Quantcast
Latest Stories

Defense urges prosecution to ‘play by the rules’

By

MANILA, Philippines – “Play by the rules,” a lawyer for Chief Justice Renato Corona said Wednesday after questions were raised on the authenticity of the documents presented by the prosecution on Corona’s dollar accounts.

Annabelle Tiongson, Philippine Savings Bank (PS Bank) Katipunan branch manager, testified on Monday that the documents attached by the prosecution in its supplemental request for subpoena were “fake”.

“It is a timely reminder to both parties to remain abiding to our oath as lawyers and officers of the court that we should not foist any falsehood upon the court, wittingly or recklessly,” former Justice Undersecretary Ramon Esguerra said in a text message.

“In a manner of speaking, we must play by the rules of the game on the basis of what is true, fair and just,” Esguerra said.

The photocopy of the PS Bank documents in the name of Corona that were allegedly handed to Oriental Mindoro Representative Reynaldo Umali had come under question after both PS Bank president Pascual Garcia III and PS Bank Tiongson testified that it had not come from their bank.

Umali said the document was handed to him by a “small lady” while he was at the Senate secretariat. However, no “small lady” was seen on CCTV. Tiongson, in her testimony before the Impeachment court, said the document was different from what they have in their possession.


Follow Us

Follow us on Facebook Follow on Twitter Follow on Twitter


Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Tags: Annabelle Tiongson , Chief Justice Renato Corona , Corona bank documents , Corona Impeachment , Defense , Impeachment court , impeachment trial , Prosecution , PS Bank , PS Bank president Pascual Garcia

  • http://joboni96.myopenid.com/ joboni96

    whose rules
    criminal court?

    mukhang gusto ng depensang
    makulong si corona
    as a criminal
    if proven guilty

    boys
    impeachment court yan
    after the truth
    different rules

    • billygunn23

      rules on evidence. read between the lines!

      • http://joboni96.myopenid.com/ joboni96

        sa criminal court yan
        where you can put the accused
        to death

        sa impeachment court
        removal from office laang

        get the truth
        the best way you can

  • Justice_Justice

    The LIARS, Tupas Umali and their Juvenile Team, will be caught in their Lies!  

    The Original and the Faked bank documents have different bank accounts… which make the Fake One a FAKED.Their “fixing” of the Fake bank document will get uncovered and they will face another Court, the ones for unlawful practice from lawyers… and go to jail!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_QZZKXPEA67I7HELEIYM35QVYFA Jon

    Intindihin nyo naman sina Tupas and company.
    Noong nakaraan, sinubukan nilang mag-presenta ng ebidensya, kaso palpak talaga.
    So ngayon, sumusubok silang gumawa na lang ng ebidensya at baka pumasa.
    Para sa Prosecution, walang masamang tinapay kaya tira lang ng tira, legal man o hindi.

  • 2rey3

    The prosecution need not attach the reproduced copy of CJ Corona’s bank account but they submitted it with the written manifestation that they are not sure as to authenticity but just the same they submitted it together with the enumeration of CJ Corona’s bank accounts to the Impeachment Court. Then the Senate thru Senate President issued the subpoena for the said accounts which were eventually proven in existence and their entries correct. 

    How come the defense is dealing on it and if it has to deal with it, why not confront the Senate President as he has already declared in open session that the buck stops with him as far as the issuance of the subpoena is concerned for those said bank accounts as he does not want to be a party to the concealment of documents which may contain information of wrongdoing?

  • quirinomayer

    The math of the defense is as follows: P31M = P3.5M.

    For so long as the prosecution does not harp on this math and does not present more evidence that Corona doctored his SALN,  it is playing by the rules. Everything that the prosecution does to find the truth about the secret accounts of Corona are violative  of the rules.

    • billygunn23

      even if the amount is trillion dolars, if the source of such evidence is illegal, it will not have any bearing in the promulgation of judgment. know that silly.

      • quirinomayer

        So you are admitting that’s what the defense is trying to say: P31M is equal to P3.5M? Read my post again. It’s not what’s admissible and not admissible evidence but the fear of the defense of anything the prosecution presents pertaining to the bank deposits of your idol.

