in your case of gross ignorance, man has not invented yet a medical treatment. so i just have to bear with the emptiness of your yellow head.

      • boypalaban

        wala? may tama nga utak mo.
        may dilaw palang ulo….baka ulo mo yon…
        alam ko utak mo may putok galing sa putok ng idol mong si atty roy putok….BOOOOOM! galing sa kanya yan….

      • francoalminolibre

        oh my you didn’t get the figure of speech. your’s is really a sorry brain. to pluck you out of the abyss of gross ignorance may i inform you therefore that a “yellow brain” is a person who is a rabid supporter of p-noy. my goodness i might die of heart attack for laughing. hahahaha.

      • boypalaban

        figure of speech ka pa diyan…basic rules lang ng syllogism di ka pa papasa, attorning wala sa ayos! kasing boploks mo mga propesor mo malamang…

      • boypalaban

        ok lang ba sa yo kung ipag-tatama ko ang english mo? baka kasi ma-insulto ka e…
        may i have your permission mr.learned?

      • francoalminolibre

        i usually don’t argue further with idiots like you.

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_I4KGDZ3GNAKUXPW737YLVJXHWE Zhenda

        Hindi pro-magsasaka… pro-constitution sya.

    • http://profile.yahoo.com/K4ZU3F4UHKD3JVMTDNUBHSXSXY Erlinda Brave

      eto na nmn ang sira ulong nag cocomment..franco lahat na lang ng bagay kasalanan ng gubyerno ogag nakahawak ka lang ng computer akala mo matalino ka na…

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_S2BRZ7WPV53I5SYQK3IZXCY7SY Josephus

    Pera pera lang =(   Anyways, i bet Danding won’t be able to buy his immortality with his stolen wealth. Same with those justices ! S hame on you! 

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/IIZ67DDAU4ZTYTC7GFCPR47HMY waldetrudes

    try to ask atty mendoza to write a letter to the supreme court clerk of court. the case will be re raffled

  • bisdakis

    This is the problem when a revolution is unfinished!

  • ofwme2807

    putek….anak ka talaga ng putek thief at mga jackals….malinaw pa sa sikat ng araw na ang coco levy fund at tax buwis na ipinataw sa coconut industry na galing sa mga coco farmers….at paano nangyaring naging kay Danding iyun o nagkaroon man lng sya ng share duon???common sense mind boggling eye-opener decision again by the SC under the thief????

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_I4KGDZ3GNAKUXPW737YLVJXHWE Zhenda

      so is the thief and the family of the president are now allies?

      • ofwme2807

        ang layo naman ng rason mo nag-aral ka ba at tinuruan kang mag-isip at mag-analyze kawawa ka naman sayang ang pinag-aral sau ng mga magulang mo…

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/K4ZU3F4UHKD3JVMTDNUBHSXSXY Erlinda Brave

        bobo mo zhenda lahat na lang ng bagay dinadamay mo ang gubyerno…nakahawak ka lang ng computer akala mo matalino ka na ogag…..

      • boypalaban

        oo nga….pa english english pa, mali mali naman….haaaay…..

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_XYPFIGTBA5LXMX2UBLCQVG5AQE Martin

        They are not allies…..Corona did not participate in the decision….he was scared to render a negative vote against Aquino and Cojuangco on the case.  Its cases like these we must always keep separation and balance of powers.  Now by allowing Pinoy to impeach Corona we have done so much damage to the NATION….over 60 Billion pesos to the Cojuangco family and not going to the people.  We the people have only ourselfs to blame for allowing Pinioy to neutralize the Supreme Court.   Notice the decision was made just before Lenten….. allowing many people to forget the decision over the next few weeks.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_BKNBRPKHFAUATHG6MZ5ZDNL7WM Truth

    We will all stand before God and be judged for our actions. No one will get away with anything as God has seen and heard all we have done.Justice will be served !

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_5X6PEYZIGEAVM6QCZDWANAPQC4 Cyrus

    For me this is not a Pnoy or Corona issue.  This is an issue of the kind of system we have. shame shame shame.  Danding was never convicted after marcos left the country.  Do not point finger here. for all we know more of our fingers are pointing to us.  Walang ibang masisi dito kung hindi tayo.  The result of our apathy and the wrong concept of forgiveness.   shame shame shame 

  • Fulpol

    panahon pa ni Cory yan!!

    haha
    ahaha
    ahahah

    • boypalaban

      at ng panginoon mong maykapal si Marcos

  • Fulpol

    Noynoying versus Danding Cojuangco?

    Supreme Court vs Noynoying?