        Unluckily for you, the public does not give a hoot about which is admissible and which is not. All they know now is that what the defense is trying to make them believe is unacceptable: P31M is equal to P3.5M.

        And don’t silly people who get more votes than you do because doing that is silly.

      • seve rino

        di ko ma gets billy, pakiulit.

  • AMORMINA

    Sorry for the misprint of the title, below is the correct version!

    ‘DEFENSE URGES PROSECUTION TO PLAY BY THEIR RULES’

    • seve rino

      Thank you for the correction.

  • parefrank

    to Justice_Justice

    The prosecution knows that the most important matter is to condition the public mind. And so they bring even wrong “evidence” to the media which then “forget” to make the same headlines when it comes out wrong. And then, the conviction is “wanted by the public” and real facts are not so important anywore.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_IE6OU4ODQIVS6F5HKL6QPTTDNI RonnieV

    This leakage must be investigated as it is a very serious offense. It should include 1. Cong Umali, 2. Cong Tupas 3. Tiongson 4. Lacierda.They should be investigated not in the senate but in the real courts. Lacierda’s earlier pronouncement that the document is not fake and he also said that the account numbers of Corona are so accurate as testified by Tiongson, Of course it’s accurate because there was a leak prior to Tiongson’s testimony. Lacierda’s pronouncement simply indicates that he has knowledge on this leakage if not one of the accomplices. To this we could ponder how much million does it cost to leak this information or document?

  • seve rino

    Prosecutors vs Defense. Defense won by unanimous decision.
    Small Lady vs Defense. Small Lady won by TKO.



Copyright © 2013, .
To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.
Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:
c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94
Advertisement

News

  • Armed men snatch wife of Marine officer in Jolo
  • Japan defends PM aide’s surprise North Korea trip
  • Saudi woman tops Everest as country warms to women in sports
  • Lotto fever strikes US as jackpot swells
  • Proclamations put period to Luzon election contests
  • Sports

  • Pacers hold off Knicks to reach Eastern finals
  • Beckham captains PSG in last home game
  • Beckham walks off in tears after last home game
  • Aces eye clincher vs Kings today
  • ABL: Beermen survive 3 OTs to down Dragons
  • Lifestyle

  • What’s cookin’ with AHA: Salad Nicoise
  • French president signs gay marriage into law
  • Sea turtle comeback in a corner of the Caribbean
  • Gate crashers descend on SJP event–or at least, they tried
  • Guess what Sarah Jessica Parker brought home to NY as ‘pasalubong’ from PH?
  • Entertainment

  • Bella Flores, 84
  • Hilda Koronel, Lino Brocka take Cannes by storm once again
  • Flamboyant celeb wins back beau via intrigue
  • Leaving a coliseum full of positive vibes
  • Ser Chief, Maya in Toronto today
  • Business

  • Elated stakeholders reelect stock exchange board
  • Save more, Filipinos urged
  • A riverine venture in Pangasinan
  • N. Luzon fiesta maker to market former US military property
  • PSE board gets new mandate
  • Technology

  • Free Inquirer tablets for lucky INQSnap readers
  • Hong Kong launches first electric taxis
  • DepEd website now up and normal
  • Report: Yahoo nearing $1.1B acquisition of Tumblr
  • ‘Sonic’ video games coming to Nintendo
  • Opinion

  • An interesting challenge
  • Premature, imprudent and illegal
  • Nations and their governments
  • Come, Holy Spirit!
  • A room in heaven
  • Global Nation

  • Filipinos in Taiwan told to limit movement
  • Philippines waiting for Taiwan anger to cool
  • Notes of a Fil-Am election observer
  • Global disasters cost P2.5T in last decade, topping UN estimates
  • Conviction of Ortega gunman draws int’l watchdog’s praise
  • Marketplace
    Advertisement
    Azure Skin Ad
    Azure Skin Ad
    © Copyright 1997-2013 INQUIRER.net | All Rights Reserved