    Supreme Court/Danding/NOynoying vesus coconut farmers??

    hahha
    hahaah
    hahaha

  • Andres_Bagumbayan

    Batikusin kaya ni noynoy ang korte suprema sa desisyong ito? malamang ang sagot ay “hindi”…

    Sangkot dito ang tiyo at numero unong taga suporta niya nuon nakaraang eleksyon na walang iba kundi si danding” the boss” cojuangco!!!! iba ang kapamilya sa kaaway!!!

  • Fulpol

    okey na ang kaso ni Danding… “final and executory na”… safe na si Danding..

    ang susunod naman ay ang 10 billion ng kamag-anak ni Danding..

    nasa impeachment na yan…

    hindi pala hawak ni Corona ang buong Supreme Court na sinasabi ng yellow???

    hahaha
    ahahah
    ahhaha
    ahahahah

    • JOSE RIZAL

      shut up pulpol. u’re nonsense like joker.

    • indiosbravos2002

      Di naman nangingilala si Corona basta pera. Kahit Cojuangco ang umabot ng pera, tutuwad yan.

      Hahahs
      Ahaha
      Wahaha

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_5QJUD47DAPM2Y5J3AEMCE2C624 John TWT

    Ito ang dapat na i-pipol power sobrang paglapastangan ito sa taumbayan

    San na ngayon yung mga nagsasabing respetuhin ang desisyon ng korte?

    Kung kayo ang magsasaka na kinaltasan ng kita tapos kakamkamin ng iba, anong gagawin nyo? respetuhin ang desisyon ng korte?

    eto ang dapat na ipaghimagsik ng taumbayan. lipulin ang mga ganid na ilustrado sa pinas.

    grabe na talaga ‘to

    • hukom2

      OO, unahin nating linisin ang korte suprema!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_5QJUD47DAPM2Y5J3AEMCE2C624 John TWT

    sinu-sino mga sangkot dito? halos lahat mga naging iskolar ng bayan sa UP. yung iba sa mga eksklusibong eskuwelahan.

    pagkatapos silang bigyan ng kakayahan at karunungan ng lipunan, eto ang sinusukli nila sa bayan; ang lokohin ang mga mangmang at masyadong mabait na mga magsasakang sunud-sunuran sa kanilang mga kagustuhan.

    matagal na ang modus operandi na ito ng mga ilustrado; mula pa nang panahon ng kastila at amer’kano; sila ang naghahari dahil mga nakatuntong sa mga magagandang paaralan at magaling humalik sa mga pu wet ng mga dayuhan.

    dapat tapusin na ang rehimen ng mga ganid na ito. yan lang ang tunay na makapagpapalaya sa atin sa kahirapan at inhustisya.

    walang tuwid na daan habang nasa paligid natin ang mga ganid na ito

  • hukom2

    Buhay pa si Pres. Corry ay di na magkakasundo ang mga Cojuanco… partido nila Pres. Corry at partido nila Danding… Kung natatandaan nyo si Gibo, na kalaban ni PNoy nung nakaraang presidential elections, siya ang nasa partido ni Danding. Wais ang mga Cojuanco, kaya sakay sila sa dalawang mga pamangkin na parehong kandidato sa pagka pesidente! Ito ang isa sa pinaka malaking mali ng Political system ng Pilipinas – NEPOTISMO!  Kung ang aso pwede gawing barangay captain, malamang ay ginawa na rin nila para lahat ng meber ng pamilya ay may pusisyon at paswelduhin ng tax payers. SOS!! Oo, Pilipinas… bakit ba panatiko ang mga Pilipino sa mga personalidad miski alam nilang baluktot na ang ginagawa!   

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_Q3QGG5QHBLRMZTIYWUFURY6J2E Night

    putcha nag ka bayaran nanaman

  • JOSE RIZAL

    who affirmed and who dissented among the magistrates? can this be revealed to the public? and can the npa do something about it? noynoying to the max, on this one. what a shame.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_XYPFIGTBA5LXMX2UBLCQVG5AQE Martin

       Due to his impeachment hearings Corona was inhibited from the ruling…

      • indiosbravos2002

        Are you crazy? Get your facts straight. The trial has not inhibited CORONA to vote or not to vote on any case. As a matter of fact, the ongoing trial does not prevent him to sit as judge on any of the pending cases in the SC . Net/net, HE CAN INFLUENCE any case he wants to and nobody can do a thing about it.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2VLO53PRSSY76BZOWLOHJDM33M jeray

    bakit d nakalista d2 kung sinu ang bomoto favor sa mga coujuangco??? Eto na ang tuwid nating daan last hope ko na sana to para paniwalaan si noynoy kaso ganid talga.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/AND7MQ5FERICDOIAUW56RYT45A tower_of_power

    Well done, SOLDPREME COURT! Like the hacienda Luisita … the timing of the court decision on the coco levy is suspect. The decision on the hacienda Luisita by the SOLDPREME court was timed such that corona and his elk can spin it such that it was the reason why the impeachment. Pnoy is being accused of using it to get back at corona. Now this coco levy …. hahahaha … kala nila stupid ang mga pinoy … kala ni corona hindi nakikita ng mga pinoy ang evil ways nila. They are just using this to agitate the people against Pnoy. What a timing!!@!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2VLO53PRSSY76BZOWLOHJDM33M jeray

      Si  Pnoy at cojuangco ang evil.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_XYPFIGTBA5LXMX2UBLCQVG5AQE Martin

       Are you losing your brains….you say the Supreme Court gave Aquino and Uncle Danding 60 Billion pesos to make Aquino and Uncle Danding mad???….and the people upset???   Hey if they want to give me 60 Billion…I will pretend to be upset also and laugh all the way to the bank.  What timing you say….yes indeed the timing corresponds to an impeachment trial where all SC Justices feel threatened by the President….who said 2 months ago…”after Corona there will be other SC justices to be impeached…”  So now we all have a SC that does what the president demands.   The people got exactly what they wanted for the president…a SC that cooperates.

  • Aleksis Capili

    Nice move by the Supreme Court under the leadership with CJ Corona… they are now for probusiness (on the side of the Danding)…ngayon, kawawa ang mga coconut farmers natin..mas malaki nawala sa kanila…

  • coladu

    Ang ABOGADO ni Danding ay ACCRA.  Ang unang pangalan sa ACCRA ay Angara, si Senador Angara na tao dati ni McCoy.  Remember, he became UP President during McCoy’s time, etc.  Ang spokesperson ng Prosecution sa Impeachment ay si Congressman Angara. Si Danding ay first cousin ni Cory, samakatuwid ay Tiyuhin ni PNOY. Paano kaya naging kasalanan ni Corona iyon kung ang Coco Levy Fund ay napunta sa tiyuhin ni PNOY.  May reliable na balita na si GIBO ay hindi sinuportahan ni Danding dahil hindi siya WINNABLE dahil sa late siya naging DND Chief.  Kaya ang sinuportahan ni Danding ay si PNOY.  Kasalanan kaya ni Corona o nililigaw lang tayo?

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_5G3QFIWH7EOGWIPRDRH2Z5FSF4 koikoi

       May punto ka. Pero di ba nakapagtataka na bigla-bigla, pumabor ang Supreme Court sa mga Cojuangco? At, ang komontra, si Sereno.
      Hmmm…. something’s fishy, really.

      • indiosbravos2002

        Bat mo naman binara, dude. Sabog tuloy argumento nya.. Hehehe.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2VLO53PRSSY76BZOWLOHJDM33M jeray

    Bakit walang batikos mula sa malacanang?

  • Samboy_rod

    We just hope that these sc*mbag justices who did the injsutices die while they were sleeping.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_5G3QFIWH7EOGWIPRDRH2Z5FSF4 koikoi

       Ako, not while they were sleeping. Sana, unti-unti silang matatabunan ng libo-libong buko kasama na si Danding.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_XYPFIGTBA5LXMX2UBLCQVG5AQE Martin

       Don’t blame the justices….this was caused by President Aquino.   As a supreme court judge you either vote his way…or your facing impeachment hearings after Corona.   Remember his quote 2 months ago.  “…after Corona we will begin impeachment hearings against more supreme court justices…”      Aquino has got them so scared they are now doing what the president wants.   Happy Lenten everyone!

      • indiosbravos2002

        If they were too scared, they should voted to open the dollar account of Corona… Your argument does not hold water…kahit katiting. Im sorry.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2VLO53PRSSY76BZOWLOHJDM33M jeray

      bakit d mo pinagdasal ang pagkamatay ng talgang ganid, sya ang may problema (cojuangco aquino)

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_5G3QFIWH7EOGWIPRDRH2Z5FSF4 koikoi

    Nakaka-bad trip ganitong balita. Ang Supreme Court lang yata ang di naniniwala na crony ni Marcos si Danding. After favoring PAL in the FASAP case, the SC is here again giving the cake to another businessman. What’s next?

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_XYPFIGTBA5LXMX2UBLCQVG5AQE Martin

      Yes Indeed…the Supreme Court is scared of Pinoy and future impeachment threats, and so gives in to his uncle Danding…remember Pinoy threatened additional impeachment hearings…so now they will do what Aquino wants. But hey…i though this is what everyone wants…a supreme court that says yes to the President Aquino.

      • indiosbravos2002

        Now, the SC is scared of PNOY? Hehehe. This is a new spin… for a change.

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2VLO53PRSSY76BZOWLOHJDM33M jeray

        e anu tangagn 2 sa taas

      • indiosbravos2002

        Broken sentence na nga. Mali pa spelling… FAIL!!!

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_W4RTNUSX3BQCWCDQAA562BFC5I Lito G

        Wow you are good in connecting missing links!

  • http://www.facebook.com/hormel.delata Hormel Delata

    It’s so much fun being a Cojuangco in the Philippines!

  • indiosbravos2002

    How come the church had no comment on the matter? Kay CORONA and the RH bill, they were pretty vocal pero dito walang imik.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2VLO53PRSSY76BZOWLOHJDM33M jeray

      tanong bakit si noy walng comment? wag kang tanga

      • indiosbravos2002

        Ewan ko. Kelangan ba syang magcomment. Eh, fuc@ed up to ng supreme court ni CORONA. bakit nya sasaluhin?

  • palakasantayo

    Could somebody please explain to me how this case came about? I was out of the country when this thing happened. I’m a coconut farmer and don’t have a clue of what happened.

    • Ronilo Yap

      No one can explain, aside the Midnight Appointees. They want to divert the attention of the Impeachment Trial to the administration. A plain classical mind conditioning.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/AND7MQ5FERICDOIAUW56RYT45A tower_of_power

    TheSOLDPREME COURT decision on Fasaf case was meant to clear the Thief Justice. This coco levy decision is meant to put the aquino government in a corner. The Aquino government has to maneuver carefully out of this one. Once the Thief Justice is out, this can be corrected … much more easily if the rest of the gloria justices are likewise removed.

    Who among the justices care about the 60B pesos supposedly won by Danding  as  a result of this decision as claimed by some people? It  is not their money nor is it a money they can pocket. The THIEF JUSTICE and those other JUSTICES afraid of their impending impeachment are only interested of finding a way out of the mess they have created. To them … Fx!K the coco farmers!

    One way out is to agitate the people and hope that the support for Pnoy nose-dives. This is the very purpose why the sudden decision on the coco levy by the SOLDPREME COURT!

    The THIEF JUSTICE and his elks are mnaster spin doctors … masters in faking documents … masters at hiding things … much more money … and they think the can fool the fILIPINO PEOPLE ALL THE TIME!!!

    Please beware!!!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2VLO53PRSSY76BZOWLOHJDM33M jeray

      Di as simple as water…. pag salitain mo yung noy… pag iaba ang pinauusapan an dyan agad alipores nya? cojuangco aquino is fooling you….

    • Bansot

      Tower, you dare to call CJ a Thief, but I doubt if you have any proof of that at all. Did he steal from you or from any member of your family, or have you seen him stealing from anyone, or do you have any hard proof of what he has stolen, from whom, from where and when did this happened? If you have all the answers to my simple question, I suggest that you volunter as a resource person in order to help this impeachment trial to finality.

      • scorpio15

        Bansot talaga ang pag-iisip mo ika nga ma-ikli.

      • Bansot

        Really??, prove to me if you can that what I have said are erroneous . Do you have any hard proof that CJ is a thief?  If you have why don’t you volunter as a resorce person instead of bablling like an old woman!!! I don’t care if he is convicted or not, but due process must be followed.

      • http://www.lifeinsuranceph.com/ Life Insurance Philippines

        Due process is being followed. Kaya nga may impeachment. He has the right to take the witness stand and answer all accusations in that forum. Kaso lang, parang ayaw. Bakit kaya?

      • Bansot

        If you call a person a “THIEF” before he is convicted do you call that due process ? I can’t recall that any member of the prosecution panel nor the impeachment body ever addressed him like that, because they have not proven anything yet till now.

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/AND7MQ5FERICDOIAUW56RYT45A tower_of_power

        Hi Bansot … the burden of proof is on the THIEF JUSTICE! He only has to be there … present himself as a witness and be man enough to answer all questions and doubts about his character. Afterall. it is his personality that is under attack … be there to protect his name … above all … to protect his family. He graduated with honors … now, why not use that to protect himself and his family? Or he lied about it?

        Para matapos na … di ba?

        Why let this thing drag for sooo loooooooong while in the meantime mud is hurled against him? I will not stop calling him a THIEF until he has proven to me otherwise.

        I believe in surveys … too bad for him!!!

      • Bansot

        You’re  wrong, the onus of proving the guilt lies with the Prosecution and not with the accused.( that’s why they’re called the “prosecutors”, and the other party as ” defendant”) Had the Prosecution focused on articles of complaints which had solid evidences instead of soliciting unsubstantive
        hearsays, like the small lady, and unverified 45 properties, this case could have been brought to finality. Irrespective of the outcome of this impeachment,my question to you is personal. Are you prepared to reveal your real identity and prove in court that CJ is a “THIEF”. I’m sure you understand the judicial implication of your action, that you called him this, and circulated it publicly by posting it in this web- site. If you can not answer me positively, then shut up before you get into trouble

      • http://profile.yahoo.com/AND7MQ5FERICDOIAUW56RYT45A tower_of_power

        Hi Bansot! For all I know you are a robot … why not put your name and address here so I can verify? And then I will not hesitate to put mine. Are you contemplating a class suit against all the people calling the THIEF JUSTICE names? Pls put you name and address so we can address the issue properly.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2VLO53PRSSY76BZOWLOHJDM33M jeray

    2LOG NA ANG TAO SA PINAS PAG GISING  TAAS NA LAHAT. POWEL OF PEOPLE MANGINIG KA SAAN TTAMA ANG KASINUNGALINGAN MO? GOD BLESS PHIL.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_WIWYLFLU4LPKS7B2ZLLRVFKS3Y vir_a

    This is what Noynoy wants to hear from the Supreme Court. The coconut farmers are the poor losers. Panalo ang mga oligarchs. What is the church doing?

    • Ronilo Yap

      What’s the connection? Is the president is can touch the present Midnight Appointee? They are untouchable kono  for what they claim separation of their powers kono. Tapos Sabihin mo masaya. Pinapapabigay na nga ang levy fund para sa magsaka ng niyog. Di ka yata updated ah. Tira ka lang nang tira sa presidente. Tumulong ka nalang, wala ka namang magagawa eh. Ikaw comentator or should i say pang bulabog lang. 

    • AllaMo

      This decision was made by The Untochables of the “fighting to remain independent” (read: unaccountable) injustices of the coronarroyo court. Hindi tama na inguso mo sa Pangulo ang karumal-dumal na desisyon’g ito.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_OHUUEZMSDKFMZLMGHAF6MUB5HI Freddie Mariano

    Paanong nasisikmura ito ng Supreme Court, ni Danding, ni PNoy? Isauli nyo ang hindi nyo naman pinaghirapan at nakuha lamang sa panlilinlang! 

    Parang nagiging ganito na ang kalakaran sa bansa natin. Kayang kayang pagsamantalahan ang mga maliliit dahil hindi maaasahang papanigan sila ng mga korte.

    • indiosbravos2002

      Why blame the president? The decision came from Corona’s people, the defender of the farmers -hahahaha-. Judicial independence, di ba?

      Corona halatang credit grabbing sa HLI decision. Ngayon tahimik sya. Hahaha. What a joke.

  • http://www.lifeinsuranceph.com/ Life Insurance Philippines

    Danding will die and he cannot take his billions with him. Who will inherit?

  • KonsensyaNgBayan

    What do we expect from the Supreme Court decisions who are remnants of the Marcos Regime and appointee of the past most corrupt administration. Let us just hope that all of these maggots and leeches of traditional politicians and political dynasty will eventually be eliminated one by one. Hopefully God will help us Filipinos through Divine intervention to call them all and their families to face His judgement. Or send a plague that will be inflicted to their families for the wealth they accumulated.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/HFYQYPW6MLJC7OLGLCJRS4IAC4 Regd

    Tumpak, pinaglalaban ni Corona ang karapatan ng mga magsasaka. Abay iyong Hacienda Luisita  nga sabi, siya, uulitin ko po, siya ang nagpasimuno at naglabas ng desisyon pabor sa magsasaka dahil mahal nya nga po sila at lalo na ang mga mahihirap.

    Susmaryosep, anong nagyari dito sa UCPB coco fund? Kanino sya pumanig? Anong nangyari sa mga hiling ng mga magsasaka? Bakit? Kamot…….kamot…..kamot…..

  • indiosbravos2002

    I dont know why the president is being blamed here. The decision did not even came from the executive. Corona already established that the judiciary cannot be touched by malacanang. Judicial independence, ika na. He even took the credit of being the defender of the HLI farmers, eventhough, the decision was made by a collegial body. Now, super quiet sya on this issue. Is it because may approval nya neto? Why the doble standard, bonsai boy.



Copyright © 2014, .
To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.
Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:
c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94
Advertisement
Advertisement
Marketplace
Advertisement